AMD Replies to NVIDIA

Sony does not own Blu-Ray, they were just most voice of it as they stood to lose the most if HD-DVD won the format war.

Blu Ray is operated by a board of 19 companies.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blu-ray_Disc_Association

Sony may not own it, but they own the largest share of the patents. If you make Blu-ray players you're going to be paying Sony boatloads of money in patent licensing fees.
 
Aren't they punishing PC gamers by pushing out the schedule of PC titles such as Dirt 2 in order to support DX11?

Proprietary standards punish gamers, not industry standards like DirectX11. Why is NVIDIA punishing gamers by putting in proprietary and closed standards like PhysX in games?

Something else to think about, it isn't punishing gamers, it is in fact giving PC gamers an advantage over the console version of DiRT 2. PC Gamers will have better graphics and acceleration than the console version of DiRT 2.

So, it isn't punishing gamers, it is actually, finally, catering to the PC gamer for a change.
 
There's a big difference between the proprietary DirectX that's owned and operated by Microsoft that ANYBODY can use versus the proprietary PhysX that is controlled by one of the major video card manufacturers and can ONLY be used on their cards.
Change video card to operating system and the point still stands. DirectX is just as proprietary as PhysX is. I believe Nvidia wants to do the same thing Microsoft did: strong arm a proprietary software tech to become an industry standard. The only problem is Nvidia doesn't have 90%+ of the marketshare to make this kind of influence.
 
Change video card to operating system and the point still stands. DirectX is just as proprietary as PhysX is. I believe Nvidia wants to do the same thing Microsoft did: strong arm a proprietary software tech to become an industry standard. The only problem is Nvidia doesn't have 90%+ of the marketshare to make this kind of influence.

This is completely different, people are not FORCED to use DirectX, it just so happens that it is used by the world's largest operating system manufacturer so it obviously is required for that OS. If you don't like it go to linux or OSX, Mac is getting games decently close to the same time as the windows crowd now. So in that case people still have options that lead to the same end.
 
There's a big difference between the proprietary DirectX that's owned and operated by Microsoft that ANYBODY can use versus the proprietary PhysX that is controlled by one of the major video card manufacturers and can ONLY be used on their cards.

I just don't understand what the big deal is... did all of you buy Ageia? Did AMD buy Ageia? no... nVidia bought Ageia.

nVidia owns the rights to PhysX so they can do whatever the hell they want with it. If they don't want ATi gear to run it, then they can do that.

If you don't like it, deal with it. If AMD doesn't like it, they should make their own version or License it.

AMD needs to shut up.

now that's over with, nVidia, meet me at camera 3...

Listen... you opted not to put out DX11 hardware. If game devs want to use DX11 and decide that a delay is worthwhile, then so be it. It does punish gamers, but don't try to pin it all on ATi/AMD.

nVidia needs to correct their statement
 
I recently jumped shipped from AMD and built an i7 920 rig. But I put an ATI video card in it. I just couldn't make sense of nvidia's cards and ATI had the perfect card for me for what I wanted it for, Photoshop CS4. Sure there's nvidia cards that would have worked but I liked ATI's better.
 
ZING! Physx stinks. It ahs such a detrimental effect on framerates for a small increase in seeing things flap in the wind. I doubt its anything havok can't do. Look at the ghostbusters game is has better physics effects within its engine than Nvidia's proprietary format has. And I am sure if You programmed it Physx would run just as fast on a multi coure CPU. tis a proprietary software that is designed to work with a certain set oh hardware. Remmebr when Physyx firsst cmae out and they ran the software without the card and got similiar performance. its designed to run like crap or not at all on non-nvidia hardware and CPU's. Nvidia is hurting the consumer. And ATI/AMD is not going to pay nvidia a royalty for the right to use it. Tehy will use industry standards such as directX11. Nvidia also did not use the full set of directX10 and cost more money. I have owned several nvidia card in the past they are great. and I buy whatever is fastest in my price range. Nvidia is jsut pissed right now becuase they are having severe manufacturing problems with their GT300 chip at less than 2% of their chips working. We probably won;t see nvidia directX hard ware until xmas time if not JAmuary at CES. I hope they catch up.

Its funny that AMD's CPU's are so far behind in the game and wont; catch up until 2011 but their GPU's are 3 months ahead if not more. I love both nvidia and ATI. I buy whatever is the fastest in my price range. We need competition to force lower prices and higher performance.
 
