THQ: Pre-Owned Games 'Cheats Developers'

Now your being pedantic, this is an illegal action and outside the regular realm and scope of THQ's arguments. We are mearly addressing the idea of used games, not the issue of piracy.

There is an issue with identifying customers, which is why they're saying it cheats them of revenue. To them, a used game purchaser, isn't their customer.
 
So by that logic, if I sell my used car to somebody I cheat the manufacturer of that car. And if I sell my Levi's to a used clothes place and somebody buys them I am cheating Levi's. Our economy has been built upon the basis that you can buy and sell your stuff as you see fit. Video games are no different than any other commodity we buy or sell. If I am done with a product I own and no longer want it, it is perfectly fine for me to sell it.

What the dumb asses haven't figure out is that often game owners sell their old games, in order to buy something new that they may not have been ordinarily been able to afford at the time. This in turn allows more new games to be sold, not less.

The difference is demanding full price performance for a used product. You don't expect your levi's to be "new" nor your car. The issue they're having is why should they take a bandwidth and usage hit for someone who didn't buy the game from them? Its a legitamate complaint, but likely not the reason they put it in. Their fix is to treat their game like mmos do and have you purchase essentially a key to online access, with single player option. I'm certain its to prevent piracy less than it is to cut out the used game market.
 
Let's not kid ourselves - buying used games does rip off the developers.

There is no incentive to buy a new game when you can get the same exact product used for half the price, which is what I used to do by purchasing games through Half.com and through the forums.

There is no "wear and tear" on a disc unless someone has mishandled it, and you get everything the initial buyer got, just at less cost.

I completely understand the need for Day One DLC and the Cerberus Network and such.

You can rationalize it any desperate way you want, but when you buy a used game, you are not supporting the developer.

The game gets scratches over time, even if you are really careful. The case, manual, etc all get worn out. If it gets too many scratches, you won't be able to use it anymore. And it depreciates over time.

How is this different from any other product? A well-cared for piece of solid-state electronics can last forever in the same way, but that doesn't mean you don't get to own it.
 
The difference is demanding full price performance for a used product. You don't expect your levi's to be "new" nor your car. The issue they're having is why should they take a bandwidth and usage hit for someone who didn't buy the game from them? Its a legitamate complaint, but likely not the reason they put it in. Their fix is to treat their game like mmos do and have you purchase essentially a key to online access, with single player option. I'm certain its to prevent piracy less than it is to cut out the used game market.

I fully expect my used CD, DVD, or BRD to function exactly the same as a new one.
If they are crying about bandwidth issues, fine, charge a subscription, or allow privately run servers.
But, we can NOT under any circumstance allow them to say used game sales are like piracy, with out telling them they are full of it. Their kind like to take little bites like this at the truth until people actually believe that their version is the truth. Every time some BS like this is brought up we need to pump our fists in the air, talk about the first sale doctrine, and tell these asses that they are liars when they attempt to liken used sales to piracy, or claim we are cheating them.
 
The difference is demanding full price performance for a used product. You don't expect your levi's to be "new" nor your car. The issue they're having is why should they take a bandwidth and usage hit for someone who didn't buy the game from them? Its a legitamate complaint, but likely not the reason they put it in. Their fix is to treat their game like mmos do and have you purchase essentially a key to online access, with single player option. I'm certain its to prevent piracy less than it is to cut out the used game market.

What hit are they taking? The original purchaser is going to use their bandwith. If they sell it to someone else, that other person uses the bandwith instead. 1 copy sold, 1 user of bandwith. It's not like it magically turns into 1 copy sold, 2 users of bandwith. There is no hit in that realm.

They just don't want anyone reselling the game, so they can make more money. That's pretty much all it boils down to.
 
The difference is demanding full price performance for a used product. You don't expect your levi's to be "new" nor your car. The issue they're having is why should they take a bandwidth and usage hit for someone who didn't buy the game from them?
Except that games' value does deteriorate over time, simply because the game has been available for a while. New games are expected to have the latest graphics and exciting new gameplay and whatever else. Their newness is the novelty, and plenty of people are willing to pay for it, in the same way plenty of people go to the movie theatre when they know the DVD will be out in a few months and they can spend less on it. It's not like used games sit on the shelf next to copies of the same game that just came out, there's a few months lag before they'll be regularly available.

