Netbook..which one to get?

What would be the best solution for myself. I currently have a HP dv2000 with a 12cell and I'm loving the 4-6 hour battery life.

I mostly use my laptop at school for a few things, browsing the internet, downloading from newsgroups (which I dump at home to my server), watching 720p .mkv's and running electronic workbench and matlab simulations (but will eventually get into other electrical engineering simulators).

I'm basing my cost off the price of getting the eee 901 which locally is roughly $500 CAD. I don't mind spending more (or less :cool: ) if it means I can run more of the features below. I stared the ones I'd want for sure.

I want in order of importance:
*6 cell battery + runs xp (if it comes with Linux the ability to flash to xp with drivers is fine)
*able to watch .mkv in 720p
*upgradable to 2+gb ram.
*wireless n
regular sized keyboard
smallest screen, highest resolution
ssh as opposed to hdd.
HDMI output (not really needed as I think only the Samsung's has one)

I don't mind so much if the mat lab or EWB can't run as I can use the lab at school or my quad core at home to do it. But for convenience it would be nice to have in case I have to demo it in the lab. I mainly want to make sure the 720p videos work as when I tested my friends eeepc (I explain below) it couldn't play it at regular speed. I want to make sure the videos I get will play while on the train, even though they will be shrunk to fit the screen.

I originally had my heart set on the eee 901 because of it's long battery life, but I'm iffy about the keyboard. I do have small hands and I think I'd adjust.

I tried installing CCCP on my friends older model (non atom) eeepc but when I went to play a .mkv it would studder and the video would lag. When I tried installed CCCP on a random atom netbook at best buy same problem, it can't decode the video fast enough. It actually ran worse than my friends older eeepc but he claimed it was because his was an empty install of xp as opposed to the factory xp installed with it's background processes.

Can any of these netbooks play 720 videos? Would (should) I learn towards a 10" 1000H, as the hdd space would be appreciated and the battery life wouldn't take as big a hit. Also would the fact that the store pc only had 1 gb of ram be the problem. Some one was telling me that 2gb wouldn't make a difference as the eee's weren't based on a specific chipset and were lacking hd hardware decoding???

I also love the look of the lenevo s10 but the lack of 6cell is a deal breaker. Plus I noticed the samsung NC10 has an hdmi out port so I'd assume it should be able to run 720p. Would waiting be a better option.
 
The MSI Wind I tried didn't struggle with an mkv I encoded to 1024x600. 1.6GHz Atom was able to handle it.

EDIT: Asus N10 has a 9300GS which AFAIK can decode HD streams upto 1080p. Just re-encode to something decodeable by the 9300GS and you're set.
 
The MSI Wind I tried didn't struggle with an mkv I encoded to 1024x600. 1.6GHz Atom was able to handle it.

EDIT: Asus N10 has a 9300GS which AFAIK can decode HD streams upto 1080p. Just re-encode to something decodeable by the 9300GS and you're set.

Yeah I'd like to not have to re-encode to get it to play. Rather just download and watch, this way later at home if I play it from the server to my tv or desktop I don't get a smaller video.
 
THe only netbook with a screen above 1024x600 is the HP2133 series which is 1280x768, unfortunately they're crippled with via c7 processors and only get 4hrs on a 6 cell battery.
 
Why is it an issue for 720p playback on an 7-10" screen? What is the logic of such high resolution on a low rez small screen? There simply is no perceivable differance between a standard DVD rip from a HD rip when screen size and monitor size are factored in.
 
I was thinking the same thing. I cant think of any convievable notion of why people feel the need to get 1280x768/1920x1080 video to play on a device with a 7-10inch 1024x600 (usually) screen. Granted, my entire media library is compose of exactly that, but I have a quad-core desktop to play it back. These are NETbooks people, surf the web on them!
 
Why is it an issue for 720p playback on an 7-10" screen? What is the logic of such high resolution on a low rez small screen? There simply is no perceivable differance between a standard DVD rip from a HD rip when screen size and monitor size are factored in.
I was thinking the same thing. I cant think of any convievable notion of why people feel the need to get 1280x768/1920x1080 video to play on a device with a 7-10inch 1024x600 (usually) screen. Granted, my entire media library is compose of exactly that, but I have a quad-core desktop to play it back. These are NETbooks people, surf the web on them!

