Dead Space 2 - thoughts, opinions?

Unfortunately, it very much does matter. To the developers and publishers. And that's ALL that matters regardless of what any of us says. No amount of bullshit quasi karma or moral relativistic rubbish changes that fact. They don't share that vision and they don't agree with it and they sure as hell don't respond according to that rubbish.


So as we continue to see more Draconian DRM, increases prices, and ultimately less support for the PC in general...sadly, it does matter. Critically.

Again, the idea that pirates will magically see the error in their ways is illogical. PC games are still breaking sales records, as are movies and albums. It's BS, they know it's BS. People that pirate also buy, they buy games they normally would never have played. You're creating a vacuum where all pirates are bloodthirsty thieves and it's simply not the case.

The DRM you refer to has a 100% failure rate and punishes legit buyers, nobody forces them to put it on and the Witcher 2 will not have any. It's a choice, it's a middle finger from the industry and I'll be happy to return the favor. Think if people were stealing clothes at particular mall and the mall raised it's prices to compensate for it's losses and equipped the clothing with paint bombs that couldn't be removed and may or my not go off during the life clothing. You have to find a sane way to deal with the problem, not flawed technology that causes people to boycott and pirate even more. There are inherent complexities at work here, you can't simply look at it in black and white terms.

If it's not profitable, why are they still in business? It's a supply and demand industry, the DRM has 100% failure rate, the consumer gets punished and the developer (given a good product) gets record sales numbers. This doesn't add up. You've effectively polarized this issue, which people tend to do. I hate that I have to qualify this next part, but I'm not advocating for piracy and I'm also not advocating that people blindly support publishers and developers who rig their products to self destruct.
 
Last edited:
Well the piracy is wrong. I don't think it's justifiable under the circumstances. I hate the draconian DRM which fails most of the time and punishes legal purchasers of the software. Still I don't think that thievery is justifiable even in light of the shitty DRM.
 
Unfortunately, it very much does matter. To the developers and publishers. And that's ALL that matters regardless of what any of us says. No amount of bullshit quasi karma or moral relativistic rubbish changes that fact. They don't share that vision and they don't agree with it and they sure as hell don't respond according to that rubbish.


So as we continue to see more Draconian DRM, increases prices, and ultimately less support for the PC in general...sadly, it does matter. Critically.

Well put Sir
 
Well the piracy is wrong. I don't think it's justifiable under the circumstances. I hate the draconian DRM which fails most of the time and punishes legal purchasers of the software. Still I don't think that thievery is justifiable even in light of the shitty DRM.

Simple as that.
 
Additionally the "try before you buy" is nonsense. I've called bullshit on that in other threads and I'll call it here too. And before people start coming out of the wood work to talk about how they are the exception, and that they do it all the time, let me stop you now. I'll give some of you the benefit of the doubt and say that some of you may actually do that while the rest of you are simply lying your asses off. The people who truly do that are in the minority. But before getting on a high horse about your moral superiority, what you are doing is similar to stealing a Corvette during a test drive, driving it for a week and then suddenly deciding to pay full sticker price for it. It's bullshit and people don't do that. It's also illegal no matter what the circumstances are. Most people choose the path of least resistance. Most people will not suddenly elect to pay full price for something they are getting and using free without consequences.
 
Additionally the "try before you buy" is nonsense. I've called bullshit on that in other threads and I'll call it here too. And before people start coming out of the wood work to talk about how they are the exception, and that they do it all the time, let me stop you now. I'll give some of you the benefit of the doubt and say that some of you may actually do that while the rest of you are simply lying your asses off. The people who truly do that are in the minority. Before getting on a high horse about your moral superiority, what you are doing is similar to stealing a Corvette during a test drive, driving it for a week and then suddenly deciding to pay full sticker price for it. It's bullshit and people don't do that. It's also illegal no matter what the circumstances are. Most people choose the path of least resistance. Most people will not suddenly elect to pay full price for something they are getting and using free without consequences.

oscar.jpg
 
Unfortunately, it very much does matter. To the developers and publishers. And that's ALL that matters regardless of what any of us says. No amount of bullshit quasi karma or moral relativistic rubbish changes that fact. They don't share that vision and they don't agree with it and they sure as hell don't respond according to that rubbish.

