Netbook..which one to get?

From what I gather, the Inspiron Mini 12 will be crippled due to it's chipset's memory limitation of 1GB, and also the fact that it does not use the standard 2.5" harddrive, making it very difficult to upgrade, which is a shame because the stock 4200rpm HDD is reportedly very slow.

I need 2GB of mem on my netbook because I want to use Vista, and I also want a fast harddrive because this means a lot for the general speed of a computer.

The Mini 12 is nice and thin, and has a nice screen/resolution, but is limited by mem and HD options. The new Atoms are supposedly .5W more power efficient, but I have heard no talk of performance improvements.

I am waiting for the NC10, or possibly the new Wind u120.

Edit: Spelling
 
FWIW, I have 1GB of RAM in my AAO with Vista Ultimate and it runs really fast. And yes, I have my Quad Core 3GHz Vista 64 machine w/ 4GB of RAM to compare it to.
 
FWIW, I have 1GB of RAM in my AAO with Vista Ultimate and it runs really fast. And yes, I have my Quad Core 3GHz Vista 64 machine w/ 4GB of RAM to compare it to.

Same here. I ran Vista on my stock AAO for a while and the 1 gig of ram seemed adequate. Machine was pretty snappy.

Only reason I went back to XP was due to wifi issues. Seems the stock Atheros wireless card has some buggy drivers and will drop the wifi connection from time to time. Folks over at the AspireOne Forums have had varying degrees of luck with different driver versions, but its kinda hit and miss. Otherwise, Vista ran pretty nice.
 
Same here. I ran Vista on my stock AAO for a while and the 1 gig of ram seemed adequate. Machine was pretty snappy.

Only reason I went back to XP was due to wifi issues. Seems the stock Atheros wireless card has some buggy drivers and will drop the wifi connection from time to time. Folks over at the AspireOne Forums have had varying degrees of luck with different driver versions, but its kinda hit and miss. Otherwise, Vista ran pretty nice.

Hmm, haven't had any WiFi issues.. yet. And I have been running Vista for about a month now. We'll see.
 
How are you guys installing Vista? could I do it from a CD on a shared drive? Thanks for any help.
 
Are there any netbooks with GSM 3g built in? I've been looking but haven't found one so far :-/ onboard storage isn't really an issue I've got 2 16gb and an 8gb pen drives if need be ;)

I've got an AT&T card and plan but compared to the netbooks the usb card is insanely huge.
 
Easiest way is from a usb thumbdrive.

Its leaps and bounds easier then installing XP from a flash drive.

This website is a must for AAO owners.

The driver links in that tutorial might be outdated, so search around on that site for the newest versions. I didn't bother putting the drivers on the flash drive before hand, I just installed them after. The first thing I did when Vista booted what run Windows Update, and that grabbed most of the drivers anyway. Good luck.
 
I have an urge for the AAO, but I really want the X3100 in the Wind.

If only Acer shoved a X3100 in a AAO, it's be perfect.

Also, how much difference is the GMA 950 from the X3100? I'm assuming it's a small advantage,,,
 
Has anyone actually gotten an x3100 wind? I think it's just a typo on msi's website.
 
It's a typo on the Acer website also... either they are all getting the same updates soon or they all made the same mistake... or the X3100 is really the same as the GMA 950, I dunno.

@dcom, I would suggest that you not worry too much about it... if you want to play some newer games, I would look at one of the Asus N10's with the 9300m GS, but other than that, the GMA 950 and X3100 aren't going to be great for gaming, unless the game is 5+ years old. I can safely say that the GMA950 can play Deus Ex, System Shock 2, Half Life 1 games, and Call of Duty very well. Although no AA at all because I don't think it's supported...
 
Nah, i won't do any gaming on my netbook. I need one before December comes because I need something that'll do flash videos and can take notes. I'm tired of sitting through a 3-hour meeting without any entertainment. Plus, If i'm going to shell out like $200 for a iTouch, mind as well shell out $100 more for a AAO.