You guys are misunderstanding me. I watch these at home on my HDTV with my family as well as on my 22" desktop LCD on my quad core. However because school gets busy and picks up I want to be able to view these on my netbook without having to re-encoding them. This way if I know I can't watch the video tonight I can transfer it off my home server to my 8gb USB key or straight to the netbook so I can watch it on the train.

Or vice versa, if I download it at school I'd like to watch it on the way home, but transfer it to my home server so I can watch it later. Once again for a 1 hour video I don't want to spend an extra hour (or more if I'm doing it on the netbook) encoding it. I don't mind the fact then while watching it on the netbook it won't be any different than say a dvd or .avi but it's for when I get home and watch it on my tv can you notice the difference.

Plus as it stands right now, whipping out my 14.1" laptop with the extended bottom battery isn't the most comfortable thing to do on a crowded train this is why I'm exploring the netbook avenue. Just being able to whip it out and watch the video then throw it back in my bag seals the purchase. After the I'd like the smallest one possible.
 
If your watching them on your HDTV, get a computer that can handle it. Even with your 22" desktop HD is hardly noticable. And wipping out your 14" laptop won't make your HD video look any better then an 8.9" netbook. Yes we all want, want, but this it the freaking reality of where these netbooks are at now.
 
If your watching them on your HDTV, get a computer that can handle it.
This is what I'm wondering. Which eee's or other netbooks can run these videos?
Even with your 22" desktop HD is hardly noticable.
I notice a huge difference between .avi's and .mkv's.
And wipping out your 14" laptop won't make your HD video look any better then an 8.9" netbook. Yes we all want, want, but this it the freaking reality of where these netbooks are at now.
I don't care about it being HD on the road. I just want it to be viewable on the road. Well viewable and more portable, which is why I want to replace my 14" with a 7-10".
 
I notice a huge difference between .avi's and .mkv's.

I don't care about it being HD on the road. I just want it to be viewable on the road. Well viewable and more portable, which is why I want to replace my 14" with a 7-10".

.avi's and .mkv's are just wrappers. Nothing to do with resolution. Same thing.
If you want to replace your 14" then render out SD .avi's or .mkv's from your all HD media library. If you own a decent PC you should be able to convert 10 movies or so in an overnight. The bonus is you can rip most movies to 700MB and fit a lot more content to an SDHC card and you will never notice the resolution decrease untill you get it on a 40" screen.
 
I want in order of importance:
*6 cell battery + runs xp (if it comes with Linux the ability to flash to xp with drivers is fine)
*able to watch .mkv in 720p
*upgradable to 2+gb ram.
*wireless n
regular sized keyboard
smallest screen, highest resolution
ssh as opposed to hdd.
HDMI output (not really needed as I think only the Samsung's has one)


N10J from asus also has HDMI
to have any chance to get what you mention... get the N10J
if you have money
get the N10J
then get a SSD like the solid series from OCZ 30gb... cheap..
 
N10J from asus also has HDMI
to have any chance to get what you mention... get the N10J
if you have money
get the N10J
then get a SSD like the solid series from OCZ 30gb... cheap..

What's the battery life though. I've been graced with long battery life in the past I can't go back now.
 
Is the internal fan loud on the Acer Aspire One?

On mine it is. Some users reports its whisper quite, and others it sounds like a wind tunnel.

There is a application call A1CTL that can control the fan in windows.

Thread about it here.

I use it and it works very well. Keeps noise and temps down.
 
the lack of 1080 or 720 playback is due to the single core CPU and crappy intel IGP

i own a 901 and i use it to watch videos all the time but i have to OC the CPU to play 720p

most of my videos are dvd rips but some are HD recorded from my HDhomerun via VMC.....

i was hoping for a 780g chipset netbook, but thats not going to happen soon
 
the lack of 1080 or 720 playback is due to the single core CPU and crappy intel IGP

i own a 901 and i use it to watch videos all the time but i have to OC the CPU to play 720p

most of my videos are dvd rips but some are HD recorded from my HDhomerun via VMC.....

i was hoping for a 780g chipset netbook, but thats not going to happen soon

How easy was the OC? Just adjusting bios voltages? If I could get the 901 to play 720p no problem in xp I'd go buy one tomorrow.
 
