Microsoft to Allow Windows XP Downgrades Until 2020

well its obvious why theyre doing it. Sure the regular end user, gamer, or IT dude is going to have windows 7. But lots of corporations that don't depend on up-to-date operating systems will be sticking with XP. Why spend the money on new operating systems when you dont have to. Plus some of these machines are so old that upgrading them all to even run windows 7 smoothly would be a disaster.

In the end, it comes down to money, and some companies will NOT shell it out.

I don't think i even know of a large company that has moved up from XP.
 
The problem is that the Windows product cycle was too long after XP. Organizations became complacent. They used to deploy a new OS every 3 years, now they want to use the same OS for going on 20 years? That borders on the insane. Windows XP is a great OS, but the longer they put off transitioning, the worse it's going to be in the end.
 
it has created too many whiney bitches like you complaining about how shitty vista is blah blah wah wah. shut the fuck up and move on or stick to the past but shut the fuck up either way. vista is better than xp not initially but at this point in time yes. stop being a dickhead and chill the fuck out. xp needs to die, progression needs to progress.

I'm tring to understand why I am being called names all of a sudden when I was trying to analyze XP on it's merits.

All I was saying was, I would prefer using Win 7,but basedon the differences, do I really need it over XP? No. Begrudgingly, no. If I could answer this question yes, then I'd have something to go to IT with and make my case.
 
If you have another operating system, why fill up a harddrive with old junk? The reason those programs don't support XP is because they were made in the last few years, and are 64bit only. So no XP, even 64XP because it was done weirdly, with little to no driver support. Also XP lacks things like RAM management. It's not less than 4gb for 32bit OS's. It's 4gb - VRAM. Install 3 GTX480s on windows XP and youll have -512mb of ram. If I blew the dust off my XP disk and installed it now on this system (after the problems of it not supporting SATA and SLI untill SP2 has on install) i'd have 640mb of ram. Oh apart from I couldn't because.
Why, when I have no real need to. Majority of programs are still 32 bit. Everything I use is 32 bit. I don't use multi-gpu setups. Only seen crap games that are DX10/11 only. XP also has memory management. It's not as good as something like Windows 7, but it has it. They all have it. 4 gb memory? Who cares. If I wanted more, I would have already installed Win2k3 Enterprise a long time ago.

XP is old. The sooner people get rid of it then the sooner everyone else can move on and software engineers will have to spend less time updating old junk, and making new junk for old junk. After 9 years, it's about time you moved on.

The thing is...why? Not everyone needs the latest. Not everyone cares to have the latest. Nothing I do requires me to have Vista or 7. I own two copies of Win 7 Pro and Win 7 Home Premium. I have yet to see it do anything differently than WinXP Pro, except annoy me with it's stupid GUI.

I haven't tried loading WinXP on my tablet yet, just to see how that goes. Right now it's got Win 7 Home Premium a 7200rpm hdd and Win 7 Pro on a 5400 rpm hdd. Was gonna get a 1 TB 5400 rpm hdd for it and load XP on it. See how it handles. Want to see how well they power manage. Only real thing I care about in my tablet. Longer battery life.

Anyway, IE7 Had tabs, IE8 had porn mode and 64bit, IE9 has HTML 5 and SVGs...

Man, I hope the 99.9% of websites not using it will start using it. But hey, there's always Firefox, Opera, Safari, or whatever else happens to run on XP and support those.
 
by the way, can anyone here say something bad about XP? other than it's old?

good point. I prefer 7 but don’t hate XP, I use it every day at work. no reason to go for 7 thier. only reason might be indexing but even if the company upgraded to 7 I would turn it off because it’ll slow my old Pentium 4/1GB RAM machine.
 
I absolutely hate using XP now. The interface is ancient. The new hot keys alone make 7 worth the price of admission for me.
I'm of the opposing view; I hate the mac-like look of 7. I hate the dock. I hate that they've hidden the all users desktop in both Vista and 7 so that you have to unhide it to place things in the all users desktop.
 
well its obvious why theyre doing it. Sure the regular end user, gamer, or IT dude is going to have windows 7. But lots of corporations that don't depend on up-to-date operating systems will be sticking with XP. Why spend the money on new operating systems when you dont have to. Plus some of these machines are so old that upgrading them all to even run windows 7 smoothly would be a disaster.

In the end, it comes down to money, and some companies will NOT shell it out.

I don't think i even know of a large company that has moved up from XP.

