BenQ G2400W

I didn't know 5 year olds visited this forum. Nice to know...

yeah that was a really weird post. Bragging on the internet about how much money you make is kind of pathetic...takes all kinds to fill the freeway though I guess...
 
You idiot, why dont you try to read the first post, when someone puts you down by telling you you work at mcdonolds, what are you going to say to them? im not going to respond to LAMERS like yourself, like i said i dont need to prove anything to you or anyone else.
 
Hello all,

I have been looking for a Full HD monitor for my Xbox 360 Elite i would be connecting it through HDMI

1. Will the 1:1 Pixel Mapping, Aspect Ratio Scaling etc work over HDMI with 360?

2. If i use 1:1 Pixel Mapping in 1080p will it give me black borders on top & bottom?

3. If i use Aspect Ratio Scaling does it scale 720p to size of a 1080p with black borders?

4. How about Motion Blur or Input Lag is there any?

5. Any other Issues i should know about?

6. Would this be the monitor of my choice?

Thanks in advance. :)
 
Comments in-line with your original post. Good luck in your choice.

Hello all,

I have been looking for a Full HD monitor for my Xbox 360 Elite i would be connecting it through HDMI

1. Will the 1:1 Pixel Mapping, Aspect Ratio Scaling etc work over HDMI with 360? Absolutely. You even have a control for overscan which will give you 100% 1:1 pixel mapping, or slightly expanded image (depending on your taste) that cuts off potential subchannel noise.

2. If i use 1:1 Pixel Mapping in 1080p will it give me black borders on top & bottom? Yes, 100%

3. If i use Aspect Ratio Scaling does it scale 720p to size of a 1080p with black borders? Yes

4. How about Motion Blur or Input Lag is there any? Motion blur is very low, input lag non-existent at all resolutions

5. Any other Issues i should know about? 1920x1080 over VGA may be stretched to 1920x1200, you have to make sure in Windows your video card is set to "do not scale" or "centred timings" to allow the display to give full aspect settings.

Some noise at the bottom at 1080p where the black bar exists below the image. Does not exist at other resolutions over DVI/HDMI. HDMI does not go into power save mode > Screen just turns blue when no signal and set to HDMI input.

6. Would this be the monitor of my choice? It's a good PC/console gaming monitor, but TN viewing angles would preclude its hardcore use as a TV. Slight motion problems with interlaced resolutions (slight hitching every three seconds)

Thanks in advance. :)
 
You idiot, why dont you try to read the first post, when someone puts you down by telling you you work at mcdonolds, what are you going to say to them? im not going to respond to LAMERS like yourself, like i said i dont need to prove anything to you or anyone else.

hahahaha..there's another option, you can just let it go because what someone thinks of "gar818" on the internet is pretty meaningless. Some people get pretty wrapped up in their internet personas though.....I suggest to just getting back to your supermodel girlfriend and your black amex card and not wasting your time on internet insults.
 
10e, Thanks.

I would be sitting in front of the monitor so the viewing angle wont be the problem.
If i may ask few more questions.

1. Just to make sure that i can connect my speakers to the monitor so i can use the audio which comes through HDMI.

2. How about Tearing in games, shouldn't happen as far as i know am i right?

3. How would you rate the scaler in this monitor?

This would definitely be the monitor of my choice as it seems to have pretty good features and good connectivity it seems to be also one of the cheapest 24'' LCD's in Finland.
 
Some noise at the bottom at 1080p where the black bar exists below the image. Does not exist at other resolutions over DVI/HDMI. HDMI does not go into power save mode > Screen just turns blue when no signal and set to HDMI input..



How bad/annoying does this get? Is it a dealbreaker? Does the noise cover actual image?
 
I did the test also and VGA was pretty bad for me. I definetly needed the DVI so I went ahead and did a exchange. No problems so far.

Anyone tried DVI vs. VGA with the G2400W?

I was trying the VGA quality and noticed that text looks a bit fuzzy, so I hooked it up thru both DVI and VGA to the same PC, and using cloned display I switched between the two.
VGA is significantly less sharp and text is pretty fuzzy.

Any one noticed that?

I was expecting a slightly worse image quality but this is pretty bad!

Edit: I did adjust clock & phase on a pixel-checkers pattern before I tested it, so that isn't the reason for the fuzziness.
 
BTW it is on sale at Newegg.com for $387.83 with the promo code "Hardocp5520" ($369.99 + $17.84 3 day shipping). I will so buy this if I get a refund (I am not sure if I will get one but it is likely that I won't:() or if I double my $ when I go play Black Jack at the casino this weekend (I do this once or twice a year) as those are the only ways that I can justify spending $400 on something that I really don't need.
 
Even though this thread has turned into a pissing match, has anyone noticed how digitalversus.com has 3ms minimum, 3ms maximum, and an average of 1.9ms for the response compared to the CRT?