I just got myself a 500gb seagate 5400.6 drive
(it is fast and quiet)
for my N10J
and i loaded alot of movie/video on it.. many are 1080p video

It can run those movie nicly via HDMI to 1080p HDTV
 
No. :)

These are computers people, use them however you like.

lol, agreed. Pretty nice computers at that. I have Ubuntu Netbook Remix all loaded up on my new Acer Aspire One. Bought it here in Mexico, came with a 160gb HDD and 3-cell battery :rolleyes: But took the spanish XP off and enjoying Ubuntu... haven't really had a need for Windows yet, although I'm thinking of throwing on a vlite'd Vista or maybe lighter XP.
 
How easy was the OC? Just adjusting bios voltages? If I could get the 901 to play 720p no problem in xp I'd go buy one tomorrow.

SuperChicken,
In this Lenovo S10 video, at 4 minutes into it they play a 720p video with only 40-60% cpu utilization.
The specs are very similar for all the netbooks, so I'm not sure why this one would be able to play 720 and the others can't. I too would like to able to just throw some movies I already have on it and be able to watch them.

But it only has a 3 cell battery. Right now I am leaning towards a AAO 6 cell.
 
It's actually very strange, under Ubuntu I was streaming 720p shows and movies to my AAO with no dropped frames that I could detect. It looked great.

I installed vista today on it (mostly because I borked my ubuntu install....) And now those same 720p videos play a frame like every other second, VERY unwatchable. I don't know what it is, because it's not like its maxing out the cpu, although its putting a good amount of strain on. My vista install was a custom vlite'd install with the iso image only 800mb.
 
My criteria was the smallest possible netbook, volume wise, that had a 10" screen.

That is the Lenovo S10e.

As a bonus it comes with an expresscard and splashtop.

If battery life is someone elses most important attribute then i can well appreciate the Samsung being first pick.

I am very happy with my S10e, it even plays Flashpoint!
 
It's actually very strange, under Ubuntu I was streaming 720p shows and movies to my AAO with no dropped frames that I could detect. It looked great.

I installed vista today on it (mostly because I borked my ubuntu install....) And now those same 720p videos play a frame like every other second, VERY unwatchable. I don't know what it is, because it's not like its maxing out the cpu, although its putting a good amount of strain on. My vista install was a custom vlite'd install with the iso image only 800mb.

Media Player Classic + CoreAVC = 720p h264 plays smooth.
 
Well funny i started this thread and still havent bought anything...Im waiting for JandR, which is about five blocks from my apt to get the Samsung in stock..they keep selling out.
 
SuperChicken,
In this Lenovo S10 video, at 4 minutes into it they play a 720p video with only 40-60% cpu utilization.
The specs are very similar for all the netbooks, so I'm not sure why this one would be able to play 720 and the others can't. I too would like to able to just throw some movies I already have on it and be able to watch them.

But it only has a 3 cell battery. Right now I am leaning towards a AAO 6 cell.

Yeah, I just quickly threw on CCCP but not CoreAVC. I called up my friend and I'm going to put it on his (non atom eee) and see how well it runs. Once I'm finished exams on the 11th I'm going to dive into heavy research to see which one I'm going to get.

I'm like the NC10 for battery life, hdd space, keyboard shift key and should run 720p. But I'm iffy about screen size and no wireless N. (Both of which I can live without) However if i can find a 7 or 9" that has everything NC10 has I'd lean towards that.

Plus I've got to figure out how this live cashback works. Is it US only, because every search I do never leads me to eBay and I'm only getting 2.5% back as opposed to the 20-30% you guys are.
 
I just picked up an Asus EEE 1000 HA on the weekend.

So far, with the Daemon tools light, I've managed to jam on some older games (HL, Diablo2, Starcraft) just for starters. Even ran up an old win98 game (Recoil - in 98 compatibility mode). Everything is flawless so far though Diablo2 is a bit "chunky" with the overhead map going. Open office, AVG, Zonealarm and other apps have been installed as well.

