Users Abandon XP for Vista, Windows 7

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to InfoWorld, Windows XP is on a slow but steady decline while the market share for Vista and Win 7 is picking up.

According to Web measurement company Net Applications, which tracks the operating systems used by a pool of about 160 million unique Web site visitors, Windows XP's share of the OS usage market fell 1.1 percentage points during August, tying its November 2008 record drop.
 
Mmm, how are they measuring this? Like how could they really get an estimate on the number of pre-existing xp installs?
 
i always think on how these people come up with their numbers. Not saying they are wrong or anything just curious.
 
I would say this is to be expected with older XP based computers cycling out of usefulness/service with newer Vista based computers taking over in both homes and offices.
 
Even if this is accurate, it's most likely due to the government transitioning they XP platforms to Vista. I just switched my department over to Vista in the last month and it's mandatory for the rest of the military for all systems to be on Vista by the end of the year. I'm fighting it though, I still have the luxury of XP :D. Perks of being the SA/IMO! Hah.
 
Even if this is accurate, it's most likely due to the government transitioning they XP platforms to Vista. I just switched my department over to Vista in the last month and it's mandatory for the rest of the military for all systems to be on Vista by the end of the year. I'm fighting it though, I still have the luxury of XP :D. Perks of being the SA/IMO! Hah.

Using XP is a luxury? Sounds like you're punishing yourself...
 
Just out of curiousity, why bother transitioning to Vista? wouldnt the next logical step be 7, since it offers "windows xp mode"?
 
Just out of curiousity, why bother transitioning to Vista? wouldnt the next logical step be 7, since it offers "windows xp mode"?

In the enterprise space, it takes years to fully vet a new OS for issues, assess needed retraining and - the biggest - application compatability with your Line Of Business applications.

It's unfortunate that so many businesses spent 1-2 years evaluating Vista and are now starting their 2 year transition/migration to Vista - just as Win7 (which we all know is Vista-with-everything-fixed). But it's not uncommon.

many companies will be moving to Vista over the next year or two just as the rest of us (and the more nimble companies) will be moving to Win7. No surprise.
 
xp mode is the bees knees.

Especially with toady's mordern processors that support virtualization. It makes it also of zero impact on the main cores. Great stuff, indeed. And once it's set up, your app runs right in Windows 7 as if it were native; no need to even crack open the Virtual PC where the (now dated-looking) Windows XP desktop resides.

I love this thing.
 
Using XP is a luxury? Sounds like you're punishing yourself...

Hmm never done/been responsible for an enterprise OS migration me thinks. See dugn's comments. Nothing like testing for 6 months and two days after updating every machine in sight you find out the year end financials will not run because it uses some obscure sub-program no one ever mentioned to you.
 
I was at walmart and the bank yesterday and they both had recently upgraded from Windows 2000 to Windows XP, and were having all kinds of problems with stuff not working,

Touchscreens were stalling, mice were not detecting, and the systems would not reboot but they would shut down and turn on, reboot they just go off into LALA land.
 
Using XP is a luxury? Sounds like you're punishing yourself...

Hmm never done/been responsible for an enterprise OS migration me thinks. See dugn's comments. Nothing like testing for 6 months and two days after updating every machine in sight you find out the year end financials will not run because it uses some obscure sub-program no one ever mentioned to you.


Nailed it.

We're having a LOT of small issues (which adds up to a big issue) with specialized software not running right on Vista. We do a lot of statistical analysis and need to run SAS to connect to our oracle database that has several Terabytes of information and build reports/charts. Vista has been a real PAI too work out the kinks in a lot of software. That compatibility mode? Yeah.. it's pretty much garbage. Also, the UAC on the Enterprise version of Vista is annoying as hell, it makes you press CTRL+ALT+DEL and enter your domain admin credentials EVERY TIME you raise the privileges. I disabled that in the gpedit pretty quick, hah. Now that I think of it, we had to make A LOT of group policy changes and reg edits to make stuff work as well as it did with XP. Who knows what issues will come up in the next few months too. So is it a luxury I'm still doing my tasks productively? YES
 
Hmm never done/been responsible for an enterprise OS migration me thinks. See dugn's comments. Nothing like testing for 6 months and two days after updating every machine in sight you find out the year end financials will not run because it uses some obscure sub-program no one ever mentioned to you.

I think that goes to show how bad "enterprise software" actually is. These days, it's synonymous with "bloated software" or "feature creep software" or "only compatible on a specific system software".
 
I doubt people are "abandoning" XP.........like they are running out with their paycheck screaming " I can't live with XP anymore, I HAVE TO HAVE Vista or Windows 7".

It's probably more like "hey there's a good deal on a computer at Best Buy/WalMart/wherever, I've been wanting something faster anyway, and Oh.....I get Vista now".:rolleyes:
 
I doubt people are "abandoning" XP.........like they are running out with their paycheck screaming " I can't live with XP anymore, I HAVE TO HAVE Vista or Windows 7".

