THQ: Pre-Owned Games 'Cheats Developers'

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
And the award for back-assward thinking goes to THQ for its position on used games. Obviously we support developers and want them to be paid but just because you are buying a used game to save a little money doesn't mean you will never be a "real" customer in the future. :rolleyes:

"I don't think we really care whether used game buyers are upset because new game buyers get everything. So if used game buyers are upset they don't get the online feature set I don't really have much sympathy for them." "That's a little blunt but we hope it doesn't disappoint people. We hope people understand that when the game's bought used we get cheated," he continued.
 
Last edited:
Toyota gets cheated every time someone sells a used car of theirs as well; they actually tout it as a feature that their products are so good they hold value.

If your games are so *(#@ that people immediately turn around and sell them for pennies on the dollar, it isn't the developer being cheated of revenue from an additional customer; it is the first customer being cheated by a developer pushing out shoddy content.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Maximize revenue at all costs no matter what.

THQ would like to be paid for your comment on their games. Please refrain from making "free" comments about them in the future.

On the other hand, the fact that you were the second post in this thread classifies your post as "secondary" or "used" so the company doesn't give a crap what you think.

:D
 
Its because they get no revenue on the resale. Its kind of like a non-transferrable warranty on a lot of cars you could say. You don't get the "feature" because you bought it used.
 
There's a lengthy discussion of this by the guys at Penny Arcade - there's a particular hash-tag being used that Gabe set up, but I can't use my Twitter client here at work.

My personal take is that, just as there's no harm done to Ford, or Ikea, or Shure, or Sam's Publishing when you buy a used product of theirs, you do in fact know that it's a used product and there could be some shortcomings - mileage, tear, wear, durability, whatever.

I find it fair that people who buy new games to have some extra incentive - in the way there are VIP map packs in Bad Company 2, for example, for those that bought the game new. Maybe multiplayer codes that can only be activated once by the original purchaser... I dunno, something, some additional perk.
 
Toyota gets cheated every time someone sells a used car of theirs as well; they actually tout it as a feature that their products are so good they hold value.

Physical property has a number of aspects that make new better than old. Warrantys, less wear & tear, longer lifespan, guaranteed to not have any hidden damage that the seller didn't tell you about, more modern appearance, more features than an older model, whatever.

Traditionally, software hasn't had that. A used copy is the same as a new copy and there's no point in ever buying new unless you're just OCD and can't stand owning something that was used.

I think it's fair to try and give some incentive to buying new software over old, just like in every other industry in the world.
 
Toyota gets cheated every time someone sells a used car of theirs as well; they actually tout it as a feature that their products are so good they hold value.

If your games are so *(#@ that people immediately turn around and sell them for pennies on the dollar, it isn't the developer being cheated of revenue from an additional customer; it is the first customer being cheated by a developer pushing out shoddy content.

I wish I could reach through my screen and choke every mother fucker to death who uses car analogies.
 
To put things in perspective here:

How many games that feature online play let a 2nd account be made with the same code? None that I am aware of.

It isn't just THQ.. it is pretty much any developer that has their own servers for online play.

True the guy came across as a complete jerk.. but besides that, I can see where he is coming from.

As for buying 2nd hand games that feature online play.. if you want the online play protion of the game and you are buying it second hand, you better make sure that you are given the online account information so you can logon and change it.
 
Pretty lame for the developer in my opinion.

He says that they do not care, however, they obviously do care. Otherwise they would not put in the measure to prevent the purchaser of a used game to have access the online features.

I think this bites them in two ways:

1) Those who buy new and sell typically do so to fund new game purchases. I'm sure they will continue to do so, however, this will reduce the "buy new" crowd's resources.

2) For the casual gamer who buys used, they probably would never buy new anyway. This is unless they fall in love with a title. Now they will not have the opportunity to become addicted to the online game play and therefore not become invested in the game and the franchise. In my opinion, it reduces the likelyhood that "used buyers" become "new buyers" .
 
Its because they get no revenue on the resale. Its kind of like a non-transferrable warranty on a lot of cars you could say. You don't get the "feature" because you bought it used.

That's not an appropriate analogy because a warranty isn't a feature. It's like buying a used car and having the manufacturer remotely disable the right front wheel as soon as the title is signed over.