How is that mathematically possible? Does this thing really have such low input lag?
 
Yes. The input lag on this monitor is amazing and I play tons of fps' games and a couple at high level. The pixel mapping is very good on this monitor and like I've already stated, I use this monitor for EVERYTHING and it performs better then I expected.
 
More comments in line for you :)

Good luck with your choice.

10e

10e, Thanks.

I would be sitting in front of the monitor so the viewing angle wont be the problem.
If i may ask few more questions.

1. Just to make sure that i can connect my speakers to the monitor so i can use the audio which comes through HDMI. Yes, you can hook speakers up to the headphone jack, but you will only get stereo out.

2. How about Tearing in games, shouldn't happen as far as i know am i right? Tearing will not happen in games if you have Vsync on. It's an issue with pretty much all LCDs, because they operate at a fixed frequency (mostly 60hz) and with Vsync OFF, video cards can jump around from 30 fps to 130, which means sometimes you will get tearing. Vsync on fixes this issue. For consoles it's never a problem because 60hz is their maximum.

3. How would you rate the scaler in this monitor? It does a pretty good job. It doesn't increase input lag when going down, and it doesn't make things blurry either.

This would definitely be the monitor of my choice as it seems to have pretty good features and good connectivity it seems to be also one of the cheapest 24'' LCD's in Finland.
 
No, the noise doesn't cover any image, so it's not a big deal. I think I posted my image one page back, and that is a fairly accurate representation.

It only shows up in 1080p as well. Not sure if it's some sort of HDCP thing. I haven't seen this with other monitors (including BenQ) before, but it doesn't bother me at all.

Regards,

10e

How bad/annoying does this get? Is it a dealbreaker? Does the noise cover actual image?
 
As Burnsco says, the input lag is phenomenal.

And the best part is that it doesn't go up as you lower resolutions.

10e

Even though this thread has turned into a pissing match, has anyone noticed how digitalversus.com has 3ms minimum, 3ms maximum, and an average of 1.9ms for the response compared to the CRT?

How is that mathematically possible? Does this thing really have such low input lag?
 
Stereo as in 2.0 Sound?

So then Creative GigaWorks T20/T40 should work good on them.

Thanks again. :)
 
Yes, that it correct.

Regular 2.0 sound/stereo, just like your computer's green headphone jack.

Enjoy. Always welcome!

10e

Stereo as in 2.0 Sound?

So then Creative GigaWorks T20/T40 should work good on them.

Thanks again. :)
 
So my stimulus check came through today and its time to buy this baby. Where is the best place purchase it that will allow me to return it no questions asked for no less than 30 days where i will not have to pay a restocking fee?
 
does anyone have any insight as to how common dead pixels are with this monitor?
 
Tough to say,

My first one had a dead green (subpixel) on the top left. It didn't bother me except if I looked for it, but I returned it for a different issue and the one I have now is basically perfect in that regard.

But to honestly answer that question, I couldn't conclusively tell you

10e

does anyone have any insight as to how common dead pixels are with this monitor?
 
I have had good luck with Tiger Direct (where I bought it from) up in Canada, but that was retail. If it's possible to do retail with this thing, I would recommend it. Shipping the G2400W can be a risky exercise unless they are willing to repack it. The box is small and insufficient for shipping IMHO.

Most would say to avoid Newegg though.

10e

So my stimulus check came through today and its time to buy this baby. Where is the best place purchase it that will allow me to return it no questions asked for no less than 30 days where i will not have to pay a restocking fee?
 
NCIX is a great Canadian / US site, that is where I bought my G2400W from. They have a zero dead pixel guarantee you can purchase for like 8$ and express RMA service. They did ship it in the retail box :( but it did arrive just fine, having travelled all the way from BC to Ontario.

EDIT: The G2400W is on sale at NCIX for $349.98CDN currently, thats .01$ cheaper then I got it for about three weeks ago. :p
 
Well retail is out of the question there is a local ma and pa shop here that sells BenQ products but i dont think they have any return policy whatsoever and i know about the dangers of shipping large monitors UPS nearly destroyed my Acer 20" when i bought it. Ill check out NCIX though. I didnt know they had a US site.

EDIT: NCIX have a "Heavy Duty Shipping Box" Option and a "ExpressRMA" option but im not seeing a dead pixel option. Is that included in the ExpressRMA or is it only for Canada. But it also seems they cant take US Credit cards :mad:
 
Check out ncixus.com and see if you can find the pixel warranty.

If not, give them a call on their toll free number. I have bought things from them and they do a great job when you add the "heavy duty shipping" box option. In that scenario your shipment will be very well protected.