Change video card to operating system and the point still stands. DirectX is just as proprietary as PhysX is. I believe Nvidia wants to do the same thing Microsoft did: strong arm a proprietary software tech to become an industry standard. The only problem is Nvidia doesn't have 90%+ of the marketshare to make this kind of influence.

Nothing stops developers from coding in OpenGL which would allow it to work under Linux and OS X.

And DirectX is proprietary yes but a major hardware vendor does NOT have control over it. NV and AMD both have equal chances to add to the DX spec. That's the difference. With PhysX only NV controls it and that's a problem.

I just don't understand what the big deal is... did all of you buy Ageia? Did AMD buy Ageia? no... nVidia bought Ageia.

nVidia owns the rights to PhysX so they can do whatever the hell they want with it. If they don't want ATi gear to run it, then they can do that.

If you don't like it, deal with it. If AMD doesn't like it, they should make their own version or License it.

AMD needs to shut up.

now that's over with, nVidia, meet me at camera 3...

Listen... you opted not to put out DX11 hardware. If game devs want to use DX11 and decide that a delay is worthwhile, then so be it. It does punish gamers, but don't try to pin it all on ATi/AMD.

nVidia needs to correct their statement

You totally have missed the point. AMD isn't crying like a baby. They straight up said what many of us already have said. We don't want proprietary shit pushed on us (It certainly didn't work for 3Dfx). Standards that can be used by anybody are the only way to go.
 
Standards that can be used by anybody are the only way to go.


This. I also don't like that nVidia wants to make me buy a program for more money so I can hardware decode HD videos. I think it's bogus. The only reason why nV makes so much money is because fan boys and uneducated people pay for all of their added BS.
 
Nothing stops developers from coding in OpenGL which would allow it to work under Linux and OS X.

And DirectX is proprietary yes but a major hardware vendor does NOT have control over it. NV and AMD both have equal chances to add to the DX spec. That's the difference. With PhysX only NV controls it and that's a problem.

BTW you'd actually be surprised at how well Linux is starting to be able to emulate DirectX programs. Even DirectX 10 games.
 
Earlier this week, someone pondered how Nvidia would respond to the 5870s.

I posted a handful of things and they've all come true :)

Knew I should have gone to Ladbrokes with it
 
Did anyone ever buy one of those shitty Physx cards before Aegia or whatever it was called got bought out by Nvidia?


*listens to crickets*

Now that Nvidia's bought the tech, it's pushing it with its industry muscle and presence - but Physx is still a joke from the perspective that matters to gamers - games.

Not only has Physx been intentionally disabled (if you don't believe it was intentional, I have a bridge to sell you) on competing cards, but the very presence of Physx in a game means that if you don't run Physx, you will get crippled physics - physics that the CPU is entirely capable of, but was deliberately removed to try to make Physx look impressive.

No honest person can argue that stuff flapping in the wind or steam and smoke or shattering glass cannot be done without Physx because it's been done for years.

Actually, let's put all this Physx bullshit aside for a second and seriously think about this. Nvidia is "collaborating" with game developers to essentially worsen non-Nvidia customers' gaming experience. Their proprietary physics doesn't simply add this or that; its inclusion is directly correlated with the REMOVAL of COMPLETELY DOABLE CPU-dependent physics.

That's messed up.

And before the frothing fanboys start swirling their spittle, I've owned exactly one ATI card in the 10 years I've been a PC gamer.
 
I honestly think I'm ready to go red. I'm sick of Nvidias rhetoric, elitist attitude. Sure, Lamborghini's are faster but what do you expect for the price? I don't respect their business practices and don't agree with their naming schemes and price model. I never have bought 'the best' gpu anyways, always just something with good price/performance. It's about time I go back to ATI for my next GPU purchase.
 
I honestly think I'm ready to go red. I'm sick of Nvidias rhetoric, elitist attitude. Sure, Lamborghini's are faster but what do you expect for the price? I don't respect their business practices and don't agree with their naming schemes and price model. I never have bought 'the best' gpu anyways, always just something with good price/performance. It's about time I go back to ATI for my next GPU purchase.

welcome back to the light my friend. Just kidding man, I actually have had like 8 nVidia cards since my 9700 pro (most of them were presents), but I am ready to go back to my childhood friend ATI.
 
