THQ: Pre-Owned Games 'Cheats Developers'

I don't think any dev anymore should be given the day-one trust on a title.

Crysis sure had its issues.

Half-Life 2 had major hitching issues.

Bioshock had FOV issues, even when it was promised such an issue wouldn't happen.

Sorry, don't game enough to know of Unreal or Quake series had issues on day one.

Wait and see what word-of-mouth is. Day-one consumption is a gamble.

And anyone can make a turd. The interest in these games is relatively subjective.

Yup, that is exactly my point, they can pretend their shit doesn't stink all the want but they better accept the fact that there are far more reasons NOT to buy a game at full value than there is to risk a bad purchase. They created the bad situation, so they should STFU and be happy they have any full price purchasers. Glass house, thrown stones, all that good stuff.
 
All of those used items degrade over time and perform less than a new product. That is not true of digital goods (yes, even ones on dvds).

Mostly untrue, depending on the goods. Used books read just as well as the original until they fall apart; re-bought CDs/DVDs will degrade until they're unreadable as well. Much used goods will never wear out, depending on it's nature. (Like a bread slicing guide, cast iron pots and pans, etc.)

Also, before this next point, is made, I am specifically excluding priacy of any sort...but much of what I'll say essentially applies to it as well.

1. If you don't want your game bought and sold, in the EULA, sell the one-time right to use to the end user along with the disk. Make it unplayable (or only partly playable) until properly registered by email (generate a key using the purchaser's ID as a basis for the code), and then tie the registration code (and maybe even the IP) to the specifc user, allowing only that user to re-register if the application gets installed onto another machine. If multiple instances of this specifically registered game run concurrently, then the game provider knows something's up, disables play until the user contacts them, providing proper ID, and changes the code. If it happens again, poof. They're out.

Sure, this is a pain, but more for the company than the LEGITIMATE end user, but it properly assigns the responsibility to ths company.

In the EULA, specify that the media can be resold, but upon doing so, the buyer assumes responsibility for purchasing a new registration code (for less than the new media and code together), under the same conditions.

...and don't hide this in fine print. Just make the conditions of use easier to be legitimate than otherwise.

Sounds kind of like Windows registration, eh? You can't stop pirates completely, but you can make it a real pain to illegitimately use something.

It's about keeping honest people honest, like the lock on your door. If someone DISHONEST actually intentionally WANTS to break into your house, there's not much that can be done until after the fact.

2. Take it a step further, but using the same basic methodology, only allow media to be obtained by digital download.

Basically, the buying and selling of used items is very much a foundation of our economy (see "velocity of money"), even though it doesn't directly contribute to the GDP. However, the money RECEIVED from selling a game does, if it gets spent on new goods or services.

I'm FOR "used anything" for sale, but if the conditions of the sale (for intellectual material) stipulate it is not to be resold, then it's on the manufacturer/seller to take reasonable precautions to make that hard-to-impossible to accomplish. (And the courts have ruled this way a number of times.) Tiny fine print in a EULA doesn't qualify as meeting that requirement.

Ahem...to address piracy specifically...

As far as the RIAA or MPAA go, they've failed to reinvest their dividends in such a way as to keep up with technology, similarly making it tougher to pirate as well as making it easier, faster, and affordable to acquire their products through legitimate means. I'd have more sympathy for them if they didn't try to use "screwing the artists" as a defense, something they've done to the artists first and worst of anyone.

The real embarrassment for them is that, like print publishers, they've had everything in a easily-convertible digital format longer than anyone else, so shame on them for not figuring out a better way to encypt and distribute by now. (Why we're not buying albums in USB flash format by now is beyond me. Even my audio receiver has a USB port.)

(I know; I'm a former songwriter and recording artist, and haven't seen a penny for my published, recorded, and sold material. Most of my friends who are signed make the majority of their money on tour, and, even then, they don't get much of what's made.)
 
No the money isn't lost and no the product isn't stolen. This isn't just a difference of opinion its a fact. There was no physical loss in money only a theoretical one. There was no loss of property.

Someone caught using pirated software is charged with CW infringement not theft, because they didn't steal anything but rather used intellectual property without a license to do so. Calling it stealing is in fact wrong, because if it was stealing someone stealing a 20 dollar game would be charge with the crime of minor theft which they are not.

So what your saying is, if everyone pirated, we'd still have products to consume. That the developer doesn't lose a cent to pirating, its only theoretical, thus not real. Its a moot point, because the economic damage is very real, and we the paying consumer, suffer for it by paying inflated prices, to subsidize the non-paying users.
 
Fair enough THQ. We don't really care about THQ games. People who buy THQ games get the shaft at resale apparently. We feel like this cheats us. I guess we will stop concentrating in buying new games from THQ. We will buy other games that retain resale value.