It really doesn't have anything to do with the cost of the new OS. Most companies buy computers (usually Dell) that cone with an OS lice se included. They keep the computer until the service co tract runs out (2-3 years depending on the plan) and then usually replace it. In most cases corporate IT departments are paying extra to get XP overanything newer or just installing XP based on their volume license on the machines and not using the included paid for OS.

My new work laptop I just got yesterday has a windows 7 pro key sticker on the bottom, but by the time I got it it had already bee. Replaced with the standard corporate XP hd image with IE6.

It has more to do with not wanting to spend the time and effort trying out legacy applications on new OS's and potentially opening pandoras box on the network if any work needs to be done to make sure a win7 box works.

For you and I, it's not a big deal, we can fix things or use an alternative program, but for a business they have a procedure that says to use program x for task x, and changing this is time consuming and costly. Any downtime is also unacceptable, cause then you have people not working and costing money.

Essentially the feeling is, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Problem is I'd argue that it is broken. Corporate firewalls or not, XP's antiquated security philosophy coupled with using IE6 (the browser with more holes than Swiss cheese) HAS to be a significant issue...
 
stealthy123 said:
by the way, can anyone here say something bad about XP? other than it's old?

Thread pool sucks
Memory management sucks
Power management sucks
Security sucks

Can we assume you're using XP32?

Memory limit sucks
Security sucks even more
 
I think Redmond is looking at economic conditions down the road and adjusting appropriately.

Ya, it's called multiple versions of Windows with different pricing schemes. It's something that I just found out with Win7.

I use multiple languages on my comp and needless to say. Win7 Pro just happens to not support that. WinXP Pro did without any problems. I gained a bunch of features I don't even use, while losing ones that I do. I have to get Win7 Ultimate to access that one feature. But hey, I gain more features that I won't use.

I'm of the opposing view; I hate the mac-like look of 7. I hate the dock. I hate that they've hidden the all users desktop in both Vista and 7 so that you have to unhide it to place things in the all users desktop.

I'm with you. I hate the Win 7 look. I hate the stupid start menu too. If I want the classic start menu, I have to run another piece of software just for that. Why they don't just include the freaking option, I'll never know.

Zarathustra[H];1035943601 said:
It has more to do with not wanting to spend the time and effort trying out legacy applications on new OS's and potentially opening pandoras box on the network if any work needs to be done to make sure a win7 box works.

For you and I, it's not a big deal, we can fix things or use an alternative program, but for a business they have a procedure that says to use program x for task x, and changing this is time consuming and costly. Any downtime is also unacceptable, cause then you have people not working and costing money.

Essentially the feeling is, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.

Problem is I'd argue that it is broken. Corporate firewalls or not, XP's antiquated security philosophy coupled with using IE6 (the browser with more holes than Swiss cheese) HAS to be a significant issue...

I hate whenever a new patch comes out, let alone a whole new OS. We spend a full week testing out new patches, then we dump it on the IT groups machines and have them test it out. Then we push it to the actual users in batches. Each batch gets to stew with the patches for a day, before we move on to the next batch.

New OS. You're kidding. We finally got Horace V. It's a weather program developed by the UK Meteorlogical Office. It barely works on WinXP and doesn't at all on Vista, let alone 7. The prior version ran on HP Unix. We get a new version about every month that fixes missing features or broken features.

Money? Pffff. We were buying old HP machines that cost $5000 to keep using the old Horace. We are talking like 1995 technology. The only reason for the switch, was HP wasn't going to make those workstations anymore.

I no longer work there though. Now I'm working on Solaris boxes. Which is also old. Some crappy Sun Blade 1000s. We also have some Sun Blade 2000s. Using them to run our imagery software. They're developing some Windows versions and have been for a couple years. Still isn't ready to be tested on a larger scale. Probably won't for a few more years.

Our standard work computers are using Vista. Swapped to them about 3-4 months ago. I really wish they didn't. Vista is too much of a resource hog. Can't install Vista on 64 megs of memory? Sure you can't. These ppl apparently have never imaged a machine.
 
Our standard work computers are using Vista. Swapped to them about 3-4 months ago. I really wish they didn't. Vista is too much of a resource hog. Can't install Vista on 64 megs of memory? Sure you can't. These ppl apparently have never imaged a machine.

Will XP SP3 run on 64 megs these days? It certainly runs slow on 512 megs these days. Every service pack seems to incrementally increase the RAM requirements.
 
Zarathustra[H];1035943724 said:
Will XP SP3 run on 64 megs these days? It certainly runs slow on 512 megs these days. Every service pack seems to incrementally increase the RAM requirements.

