Battlefield 3 General Discussion Thread

nearly 60 hours in i am starting to feel this game is a bit hyped up. many guns have worthless unlocks (f2000 has a bipod for example). many team balance issues. infantry is basically, in short to medium range, nearly identical to cod to me aside from the differences in the engine (you can think you have a corner locked down while prone and lmg deployed only to have someone run around the corner at full speed, not knowing you're there, and seconds later you're dead)... not to mention all the silly bunny-hopping when people go through open ground. :eek: in short, it just doesn't feel like the next step from bf2 to me.
 
not to mention all the silly bunny-hopping when people go through open ground.

To be fair, some of the bunny hopping is because you get stuck on ridiculously small pieces of stuff sometimes. I hop whenever I run over a rock or something lying in the road, because you never know whether it is going to catch you or not. Karkand and Oman seem really bad for it.
 
Transfering large files of data you will see a difference.

Transferring them to where? If you are moving to another drive, that drive is going to be slower anyway. The only time you'll see any difference at all is loading large files into memory, which happens very rarely. Loading game levels isn't going to make a noticeable difference. It'll be 2.75 seconds instead of 3, or 45 seconds instead of 52 - it's faster in benchmarks, but not worth the extra money for real-world use.
 
Last edited:
uh.....wut?
The main advantage of a SSD over a hard drive are their extremely low random read/write speeds. Thats what really gives a SSD its snappy performance. There's really no difference between SATA 3.0Gb/s and SATA 6.0Gb/s in regards to SSD's random read/write speeds.

However there is a difference with the read and write speeds of a SATA 6.0 SSD when used on a SATA 3.0Gb/s: The difference is around 25% give or take. But unless you're constantly transferring files between the SSD and another device, as Forceman noted, you really wouldn't notice a difference.

It's really all about that random read/write speeds. Hence why the older Sandforce SSDs, despite having higher transfer speeds, were noticeably slower than older Intel or Crucial SSDs with significantly lower transfer speeds as those Sandforce SSDs had a relatively high random read/write speeds compared to those Intel and Crucial SSDs.
 
The main advantage of a SSD over a hard drive are their extremely low random read/write speeds. Thats what really gives a SSD its snappy performance. There's really no difference between SATA 3.0Gb/s and SATA 6.0Gb/s in regards to SSD's random read/write speeds.

However there is a difference with the read and write speeds of a SATA 6.0 SSD when used on a SATA 3.0Gb/s: The difference is around 25% give or take. But unless you're constantly transferring files between the SSD and another device, as Forceman noted, you really wouldn't notice a difference.

It's really all about that random read/write speeds. Hence why the older Sandforce SSDs, despite having higher transfer speeds, were noticeably slower than older Intel or Crucial SSDs with significantly lower transfer speeds as those Sandforce SSDs had a relatively high random read/write speeds compared to those Intel and Crucial SSDs.

he was inferring that sata II isnt really needed or noticable, when there are tons of drives, esp SSDs that can easily destroy the limits of SATA I

it noticable, I put an SSD in my wifes computer(while she was gone for teh weekend) who is 99% oblivious to most everything and asked what I did because her computer seemed so much faster
 
Is this a good example of an IR camera working IRL?

It's a scene from mythbusters shot in the California desert, during the day, and from very high up.

flirdesert.jpg


The blue is from the cars driving around and blowing away the topsoil to generate a dustcloud. You can even see the guy standing between the 2nd and 3rd car.
 
he was inferring that sata II isnt really needed or noticable, when there are tons of drives, esp SSDs that can easily destroy the limits of SATA I
You're missing the point: The SSD's main advantage is the random read/write speeds which aren't affected by being on a SATA 3.0Gb/s interface rather than being on a SATA 6.0Gb/s or PCI-E interface. The average real world usage doesn't involve one constantly reading and writing large amounts of data to the drive. It's mostly composed of applications trying to quickly find the files they need. Hence why random read/write speeds are important. So yes, unless your particular "real world" usage requires you to constantly read/write data to the drive, Forceman is right in that SATA 3.0Gb/s won't be a noticeable impact on SATA 6.0Gb/s or even PCI-E SSDs
it noticable, I put an SSD in my wifes computer(while she was gone for teh weekend) who is 99% oblivious to most everything and asked what I did because her computer seemed so much faster
That's not what we're arguing: SSD do make a difference in the performance of a PC. That much we can agree. However, the interface itself isn't a huge concern for real world usage. It's all about the random read/write speeds which aren't affected that much by the interface. Again, unless you're constantly writing and reading data to the drive, you won't notice a performance difference between SATA 3.0Gb/s and SATA 6.0Gb/s.
 
