Netbook..which one to get?

harsaphes

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Aug 29, 2005
Messages
5,333
Well i want to pick up a netbook this weekend and cant decide which one to get...I was leaning towards the Asus 1000HD or HA, but would like to hear what others have to say.
500 is about the max.
Your thoughts?
 
Go with the HD you'll need the wireless.

In general Asus is good and the EEE pc is really popular. I know a few people who have it and really like it.

You really only need a netbook though right?
 
i love my 901 eee pc, i like the 8.9" size...... it is great for portability. i havent used the 10" but
 
The ASUS EEE has been really dropping in price lately.
 
I tried the EEE 901, and I found the tiny keyboard unusable, even for my tiny hands. The 1000HD right next to it (at Bestbuy), was great, though. I'd go for the 1000HA over the 1000HD for the atom processor. Try to get it on ebay with the 30% off cashback. It'll end up being around $300.

I wish I could try the MSI Wind, but I doubt it'd be worth the extra cost over the 1000HA. I don't think the wireless N and bluetooth is worth the extra money for the 1000H either.

The Lenovo S10 is supposed to have a smaller keyboard than the 1000HA, and so is the Aspire One. Oh, and the Samsung just came out I think, but I'm pretty sure it's expensive.
 
If you get a 1000 go for the HA over the HD. The wind is cheaper than the ha now. it 400 after a 50 MIR. So cost isn't an issue. I suggest researching the wind and ha and see which one fits your needs more.
 
If you get a 1000 go for the HA over the HD. The wind is cheaper than the ha now. it 400 after a 50 MIR. So cost isn't an issue. I suggest researching the wind and ha and see which one fits your needs more.

For the 3 cell? 9"? Where are you seeing that price?
 
FYI on the wind, recent production isn't using a synaptics touchpad. This is only significant in that synaptics has a patent monopoly on swiping the edge of the pad to scroll. It's not a feature I've ever used but if you do, the wind's probably not what you want.
 
This is only significant in that synaptics has a patent monopoly on swiping the edge of the pad to scroll.

Ya know, thats the first "feature" I disable when I use a laptop with a synaptics pad.

I picked up an Acer Aspire One last week and soon as I got into XP, I went hunting for the option to turn that fucking thing off.

If a laptop has a huge Macbook like touchpad, then it might be an ok feature to have. But cosidering how small the touuchpad on these Netbooks are...yeah, no thanks.
 
does 10.2" screen usually come with a full size keyboard. I have big hands and i dont think i can compensate for a smaller scaled keyboard.
 
Ya know, thats the first "feature" I disable when I use a laptop with a synaptics pad.

I picked up an Acer Aspire One last week and soon as I got into XP, I went hunting for the option to turn that fucking thing off.

If a laptop has a huge Macbook like touchpad, then it might be an ok feature to have. But cosidering how small the touuchpad on these Netbooks are...yeah, no thanks.

Wrd on that hahaha I had to turn that f ka off too
I scrolled all over the frigen screen ....
 
the 10" models come with 92/95% keyboards. I have large hands* and was able to start typing on my wind with almost no adjustment, the only issues being in the bottom corners were the fn/ctrl buttons were swapped and things got a little squished.

* With the edge of my palm on the left end of a keyboard my fingertips cover the 8, O, L, and comma keys.
 
I'vw owned the top model of "The One" for a couple of weeks now and absolutely love it. The 6 cell battery life is outstanding. Screen quality and size is adequate and the machine really does the job done under XP. Vista would be a stretch, but people have put it on them.

A bonus is that I can play my Worms World Party again ;-) (it did not run under Vista)
As for graphics card, it will play games 5 year old (tried Max Payne, and GTA3) I installed Phantom CD to mount images for the drive requirement and bought 8gb SD card to hold as my "image drive".

Love two card ports BTW.

My 2 cents,
DK
 
The best suggestion is to try out all of the netbooks you can before you buy any. The stats are essentially identical between all the brands, with the exception of N wireless, bluetooth, screen size and 3G. The most crucial thing is usability and build quality.

For me, the choice was the Aspire One. I tried out the MSI Wind and the Asus EEE with mixed feelings. The Asus EEE has that annoying right shift key to the right of the up arrow problem that is omnipresent in 92%/95% keyboards, so that you really have to retrain yourself to type at full speed. The MSI Wind's keyboard had way too much flex for me to happily type away at it. The S10 hadn't been released at the time, so I don't know much about it, and the Dell's keyboard simply makes no sense whatsoever.
The touchpads suck across the board, regardless of whether the buttons are to the side or below. Fine control simply doesn't exist on a 1" by 2" rectangle. Your best bet is to get a Logitech VX450 Nano and leave the dongle in there permanently.

As for screen size, 8.9" is a great size IMO. It takes time to get used to and you'll definitely get annoyed by it at times, but it's a very portable size. By the time you get to 10" and 11" sizes, you're looking at an ultraportable rather than a netbook.

