Scientists Predict Possible Ice Increase in Arctic

You people are incredible, in a bad way. SMH. Heed this warning: Fox News commentators shouldn't be trusted with relaying scientific information.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_warming

http://www.palmbeachdailynews.com/blogs/content/shared-blogs/palmbeach/weather1/entries/2011/07/22/

In July of this year, we've broken ~1200 temperature records in the central part of the US.
US%20records%20July%202011.jpg

more measurement means more records will be broken... were all these weather stations measuring temperature 100, 50, 20, 10, 2 years ago? How accurate were they, how accurate are they now, how frequently did it record temperatures, how frequently does it now? lol and Wikipedia? Well, if its written in Wikipedia it just has to be true! lol. I know from personal experience that Wikipedia is heavily censored, i remember doing research into the LDS Church, went back to find some pages with some important information about fur farming and all of a sudden all reference to it was gone, most notably the article in Wikipedia about the breed of fox called the Mormon Fox, all of a sudden, no page, no page history, nothing... wiped from existence.
 
But the polar ice are floating, a large part of them are above sea level and so they do not displace the same amount of water now than they would when they melt into the ocean

bdnnmx.jpg


Imagine if this huge block of ice melted, all those mass visible would have to go somewhere in the ocean.

X amount of frozen water molecules takes up more space than X amount of liquid water molecules. when your block of ice melts, that formally melted water will take up the same space as the amount of your block of ice that is currently underwater.

this is my intentional simplification that ignores the minuscule difference in the mineral and gaseous deposits of both bodies of water, which may cumulatively make a difference on a global scale.
 
more measurement means more records will be broken... were all these weather stations measuring temperature 100, 50, 20, 10, 2 years ago? How accurate were they, how accurate are they now, how frequently did it record temperatures, how frequently does it now? lol and Wikipedia? Well, if its written in Wikipedia it just has to be true! lol. I know from personal experience that Wikipedia is heavily censored, i remember doing research into the LDS Church, went back to find some pages with some important information about fur farming and all of a sudden all reference to it was gone, most notably the article in Wikipedia about the breed of fox called the Mormon Fox, all of a sudden, no page, no page history, nothing... wiped from existence.

IDK about the scientific methodology that the weather monitoring systems use, but I do know that breaking records across an entire continent means it's getting hotter. I doubt they're calibrating the systems wrong, they're scientists.

I hear that complaint about Wikipedia all too often, as if the fact that anyone can put the information there means that the information magically fell out of the sky. You click the number at the end of the passage and you follow the link if you don't take the information at face value and/or want scientific proof. It's there if you look for it. If the information (such as anti-warming) isn't there, either it doesn't exist, or someone didn't put it up yet, in which case I encourage you to show me it.

Yeah, I know what you mean about people censoring information on Wikipedia. Some of Michelle Bachmann's fans tried to edit information from the 18th century regarding the founding fathers and their participation in slavery so that it would fall in line with her misconceptions and make her seem sane/knowledgeable. It's tragic.
 
I'm not saying its calibrated wrong. in fact the opposite. i'm saying more accuracy, more frequent measurements and measurements in more locations. more locations mean some of these weather stations could have a short or very short history making records come easily. more frequent/more accurate measurement would catch fleeting spikes in temperature that previous methods may not have been able to record.

statistics are easily skewed to fit just about any argument. also how many weather stations didn't record record temperatures. also what do these records represent? hottest temperature ever recorded or highest temperature for a 28th of June?
 
Ice floats because the crystalline structure takes up more volume than when liquid. The mass of icebergs and glaciers helps to remove any trapped gasses. They have a very clear blue tint as a result, not at all like ice from your freezer.
 
I'm not saying its calibrated wrong. in fact the opposite. i'm saying more accuracy, more frequent measurements and measurements in more locations. more locations mean some of these weather stations could have a short or very short history making records come easily. more frequent/more accurate measurement would catch fleeting spikes in temperature that previous methods may not have been able to record.

statistics are easily skewed to fit just about any argument. also how many weather stations didn't record record temperatures. also what do these records represent? hottest temperature ever recorded or highest temperature for a 28th of June?

