Dead Space 2 - thoughts, opinions?

I agree with you. The DS games are fun but no question for me that Amnesia is far more original and effective.

I guarantee that this thing will unsettle and offer legit scares to anyone that takes it for a spin.

The thing I don't like about Amnesia is the whole idea that you can't fight back. The game should be called "Running and Hiding Like a Bitch."

Awesome setup. I thought my 3x24" looked good with Dead Space2 but that's awesome.

However, he's using a mouse and keyboard.. C'mon it's a 3rd person survival horror game. You're supposed to use an XBOX pad. Using a mouse? You might as well as the aliens to turn all the lights on, while you're at it... or maybe ask them politely to stop making scary noises as it makes you QQ.

I use a mouse and keyboard for all 3rd person games. I've been doing that since long before XBOX 360 controllers were an option on the PC platform. It's smoother, faster and far more responsive. My accuracy is better as well. I tried playing the first one with an XBOX 360 controller and didn't like it. It's effective enough, but it really doesn't provide any advantage over the mouse and keyboard and I don't even think it works as well.
 
I use KBM for everything except in cases like GTA IV when I want to fly a chopper or something like that.

Dan D. said:
The thing I don't like about Amnesia is the whole idea that you can't fight back. The game should be called "Running and Hiding Like a Bitch."

True.
 
Yeah but that's what survival horror IS. You can't have a guy with plasma cutters and flamethrowers and nuclear missiles and shit and call it survival horror.
 
there should be more trying to hide from enemies. stealth = win
 
there should be more trying to hide from enemies. stealth = win

Stealth is definitely an aspect I appreciate in any game that it's in. That would definitely add a nice dimension to this series. I'd like that and I'd like more exploring and incentive to do so. In other words, I'd love for part 3 to be a hybrid of what it is now combined with light RPG elements.
 
there should be more trying to hide from enemies. stealth = win

I'm not interested in stealth. I've never enjoyed it in any game it's ever been in that I've played. Or more to the point, I don't want it to be required. Ideally the game would be more open ended like the first halves of Far Cry and Crysis are. So if you like stealth and If that's your style than go for it. I can take tactical approaches to killing but when it comes down to it I'd rather kill all the bad guys. For me, it's always been next to impossible to pull off stealth. It seems you have to stand on a precise set of pixels or it doesn't work. It's always been a frustrating game mechanic for me.
 
I'm not interested in stealth. I've never enjoyed it in any game it's ever been in that I've played. Or more to the point, I don't want it to be required. Ideally the game would be more open ended like the first halves of Far Cry and Crysis are. So if you like stealth and If that's your style than go for it. I can take tactical approaches to killing but when it comes down to it I'd rather kill all the bad guys. For me, it's always been next to impossible to pull off stealth. It seems you have to stand on a precise set of pixels or it doesn't work. It's always been a frustrating game mechanic for me.

I get what you're saying. Put like that I agree with you. The key word is "implementation." You're right. Most of the time, stealth implemenation has flat out been bad.

A recent game where I thought stealth was done well was Splinter Cell Conviction. It can be done.

Obviously that's a completely different kind of game than a wide open slasher like the Dead Space games. ;)
 
I get what you're saying. Put like that I agree with you. The key word is "implementation." You're right. Most of the time, stealth implemenation has flat out been bad.

A recent game where I thought stealth was done well was Splinter Cell Conviction. It can be done.

Obviously that's a completely different kind of game than a wide open slasher like the Dead Space games. ;)

Partly the game mechanic requires precision that's contrary to logic. For example in the CoD games I can't hide from the enemy in places where I'm not in their line of sight or in the dark where the helicopters couldn't possibly see me. You have to hide and move precisely the way the game wants you to which often doesn't make sense. About the only time I've ever been able to pull off stealth in any game was in Call of Duty 4 Modern Warfare during the Chernobyl level. Any other time it's simply frustrated me. The only way I've made it through games that often feature it is simply by killing all the bad guys. In games where that's not really possible I get stuck and frustrated to the point where I can't finish the game. In others where it's possible, I end up having a hard time because the game seems to punish your lack of stealth skills. Still if it's possible to kill the bad guys and make it through, I will.
 
The thing I don't like about Amnesia is the whole idea that you can't fight back. The game should be called "Running and Hiding Like a Bitch."

Well in that case DS2 should be called "Use Insane Weapons To Blowing the Living Shit Out Of Monsters + Now With More Monster Closets"

DS is a great game from what I have seen, but its not survival horror.
 
