Would You Take $10 To Remove Negative Feedback?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Would you take a $10 bribe + apology to remove negative feedback you left for an eBay seller? What if the item was a $2.69 cable and the only problem is that it was 4' long instead of 5'?

After he posted his negative feedback on eBay, he received the e-mail shown above. In addition to an apology, it reads, "We would like to do anything possible to fix our relationship... Is there any possibility to make the revision for the negative feedback? we can give you 10usd reimbursement if you can simply remove the negative feedback for us."
 
They make neutral feedback for a reason. The guy who left the feedback is a douche bag, as is apparent from him bringing this to Consumerist's attention.
 
This is an interesting situation, but there are a few factors to consider.
1. The seller may be honestly trying to satisfy a customer. Working in customer service, I've given discounts to customers for poor service they received. How different is this?
2. This is not a sustainable system for the seller. The seller is taking a loss on the cable. If they get too much negative feedback, and they keep having to take a loss to get it removed, then the problem solves itself.
 
The buyer is a complete moron and should have left neutral feedback or just accepted a refund from the seller. Buy the cable through monoprice.
 
The buyer is a complete moron and should have left neutral feedback or just accepted a refund from the seller. Buy the cable through monoprice.

Yeah, it's crazy that he wouldn't just accept a refund. They sent you the wrong item, and they offered to refund your purchase time nearly 4 times over.

I second that Monoprice is great though - one time I thought I'd try to save a few bucks by ordering off Amazon with prime shipping instead, and the cables were FAR lower quality than the Monoprice cables I've received in the past.
 
In general, yeah I would, it's basically the company trying to do right so that their image doesn't get tarnished, and if it's nearly a 400% refund of money PLUS I get to keep the item because I'm not satisfied, sure!

Now if its a scam that I was just the first one to catch onto and he wanted to buy my silence, then no... well not for $10 at least :D

That said, I don't trust feedback systems that are in place, "OMG I COULDN'T GET IT TO WORK!!! 1 STAR" or "Thing works great, I don't really know anything about computers, but it works like I think it should 5 STARS!" Last time I shopped on ebay while you could click on a person's 9984 positive feedback rating(bullshit) trying to find the negative feedbacks tended to be a bit problematic.
 
Ed isnt smart in ordering from hong kong in the first place.
 
Sounds like the seller is trying to make good. But I don't know if we are getting the whole story either.
 
The buyer is a complete moron and should have left neutral feedback or just accepted a refund from the seller. Buy the cable through monoprice.

I agree. Something about this story just makes me very annoyed with "Ed".
 
Yep, I'd take the 10 bucks in a heartbeat. The seller seemed genuinely apologetic for the transaction. For an item that was all of 2 bucks and change, no hesitation.
 
Negative feedback can have drastic consequences for eBay sellers. A friend of mine got his account throttled because of negative feedback and he was limited to a much smaller number of listings per month than he normally put up and this was done for I believe at least 6 months or more. This seriously affected his personal income and he ended up having to make a lot of cutbacks.

Now, the issues involving his negative feedback were questionable, so I think it is tough when a company gets punished for such minor mistakes. If a company is just a crappy business that screws people over and messes everything up that is one thing, but small occasional mistakes can cost them a lot. Maybe eBay should have a graded system - rank 1-10... I dunno. All I know is if you get throttled you get hurt.
 
Negative feedback can have drastic consequences for eBay sellers. A friend of mine got his account throttled because of negative feedback and he was limited to a much smaller number of listings per month than he normally put up and this was done for I believe at least 6 months or more. This seriously affected his personal income and he ended up having to make a lot of cutbacks.t.

ahhh. no wonder he wanted to get rid of the negs.


As a buyer, I wouldn't give a shit if a seller has a 95% rating or a 99.9% rating.
same difference to me. As long as most feedback is positive, I'd buy from them.

I've bought a lot of things from hong kong ebayers, since they're really cheap, and they do the job.

the only problem I ever had was when i bought a replacement smartphone bezel, and it arrived scratched. it cost $8 or something, but they probably got it for pennies as factory surplus. I wasn't about to send that shit back to hong kong at my expense, so I filed a complaint saying I never received it. Got a refund, and kept the scratched item.
 