Good point I really don't know. Record temperatures for one month probably isn't a good indicator of the global warming. On the other hand, look at the graphs on the Wikipedia page which show temperature estimates over 2000 years, then compare them with the Industrial Revolution going forward. The slope of the increase in warming increases twice as quickly from the Industrial Revolution and on as it does during any other time in the past 2000 years. Considering that this time period corresponds with the proliferation of fossil fuels, a dramatic increase in CO2 levels, the melting of ancient glaciers and by virtue of that, the greenhouse effect, do you really think it's "just a coincidence"?

The overwhelming majority of US scientists certainly don't. ~97% of publishing US scientists think global warming is caused by human activity.
 
my parents live on a tiny island in north carolina and the island is losing a house a year to the ocean
 
@ gaspah: The ^^^ post wasn't really aimed at you, it's just me pontificating about the facts. I hope at least one person was enlightened by it.

To get on topic (for my first post out of four :p), I have an idea:
A new computer climate simulation found that, under current climate conditions as well as changing wind patterns, Arctic ice is as likely to expand as it is to contract for periods of up to about a decade.

"The computer simulations suggest that we could see a 10-year period of stable ice or even a slight increase in the extent of the ice,"

If I had to guess about why the model was wrong and had to be adjusted, I'd say it probably is because of the global economic downturn. People don't have jobs, they don't drive to work, don't use as many appliances/resources, don't buy as much, and have therefore eased their burden on the environment, relatively speaking. A decade from now when we've mostly recovered from the downturn (hopefully America too), it'll be back to the old pace, and the long-term trend will be for the ice caps to melt, like before. My $0.02
 
A new computer model is showing the arctic ice may be getting a reprieve from melting over the next 10 year period. Even in the face of the good news, the scientists at the National center for Atmospheric Research are warning that the effects are only short term and the ice will continue to retreat is all factors remain the same.

Al Gore is sad today...:p
 
The earth's plates shift, collide, mountains rise and crumble, alot of areas in North America are vastly different than they were even 100,000 years ago. This planet changes. I've seen key phrases like "greenhouse gases" and "fossil fuels" thrown around for years and years. Are we having an effect on global warming? Absolutely. Are we destroying the planet? Absolutely not. We can destroy our ability to live on the planet, but this planet will keep on chugging along. Believe it or not, global warming has become big business. And it will act like any other big business.
 
Excuse me for kicking the dead horse, but a floodlight needs to be cast on this.

The earth's plates shift, collide, mountains rise and crumble, alot of areas in North America are vastly different than they were even 100,000 years ago. This planet changes. I've seen key phrases like "greenhouse gases" and "fossil fuels" thrown around for years and years. Are we having an effect on global warming? Absolutely. Are we destroying the planet? Absolutely not. We can destroy our ability to live on the planet, but this planet will keep on chugging along. Believe it or not, global warming has become big business. And it will act like any other big business.

I bolded the two most important parts of your post. That's the whole point of global warming being a bad thing LOL. You're basically saying "well, the future generations may be doomed to a scorching Hellfire-like wasteland because of how we're raping and pillaging the Earth, but at least the Earth will survive even if we don't, so no worries."

Yes, that is something to be worried about.

I'm willing to bet more houses are lost due to the economy than global warming.

You're right about that for now and probably for several decades, but that proportion is going to get turned on its head at the current rate we're going. The environment came/comes first, the economy can't exist without it, and neither can we.
 
I guess this finally disproves Global Warming.

That was what concerned me when I read this.

Idiots rejecting the fact - not theory - of climate change caused by human activity would use this short term trend to try to stir up some more nonsense to hurt our overwhelmingly crucial efforts to cot down on fossil fuels.

Thank you for making my prediction of human stupidity come true.
 