Oh, it'll run. That's what virtual memory is for. Just expect it to run extremely slow. Also, expect your hdd to fail a lot sooner too. I'm not saying my current work machine has only 64 megs in it, just saying it's possible. My current machine at work has 2 gb. It needs it too, to run all the crap they have in the background. Stupid McAfee, background scripts, and god knows what else. It's a 2.4 ghz C2D that happens to run like a 1 ghz P3. It's awesome.

I've actually tested 98SE, Me, WinNT 4.0, Win2k, WinXP, Vista, and Win7 on my old laptop. A Dell Inspiron 5000e with 256 megs of memory. Needless to say, past Win2k, everything on it runs extremely horribly. You can get XP to run better by turning off all the GUI pretty features and shutting down services. Vista has no hope, it's horrendous. Win7 is better, but not much better than Vista. They might support the latest and greatest, but not so much the old.
 
But really, who actually cares about running anything on 256mb or RAM these days?

When I was upgrading systems from XP SP1 to SP2 6+ years ago, 256 was rare and upgrading those ones was painful as the install took hours.
 
There's few kernel changes.
:rolleyes: Very well, then:
Kernel Enhancements for Windows XP

Introduction
The information in this article applies for the Windows XP and Windows Server 2003 operating systems. Where any reference states "Windows XP," the information also applies for Windows Server 2003, unless differences are stated explicitly.
Microsoft has made substantial enhancements to the kernel at the core of Windows XP. Kernel improvements are significant because the kernel provides low-level operating system functions, including thread scheduling, interrupt and exception dispatching, multiprocessor synchronization, and a set of routines and basic objects used by the rest of the operating system to implement higher-level constructs.
This article describes the kernel improvements for Windows XP, which include:
•
Registry Larger registries, limited only by available system disk space. Improved algorithms for faster queries.
•
Support Enhancements Cross-session debugging, new quit and detach command for debugging without killing the application, and built-in user mode heap-leak detection.
•
I/O Subsystem New input/output (I/O) interfaces for performance enhancement, while retaining compatibility with Windows 2000 drivers. File System Filter driver application programming interface (API) improvements. Support for performance measurements in retail code, and improved low-memory performance.
•
Memory Management Broad range of improvements, including logical prefetch to improve boot and logon performance, reduced paged pool usage, enhanced terminal server support, support of giant drivers, and Windows XP execution from ROM.
•
Power Management Native support for processor performance control such including Intel SpeedStep Technology, AMD PowerNow!, and Transmeta LongRun for longer mobile PC battery life. Hibernate, standby, and resume performance have been greatly improved.
•
Improved Boot and Logon Performance When a Windows XP-based system is first booted, data is saved about all logical disk read operations. On later boots, this information is used to pre-fetch these files in parallel with other boot operations.
•
Headless Support For "lights-out" datacenter deployment and remote administration.
•
ccNUMA Support Provides better performance for Cache CoherentNon Uniform Memory Architecture (ccNUMA) computers, as well as an interface to let applications tailor their execution characteristics in the ccNUMA environment.
The Windows XP kernel improvements provide new opportunities for independent software vendors (ISVs) and independent hardware vendors (IHVs), and other value-added providers working with Windows 2000. Windows XP provides compatibility with Windows 2000 devices and drivers, while providing new APIs, enhancements, and other features that can be leveraged into future products and services.

And that's just the freaking INTRODUCTION.

I can't understand people bitching about the price of the OS.
An OS is much more complex than, say, Photoshop is. You get more functionality out of an entire OS than you do from one given app.
People happily pay $1,000 for Photoshop but then complain when you get an entire freaking OPERATING SYSTEM for $100.
Windows, for what it is, is a bargain when you think about it.
 
Sigh. Why can't everyone just cap Old Yeller and put him out of his misery yet? Windows XP is about as relevant to me as an N64 is to current generation consloles. Old and archaic.
 
An OS is much more complex than, say, Photoshop is. You get more functionality out of an entire OS than you do from one given app.
People happily pay $1,000 for Photoshop but then complain when you get an entire freaking OPERATING SYSTEM for $100.
Windows, for what it is, is a bargain when you think about it.

It would be interesting to see a comparison in the number of lines of code...
 
Maybe when windows 7 runs as fast as windows XP on a virtual machine with just 1 core and 512mb of ram, I'll consider upgrading.

But I don't use windows as a primary OS, so I guess my thoughts are void -.-
 
We still run and I support - Irix 5.3, VMS, Solaris 7-9, DOS/WIN3.11, 98, NT 4.0, 2000, XP Server 2K3.

