THQ: Pre-Owned Games 'Cheats Developers'

It has, which is why this is an arguement. You're selling something that you don't own. But in a time when DLC and digital distro is saving companies, and prolonging games, why not sell the code and try to gain a new customer. I don't see how they can whine if they don't even try to make any money off the second buyer by providing a way to go online or get the special character. They act like some money from the used buyer is worse than none.

Selling a license for on line content would make a lot of sense for these companies. They already take measures to prevent illegal distribution of their software. Sell a license to someone who purchased used. They would not have the overhead that was factored into the game price the first time: Packaging, design, marketing, distribution. Their overhead would be to set up a system to generate, issue and charge for a new key. They can already generate keys. I'm sure they already have some sort of on line store.

This of course would require two licenses for games. One for the software and a second for on line content.

They need to figure out how to use the market to their advantage.

I will be more than happy to be a paid consultant. As long as they do not distribute my ideas to a third party. My ideas would not transfer to parent companies or subsidiaries, present or future.
 
I can understand their stance on this issue kind of. A lot of you guys probably buy used games so you are a little partial, but being a PC gamer only I'm probably a little less bias. There is a big difference between buying a used Toyota and a used ps3 game. When you buy a used car companies will still make money off of replacement parts and such. When you buy a used game the only person making money is the game store.. Maybe game stores should start paying a percentage of the profit of the game to the developer.
 
I can understand their stance on this issue kind of. A lot of you guys probably buy used games so you are a little partial, but being a PC gamer only I'm probably a little less bias. There is a big difference between buying a used Toyota and a used ps3 game. When you buy a used car companies will still make money off of replacement parts and such. When you buy a used game the only person making money is the game store.. Maybe game stores should start paying a percentage of the profit of the game to the developer.

A percentage is a bad idea. In your example of Toyota being able to sell replacement parts, the company could just as easily sell DLC or codes to unlock mulitplayer etc.
 
SO...with this logic...WE SHOULD ELIMINATE ALL USED BOOKSTORES, USED CAR SALES, YARD SALES, FOR SALE ADS, etc?

Are you kidding me?!?
 
Lets fuck with libraries while we're at it, since they so obviously cheat writers out of money!

Ok lets be honest, publishers. Used games don't cheat developers, because there are numbers for resales as well (granted maybe not as accurate), and that's what they get paid for, they don't get paid for how many games they sell after the fact unless its specifically written in their contracts, and most "developers" get paid a salary for a particular job. Its the PUBLISHER like THQ who gets money based upon sales that get screwed the most...

and quite frankly I couldn't give less of a shit about them.... this is literally the RIAA bitching about sales hurting artists.
 
There's no money lost. Once it's sold once it isn't their game to sell again. It's the buyers. There can be zero real expectation that a person would buy a new game instead of a used one if it weren't available.

Of course you can. It probably not a 100% expectation, but on average there will be some percent that you can estimate.
 
I feel cheated everytime I buy a $60 game and it's complete garbage.

Why can't I return games for a full refund?
 
SO...with this logic...WE SHOULD ELIMINATE ALL USED BOOKSTORES, USED CAR SALES, YARD SALES, FOR SALE ADS, etc?

Are you kidding me?!?

All of those used items degrade over time and perform less than a new product. That is not true of digital goods (yes, even ones on dvds).
 
If a developer sells 100K copies of a game they have 100K customers. Say 1K of the users sell their copies as a used game the developer still has 100K customers. The developer should support each copy sold no matter who owns it.

What I see is greedy developers that want to sell 100K copies of a game yet support 20K copies after the first six months because the games have limited replay and most people move on to a new game.
 
If they don't get any revenue from used games. then how can they complain about piracy, no difference except the used game is transferred as a gift!
 
i've got a better idea, make games better so that people don't want to sell them?
i mean what if i buy a game, and just decide i don't want it anymore and i GIVE it to my brother in law. now he's screwed out of multiplayer content?

the sale was made, it shouldn't matter who is using the game. as long as it is the original game being given or sold and not some illegal copy, why should the developer get more money out of it?

if i buy video card off craigslist, should nvidia or ati receive more money for an item they already sold?
 
As I understand it, the game plays, you just don't get online content. If its truly crippled and you can't play at all then I'd say yeah.
They're losing a potential customer. Had used game not have been available where they get no revenue, that buyer would have to buy the new game where they would. They're then losing bandwidth to a player who didn't pay them. This doesn't even address the issue of how they're supposed to differentiate between a bootlegger and a second hand purchaser.