The thing I don't like about Amnesia is the whole idea that you can't fight back. The game should be called "Running and Hiding Like a Bitch."



I use a mouse and keyboard for all 3rd person games. I've been doing that since long before XBOX 360 controllers were an option on the PC platform. It's smoother, faster and far more responsive. My accuracy is better as well. I tried playing the first one with an XBOX 360 controller and didn't like it. It's effective enough, but it really doesn't provide any advantage over the mouse and keyboard and I don't even think it works as well.

Completely agree with the "run and hide like a bitch" aspect to Amnesia, I watched some videos and decided it wasn't for me, but it's good to see indie titles having success. I don't need to fight back all the time, there are ways of establishing a balance. For instance, on the harder levels of DS2 or Metro 2033 ammo becomes a little more scarce and in DS2 I've actually run out of ammo and had to fight hand to hand or use kinesis to win, which creates a sense of survival. Hell, I'd run and hide if I could, but the game requires me to eliminate enemies to advance.
 
concerning vsync. enabling it in the game would make my whole rig crap out and hard-lock after about 30 to 45 minutes of playing. truning it off fixed this, but now i have to deal with some awful tearing.

anyway.

game was fun, although not as creepy as the first one. and it gets better as you progress. plus there are some good lulz to be had.

when riding the tram to some sector or other, isaac and ellie are chatting. the conversation goes something like this:

isaac: i'm on my way now.
ellie: ok, i'll wait for you there. the necromorphs seem to be coming through a hole in the med bay. good thing you don't have to go through there.

*train shudders and stops*

PA system: unexpected obstruction ahead. diverting to nearest station. welcome to the medical sector.

isaac: :mad:

me: :D

only complaint i have are some situations where the game just mindlessly spams you with enemies for no reason. god i hate that.
surely you know that you can turn on vsync form your Nvidia control panel?
 
I get what you're saying. Put like that I agree with you. The key word is "implementation." You're right. Most of the time, stealth implemenation has flat out been bad.

A recent game where I thought stealth was done well was Splinter Cell Conviction. It can be done.

Obviously that's a completely different kind of game than a wide open slasher like the Dead Space games. ;)

Oh no way, you liked Conviction too - we must have been the only two people on the planet.
 
Well in that case DS2 should be called "Use Insane Weapons To Blowing the Living Shit Out Of Monsters + Now With More Monster Closets"

DS is a great game from what I have seen, but its not survival horror.

Yeah but that's what survival horror IS. You can't have a guy with plasma cutters and flamethrowers and nuclear missiles and shit and call it survival horror.

Oh so people struggling to survive can't actually fight back or it's no longer survival?

I think several people posting in this thread have some basic comprehension issues. :rolleyes:

Survival

"Survival is the struggle to remain alive and living."

The game is full of gross and horrifying looking things. It presents them in a suspenseful and some times "scary" manner. The visuals and style of the presentation are very much in line with the horror genre. You are constantly struggling to stay alive by fighting various horrible creatures and traversing an extremely hostile environment. You constantly have to search for supplies and resources to ensure your survival. This requires exploring the environment which is by it's very nature, dangerous. If this isn't survival horror I don't know what is.
 
I disagree. Survival is just that: survival. When you hear about a holocaust or rape survivor, do you think of someone who ran away, escaped, and lived through an event, or someone who whipped out a line gun and mowed down rows of enemies?

What I love about Amnesia, conceptually, is not just that it is true survival, but that it offers a measure of verisimilitude. If you so much as look at a monster, you start to lose your "sanity" - so you have to be afraid to look at monsters ( go insane) and be afraid to not look at them (get killed).

It's brilliant.
 
DS is a great game from what I have seen, but its not survival horror.
Why? It has limited ammunition, limited health, spartan saves, a horror setting... what else does a game need to be survival horror?
 
This game seems to tax my cards more than DS1. I could run DS1 in 2D Surround with a constant 60+ fps @ 5960x1200, while in DS2 it's more like 35-50 fps (depending on the room up to 85 fps). There is no lag though. The nice thing is that my cards are literally up to 85-99% usage in Tri-SLI. I guess the extra video options are really showing their potential there.
 
Last edited:
"Survival is the struggle to remain alive and living."

The game is full of gross and horrifying looking things. It presents them in a suspenseful and some times "scary" manner. The visuals and style of the presentation are very much in line with the horror genre. You are constantly struggling to stay alive by fighting various horrible creatures and traversing an extremely hostile environment. You constantly have to search for supplies and resources to ensure your survival. This requires exploring the environment which is by it's very nature, dangerous. If this isn't survival horror I don't know what is.


