AMD Replies to NVIDIA

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
What is the old saying? Something about being careful about what you ask for? Well, NVIDIA asked the questions and now AMD has responded:

NVIDIA: Aren't they punishing PC gamers by pushing out the schedule of PC titles such as Dirt 2 in order to support DX11?

AMD: Proprietary standards punish gamers, not industry standards like DirectX11. Why is NVIDIA punishing gamers by putting in proprietary and closed standards like PhysX in games?
 
Damn NVIDIA is getting hammered all this week. By my count this is:


AMD - 2
NVIDIA - 0


I'm actually glad for AMD. My first hardcore gaming card was a Radeon 9700 Pro and to this day it was the most reliable and overclockable card I have ever owned. I love AMD processors and Video Cards.
 
And yet Nvidia was 100% open to letting ATI use PhysX which ATI refused. Doubt ATI will ever own up to that one.
 
I'm with AMD on this one. I find PhysX and similar proprietary standards to be in the way of true progress. That, and the fact that PhysX degrades 3D performance makes it even less practical imo.
 
Ouch! and more Ouch! LOL, using ATI's market spin from last year, I think Nvidia is just focusing more on mainstream GPUs instead of the high end market because that's where the sales are. They should immediately cut prices of their top of the line products by at least $100 to stay competitive with the 5000 series.
 
128665953742356016.jpg
 
pure pwnage cuz proprietary standards does affect the gaming environment. look at EAX.
 
It certainly does look like Nvidia has been caught with their pants down this time --
 
And yet Nvidia was 100% open to letting ATI use PhysX which ATI refused. Doubt ATI will ever own up to that one.

Do you understand how that works in the world of businesses and patents? PhysX is owned by Nvidia, that means that licensing is involved. Would you pay money to your competitor?
 


nVidia can suck a big one. That company has done enough to screw over its customers. I'm AMD for life now!
 
And yet Nvidia was 100% open to letting ATI use PhysX which ATI refused. Doubt ATI will ever own up to that one.

They don't have to own up to it, better yet why should they? ATi did the right thing by sticking with a widely used industry standard instead of paying royalties and going through Nvidia. Does apple still hold the trademark on OpenCL though? Or do they even collect royalties on that technology?

This is all about marketshare, and while AMD did dodge question 3in regards to their Havok engine, but Nvidia did word it kinda schiesty IMO since they asked about their GPU implementation. I think AMD and ATi are looking at both angles from utilizing dual and quad core setups as well as GPU enabled physics, whereas Nvidia is only looking at the GPU route.
 
If Perez was still there it probably would of been a whole lot worse (pr wise) for Nvidia.
 
Well round 1 and round 2 goes to AMD .. I bet nVidia's thinking of using steroids on their cards right now!
 
Would you pay money to your competitor?
While I understand what your point is, competitors pay each other all the time. Sony gets a portion of the licensing from Blue Ray, no matter who made the player.
 
Why would nVidia tear apart ATI drivers to ensure compatibility?

Well they obviously did some sort of research to ensure that you are unable to do hybrid PhysX. NVIDIA is definitely in the wrong on this one sir. Stop being such a fan boy and open your mind to the fact that your beloved NVIDIA has majorly screwed the pooch on this one.
 
Well they obviously did some sort of research to ensure that you are unable to do hybrid PhysX. NVIDIA is definitely in the wrong on this one sir. Stop being such a fan boy and open your mind to the fact that your beloved NVIDIA has majorly screwed the pooch on this one.

dont feed the troll, he has been doing that for years..
 
Well they obviously did some sort of research to ensure that you are unable to do hybrid PhysX. NVIDIA is definitely in the wrong on this one sir. Stop being such a fan boy and open your mind to the fact that your beloved NVIDIA has majorly screwed the pooch on this one.

You didnt answer my question. Actually, all you did was call me a fanboy and try to insult me. And i seriously doubt they did what you call "research", and someone will likely hack nV drivers anyway to reverse it. So...again...why would they do their competitors job?

dont feed the troll, he has been doing that for years..

Lame.
 
Why would nVidia tear apart ATI drivers to ensure compatibility?

Perhaps you didn't read the thread he linked to. Basically PhsyX was working fine with an ATI card doing 3D and the nvidia card doing physics. Then nVidia released a driver update that intentionally disables PhysX because you have that ATI card doing your graphics. That isn't an 'oh oops, we didn't mean to do that' mistake, that's nVidia intentionally going out of their way to remove functionality from somebody that has bought one of their products.
 
Well it was a good set of questions, with good answers. Since Nvidia has had no leaks or anything but rumors about their latest chips, its very easy to poke them in the eye right now.

What should be pointed out though, is the promises of DX10 itself were not about looks, but streamlining performance.. Which DID NOT happen. I think I've seen 2-3 games that actually play better in DX10 then DX9.. One of the even more laughable fiascoes with DX10 was Crysis.. When you can use 90% of the effects from DX10 IN DX9.. (Maybe it was all the effects i'm not sure)..

The same promises about DX11 are coming up again, from what I've read about Dirt 2, they are adding a new level of compression to the textures so they can be even higher resolution with a lower impact. There was also a screen shot in the 5870 review forum about a game that ran better in DX11 too..

I hope thats all true, and would hope to see tests done on it.
 
You didnt answer my question. Actually, all you did was call me a fanboy and try to insult me. And i seriously doubt they did what you call "research", and someone will likely hack nV drivers anyway to reverse it. So...again...why would they do their competitors job?



Lame.


They most definitely did have to do research? Do you think they just consulted their crystal ball to find out how exactly people did hybrid PhysX? And ATI made the correct choice by not wanting to use a proprietary standard, because as history has showed proprietary doesn't work, ATI figured that out by themselves as they had one fail on them. And they are not doing their competitors job, if they really wanted to make PhysX last for an extended period of time they would have just left it the way it was instead of taking the extra time to put a roadblock in the way. They are still selling their cards so why should they care?
 
Perhaps you didn't read the thread he linked to. Basically PhsyX was working fine with an ATI card doing 3D and the nvidia card doing physics. Then nVidia released a driver update that intentionally disables PhysX because you have that ATI card doing your graphics. That isn't an 'oh oops, we didn't mean to do that' mistake, that's nVidia intentionally going out of their way to remove functionality from somebody that has bought one of their products.

I did read it, and to me it looks like a retalitory act, but dont dismiss the fact that perhaps nV changed the driver structure a bit and it would cause problems.
 
I did read it, and to me it looks like a retalitory act, but dont dismiss the fact that perhaps nV changed the driver structure a bit and it would cause problems.

perhaps? give some example please..... or "LAME!!!"
 
Very original...How bout you show some proof they went out of their way to change it? Or is that just a hunch that every nV hater has...

I believe you can find your answer in upper thread already, or perhaps you never read them..

LAME!!!! :p
 
Back
Top