THQ has a seriously fucked up worldview if they think they're being "cheated" buy a used game sale. They've already made their money on it. If the person buying a game wanted it new, they would have bought a new one. They aren't losing a dime, only fake "potential profit" which is worth about as much as the hair on my ass.
 
I'm sure used console game sales put PC piracy to fucking shame on the amount of money lost to the developer.
 
Way to alienate potential buyers of your upcoming titles THQ!
 
I think consumers do have the right to feel slighted. Companies are adopting this all or nothing stance. Buy it used, lose the ability to play online, buy it new, welcome to the online community. Why is there no middle ground? No offer to sell a mulitplayer code? No offer to sell the codes to run your normal edition into a collectors edition? I'm a huge of customer service, if the company treats me right I am willing to pay more and develop a brand loyalty. Providing a way to bring used game buyers into the community is a way to help earn new customers. Companies aren't adapting, this debate would still be raging over the people who buy at full price and the people who only ever buy a game on a Steam sale. You can't keep shunning potential customers, and then claim they are hurting your business because they won't pay full price for your product. Some times your product isn't worth full price, wouldn't you rather have some sort of sale, even if it is just DLC? Maybe the first buyer didn't care about the DLC, but the used buyer does because he decided he liked the game more than he thought he would.
 
I wish I could reach through my screen and choke every mother fucker to death who uses car analogies.

SWM, you strike me as a very angry person. Or does it just come across that way because every other post of yours has "fuck" in it in one form or the other? :p
 
I'm sure used console game sales put PC piracy to fucking shame on the amount of money lost to the developer.

There's no money lost. Once it's sold once it isn't their game to sell again. It's the buyers. There can be zero real expectation that a person would buy a new game instead of a used one if it weren't available.
 
I have to say I agree with the THQ statement that the pre-owned games somewhat cheat dev's. Let the player have some single player goodness (think demo) from a used game, but make them pay to get online gaming.

On the other hand I have bought games in the past which really sucked or were incompatible to my hardware, and selling it would at least let me recoup a bit of the money spent. But to be fair, this hasn't happened in a long time (since the late 90's), and even then only 2 games fit this scenario.
 
That's not an appropriate analogy because a warranty isn't a feature. It's like buying a used car and having the manufacturer remotely disable the right front wheel as soon as the title is signed over.

THQ has a seriously fucked up worldview if they think they're being "cheated" buy a used game sale. They've already made their money on it. If the person buying a game wanted it new, they would have bought a new one. They aren't losing a dime, only fake "potential profit" which is worth about as much as the hair on my ass.

As I understand it, the game plays, you just don't get online content. If its truly crippled and you can't play at all then I'd say yeah.
They're losing a potential customer. Had used game not have been available where they get no revenue, that buyer would have to buy the new game where they would. They're then losing bandwidth to a player who didn't pay them. This doesn't even address the issue of how they're supposed to differentiate between a bootlegger and a second hand purchaser.
 
There's no money lost. Once it's sold once it isn't their game to sell again. It's the buyers. There can be zero real expectation that a person would buy a new game instead of a used one if it weren't available.

You know you can use the same exact argument for piracy, yet people get called out for being "thieves" if that happens.
 
Overpriced new games cheat customers.

Guess we're even.

That is what I was thinking! Most people prefer new over used if the price is what they feel is a good value.

oh and: Craigslist, eBay, yard sale, etc.. those are cheaters helping people cheat others then?
 
There's no money lost. Once it's sold once it isn't their game to sell again. It's the buyers. There can be zero real expectation that a person would buy a new game instead of a used one if it weren't available.

That would depend on the terms of the license. Seems to me that software has long ago moved away from "owning as property" to a "licensed to use" paradigm for the end user.
 
One word comes to mind. Idiot. If you sympathize with his view. Idiots.

If you sell the game to customer A, and provide content to customer A, then customer A sells game to customer B, customer A ceases to use the game and Customer B begins to. the burden is no greater on any developer, unless of course, customer A continues to use the game after selling it to customer B.
 
There's no money lost. Once it's sold once it isn't their game to sell again. It's the buyers. There can be zero real expectation that a person would buy a new game instead of a used one if it weren't available.

Oh please. Let's look at the numbers. Most used game buyers just grab the used crap at GameStop or whatever. That shit is only $5-10 off, typically. If that weren't available, I think it's a pretty safe bet that they'd just pony over the extra $5.

