ASUS RMA is Ridiculously Horrible!

I don't know if it'll work but I just sent Asus a nice little letter telling them I'm going to file a lawsuit if they don't fully replace my board, don't know if they'll do anything but filing a lawsuit will at least convince them I'm dead serious. I've had it ...that's what my bro suggested I do, file a lawsuit (my employer lost thousands of dollars of irreplaceable, invaluable Geological data *TWICE* and it cost me my contract with them, basically 18 months of work down the drain). So regardless I'm going all out on this, this is the fourth computer I've had with an ASUS mobo in it that has failed me, I can't afford to keep replacing computers because their products are inferior. And i sure as hell can't keep loosing contracts. I'm also going make a video and post it on every social media site I can find in hope of exposing this BS ....anyone want to help or share their story of misery? Maybe together we can end this kind of bullshit :)


Wait, you are going to sue Asus because you do not know how to back up data? Data that you spend 10's of thousands on the drill and get samples from? Sorry, but you have no case. I don't buy Asus anymore after dealing with their terrible service, it just isn't worth it, but their product are very good and reliable. It is us, the unlucky 1 or 2% that have had to deal with their horrid service.
 
WTF
I can see replacing computer parts being an annoyance and an expense but it sounds like people need to be fired for not putting in place a plan for backing up important data.
I'll second that emotion.

I'm sure his lawyer will get things straightened out. :rolleyes:
 
That sounds like a nightmare. This is why I like EVGA products because they will ship you the replacement first.
 
That sounds like a nightmare. This is why I like EVGA products because they will ship you the replacement first.

Asus is SUPPOSED to over Advanced replacement on products like Motherboards. They dont offer it on VGA cards though. With my last fiasco, I calld the customer service line...every day...until i got a resolution, and they advance replacement'ed me a card.
 
I had an issue once that a M3A-MVP 790FX mobo for some reason would not post with a quad, but would post with a dual core no problem. I RMA'd with explicit instructions about this issue, they sent me the same board back. Just for the shit of it, I test it; problem still there.

I get ahold of the RMA department, and explained it wasn't repaired. The tech said maybe they didn't have a quad core to test it with. I told him that's not my problem that your techs are not prepared, and the board should work with any chip on the CPU support list. He asked me to send it back again, and I said I'm not paying for shipping twice. He emailed me a prepaid label, and they shipped me back a brand new retail box motherboard. So in the end it worked out, so I forgave.

Just hope you never have to RMA anything with Gigabyte.......:(
 
There's always two sides to a story like said before and people bitch more about poor service than others praise for great service. RMA is just a shitty process with almost any company but blaming ASUS for you losing the silicon lottery and not properly backing up your computers... not ASUS's fault. Electronics fail, they're too complex to be made perfect every time, if they weren't, you'd probably build them yourselves. That data loss is your fault, at least from the information given.
 
So why didn't the OP use it?

Because I only found out about advanced replacement AFTER I asked for RMA.
Are you going to try to push the blame on me because I wasn't aware of their programs?
They didn't offer me anything. I called, said my motherboard was dead and asked if I had warranty still on it. The rep replied "Yes, you have warranty on it. Would you like to RMA it?" and I said "sure".
That is exactly how it went down.
 
Not the OP's fault... that is Asus who should have offered it as a courtasy.
 
Are you going to try to push the blame on me because I wasn't aware of their programs?
Not at all.

I investigate that kinda stuff before I do it but many don't.

I asked why, you answered, and that's enough.
 
You think a public bitch board indicates that all the returns/problems were Asus's fault? LOL!

There's ALWAYS two sides to every story. :)

I used to work at the center his board is at and who hes dealing with. That link pretty much accurately reflects that place. I could literally write a novel about it. Ill leave it at this and give you their side. Everything done and every process in that center does no make sense. Its not effecient nor does it have any logic. Everything is designed around a production environment where you have to meet a ridiculous quota. All of the managers are not capable of being a tech there yet they make the quota. So no matter how hard it is to hit you have to hit quota or you get bitched out in chinese and treated like a kid in a sweatshop with ongoing repercussions from management. Literally about 90% of the non chinese people there would fail a drug test. Most are deadbeats who get drunk and high in the parking lot. There might be enough people who truly cared about their job when they worked there and focused on quality over quantity that you could count on two hands. So when your board doesnt get fixed its because there is some guy that is prolly fucked up doing it in the most half assed way and just trying to meet the quota.
 