Also, why should I accept being forced to use their servers that they will inevitably shut down, depriving me of that part of the game? Why do I care that they might have to support a bit more playtime because I'm done with the game and pass it on to someone else, it's not my problem, they just need to deal. Also I think the norm on consoles (which they seem to be mostly talking about) is for games to be entirely P2P with only matchmaking provided, meaning their cost to provide the service is a very, very small part of the purchase price.

Personally I think THQ and other devs are probably more pissed about the fact that companies like GameStop make mad bank off the used game sells. Plus they tend to push used games sales and trade in's down peoples throats maximizing the stores profits at the expense of the devs.
Yeah, as a consumer gamestop pisses me off too, and I'd never buy a used game from them because their prices are absurd. However they are a legitimate business and if THQ doesn't like it, they need to improve their product and actually compete, instead of try to use shenanigans to force them out of the market. One reason GameStop behaves like this is their own damn fault for the price fixing and tight margins they force on retailers.
 
It is pretty bad that these companies have already stopped us from returning product we don't like, now they try to limit our ability to sell it as well.

What exactly are the options we have left when dissatisfied with their product?

If I buy an MP3 player from a local electronics shop I can return it for a full refund if I don't like it for about 15 days. After that I can always sell it, and the next user won't find it crippled, thus my resale won't be crippled.

But games. Can't return them and they want to stop you from selling as well.

Forget us ripping developers off. This is all about the developer ripping us off.
 
I don't know why this has generated so much discussion. Has everyone forgotten it's THQ we're talking about? I mean, they make WWE games. I'm sure all 50 of their loyal game buyers are just fine with THQ's position. In other news, gamers exclaim: They make wrestling games?
 
Let's not kid ourselves - buying used games does rip off the developers.

There is no incentive to buy a new game when you can get the same exact product used for half the price, which is what I used to do by purchasing games through Half.com and through the forums.

This describes second hand sales as a concept. It doesn't discriminate against any one industry.

You would have ban second hand sales period to fix this "problem".
 
This describes second hand sales as a concept. It doesn't discriminate against any one industry.

You would have ban second hand sales period to fix this "problem".

Not really. Most other products have incentives to buy new already, and no one whines about that. Cars, home appliances, electronics, homes, clothes, accessories, the list goes on and on. Games are just catching up.
 
Not really. Most other products have incentives to buy new already, and no one whines about that. Cars, home appliances, electronics, homes, clothes, accessories, the list goes on and on. Games are just catching up.

Really? What is the incentive to buy new speakers versus used? Amplifier? MP3 player?

Stop making excuses for corporate greed.
 
Not really. Most other products have incentives to buy new already, and no one whines about that. Cars, home appliances, electronics, homes, clothes, accessories, the list goes on and on. Games are just catching up.

What incentive did I have to buy a used monitor versus new? I just got 3 used monitors off ebay.

What incentive do I have to get appliances new?

What incentives do I have to get cars new?

The answer is that the new version would be in better working order then the used. And yes, cds and dvds can get scratched, you obviously have never owned one. I've bought used games that didn't work.

Most people say to buy used cars anyway.

I hate to tell ya, but most homes are also sold used.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
eh, look.
there is nothing new here, it is all pretty much the same thing steam does. most people here would say they love steam and all the massive sales they are able to have. steam would not be able to do any of that if games could be transferred between people.

Hate the high prices? wait for a sale.

The whole thing I see in this used game debate is that you don't want to wait a few months. Well, play something else until the price is right.

Given a choice between draconian DRM or "fixing" the used game market, I'm all for the latter.
 
Gamestop and its ilk are worthless middlemen, siphoning money from the people who did the backbreaking work of making the game and/or getting the game to market.

There's no way to prove that a pirate would or wouldn't have paid for a game.
People buying from Gamestop--yes, Gamestop, the worthless middleman who creates nothing--prove that they are willing to pay for a game, and that money is diverted from devs and publishers to a company which exists only to keep itself running.
 
Many posters here need to have a better understanding of economics and business law prior to posting irrational and illogical arguments.

...

2. Piracy is stealing, and thusly illegal. We're not talking about backups, unless it later conforms to #1. Pircacy is a criminal law case; resales fall under civil codes.

...

Uh yeah, you better go have a re-read of your business law texts because last time I checked piracy does not constitute theft in a legal sense.
 