See what I did there.:D
 
So what your saying is, if everyone pirated, we'd still have products to consume. That the developer doesn't lose a cent to pirating, its only theoretical, thus not real. Its a moot point, because the economic damage is very real, and we the paying consumer, suffer for it by paying inflated prices, to subsidize the non-paying users.

If that is what I was saying I would have said it.

Pirating does have an impact but nobody know what it is and it can't be calculated. If all pirating ended today I doubt we would see huge gains in software sales because the people pirating rarely have the money to buy the actual product. Pirates for the most part aren't a part of the target market because they don't spend money.

Also if Pirating stopped right now who knows what other impacts it would have. For example maybe Linux would start taking off because the pirates all move to that platform, and then puts Microsoft out of business because it starts to lose its huge following. This will also allow other companies to introduce free software OS's like Google without people having a free windows counter part.

Pirating is a part of the business ecosystem removing it will have unknown effects. Anyone who puts an estimated loss on piracy is a fool.
 
I think this is a totally legit stance for the developer.

With a car their is still the service department and a few other ways they generate revenue on their product living in the market.

For software developers you've either paid them or you haven't.


Also to put it into the context of used cars, if you buy a used car and the radio doesn't work, well that's your deal, you bought it used. I don't see any reason why a used game's online code can't be expended on the original purchaser. You buy used you get less than new value for less than new price.
 
I support THQ in this.

I don't mind at all paying $60 for a game... IF IT'S GOOD. I don't buy crap games, or 'oh this might be good' games... I research the hell out of it on gaming sites, I wait a week after it comes out to see the user's judgement (unless it's bioware... or blizzard.. those are auto first day, and they've earned that). When Lamestop asks me "would you like to buy a pre-owned copy? it's $5 cheaper" I tell them to shove that used disc where the sun don't shine. I would much rather the developer get my $10, then gamestop get my $45.
 
If the game was bought new, then the developer was paid. Anything expected after by them is absurd. If they do create a model by which their games are bought used, then they should create a facility to transfer licenses unless specifically noted in the EULA that they won't or don't do that. Otherwise to claim that they are being cheated is ridiculous.
 
actually i'm gona agree with THQ on this one, i mean you could say the exact same thing about pirating a game, i mean from the developers stand point its the exact same thing.
 
Although digital media doesn't degrade in the physical sense, it does depreciate over time just like any other commodity. You don't believe me? Try reselling any of your X-Box games after you already opened them. You are not going to get as much money as brand new no matter how much you cry about how it's digital and it doesn't degrade. Heck, even brand new games on the shelf depreciate over time. I think it is only fair that the customer is allowed the right to resell their games. As has been pointed out, most of the time it is so they can buy new games in the future. We do this with everything else in life, yet when it comes to software, it is considered piracy? Please :rolleyes:

Give customers something of value instead of treating them like criminals and you will get a lot farther in business. Examples are XFX double lifetime warranty as opposed to XFX non-resellable cards, and Steam. I have a ton of games on Steam even though I can't resell them. Why? Because Steam offers other benefits that make me a happy customer.
 
Steam has a great model imo, they have MASSIVE price cuts on old games or the 4pack pre order deals, not to mention the easy access of your whole library and great support
 
the paying consumer, suffer for it by paying inflated prices, to subsidize the non-paying users.

Piracy does harm game developers (but I can't believe you have game developers actually saying used games are the same as piracy, at least when somebody buys used the person they bought it from usually turns right around and buys a new game with the money they got), but game prices are where they are because the publisher believes that's the maximum you'll pay for the game. If piracy was truly the cause of rising game prices then games that are completely unable to be pirated when they come out, like World of Warcraft at launch, would be priced lower than all other games. Was it priced lower? Absolutely not.
 
Ok, I went back to pennyarcade and to shoot down additional BS arguments brought up by any devs they posted. All the sympathy they want is based on superficial arguments. Car and Book argument have been done. Next up, the Movie argument, they say that unlike movies that get a theatrical release, they dont get that, they only get store sales. You what to know what else gets theatrical releases? NOTHING. They just have to admit they are not all these other products they compare themselves with and strive to make their product better.

Now, before I get labeled a bitter old cynic - although I am - let me instead try to come up with a solution: Devs, make and sell the games normal, don't try to remove the consumer's right to resell their property. Instead, give other potential consumers a bigger incentive to purchase the game new. Trinkets inside the box, posters, collector's edition stuff, all good ideas if you have a strong brand and a product worth buying. How about additional perks after the purchase? Original buyers that register are eligible for future perks including but not limited to, beta testing upcoming products, company sponsored tournaments, custom forum badges, etc. Please note: none of these suggestions in anyway affect the game or make the gaming experience less for the second hand purchasers. These are all above any beyond what is expected when you buy the product, and this is why I didn't include things like level-editors, extra weapons, or any other game changers.
 