he was inferring that sata II isnt really needed or noticable, when there are tons of drives, esp SSDs that can easily destroy the limits of SATA I

Nah, you misunderstood, or I wasn't clear. I meant that running in SATA 2 instead of SATA 3 (6Gb) doesn't matter - not that SATA 2 doesn't matter over SATA 1.
 
Nah, you misunderstood, or I wasn't clear. I meant that running in SATA 2 instead of SATA 3 (6Gb) doesn't matter - not that SATA 2 doesn't matter over SATA 1.

makes so much more sense, and yes, while there is a difference it would be hard to really actualyl notice
 
It's a shame what they did to IGLAs and Stingers. What's the point of using them now? You don't get points for making a pilot's lock warning go off. :/ That's all their good for now. Shame. Shame on you, DICE.
 
It's a shame what they did to IGLAs and Stingers. What's the point of using them now? You don't get points for making a pilot's lock warning go off. :/ That's all their good for now. Shame. Shame on you, DICE.

They look cool on your Engie's back?

But yeah, the IGLAs and Stingers are all but useless short of a retarded/noob pilot.
 
It's a shame what they did to IGLAs and Stingers. What's the point of using them now? You don't get points for making a pilot's lock warning go off. :/ That's all their good for now. Shame. Shame on you, DICE.

Ya you have a better chance at a kill by using an RPG. :p
 
Transferring them to where? If you are moving to another drive, that drive is going to be slower anyway. The only time you'll see any difference at all is loading large files into memory, which happens very rarely. Loading game levels isn't going to make a noticeable difference. It'll be 2.75 seconds instead of 3, or 45 seconds instead of 52 - it's faster in benchmarks, but not worth the extra money for real-world use.

Correct to an extent, but as game maps get bigger and bigger we will eventually see a difference. Im suprised BF3 maps load so fast. They load faster then BF2 maps!!!
 
Correct to an extent, but as game maps get bigger and bigger we will eventually see a difference. Im suprised BF3 maps load so fast. They load faster then BF2 maps!!!

Huh? BF2 maps took about 10-15 seconds to load for me on my HDD. BF3 maps take around 5-8 seconds or so to load on my SSD(Took like 20-30 seconds on my HDD, but that is dying so it doesn't count)
 
Huh? BF2 maps took about 10-15 seconds to load for me on my HDD. BF3 maps take around 5-8 seconds or so to load on my SSD(Took like 20-30 seconds on my HDD, but that is dying so it doesn't count)

Last time I was running BF2, was on 2 x raptors RAID 0 and map loads took at least 30-45 seconds.
 
Is this a good example of an IR camera working IRL?

It's a scene from mythbusters shot in the California desert, during the day, and from very high up.

flirdesert.jpg


The blue is from the cars driving around and blowing away the topsoil to generate a dustcloud. You can even see the guy standing between the 2nd and 3rd car.

That is a thermal camera, not an IR camera.
 
What's the difference?
Thermal cameras are more specialized infrared cameras that show the temperature of objects using varying degrees of color shading to replace the varying degrees of grayscale that a typical infrared camera usually uses.
This is an infrared image from a Apache gun camera:
0.jpg
 
Thermal cameras are more specialized infrared cameras that show the temperature of objects using varying degrees of color shading to replace the varying degrees of grayscale that a typical infrared camera usually uses.
This is an infrared image from a Apache gun camera:
0.jpg

So it's the same thing with a different color display. Same IR principle, but they just made it grayscale instead of color coded.

The picture i posted is taken with an FLIR, they're normally demoed on TV to output in black and white, or green. IR intensity has always been measured lineary, it's just that they used color to make it easier to see heat variations.

The issue that made be think of it is the talk a while back about IR cameras being useless in daylight. There have been demonstrations of it being used in daytime, which should have debunked the argument even back then (The one i posted back then was tuned to human heat and actually highlights them, but it was done in a forest). But this was the first time i've managed to see an IR camera demoed in a desert in the middle of the day.
 