There will be an ice increase here in the winter too. And when January comes around and I am "enjoying" the sub zero weather if anyone says anything to me about global warming I will smack them with a rolled up newspaper. :eek:

TX is currently in its worst-ever drought and 2nd hottest summer ever. Please, tell us more of your scientific findings.
 
You guys are confusing weather and climate again...

Individual record temperatures (high or low) don't really matter as much, and are not what is measured as part of climate change.

What is concerning scientists is the long term averages. How year after year, the average annual temperature is rising. A difference of even one degree can have profound impacts.

Ice melting and flooding is a long term impact that most of us will not be around to see the dangers of, but there are more short term impacts.

Just look at the example of the Mountain Pine Beetle. This is a bug that lays eggs underneath the bark of pines. The larvae kill the trees by eating them from the inside.

In the past, the tops of most tall mountains were safe from this bug as the winters got too cold for them to survive. Just a fraction of a degree higher annual average temperatures has been enough to allow the beetle to survive the winters, resulting in the American biggest deforestation of our time. Soon there might not be any trees on mountains anywhere in the U.S.

Climate change does also have short term impacts on the weather, and its a lot less intuitive than the long term impacts. Higher average annual temperatures mean more moisture in the air, as more heat is applied on average to lakes and seas.

More moisture in the air creates more violent storms, harder hurricane seasons, and yes - counter-intuitively - more snow during the winter. The heave snows over the last couple of years in areas not used to seeing lots of snow, are likely caused directly by climate change.

We are already seeing a higher incidence rate of dangerous storms, and its only going to get worse.

Denying climate change today does nothing but show how ignorant you are. 10-20 years ago, you might have had a case. The numbers and data was less clear then. Today there is no doubt what so ever what is going on.

When you argue against Climate Change you place yourself in the lovely company of the following nitwits:
  • Those who argue vaccines cause downs syndrome
  • Those who don't believe HIV causes AIDS
  • Those who think 9/11 was an inside job
  • Those who believe the earth was created 6,500 years ago and man and dinosaur coexisted.

At least go get a fundamental understanding of statistics before trying to challenge a scientifically near universally accepted fact.
 
Well, that is because water displaces the same amount weather it is frozen or liquid.

So even if the entire arctic (north pole, which has no land mass under it) and the glacier parts of the antarctic that have no land mass under it, were to melt, there would be no rise in sea level, since displacement is pretty much almost constant. And I say almost cause with ice there is a higher percentage of air in frozen ice than in just water, so when ice melts, the air is released and it looses the amount displacement it was taking up, so actually ocean levels will actually go down.

Its the same if you fill a glass of water with ice, then with water. When the ice melts the cup does NOT overflow, the water level will actually be lower than it started, depending on how much air was trapped in the ice and gets released.

Basic science. The powers that be (the money people) behind the scientists think the populace are ignorant of the basic law of conversation of mass and fluid mechanics.

LOL

Put 5 ice cubes in a cup.
Fill that cup up to the brim with water
Let ice melt
Notice your cup has overflown!

wow....

Seeing as how liquid water CONDENSES (gets smaller) when it freezes, how can you say this at all?

This is easy 8th grade science. (at least when I was in 8th grade)
 
LOL

Put 5 ice cubes in a cup.
Fill that cup up to the brim with water
Let ice melt
Notice your cup has overflown!

wow....

Seeing as how liquid water CONDENSES (gets smaller) when it freezes, how can you say this at all?

This is easy 8th grade science. (at least when I was in 8th grade)

I completely messed this one up
 
Zarathustra[H];1037660743 said:
Thank you for making my prediction of human stupidity come true.

You're a little late on your prediction about that.



As for the climate change thing. Of course climate change happens and of course we're ruining the world. Are they related though? I say that because It does not mean humans are warming it or cooling it with their pollution. It could easily be just what the world has been doing normally for billions of years.

I believe we need more analysis before we jump into a conclusion for either side of this argument. Do we have to stop polluting the Earth, and now space too, of course!
But again, saying one side is true without enough dots to draw a line is naive.