Nvidia better start putting up or shutting up, and this is coming from an NV fanboy

I honestly don't know what is keeping vN afloat. Especially since AMD/ATI released the 5870. nV fanboys should go into hiding or just give it up already.
 
Matrices, I was a mouseclick away from buying an Ageia card in the olden days, but time passed and PhysX remained an unimpressive no-show. Then I learnt that all these games I've been playing all the time had a physics engine in them that didn't require extra hardware. Then I kept eyeing it and waiting for more.

Now it's late 2009 and you can't even use Ageia PhysX cards any longer, so those who combined ATI and Ageia (I know a few), and the coolest title I know with PhysX is Batman, but stick that side to side with motherfreaking Red Faction (the latest one) and see what has the most impressive physics?

AMD's won't win the performance crown this generation (75% sure of it) but they've won everything else in my heart, particularly calling them out like this (see official letter comment).
 
Why do some of your insist on attacking each other when we should cheer for both Nvidia AND AMD. This competition means better cards at lower prices.

I personally prefer Nvidia products but I want AMD to keep them on their toes and even beat them. Same with processors. If it werent for AMD Intel would charge stupid prices for their chips.

Competition is a wonderful thing!
 
Something else to think about, it isn't punishing gamers, it is in fact giving PC gamers an advantage over the console version of DiRT 2. PC Gamers will have better graphics and acceleration than the console version of DiRT 2.

So, it isn't punishing gamers, it is actually, finally, catering to the PC gamer for a change.

also, free DiRT 2 for all 5800 series owner :p
 
today, my car broke down after less than 46 hours of owning it and i was stranded 30 miles form home with no cell.

I however, right now, have a smile on my face and happiness in my heart.

I only have nvidia GPUs because AMD/ATi was slow to reveal OpenCL...that and my motherboard didnt' do crossfire, only SLI. I am running thier processors though :)
 
Why do some of your insist on attacking each other when we should cheer for both Nvidia AND AMD. This competition means better cards at lower prices.

I personally prefer Nvidia products but I want AMD to keep them on their toes and even beat them. Same with processors. If it werent for AMD Intel would charge stupid prices for their chips.

Competition is a wonderful thing!

The Intel Lemmings are a lost crowd. Most of them still think CPU's have some kind of relevance.

We all agree that competition is a good thing. We're just waiting for Nvidia to provide us gamers a reason to purchase their cards. Nvidiots are a tough crowd to crack.
 
I would assume right now the folks at Nvidia are rather nervous about this coming season. The new ATI card is pretty much neck and neck with their fastest card (GTX 295) depending on the game you are playing and is quite a bit faster than their fastest Single GPU card (GTX 285), but at a much lower price than the GTX 295 and pretty close to the GTX 285 price. I would assume by the start of the all important do or die winter holiday shopping season starting in mid November, ATI will have the 5870 and something like a 5870x2, so Nvidia had best really hope they get enough GT300 chips done and that they work and can be out the door and at the OEMs and then on the shelves within the next 2 months (and that the GT300 or such is a big enough performance jump) or they will be pretty much a second rate player for the end of the year. One of the executives at Nvidia once wrote a nice long paper about how bad it is to miss a product launch window for a major season and how they benefited hugely from ATI missing a few.............


p.s. I want my GT300 but will take a 5870 if there are no GT300s soon and I bet a lot of other people won't be willing to wait forever either.
 
Why do some of your insist on attacking each other when we should cheer for both Nvidia AND AMD. This competition means better cards at lower prices.

I personally prefer Nvidia products but I want AMD to keep them on their toes and even beat them. Same with processors. If it werent for AMD Intel would charge stupid prices for their chips.