I used to work at the center his board is at and who hes dealing with. That link pretty much accurately reflects that place.........
After reading that you'd think that they would never ship a fixed product but obviously that's not true. LOL!

You didn't give me their side you gave me your side.....and there's another side to that story too. :D

It doesn't really matter.

Seems like they have dropped the ball on the OP's RMA but I don't feel that a 1 month turnaround is all that bad and IDK what was even wrong with the MB.

There's always two sides to every story and my side of the OP's story ends now.

Good Luck!
 
After reading that you'd think that they would never ship a fixed product but obviously that's not true. LOL!

You didn't give me their side you gave me your side.....and there's another side to that story too. :D

It doesn't really matter.

Seems like they have dropped the ball on the OP's RMA but I don't feel that a 1 month turnaround is all that bad and IDK what was even wrong with the MB.

There's always two sides to every story and my side of the OP's story ends now.

Good Luck!
You dont get it. This isnt a rare situation. Its very common for stuff like this to happen. Its very rare that things go smoothly.
 
I used to work at the center his board is at and who hes dealing with. That link pretty much accurately reflects that place. I could literally write a novel about it. Ill leave it at this and give you their side. Everything done and every process in that center does no make sense. Its not effecient nor does it have any logic. Everything is designed around a production environment where you have to meet a ridiculous quota. All of the managers are not capable of being a tech there yet they make the quota. So no matter how hard it is to hit you have to hit quota or you get bitched out in chinese and treated like a kid in a sweatshop with ongoing repercussions from management. Literally about 90% of the non chinese people there would fail a drug test. Most are deadbeats who get drunk and high in the parking lot. There might be enough people who truly cared about their job when they worked there and focused on quality over quantity that you could count on two hands. So when your board doesnt get fixed its because there is some guy that is prolly fucked up doing it in the most half assed way and just trying to meet the quota.

All I can say is this sounds pretty accurate to me, makes complete sense, and from the Asus reps I have met in person does not surprise me in the least. I am not a fan of Asus boards, and only use them if requested. I have been a system builder for over a decade and Asus at one time was the board to get. Highly regarded for there standards and quality builds. Not anymore. When they shifted to sell direct to the public they brought there VAR/OEM mentality with them for support. Which has always been, next to none. Certain segments of Asus has done better than others, but barely.

I had a customer today asking me about the Asus Zenbook and the Mac Air. Let me just say I am as anti Mac as can be and it cost me a sale but for almost equal prices I steered him towards the Mac. Because he can walk into any Apple store and get service. Asus service standards have degraded to a point where it costs me money to carry there products therefore I do not recommend them nor will I sell them unless it is insisted upon.

And for the record there are technically three sides to every story, yours, theres, and truth which is somewhere in the middle.
 
ASUS RMA is the worst of the worst. They did the exact same thing to me with a Striker II NSE. I powered on the board and a cap came flying off it, on fire. I sent it back... Three weeks later they sent me the exact same board back(obvious because of the burnt area and missing cap), and said they did not find any problems with the board.

I wanted to kill.

If you search for posts started by me I'm sure you can find the entire drama.

It wasn't even the first time ASUS gave me the shaft, nor would it be the last time either. And the only way I managed to get help was because Kyle noticed my ranting here on [H] and contacted ASUS on my behalf.

Yet for some reason I still keep buying ASUS products. I'm running a R3E, and I just got a Zenbook UX31E-DH72... When the products work... They're second to none... But if you need help... Expect it to be like getting a root canal with no anesthetic.
 
I honestly did not think that ASUS was this bad. This is my first encounter with their customer service. Reading all your stories just makes me even more angry and sympathetic with you guys. I am still waiting for the motherboard to arrive (should be here monday or tuesday).

I am also contemplating RMA'ing a graphics card with them but I am not sure if I want to do that.
The graphics card is artifacting and when I called to ask about RMA'ing the graphics card I was told that that my model is not in stock. The rep also told me if I send in my card they will either wait for that model to be in stock so they can mail me it or they will try to repair the card. And we all know how well they "repair". Waiting for that model to be in stock also doesn't sound too appealing, since I could be waiting for half a year.

OC_Seer from ASUS Support PM'd me and told me that if they do not have that model in stock, they will mail me the next available step-up..but I am not sure if that is true, since that is not what the rep told me over the phone..
 