So just to confirm, pretty much all netbooks have the GMA 950 (not including ASUS N10 & Lenovo S10)
 
Aw, I think I read a typo somewhere with the S10 with a X4500..

Anyways, do anyone know a great cheap place to buy the AAO? Or better yet, a great deal on the other Netbooks. I'm particularly attached to that AAO...
 
The AAO is all over the place these days for $349. Office Depot has 'em, Circuit City, Wal-mart, Best Buy, Fry's, etc... it's not like you can't get one. :D

Wal-mart had a package deal last week offering the 1GB/120GB model with a Lite-On external 20x DVD drive and a 2GB USB stick (bleh) for $449, not that much of a savings on the external drive and the 2GB stick is just a throwaway addon, but even so, a friend of mine grabbed the package and was told she'd get it after the 17th. She got it today and is loving it to death, that's the 9th person I've recommended the AAO to and they all can't stop raving about 'em.

Add that 6 cell battery for a reasonable cost and you're looking at ~6 hours of battery life and excellent performance all around.

Still the Netbook to get, I say... nothing has changed since it hit the market. Dell lowering the price of the mini - and MSI is expected to follow suit with the Wind - isn't going to alter the fact that they're behind the curve: it's the AAO or nothing at all... :D

Also, how much difference is the GMA 950 from the X3100? I'm assuming it's a small advantage,,,

A lot of info can be culled from the Intel GMA Wikipedia page at:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_GMA

The GMA950 is all software, basically; the X3100 offers actual hardware based transform and lighting so that's a big boost right there. Also offers slightly more RAM usage if needed (up to 384, the GMA950 tops out at 224). Even so, they're not for serious gaming but can handle HD video content just fine, even the GMA950 can handle 1080 content at full spec without breaking a sweat.
 
I just did a bunch of reading on the Samsung NC10 today... looks like the new king of the netbooks. Only thing that it doesn't rival the AAO on is the price, and maybe portability, being a 10" netbook... but it has the looks IMO, it has a better keyboard, amazing battery life with the 6-cell battery, good screen, same or better speakers than the Asus 1000H... well, at least this is what I read about from some reviews.

Only thing is that it costs $100 more than the 6-cell AAO. It's a toss-up, but if I had the $500 I would buy the Samsung without a doubt. For $400 though, the AAO 6-cell is very tough to beat.
 
I am strongly leaning to getting a Samsung NC10, it looks to be one of the best netbooks if not the best on the market.

That with a VX Nano mouse and I think I have my self a Christmas present. =)
 
8 hour battery life with Wi-Fi enabled - that's quite a boast in the specs. I'll believe it as soon as I see some people I trust actually tell me yes, it actually can do that much on a single charge... ok, so maybe it doesn't specifically say "Wi-Fi enabled" but, that's the point they're trying to hammer out even if it means surfing over the hardline.

Would be nice, definitely, and worth the additional cost, but I ain't believin' it anytime soon. ;)

EDIT:

http://blog.laptopmag.com/samsung-nc10-battery-life-almost-8-hours-with-ssd

Hmmm... no SSD option from the factory, however, so the price goes up up up... 7 hours 55 mins of surfing with Wi-Fi enabled, 12.5% brightness... ok, maybe this one is worthy of consideration.

Look at those times and the brightness - something really needs to be done about display tech, that's still a huge huge hit to battery life, unbelievable.
 
When the rest of the hardware only sips about 4w of power, even an extra watt or two for the backlight makes a large difference.
 
Look at those times and the brightness - something really needs to be done about display tech, that's still a huge huge hit to battery life, unbelievable.

Some day OLED's will become a viable option for note/netbooks... From what I have read OLED's consume much much less power then regular LED, the only problem is cost of production is still high but it will work its way down.


Graphics chip sets are the big power consumer right now tho, I think die shrinks will help but overall the consumption is a materials issue with resistance in such small traces at such high relative voltage.
 