Last edited:
he was inferring that sata II isnt really needed or noticable, when there are tons of drives, esp SSDs that can easily destroy the limits of SATA I

it noticable, I put an SSD in my wifes computer(while she was gone for teh weekend) who is 99% oblivious to most everything and asked what I did because her computer seemed so much faster

Then what you and your wife are experiencing the benefits of 0.1ms access times (roughly) of your average SSD more than raw speed. Thanks to the benefits of an SSD being a giant flash drive and no mechanical drive head having to "seek" information manually , this is the single biggest benefit of an SSD.

People are always concerned with transfer throughput on SSD's but honestly unless you are transferring blu ray's across your network or moving other large data folders across your own system , raw speed means jack shit for games.

The benefits of using an SSD for BF3 are probably you being able to load faster into the game and maybe by only as little as a few seconds. So no there is no great advantage to using SSD's for gaming (with the exception of MMO's that are constantly streaming data from the drive).
 
Then what you and your wife are experiencing the benefits of 0.1ms access times (roughly) of your average SSD more than raw speed. Thanks to the benefits of an SSD being a giant flash drive and no mechanical drive head having to "seek" information manually , this is the single biggest benefit of an SSD.

People are always concerned with transfer throughput on SSD's but honestly unless you are transferring blu ray's across your network or moving other large data folders across your own system , raw speed means jack shit for games.

The benefits of using an SSD for BF3 are probably you being able to load faster into the game and maybe by only as little as a few seconds. So no there is no great advantage to using SSD's for gaming (with the exception of MMO's that are constantly streaming data from the drive).

that few seconds is often the diff between me getting the viper and walking :(
 
So does the mobile AA not damage tanks anymore? Is that the "tweak" they were talking about? Because I wasn't getting hitmarkers when hitting tanks with the LAV last night. Is this an old change and it's just been too long since I last played?

Edit: Just tested it and yeah, no damage...when did this happen? :( lol
 
Last edited:
team with most SSD's wins Metro every time.....Unless they utterly suck.

On most servers, when I load the game at the start there's usually a 20 second delploy counter before you can move... If it loaded any faster it would just be an even longer deploy counter. :p
 
On most servers, when I load the game at the start there's usually a 20 second delploy counter before you can move... If it loaded any faster it would just be an even longer deploy counter. :p

This. Saying that because an entire team uses an SSD to load the game gives them a win is just wrong.

Again , if SSD's truly gave you a huge advantage in games you would have read article after article on the matter and people wouldn't be installing games on large regular HD drives and using an SSD to run their OS as is often the configuration.
 
Okay I am dumb. How do you individually change the video settings? All I get is the preset LOW, MEDIUM, HIGH, ULTRA. The individual settings are greyed out.
 
Okay I am dumb. How do you individually change the video settings? All I get is the preset LOW, MEDIUM, HIGH, ULTRA. The individual settings are greyed out.

there is a CUSTOM setting right before ULTRA or after it. Cycle through and you will find it.
 
To be fair, some of the bunny hopping is because you get stuck on ridiculously small pieces of stuff sometimes. I hop whenever I run over a rock or something lying in the road, because you never know whether it is going to catch you or not. Karkand and Oman seem really bad for it.

This is probably one of my biggest complains about BF3.

I can't count the amount of times I've been killed because, as I was running for cover, I understandibly got stuck on a blockade consisting of a cigarette butt or 1" raised piece of cobblestone.

Seriously? WTF? How is that even possible?

Don't even get me started on the rediculous DLC packs... $60.00 to let people unlock all the attachments/weapons/etc on top of $60.00 for the game itself? Holy hell!
 
This is probably one of my biggest complains about BF3.

I can't count the amount of times I've been killed because, as I was running for cover, I understandibly got stuck on a blockade consisting of a cigarette butt or 1" raised piece of cobblestone.

Seriously? WTF? How is that even possible?

Don't even get me started on the rediculous DLC packs... $60.00 to let people unlock all the attachments/weapons/etc on top of $60.00 for the game itself? Holy hell!

Actually it's $40; still expensive though.
 
Back
Top