BF3: RAM - 4GB vs. 8GB

McFry

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 25, 2011
Messages
1,715
If anyone recalls playing BF2, you would probably remember that if you had anything less than 2GB of ram, the game would struggle streaming in new map data when you entered new areas. After awhile it would eventually clear itself. It came to the point where often you would just grab a jet or something and do a little overworld "fly through" to make sure the entire contents of the world were fully loaded. Once you bumped up to 4GB you never had this problem, as apparently the entire game world would be loaded at start.

I think I am noticing the same behavior in BF3. I currently have 4GB of ram, and have talked in game with a few people who have 8GB and they say the levels always play seamlessly, there is no harddrive seeking going on half way across the map causing the game to freeze for a second here or there.

Has anyone else noticed similar behavior? If you are on 4GB of ram do you observe lots of hd seeking at times? If you have 8GB of ram does the entire map stretch from end to end without any loading issues at all?
 
I have 4gigs of ram and have had for the last few years. I've NEVER had an issue with any game whatsoever. 4gigs of ram is a huge huge amount of memory for a video game. I know at some point I saw the memory footprint for a ton of games and none of them used much ram. Most of the games used around 900megs of ram loaded up. I think BF3 is under 1gig? Easy to go and look.
 
I doing think I've ever encountered a game that used more than 2 GB of RAM, and even that is rare.
 
Most games don't tend to use more... but having more RAM allows for better alt-tab if you happen to have other applications running while you game. (I find that I can go hat collecting in TF2 while one of my brothers takes a time out to eat supper while playing SupCom:FA) 8G is so silly cheap these days, hard not to do it for just the extra head room.
 
I have 4GB and I did have one instance where the game picture froze for a second. Could be totally unrelated.
 
Turn on task manager and see how much it is using? :eek:
 
BF3 was pretty jumpy on my laptop last night, and I only am running 4GB... I was actually just considering upgrading, I didn't know the thing about BF2, so I may just give it a try...
 
Using Process Explorer to monitor BF3.exe, it never needed more than 1.8GB of total system memory. That's both dedicated and shared resources. Unless you have a shit-ton of open apps in teh background, I can't see only having 4GB hurting you.
 
Just checked task manager while playing, overall system memory usage was something like 3.5GB. Pretty sure this is whats responsible for my version of "stuttering". I'll try to get some more by this weekend and see what happens. No PC ever runs well with 98% of it's memory eaten up.
 
I definitely need more ram for BF3. It consumes 1.6gb of ram and an extra 1.7gb of virtual. It's taking me 3-4 minutes to load up a map but once I'm actually in the game plays great. It's kind of a problem though because the first objective is already taken in rush by the time I'm loaded in. With only 4gb of system memory after exiting BF3 everything in windows takes an ungodly amount of time to become responsive again (about 2 minutes for firefox).

Q6600, 4gb ram, HD6950 2GB. All settings on ultra/high. 30-45 fps avg.

Thinking of turning texture detail down just so it won't take so friggin long to load, even though the card handles it just fine with zero stutter :\

On the plus side BF3 runs MUCH better than BC2 did. I'd get pretty consistent stutters in BC2, none of that in BF3.
 
I thought it was impossible for non-64bit applications to use more than 4 GB...

I had the 4gb patch for it, which I guess can make it use more than 4gb? (just like for my STALKER complete mod where it makes it Large Address Aware or something)

3.5gb memory usage for me in BF3. Out of 6gb.
 
Haven't had an issue yet on 64 people maps. I'm sure it would add FPS, but it runs very well as is.
 
Ok it seems like running the visuals at High settings also addresses this. I havent been freezing at all now.
 
The problem with that is how the game allocates memory based on available usage. With BF2 on a 1GB platform, the engine would prevent itself from using any more than say 600MB or so. As soon as you bumped it up to 2GB all the sudden bf2.exe is using 900MB+.

I remember getting sketchy details with BF2, other than some confirmations that their game will hitch on occasion. It wasnt until I pulled the trigger and upgraded that I could confirm for sure. Guess I'll have to do the same for BF3.

Resource Monitor is your friend.
 
For BF2, I had a single-core processor and 2GB of RAM and the game ran smoothly on max settings. Now I have a quad-core processor and 4GB of RAM and BF3 runs smoothly on max settings. However, YMMV, which is to say, 4GB works, 6GB would be peace of mind and 8GB probably isn't necessary.
 
why even guess at such things, when you could use some sort of hud/osd like rivatuner, evga precision, msi afterburner, etc. that could show any type of cpu/gpu or system memory usage via hotkey any time, instead of tabbing out to task/res/perfmon and possibly skewing your results. how do you guys even properly tune your settings without this kind of informations, fps alone is a poor measurement unless you know what exactly it is limiting performance. this way you can keep track of limits in the proper scenarios, and tweak your settings without leaving the game.