Not really, because the person who sold the game used is no longer using any bandwidth from their servers, it has just transferred locations.
 
i've got a better idea, make games better so that people don't want to sell them?
i mean what if i buy a game, and just decide i don't want it anymore and i GIVE it to my brother in law. now he's screwed out of multiplayer content?

the sale was made, it shouldn't matter who is using the game. as long as it is the original game being given or sold and not some illegal copy, why should the developer get more money out of it?

if i buy video card off craigslist, should nvidia or ati receive more money for an item they already sold?

Uncharted 2 is an amazing game. I still sold it. A game being good has little to do with reselling it. If anything, a good single player game has a higher chance of being resold since you'll likely get more for it.
 
Maybe because game devs are too damn stupid to put out a demo for him to try it first, so there is no way he could know if he is going to like the game.....

Hmm, if only there were websites out there that could give you and idea of whether a game is good or bad...
 
If they don't get any revenue from used games. then how can they complain about piracy, no difference except the used game is transferred as a gift!

*face palm*

They complain about them both, arguing that both the pirate and the used purchaser would purchase a new copy if they were unable to pirate or buy used. Logically, we all know that to be total bullshit, but that is what they argue.
 
Maybe because game devs are too damn stupid to put out a demo for him to try it first, so there is no way he could know if he is going to like the game.....

Thanks for backing me up, but I wouldn't feed Obs; he's just trying to incite offtopic discussion.

And besides, it's not like you can really trust 8-10ign, or easily bribed gamespot, or other such sites were they need to give good reviews in order to get in good with devs.

Some games are well worth $60. For example, every Blizzard game ever. But some games you're just not sure about, like Halo ODST. There's no try before you buy, and there's no refunds if the game is not what you expected (like ODST was for many). I'm glad THQ wants to protect their employees jobs, but where's my customer protection from shovel-ware, rushed jobs, and badly coded multiplayer?
 
This is one of those times where everyone is both right and wrong at the same time.

While they don't make the money off resale they may lose money without the ability of resale so in turn they do make theoretical money; the same theoretical money they lose when their games are pirated.

So if they say they don't care about the used game market which gains them theoretical money then by the same reasoning they shouldn't care about pirating because it loses them theoretical money.
 
We aren't buying games, then, we're buying rentals. That's fine with me, if the price is right.

When I buy a game, I BUY that game. It is MINE. I can do what I want with the disc, outside of copying it.

You can't charge me $60 for a rental. I won't pay that much for it. Period.
 
If new games were cheaper, (Seriously $60?!?!) Maybe people wouldnt feel the need to buy used?

Well then what about used console systems? Are used Xboxs going start not having Xbox capability?
Or used comp parts like video cards? Is a used 5770 going to be slower than a new 5770?


.....Buying games new, and taking them back for the next person to by used has been around for a long while. Hell, Amazon almost has used copies of everything.

We've been allowed to buy full featured used copies since before the NES days...why change it now?
...To be assholes I presume?
 
Opps.. Correction:
Are used Xboxs going start not having Xbox Live capability?
 
This is one of those times where everyone is both right and wrong at the same time.

While they don't make the money off resale they may lose money without the ability of resale so in turn they do make theoretical money; the same theoretical money they lose when their games are pirated.

So if they say they don't care about the used game market which gains them theoretical money then by the same reasoning they shouldn't care about pirating because it loses them theoretical money.

Sorry Steve, a pirated game costs the company, not only in lost sales but in the lost customer (pirates will be pirates, unless forced otherwise). The used game market still keeps cash flowing, where as pirating there is no exchange of cash period. Those that buy games, used or new, are still spending something, promoting economic growth, and part of the consumer chain, those pirating are not.

A good example is this: Bob buys Mass Effect 2 (+ retailer, + Developer, - Bob), Bob then sells it to Gamespot (+Bob, -Retailer), Gamespot in turn sells it to John (+Retailer, -John).
Bob then buys Modern Warfare 2, and the cycle repeats, perhaps on day John will buy a new game, but he is still part of the chain.

Bill pirates Mass Effect 2 (+Bill, - to everyone else), no cycle, economic growth is halted, and the industry and paying consumer suffers.
 
So by that logic, if I sell my used car to somebody I cheat the manufacturer of that car. And if I sell my Levi's to a used clothes place and somebody buys them I am cheating Levi's. Our economy has been built upon the basis that you can buy and sell your stuff as you see fit. Video games are no different than any other commodity we buy or sell. If I am done with a product I own and no longer want it, it is perfectly fine for me to sell it.

What the dumb asses haven't figure out is that often game owners sell their old games, in order to buy something new that they may not have been ordinarily been able to afford at the time. This in turn allows more new games to be sold, not less.