No, in the context we're talking, it does not matter at all. Whether I borrowed from a friend, pirated it or gave me a copy, it's irrelevant, my objective opinion of the game is based on the merits and pitfalls of the game alone and nothing else.

If you're on some piracy rant then that has nothing to do with what I'm talking about, I'm merely explaining why what Wabe is saying doesn't make any sense. If you want to rant about piracy that's fine but I don't really see what it has to do with me, I did not say I pirated the game, I said that I played it for free.

Additionally the "try before you buy" is nonsense. I've called bullshit on that in other threads and I'll call it here too. And before people start coming out of the wood work to talk about how they are the exception, and that they do it all the time, let me stop you now. I'll give some of you the benefit of the doubt and say that some of you may actually do that while the rest of you are simply lying your asses off. The people who truly do that are in the minority.

What exactly are you basing that off? Do you have any solid data to back what you're saying?

The few studies done in this area pertaining to music piracy clearly showed that people who pirate music spend way more on legit music than the average consumer, why would that be any different for games?

Would a poll in the [H] forums that asked people to vote on whether they had pirated games or not be acceptable or would this break the [H] anit-piracy rules? I'd be happy to start one to try and determine some numbers on that, I'd love to see the results. Can polls be made private to encourage people to vote honestly?
 
Last edited:
I would guess that people who pirate games do not buy hardly anything they play. the main reason they steal is because they want to "try out" games. some of those games they deem not worthy even though they had no business being able to play in the first place. and that goes for games that even have a demo.
 
I've seen 6 posts on this page alone, not one of them addressed a SINGLE counter point that has been made. Instead, I've seen denial and false dilemmas, I've also seen people awarding trophies and not supporting their claims. I would like to have a conversation about this, but it's become almost political or religious in nature. You can't just ignore facts and give yourself a trophy.

Guys, I'm not advocating one way or another, but this is scary, I've come to expect more from [H] users. Before you get upset, I frequently enjoy reading posts from several of the people I'm responding to. I've already spent too much time on this, and I hope you guys will temper or moderate your opinions a little after you consider what a complex dynamic piracy is. It's literally an issue in it's infancy stages, it demands a discussion since it's a real issue for the developers and publishers and has no solution as of yet. Yes, it's wrong to take things and not pay for them, but it's generated a ton of awareness and revenue for certain products, a number of credible studies support this. I'm not sure I actually know anybody who has NEVER pirated anything, and you might be shocked to learn that people around you have engaged in this practice as well, it's not something people boast about.
 
Running it at 6180x1080 with bezel correction and it runs at what I assume is an engine limited 30 (but never dips below) FPS with all visual options on max. Having a good time so far but for some reason the menus in the beginning are a bit faded once I turned up the custom graphics. In game they are fine but that neural network or whatever at the beginning has some oddities.

As to the controls, they are much better than before and with my steelseries xai mouse I just hit the profile button and the souped up DPI makes it almost as quick as a quake game for aiming. It still seems that the X axis is more sensitive than the Y axis but maybe that is just me.

Gameplay has been kind of ho-hum so far for me - it isn't scary like the first time I played the first one. Which to be fair is to be expected. I did have one or two moments where I flinched at the sound effects of the things popping down behind me. Even though I was expecting it, the sound effects made me jump a bit. That is a plus. Overall we will have to see what happens as I progress still in Chapter 2.
 
Last edited:
Running it at 6180x1080 with bezel correction and it runs at what I assume is an engine limited 30 (but never dips below) FPS with all visual options on max. Having a good time so far but for some reason the menus in the beginning are a bit faded once I turned up the custom graphics. In game they are fine but that neural network or whatever at the beginning has some oddities.

As to the controls, they are much better than before and with my steelseries xai mouse I just hit the profile button and the souped up DPI makes it almost as quick as a quake game for aiming. It still seems that the X axis is more sensitive than the Y axis but maybe that is just me.

Gameplay has been kind of ho-hum so far for me - it isn't scary like the first time I played the first one. Which to be fair is to be expected. I did have one or two moments where I flinched at the sound effects of the things popping down behind me. Even though I was expecting it, the sound effects made me jump a bit. That is a plus. Overall we will have to see what happens as I progress still in Chapter 2.

I found that the first Dead Space made me feel tense during the early part, but that it wore off later on. Dead Space 2 seems to be the opposite of that.
 