this discussion is kind of moot though unless we know for sure bf3 is a large-address aware app, even in x64 it will not address over 2gb memory unless they have configured it this way. x86 is not actually limited to 2gb contrary to popular belief, this is purely a microsoft limitation that many devs fail at keeping in check, since graphics and assets got more complex even way before they started programming for x64 environments.

you can mod boot options and app headers in both x86/64 to make use of more, this is a good way to fix app crashes in those memory hungry games that like to swap and crash alot when they get close to the limit, supcom being the best example I know of. limit for 32-bit is 4gb, while x64 is of course way more, but again apps that want to use this much memory need to enable it.

wiki has more info:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X86-64

also a nice universal app to patch headers for both x86/64:
http://www.techpowerup.com/forums/showthread.php?t=112556

I doubt bf3 is limited this way, but I really would not be at all surprised if it was. the hardocp benches in sli show that it's most likely not, but any of you still on x86 could probably make good use of the above, if you happen to be running 4gb on 32-bit (yes this is possible, I did it for years before switching to win7).
 
I have 4GB of ram and am getting 55-60FPS with my rig on High everything, Ultra textures, 16xAF, no MSAA, AA PP High, HBAO on, motion blur on @1920x1200.

Had to overclock my 5850 to 820/1200 but it works like a charm. 11.10v3 drivers and 4GB of ram.

Did I mention 4GB of RAM? :D
 
I have 12 GB of RAM. My system shows about 6GB used when I am playing BF3.
 
Proof? I have 8GB and it doesn't use even 3gb
The proof would be in my widget that monitors thread use/RAM use. Not sure what you want me to do, screenshot it while I play? I promise I am not lying. I am not sure if BF3 itself uses that entire amount. Part of it is certainly Windows precaching. Still, I would definitely recommend at least 6GB for a system these days. With 8GB you are fine so not sure why you are worrying one way or another :)
 
BF2 was the game that made me upgrade to 2GB, and BF3 was the game that made me upgrade to 8GB :p.

The most i've seen it using is around 1.7GB of ram. With everything else running in the background, my system topped out at 4.5GB used, the highest i've seen it. So while it doesn't need it... it could help if you like to leave your shit running in the background.
 
I definitely need more ram for BF3. It consumes 1.6gb of ram and an extra 1.7gb of virtual. It's taking me 3-4 minutes to load up a map but once I'm actually in the game plays great. It's kind of a problem though because the first objective is already taken in rush by the time I'm loaded in. With only 4gb of system memory after exiting BF3 everything in windows takes an ungodly amount of time to become responsive again (about 2 minutes for firefox).

Q6600, 4gb ram, HD6950 2GB. All settings on ultra/high. 30-45 fps avg.

Thinking of turning texture detail down just so it won't take so friggin long to load, even though the card handles it just fine with zero stutter :\

On the plus side BF3 runs MUCH better than BC2 did. I'd get pretty consistent stutters in BC2, none of that in BF3.

Thats because bc2 is cpu heavy, and bf3 is all vid card.
 
Doesn't a console have like 512mb or ram? I'm running all medium and i still get about 1.5-1.7gb . Not sure how they optimized ram usage on consoles to well but kudos to them.
 
on my g13 I show 58% ram usage = 4.64gb used (8gb installed). Thats with origin, steam, asrock system utility, MSE, some other small random stuff and msi afterburner running
 
I have 8GB and tabbed out and saw that I was using 48% of my ram. I had firefox and maybe one other app running. I don't think 8GB would hurt, and it's dirt cheap now anyways for another 4GB.
 
I have 8gb of ram and im currently using an AMD HD 4800 running on high setting and the game runs has smooth has silk in multi. and single player. and yes the levels strecth on for long distances with no loading problems.
 
I have 8GB and tabbed out and saw that I was using 48% of my ram. I had firefox and maybe one other app running. I don't think 8GB would hurt, and it's dirt cheap now anyways for another 4GB.

Not if you're running 4GB DDR2 (Q6600 CPU) in 4X1GB slots :D

It would actually cost me like $84 to pick up 4X2GB of DDR2. Not worth it it. DDR3 on the other hand is like $35 for 8GB :eek:
 
tried with 8gb vs 4gb. load times were quicker with 8gb, less hard disk thrashing. took about 5-10 secs off load times.. me likes 8gb
 
It probably won't use even 2GB, but honestly RAM is so freaking cheap nowadays, there's no reason not to spring for 8GB.
 
A dev said on twitter earlier that they weren't even shipping 64-bit binaries. If that's true, this whole thread is sort of a moot point, the "only" benefit you'd see from more than ~4GB memory is from disk cache.
 
Ordered a Vertex3 SSD today to help with load times, and I also ordered 4GB more RAM. Not sure if the extra RAM will actually help, but it was cheap enough that it's worth a shot.
 
Back
Top