Also, a government (or the UN) trying to implement a carbon tax when they're the biggest contributor to the pollution of the Earth is just plain evil. How about they stop dropping (nuclear) bombs (testing sites, enemies, etc), or letting the richest companies rape the planet, and make laws/tax breaks promoting green technology creation/implementation instead!

The oil sands are one of the newest biggest construction sites on the planet. It's killing the indigenous people of the surrounding land. Lets stop things like this first before trying to make the common Sapien pay for it all.
 
I'm not worried. God promised after the flood that the world wouldn't be destroyed again. The fact that we have rainbows proves this.
 
LOL

Put 5 ice cubes in a cup.
Fill that cup up to the brim with water
Let ice melt
Notice your cup has overflown!

wow....

Seeing as how liquid water CONDENSES (gets smaller) when it freezes, how can you say this at all?

This is easy 8th grade science. (at least when I was in 8th grade)


Actually, if you take a PET bottle, fill it to the brim, seal it and put it in the freezer. You'll find that the sides are bloated when it finally freezes. Often to the point that it flattened the concave at the bottom and it won't stand up straight anymore.

Likewise, if you leave the cap off, freeze the bottle, and then seal it and leave it on the kitchen table to melt. The bottle would collapse.

Water expanding allows it to displace more water than its initial weight, that's why it floats.
 
Actually, if you take a PET bottle, fill it to the brim, seal it and put it in the freezer. You'll find that the sides are bloated when it finally freezes. Often to the point that it flattened the concave at the bottom and it won't stand up straight anymore.

Likewise, if you leave the cap off, freeze the bottle, and then seal it and leave it on the kitchen table to melt. The bottle would collapse.

Water expanding allows it to displace more water than its initial weight, that's why it floats.

Partially agreed.

Yes, if you can force the ice under the surface of the water it will displace more water, but if it floats freely on the surface, it displaces its weight rather than its volume, and as such ought to displace the same amount of water as it would if it were not frozen.

The ice is taking a larger area than the water in the example above, but it is doing so by occupying the air over the surface of the glass. Its resultant overall lower density with the same mass allows it to float on the water.

Now, the reason this does not apply to global warming and sea level rises is simple. Not all ice floats freely on the surface. A lot is on land (Antarctica, Greenland, Siberia, Iceland to mention a few). other polar ice exists in places where the water is not that deep, so the ice actually rests on the sea bottom, meaning that it is not displacing as much water as it would if it were liquid.

If all the planets ice were in the form of floating ice bergs, then yes, we would not have to be that concerned about sea level rises. Problem is, it isn't

Vatnaj%C3%B6kull.jpeg


The above is Vatnajökull, Iceland's largest Glacier. 750 cubic MILES of ice, all sitting on land in Iceland

it can be quite pretty:

800px-Iceland_Grimsvoetn_1972-B.jpg


800px-VatnaJokull.jpg
 
God wills the ice to float.

God/Allah/Jehova/Krishna/The Boogeyman/the Easter Bunny/The Tooth Fairy/Santa/Ghosts/whatever.

All the same. Just pick the one you like best.

I seem to prefer Santa.

"In the beginning Santa created the heavens and the Earth..." :p
 
This is not true. Not for over 20 million years.
and how old is the planet? and what did i say about timescale?

I'm sure you have some proof of what you said, right? If not you are just making things up. In the short term (there is a drastic increase in CO2 and lower O2 in the last 150 years) and the long term (gradual increase over 20 million years) you are wrong.
 
Al Gore has the answer...:rolleyes:

Do you believe simply dropping Al Gores name completely negates the difference between weather and climate or climate change in general?

I guess we will have to come up with a new Godwins Law for Al Gore.
 
how come when something goes against "global warming" it comes with a disclaimer of "we don't completely understand climate change so this isn't necessarily a good thing!" but when it's in support of "global warming" it's further proof of something the infallible scientists already knew?
 