Thanks for this thread, I am by no means a PC guru and have been on here trying to get educated on an upcoming build. Honestly I have read a few poor reviews on their customer service, but dang. Now I might have to reconsider my choices and I was really getting attached to the idea of an ASUS P8Z68-V PRO. Also was considering one of their monitors if one I have doesn't work.
 
I wonder if RMA quality differs by country and region, depending on the local service center. I live in Australia and haven't had any Asus RMA issues with the 3 or so returns I've made to them. Albeit that's a very small sample. :p
 
I can only speak for US rma of Asus and there support system. If you have good support where your at then this thread is probably not applicable to you. I sure do wish they would step it up here.
 
You think just because America is on the otherside of the world,
Asus takes time?

I am living in asia, just a few hours flight to Taiwan and when I
RMAed my dead GTX480 which was their flagship, I had to wait 6 months!
Know what they said, out of stock! And that was about 8 months before
GTX580 came out! I totally agree Asus RMA sucks BIG time.
 

Eh, ASUS is the *only* brand motherboard I've bought my entire life (and believe me, I've built quite a lot of computers since the IBM Clone days) and I have yet to come across a bad board. In my experience most boards go back when cheap PSU (surges are a no-no) are used or when people don't properly ventilate their computer. Ditto a badly grounded house. Ditto tinkering inside their computer while it's still powered on or when you've not discharged static electricity from yourselves.

Not saying ASUS can't make bad boards, but just saying a bad experience with one item with any company shouldn't deter you from giving them another shot. Believe me, there's not all that many board makers out there that's as top notched as ASUS. There's Gigabyte and MSI and Intel - that's pretty much about it.
 
Eh, ASUS is the *only* brand motherboard I've bought my entire life (and believe me, I've built quite a lot of computers since the IBM Clone days) and I have yet to come across a bad board. In my experience most boards go back when cheap PSU (surges are a no-no) are used or when people don't properly ventilate their computer. Ditto a badly grounded house. Ditto tinkering inside their computer while it's still powered on or when you've not discharged static electricity from yourselves.

Not saying ASUS can't make bad boards, but just saying a bad experience with one item with any company shouldn't deter you from giving them another shot. Believe me, there's not all that many board makers out there that's as top notched as ASUS. There's Gigabyte and MSI and Intel - that's pretty much about it.

You are very obviously in the minority, and in my opinion are just downright lucky.
Take a look at these pics from the *second* striker 2 nse they sent back to me(after sending me the same board back). After this happened Kyle got involved and I got a brand new board from ASUS, which worked perfectly until the guy I sold it to broke a cap off it.

Back panel is wrecked. Connectors bent and connectors flat out MISSING:


Visible trace damage:


Cooling hardware had obviously been removed and improperly rebuilt:


Water damage:


More water damage:


Now, I do have a bit more advice. A friend of mine who I assist building his machines, had significant problems with the striker 2 formula(780i, blech). Those boards died SO MANY times that ASUS *OFFERED* him an upgrade board. It wasn't the same chipset or the same CPU/ram compatibility, but it is also a rampage 3 extreme. Which was a great reason for him to upgrade everything.
 
Who do you guys think has the best RMA process for motherboard makers? I've always bought Asus and GA but have only had to RMA once and the process for the board was good (Asus), but it was during the P4 days. Maybe things have changed.
 
You are very obviously in the minority, and in my opinion are just downright lucky.
Take a look at these pics from the *second* striker 2 nse they sent back to me(after sending me the same board back). After this happened Kyle got involved and I got a brand new board from ASUS, which worked perfectly until the guy I sold it to broke a cap off it.

Back panel is wrecked. Connectors bent and connectors flat out MISSING:


Visible trace damage:


Cooling hardware had obviously been removed and improperly rebuilt:


Water damage:


More water damage:


Now, I do have a bit more advice. A friend of mine who I assist building his machines, had significant problems with the striker 2 formula(780i, blech). Those boards died SO MANY times that ASUS *OFFERED* him an upgrade board. It wasn't the same chipset or the same CPU/ram compatibility, but it is also a rampage 3 extreme. Which was a great reason for him to upgrade everything.

Jesus Christ. Are you sure I'm lucky or you're extremely unlucky?
 
Jesus Christ. Are you sure I'm lucky or you're extremely unlucky?
I'm 100% certain you're lucky, and this is the norm for ASUS products.