This definition also applies to titles like Super Mario RPG. You could claim pretty much anything more hardcore than Kirby's Epic Yarn (you can't die) is a survival game based on this.
 
I disagree. Survival is just that: survival. When you hear about a holocaust or rape survivor, do you think of someone who ran away, escaped, and lived through an event, or someone who whipped out a line gun and mowed down rows of enemies?

That's bullshit. The fact that someone actually had a chance to or chose to fight back doesn't negate the fact that someone survived an incident which could very well have easily resulted in their deaths. Let me see if I understand this correctly. By your definition people who have fought in combat and even wounded aren't survivors of war because they had M16's and shit and fired back at the enemy? Is a rape victim not a survivor because she fought off a guy who was trying to kill her after raping her or vice versa? If someone breaks into your home and you exchange gun fire, you aren't a survivor if you were victorious?

I think I've got it now. Thank you for your explanation. :rolleyes:

This definition also applies to titles like Super Mario RPG. You could claim pretty much anything more hardcore than Kirby's Epic Yarn (you can't die) is a survival game based on this.

Indeed. Any situation that could result in your death would by definition make you a survivor if you didn't die and made it all the way through the ordeal. In games this is no less true. I don't think that people tend to think of games as being survival oriented because they are either too easy or we don't concentrate on the aspect of survival because we are more concerned about the action in the game, the story, or whatever else that entertains us so much.
 
Survival horror as a genre is hard to peg down. You could argue it was invented by Sweet Home which is basically an RPG that lets characters die permanently. A lot of PC die hards will point to Alone in the Dark as the first true survival horror. I think most people agree the game that put it on the map is Resident Evil.

But then you also have stuff like Siren, Clock Tower, Silent Hill, even Amnesia which I would classify as maybe post modern survival horror.

Who can say what exactly a survival horror game needs to have. Personally I think my list a couple posts up covers most of the high points.

The setting should be horror focused. Resources like health and ammo should be limited and non-renewable (ie- you don't get all your HP back at save points.) I think those two things are survival horror at its core. They address both aspects of the name.
 
In Dead Space, health and ammunition are indeed limited. You either need to explore enough to find what you need or you need to find enough money to buy what you need.
 
That's bullshit. The fact that someone actually had a chance to or chose to fight back doesn't negate the fact that someone survived an incident which could very well have easily resulted in their deaths. Let me see if I understand this correctly. By your definition people who have fought in combat and even wounded aren't survivors of war because they had M16's and shit and fired back at the enemy? Is a rape victim not a survivor because she fought off a guy who was trying to kill her after raping her or vice versa? If someone breaks into your home and you exchange gun fire, you aren't a survivor if you were victorious?

I think I've got it now. Thank you for your explanation. :rolleyes:

Yes, in addition to surviving, you can do 200 jumping jacks or kill 200 monsters with a linegun, but those are not basic elements of survival or part of the definition. They are modifiers, which is why DS is called "survival action" and such.

Amnesia is "survival", period.

No one says that just because you do something in addition to surviving that survival is not involved, so don't play with words.

The point is that Amnesia is survival distilled to its essence where Dead Space is survival larded with a lot of action and gore.

One simple example of this distinction in real-life is that if you "merely" survive an event, you are called a survivor. But if you fight back in the manner you described, you are often also called a "hero," because you went above and beyond surviving and actively resisted.
 
Last edited:
In Dead Space, health and ammunition are indeed limited. You either need to explore enough to find what you need or you need to find enough money to buy what you need.
maybe on the harder levels but on normal and easy there is so much health and ammunition that there is very little survival feel. at stores I end up just selling tons of ammo and health packs. even without exploring there would be no way to run out of ammo or health on easy or normal. and yes I am terrible at games so harder settings would just be frustrating for me.
 
maybe on the harder levels but on normal and easy there is so much health and ammunition that there is very little survival feel. at stores I end up just selling tons of ammo and health packs. even without exploring there would be no way to run out of ammo or health on easy or normal. and yes I am terrible at games so harder settings would just be frustrating for me.

Well I'm not very far into the second game. From what I've seen thus far ammunition is relatively plentiful but I've run out of ammunition once or twice. I'm only playing on the normal difficulty. The first game had a few parts where I ran out of ammunition quite often and I nearly went bankrupt in the game buying ammunition and health packs.
 