Running it at 6180x1080 with bezel correction and it runs at what I assume is an engine limited 30 (but never dips below) FPS with all visual options on max. Having a good time so far but for some reason the menus in the beginning are a bit faded once I turned up the custom graphics. In game they are fine but that neural network or whatever at the beginning has some oddities.

As to the controls, they are much better than before and with my steelseries xai mouse I just hit the profile button and the souped up DPI makes it almost as quick as a quake game for aiming. It still seems that the X axis is more sensitive than the Y axis but maybe that is just me.

Gameplay has been kind of ho-hum so far for me - it isn't scary like the first time I played the first one. Which to be fair is to be expected. I did have one or two moments where I flinched at the sound effects of the things popping down behind me. Even though I was expecting it, the sound effects made me jump a bit. That is a plus. Overall we will have to see what happens as I progress still in Chapter 2.

I was a little concerned in the early goings but I felt like the game opened up a bit more after...a point you're not too far from. ;)

I still think this game is better than part 1 across the boards.
 
I like the game so far, but the space geek in me is raging. The first few levels are taking place in an manned colony on Saturn's moon Titan. The thing is, the surface of Titan is not a vacuum like outer space. The moon actually has a very dense atmosphere. Our hero wouldn't get sucked out in space, rather, he would instead get suffocated by the highly toxic air.

If your a space geek then you should know that if an airplane window at high altitude breaks people dont get sucked out either. Its the high pressure inside escaping and this can cause objects to be pulled out. Same can be said about the game. So it could be a heavily pressurized environment system to provide clean air and livible climate on the surface of Titan.
 
If your a space geek then you should know that if an airplane window at high altitude breaks people dont get sucked out either. Its the high pressure inside escaping and this can cause objects to be pulled out. Same can be said about the game. So it could be a heavily pressurized environment system to provide clean air and livible climate on the surface of Titan.

Planes are pressured at high altitudes due to the atmosphere being thinner at high altitudes.

The atmospheric pressure of Titan is 60% greater than earth's. It'd be like the air was as dense as being in a swimming pool. There's no way the pressure inside the base should be higher than the pressure outside the base. It'd be more like our hero would be pushed back in than sucked back out.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like a good title. But I won't be paying $60 to be a second-class citizen. I like SP DLC, particularly those two characters who are in it, since I played Extraction. Gimped content or gimped graphics...fuck EA for forcing this choice. I wonder if someone could make a legal argument that cutting off support post-release constitutes false advertising. Will pick it up on sale, I guess.
 
What exactly are you basing that off? Do you have any solid data to back what you're saying?

The few studies done in this area pertaining to music piracy clearly showed that people who pirate music spend way more on legit music than the average consumer, why would that be any different for games?

Would a poll in the [H] forums that asked people to vote on whether they had pirated games or not be acceptable or would this break the [H] anit-piracy rules? I'd be happy to start one to try and determine some numbers on that, I'd love to see the results. Can polls be made private to encourage people to vote honestly?

So the fact that people who pirate software tend to buy and acquire more software than others is an excuse for occasional piracy? I call that argument bullshit as that's what your argument really amounts to. I don't need data to understand human nature. The data in this case (assuming music and software data has any correlation) still doesn't excuse thievery.

The only thing I think we can agree on is that we are getting off topic.

If your a space geek then you should know that if an airplane window at high altitude breaks people dont get sucked out either. Its the high pressure inside escaping and this can cause objects to be pulled out. Same can be said about the game. So it could be a heavily pressurized environment system to provide clean air and livible climate on the surface of Titan.

Technically that's getting "blown out." Not "sucked out."
 
I found that the first Dead Space made me feel tense during the early part, but that it wore off later on. Dead Space 2 seems to be the opposite of that.

I think that could easily be attributed to the pacing of the game. In Dead Space, it went from a struggle to survive on a ship where the entire population had been decimated and torn to pieces to a situation where you're just like "hell, I'm stuck here, might as well wander around and do what we can to get off, and if we can't, oh well."
 