The argument that "Oh it doesn't cost sales because used game buyers would never fork over a few extra bucks, they'd just stop gaming entirely!" is beyond ridiculous.
 
Anyone remember when some analyst (or Kotick? I can't remember) said multiplayer gaming is hurting the industry overall because people aren't buying games? Well, single player campaigns can only last so long - maybe 10 hours for a really good one. Multiplayer is what keeps the player owning the game and not selling it to GameStop or whoever. That's hurting the industry, eh?
 
One word comes to mind. Idiot. If you sympathize with his view. Idiots.

If you sell the game to customer A, and provide content to customer A, then customer A sells game to customer B, customer A ceases to use the game and Customer B begins to. the burden is no greater on any developer, unless of course, customer A continues to use the game after selling it to customer B.

How do you know that it wasn't copied? How do you know customer A removed it from their machine?
 
That is what I was thinking! Most people prefer new over used if the price is what they feel is a good value.

oh and: Craigslist, eBay, yard sale, etc.. those are cheaters helping people cheat others then?

There's a big difference - as others have pointed out - between physical objects and licences to consume digital content. You can't sell a cinema ticket back to the cinema after you're done watching a film, just as you can't sell a digital download back to iTunes once you're bored of a song.

Games are not about the plastic box and a DVD. They are licences to consume digital content. It will all go account based with digital downloads eventually. Steam is way ahead on this.
 
One word comes to mind. Idiot. If you sympathize with his view. Idiots.

If you sell the game to customer A, and provide content to customer A, then customer A sells game to customer B, customer A ceases to use the game and Customer B begins to. the burden is no greater on any developer, unless of course, customer A continues to use the game after selling it to customer B.

In fact, the real key here, unlike THQ's whining, is to make the game compelling enough, and release enough added content, to prevent customer A from selling their copy, thus forcing customer B to by and additional copy to enjoy the game. Thus resulting in more legitimate copies of the game in circulation.
 
I can understand THQ not caring about the secondary market. They don't profit form them, so they aren't their customers.

However, the guy who initially buys the game IS a thq customer. If they perceive part of the value of games as the ability to resell them at a later date, then THQ games have become less valuable to them.

Additionally, there are only so many gaming dollars to go around. Decrease your secondary market, and you decrease your brand recognition. Decrease your brand recognition, and all of the sudden your franchise might not be something people give a crap about having as soon as it is released.

I feel for those trying to make a buck in the industry. They have tried front loading by adding bonus material for pre-orders. Except that can have a chilling effect on anyone who doesn't pre-order. The backlash to that is some people feel like they missed the boat, and might as well not bother. They try DLC, and it is either very ignorable, or you wind up with something that is compelling but expensive. The backlash to that is "I'll just wait for the GOTY edition". You can have sales, but even that isn't without a downside. Unless your sale is very cheap, more sales means a more glutted market.

The reality is that there are more good-enough titles than most purchasers have a time or money budget for. On top of that the industry creates a subjective experience that only succeeds if it resonates with the audience. You can't take the risk out of that. If you want to maximize profits, you make less games and you make them better. But that will increase the risk of being screwed if you misjudged your audience.
 
How do you know that it wasn't copied? How do you know customer A removed it from their machine?

Now your being pedantic, this is an illegal action and outside the regular realm and scope of THQ's arguments. We are mearly addressing the idea of used games, not the issue of piracy.
 
So by that logic, if I sell my used car to somebody I cheat the manufacturer of that car. And if I sell my Levi's to a used clothes place and somebody buys them I am cheating Levi's. Our economy has been built upon the basis that you can buy and sell your stuff as you see fit. Video games are no different than any other commodity we buy or sell. If I am done with a product I own and no longer want it, it is perfectly fine for me to sell it.

What the dumb asses haven't figure out is that often game owners sell their old games, in order to buy something new that they may not have been ordinarily been able to afford at the time. This in turn allows more new games to be sold, not less.
 
So by that logic, if I sell my used car to somebody I cheat the manufacturer of that car. And if I sell my Levi's to a used clothes place and somebody buys them I am cheating Levi's. Our economy has been built upon the basis that you can buy and sell your stuff as you see fit. Video games are no different than any other commodity we buy or sell. If I am done with a product I own and no longer want it, it is perfectly fine for me to sell it.

