AMD Replies to NVIDIA

i guess you missed the world passing you by. dirext10 failed because its not on a console. Almost every game released today on the pc now is developed first on the xbox360 and except for prehaps crytek no developer is going spend the time and money to make a full bodied directx 11 engine on a multiplatform game. Directx 11 like dx 10 is dead on arrival, until it gets on a console period. the companies that make pc exclusive games nowadays,the blizzards and stardocks, are not tech pushers, none of those companies are going to design a dirext 10 game much less a directx 11 game.

Physx will have more impact, because it's on console, and its got a company that gives a damn about it and is actually spending money pushing it. I would have more respect for AMD if they actually did somthing to push the industry foward, It's been years since they made their havocfx annoucement, still waiting. INTEL and NVIDIA maybe bastards but at least they put thier money out there and push new tech.

Bzzzzt wrong answer! DirectX10 died because Vista bashers aplenty complained Microsoft would not make DirectX10 for XP. DirectX10 died because majority of computer users were still using XP and game developers didn't want to abandon them.

With more and more people buying newer computers with Vista and soon Win7, DirectX will be back on track again. Just as before.

Thank you for playing though.
 
Everything you could do in EAX before microsoft made hardware direct sound a thing of the past can be done in OpenAL...and no other sound middleware comes close...so EAX still lives, sorry.
Heh. That's not what he was talking about. EAX isn't middleware, either.
 
directx 11 is pointelss and useless, and nvidia is right. if it were the case that directx 11 were part of the xbox360 then ati would be right, but right now, it clear that physx will have more impact than directx 11 ever will , until directx 11 gets into a console.

What are you smoking? DX11 will eventually be used by nearly every dev that makes games for the Windows PC. PhysX on CUDA on Nv GPU, will never see DX level penetration. Hell, PhysX on OpenCL on any gpu or even just on cpu will never see DX level penetration.

Like it or not, for good or bad, DX11 WILL be the standard, and PhysX on CUDA on Nv GPU never will be. They are like apples and dumptrucks anyway, it's not like they are in direct competition with each other.
 
facepalm.jpg

I'ts like everyone has fallen alseep, and has noticed the world passing them bye. the last big pc exclusive game was crysis two years ago. the only exclusive feature nowadays physx. have you even looked at game shelf recently? PC games are delayed 6 months to year already, just to prevent poaching the console release. MS can't even be bothered to release pc games anymore, how long ago was fable released. Crytek created an inferior engine just say could go multiplatform, And you guys seriously believe that in this economic climate develops are going to spend the extra time which is money, to code directx 11 for a pc game? jesus, like i tell my jurors, common sense is your best friend.
 
Why would developers have to abandon DX9 to support DX10?

They wouldn't. It would just cost them more time and money to develop codes to support both DX9 and 10 APIs. It didn't make sense at the time when Vista introduction rate was at an all-time low.
 
What are you smoking? DX11 will eventually be used by nearly every dev that makes games for the Windows PC. PhysX on CUDA on Nv GPU, will never see DX level penetration. Hell, PhysX on OpenCL on any gpu or even just on cpu will never see DX level penetration.

Like it or not, for good or bad, DX11 WILL be the standard, and PhysX on CUDA on Nv GPU never will be. They are like apples and dumptrucks anyway, it's not like they are in direct competition with each other.

dear lord, pc games TODAY are xbox360 ports. The xbox360 does not have directx 11, directx 11 is pointless and useless. Tell me how pc exclusive games are going to released? PC exclusive games today come in the shape of blizzard, stardock, witcher 2, none of those are going to be directx 11, hell they won't even be directx 10. The pc gameing world is not what it once was. MS and its XNA has pretty much won, they have made the xbox360 the standard, but for physx and higher resolution. Most deveopers can't even be bothered to include high res textures.
 
dear lord, pc games TODAY are xbox360 ports. The xbox360 does not have directx 11, directx 11 is pointless and useless. Tell me how pc exclusive games are going to released? PC exclusive games today come in the shape of blizzard, stardock, witcher 2, none of those are going to be directx 11, hell they won't even be directx 10. The pc gameing world is not what it once was. MS and its XNA has pretty much won, they have made the xbox360 the standard, but for physx and higher resolution. Most deveopers can't even be bothered to include high res textures.