Additionally the "try before you buy" is nonsense. I've called bullshit on that in other threads and I'll call it here too. And before people start coming out of the wood work to talk about how they are the exception, and that they do it all the time, let me stop you now. I'll give some of you the benefit of the doubt and say that some of you may actually do that while the rest of you are simply lying your asses off. The people who truly do that are in the minority. But before getting on a high horse about your moral superiority, what you are doing is similar to stealing a Corvette during a test drive, driving it for a week and then suddenly deciding to pay full sticker price for it. It's bullshit and people don't do that. It's also illegal no matter what the circumstances are. Most people choose the path of least resistance. Most people will not suddenly elect to pay full price for something they are getting and using free without consequences.

While I agree with this I think the devs open themselves up to this argument.Look at the blatant"F PC gamers you aint getting a demo"stance that Epic took with Bulletstorm.I mean really,PCs are complex and a demo to see if a game runs on a particular rig imo is not too much to ask for.Just as its wrong for the"try before buy"thing,its even more wrong to plunk down hard earned cash for a game to find it does not work on your rig and having no recourse..
 
No, the end result is the same. Technically though, blown out and sucked out are different.
No, they are not different. It's a mass flow from a high pressure region to a low pressure region. Think about sucking liquid through a straw. What actually happens is that you create a low-pressure zone inside your mouth, and atmospheric pressure pushes the liquid through the straw and into your mouth to equalize the pressure.
 
Q-BZ, 8 hours seems pretty short compared to reviews saying its 12 hours. I have 8 hours right now but I am only just starting Chapter 8 so I am only half done. now I did spend close to an hour trying to deal with the horrible color banding but thats still nearly an hour a chapter it is taken me so far. I am guessing it should be about 13-14 hours of actual gameplay for me when I finish.

Yeah, I thought that was pretty short too. I played through the game at a normal pace (looked for all the power nodes, schematics, ammo, etc.) and finished the game right at 12 hours 4 mins. I'm on New Game+ now and I'm pretty much rushing through to show the story to my wife and I'm at Chapter 10 now with like 6 hours in the game (I think).

Anyways, the game certainly did not disappoint me. I got it for 360 this time though (have DS on PC and 360 both, heh). I did notice some slight color banding like someone else mentioned earlier in the thread, but I didn't think it was distracting or anything (playing it on my Asus 25.5" 1920x1200 monitor in 1080p and also played it on my 46" Sony XBR).

My favorite level was certainly re-visiting the Ishimura. Seeing what they did to it after 3 years was pretty cool and going through that huge, dark tunnel was intense! I don't know what it is about that ship, but it's very intriguing to me too. It's like the perfect setting for this game and games like it, IMO.

The ending was pretty insane (i.e. over the top), but I think it worked pretty well. I totally expected Isaac to die and was amazed to see Ellie come back for him, then have him Iron Man out of there, lol. I've read the reviews before the game and they made it seem like they left the end open like the first DS and were expecting a sequel. But I don't think they did. Though there's still plenty more pieces of the story they could add to or elaborate on, I think they could easily end it like they did in DS2.

PrincessFrosty, I know you're having probs getting DS to work on your PC. I'm not sure what your issue is (me and my friend didn't have any issues on our PCs), but I think it'd behoove you to figure it out if you like games of this genre. No, they don't bring anything new to the table in terms of new concepts or story telling, but I think the presentation of the story and the gameplay it brings with it definitely makes it worth playing. I would also try to play through it before you play through DS2. Yeah, there's a recap in DS2, but playing through the first one will definitely get you more into it, I think. Or you could just hate it anyways, but if you did, then you would be the exception among most people who have played these games.
 
While I agree with this I think the devs open themselves up to this argument.Look at the blatant"F PC gamers you aint getting a demo"stance that Epic took with Bulletstorm.I mean really,PCs are complex and a demo to see if a game runs on a particular rig imo is not too much to ask for.Just as its wrong for the"try before buy"thing,its even more wrong to plunk down hard earned cash for a game to find it does not work on your rig and having no recourse..

Honestly I think the reasons for a serious lack of PC game demos these days has more to do with the fact that a lot of games are crappy console ports which would lead to disappointment and back lash amongst the PC community at large. The developers may in fact conclude that a PC demo would hurt them more than it would help them. Without a demo there will always be people that will give the game a try and actually buy it sight unseen. With a demo a shitty game will certainly sell less copies.
 