I have had to send back every single motherboard I've ever bought from ASUS at least once. Including the latest Rampage 3 Extreme, and including boards that I did not overclock and ran 100% stock.

ASUS always seems to end up in my computer because of layout considerations and features. I'm a little ashamed to say it, but I also tend to prefer ASUS color schemes to all the other manufacturers.

On the flip side, I've now built several machines that have Gigabyte boards in them, and have had no problems at all with them(in fact, when I build computers for others, I now exclusively use Gigabyte boards instead of ASUS).

I've also stopped buying ASUS GPU's and now buy Gigabyte or EVGA GPU's, even for my own system.
 
These stories do not surprise me lol. They've been this way for a while... Then again I think many manufacturers are pretty shoddy in the RMA dept; only "good" one I know for sure is corsair.
 
OC_Seer from ASUS Support PM'd me and told me that if they do not have that model in stock, they will mail me the next available step-up..but I am not sure if that is true, since that is not what the rep told me over the phone..

Fat chance. They can't repair my 5970 and I've been waiting a month for them to get a 5970 in stock to send me. Before sending the card I applied for the advanced rma which was declined because they didn't have any in stock. I'm not sure how they plan to get a card no longer produced back in stock. Tomorrow will be the last day of the time frame I was given so I'll have to call in and be a dick it looks like.

Mind you this is all after already sending my card in once and getting it back without any repair notes and still not functioning. Ive been without a working gpu that i paid $700 for for almost 2 months.

The only reason I buy asus is for the US based support. I have a friend who had a diamond 5970 that went bad and he was sent a 6990 within a month. So guess asus isn't any better than every one else.

Even if they do send me a 6990 I will have a water block that's no good and a 5870 with a water block that's also no use. But at least I won't feel like I was raped.
 
Last edited:
I'm 100% certain you're lucky, and this is the norm for ASUS products.

I have had to send back every single motherboard I've ever bought from ASUS at least once. Including the latest Rampage 3 Extreme, and including boards that I did not overclock and ran 100% stock.

I usually buy ASUS boards, not because of brand loyalty, but because of price/features. Was going to go for gigabyte on the main, but the PCIe express lane bandwidth choose ASUS for me, same with laptop, MSI/dell/sony were all way way more expensive for the same components. I wouldn't mind an MSI or EVGA, but EVGA tend to be a little pricey for the same stuff, or outdated, and MSI have weird holes in their feature set. I've never gotten an ASUS GPU.

At the moment I have 5 computers all running asus boards, and the only board I have ever had fail wasn't from them. Several of the earlier computers were probably 80% ASUS boarded too. The biggest issue i've ever had was coil whine on one board when undervolting. There is a supposed 5% fail rate on electronics. If you have multiple failures of different products from any brand, there is a chance that it's some other common component. But I don't think asus stuff has a particulary high fail rate otherwise you would hear about it way way more often (think xbox 360).

So statistically i've had way more problems with corsair stuff, yet I still buy their ram/PSUs almost exclusively, and would recommend them to anyone. (though any problems i've had with them have been dealt with very very quickly and usually dealt with an advanced replacement! :D Still waiting for them to release an updated 800D...)
 
I usually buy ASUS boards, not because of brand loyalty, but because of price/features. Was going to go for gigabyte on the main, but the PCIe express lane bandwidth choose ASUS for me, same with laptop, MSI/dell/sony were all way way more expensive for the same components. I wouldn't mind an MSI or EVGA, but EVGA tend to be a little pricey for the same stuff, or outdated, and MSI have weird holes in their feature set. I've never gotten an ASUS GPU.

At the moment I have 5 computers all running asus boards, and the only board I have ever had fail wasn't from them. Several of the earlier computers were probably 80% ASUS boarded too. The biggest issue i've ever had was coil whine on one board when undervolting. There is a supposed 5% fail rate on electronics. If you have multiple failures of different products from any brand, there is a chance that it's some other common component. But I don't think asus stuff has a particulary high fail rate otherwise you would hear about it way way more often (think xbox 360).

So statistically i've had way more problems with corsair stuff, yet I still buy their ram/PSUs almost exclusively, and would recommend them to anyone. (though any problems i've had with them have been dealt with very very quickly and usually dealt with an advanced replacement! :D Still waiting for them to release an updated 800D...)

I agree with everything you've said above in an ideal situation.