I should be getting an MSI wind [The newest ones, b/g/n, 160HDD, 6 cell) from a fellow [h] member, pretty much brand new, for an awesome price of 302 :p
 
Some day OLED's will become a viable option for note/netbooks... From what I have read OLED's consume much much less power then regular LED, the only problem is cost of production is still high but it will work its way down.


Graphics chip sets are the big power consumer right now tho, I think die shrinks will help but overall the consumption is a materials issue with resistance in such small traces at such high relative voltage.

LED backlights don't do Jack Shit for battery life, yet, because the technology is still not efficient enough. Apple loves touting them but neglects to say that they don't really do much more than add a few minutes at best to the lifespan of a charged battery put to use as easily noted by the discrepancies you can find when doing testing at various levels of brightness as those Samsung benchmarks did.

LED backlights will show almost exactly the same percentages of change and big gaps because of it at each level. They were hoping people would think, "Oh, I have this older Macbook with a regular backlight and I get 3.5 hours of use, so if I upgrade to the same Macbook I already have but with an LED backlight, I'll get 6!" or something like that. And believe me, I know people that sold their older Macbooks and bought the same damned thing with the LED backlight last year when they introduced the LED backlight models... and were very disappointed at no appreciable addition to the length of time they could use the "new" laptops.

It's all marketing doublespeak at this point. SSD and LED backlight technology is new stuff and will take years to get to the point of being nearly as efficient as hard drives and actual cathode element backlights have developed into when you compare them against how dreadfully inefficient both technologies were at introduction decades past.

They have a long way to go, but they'll get their sooner, in a proportionate sense because technology almost exactly follows Moore's Law. Things are just getting and happening faster these days...
 
The only downside to all these netbooks is the power brick.

In terms of ultimate protability, I would have the say the original ASUS EEEpc had the best power brick; as the size of a cell phone charger.

Now, I deciding which to get; Asus EEE 900HA or the AAO. They're very tough competition and offer a lot for the price. Personally, I like the AAO, but the specs and bettery life on that 900HA is very attractive.
 
I saw the 900HA as well, looks pretty nice for $330... but the keys are reportedly very tiny, like the original 900 and older EEE PC's... like 83% or smaller keyboard size, almost child-sized... just something to think about. At least the AAO has a better keyboard layout and bigger keys.
 
The 900HA has very good battery life for the money but I like the overall design and kayboard layout of the AAO.
 
I was pretty much set on the Acer Aspire One but now I have spotted the Samsung NC10. What do you guys think? I would love to have a 10 inch model. I think thats the sweet spot for me but I have to have a full sized right shift key. I also want an SD card reader. Is the NC10 the only 10 inch netbook that has everything the Acer Aspire One has??
 
Seeing the AAO at costco for $349 was an eye opener... BUT reading about a lot of problems people are having and the loud fan noise pushed me towards the NC10. Paid $499 at Newegg. Its down to $489 now. Keyboard is great.

No complaints - Trackpad is good - with there was more on an edge between the trackpad and the rest of the surface. Beyond that - couldn't as for more.
 
btw, in case people hadnt noticed, the nc10 is on ebay now for 499$ and w the 25% Live discount, thats 375$

I am considering getting this, has anyone on here gotten theirs yet? would love an actual [H] member review
 
The AAO is all over the place these days for $349. Office Depot has 'em, Circuit City, Wal-mart, Best Buy, Fry's, etc... it's not like you can't get one. :D

Wal-mart had a package deal last week offering the 1GB/120GB model with a Lite-On external 20x DVD drive and a 2GB USB stick (bleh) for $449, not that much of a savings on the external drive and the 2GB stick is just a throwaway addon, but even so, a friend of mine grabbed the package and was told she'd get it after the 17th. She got it today and is loving it to death, that's the 9th person I've recommended the AAO to and they all can't stop raving about 'em.

Add that 6 cell battery for a reasonable cost and you're looking at ~6 hours of battery life and excellent performance all around.