If I can't get rid of IRIX and VMS I certainly ain't gonna bitch about having to continue to support XP.
 
Zarathustra[H];1035945369 said:
It would be interesting to see a comparison in the number of lines of code...

CS5 extended isn't even using 400MB of disk space. Windows eats up 10GB+... I think it's fair to say which one is the inherently more complex one ;)
 
Anyone still running Win 3.1? exactly....

not as a desktop, but I do know a few places that still run it on their POS (That's point of sale) terminals and a few sign terminals of a couple of businesses. A few have plans to get rid of it finally but are just going to wait until the systems finally die. XP embedded wasn't really available as a alternative until 2005 either.
 
Honestly, I still run XP on a really old laptop that I have. It's still useful on older hardware.

Do I think you should be able to downgrade to XP on brand new hardware, though? No. There's no reason.
 
by the way, can anyone here say something bad about XP? other than it's old?

someone already covered security.

yes old is its biggest detractor, not just because of age but its inefficient nowadays, so many things we use every day didn't exist when xp was put together, i mean do ya'll remember digging out a damn dvd codec so windows could play dvds? stuff like that makes it annoying...not to mention it's usual penchant to slow down over a number of months as it gets used.

i don't understand why people are so enamored with it. I hated win2000 and xp was good but it's time to move on. I can't possibly understand a tech forum basically having stockholm syndrome for xp....
 
But really, who actually cares about running anything on 256mb or RAM these days?

When I was upgrading systems from XP SP1 to SP2 6+ years ago, 256 was rare and upgrading those ones was painful as the install took hours.

You'd be surprised by some companies.

:rolleyes: Very well, then:
Kernel Enhancements for Windows XP



And that's just the freaking INTRODUCTION.

Yes, and that's actually minor. There's really nothing major at all about it. The biggest changes from Win2k to XP is all the other non-kernel changes they dumped onto it. This was nothing like the gigantic step they took from XP to Vista. 2k to XP was a drop in the bucket.

We still run and I support - Irix 5.3, VMS, Solaris 7-9, DOS/WIN3.11, 98, NT 4.0, 2000, XP Server 2K3.

If I can't get rid of IRIX and VMS I certainly ain't gonna bitch about having to continue to support XP.

We have some old crap too. Solaris 8, Solaris 10, Trusted Solaris 8, Win2k Server, Win2k3 Server, WinXP, and Vista. We actually just moved to 10 less than a year ago.
 
Besides, 7 has XP virtualization for increased compatibility with older software. Since it's XP virtualized transparently, why wouldn't Microsoft continue to support XP? Should be as easy as 1-2-3 for them to keep the two (XP virtualized + XP standalone) in sync.
 
I run a phenom x4 and pretty decent hardware accross the board, fuck microsoft trying to force me to shell out 200 bucks for a single license of an operating system just so I can use dirext X features.

vista wasn't an upgrade to xp, so that's bullshit, and windows 7 may be a legit OS, but again, fuck microsoft trying to force me to spend 200 bux just so I can play a game. I won't play it.

And yet the uninformed trolls thinking Vista / 7 only added DX 10/11 to the game still live on strong i see!

Get informed before you post about something you clearly know nothing about.
 
Fact: Windows 3.11 was still sold to embedded manufactures as late as November 1, 2008.

Which is exactly why Microsoft is keeping XP around till 2020. It's the next logical step for embedded companies to go to. Embedded 7 exists, but it still is a bit massive for some setups, while XP works just fine. Don't expect current companies to keep making drivers or keep support past 2014, heck I doubt you'll see much past next year.

Yea I was going to bring up the 3.11 embedded but you beat me to it. XP will be around in embedded devices for a long time.

We still run and I support - Irix 5.3, VMS, Solaris 7-9, DOS/WIN3.11, 98, NT 4.0, 2000, XP Server 2K3.

If I can't get rid of IRIX and VMS I certainly ain't gonna bitch about having to continue to support XP.

I have a ibm as/400 running the system 36 OS. Most of the stuff is marked between 1982 and 1985 on it. Been working on exporting data to a format the programmer working on the new system can use.
 
krotch i read some more of your posts and you do seem to know that Win7 isn't just a DX update, but your reasons for claiming it is crap are purely personal.

and again MS isn't forcing you to do anything you don't want, don't like it, go get Linux on your desktop.

Vista was leaps past what XP was, the superfetch alone and security it offered were worth it alone for me.