But a car and a pair of Levi's are something that will wear down over time and use.

The license to a used copy, well, you can always find copies with fresh data, as it's just data. As long as the data's available, it will never wear out.

The game can be as fresh 20 years later as the day your bought it, with no maintenance required. You can't say that for cars and clothes.


FWIW - As long as everyone is patient enough to wait, a single person could buy a game, then sell it, then that person plays it and sells it... Do this enough times, and everyone could have played the game off of one license.

You can't realistically make that suggestion about a material object that goes wherever the buyer goes.
 
Those Cheating end users! How DARE they try to re-coup some of there small fortune they lost buying all those games by reselling!!

Really? If these types of people put half as much effort into coming up with solutions for something they see as a problem, instead of alienating there customer base, we could cut [H]ardocp's headlines in half!! :rolleyes: :D
 
Sorry Steve, a pirated game costs the company, not only in lost sales but in the lost customer (pirates will be pirates, unless forced otherwise). The used game market still keeps cash flowing, where as pirating there is no exchange of cash period. Those that buy games, used or new, are still spending something, promoting economic growth, and part of the consumer chain, those pirating are not.

A good example is this: Bob buys Mass Effect 2 (+ retailer, + Developer, - Bob), Bob then sells it to Gamespot (+Bob, -Retailer), Gamespot in turn sells it to John (+Retailer, -John).
Bob then buys Modern Warfare 2, and the cycle repeats, perhaps on day John will buy a new game, but he is still part of the chain.

Bill pirates Mass Effect 2 (+Bill, - to everyone else), no cycle, economic growth is halted, and the industry and paying consumer suffers.

But that is under the assumption that each person who pirates a game would have otherwise boughten it if he could download it for free........which isn't the case. Which is why the money lost form pirating is theoretical. So no real actual money is lost from pirating.

you say (pirates will be pirates, unless forced otherwise) but how can you force someone to buy something they don't want to pay for. Stopping a pirate from downloading doesn't turn him into a paying customer, hell he may just go to a best buy and steal the product, which would result in an actual lose of real money.
 
But a car and a pair of Levi's are something that will wear down over time and use.

The license to a used copy, well, you can always find copies with fresh data, as it's just data. As long as the data's available, it will never wear out.

The game can be as fresh 20 years later as the day your bought it, with no maintenance required. You can't say that for cars and clothes.


FWIW - As long as everyone is patient enough to wait, a single person could buy a game, then sell it, then that person plays it and sells it... Do this enough times, and everyone could have played the game off of one license.

You can't realistically make that suggestion about a material object that goes wherever the buyer goes.

And yet by limiting the resale of games, your alienating a market segment, and risk increasing the number of pirates, adversely effecting overall sales. No one is going to wait that long to play a game, and the added multiplayer features actively encourage people to buy their own copy. Your argument holds only limited merit as it is to focused on one point (wear and tear) and not the overall market image and penetration. When I sell my copy of dragon age, it does not go with all my DLC, the next user will have to purchase that if they want it.

These people focus on a minor to none issues in the industry, at the expense of their ever dwindling public image.
 
i don't know a 1980's gamer that never bought a used game. 20 years later we buy both new and used and were not the millionaires. try selling the games at 20$ and i'll stop buying used bimbos.
 
THQ,

I see your point, and while it goes against pretty much every consumer protection law and rights, I will be happy to oblige you. I promise not to sell any of your products to your non-customers. Myself, a regular consumer of newly released 60 dollar games, I expected to be able to sell these as used products to help fund my newer purchases of 60 dollar games. Instead, I will stop purchasing your 60 dollar games and wait until they hit the sub 20 dollar shelf. At that point, I will not care about recouping a portion of my purchase price.

The analogy that used games are just as good as new games is pure bullshit. Everything depreciates. The developers (as seen writing on penny arcade) like to state that digital code does not depreciate like wear on a vehicle or a book, yet they neglect to point out that the media they deal in actually depreciates much faster, both in dollar value and in worth. A game made a few years ago doesn't have the newest technology, best physics, the best graphics, or the fun "new factor". Both the book and the car hold value far longer than a video game. And since you love to compare yourselves to physical products so much, lets not forget that re-production of your product does not cost nearly as much as a book or a car. You cannot have your cake and eat it too.

Where is my lemon law? Anything else I buy, I can return because it sucks. But the second I buy a shitty (or released too early) game, I am stuck with it with little to no recourse. When thinking about games in your ideal view, you seem to be making the assumption that every game released is an A+ title. Unfortunately, this is not the case, and fewer than 10 percent of the games I have purchased in the last 5 years have been worth the sticker price.