It's probably more like "hey there's a good deal on a computer at Best Buy/WalMart/wherever, I've been wanting something faster anyway, and Oh.....I get Vista now".:rolleyes:

I'm guessing the average person probably doesn't care too much, although certainly some people would fall under the first category. It's all good though. The more people use Vista / Win7, the more support it will get, and the faster any of its quirks will be resolved.
 
I'm guessing the average person probably doesn't care too much...QUOTE]

Agreed.

When family and friends have asked whether they get a new computer with Vista, I've asked them "What do you do with your computer?"

When they say, "email and browse the web", I ask them if they like the Windows XP they have or whether they need something new (say, if they've never had their own computer before).

My answer: If XP works today, stick with it. If you need a something new, buy a Mac.

With Win7, there are finally compelling reasons to move to the new MS OS.
 
I'm guessing the average person probably doesn't care too much...QUOTE]

Agreed.

When family and friends have asked whether they get a new computer with Vista, I've asked them "What do you do with your computer?"

When they say, "email and browse the web", I ask them if they like the Windows XP they have or whether they need something new (say, if they've never had their own computer before).

My answer: If XP works today, stick with it. If you need a something new, buy a Mac.

With Win7, there are finally compelling reasons to move to the new MS OS.

So that's where family members get their false information from. I've always wondered. :rolleyes:
 
If you have a corporate environment with obscure apps they should port those to web apps.
Thats what we did... with everything web based, you get your security, you get your anywhere access. and its pretty much hardware/software agnostic. Doesn't work for everything but if its an option.. its a beautiful solution.
 
If you have a corporate environment with obscure apps they should port those to web apps.
Thats what we did... with everything web based, you get your security, you get your anywhere access. and its pretty much hardware/software agnostic. Doesn't work for everything but if its an option.. its a beautiful solution.

Web apps aren't always hardware/software agnostic. IE8 broke a lot of our web based apps, they never did run right on mozilla/firefox and forget about using a non M$ platform.

And the cost.... We still have COLBOL based apps running because noone has $3mil to throw at getting it rewritten into a newer language/system.
 
1% drop is hardly "abandoning"

Anyway, a much more interesting statistic is here:
http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey
Still over 50% of average gamers using XP 32 bit. (Which incidentally is probably why we won't see many vista only games for a bit).

Also still less than 1/3 of average gamers using DX10 with vista.

Interestingly, it says that xp 32 dropped 1.56%, so it seems to be a bit faster amongst average gamers, which I would expect given that DX10 is a fairly big reason for gamers to change to vista.
 
I just noticed something else interesting. Windows 7 seems to have picked up most of the drop of XP in between this survey and the last one.

Makes me wonder how many are trying out a free RC, or how many are using a warez version.
(of course there's other possabilities too, but I think those are the 2 most likely categories)
 
Hmm never done/been responsible for an enterprise OS migration me thinks. See dugn's comments. Nothing like testing for 6 months and two days after updating every machine in sight you find out the year end financials will not run because it uses some obscure sub-program no one ever mentioned to you.

Nailed it.

We're having a LOT of small issues (which adds up to a big issue) with specialized software not running right on Vista. We do a lot of statistical analysis and need to run SAS to connect to our oracle database that has several Terabytes of information and build reports/charts. Vista has been a real PAI too work out the kinks in a lot of software. That compatibility mode? Yeah.. it's pretty much garbage. Also, the UAC on the Enterprise version of Vista is annoying as hell, it makes you press CTRL+ALT+DEL and enter your domain admin credentials EVERY TIME you raise the privileges. I disabled that in the gpedit pretty quick, hah. Now that I think of it, we had to make A LOT of group policy changes and reg edits to make stuff work as well as it did with XP. Who knows what issues will come up in the next few months too. So is it a luxury I'm still doing my tasks productively? YES

I guess I misunderstood your original post?

To me it sounded like you had already done all of the testing and made the department switch over to Vista and just chose to have your personal rig on XP.

Irregardless, sounds like a lot of headache-causing work, glad I'm not you :p
 
1% drop is hardly "abandoning"

Anyway, a much more interesting statistic is here:
http://store.steampowered.com/hwsurvey
Still over 50% of average gamers using XP 32 bit. (Which incidentally is probably why we won't see many vista only games for a bit).

Also still less than 1/3 of average gamers using DX10 with vista.

Interestingly, it says that xp 32 dropped 1.56%, so it seems to be a bit faster amongst average gamers, which I would expect given that DX10 is a fairly big reason for gamers to change to vista.