Regards,

10e

Well retail is out of the question there is a local ma and pa shop here that sells BenQ products but i dont think they have any return policy whatsoever and i know about the dangers of shipping large monitors UPS nearly destroyed my Acer 20" when i bought it. Ill check out NCIX though. I didnt know they had a US site.

EDIT: NCIX have a "Heavy Duty Shipping Box" Option and a "ExpressRMA" option but im not seeing a dead pixel option. Is that included in the ExpressRMA or is it only for Canada. But it also seems they cant take US Credit cards :mad:
 
Hmm its cheaper to use the Canadian NCIX site also the US site doesnt offer heavy duty boxing, only downside to using the Canadian site is i would have to wait longer and pay via paypal. And i must have been blind when i was checking them out before there is a checkbox for the dead pixel guarantee when you add it to your cart. On both sites.
 
Generally yes because the internal electronics on the speaker system will re-direct bass to the subwoofer.

Regards,

10e

Does 2.1 Speaker systems work properly over the monitors 3.5mm jack?

Thanks. :)
 
Weird that it's cheaper, as the Exchange rate is pretty much par right now ($1.00 U.S. equals $1.00 American) but I guess because NCIX is located close to a port of transfer in BC they are able to sell for cheaper.

It's good that you got the warranty.

Did you know that your username is an archaic Greek word meaning death? :)

Just thought I'd add that, because I'm of greek descent.

Regards, and I hope you are happy with it :)

10e

Hmm its cheaper to use the Canadian NCIX site also the US site doesnt offer heavy duty boxing, only downside to using the Canadian site is i would have to wait longer and pay via paypal. And i must have been blind when i was checking them out before there is a checkbox for the dead pixel guarantee when you add it to your cart. On both sites.
 
Yeah i chose Thanatos as my online/gaming alias cause he is the God of Death, (Son of Night and Darkness and brother of Sleep how cool is that) and im really into mythology (Greek, Norse, Egyptian whatever) And thanks for all your input in the this thread 10e. Really help make up my mind. I haven't exactly pulled the trigger on this but my mind is pretty made up and i should have it purchased by the end of the week.
 
We just got our second G2400W for our house and no issues on the new one either. The only thing I don't like is that they both get noticeably darker as you go up the screen, other than that we are happy. :)
 
Is it possible to get the G2400W to go into power saving (sleep) mode when the source is set to HDMI and that source powers down/stops sending a signal?
 
BTW will this monitor upscale 1080i on hdmi to 1080p or would you be better off at 720p (DVD player doesn't do 1080p)?
 
If you're using an upscaling DVD player 720p should be fine.

You can also try 1080i. The G2400W deinterlaces just fine too, but it will give you a "non preset mode" message, and if you go into the OSD, it will show you 1920x540 which is kinda funny, but it still works.

10e

[21CW]killerofall;1032474048 said:
BTW will this monitor upscale 1080i on hdmi to 1080p or would you be better off at 720p (DVD player doesn't do 1080p)?
 
Trent,

The screen turns blue on HDMI when in power save mode or no signal is applied.

This is typical of other monitors over HDMI like the Westinghouse L2410NM, and others where the HDMI is purely used as a "video" connection.

You still having problems with "waking up"?

Regards,

10e
 
Damn, the V2400W has more input lag??? Thats sucks, seems like the G2400W is better.
 
Anyone else having the issue where the boot screens/bios dont display when hooked up thru DVI but display fine thru VGA?

I thought it was a primary/secondary issue at first, so I tried it with another monitor, but that one worked fine w/ both DVI and VGA.
 
Damn, the V2400W has more input lag??? Thats sucks, seems like the G2400W is better.

Marginal differences. Almost non one could notice the small increase in input lag. It looks like a small increase for input lag while getting a small increase in response time. I think it is more down to case design and price.
 
Trent,

The screen turns blue on HDMI when in power save mode or no signal is applied.

This is typical of other monitors over HDMI like the Westinghouse L2410NM, and others where the HDMI is purely used as a "video" connection.

You still having problems with "waking up"?

Regards,

10e
I ordered an HDMI cable not knowing that :( so that won't work!

Although I discovered that if while using DVI I keep the VGA cable plugged in and the other end not plugged to anything it wakes up from sleep! Kind of weird ... and it seems that when the PC is off (with the VGA cable plugged in) every once in a while the monitor wakes up checks for a signal and goes back to sleep. Not really a problem since my computer isn't in my bedroom :p

But the HDMI wasn't a total waste, I was having problems configuring the screen resolution in linux with DVI (not too much of an expert), but HDMI seems to be working flawlessly without any extra config.

So probably gonna have all inputs plugged in HDMI for linux, DVI for windows, and VGA so that DVI wakes up :D

Not gonna risk getting dead/stuck pixels for a problem that I can have a workaround for that isn't too inconvenient! This baby is staying :p
 
Back
Top