I personally own an Aspire One since I found the $350 price point unbeatable at the time (mid-August), and I don't regret it at all.

*edit*
fixing wall of text problem
 
MSI Wind or Acer Aspire One imo, the keyboard on those two seems far more usable than any of the other netbooks (Dell, most/all ASUS EEE's, etc.). The AAO in particular is pretty attactively priced, at $400 for a 160GB version with 1GB RAM, Win XP, and a 6-cell battery... That's one thing I'd want for sure, a 6-cell as opposed to a 3 or 4-cell battery. The AAO SSD versions with Linux are even cheaper, you can get WinXP installed on 'em but it's tricky, the SSD is a lil' sluggish.

The Wind's a lil' wider, but they're both wider than the EEE 901 which allows for a better keyboard design, the 1000 has a somewhat larger keyboard too but some of the key arrangements are off. Altho it's cheaper than the 901 in some cases, with a HDD (not SSD), which doesn't make much sense but w/e. I really like the fact that the AAO has dedicated Page Up/Down keys by the arrow keys (wasted space on other keyboards, really useful with these screen sizes tho), and none of it's keys are too skinny (punctuation keys on the Wind are, they're used a lot in programming). Dell's kb is just atrocious if you do anything more than IM on it...

As noted, MSI has switched from a Synaptics pad to something else, which may or may not bother you... Can't really speak on the quality of the touchpad they're using now. The AAO's side buttons might bug ya as well, personally I've got no problem with them but if you're really really used to buttons below the touchpad it might bother ya. I actually find it more comfortable. The Wind touchpad is a lil' taller.
 
Hmm, good info in this post. I had it narrowed down to the AAO or the 1000HA, but the AAO is starting to look more attractive with its slightly smaller design and better keyboard layout, not to mention cheaper.

I was almost convinced with the 1000HA because of the supposedly better speakers, bigger screen, overclocking ability, screen resolution changing on-the-fly.... But I wonder how often I would actually use most of that stuff. The speakers would definitely come in handy for watching movies with my wife, but other than that....
 
The only complaint I have about my eeePC 1000H/XP is that stupid right shift key. I can't believe any engineer thought that was a good idea, especially since there is plenty of room for a normal shift key.

It is very easy to upgrade and, unlike the Wind, does not void the warranty when you do so. A 2GB module was only $33 from Crucial.
 
i am have been using my 901 for about a week and all i can say is that i am typing on it right now and have found that the keyboards is small but it is useable..... it takes some getting used to, but the fact that it is smaller than my Bible and can take it anywhere makes this one of the best devices i have ever used.


I also own an ATT Tilt and have found myself only using it as a 3g modem for my 901. I havent used it to suft the net or watch TV this whole week bc my 901 is always with me.


I upgraded to 2gb of RAM and I just bought a 1.8" 80gb hard drive for it to replace the 8gb MLC SDD.

I installed a vlite copy of vista ultimate that uses around 2gb so i have 1.5gb +/- free on my c: drive and it is fast. I love the look and feel of vista and the multitouch touchpad is awsome. I use the ALT+TAB 3 finger swipe all the time, pg back and pg forward finger swipes and also the two finger scroll.


I think the eee PC line wins hands down bc of the touchpad and its multitouch ability.


Zooming in on webpages or rotating photos is very easy and it add a cool factor to it as well.


JMO, but it is a great little toy that i use everyday.
 
What does Alt+Tab+3 fingers do? I've heard from others that they weren't quite as happy with the touchpad in general, some said they would've rather had a regular Synaptics touchpad, though the EEE's touchpad is one of the things that had initially attracted me to the line...

The AAO is still smaller (a lil' under an inch on each side) and like $80 cheaper for the same general specs. Screen's an inch smaller too though, albeit with the same res. Guess you can't really go wrong with either, comes down to personal choices. I've seen Newegg have a $50 rebate on the 1000H in the past too, which makes it more attractively priced...

Personally, I'm all about the keyboard layout, it's by far the one aspect of the netbook with the most potential to infuriate me... :p Edit: That and I'm rather partial to the blue AAO, heh.
 
the 3 fingers down pulls up alt+tab and the move right to left to switch programs, just like alt+tab

the eee line does not come with the drivers from the touchpad manufacturer but rather it uses MS driver, which does not enable zooming or the 3 finger alt+tab function or pg up and pg down.
 
Ahh, I see, cool functionality... Weird that it comes without the proper drivers installed.
 
Well I just got my eee pc 1000ha today, I have not started to play with mine yet but have used one at Best buy before. It took me about 3 weeks to decide which to get, ended up with the eee for the screen/keyboard size, easy upgrades, and most of all the long battery life!
 