Games take years to develop. Games released today would not have DirectX11 anyways. DirectX11 is too new.
 
Games take years to develop. Games released today would not have DirectX11 anyways. DirectX11 is too new.

but it's more than it's just new, there is no economic incentive to use it, and further its a negative to use it. The bulk of your profits are from the consoles. why would you waste precious resources going beyond what your console can do? You already have the sunks cost in by developing xbox360, why add more costs to a simply port, for very little benefit. Physx is easy for nvidia because it's fully supported by the xbox360.

The only time you could start a serious directx 11 game, is when it's on your main source of income a console, thats just reality. Directx 11 died when crysis did not do well enough, once it was decided that kind of game could be supported enough only for pc, then that was the end. No publisher/developer is going to spend the money.

The only excpetion is possibly crytek, and thats just because of pride, but i dont' expect any other developer to make any extensive use of directx 11 until it becomes part of a console developmental system.
 
Hmmm really?

http://techreport.com/discussions.x/16596

Looks like a free SDK to me....

BTW you keep dodging the issue of Havok. AMD has publicly came out supporting Havok so it's kind of hypocritical of them to bash PhysX.

Also there are gamers who game on Mac and Linux just because Microsoft has a near monopoly in no way excuses DirectX from this conversation.

NVIDIA has a greater marketshare than ATI upwards of 3:1. Does that excuse PhysX now?

Well if AMD can freely use PhysX then their comments about it being a closed standard make little sense.
 
Right...The extra cores. Lets ignore that MOST people don't have quad-core CPUs so there are no extra cores to be used. Yes lets design a physics engine that only allows a game to be run on a tiny niche of systems and completely kill any profit. Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. GPGPU apps like PhysX have a place because they off-set other weakeneses. That being said, PhysX has its own major weakness, it really requires a GPU dedicated to it so that hurts any game using more than just some basic effects. Not sure how the up-coming Havok GPU API will react to just having one card, but hopefully it can manage better than PhysX. I don't see PhysX lasting, but it should prove to be a nice little stepping stone in the advancement of physics.

So wait, you're saying more people have dual gpu setups than consumers that have dual core setups? Because that would be 100% wrong.
 
So wait, you're saying more people have dual gpu setups than consumers that have dual core setups? Because that would be 100% wrong.

I have not met a person in real-life with a dual-GPU setup. The penetration of that market is likely <1%.
 
I have not met a person in real-life with a dual-GPU setup. The penetration of that market is likely <1%.

You don't know anyone who has bought a 4870x2 or a 9800GX2 or a 7950? You need to get out more man. :(
 
Well if AMD can freely use PhysX then their comments about it being a closed standard make little sense.
That's what I have been trying to say ;)

http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Nvidia confirms its commitment to making PhysX an open standard for everyone

Not to mention AMD backing Havok which is proprietary to Intel.

Either way the original issue was AMD delaying Dirt 2 so that they could duct tape DX11 into it. Granted Dirt was a pretty crappy game, but if NVIDIA delayed Half-life 3 in order to duct tape PhysX into it, I imagine the level of anger would be legendary. :D
 
Have you seen ATI drivers? They were probably trying to fix them.

Have you seen nVidia's hardware.......they're still trying to fxi it.......lol :p

ATi's drivers are very good and unlike Nvidia we get a monthly release and a hot fix if a problem crops up
 
That's what I have been trying to say ;)

http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html



Not to mention AMD backing Havok which is proprietary to Intel.