Zarathustra[H];1037661314 said:
God/Allah/Jehova/Krishna/The Boogeyman/the Easter Bunny/The Tooth Fairy/Santa/Ghosts/whatever.

All the same. Just pick the one you like best.

I seem to prefer Santa.

"In the beginning Santa created the heavens and the Earth..." :p

Blasphemy. Thou shall not show any other god before the almighty teapot.
 
First to those that say that with icebergs and the like that have ice above the water level, this is due to buoyancy of the ice due to trapped gases, it actually has little effect on the displacement. A pound of ice is a pound of ice, weather it floats or not. Regardless when the ice melts the gases escape into the air and the volume of air is equal in relation to the buoyancy. ALSO a little fact about icebergs and glaciers that are in water... there is MORE ice under the water than above. Seems everyone forgot about this basic fact about icebergs.

iceberg.jpg


The to the person that said "Seeing as how liquid water CONDENSES (gets smaller) when it freezes, how can you say this at all?"

Um because freezing is not CONDENSING, condensation is the change from a gas into liquid, the reverse of evaporation. And also when water freezes it EXPANDS not shrinks. This is one of the reasons freezing a person and reviving them is difficult cause the water in the cells expands as it freezes and actually explodes the cellular walls (And that is a conversation for another time, and just used as an example of ice expansion).

Then
 
First to those that say that with icebergs and the like that have ice above the water level, this is due to buoyancy of the ice due to trapped gases, it actually has little effect on the displacement. A pound of ice is a pound of ice, weather it floats or not. Regardless when the ice melts the gases escape into the air and the volume of air is equal in relation to the buoyancy. ALSO a little fact about icebergs and glaciers that are in water... there is MORE ice under the water than above. Seems everyone forgot about this basic fact about icebergs.

iceberg.jpg


The to the person that said "Seeing as how liquid water CONDENSES (gets smaller) when it freezes, how can you say this at all?"

Um because freezing is not CONDENSING, condensation is the change from a gas into liquid, the reverse of evaporation. And also when water freezes it EXPANDS not shrinks. This is one of the reasons freezing a person and reviving them is difficult cause the water in the cells expands as it freezes and actually explodes the cellular walls (And that is a conversation for another time, and just used as an example of ice expansion).

Then

The buoyancy of ice has little/nothing to do with trapped gases and almost everything to do with the crystalline structure of ice as compared to water.

When water freezes the crystalline structure of the ice makes the frozen water take up a larger volume. It still has the same molecular weight - however, so we wind up with something larger that still weighs the same.

Density = mass / volume

Something with a lower density will float ontop of something with a higher density. (this is the same reason why heat rises, and hot air balloons can fly)

Interestingly enough, the portion of the iceberg underneath the water is exactly the same size as the water in the iceberg would take up if it were not frozen.

In other words, the weight of the water in the ice will displace its mass in the water, regardless of whether or not it is frozen, as long as it is not fully submerged.

Here is a physics problem that illustrates this point nicely.

It's a confusing subject, which is why mistakes are made often.

Robert Oppenheimer, George Gamow, and Felix Bloch all famously got this problem wrong on the first try :p
 
Lets say you have a cubic foot of water. If it freezes, it expands to 1.1 cubic foot (guesstimate). It's that .1 that sticks above the water line.
 
The earths climate and geography has changed greatly over its >4 Billion year history.
Most, if not all, of us will be dead by the time this debate is over.
By then it will be too late for your great grandchildren to make any choices about it.
 
Isn't there land under the sound pole or something? I know the north pole could melt and nothing would happen, but the south would mess things up. But still...i've seen water world and know to grab the first shitty yacht and reems of HP paper. :D

Do you really not understand the difference between weather and climate?

Don't you dare bring reason to this. Don't you dare! The summer was hot too.
 
Do you believe simply dropping Al Gores name completely negates the difference between weather and climate or climate change in general?

I guess we will have to come up with a new Godwins Law for Al Gore.

He is the god of the wachos, and is totally nuts.
His name can be dropped, and hard.
 
Back
Top