Steam has a great model imo, they have MASSIVE price cuts on old games or the 4pack pre order deals, not to mention the easy access of your whole library and great support

Yep, I never feel the need to sell a game with the deals I get on Steam.
 
i have just lost all respect for THQ and will probably never buy one of their games again.

sadly, i kinda liked them and have bought quite a few of their games. their stupidity, their loss.
 
You know you can use the same exact argument for piracy, yet people get called out for being "thieves" if that happens.

I think the difference here is that it's physical media that's being sold it's not going to get around that much. The piracy companies are worried about are when someone puts up a cracked game online and 5,000 people download it a day.
 
Dear THQ, your games suck and that's why I buy them used. I don't actually play them, I just buy them used to piss you off.
 
Thank good the auto industry hasn't had this sort of thinking over the years.
 
Dear THQ:

If you wanted me to stop buying your shitty games, all you had to do was tell me. No need to make it a public announcement.

Never again yours,
SamuraiInBlack

P.S. I still haven't played Darkstalkers. Thanks for making this decision easier. Now I won't.
 
Dear THQ:

If you wanted me to stop buying your shitty games, all you had to do was tell me. No need to make it a public announcement.

Never again yours,
SamuraiInBlack

P.S. I still haven't played Darksiders. Thanks for making this decision easier. Now I won't.

Fixed it myself
 
Person 1 buys a game and sells it to person 2... Um, hello THQ, but you DID make money off the sale: when you sold it to Person 1. Person 2 shouldn't be treated any differently than if they paid THQ directly.

Just keep diggin' that hole...
 
This is just mind-bogglingly stupid.

The bottom line, regardless of how you feel about the ethics of it, is that they have just reduced the value of their product by the $20-30 you could get by reselling it for a lot of their customers. Since (I assume) they aren't going to correspondingly decrease their sale prices, they've just hiked the price of their product by 50%. Do they really think they'd get away with that if they just jacked the sticker price?

I (strongly) disagree with their so-called ethical argument, but regardless of that, this is just stupid business. They are alienating their customers with the announcement. They are undermining their secondary market that plays a big part in funding the primary one. It's just plain anti-consumer and there's no two ways about it. If they want to make money on the secondary sales, they should try to compete with the resale market, not whine and complain that they're being screwed after they've already got their money. They could directly compete, buying back games in exchange for credit towards new ones, taking them out of the market entirely. They could do as suggested and sell multiplayer rights separately. They could do a better job of optimizing their pricing so that gamers are more confident about buying new, or that they have new options in the pricerange they are considering (ie. price mediocre titles lower than AAA $100mil titles instead of this retarded flat pricing they are currently using). There are tons of things they could do to compete instead of just whining. Buck up and live in the market you're in instead of trying to mold the market to exclude everyone using it differently.

Nothing good can come of this, but what I hate about these IP arguments is that piracy is such a convenient scapegoat. Any time sales aren't good, piracy is blamed, and they just continue with their anti-consumer bullshit thinking it will somehow help.
 
My reply to this...Welcome to a free enterprise market THQ. If you dont like it, say high to china for me.
 
Maximize revenue at all costs no matter what.

Not at all costs but at most, sure. I'm kind of neutral on this particular subject but we're talking about bottom lines here and when the bottom line is involved people attitudes generally are the same, show me the money or you get no honey. For instance there's particular types of software that are not to be discussed around here, why? Money, plain and simple.

People are just a little hypocritical about the subject of money.
 
Here's my take.

Player A buys game new, buys DLC for game, completes game.
Player A sells game to Player B.
Player B buys DLC for game, completes game.

Hey, look, the publishers have just made money for (literally) nothing, with Player B buying the DLC. According to US law, Player A has every right to sell whatever he owns (It's called "First Sale Doctrine", go look it up), but of course Player A can't sell the DLC he bought for the game (Though, legally speaking, he should be able to).

As for not getting online access if you buy used, that's a load of bullcrap. Let's look at Server load (Not that that's a problem with recent titles disabling "Dedicated servers", but I digress).

Player A plays game. Server load is 1.
Player A sells game to Player B. Server load is 0.
Player B plays game. Server load is 1.

Look, the server load is EXACTLY THE SAME! Player A can't play the game anymore, and can't use Server resources, as he no longer physically has the game. But Player B can use the SAME resources when he plays online.

100 Games sold, 50 games re-sold = 100 players TOTAL at any one time. The bandwidth they're "Losing" was already paid for by the original retail purchaser.