As for companies not moving from XP, usually because of customer applications to which they dont want to spend the money to have redone or they simply cant get it redone and would need an entire new suite

If it aint broke... dont fix it ?
 
krotch i read some more of your posts and you do seem to know that Win7 isn't just a DX update, but your reasons for claiming it is crap are purely personal.

and again MS isn't forcing you to do anything you don't want, don't like it, go get Linux on your desktop.

Vista was leaps past what XP was, the superfetch alone and security it offered were worth it alone for me.

As for companies not moving from XP, usually because of customer applications to which they dont want to spend the money to have redone or they simply cant get it redone and would need an entire new suite

If it aint broke... dont fix it ?

At no point in time did I say Win7 is crap, except for mostly the GUI, which of course depends on personal tastes. Some ppl like Aero, some don't. It was the same with when XP released.

From my time using Win7, it's worked perfectly. No different than my experiences with Vista, XP, 2k, and NT. It's just some ppl think everyone needs to move to it, when that simply isn't the case. It'd be good just from a security standpoint that everyone does move to it, even if they don't see the benefits of all the kernel enhancements, changes, overhauls, complete reworks, etc.

My personal opinion, if you're a stupid user, please move to Win 7, now. For those that can maintain their system, use whatever you think works for you. For now, I'll probably keep using WinXP until majority of games require a DX11. All the programs I use (minus old version of Nero) works fine under Win 7.
 
I agree, if you don't need the features, don't move, for stupid people, certainly should move over if they have a semi decent rig (1g of ram or more and a semi decent cpu)

most people dont notice new features in an OS and just see the outside, why i jumped so fast on your DX comment as that is what everyone claimed Vista was with out understanding the changes, i think many more people had they of really used Vista, would not of hated it so much.
 
Zarathustra[H];1035943453 said:
I'm tring to understand why I am being called names all of a sudden when I was trying to analyze XP on it's merits.

All I was saying was, I would prefer using Win 7,but basedon the differences, do I really need it over XP? No. Begrudgingly, no. If I could answer this question yes, then I'd have something to go to IT with and make my case.

i saw a "vista is tehsuxcox" post
 
Windows 7 has some new features that make it attractive for my uses and I enjoy using it. I'm not running some old Pentium 4 / 1GB crappy hardware that wouldn't be able to run it, so I'm all good. I enjoy my increased security and enhanced visuals, I also enjoy the memory management and start menu that is much more productive than the classic start menu ever could be.

But it's obvious that there are millions out there who rely on older machines, and for those, XP is still doing it's job. I have no reason to object to them using XP, and I don't really care if Microsoft wishes to continue support, I'm sitting well with Windows 7.
 
Isn't that all that really matters. If it's working for you, keep using it. But there's always those that want everyone to move forward, if only just for the sake of moving forward. They can just keep moving forward on their own.
 
Oh good. Ill dig out all my old IDE drives and AGP and throw away all this SATA crap, it will be like the 2000's never happened. Anything to help progress.

What progress? Its all about consolidation on the cloud now. meeeeeeeehhhhhhhhh:D
 
Why so much XP hate in here? IMO it's the best OS released to date. The longevity of the OS should tell that story. Companies like the one I work at can't upgrade till our software vendors make their programs compatible with Windows 7. XP is our only choice!

I'm sure someone is going to say... get a new software vendor noob. Not that simple for some companies. I work for a transportation company and some logistics software still doesn't run well with the new release of win7. It's almost spot free but we can't officially start moving to Win 7 until we can remove our "SCO UNIX" system. Old school.. yes.

If you still want our company to upgrade to win7 "NOW" because it's the omg cool thing to do.. Please send $ to me and I"ll give it to our companies upgrade funds.

-Dill
 
P.S. What does windows 7 bring to the table that Windows xp doesn't? I'm running win7 and besides confusing the hell out of my user base with the new menu system and finding things... I don't see the reasoning to even upgrade... Will I eventually? Of course.
 
Why so much XP hate in here? IMO it's the best OS released to date. The longevity of the OS should tell that story. Companies like the one I work at can't upgrade till our software vendors make their programs compatible with Windows 7. XP is our only choice!
So you're saying XP is better based on the fact your company is tied to vendors? Sorry but that's a bad qualification...

I 100% understand NOT being able to move forward. But that doesn't make what you're using the best.

Isn't that all that really matters. If it's working for you, keep using it. But there's always those that want everyone to move forward, if only just for the sake of moving forward. They can just keep moving forward on their own.
Yea because all those "other people" plug into the cloud and spread crap around. I've yet to see a Windows 7 machine I've had to resurrect from the depths of malware infestation... Plenty of examples of XP though.
 
Back
Top