Gamers are a small minority of computer user. The statistics you linked can be very skewed. Businesses have the highest PC headcount and non-gaming home computer comes second. Gamers are too far and few. Steam gamers vs other gamers slices up the pie some more.
 
is it easier to just beat the crap out of someone making a stupid statement like "users abandon xp for vista/win7", or just sit here and argue about it for multiple pages? I thought so. :p
 
Using XP is a luxury? Sounds like you're punishing yourself...

Hardly. Punishing yourself is spending hard earned money on something that does the same thing. XP works great. It works with everything and is super stable. Windows 7 might be an alternative now that it has fixed many of the Vista problems that Microsoft created.

Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.
 
I guess I misunderstood your original post?

To me it sounded like you had already done all of the testing and made the department switch over to Vista and just chose to have your personal rig on XP.

Irregardless, sounds like a lot of headache-causing work, glad I'm not you :p

More like they (deliberately?) misunderstood YOUR post. I would not want to use XP on my own machine anywhere if I could help it (7 RTM here, with an XP install in a VM if needed) but I sure as hell wouldn't want to be responsible for migrating my employer from XP to Vista or 7 either. Dear god... the nightmares... *shudder*
 
Hardly. Punishing yourself is spending hard earned money on something that does the same thing. XP works great. It works with everything and is super stable. Windows 7 might be an alternative now that it has fixed many of the Vista problems that Microsoft created.

Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.

:rolleyes:
 
Hardly. Punishing yourself is spending hard earned money on something that does the same thing. XP works great. It works with everything and is super stable. Windows 7 might be an alternative now that it has fixed many of the Vista problems that Microsoft created.

Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.

MS never forced gamers to upgrade. You can still play all your DX9 games in XP if you want.

Thing is, MS wanted DX10 to work with their new driver model (that they had to make in order to satisfy the movie studios and get Blu-Ray / HD-DVD working) and for that they had to make a new OS. And including two driver models in one OS isn't really a solution...

Also, I personally wouldn't call XP "super stable." It was pretty damn stable back then, but now, at least compared to Windows 7, we're running into all kinds of issues at work that I *know* have been fixed in 7. But we're not migrating to Windows 7 until April, so I'll have to wait until then...
 
Does the same thing? Seriously? Vista may have had it's flaws, many which weren't even MS' fault... But it did improve on XP in many very tangible ways, to hear the way some of you talk about it you'd think it's a worthless upgrade. On the enterprise level it's definitely more of a hassle than it's worth for most, but at the home user/enthusiast level it's a far different story.

I guess I misunderstood your original post? To me it sounded like you had already done all of the testing and made the department switch over to Vista and just chose to have your personal rig on XP. Irregardless, sounds like a lot of headache-causing work, glad I'm not you

Sounds to me like even post testing and validation they're still finding quirks and issues in several places... Stuff he'd rather avoid for the time being on a work machine, I don't blame him. Dealing w/that stuff at home is one thing, you can always step away and it's usually not a big deal (or you've got other systems). At work it's a whole other story, you just want shit to work, all the time. (hey one can dream!)
 
First past of that post was in reply to this post/quote...

Hardly. Punishing yourself is spending hard earned money on something that does the same thing. XP works great. It works with everything and is super stable. Windows 7 might be an alternative now that it has fixed many of the Vista problems that Microsoft created. Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.
 
Hardly. Punishing yourself is spending hard earned money on something that does the same thing. XP works great. It works with everything and is super stable. Windows 7 might be an alternative now that it has fixed many of the Vista problems that Microsoft created.

Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.

Does the same thing?
Vista problems?
Problems Microsoft created?
Forcing to upgrade?


Uh... are you done talking out of your ass?
 
Hardly. Punishing yourself is spending hard earned money on something that does the same thing. XP works great. It works with everything and is super stable. Windows 7 might be an alternative now that it has fixed many of the Vista problems that Microsoft created.

Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.

If XP works for you and others then stick with it. Great is an overstatement when compared to 7.
 
I remember about 8 months ago my g/f's computer crapped out so she wanted a new laptop instead of a desktop. So we piled into the car and went down to BB and looked around. Well she found a nice laptop within her price range with Vista on it. She absolutely loves it, she wishes she had upgraded to Vista sooner.

I have to agree with some that as peoples old PC's are dying or they are just ready to upgrade that they are transitioning over to Vista, not being forced to cause you can still buy XP and just install that.
I think some of the new buyers are finally seeing how well a fully updated Vista really is :D.


Were it not for Microsoft forcing gamers to upgrade, the Vista adoption even on here would have been much lower.

I don't think the Vista adoption would have been slower here, remember, this is an enthusiast board. We like to test out new stuff :D.
 
I don't know about the rest of ya, but I like my intelligent memory management personally.
 
Windows 7 is good and I'm glad I got in on the msdnaa deal. On my other computers I've set up, I plan to leave em on XP for a while because my parents/little brothers have gotten used to it. Now that I think about it, how is introducing a new OS for parents/family like? Anyone have a experience they can relate to? (user friendly that is)
 
Back
Top