I bought an Acer Aspire One yesterday. Cost was a pretty high priority. With Ebay/paypal's fall coupon and Live's 25% cashback, I'll be out around $270 for for 1gig, 160gb, atom 1.6ghz 6 cell. No bluetooth will only bother me later on if I get a hankering for cell data BT tethering, and there are tiny usb dongles now that only stick out a couple of centimeters that will work just fine for that. No wireless N is a little bit of a letdown, but not much.

If the ideal (ideal for me specifically) netbook existed already, cost wouldn't have been as much of a priority. The Asus N10j comes close, and maybe it's next generation will be everything I want, but not this year. For now, I like what I got for my money, and I won't kick myself in 18 months when the perfect netbook arrives and I want it bad.
 
I got one of those tiny Bluetooth adapters for using with my netbook (whenever I get around to buying it), been using it with my main system right now to use my cell phone as a remote (Sony Ericsson, comes with profiles to do that), works pretty nicely actually,

Anyway, I got an iogear that Best Buy carries for like $30... I was gonna order a $20 one off Newegg, Azio brand, because it's Class 1 which has much farther range... As opposed to Class 2 for the iogear and most others, but I started reading about the different drivers and Bluetooth stacks that all those dongles come with. Ideally any one of 'em installs and operates seamlessly, and you can even mix and match to an extent, in practice it can be tricky sometimes.

I ended up getting the iogear dongle 'cuz it was available locally and because it comes with drivers that use the Widcomm stack. There's like 3 or 4 different BT stacks too... MS' own, Widcomm (the oldest 3rd party one, originally by Broadcomm), a Toshiba one, and I forget what else.
 
i use my bluetooth all the time with my netbook, eee pc 901: 2gb of RAM running vlite vista, i would not really use my netbook much if it wasnt for the ability to connect to my ATT Tilt and use my 3G internet


I love it, i am so temped even in the car to use it ;) i dont but i am soooooo temped to be here on [H] while driving.


as for the eee pc multi touch touchpad, i have gotten so use to it that when i use any other laptop my productivity goes down, i find myself struggling to scroll on pages and alt+tab, right click, zoom and rotate are all function I use with my touchpad on a regualar basis

I looked into the AAO but the soldered RAM and lack of bluetooth was a killer and with the ebay live 30% cash back i got my 901 for $330
 
Another vote for the AAO. I couldn't be happier with mine, its such a nice little machine, and the build quality is top notch. Vista runs beautifully on it, Aero and all, even with 1GB of RAM. I will, however, be upping that to 1.5GB soon (the max amount supported by the chipset)

http://www.aspireoneuser.com/forum/
 
Technically, the max amount supported by the chipset is actually 2GB, not 1.5GB... Problem is, 512MB is obviously soldered in, and you can't run 2.5GB (due to the chipset). The intelligent work-around on Acer's part would be to allow users to disable the on-board soldered 512MB of RAM thru the BIOS, so the user can add a 2GB DIMM. I know of at 'least one other Atom netbook that allows this, alas... It's not an option. Not really a big deal either way, just saying.
 
So I think I may have narrowed it down between 2. Acer Aspire One and the Asus EEE 1000H or the 1000HA. I cant seem to find a difference between the Asus models other than wireless N. Note worth 50 bucks to me.
 
So I think I may have narrowed it down between 2. Acer Aspire One and the Asus EEE 1000H or the 1000HA. I cant seem to find a difference between the Asus models other than wireless N. Note worth 50 bucks to me.

Wireless N and Bluetooth. If you don't use either than save the $50 with the HA. It's a difficult decision though because these netbooks all have basically the exact or very similar specs... I'm leaning towards the AAO myself because it's cheaper, smaller, lighter, more portable, and MUCH better keyboard because of the shift key. On the other hand, the Asus has improved speakers (probably not by much though), bigger screen, expandable to a full 2 gigs of ram...
 
^^ I will say, I love my AAO to death, but the speakers are atrocioius. I think I blew them out already, and I have had the thing for a week. I don't even use full volume.

At the end of the day though, they ARE just laptop speakers, i don't in any way expect them to sound good.
 
You know, I may need to take another look at the Asus. If it has the same jacked up keyboard layout as there past models then I dont want it. I thought at first due to the larger screen, they may have reworked the keyboard but never looked yet. lol

Acer may be the way to go.
 
The 1000 has a different keyboard than the older models 92 or 95% vs 80%.
 
if you are a lefty (like us), the misplaced right shift key doesnt matter at all

also, consider that the 1000H/A might actually be more portable than the AAO because of the standard 6 cell battery... which means for most people, carrying a power adapter is not necessary for a day's worth of computing.

dont forget the extra inch of screen space, correct mouse button placement


as a sidenote, I've managed the increase the battery life by about 20 minutes (to 6:20) of my girlfriend's 1000H by installing an application that automatically turned off Aero while on battery power.
 
Back
Top