Gamestop and its ilk are worthless middlemen, siphoning money from the people who did the backbreaking work of making the game and/or getting the game to market.

There's no way to prove that a pirate would or wouldn't have paid for a game.
People buying from Gamestop--yes, Gamestop, the worthless middleman who creates nothing--prove that they are willing to pay for a game, and that money is diverted from devs and publishers to a company which exists only to keep itself running.

Proves that people aren't willing to pay full price you mean.
 
Nobody's getting cheated, not the developer, publisher or anyone else down to the guy who watched the box get shrink wrapped. They got more money than the game was worth at the outset.

Why complain about it anyway. If you want the online content and you're not the original owner then just re-register the game and pay 5 or 10 bucks for a membership that gets you the DLC and such.

Their attitude could be overlooking a possible revenue stream from that "dirty" old secondary market.

:D
 
this notion of "worth". something is "worth" whatever someone will pay for it.
if a game is overpriced at launch then the market will punish the game companies with low sales
-> until the price drops and more people purchase it.

if you have issues with how much a game costs then play something else until the price
drops to what you consider to be a value.
 
this notion of "worth". something is "worth" whatever someone will pay for it.
if a game is overpriced at launch then the market will punish the game companies with low sales
-> until the price drops and more people purchase it.

if you have issues with how much a game costs then play something else until the price
drops to what you consider to be a value.

Or wait until the game is recycled into the used market by somebody else.
 
if you have issues with how much a game costs then play something else until the price
drops to what you consider to be a value.

Pretty sure that's exactly what people buying used are doing, they just don't have to wait as long. This point that you've made also handily demonstrates very well that games *do* lose value over time. In-fact, games lose value over time in a way that NO physical good does; If you buy a car and keep it in perfect condition it can be worth a LOT more than other similar used cars. How about a game? Is the fact that my Quake 1 box and CD are in perfect condition going to help me get more money for it? Probably not! I'd like to see Id software try to sell Quake 1 for $50 and see what people have to say about the "fact" that "Games don't lose value".
 
eh, look.
there is nothing new here, it is all pretty much the same thing steam does. most people here would say they love steam and all the massive sales they are able to have. steam would not be able to do any of that if games could be transferred between people.

Given a choice between draconian DRM or "fixing" the used game market, I'm all for the latter.

The used market doesn't need to be fixed it works just like the used market for everything else: books, electronics, DVDs etc... There is no logical difference. Game corporation are trying to create a technical exploit to steal our right of resale. Consumers should not support this. Gullible corporate patsies apparently do.

You don't need Steam of have good deals. Sales also happen on physical media. You can buy bargain games and still have the ability to loan them, sell them, trade them.

I picked up KOTOR for under $20 Physical copy. I picked up Planescape Torment for under $3 net ( it was $20 with a $20 MIR).

We need resale rights for games more than most products because we already can't return products because of dissatisfaction, all we can do is sell it to get some return for a bad purchase. Now they want to take that from us as well.
 
You're buying a non-trasferable license to use the game. You don't own it.

That said, a better example from another forum was something along the lines of selling a used book, but some pages are ripped out and missing. You are selling something that isn't whole and will never be again.

Uh no. You aren't buying a license, its a finished product. You can use lawyer speak all you want, your argument is still shit, and video games are still consumer goods.
 
Next thing you know, RIAA and MPAA will be complaining that people selling used CDs and DVDs are depriving them of sales. :rolleyes:
 
Penny arcade has an editorial by Tycho where he addresses THQ stance on used games and compares buying used games to piracy

http://www.penny-arcade.com/

The problem with that is that only one person has access to the content at any given time. Once the game is sold, the original owner relinquishes ownership, so how is this piracy? They're not giving out free stuff.
 
I don't know why this has generated so much discussion. Has everyone forgotten it's THQ we're talking about? I mean, they make WWE games. I'm sure all 50 of their loyal game buyers are just fine with THQ's position. In other news, gamers exclaim: They make wrestling games?

Company of Heroes was amazing.
 
The game gets scratches over time, even if you are really careful. The case, manual, etc all get worn out. If it gets too many scratches, you won't be able to use it anymore. And it depreciates over time.

How is this different from any other product? A well-cared for piece of solid-state electronics can last forever in the same way, but that doesn't mean you don't get to own it.


