Netbook..which one to get?

Take note of the dedicated Page Up/Down keys on the AAO if you're comparying keyboard layouts too, often overlooked but a pretty huge convenience imo (considering all the scrolling you'll do on these netbooks), particularly where they're placed.
 
lol! I haven't really watched to see which side I use, but I'm getting this feeling that it's usually the left side... actually typing this out... I thought maybe doing capital A's or C's or E's.... nope, it's all the left side. O, I, M, N.... guess I would be okay with the Asus :p
 
lenovo S10, by far the smallest volume of all the 10" netbooks, smaller than most the 9" ones too.
 
lenovo S10, by far the smallest volume of all the 10" netbooks, smaller than most the 9" ones too.

And very limited on what you get... Personally I don't want to buy ANY netbook unless it comes with a 6-cell battery or gets at least 4-5 hours of battery life with what it has... 6-7 is much better.
 
And very limited on what you get... Personally I don't want to buy ANY netbook unless it comes with a 6-cell battery or gets at least 4-5 hours of battery life with what it has... 6-7 is much better.

I just bought one yesterday (Black, 1GB RAM, 160GB HDD for $449 at CircuitCity.com), it should be here by the end of the week. I hear what you're saying about the battery, but I wouldn't say the S10 is limited. They will be offering 6-Cell batteries soon enough, albeit at a price premium, but I'm used to the 45 minute battery life of my T30, so 2-3 hours is an eternity for me.
 
I just bought one yesterday (Black, 1GB RAM, 160GB HDD for $449 at CircuitCity.com), it should be here by the end of the week. I hear what you're saying about the battery, but I wouldn't say the S10 is limited. They will be offering 6-Cell batteries soon enough, albeit at a price premium, but I'm used to the 45 minute battery life of my T30, so 2-3 hours is an eternity for me.

Hey that ones not so bad. I've only seem them for sale on the Lenovo website... $399 for 512mb ram, 80 gig HDD, 3 cell battery... wasn't such a good deal compared to the Aspire One at ALL.

Looks like it will a nice netbook, offering the same things as all the others :p The right shift has the same problem as the Asus netbooks though, apparently it matters to a lot of people.

Edit: There is a review here
 
Circuit City was carrying the AAO's at some point, I dunno if they still do, they never had 'em in stock down here in Puerto Rico. CompUSA here has the AAO's in stock (3-cell w/120GB HD version) though they had none on display last week, I'm sure they've put one up by now because in the 45 min. I spent there (looong register line for some reason) I saw an employee running out of the stock room with a box about 4 or 5 times. :p

I know CompUSA only re-opened in like three states in addition to Puerto Rico though... I haven't seen 'em at my local Costco either though I haven't been in about a month, but my cousin in Denver saw the same 3-cell 120GB version in stock over at his Costco. So you've got a few places to check, but I haven't heard of any retail store carrying the 6-cell version yet. In fact, they often sell the 3-cell 120GB HD version for $400, kind of a rip-off.
 
Anyone who has time to wait for samsung's nc10 might want to. Laptopmagazine tested it and got 7 hours of battery life, compared to the same test that got 5+ with Wind and just under 5 with the eee 1000h. The keyboard has all the size of the Wind with the sane layout (arrow key lowered instead of gimping punctuation or shift) of the AAO.

I don't have time to wait around, but if you do...
 
I just noticed their review of the HP Mini 1000... Man, they got so close, yet missed the mark big on some key items.

I was really expecting them to come up with a winner when they finally introduced an Atom netbook... Great display(s) and great keyboard with properly placed Shift keys and no tiny punctuation keys; but it lacks VGA out, the mic/headphone ports are combined into one somehow, and the price for the 3-cell version is a pretty steep $525 right now (while the 6-cell won't be available 'till '09 apparently)

What's worse the only storage options are 8/16GB SSDs or a slow-poke 4,200 60GB drive (I wonder if it's a 1.8" drive...), how underwhelming. :( Those SSDs are probably no speed demons either. It's pretty customizable though, you can go with an 8.9" display instead of the 10.2" and shave $50 off that, and you can add BT for like $25. The SSDs cost the same or less than that 60GB HD too.