Basically, the publishers are getting greedy, and want a second bite of the apple, despite the fact they are doing absolutely nothing to warrant it.
 
As for not getting online access if you buy used, that's a load of bullcrap. Let's look at Server load (Not that that's a problem with recent titles disabling "Dedicated servers", but I digress).

Player A plays game. Server load is 1.
Player A sells game to Player B. Server load is 0.
Player B plays game. Server load is 1.

Look, the server load is EXACTLY THE SAME! Player A can't play the game anymore, and can't use Server resources, as he no longer physically has the game. But Player B can use the SAME resources when he plays online.

Your example only works if Player A would have continued to play had he not sold the game. I've never sold a game, but how many that do sell it before they're done with it?

Rather, the comparison is something like this:
Player A plays game for 6 months, stops.

vs

Player A plays game for 6 months, sells game.
Player B plays game for 6 months, stops.

The publisher/developer had to support online play for that box for 6 extra months with no additional revenue.
 
With digital distribution on the rise, all they're doing is alienating their customers. First sale doctrine is slowly disappearing with Steam and such anyway.

Just another reminder on why I shouldn't bother with THQ. (The main reminder being their games usually suck)
 
I still don't get all the hate. Their Steam sales have been excellent:

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1035870518&postcount=77

THQ pack is on sale too, damn if I didn't own a majority of those titles already, I'd swoop it up.

$50 for the following:

Company of Heroes
Company of Heroes: Opposing Fronts
Company of Heroes: Tales of Valor
Frontlines: Fuel of war
Full Spectrum Warrior
Juiced 2
Metro 2033
Red Faction
Red Faction Guerilla
Stalker: Shadow of Chernobyl
Saints Row 2
Titan Quest
Titan Quest: Immortal Throne
Warhammer 40000: Dawn of War - Dark Crusade
Warhammer 40000: Dawn of War - Soulstorm
Warhammer 40000: Dawn of War 2
Warhammer 40000: Dawn of War 2 - Chaos Rising

17 games for $50. $3/game.

That includes Metro 2033.

Except for perhaps the Eidos(?) deal that came with Batman for $50, I thought this pack has been the best bargain around on Steam.

Maybe I'm missing some bigger picture here, but these games are being sold as new. They're absolutely good to go for whatever the game has to offer.

At $3/each, who cares to re-sell any of 'em?

(FWIW - I bought the pack, and have still only ever bothered to play STALKER:SoC so far...)
 
I still don't get all the hate. Their Steam sales have been excellent:
I think you do, in a way, sort of get it.

This is exactly the kind of thing they should be doing to compete with the used market, they shouldn't be calling a significant portion of their customers pirates and thieves and acting entitled to a portion of the resale market just because they created the product being resold.

Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think they're mostly talking about console games, where this kind of thing is a lot less common and game pricing is pretty much fixed regardless of the game's quality, popularity or anything else, until it hits the 'platinum sale' bin.
 
Games which have no demo because they know we will see it is crap cheat customers.
 
I haven't purchased a game on launch day or at full price in over 10 years. I like games, I just have a family now and other responsibilities. I buy used and wait for Steam sales. Sorry THQ; double my salary and I'll start buying from you at launch.
 
I purchase most of my games digitally through Steam sales where I can save a buck. That is because I live on Social Security disability payments and thus have a very limited income. If new games were cheaper at first release, then maybe I could afford more, but for now I just fore go the first day excitement and wait on the sale... :D
 
Maybe we should do this with movies too? Cut off the last 30 minutes?
 
I really see no question in law or, truth be told, ethics in this matter. Used game sales are legit, it is not piracy, or anything of the like. Used game sales, fall under the same legal and moral umbrella as used DVD/BRD/CD's. As long as you don't make a copy, resell to your hearts content. The ones skirting the law and morality, imho, are the devs/pubs attempting to get paid twice for the same disc. Has nobody ever heard of the first sale doctrine?

I understand that the devs and pubs want to make more money. If they are afraid of paying for server traffic on used games, allow private, dedicated servers. The RIAA and MPAA take the same stance as THQ on this. I don't see anyone scrambling to give those guys a "transfer fee" or whatever they want to call a second bite of the apple, for their products.
 
I haven't purchased a game on launch day or at full price in over 10 years. I like games, I just have a family now and other responsibilities. I buy used and wait for Steam sales. Sorry THQ; double my salary and I'll start buying from you at launch.

THQ: "May we suggest you become Don-no-longer-in-Kansas?"

I live next door to you. I may pass through occasionally, by the pedal's to the medal when I do! (don't even need to stop for gas... whew!)
 
Do business with us on our terms or we whine like babies.

Sounds like a lot of other people these boards know and love...
 
Back
Top