Again, you can fool yourself if you want, but there is no honest comparison between a used game and most other used products, because unlike most other used products, the game disc simply works unless it's been handled by a 2-year-old.

Also - I am not debating the legality of anything. I am saying that when you buy used games, the developer sees no profit, and because there used to be almost no advantage to buying a game new, developers were realizing no profits and no sales where they should have been.

A used game is trivially easy to sell, ship, and acquire, and until recently retained its full value when kept in adult hands, making it so lucrative that it made purchase of a new game unnecessary in many cases.

I support developers whose games I appreciate. If you don't, fine, but let's not pretend that a game disc is a car or a video card or a sofa.
 
eh, you guys love to play games. that's a given in these forums. but to develop the games the companies need to have money. The money obviously comes from the consumers. Now given a choice between your gaming dollars going to gamestop or to finance new games where would you rather see it go?

The assumption of "well, they make enough money anyway". Well, they don't aside from a few exceptions. Many of the minor players are getting shut down. Projects are getting canceled. This all impacts you directly when you browse for new games and see mostly expansions or new versions of the same IPs.
 
Again, you can fool yourself if you want, but there is no honest comparison between a used game and most other used products, because unlike most other used products, the game disc simply works unless it's been handled by a 2-year-old.

Ya, the game disc simply works. Hence my brand new games getting like 50 updates within the first 2 weeks of ownership.

Also - I am not debating the legality of anything. I am saying that when you buy used games, the developer sees no profit, and because there used to be almost no advantage to buying a game new, developers were realizing no profits and no sales where they should have been.

And? Maybe the developer should lower their costs to help boost sales, instead of trying to alienate their consumer base.

A used game is trivially easy to sell, ship, and acquire, and until recently retained its full value when kept in adult hands, making it so lucrative that it made purchase of a new game unnecessary in many cases.

Welcome to capitalism.

I support developers whose games I appreciate. If you don't, fine, but let's not pretend that a game disc is a car or a video card or a sofa.

And why not? If a brand new game releases, the 1st owner beats it within the 1st day of ownership (cause all fucking games are like that now), then decides to resell it 2 weeks later. How is that going to be different from selling a brand new car, video card, or sofa 2 weeks later? All of them will be in excellent condition. Just that they'll cost less, as they were previously owned.

The car, video card, or sofa are definitely going to hold higher value over time, than a game. Maybe cause they tend to be quality products that aren't overpriced to begin with.
 
Also - I am not debating the legality of anything. I am saying that when you buy used games, the developer sees no profit, and because there used to be almost no advantage to buying a game new, developers were realizing no profits and no sales where they should have been.
Why 'should they have been' making money on these consumers that clearly are unwilling to pay full price for their product?

And there is an honest comparison with most other 'cultural media' items, like books and DVDs.

eh, you guys love to play games. that's a given in these forums. but to develop the games the companies need to have money. The money obviously comes from the consumers. Now given a choice between your gaming dollars going to gamestop or to finance new games where would you rather see it go?

The assumption of "well, they make enough money anyway". Well, they don't aside from a few exceptions. Many of the minor players are getting shut down. Projects are getting canceled. This all impacts you directly when you browse for new games and see mostly expansions or new versions of the same IPs.
The secondary market drives the primary market. If I can't sell the game I just finished playing for $30 to fund a new game, I'm going to buy many less games. I'd guess that almost everyone that is financially stable and selling their games used is using the proceeds towards new games. Not to mention that used games, if they're any good, can potentially gain them goodwill with someone who will in future be more excited about paying full price on launch day for that developer's games.

It's not taking money from them, it's how the market is supposed to work. If they want to make money from these people, they should make their product more compelling to them, not whine about it.
 
Pretty sure that's exactly what people buying used are doing, they just don't have to wait as long. This point that you've made also handily demonstrates very well that games *do* lose value over time. In-fact, games lose value over time in a way that NO physical good does; If you buy a car and keep it in perfect condition it can be worth a LOT more than other similar used cars. How about a game? Is the fact that my Quake 1 box and CD are in perfect condition going to help me get more money for it? Probably not! I'd like to see Id software try to sell Quake 1 for $50 and see what people have to say about the "fact" that "Games don't lose value".