Unfortunately the majority of the failures I've had, had no common components. And also, most of the time the systems I'm referring to are still running years later without issue after getting the replacement. I could go into detail on every single system, but it would fill pages and everyone would tl;dr.

The only system I had issues with where it turned out to be a problem with another component was when I was using a silverstone OP1000-E PSU... That PSU failed eventually, but by the time I figured out the issue... It had already taken out two boards(the board it killed, and the board I used to verify the integrity of the other components in the system). I didn't RMA either of those two boards because it wasn't a manufacturer defect. Silverstone sent me a replacement for that PSU that was flat out DOA, then tried to blame me for the second psu having a dead 12v rail. I'll never use another silverstone product again.

People constantly complain about ASUS failure rate and support. See the customer support scoreboard link with 322 negatives and only 22 positives, that was posted earlier in this thread.

Also, what you've said above doesn't explain how 5 out of 6 RMA's I've done with asus, they sent me either the same broken board back and claimed there were no problems with it, or they sent me another board that was visibly defective/damaged by the previous owner. Not to mention sending someone a used part as a replacement to begin with. Hey lets do the parts shuffle! Send user a the board that user b sent in, then send user b the board user a sent in, and say there's nothing wrong with them!
 
I dont understand why these large companies even do manual repairs, the best honest way to deal with RMA's is the same as hdd manufacturers, ship out a brand new replacement, even if it died 1 day before end of warranty. I think the failure rate is low enough that this is affordable for these companies. Especially taking into account the time spent on doing these attempted repairs and RMA processing.

I remember when I RMA'd a old viewsonic monitor, it broke with (at the time) a common fault for the model, which was the power not coming on properly and burst capacitor was cause. I RMA'd instead of manually repairing myself, and I got another monitor back which developed the same fault within weeks, unfortenatly there was only a week of warranty left so when the 2nd fault occured I was out of warranty. Clearly the exchanged monitor was a refurbushed one done poorly. I then repaired myself and it still works to this day, but dont use it anymore.
 
I just got the motherboard back today.
First thing I noticed is that the casing around the IDE HDD pins (the long blue one) is busted. There is a piece of plastic broken off..

Also, I think one of the RAM slots is busted, as it's not recognizing one of my sticks. My friends was using my RAM just yesterday and I took them out myself and they were working fine. I will test the RAM one more time and reseat the ram to make sure it's not the motherboard. I will take pictures and post when I have time.

EDIT: Ok, RAM issue solved. I just reseated and it was good.
Another issue:
Keyboard PS2 port is not functional..at all..
Board is bent.

I think they do this on purpose..they make you choose between deciding to send the board for replacement or saving yourself the headache and keeping the faulty board..
 
Last edited:
the best honest way to deal with RMA's is the same as hdd manufacturers, ship out a brand new replacement
I have never gotten a new drive from an RMA....WD, Hitachi, Intel, Samsung, or Seagate have all sent refurbs.
 
Seems like they have dropped the ball on the OP's RMA but I don't feel that a 1 month turnaround is all that bad and IDK what was even wrong with the MB.

I'm REALLY surprised to read this statement on an enthusiast forum. Most everybody I know (from computer layman to expert) would probably agree with "My computer is among the few things in my life that HAS to work. A few days of downtime, let alone a month, would be a serious problem."

That you think a month is okay, especially for an enthusiast, speaks volumes for how bad computer service has become and our how expectations have adjusted accordingly (e.g. forget repairing, just chuck it and get a new one).

I had a customer today asking me about the Asus Zenbook and the Mac Air. Let me just say I am as anti Mac as can be and it cost me a sale but for almost equal prices I steered him towards the Mac. Because he can walk into any Apple store and get service. Asus service standards have degraded to a point where it costs me money to carry there products therefore I do not recommend them nor will I sell them unless it is insisted upon.

This is why I ended up with an ipad instead of the transformer.

Like the OP, I work in the field of research and have worked in small/medium sized research centers. Sometimes the IT budgets in these places is small, and a their "IT guys" are part time undergraduate students. A lot of them come in and say "Why are we getting stuff from Dell/HP/Lenovo/Apple? I could build computers for cheaper and repair them myself"

At that point I have the discussion about how much money is lost when a computer is down, especially if a computer is down for more than a day or two. Once I throw in the headaches with software licenses, clueless employees, and the higher ups pointing fingers, they realize the differences between costs and downtime in the home versus the office.
 
Back
Top