AMD Replies to NVIDIA

There's a big difference between the proprietary DirectX that's owned and operated by Microsoft that ANYBODY can use versus the proprietary PhysX that is controlled by one of the major video card manufacturers and can ONLY be used on their cards.

There really isn't. Like PhysX, DirectX is a single-vendor standard. The fact that the vendor in question is ubiquitous (on the desktop at least) may change the end result a fair bit, but it doesn't change the facts behind things.

The person you're quoting is correct. DirectX does hurt gamers as it limits PC gamers for practical reasons to using Windows and it's one of the few remaining major hurdles to broad cross-platform compatibility.

You should hope that Khronos gets their collective heads out of their ***es and improves things sufficiently to eventually replace DirectX as all else being equal OpenGL would be better for people as consumers.

Anyways: AMD/ATI **** yeah!
 
So in other words it's not an open standard. How is DX11 being proprietary to the Windows operating system any different from PhysX GPU physics being proprietary to NVIDIA video cards? Or even Havok potentially being proprietary to ATI?

By the way, PhysX runs on everything but AMD graphics cards. It even runs on AMD CPUs and on multiple operating systems and game consoles.

Also NVIDIA has offered up PhysX to AMD in the past, but AMD turned it down.
http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Nice try though....well not really. Epic fail seems to be more accurate a description.

Whoever called DirectX an open standard in the first place made a mistake and Havok physics is CPU based and owned by Intel. We've already seen massive physics done CPUs and as far physx goes I've yet to be impressed. All I've seen this far is some wavy paper and cloth and A LOT of static and physics effects being removed when Physx is not enabled. This recent mess of not being able to use hardware physics with an ATI card installed hasn't made anything better.
 
Whoever called DirectX an open standard in the first place made a mistake and Havok physics is CPU based and owned by Intel. We've already seen massive physics done CPUs and as far physx goes I've yet to be impressed. All I've seen this far is some wavy paper and cloth and A LOT of static and physics effects being removed when Physx is not enabled. This recent mess of not being able to use hardware physics with an ATI card installed hasn't made anything better.

Absolutely agree about DirectX. GPUs theoretically at least should be a lot better to use for physics than CPUs just because the processing power is so much greater when comparing them to CPUs, which is why there is so much talk about GPGPUs and I think that it's going to be the future. Still, Physx isn't the way to do it. We'll have to see if OpenCL works out.
 
The ignorance in this thread astounds me.

...No, wait. It doesn't.

Carry on, sheep.
 
So Havok is not "proprietary and closed"? *LOL*

I never said that. Someone claimed it was proprietary to ATI which is just plain ridiculous. We can argue about the meaning of "proprietary and closed" all fucking day but people are just using the wrong terms to describe the nature of Physx.

Also I wouldn't be lolling. You have a fucking Killer NIC in your machine.
 
I never said that. Someone claimed it was proprietary to ATI which is just plain ridiculous. We can argue about the meaning of "proprietary and closed" all fucking day but people are just using the wrong terms to describe the nature of Physx.

Havok is proprietary to Intel.
DirectX is proprietary to Microsoft.
OpenCL can't do jack shit physics on it's own...it's needs a middleware.
Like the proprietar Havok.

Also I wouldn't be lolling. You have a fucking Killer NIC in your machine.

Just looked.
My KillerNiC isn't involed in any sexual acts, you need to recheck your information...and drop the fallacies.
 
pure pwnage cuz proprietary standards does affect the gaming environment. look at EAX.

EAX is such a deadbeat "standard" A3d atleast that was something to talk about , creative sux in dimensions we humans havent heard yet about!!
 
EAX is such a deadbeat "standard" A3d atleast that was something to talk about , creative sux in dimensions we humans havent heard yet about!!

Everything you could do in EAX before microsoft made hardware direct sound a thing of the past can be done in OpenAL...and no other sound middleware comes close...so EAX still lives, sorry.
 
Those clearly weren't NVIDIAs "questions".. they don't spell Havok with a "c":

http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showpost.php?p=4032016&postcount=25

UPDATE - NVIDIA's PR company for Asia Pacific in Singapore, CIZA Concept, has contacted us and claimed that the source of the questions was from them as "our observations, as industry watchers" and not NVIDIA. We always get these types of questions and they seem to read like they are from NVIDIA, so we are unsure. We were asked to state this in this news post, which has been done here.