It's also pretty compact, about the size of the AAO even with the 10.2" screen, yet the touchpad's even smaller (slightly), go figure. I'm not a fan of those flat keys, but I guess some like 'em (Sony's ultraportables all have 'em too), I like the more beveled/edged keys of the othe netbooks more, seems easier to feel your way around the kb. I guess 6-cells will end up at like $575 which is $100 more than the Wind itself, totally pricing itself out of contention imo, kinda like the Lenovo.

Reading that Samsung review now... I didn't even know they made any kind of full-on systems. :confused:
 
I finally ordered my blue AAO off CDW, hope it ships soon as it says 1-3 days under availability, though I see no way of checking my order status on their site... I need an order number and a customer number but I don't have the latter, seems like it's some corporate type-thing, which I know is their focus, guess I'll have to call tomorrow.

After re-reading the Wind/AAO reviews on Laptop Mag and also reading the new HP/Samsung reviews I've got no regrets though... For me personally, the AAO makes the 'least compromises and strikes a good balance. Originally I was tempted by the Wind's larger screen but the weak horizontal viewing angle, skinny punctuation keys, and higher price didn't convince me. :eek: For some reason the AAO's WiFi seems stronger as well, 'least according to Laptop Mag's tests. Only the HP bests it in that regard. They get like double the throughput as the Wind at 50 feet, though testing that reliably can be pretty flakey to be honest. Samsung's is equally strong here.

Now I'm almost tempted to cancel and wait a bit to pay an extra $100 for the Samsung's larger screen, and slightly better speakers/webcam but ehh... I'm sure in a year or two I'll be upgrading this anyway. The Samsung NC10's keyboard layout is like, identical to the AAO's btw, even the Page Up/Down keys are there! :eek: It's slightly larger too but the resemblance is uncanny. Alas, the touchpad is even smaller, heh, though it does have a bottom-located mouse button (single rocker-bar type) if the side-buttons on the AAO bother ya. :cool:

The Samsung NC10 definitely bests the Wind at $500-ish tho, and imo makes the chunkier 1000H outdated, heh. The Samsung NC10 even includes BT (AAO doesn't), if they manage a good level of availability by the holiday season they could run away with this category.
 
BTW, the Samsung NC10's increased battery life seems to be a product of the lower default brightness (or they brightness they had it set at when they ran the test), i.e. 50%... I've no clue what the brightness was set at on the other netbooks Laptop Mag tested but it was probably 100%, could be the Samsung's display is just inherently brighter and thus they didn't notice... You'd think that's the first thing they'd standardize across tests tho. :rolleyes:

Either way, I doubt it magically ekes out an extra 2 hrs out of the same kind of batteries as the other netbooks, they've got several mish-mash updates that don't quite clarify this but provide a notice of sorts. Then again, after seeing Anand's tests of battery life on the Macbooks with OS X vs Vista I guess anything's possible...

Edit: Read this somewhere "Laptop Magazine reran the battery test and got 4:48 with the brightness set to full. They have updated the review.", can't find the updated comment on LM's review myself but the editor of the review himself posted there to confirm it.
 
Just got my S10 today. I have no regrets, and I'll post a thread this weekend when I have time.
 
ahhh, there are some many choices... i have no idea where to start.. from reading comments, it seems like the heavy contenders are:

1. AAO
2. Wind
3. Everyone else... (S10, 1000 HA/HD, etc)

And the new Samsung looks even sexier! I'm looking to pick one of these up by Christmas, so does anyone have any advice? Should I just wait awhile and see what happens to price points and such?
 
1. Samsung NC10 imo
2. AAO
3. Wind
4. S10 (it does look good)
5. 1000H
6. Dell Mini (personally I can't imagine grappling with that kb)

Dunno what to make of the HP Mini 1000 'till someone reviews and benchmark the speed of the SSDs, but at $525 with a 3-cell battery for a 16GB SSD or a slow 60GB HD it's grossly overpriced and heavily flawed if those SSD's aren't a cut above the norm speed-wise (and they're probably not).