Either way the original issue was AMD delaying Dirt 2 so that they could duct tape DX11 into it. Granted Dirt was a pretty crappy game, but if NVIDIA delayed Half-life 3 in order to duct tape PhysX into it, I imagine the level of anger would be legendary. :D

why wouldn't ati/and back it? they do make intel compatable cpu after all so they would be able to use it..........
 
You don't know anyone who has bought a 4870x2 or a 9800GX2 or a 7950? You need to get out more man. :(

I probably get out more than you. ;)
Look, the market simply isn't that big for multiple cards. My friends have no need for such hardware. The highest they go is GTX 260.
 
Have you seen nVidia's hardware.......they're still trying to fxi it.......lol
Fix what? What is "it"? My NVIDIA cards work fine.

ATi's drivers are very good and unlike Nvidia we get a monthly release and a hot fix if a problem crops up
AMD owners get one WHQL-certified driver a month. NVIDIA owners get a WHQL-certified driver every month to two months and a handful of betas in between.

I'm not one to update my drivers very frequently, but the latter option is certainly more appealing than the former.
 
ok if the "open source" physics is written in OpenCL (it is) then it will work on NVIDIA as well....

Now if I am going to go out an buy a card based on some sort of Physics engine, i am going to buy the one that does both PhysX and Open Source instead of the one that only does Open source...


This is like people bitching about M$ using DX COMPUTE instead of OpenCL.... but yet no one does and everyone still uses Windows.... WHY? because DX within windows is a great solution for games and hardware acceleration.
 
Fix what? What is "it"? My NVIDIA cards work fine.


AMD owners get one WHQL-certified driver a month. NVIDIA owners get a WHQL-certified driver every month to two months and a handful of betas in between.

I'm not one to update my drivers very frequently, but the latter option is certainly more appealing than the former.

Tell that to those users with 8000 series mobile GPUs that have failed repeatedly.

NV releases WHQL drivers quarterly, so every 3 months.
 
Fix what? What is "it"? My NVIDIA cards work fine.


AMD owners get one WHQL-certified driver a month. NVIDIA owners get a WHQL-certified driver every month to two months and a handful of betas in between.

I'm not one to update my drivers very frequently, but the latter option is certainly more appealing than the former.

I've only installed my ATI driver once the whole time I used Vista - original installation too since launch.

I'm sure as with most of us, we don't care if they release drivers once a month as opposed to a handful of betas.

My driver works great. If it ain't broken...
 
I've only installed my ATI driver once the whole time I used Vista - original installation too since launch.

I'm sure as with most of us, we don't care if they release drivers once a month as opposed to a handful of betas.

My driver works great. If it ain't broken...

err.. I meant to say I've only updated once.
 
Tell that to those users with 8000 series mobile GPUs that have failed repeatedly.

NV releases WHQL drivers quarterly, so every 3 months.
I have a 8600M GS in one of my notebooks I used for F@H. A little slow to be worth it.
It's still running fine. Guess I got lucky. :)
 
NV releases WHQL drivers quarterly, so every 3 months.
Not quite. NVIDIA is a little erratic about their driver release schedule. The past WHQL driver releases going back to February were on:
9/24
9/8
6/19
5/8
4/3
3/4
2/19

So, in seven months, they've released seven WHQL-certified drivers (for Vista, as an example) -- competitive with AMD. On average, it looks as if they release between three to four times as many beta drivers as they do WHQL-certified drivers.

I have a 8600M GS in one of my notebooks I used for F@H. A little slow to be worth it. It's still running fine. Guess I got lucky.
You certainly aren't in the minority.
 
Not quite. NVIDIA is a little erratic about their driver release schedule. The past WHQL driver releases going back to February were on:
9/24
9/8
6/19
5/8
4/3
3/4
2/19

So, in seven months, they've released seven WHQL-certified drivers (for Vista, as an example) -- competitive with AMD. On average, it looks as if they release between three to four times as many beta drivers as they do WHQL-certified drivers.


You certainly aren't in the minority.