I've been running "standard" video files on the unit and haven't yet tried any 720p material. Standard files (350/700 meg) have been smooth. Colour on the screen is also good. I need to try and hook this into my tv yet and try this out (my tv supports vga).

Features vs price point: The asus is a good deal.

At this point, I'm pretty pleased with performance and battery time on the unit.
 
Also, not all encodes are the same. If it is not done the right way, it can cause the CPU to have to do much more work. The best ways to maximize success is to get rid of any CODEC pack and follow the guide in the HTPC subforum.
 
Does anyone have impressions of the Asus Eee PC 1002HA? After reading a couple previews/reviews it seems like a good fit for me, but I wanted to see if anyone here has actually had their hands on it yet.

My impressions from reading about it:

Pros: Great chassis design with sleek brushed aluminum case, large touchpad, easily upgradable hard drive.

Cons: Slightly more expensive than the NC10, battery life isn't great, right shift key is placed awkwardly (but this doesn't concern me, as I never use right shift).
 
My search on Craigslist has begun. I have e-mailed every single AAO seller. If none will sell to me at my desired price, I shall wait at Frys and BB during Black Fridays.

I didn't see any particularly good deals on Black Friday on netbooks, maybe I missed 'em since I didn't see any eye-popping deals on much of anything anyway. I'd been looking for a GPS as a present for months and the Garmin 750 that Costco had been selling online for a month for $200 was a better deal than anything I saw on black friday, seems like retailers were trying to clear out stock of a lot of older models (non-widescreen models or models that don't have TTS to speak out street names, etc.).

Anyway, this thread certainly took a turn into vide-conversion land but I just wanted to pipe in and state I've been absolutely and completely satisfied with my AAO... For the price I haven't seen anything that can beat it still. The NC10 is a nice upgrade for an extra $100, but frankly I'm kinda glad I pulled the trigger and saved myself the $100. 5+ hours of battery life is enough and I've been using one of the SD slots (where the card is fully recessed) as my backup solution. Gonna look into using it as a ReadyBoost-like devide with a program I've heard of for WinXP... Plenty of space on it at 16GB.

On the NC10 the SD cards don't sit flush with the case, that's probably the only semi-significant flaw I've read about it for anyone that's got $500 to spend... Other than that it's got the extra 1" on screen size over the AAO, along with better speakers and somewhat better battery life; as has probably been stated here before.

Battery life on my AA1 has been very very consistent and I've encountered literally no quriks whatosever. I'd heard of reports of WiFi slowing down after Hibernate or not re-initializing but mine came with almost all the newest drivers installed and it's been smooth sailing. Installed NIS and MS Office on it over the network in under an hour without a hitch too. The fan's not loud at all, but audible in a quiet room... AA1FanCtl or w/e that app is called easily solves that though (look for it at www.aspireoneuser.com).

If you're looking for a simple sleeve for it (or similarly sized netbooks), Walmart has those Case Logic sleeves (MDXS-9, I think online they show up as MDX-9 w/o the S) cheaper than anyone else does, and in more color choices to boot. I like this one specifically because it lacks any zippers, it's easier to slip the laptop in and out (folds back) and it's probably less trouble at the airport w/TSA's requirements.
 
well i started this thread back on 10-18 and today i FINALLY bought a netbook! yeah!....I bought the Asus N10J series...very sweet, vid cam and fingerprint scanner. Just setting it up now, but i love how it looks.
 
its good that u were patient and waited/took your time.... because in those 2 months, the value/money has skyrocketed with these things if you shop at the right places.....
 
I loved my MSI wind. It's great for the price and size. The keyboard was much bigger than other netbooks. I compared it up close to the lenovo s10 and the wind just had a better feel to it.

Ps.I'm selling my Wind to fund a desktop replacement, if anyone is interested.
 
maybe I missed 'em since I didn't see any eye-popping deals on much of anything anyway.