Still the Netbook to get, I say... nothing has changed since it hit the market. Dell lowering the price of the mini - and MSI is expected to follow suit with the Wind - isn't going to alter the fact that they're behind the curve: it's the AAO or nothing at all... :D

I've seen the 120GB 6-cell AAO on Newegg for $380... They actually had it at $400 when they were out of stock of the 160GB 6-cell but then lowered it... It's a good deal if you wanna shave a couple bucks I guess, add a $20 Bluetooth dongle and you've managed to come in at $400 all in. I agree that at that price point the AAO still beats all of them hands down (or at $350 even if you don't need/want the 6-cell batt.), but as Citizen pointed out, for an extra $80-90 the Samsung NC10 is very much worth a look... Comes with BT too so if you need it then the price difference is even smaller. :D

From what I've seen it's got a better set of speakers, a slightly better webcam (0.3mp vs 1.3mp), a larger screen (8.9" vs 10.2" iirc). and somewhat better battery life (maybe an hour extra imo, not as much as claimed)... There's several other 10-10.2" netbooks obviously, but a lot of them had drawbacks and/or weren't priced right. The MSI Wind was the only one I was tempted by over the AAO, but the NC10 just blows 'em all away at $480-490... It's got a keyboard layout identical to the AAO and no significant downsides, 'cept it's not as widely available yet (and it comes in less color choices AFAIK).

I'm pretty happy with my AAO though, only got it a couple weeks ago so I haven't had too much time to tinker but I'm very pleased. Sapphire Blue looks much nicer in person than on all the photos where it usually looked too dark or too blue. :cool: Fan hasn't been an issue at all so far though I haven't used it in a particularly quiet environment much. It's also pretty easy to tweak with several different programs available though so I'm not worried.

Has anyone tried ReadyBoost on these systems btw? From what I recall it was never worth much on desktops w/1GB+ of RAM but I'm still curious...
 
Has anyone in here considered being able to upgrade the netbooks? You have to completely take apart the AAO to add a new hard drive, and there's the RAM limitation. If you're outside the UK, you completely void the warranty by upgrading the RAM or anything internal with the Wind. I'm not sure on the Samsungs, but damn is that a sexy machine - but $100 out of the price range I set. That really put me down to the S10 - I'm hoping it ships out on Monday, as I ordered by BT module already. I really wish the blue version came with Wifi, but their website shows that it doesn't.
 
I knew all about the hassle of upgrading the AA1 when I got it (it's one of the trickiest)... The RAM doesn't bother me, I can go to 1.5GB instead of 2GB if I need to, but 1GB seems enough for what I'll use it for to be honest, and I'm not adding a new hard drive any time soon. /shrug If I ever do upgrade the HD it'll be once SSD prices come down and I can get a 32GB+ drive that doesn't sacrifice speed.
 
I think I'm pretty much set on the AAO.

I'm going to buy it in a week at BB but the thing is that it says "Online Only" on it's website. So no in-store models??

Anyone bought a AAO instore at BB?

Also, can we predict further price cuts during Black Fridays? I know I'm going to line up for sure at Frys (always full of surprises) but I highly doubt BB will have price cuts on the AAO..
 
I'm pretty sure online only means you have to order it from the website... you can call your local Best Buy and see if they have any in stock though, but probably not.
 
Any specific reason you're set on the AAO? You can get a Samsung NC10 from Overstock.com for $400 + $1 shipping.

1) Go to live.com and search for iPod
2) Select the Overstock.com Option
3) Log into the Live Cashback
4) Search for the Samsung NC10 and add to cart
5) Checkout
6) Profit!
 
I don't really find a need to spend over $350 for a netbook. Also need something very portable (don't have large battery or huge screen.)

I have a coupon for BB so that's why I'm going to get the AAO.
 
Another vote for the AAO. I've got the 1GB/120GB Windows version and love it! I've got an extra 3 cell battery I purchased directly from Acer for about $70. Great little machine, highly recommended!
 
My search on Craigslist has begun. I have e-mailed every single AAO seller. If none will sell to me at my desired price, I shall wait at Frys and BB during Black Fridays.
 
Back
Top