Ok well, as for personal experiance, I would have to say Halo and Halo 2. They have about the same story as doom. You are so and so. Kill all the aliens. They are the most overhyped piece of crap games I have ever seen. The multiplayer is decent, but I still prefer CS. I do acknowledge though, that it is the best FPS out for Consoles, which is the reason I dont own a console.
As for actual horribleness in programming and such? Easily Driv3r. Lets take the physics engine. I was going 120 in a car, hit a jump, turned veritical. I hit a small metal fence. About 1/10th of the car hit it. My car stopped dead and dropped straight down. What the hell is up with that? Last I checked a 2000 pound piece of metal traveling at speeds in excess of 100mph doesnt come to a dead stop because it hit a 3 foot tall decorative metal fence. And can you save GTA: Vice City RIPOFF? I mean for gods sake, if you look at the beach area, in GTA where you start out at the hotel, it is EXACTLY the same as in Driv3r. The maps are exactly the same...
Just in my experience and my opinions of course.
As for actual horribleness in programming and such? Easily Driv3r. Lets take the physics engine. I was going 120 in a car, hit a jump, turned veritical. I hit a small metal fence. About 1/10th of the car hit it. My car stopped dead and dropped straight down. What the hell is up with that? Last I checked a 2000 pound piece of metal traveling at speeds in excess of 100mph doesnt come to a dead stop because it hit a 3 foot tall decorative metal fence. And can you save GTA: Vice City RIPOFF? I mean for gods sake, if you look at the beach area, in GTA where you start out at the hotel, it is EXACTLY the same as in Driv3r. The maps are exactly the same...
Just in my experience and my opinions of course.