Competition is a wonderful thing!

trying to bring fanboys together is like trying to take away a juicy bone from a rabid dog - you're just going to end up getting hurt in the process.

as for gpu physx, i don't understand the hatred aside from it being proprietary, unless you just really hate nvidia. without someone trying to get accelerated physics in the mainstream, we might still be stuck on software physics alone for who nows how long; and given the slow gradual growth of cpus, theres only so much that can be done in software before rapidly hitting a performance ceiling when there are arguably better solutions available.

if gpu accelerated physics was no better or worse than cpu physics, i doubt amd would bother wasting their time and resources trying to develop an alternative to nvidia's tech, which they obviously have been doing for awhile now. so gpu accelerated physics is here to stay, even if one wishes to begrudgingly cling to the cpu no matter what. competition will force hardware accelerated physics into converting into open standards, imo. but without the initial impetus driving the need for improvement in the first place, the growth of more advanced physics would more than likely stagnate.

i'm glad ageia made physics a big deal a couple years ago, even though they failed with their hardware. with so few pioneers trying to improve physics in gaming, they were able to get it the attention that it desperately needed if any significant progress was to be made. because of their valiant efforts in planting the seeds of awareness, physics will begin to play an even more important role in gaming as time goes on.

just like 3d acceleration 15 years ago, physics acceleration is still a nascent technology. as time goes on, it will improve and grow leaps and bounds over what one might have previously thought possible. (i know i'll probably get flamed anyway, so oh wellz)
 
How I wish these tech giants would fight each other in a price war instead of these.. little media cat fight or whatever you want to call them.
 
Do you understand how that works in the world of businesses and patents? PhysX is owned by Nvidia, that means that licensing is involved. Would you pay money to your competitor?

AMD does it all the time, to Intel. Truth be told, with all the licensing dollars flying around I wouldn't be surprised if AMD is paying Nvidia (and vice versa).

Note: Nvidia might use Global Foundries, an AMD partner company, to make chips. That means they would be paying money to their competitor.

Truth be told, it's a stupid little marketing game for no reason. Nvidia is stupid, and AMD/ATI is stupid. More appropriately, their marketing departments are stupid. Please note, this is standard for all marketing departments.
 
DirectX 11 is an open standard? Hmm.. I wonder if Linux or Mac have it....oh wait....

What about Havok....hmm wait again....

If AMD ever gets physics working on games with their video cards they can go ahead and talk sh**, until then they really need to STFU.
 
DirectX 11 is an open standard? Hmm.. I wonder if Linux or Mac have it....oh wait....

What about Havok....hmm wait again....

If AMD ever gets physics working on games with their video cards they can go ahead and talk sh**, until then they really need to STFU.

The standard may be proprietary to the Microsoft operating system but it is a recognized industry standard that anyone can develop hardware and software to take advantage of. The SDK's are downloadable and are free to use. While "open standard" may not have been the best way to word it AMD's point was clear and well understood by most everyone reading this thread.
 
PRO-TIP of the day;

If you don't like something, don't buy it.

Pretty simple concept.
 
The standard may be proprietary to the Microsoft operating system but it is a recognized industry standard that anyone can develop hardware and software to take advantage of. The SDK's are downloadable and are free to use. While "open standard" may not have been the best way to word it AMD's point was clear and well understood by most everyone reading this thread.

So in other words it's not an open standard. How is DX11 being proprietary to the Windows operating system any different from PhysX GPU physics being proprietary to NVIDIA video cards? Or even Havok potentially being proprietary to ATI?

By the way, PhysX runs on everything but AMD graphics cards. It even runs on AMD CPUs and on multiple operating systems and game consoles.

Also NVIDIA has offered up PhysX to AMD in the past, but AMD turned it down.
http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Nice try though....well not really. Epic fail seems to be more accurate a description.
 
amd still has teeth! theyve always been counted out before, will be fun to watch them scrap back to the top again.
 
Ummm... You do understand that AMD has to license patents from Intel to make processors, right?

That's because AMD's entire business relies on that technology. This is not the case for PhysX.
 
Windows is the common platform for gaming on the PC, this is fact. DX is the common API for gaming on the Windows platform, this is fact. In these terms, DX is an open standard platform for gaming on the PC.

Any graphics vendor, any game developer, is welcome to use it quite easily for hardware acceleration. It is not proprietary to just AMD or NVIDIA or Intel, it is available to all to use for hardware acceleration.

When NV supports DX11 they will be singing a different tune, it has always been this way with AMD and NV, praise what you support, darn what the other side supports claiming it doesn't matter.

Gamers and hardware enthusiasts alike know the truth.

I am glad AMD has their DX11 cards out now so that game developers can start coding DX11 games. They've been out to developers since June of 2009, and this is good news as it kick starts the development of DX11 games, ultimately putting them in gamers hands sooner.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top