We were also contacted by phone about this by NVIDIA and we have offered them the chance to do a follow-up. We are in the process of preparing questions and will have them answered early next week in a new news post.
 
So DirectX works on OSX, linux or BEOS?
DirectX is proprietary, like it or not.

Sure is. And it's also a proprietary standard. Wait, what were we talking about again? Is there anything wrong with it being a proprietary standard per se? I think the original discussion was centered around nV-specific standards used to sell nV hardware. DirectX is a Microsoft standard, used to sell... the Microsoft platform (Windows), on whatever graphics card you have drivers for.
 
Sure is. And it's also a proprietary standard. Wait, what were we talking about again? Is there anything wrong with it being a proprietary standard per se? I think the original discussion was centered around nV-specific standards used to sell nV hardware. DirectX is a Microsoft standard, used to sell... the Microsoft platform (Windows), on whatever graphics card you have drivers for.

I have no problem with it...but others seem to warp facts (Havok, DX as "open").
 
A couple of people in this thread honestly make me weep for humanity.
Anyway cheers to ATi they are on one helluva roll.
Nvidia can keep PhysX to itself all they want, thats fine. I am fairly certain that within the next couple of years OpenCL will be used for physics and developers will not have to decide if they want to implement physics fora select few versus all the consumers as a whole.
 
I didn't go back and read all the pages. I just wanted to bring this up.

DE FACTO STANDARDS
 
I am fairly certain that within the next couple of years OpenCL will be used for physics and developers will not have to decide if they want to implement physics fora select few (with an extra million or two in their pockets, "The Way it's Meant to be Paid TM", courtesy of NVIDIA) versus all the consumers as a whole.

Fixed it for you.
 
I'm just waiting to see if Nvidia once again, for the what...third year in a row? Come to the table with nothing but a die shrink, core and ram clock increases and a shifting down of the naming structure.
 
A couple of people in this thread honestly make me weep for humanity.
Anyway cheers to ATi they are on one helluva roll.
Nvidia can keep PhysX to itself all they want, thats fine. I am fairly certain that within the next couple of years OpenCL will be used for physics and developers will not have to decide if they want to implement physics fora select few versus all the consumers as a whole.

Sorry but I have to do this.. you do realize that your "select few" is actually 70% of the market right? That's NVIDIAs marketshare. Not a bad total marketshare to roll PhysX out on to..
 
A couple of people in this thread honestly make me weep for humanity.
Anyway cheers to ATi they are on one helluva roll.
Nvidia can keep PhysX to itself all they want, thats fine. I am fairly certain that within the next couple of years OpenCL will be used for physics and developers will not have to decide if they want to implement physics fora select few versus all the consumers as a whole.

OpenCL has no physics, what is your point?
 
Ummm... You do understand that AMD has to license patents from Intel to make processors, right?

Funny comparison, I thought having an x86 license was necessary while a PhysX license is about as useful as a 3rd testicle. So Intel is killing AMD in the processor market, so I guess you want Nvidia to own ATI as well.
 
AMD does it all the time, to Intel. Truth be told, with all the licensing dollars flying around I wouldn't be surprised if AMD is paying Nvidia (and vice versa).

Note: Nvidia might use Global Foundries, an AMD partner company, to make chips. That means they would be paying money to their competitor.

Truth be told, it's a stupid little marketing game for no reason. Nvidia is stupid, and AMD/ATI is stupid. More appropriately, their marketing departments are stupid. Please note, this is standard for all marketing departments.

Maybe I should clarify. Licensing PhysX would be a pretty stupid move as it is not a required technology, so why pay money for something you don't need. If they did license it now, that would only make PhysX the defacto standard and ensure licensing fees in perpetuity.
 
DirectX 11 is an open standard? Hmm.. I wonder if Linux or Mac have it....oh wait....

What about Havok....hmm wait again....

If AMD ever gets physics working on games with their video cards they can go ahead and talk sh**, until then they really need to STFU.

Is this even an argument? Last I remembered, Linux and Mac were different OS then Windows. Next you will be complaining why DX11 won't run on your pocket calculator. Funny you should even bring up Macs cause Apple is the very model of companies that embrace open standards and proprietary tech.
 
So in other words it's not an open standard. How is DX11 being proprietary to the Windows operating system any different from PhysX GPU physics being proprietary to NVIDIA video cards? Or even Havok potentially being proprietary to ATI?

By the way, PhysX runs on everything but AMD graphics cards. It even runs on AMD CPUs and on multiple operating systems and game consoles.