What the dumb asses haven't figure out is that often game owners sell their old games, in order to buy something new that they may not have been ordinarily been able to afford at the time. This in turn allows more new games to be sold, not less.

Absolutely.
 
That would depend on the terms of the license. Seems to me that software has long ago moved away from "owning as property" to a "licensed to use" paradigm for the end user.

It has, which is why this is an arguement. You're selling something that you don't own. But in a time when DLC and digital distro is saving companies, and prolonging games, why not sell the code and try to gain a new customer. I don't see how they can whine if they don't even try to make any money off the second buyer by providing a way to go online or get the special character. They act like some money from the used buyer is worse than none.
 
So by that logic, if I sell my used car to somebody I cheat the manufacturer of that car. And if I sell my Levi's to a used clothes place and somebody buys them I am cheating Levi's. Our economy has been built upon the basis that you can buy and sell your stuff as you see fit. Video games are no different than any other commodity we buy or sell. If I am done with a product I own and no longer want it, it is perfectly fine for me to sell it.

What the dumb asses haven't figure out is that often game owners sell their old games, in order to buy something new that they may not have been ordinarily been able to afford at the time. This in turn allows more new games to be sold, not less.

Absolutely.

You're buying a non-trasferable license to use the game. You don't own it.

That said, a better example from another forum was something along the lines of selling a used book, but some pages are ripped out and missing. You are selling something that isn't whole and will never be again.
 
Okay, so make multiplayer have an unlock code that you can buy, but do the following first:

1. Lower the price of new games by at LEAST $10.

2. Lower the price of used games by more than $10 off new.

The problem is that, currently, no one wants to pay $50 for a used game and then another $10-15 for a multiplayer unlock code when the game brand-new is $60.
 
You're buying a non-trasferable license to use the game. You don't own it.

That said, a better example from another forum was something along the lines of selling a used book, but some pages are ripped out and missing. You are selling something that isn't whole and will never be again.

How is that a better example? Being that you bought the book whole, the pages didn't magically remove themselves, you did by being careless. On the flip side, the developer is pushing to sell you something that is in essence a right to play the game, you owned the book initially, while you never owned the game. I'm surprised people aren't more worried about this from a personal stand point, I assume most people here buy games new and thus think narrowly and say "it doesn't apply to me". Truth is, there is room for massive amounts of abuse as too much control over your right to play is placed in the hands of the developer, so used or not, beware.
 
Unlock code should only be like 5$, but even if it was 10$ and the used game was 50$, making buying the game new the better option, maybe the person didn't know they even wanted to play online till a friend got the game. If they end up forking out what would have been new game pricing, albeit over a longer span of time than one single purchase, they might consider buying new to begin with next time.

As it currently stands, nobody will ever know, since the option isn't provided.
 
Oh please. Let's look at the numbers. Most used game buyers just grab the used crap at GameStop or whatever. That shit is only $5-10 off, typically. If that weren't available, I think it's a pretty safe bet that they'd just pony over the extra $5.

The argument that "Oh it doesn't cost sales because used game buyers would never fork over a few extra bucks, they'd just stop gaming entirely!" is beyond ridiculous.

So GameStop is the problem? Boo hoo. People have bought and sold used games since games existed, too bad for them.
 
How is that a better example? Being that you bought the book whole, the pages didn't magically remove themselves, you did by being careless. On the flip side, the developer is pushing to sell you something that is in essence a right to play the game, you owned the book initially, while you never owned the game. I'm surprised people aren't more worried about this from a personal stand point, I assume most people here buy games new and thus think narrowly and say "it doesn't apply to me". Truth is, there is room for massive amounts of abuse as too much control over your right to play is placed in the hands of the developer, so used or not, beware.

The book example just goes to the fact that the used game isn't whole. The game can't access multiplayer anymore, and the book might not have an ending anymore. It's not perfect, but I think it fits better than the car examples. It's one I read from another forum and it kinda stuck with me.

I'm annoyed that you don't own the game when you get. Shy of giving away a ton of copies for free, or profiting off of more than your copy, I think you should be able to do what you want with it. The fact that the developer has this amount of control, and it only seems to be growing, Ubisoft being a prime example, is scary. It doesn't effect to many people yet, but by the time it does it will be to late to really do much about it.
 
Back
Top