I don't think this is right. The seller probably shouldn't have left negative feedback in the first place because it's not as if the seller was actively trying to rip him off (I once bought a PS2 off eBay and it arrived non-operable with the case full of sand, that's what I consider constitutes bad feedback) but offering $10 for good feedback is a really scummy move. I wouldn't repeal bad feedback for someone who had ripped me off.
 
Sounds like a good reason to leave negative feedback all the time, so you can bank an extra ten bucks each time.
 
so wait, the seller offered to make up for a bad transaction, and the moron who left feedback says "he would feel guilty about changing the feedback and misleading others"


how the hell did the seller not deserve positive feedback for trying to go above and beyond the name of customer service?

Ed is a dickhead.
 
Dude is a dumb ass.. Mistakes happen & they were trying to do more then enough to correct it.
 
eh; not sure how the buyer suffered. $10 may be chump change for what it cost him when he didn't have the proper length cable when he needed it.

Imagine you're remodeling and have a sheetrock contractor scheduled but you just got your cable and it's too short to run through the wall. I'd be pissed too.
 
eh; not sure how the buyer suffered. $10 may be chump change for what it cost him when he didn't have the proper length cable when he needed it.

Imagine you're remodeling and have a sheetrock contractor scheduled but you just got your cable and it's too short to run through the wall. I'd be pissed too.

A 4' VGA cable in your wall, really? :rolleyes:
 
eh; not sure how the buyer suffered. $10 may be chump change for what it cost him when he didn't have the proper length cable when he needed it.

Imagine you're remodeling and have a sheetrock contractor scheduled but you just got your cable and it's too short to run through the wall. I'd be pissed too.

It's a 5' vga cable. Doesn't sound to me like a cable that would be run through sheet rock drywall. If it were a 24 AWG 25' to 50' HDMI, or 50'+ Cat 6 cable yes. But seriously, 5' vga in wall?
 
Sounds like the seller is making a serious effort to make the customer happy. I'd take the $10 and change the feedback.
 
A while back a chinese seller on Ebay offered me $1 to reverse a neutral feedback that I had left. I declined, but if he had offered $10, I would have taken it.
 
People are so stupid. Why would you bother with all this over a purchase that insignificant?

eBay feedback is broken because of this very thing. I have a friend who sells a ton there and he has to deal with crazy people like this all the time. Many buyers expect an immediate response, and anything more than a few hours is enough to send them over the edge.
 
A while back a chinese seller on Ebay offered me $1 to reverse a neutral feedback that I had left. I declined, but if he had offered $10, I would have taken it.

Here's the message from last May. Guess it was $2 not one, I still would have reversed it for $10 :D

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi -

Good evening. Are you upset about your transaction with me, that you left neutral feedback? I do not understand to why you left neutral against me, when I offered this on ebay site, and you liked my price, and i shipped it to you, and I offered FREE Shipping on this.

Will you consider changing your feedback to positive if I offered you $2.00 cash to your paypal?

I would like to make sure you feel comfortable with our transaction.

thank you;
--name removed--
 
The guy paid under $3, including shipping. For that price, anything less than a neutral review is undeserved. And, I would never give a negative review to any company that wants to fix its mistakes.
 
I had a seller offer me a $25 credit on a Xbox 360 hard drive because I put in my comments that I paid for 2 day shipping and didn't receive the item for over 2 weeks. I politely declined and kept my feedback up. It's not like I was bashing the guy with a 1 star review either, I gave them a 3 and said their prices were good but shipping was slow. This was on Amazon though, not ebay.
 
If there's a person with an opinion, there's a person with enough money to influence it.

Washington DC has proven that time and time again.
 
It depends,

If they were not willing to help until after negative feedback left: I'd leave the negative.
If they were willing to fix the problem before leaving a negative mark, I'd leave positive feedback.

The feedback is meant to be about your experience with the seller, if the item shows up busted or wrong and they go beyond to please you it is a positive experience.

It's happened to me as a seller, item arrived damaged. I had no experience with the type of item before so I likely didn't pack it well enough. Guy sent me an e-mail with a photo of it broken, I sent him a refund. He left me positive feedback for making things easy.
 
Dumb-ass or not, guy bought an item.