All the other 10" models are going for the same price point right now, basically $500 give or take $25... And if the NC10 becomes available at $500 flat it'll easily be the best buy imo. At $100 less the AAO has a price advantage albeit using a 9" screen, but the keyboard is still excellent and/or better than some of the 10" models. Older 9" models like the 901 are not even worth considering anymore unless they get some heavy discounts.
 
i love the SSD that is a SLC drive my 901, its only 4gb but i can fid a vlited vista on it.

it has really fast boot time and is very resposive. the atom CPU is the way to go.



yes the KB is small but you get used to it.


i love getting 7hrs of battery life :)

i would definitely buy another asus eee pc
 
Even the slightly better boot-drive SSD on the 901 EEE's (unlike most it has two, one fast for the OS, one slower for docs) don't really offer any faster performance than most 5,400 RPM HD drives... From what I've seen, I could be mistaken, but several of the models with HDs boot into Windows in like 40s and wake up from Hibernation almost instantly, and sustained transfer rates of those laptop drives is usually around 40MB/s, the EEE's faster SSD was around 35-37MB/s IIRC.

The only real reason to opt for the SSD's is durability, not performance, because even the argument of whether they really have an impact on battery life or not is kind of up in the air (and depends a lot on usage patterns and such). Personally, 'till the SSD's used on these netbooks are faster, I'm favoring the higher capacity HDs.
 
Either way, I doubt it magically ekes out an extra 2 hrs out of the same kind of batteries as the other netbooks, they've got several mish-mash updates that don't quite clarify this but provide a notice of sorts. Then again, after seeing Anand's tests of battery life on the Macbooks with OS X vs Vista I guess anything's possible...

Even with the battery manager disabled (that dims the screen to absolute minimum after 30 seconds of inactivity), it still gets 6:34 at the 50% brightness that they tested the other netbooks at, which is VERY impressive. And 4:48 on full brightness is no slouch either. Assuming that the battery manager jumps the screen back to normal brightness upon activity, I could see actually using it that way. Not when watching a video, obviously, but when word processing possibly.

I'm all about having options when it comes to battery life, the NC10's solution sounds like a real winner.

Note: When we first ran the LAPTOP Battery Test the NC10 yielded a runtime of 7 hours and 34 minutes. This was with the Samsung Battery Manager 2.0 enabled, which dims the screen to its lowest setting after 30 seconds of inactivity on the keyboard or touchpad. The screen is usable during this time, but it's uncomfortable. When we ran the battery test at 50 percent brightness with the Battery Manager disabled, the NC10 ran for 6:34; cranked up to 100 percent, it ran for 4:48.
 
Some teasers of my S10.

012.jpg


013.jpg


014.jpg
 
that last pic is awesome, it's nice to have a size comparison

The "big" one is a 14.1" T30 btw.

So far, I'm getting 3.5 hours out of it with WiFi on, and I'm using the the "low power" setting in the Lenovo energy management software. Mostly just surfing the net and taking notes in class with Word 2003. Thats what its for dudes! Keyboard isn't bad at all. I love it--I'm posting from it right now!!!

EDIT: This thing plays GTA2 like its nobody's business.

Free: http://rockstargames.com/classics/

006.jpg


009.jpg


011.jpg


015.jpg
 
So i own a 901 eee PC, what is the advantage of the S10 over thee eee PC?


price seems similar, the eee PC has the multitouch touchpad, SSD drive and a 6 cell battery
 
Well, mine has bluetooth, an express port, a 10" screen, and also a multitouch pad. I updated my previous post with some GTA2 action.
 
I have been using the asus 900 for a while now and it has replaced any need for a conventional laptop. These things are great. From the specs I have come across the version i have is basically the smallest form factor around. The 10 inch asus 1000 seems much larger. But either way they are a great buy.
 
I like the look of the Samsung as I think it has a slightly better graphics chip than the norm.