Also NVIDIA has offered up PhysX to AMD in the past, but AMD turned it down.
http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Nice try though....well not really. Epic fail seems to be more accurate a description.

Sorry, "Epic Fail" on your part cause DX11 does not require a license from MS and neither does Havok, but if ATI wants PhysX to run on their cards, Nvidia is going to want some blood money from ATI.
 
Its official... As long as I can avoid the issue I had last time with ATi's cards (my 1080P TV would receive a full boxed 1080P signal when set at 1920x1080 making it impossible to use), then I am definitely switching over to ATI.

Was hoping to at least use my GeForce 280 as an expensive Physx card and a back up for new games that haven't had driver loving yet on the ATI end. Of course I found out days ago that this was no longer possible so I was going to hold off on this...

After reading this article (not saying that AMD is a company that only cares about their customer's needs) but this was truly well played and a very good point.

I look better in red anyways...
 
Sorry but I have to do this.. you do realize that your "select few" is actually 70% of the market right? That's NVIDIAs marketshare. Not a bad total marketshare to roll PhysX out on to..

There's a funny saying about making assumptions... it makes an ass out of u and me.

I don't know whether or not NVIDIA has a 70% market share for discrete graphics but you are assuming that everyone has a video card that supports PhysX. Here's a hint, they do not.
 
So in other words it's not an open standard. How is DX11 being proprietary to the Windows operating system any different from PhysX GPU physics being proprietary to NVIDIA video cards? Or even Havok potentially being proprietary to ATI?

By the way, PhysX runs on everything but AMD graphics cards. It even runs on AMD CPUs and on multiple operating systems and game consoles.

Also NVIDIA has offered up PhysX to AMD in the past, but AMD turned it down.
http://www.bit-tech.net/custompc/news/602205/nvidia-offers-physx-support-to-amd--ati.html

Nice try though....well not really. Epic fail seems to be more accurate a description.

Again I said "open standard" was probably the wrong choice of words. However anyone can develop for Direct X without paying royalties to anyone. The SDK's are free. PhysX on the other hand is closed, proprietary and you have to pay NVIDIA to license it. Sounds different to me. AMD cards support OpenGL as does NVIDIA cards. So they both support an open standard but for whatever reason game devs have chosen to virtually abandon it in favor of Direct X.
 
There's a funny saying about making assumptions... it makes an ass out of u and me.

I don't know whether or not NVIDIA has a 70% market share for discrete graphics but you are assuming that everyone has a video card that supports PhysX. Here's a hint, they do not.

I think the point he is getting at is that Nvidia holds a larger market share, which has some impact on a business level to support a companies exclusive product. The more developers jump on board the larger the chance ATi card owners will contemplate switching over, that is if they want the features to begin with.

I'm playing Devil's Advocate here but I was originally not consdering the 5870 when I found out that you were no longer able to have an ATi card for graphics and an Nvidia card for Physx. After seeing Nvidia's whiney PR stunt and ATi's knock out punch reply, out of spite (and the fact that I don't own many games with Physx yet), I am going to switch my GeForce 280 to a ATi 5870.

It's not the first time we have seen nasty PR stunts from these companies but with the G300 being nothing more than the carbon dioxide emitted when Nvidia management mentions it's name and their words in this article... I am worried about Nvidia getting the G300 out anytime soon and if it comes out even a year later and it does rape the 5870, well I switch back then if ATi doesn't have something to compete against it.
 
Jesus Christ you guys, way to take AMD out of context.

DirectX may not be standard among operating systems, but it's a standard among game developers. They all agree for the most part that games is to be written using DirectX API. That's what AMD meant by standard. All video card manufacturers include DirectX hardware capabilities. That's what AMD meant by standard. All soundcard has hardware DirectX capability. That's what AMD meant by standard. All controllers have DirectX (DirectInput) capabilities. That's what AMD meant by standard.

But go ahead and keep the blindfolds on. The fanboy parade goes marching on.
 
There really isn't. Like PhysX, DirectX is a single-vendor standard. The fact that the vendor in question is ubiquitous (on the desktop at least) may change the end result a fair bit, but it doesn't change the facts behind things.

The person you're quoting is correct. DirectX does hurt gamers as it limits PC gamers for practical reasons to using Windows and it's one of the few remaining major hurdles to broad cross-platform compatibility.

You should hope that Khronos gets their collective heads out of their ***es and improves things sufficiently to eventually replace DirectX as all else being equal OpenGL would be better for people as consumers.