I disagree. Survival is just that: survival. When you hear about a holocaust or rape survivor, do you think of someone who ran away, escaped, and lived through an event, or someone who whipped out a line gun and mowed down rows of enemies?

Wow, what the hell?

What I love about Amnesia, conceptually, is not just that it is true survival, but that it offers a measure of verisimilitude. If you so much as look at a monster, you start to lose your "sanity" - so you have to be afraid to look at monsters ( go insane) and be afraid to not look at them (get killed).

It's brilliant.

It is brilliant but it has its own flaws. It's also completely different from either Dead Space game in just about every aspect you could name.
 
Man I started this last night, I can't figure out how to even get through the first part....everytime I walk through that one doorway, that creature sitting in the wheelchair gets me.....spent 20 minutes or so trying it over and over and can't get past him.......of course I'm missing something, but I didn't take the time to figure it out. The game looks amazing maxed out, very happy with my performance, and its the creepiest game I've played since Doom3....but damn its hard already and I've only played 30 seconds of it LOL.....

This is a bug on the developers part, there is supposed to be a float "E" key HUD element floating around the screen to indicate that you have to mash E in order to survive, it's basically a quicktime event but they're too stupid to tell you what key to press :rolleyes:

it is in fact the first real interaction you have with the game and it's just flat out broken, I had the same experience where I did that first section about 7 times in a row, the section at the start actually had the real possibility of being genuinely terrifying since you're basically trapped stumbling about, but they completely messed it up. It's scary for 10 seconds then you die 5+ times in a row and it's just like a comedy really, you're kind of just laughing at it because it's just so retarded, eventually you work it out and you can't take the game seriously anymore.

The fact that this slipped through beta testing is quite embarrassing.

The thing I don't like about Amnesia is the whole idea that you can't fight back. The game should be called "Running and Hiding Like a Bitch."

Yes, amnesia is a real survival horror, you're not rambo with super magneto shields and miniguns that fire mini tactical nuke bullets. Dead Space is hard to take seriously as a horror, as I've pointed out almost 100% of the scares are cliche and so if you've played more than about 3 horror games or seen a horror movie ever then you can probably predict every scare.

But on top of that it suffers from the fact that if you're even slightly competent at video games then it's a cakewalk because the gameplay is so mind numbingly simple.

Enemy with arms on the side = turn pistol to vertical to cut off limbs
Enemy with limbs on top = turn pistol to horizontal to cut off limbs
Lots of little enemies = use the rapid fire machine gun
Big slow enemies = use mines
Fast enemies = use slow mo on them and do whatever

If you're a good shot the enemies go from being scary for the first time, to being predictable and easy to kill after about 3 encounters, the standard mutant human ones just have a tripple shot, one to the chest to stumble them, one on the left arm, one on the right arm, and maybe one when they drop to the ground to gurantee they're dead and release their ammo/health. They're not so much scary more like kind of awkwardly wobbling idiots who are disposed of easily.

Up until chapter 6 where I stopped playing last, I was leaving behind 75% of all of the goodies because I couldn't carry it all.

I'm not interested in stealth. I've never enjoyed it in any game it's ever been in that I've played.

Stealth is rarely done well, the Thief games did it near perfectly though it was exhilarating having the guards chase you down and search for you in pitch black rooms and be practically sticking their nose in your eye as they leaned in to try and see you. With any luck Thief 4 wont be completely shit, then again the working name is Thi4f so

Why? It has limited ammunition, limited health, spartan saves, a horror setting... what else does a game need to be survival horror?

Saves are pretty frequently, I'm tripping over health and ammo. I feel like a tank trundling through the linear corridors just blasting the enemies to pieces with my heavy machinery.

Who can say what exactly a survival horror game needs to have. Personally I think my list a couple posts up covers most of the high points.

I think a genre with "horror" in the name should be scary, fundamentally that's why we play horror games and watch horror movies. I don't think arming the player to the teeth is a particularly good mechanic for scaring people unless done in some very specific scenarios like for example FEAR where the supernatural elements actually made your weapons kind of useless, which if anything made it more scary. In DS2 the supernatural stuff isn't really aggressive, you see visions and stuff but they're kind of passive. When you're being pinned by Alma in FEAR 2, that's some scary shit.
 
Yeah but the trouble with the FEAR games is that you know the Alma can do nothing to hurt you. Every scene in which she appears is just a scare tactic with no consequences. They're basically just in-game cutscenes.
 