Whislt I wouldnt be playing hyper games on it, it would be nice to know for maybe the odd 3D app and video playback to have a bit more horsepower under the hood.
 
I like the look of the Samsung as I think it has a slightly better graphics chip than the norm.

Whislt I wouldnt be playing hyper games on it, it would be nice to know for maybe the odd 3D app and video playback to have a bit more horsepower under the hood.

Pretty sure they all use the same Intel GMA 950
 
Even with the battery manager disabled (that dims the screen to absolute minimum after 30 seconds of inactivity), it still gets 6:34 at the 50% brightness that they tested the other netbooks at, which is VERY impressive. And 4:48 on full brightness is no slouch either. Assuming that the battery manager jumps the screen back to normal brightness upon activity, I could see actually using it that way. Not when watching a video, obviously, but when word processing possibly.

I'm all about having options when it comes to battery life, the NC10's solution sounds like a real winner.

It does seems like it might be getting an extra hour out of the battery at 50% brightness compared to some of the other netbooks (which do like 5:30 or so, AAO/Wind w/6-cell), but it still seems sketchy... I'm waiting for another publication to test it properly before buying that claim of improved battery life.

when can we buy Samsung NC10?

Nowhere yet, though Amazon is taking pre-orders (they were notoriously lousy about fulfilling the AAO pre-orders though), and CDW and other places have it listed already.
 
So i own a 901 eee PC, what is the advantage of the S10 over thee eee PC?

price seems similar, the eee PC has the multitouch touchpad, SSD drive and a 6 cell battery

There's a big number of advantages to the newer netbook models over the 901, including ASUS' own 1000H... A lot of these netbooks are available with 6-cell batteries for the same price as the 901 or less (AAO/Wind/NC10, the S10 not yet), and virtually all of them have a bigger and better keyboard layout (some are barely wider, like an inch, some are like an inch larger all around).

The SSD arrangement on the 901 was a splti MLC+SLC 4+8GB setup no? A lot of the newer netbooks are opting for a simple 5,400 RPM laptop drive which is usually as fast or faster anyway while offering much more capacity (120-160GB), until SSD's become more affordable the only advantage they posses is durability, though many of the newer netbooks still offer that option too. Some of these newer models have a larger 10-10.2" screen...

Nothing groundbreaking, but still very big factors from a usability standpoint, just the natural evolution of the form-factor.

I have been using the asus 900 for a while now and it has replaced any need for a conventional laptop. These things are great. From the specs I have come across the version i have is basically the smallest form factor around. The 10 inch asus 1000 seems much larger. But either way they are a great buy.

The 1000 is slightly chunkier than some of the other 10" netbooks out there, all the ones with the better keyboard layouts are slightly wider (1" or less) than the 900/901 but it's well worth the tradeoff.
 
okay, good points, was able to get my 901 on ebay brand new and with the live 30% cashback the total price was $439 - 30% which is $131 so i got my 901 for $307


I was looking at the dell mini 9 also but shipping delays were killer


I love the 901, the KB isnt bad for my fingers, not that i type perfectly or anything but its not bad....

i love the boot time of SSD and yes its a 4/8 split SSD
 
The Samsung NC10 in blue and white are up for sale at PortableOne , with RAM and HDD options. I think I'll grab a black one when they come out. Any word on that?

Edit: Sorry, didn't notice until now that it says "Available Mid-November 2008. Pre-order yours now!"
 
I really want the Lenovo S10 with a 6 cell battery. I like how the overall chassis looks compared to the AAO and the Asus Eee PCs. The 2 USB ports kind of sucks but at least you can add an ExpressCard for expansion.

Has anyone upgraded to a much larger hard drive on their netbook?

Also, does the S10 use a SATA hard drive?
 
I'll put another vote for the Aspire One. Only had it two days, so can't comment on durability, but it seems very well built, and performance is easily up to par with other "budget" laptops, around the $500 price point. I have the 1GB,1.6Ghz,120GB model with XP Home.
 
Back
Top