I stand corrected. :) Been a long time since I've used NV outside of the piece of shit 8400m in my laptop so they've changed. Good to hear although the latest drivers for my 8400m under Windows 7 RTM still blow. ;)
 
You don't know anyone who has bought a 4870x2 or a 9800GX2 or a 7950? You need to get out more man. :(

To be honest, nope. I get out quite often, but I guess the circles we hang out in determine what we talk about. I'm the only PC gamer I know since I've moved to Colorado, back in California it was a little different, but even then I was the only one running anything that would be called top of the line. I never met a single gamer at any lan parties or at a computer store that could tell you about SLi or gaming on a 30" monitor.

LIke I said, the market saturation for dual GPU setups, even with the X2 series cards, dual core and Quad Core setups are far more frequent then a dual card setup. So the guy who was claiming that dual card PhysX options were more viable because no one has dual or quad core setups was wrong inhis assertion of that statement.
 
I repeatedly hear about these failed Nvidia chipset motherboards in laptops and I work on PC's for a living. All makes and models. I have replaced 3 faulty Nvidia chipset motherboards out of about 3000 pc's I've worked on since January 1st of this year. Yes I know places such as Semi-Accurate have mentioned that 1000's of these boards and chipsets have been failing, yet somehow I'm not inundated with bad nvidia cards + boards? So I'm not sure where these numbers are coming from. Perhaps the makers of the PC's, HP, Sony etc notice the defect before putting them in the product and selling them? Not sure but I sure as hell have not seen 1000's or even hundreds of these defective products come into our doors and I do warranty work for HP, Compaq and Dell.
 
Fix what? What is "it"? My NVIDIA cards work fine.


AMD owners get one WHQL-certified driver a month. NVIDIA owners get a WHQL-certified driver every month to two months and a handful of betas in between.

I'm not one to update my drivers very frequently, but the latter option is certainly more appealing than the former.

how so? ATi has been far more consistant over the last several years than Nvidia has....and please tell us where the 300 series is.....Ati has been beating them to market with new parts for quite some time now........
 
I repeatedly hear about these failed Nvidia chipset motherboards in laptops and I work on PC's for a living. All makes and models. I have replaced 3 faulty Nvidia chipset motherboards out of about 3000 pc's I've worked on since January 1st of this year. Yes I know places such as Semi-Accurate have mentioned that 1000's of these boards and chipsets have been failing, yet somehow I'm not inundated with bad nvidia cards + boards? So I'm not sure where these numbers are coming from. Perhaps the makers of the PC's, HP, Sony etc notice the defect before putting them in the product and selling them? Not sure but I sure as hell have not seen 1000's or even hundreds of these defective products come into our doors and I do warranty work for HP, Compaq and Dell.

I had one replaced already in my Dell Vostro 1400.......
 
I repeatedly hear about these failed Nvidia chipset motherboards in laptops and I work on PC's for a living. All makes and models. I have replaced 3 faulty Nvidia chipset motherboards out of about 3000 pc's I've worked on since January 1st of this year. Yes I know places such as Semi-Accurate have mentioned that 1000's of these boards and chipsets have been failing, yet somehow I'm not inundated with bad nvidia cards + boards? So I'm not sure where these numbers are coming from. Perhaps the makers of the PC's, HP, Sony etc notice the defect before putting them in the product and selling them? Not sure but I sure as hell have not seen 1000's or even hundreds of these defective products come into our doors and I do warranty work for HP, Compaq and Dell.

My GF had hers go out on her HP lappy two times. I ended up with one of them because HP didn't cover the warranty. New laptop for <$100 FTW!
 
how so? ATi has been far more consistant over the last several years than Nvidia has....and please tell us where the 300 series is.....Ati has been beating them to market with new parts for quite some time now........

Only for the last two generations. The Geforce GTX 280 beat the AMD Radeon 4870 to market by about two weeks as I recall. Then they came out with the 4870 X2 and it was awhile before the GTX 295 and refreshed GTX 285 parts came out.
 
Back
Top