Yeah but the trouble with the FEAR games is that you know the Alma can do nothing to hurt you. Every scene in which she appears is just a scare tactic with no consequences. They're basically just in-game cutscenes.

I just played FEAR for the first time, and I only died twice.

Once a truck hit me (thought maybe I could jump over it), the other time was Alma.

I ran to her, not knowing I was supposed to shoot her and try to kill her, and yes, she killed me.
 
Yeah but the trouble with the FEAR games is that you know the Alma can do nothing to hurt you. Every scene in which she appears is just a scare tactic with no consequences. They're basically just in-game cutscenes.

same thing with the girlfriend scenes.

I was like hi bitch, could you keep it down, im trying to play here... kthx
edit

not a plot spoiler... but

remember when you first saw the exploding babies? and the windows was covered, reminded me of the pizza pop commercials. someone needs to do a ds2 / pizza pop mashup.
 
Last edited:
This is a bug on the developers part, there is supposed to be a float "E" key HUD element floating around the screen to indicate that you have to mash E in order to survive, it's basically a quicktime event but they're too stupid to tell you what key to press

I'm confused....in my game, the full retail DVD set with two DVDs that I bought at Walmart......in that initial scene I had a big fat [F] floating across my screen telling me to mash the "F" key to escape. (I use the F key on my Z-Board for interactions)

I like the game. Yes it is somewhat of a "corridor shooter" and yes, it's a bit like Doom3.
After a while you figure out what's what........but the variety of how those enemies are used makes it interesting.
I think the necromorphs that peek around corners and tease you before finally charging are brilliantly designed.
 
I'm confused....in my game, the full retail DVD set with two DVDs that I bought at Walmart......in that initial scene I had a big fat [F] floating across my screen telling me to mash the "F" key to escape. (I use the F key on my Z-Board for interactions)

I like the game. Yes it is somewhat of a "corridor shooter" and yes, it's a bit like Doom3.
After a while you figure out what's what........but the variety of how those enemies are used makes it interesting.
I think the necromorphs that peek around corners and tease you before finally charging are brilliantly designed.
I seriously doubt you have some version of the game where it tells you to push F instead of E. ALL versions should say E so you either changed the key layout in the settings or you are having trouble seeing, lol. and btw I also have the retail version and it certainly says E.
 
I'm confused....in my game, the full retail DVD set with two DVDs that I bought at Walmart......in that initial scene I had a big fat [F] floating across my screen telling me to mash the "F" key to escape. (I use the F key on my Z-Board for interactions)

I like the game. Yes it is somewhat of a "corridor shooter" and yes, it's a bit like Doom3.
After a while you figure out what's what........but the variety of how those enemies are used makes it interesting.
I think the necromorphs that peek around corners and tease you before finally charging are brilliantly designed.

I think Dead Space is closer to what id wanted Doom 3 to be. Ultimately Doom 3 never had the atmosphere, or the creepiness that Dead Space has.Doom 3 had better controls but that's about it.
 
Oh no way, you liked Conviction too - we must have been the only two people on the planet.
I liked it as well, although it was not nearly as good as the first three games in the series (especially Chaos Theory).
I seriously doubt you have some version of the game where it tells you to push F instead of E. ALL versions should say E so you either changed the key layout in the settings or you are having trouble seeing, lol. and btw I also have the retail version and it certainly says E.
He said he uses the F key instead of E for interactions. So, yes, he did change his key bindings.
 
Oh no way, you liked Conviction too - we must have been the only two people on the planet.

Loved it. I still mess around in Deniable Ops. I wish they'd add more.


I think Dead Space is closer to what id wanted Doom 3 to be. Ultimately Doom 3 never had the atmosphere, or the creepiness that Dead Space has.Doom 3 had better controls but that's about it.

I hadn't thought about Doom 3 compared to this too much but I absolutely agree with you here.

If I could have Doom 3 controls (FPS and such) with DS's atmosphere and such...wow, that's a kick ass game right there. Taking nothing away from the DS series as is of course.
 
Doom 3 was such a disappointment all around. I will hold my tongue on RAGE until I see it, but as far as I'm concerned id Software lost its touch a long time ago.
 
I liked it as well, although it was not nearly as good as the first three games in the series (especially Chaos Theory).

He said he uses the F key instead of E for interactions. So, yes, he did change his key bindings.
then what is he confused about???
 
Have any of you had the problem with Save Stations not saving your games?
 
Back
Top