Honestly I think the reasons for a serious lack of PC game demos these days has more to do with the fact that a lot of games are crappy console ports which would lead to disappointment and back lash amongst the PC community at large. The developers may in fact conclude that a PC demo would hurt them more than it would help them. Without a demo there will always be people that will give the game a try and actually buy it sight unseen. With a demo a shitty game will certainly sell less copies.

Precisely,but of course they want the money in their pockets and you can pound salt if youre not happy with it while they laugh on the way to the bank..So where does that leave the guy who "tries it"concludes its a shitty port,deletes it and doesnt waste his money on it..Can you really blame him?
 
Whoa, we get to keep all our stuff from the first time through. Yowsa!

That erases everything. I'm playing on Easy right now (chiefly because I suck at gaming, though I didn't used to), and was planning on playing again at the same difficulty setting... but in light of this news... well, I'll probably play on Normal, or even one above Normal.

I liked Resident Evil 5 for the same reason. You got to level up all your equipment and keep it with you each new time you played.
 
Whoa, we get to keep all our stuff from the first time through. Yowsa!

That erases everything. I'm playing on Easy right now (chiefly because I suck at gaming, though I didn't used to), and was planning on playing again at the same difficulty setting... but in light of this news... well, I'll probably play on Normal, or even one above Normal.

I liked Resident Evil 5 for the same reason. You got to level up all your equipment and keep it with you each new time you played.
yeah I am going to bump it up to normal on the next platythrough too since I will be quite powerful. plus if you screw up in this game I believe you still have the checkpoints on every difficulty level expect hardcore. I would have been super pissed having to go all the way back to an actual save over and over on a couple of parts.
 
Yeah, I thought that was pretty short too. I played through the game at a normal pace (looked for all the power nodes, schematics, ammo, etc.) and finished the game right at 12 hours 4 mins. I'm on New Game+ now and I'm pretty much rushing through to show the story to my wife and I'm at Chapter 10 now with like 6 hours in the game (I think).

Man, you guys are making me feel bad. ;) I'm wondering if I missed some things. Not sure how I got through it as fast as I did. I swear I didn't rush or anything! :)


My favorite level was certainly re-visiting the Ishimura. Seeing what they did to it after 3 years was pretty cool and going through that huge, dark tunnel was intense! I don't know what it is about that ship, but it's very intriguing to me too. It's like the perfect setting for this game and games like it, IMO.

The ending was pretty insane (i.e. over the top), but I think it worked pretty well. I totally expected Isaac to die and was amazed to see Ellie come back for him, then have him Iron Man out of there, lol. I've read the reviews before the game and they made it seem like they left the end open like the first DS and were expecting a sequel. But I don't think they did. Though there's still plenty more pieces of the story they could add to or elaborate on, I think they could easily end it like they did in DS2.

I definitely agree with all of that. My favorite part of the game.


I think if they make a part 3 they need to take everything to the next level and add a few new wrinkles to the gameplay and such.
 
Havent gotten into the game much because A) the fov is annoying, and B) I got jacked up graphics with my 4850. Its hard to explain, but there are lines up and down at random times. Anyone else? I have the newest drivers.

And for the love of God, why cant you use two movement buttons together. Such as forward and left, to go diagonal in that direction. Its one or the other. Almost wish I had gotten this on my PS3.

http://i52.tinypic.com/2nv5ipu.jpg
Good.

http://i52.tinypic.com/2hxrjfk.jpg
Bad.

You cant really tell because the pics are so small.
 
Whoa, we get to keep all our stuff from the first time through. Yowsa!

That erases everything. I'm playing on Easy right now (chiefly because I suck at gaming, though I didn't used to), and was planning on playing again at the same difficulty setting... but in light of this news... well, I'll probably play on Normal, or even one above Normal.

I liked Resident Evil 5 for the same reason. You got to level up all your equipment and keep it with you each new time you played.

I played through on Normal the first time and prolly died like 10-15 times (most were at the same spot like 4-5 times trying different things). I didn't ever think it was too hard. Now on my New Game+, I'm playing on Zealot (2nd hardest next to Hard Core mode) and with most of my weapons and suit maxed out, it's pretty much the same difficulty as playing on Normal. Since I kept all the ammo from my first game too, I haven't had an issue with that either. My stash is slowly dwindling, but I think I'll beat the game again without having to buy much ammo from the store, if any.