Bingo. To have watched the evening news, you'd have thought the whole world was on sale, but if you actually go to a store, there was jack. I got some stuff from newegg, but the deals were pretty much the same deals newegg always has.

completely satisfied with my AAO... For the price I haven't seen anything that can beat it still. The NC10 is a nice upgrade for an extra $100, but frankly I'm kinda glad I pulled the trigger and saved myself the $100. 5+ hours of battery life is enough and I've been using one of the SD slots (where the card is fully recessed) as my backup solution. Gonna look into using it as a ReadyBoost-like devide with a program I've heard of for WinXP... Plenty of space on it at 16GB.

I'm also totally happy with my AAO. The NC10 wasn't on the block when I made my buy, but those reviews were painfully tempting. I got live's ebay cashback AND paypal 10% off coupon for my purchase, so it would have been more than 100$ premium for me to wait. It was on my radar, but I'm glad I didn't hold off. My AAO is better than I'd hoped. I actually didn't want a glossy screen because of the glare, but I had no idea it would make colors look as rich as it does, and it's turned out to be a nice perk.

The glossy exterior however, is every bit as much a pain as I imagined.

I'm actually pretty impressed with it's gaming prowess too. Still tinkering with it, but frankly, I expected less than it can actually do. Tinkering with resolutions is annoying, but lots of people have been working on that and providing tools to help.

If you're looking for a simple sleeve for it (or similarly sized netbooks), Walmart has those Case Logic sleeves (MDXS-9, I think online they show up as MDX-9 w/o the S) cheaper than anyone else does, and in more color choices to boot. I like this one specifically because it lacks any zippers, it's easier to slip the laptop in and out (folds back) and it's probably less trouble at the airport w/TSA's requirements.

I just ordered the deal extreme one: http://www.dealextreme.com/details.dx/sku.15379

5$ with free ship is nice. A lot of other users reported success with it, and no zipper was one of my reqs. I don't like the red shows through even when it's on its black side, but no biggie.
 
On the Samsung NC10. I installed the K-Lite codec pack and everything seemed to work fine with 720p content til I skipped ahead then the audio didn't match up. Installed CoreAVC + MPC and skipping ahead has no effect on the audio sync. Really impressed with this machine.

Might need to upgrade the HDD to something a lil bigger if I can.
 
I had to go with an Asus EEE 900a... sure, I know, probably the least feature packed of them all, but you can find the Linux only for dirt cheap. If all you're doing is internet and email you really can't beat the price vs performance.
 
Fry's has the AAO now for $299 out the door (the 1GB/8GB SSD model)... not a sale price either, I think they'll be selling it that way from now on as the regular day-to-day price. Not too bad... not too bad at all.
 
IMO, what I've seen so far, in comparison to the stock netbooks that every company has done so far, I think the Samsung seems to be best for its keyboard, battery life, and size.
 
On the Samsung NC10. I installed the K-Lite codec pack and everything seemed to work fine with 720p content til I skipped ahead then the audio didn't match up. Installed CoreAVC + MPC and skipping ahead has no effect on the audio sync. Really impressed with this machine.

Might need to upgrade the HDD to something a lil bigger if I can.

Yeah, that Samsung looks good. I was waiting for the Sammy's to drop a little in price. I have essentially $500 for a Netbook from my HP1000 return. Rather not blow it all though.

Anyone know any B&M that carry the Samsung? I checked a Best Buy, they didn't have it.

My ideal netbook is: small/compact, lightweight, 6-cell battery stock, good keyboard (usually means 10" screen), fast boot times. Prefer Wireless-N support.
 
I purchased the HP Mini 1000, and so far have been nothing but delighted with it. It is plenty fast enough for Hulu and Youtube, which my Aspire One was not. I don't know why this is, but the AAO Hulu and Youtube were virtuall unwatchable. I guess that perhaps the HP's SSD helps with it some, I honestly have no idea. I can say that so far I am very impressed with the speed of the SSD, and it's SO much quieter than the Aspire One. The One made a good deal of noise when it was doing anything but web surfing, but the HP is whisper quiet. I have gotten mine to the point where it will boot in only 38 seconds from power on to ready to go. That's very impressive, but that's all thanks to the SSD. I'm surprised the HP Mini 1000 isn't a more popular netbook, because I love mine.
 
Back
Top