Lumping us paying customers that legally re-sell goods we have purchased with pirates is pretty much rewarding our loyalty with a big fuck you.

Yours Truly,
-Former Day-One Consumer
 
But that is under the assumption that each person who pirates a game would have otherwise boughten it if he could download it for free........which isn't the case. Which is why the money lost form pirating is theoretical. So no real actual money is lost from pirating.

you say (pirates will be pirates, unless forced otherwise) but how can you force someone to buy something they don't want to pay for. Stopping a pirate from downloading doesn't turn him into a paying customer, hell he may just go to a best buy and steal the product, which would result in an actual lose of real money.

Actually yes, money is lost from pirating. It isn't theoretical, time and money was put into the product for final sale, each time its pirated it is stolen (whether physical property is taken or not). The only theoretical part is if the person would have bought the item if he couldn't pirate it, which holds true for the person stealing an item directly from a store as well. We like to sugar coat piracy because we see some... 'noble rebellion' in it as consumers, but it is stealing nonetheless.

Whats more, money is removed from the system when an item is pirated, which hurts the economy as a whole, top to bottom.

There is better ways to protest corporate excess, just like there is better ways for these corporations to combat piracy.
 
Yours Truly,
-Former Day-One Consumer

I don't think any dev anymore should be given the day-one trust on a title.

Crysis sure had its issues.

Half-Life 2 had major hitching issues.

Bioshock had FOV issues, even when it was promised such an issue wouldn't happen.

Sorry, don't game enough to know of Unreal or Quake series had issues on day one.

Wait and see what word-of-mouth is. Day-one consumption is a gamble.

And anyone can make a turd. The interest in these games is relatively subjective.
 
Sorry Steve, a pirated game costs the company, not only in lost sales but in the lost customer (pirates will be pirates, unless forced otherwise). The used game market still keeps cash flowing, where as pirating there is no exchange of cash period. Those that buy games, used or new, are still spending something, promoting economic growth, and part of the consumer chain, those pirating are not.

THQ is lumping used game buyers in the same category as pirates. Realistically speaking you cannot tabulate, calculate, or estimate "potential" lost sales from either one. Potential lost sales aren't real lost sales. Sure, some people might not buy a new game if they can get it used or pirated but there's no reliable way to figure out what that mysterious magic number may or may not have ever been or could be. It's another scape goat to blame their poor margins on besides their own failures.
 
Actually yes, money is lost from pirating. It isn't theoretical, time and money was put into the product for final sale, each time its pirated it is stolen (whether physical property is taken or not).

Absolutely 110% wrong! For the billionth time, piracy /= theft. It's called copyright infringement for a reason.
 
Actually yes, money is lost from pirating. It isn't theoretical, time and money was put into the product for final sale, each time its pirated it is stolen (whether physical property is taken or not). The only theoretical part is if the person would have bought the item if he couldn't pirate it, which holds true for the person stealing an item directly from a store as well. We like to sugar coat piracy because we see some... 'noble rebellion' in it as consumers, but it is stealing nonetheless.

Whats more, money is removed from the system when an item is pirated, which hurts the economy as a whole, top to bottom.

There is better ways to protest corporate excess, just like there is better ways for these corporations to combat piracy.

No the money isn't lost and no the product isn't stolen. This isn't just a difference of opinion its a fact. There was no physical loss in money only a theoretical one. There was no loss of property.

Someone caught using pirated software is charged with CW infringement not theft, because they didn't steal anything but rather used intellectual property without a license to do so. Calling it stealing is in fact wrong, because if it was stealing someone stealing a 20 dollar game would be charge with the crime of minor theft which they are not.
 
Absolutely 110% wrong! For the billionth time, piracy /= theft. It's called copyright infringement for a reason.

Money is still lost regardless, a crime was still committed, and the game is still being used without the person paying for it. We are sitting in an unfortunate time in our legal system, which is still operating in the 1980's for the most part. When your product is digital code, that happens to be on a disc, and that digital code is appropriated, and used without paying for, it is akin to theft, like it or not.
 
Wow, I cannot imagine how some of you live in such a world with crime surrounding you daily....

When you buy used it is not the same as buying new. People are trying to argue that games never degrade but what about scratched disks or packaging? I don't know about most people but when I buy games I like the extras, like manuals, maps and trinkets. To give the best example is the old Lunar Silver Star Edition game I got years ago. You could get it used for, lets say, $40 but new was $50 which included what they called an Omake box . Used let you play the game and enjoy it like normal, but new gave you collectible stuff and extras. To cut it short, if you want people to buy new give them something extra like DLC or whatnot but don't gimp the game of the reason people buy them in the first place.
 
Back
Top