Anyways: AMD/ATI **** yeah!

incorrect, DX has done more to help PC gaming than anything else as it did the following

1. provided a common interface to program to
2. removed the developer having to program to multiple chipsets like rendition, voodoo, TNT, S3, Matrox, etc
3. helped give us the incredible performance we have today in the 3d market.

MS has done more to standardize the PC platform than any other single vendor and thank God they did.............
 
Again I said "open standard" was probably the wrong choice of words. However anyone can develop for Direct X without paying royalties to anyone. The SDK's are free. PhysX on the other hand is closed, proprietary and you have to pay NVIDIA to license it. Sounds different to me. AMD cards support OpenGL as does NVIDIA cards. So they both support an open standard but for whatever reason game devs have chosen to virtually abandon it in favor of Direct X.

I believe that it has much to do with console development and portability, more specifically the XBOX 360's development.

Honestly if Microsoft didn't make such a good effort in the generational jump from the XBOX to the 360 I doubt this would be happening right now.

It also concerns me about DirectX 11's adoption rate, specially on more exclusive features that can't be translated to DirectX 9, but if my hunch is right. DirectX 11 is a PC testing bed for Microsoft's next console's development features.
 
directx 11 is pointelss and useless, and nvidia is right. if it were the case that directx 11 were part of the xbox360 then ati would be right, but right now, it clear that physx will have more impact than directx 11 ever will , until directx 11 gets into a console.
 
directx 11 is pointelss and useless, and nvidia is right. if it were the case that directx 11 were part of the xbox360 then ati would be right, but right now, it clear that physx will have more impact than directx 11 ever will , until directx 11 gets into a console.

:rolleyes:

Yeah because all console makers make new console every time a new version of DirectX comes out, right?

Study your computer history lessons. DirectX has been nothing but good for PC gamers. Only DirectX10 dropped the ball.
 
DirectX may not be standard among operating systems, but it's a standard among game developers. They all agree for the most part that games is to be written using DirectX API. That's what AMD meant by standard. All video card manufacturers include DirectX hardware capabilities. That's what AMD meant by standard. All soundcard has hardware DirectX capability. That's what AMD meant by standard. All controllers have DirectX (DirectInput) capabilities. That's what AMD meant by standard.

I think that, That's what AMD meant by standard. :p
 
directx 11 is pointelss and useless, and nvidia is right. if it were the case that directx 11 were part of the xbox360 then ati would be right, but right now, it clear that physx will have more impact than directx 11 ever will , until directx 11 gets into a console.

facepalm.jpg
 
:rolleyes:

Yeah because all console makers make new console every time a new version of DirectX comes out, right?

Study your computer history lessons. DirectX has been nothing but good for PC gamers. Only DirectX10 dropped the ball.

i guess you missed the world passing you by. dirext10 failed because its not on a console. Almost every game released today on the pc now is developed first on the xbox360 and except for prehaps crytek no developer is going spend the time and money to make a full bodied directx 11 engine on a multiplatform game. Directx 11 like dx 10 is dead on arrival, until it gets on a console period. the companies that make pc exclusive games nowadays,the blizzards and stardocks, are not tech pushers, none of those companies are going to design a dirext 10 game much less a directx 11 game.

Physx will have more impact, because it's on console, and its got a company that gives a damn about it and is actually spending money pushing it. I would have more respect for AMD if they actually did somthing to push the industry foward, It's been years since they made their havocfx annoucement, still waiting. INTEL and NVIDIA maybe bastards but at least they put thier money out there and push new tech.
 
Again I said "open standard" was probably the wrong choice of words. However anyone can develop for Direct X without paying royalties to anyone. The SDK's are free. PhysX on the other hand is closed, proprietary and you have to pay NVIDIA to license it. Sounds different to me. AMD cards support OpenGL as does NVIDIA cards. So they both support an open standard but for whatever reason game devs have chosen to virtually abandon it in favor of Direct X.

Hmmm really?

http://techreport.com/discussions.x/16596

Looks like a free SDK to me....

BTW you keep dodging the issue of Havok. AMD has publicly came out supporting Havok so it's kind of hypocritical of them to bash PhysX.

Also there are gamers who game on Mac and Linux just because Microsoft has a near monopoly in no way excuses DirectX from this conversation.

NVIDIA has a greater marketshare than ATI upwards of 3:1. Does that excuse PhysX now?
 
Back
Top