I'm definitely going to try Hard Core mode though, just so I can get the hand cannon! LOL "Bang bang! Pew pew!"
 
So the fact that people who pirate software tend to buy and acquire more software than others is an excuse for occasional piracy?

I'm not advocating anything, you stated in no uncertain terms that people who pirate only rarely end up buying games, I was simply asking you to demonstrate how you know that.

PrincessFrosty, I know you're having probs getting DS to work on your PC. I'm not sure what your issue is (me and my friend didn't have any issues on our PCs), but I think it'd behoove you to figure it out if you like games of this genre. No, they don't bring anything new to the table in terms of new concepts or story telling, but I think the presentation of the story and the gameplay it brings with it definitely makes it worth playing. I would also try to play through it before you play through DS2. Yeah, there's a recap in DS2, but playing through the first one will definitely get you more into it, I think. Or you could just hate it anyways, but if you did, then you would be the exception among most people who have played these games.

DS the original simply does not work for me, I've been through all their support steps and it still doesn't work, no sign of a refund yet either :(

If they'd not released such a shables of a first game and then refused to patch it to completion then we wouldn't even be having this debate, that's their own fault for treating customers like this.
 
Havent gotten into the game much because A) the fov is annoying, and B) I got jacked up graphics with my 4850. Its hard to explain, but there are lines up and down at random times. Anyone else? I have the newest drivers.

And for the love of God, why cant you use two movement buttons together. Such as forward and left, to go diagonal in that direction. Its one or the other. Almost wish I had gotten this on my PS3.

http://i52.tinypic.com/2nv5ipu.jpg
Good.

http://i52.tinypic.com/2hxrjfk.jpg
Bad.

You cant really tell because the pics are so small.
in that first pic that's the color banding I have been bitching about. I don't know why more people don't complain because its the worse I have ever seen in any game and quite distracting.
 
I'm not advocating anything, you stated in no uncertain terms that people who pirate only rarely end up buying games, I was simply asking you to demonstrate how you know that.



DS the original simply does not work for me, I've been through all their support steps and it still doesn't work, no sign of a refund yet either :(

If they'd not released such a shables of a first game and then refused to patch it to completion then we wouldn't even be having this debate, that's their own fault for treating customers like this.

Is it a prob with the 5970/ATI/AMD? Both me and my friend were playing it with GTX 285s.
 
Is it a prob with the 5970/ATI/AMD? Both me and my friend were playing it with GTX 285s.

I have no idea, I've tried everything, the steam support guy game back to me again and asked me to follow the EA customer support system and if that doesn't result in a fix then they will refund my steam wallet, which I presume means I won't actually get a refund but something I can redeem on steam to offset the cost of another game. It's something I suppose.

So now have to deal with EA, haha :eek:

I've tried everything, I work in IT professionally and I've been gaming for 15 years, build my own PC...done everything to get this working and nothing works. It's funny really because had I pirated Dead Space to try before I buy then I would have know it doesn't work and could have saved myself being ripped off. :mad:

It's what you get for being a legit customer I guess :(

*edit*

I've just found a thread saying the 10.5 drivers work better for the 5970 and that it still spazes out but you can get into game and play, I might have to settle for that...
 
Last edited:
Havent gotten into the game much because A) the fov is annoying, and B) I got jacked up graphics with my 4850. Its hard to explain, but there are lines up and down at random times. Anyone else? I have the newest drivers.

And for the love of God, why cant you use two movement buttons together. Such as forward and left, to go diagonal in that direction. Its one or the other. Almost wish I had gotten this on my PS3.

http://i52.tinypic.com/2nv5ipu.jpg
Good.

http://i52.tinypic.com/2hxrjfk.jpg
Bad.

You cant really tell because the pics are so small.
Do you have the in-game anti-aliasing enabled? I believe the DS games use shader-based AA, and since the graphical glitches appear to be happening around the edges of geometry, disabling that AA feature or perhaps changing your shader settings may help reduce or eliminate the problem.
 
Do you have the in-game anti-aliasing enabled? I believe the DS games use shader-based AA, and since the graphical glitches appear to be happening around the edges of geometry, disabling that AA feature or perhaps changing your shader settings may help reduce or eliminate the problem.
AA has nothing to do with the color banding.
 
Back
Top