Seller didn't provide the correct item.
Seller should rectify the problem, but not try to bribe the guy to change his mind, or his feedback.

What happened, happened.

If the seller doesn't like it, simply post a response to the negative feedback. I put more trust in reading both sides of the story than knowing the seller bribed the customer.
 
the only problem I ever had was when i bought a replacement smartphone bezel, and it arrived scratched. it cost $8 or something, but they probably got it for pennies as factory surplus. I wasn't about to send that shit back to hong kong at my expense, so I filed a complaint saying I never received it. Got a refund, and kept the scratched item.

Thats pretty shifty, glad I dont have to do business with you. I ordered waterproof matches that was listed as a case lot on amazon and when they showed up it was a single tube of 12 matches. I contacted the seller and got no reply till I posted a feedback of like 2, for the wrong amount and the lack of reply. Once that feedback went up they emailed me and refunded my money right away and gave me the item. I did change the feedback and explained why.
 
People are entitled about everything more and more. The tiniest minor screwup by any company and the customers, however minor the purchase or however little they were "wronged" demand the sellers first born as a sacrifice + $1.8b for emotional hurt. The bigger the company the more they think in their mind they will get and the less they will accept, while feeling genuinely like some kind of "victim".

What these people don't get is that everyone else, including them is going to be paying for their stupidity. The next purchase is going to be more and more expensive. Like people who RMA everything they broke accidentally because the company "owes them" it's just entitlement, and annoying and costly for everyone else. Hopefully this guy self castrates, and helps deal with the problem. :p
 
Something similar happened to me on ebay. I ordered a connector and they sent me the wrong one. Before leaving feedback, I contacted the seller and explained that I received the wrong item. The seller wanted a picture, and when I sent it to him, he mailed me the correct connector and allowed me to keep the wrong one.

No harm no foul, I left positive feedback.
 
People are entitled about everything more and more. The tiniest minor screwup by any company and the customers, however minor the purchase or however little they were "wronged" demand the sellers first born as a sacrifice + $1.8b for emotional hurt. The bigger the company the more they think in their mind they will get and the less they will accept, while feeling genuinely like some kind of "victim".

What these people don't get is that everyone else, including them is going to be paying for their stupidity. The next purchase is going to be more and more expensive. Like people who RMA everything they broke accidentally because the company "owes them" it's just entitlement, and annoying and costly for everyone else. Hopefully this guy self castrates, and helps deal with the problem. :p

I totally agree with this. I sold a book on amazon a while back, and the chick gave me the wrong address. I offered to mail it next day on my dime to make it right, and she basically told me to fuck my self, she didn't need the book anymore.

Amazon refunded her money, and took it out of my bank account. They didn't even return any of my messages in the process, they ignored me completely, and gave the buyer their money back. The entire fuck up was on their end, but it didn't matter and no one even contacted me from amazon the entire time. I will never sell on amazon again.
 
I don't leave negative feedback unless there is a major breakdown with the transaction.
I try really hard to give the seller room to allow me to give positive feedback.
Recently I gave a 'Neutral' rating on a transaction that really pissed me off. Seller had item listed on eBay, I purchased and my account was debited ~$150. It's a drop ship item so shipping is expected to be a little longer than usual. After almost 4 weeks I finally get a couple emails from eBay and PayPal informing me of a refund, item has been discontinued. Seller tried to get me to change my rating from Neutral. No freaking way. They didn't have an accurate handle on the status of their product and held $150 for almost a month. I'm still irked.
 
Well, the hell with the buyer! As for the seller just annotate in your feedback what you tried to fix the problem and how the seller was so dumb ass not to cooperate. Buying and selling is a mutual agreement not one sided like the buyer thinks it is!
 
Give me 10 bucks and I'll let you shit in my dinner tonight......

Sorry I'm broke these days...
 
This is an honest mistake and I doubt there was any malicious intention to scam the buyer out of his $2.50.

I bought some primochill tubing from an amazon seller and they sent me the wrong color, but instead of leaving the seller negative feedback that could've ruined him and probably freeze the funding in his account, I simply contacted him to get the issue straighten out.

The buyer in this case was just being ridiculous and left the neg feedback because of the insignificant amount and thought of nothing more of it.
 
Back
Top