LOL! n You kids need to stop posting. New cars can lose as much as HALF their value in one year. No games do that.
 
eh, you guys love to play games. that's a given in these forums. but to develop the games the companies need to have money. The money obviously comes from the consumers. Now given a choice between your gaming dollars going to gamestop or to finance new games where would you rather see it go?

All depends on games. Some I'll want to go to developers. Others, Gamestop can have my money. When it comes to THQ, I don't want either developer or Gamestop to have my money.

The assumption of "well, they make enough money anyway". Well, they don't aside from a few exceptions. Many of the minor players are getting shut down. Projects are getting canceled. This all impacts you directly when you browse for new games and see mostly expansions or new versions of the same IPs.

I tried buying games from these minor players. Let them shut down. All they've ever done for me was take my money and give me a total shit project. Maybe when they're out of the game, I'll have less shovelware choices on my plate.
 
LOL! n You kids need to stop posting. New cars can lose as much as HALF their value in one year. No games do that.

WTF new car loses half it's value in a year? I can buy a brand new BMW, crash it into a telephone pole, repair it, and still sell it for over half it's value in 1 year.
 
LOL! n You kids need to stop posting. New cars can lose as much as HALF their value in one year. No games do that.

Splinter Cell Conviction is a reasonably "big name" title that came out in April, MSRP for $60 of course, and can now be purchased for $20 at Best Buy. "No games do that" my ass.
 
Splinter Cell Conviction is a reasonably "big name" title that came out in April, MSRP for $60 of course, and can now be purchased for $20 at Best Buy. "No games do that" my ass.

Alright fine. 'Big name' games that are horribly blotched with bad drm can lose more then half of their value in a few months.

We are also talking $60 versus $20,000.

Make a coherant argument guys.
 
Alright fine. 'Big name' games that are horribly blotched with bad drm can lose more then half of their value in a few months.

We are also talking $60 versus $20,000.

Make a coherant argument guys.

If you have to make random, unjustified exceptions to your argument for it to make any sense at all, it's not a very good one. Games depreciate. A lot. And quickly.
 
If THQ is so confident then they should instead some selling software and instead sell subscriptions. $10 a month, you can play any THQ game for as long as you have an active subscription.
.

But then you're assuming they're going to continue releasing good games in a reasonable time frame that you want to play, which I think is more credit than is due to THQ at this point in time. :cool:
 
Alright fine. 'Big name' games that are horribly blotched with bad drm can lose more then half of their value in a few months.

We are also talking $60 versus $20,000.

Make a coherant argument guys.

Batman: Arkham Asylum. Came out 1 year ago. Half the cost now.
Street Fighter IV. 1 year ago. Half the cost now.
Red Faction: Guerilla. 1 year 1 month ago. 1/3rd to 1/2 the cost.
Borderlands. 10 months ago. 1/2 the cost.

Sorry, but show me a $20000 car that costs only $10000 after 1 year. We're talking excellent/good condition with average mileage (10,000-15000 miles).
 
Again, you can fool yourself if you want, but there is no honest comparison between a used game and most other used products, because unlike most other used products, the game disc simply works unless it's been handled by a 2-year-old.

Also - I am not debating the legality of anything. I am saying that when you buy used games, the developer sees no profit, and because there used to be almost no advantage to buying a game new, developers were realizing no profits and no sales where they should have been.
.

I keep asking, but the people who claim games are special have consistently failed to explain how games are different than Books/DVDs/CDs/Speakers/Wood furniture. All of which function like new a decade from now if handled properly.

Not one is arguing that developers don't see additional profit on used sales. That is only common sense. They don't deserve a cut of resale anymore than the furniture maker does.

The sad thing is that the gullible are starting to buy into the corporate propaganda and have now become unwitting shills for this corporate nonsense.

Right of resale gives you residual value for products. No resale rights, zero residual value. Crappy game: Tough. You can't return it and now you can't sell.

The only theft here is the corporations attempting steal our resale rights, destroy our residual value and leave us with nothing we can do with a poor game.
 
eh, how much does a book cost to write? actual costs? How much does an album cost to make? Probably more than a book costs I would guess. How much do these things cost to market? = the big expense.

now compare that to a video game.

How much does it cost to employee 20 to 50 professionals for 3 to 4 years to develop one game? then how much does it cost to market it? You are already out MILLIONS to HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS.
 
Back
Top