Why Linux Is More Secure Than Windows

There's a file on your system... you don't know what it is. Is it a virus? Is it supposed to be there?

Windows user: What do you do, Google it?

Fuck yeah I Google it, you see the advantage of using Windows is there are more than 2 people using it and you can find advice for any Windows file or problem at the click of a finger. Better yet, the advice is in English.

Debian/Ubuntu user (/usr/sbin/luksformat used as an example):
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ dpkg -S luksformat
cryptsetup: /usr/share/man/man8/luksformat.8.gz
cryptsetup: /usr/sbin/luksformat
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ md5sum ./luksformat
de3e7f7b71da72f7117b2ed6a274aede ./luksformat
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ grep luksformat /var/lib/dpkg/info/cryptsetup.md5sums
de3e7f7b71da72f7117b2ed6a274aede usr/sbin/luksformat
30ca6bea87a45a53e3f81ec4cf60c3e6 usr/share/man/man8/luksformat.8.gz
Yes, Linux will make it as the OS for the lay man (mainstream) with that sort of mumbo jumbo.

Well, looks like I'm in the clear. I can also go grab the package from packages.ubuntu.com and compare it to my installed version.
Well I suppose that's kind of an advantage of Linux, being so limited in software that it can be handled by a centralised database.

RedHat has a similar function, I can have it check the whole system for md5sums that don't match what it knows about the packages. ( `rpm -V` IIRC)
So should your grandmother remember command line functions to use her computer, I remember way back when computers started using a Graphical User erm something, anyways what this revolutionary idea did was visually navigate your way through your computer.

Then you have my XP VM that has a shit ton of folders in C:\Windows... wtf is C:\Windows\$weird_foldername$, why does it have 50MB of shit in it? Can I nuke it? Who the fuck knows? I better take a snapshot first. Fucking ridiculous.
Hmmm... why on earth would you have a Windows virtual machine on your totally complete, totally without flaws Linux distro? I can't seem to recall anyone with a Linux VM on their Windows machine. Also, I mean wow 50 whole megabytes of shit, I'm sure that's a real issue on your 286, what with it's whopping 80MB hard drive.. but oh wait I have a modern computer with around 20TB of raw storage space amongst my plethora of computers, I have no problem backing up my OS volume on two separate raid volumes let alone worry about how much space it takes up on my OS volume.
 
*snip* Fucking ridiculous.

Open a Command Prompt in Windows, type:

sfc /scannnow (and press Enter)

All the digital signatures on the system/OS files are checked against their known cataloged values.

MD5 hashes? While it's fairly "safe" it's still hackable and can be spoofed if necessary (not worth the effort more often than not but possible.

Digital signatures? Lemme see ya dupe one... come on, lemme see it... ;)
 
Bleh, damned typos...

sfc /scannow (then press Enter)

Only 2 "n"s in the /scannow switch, my bad...
 
Open a Command Prompt in Windows, type:

sfc /scannnow (and press Enter)

All the digital signatures on the system/OS files are checked against their known cataloged values.

MD5 hashes? While it's fairly "safe" it's still hackable and can be spoofed if necessary (not worth the effort more often than not but possible.

Digital signatures? Lemme see ya dupe one... come on, lemme see it... ;)


sfc only checks protected system files. Would it check notepad.exe?
 
Debian/Ubuntu user (/usr/sbin/luksformat used as an example):
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ dpkg -S luksformat
cryptsetup: /usr/share/man/man8/luksformat.8.gz
cryptsetup: /usr/sbin/luksformat
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ md5sum ./luksformat
de3e7f7b71da72f7117b2ed6a274aede ./luksformat
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ grep luksformat /var/lib/dpkg/info/cryptsetup.md5sums
de3e7f7b71da72f7117b2ed6a274aede usr/sbin/luksformat
30ca6bea87a45a53e3f81ec4cf60c3e6 usr/share/man/man8/luksformat.8.gz
W
T
F

I hope they don't make Linux mandatory.
 
Fuck yeah I Google it, you see the advantage of using Windows is there are more than 2 people using it and you can find advice for any Windows file or problem at the click of a finger. Better yet, the advice is in English.
Windows user is mad.

Yes, Linux will make it as the OS for the lay man (mainstream) with that sort of mumbo jumbo.
Windows user makes red herring.

Well I suppose that's kind of an advantage of Linux, having a vast wealth of available programs that are all packaged, signed and verified in a normalized manner.

So should your grandmother remember command line functions to use her computer, I remember way back when computers started using a Graphical User erm something, anyways what this revolutionary idea did was visually navigate your way through your computer.
I guess that's why Windows has a command prompt? You realize that area effect hits Windows as well, right?

Hmmm... why on earth would you have a Windows virtual machine on your totally complete, totally without flaws Linux distro? I can't seem to recall anyone with a Linux VM on their Windows machine. Also, I mean wow 50 whole megabytes of shit, I'm sure that's a real issue on your 286, what with it's whopping 80MB hard drive.. but oh wait I have a modern computer with around 20TB of raw storage space amongst my plethora of computers, I have no problem backing up my OS volume on two separate raid volumes let alone worry about how much space it takes up on my OS volume.
Make another straw man, pretend it's relevant. Still don't answer why Windows leaves shit lying around all over the place.
 
Windows user is mad.
Yes I often laugh when I'm mad. It's quite an odd trait.. but I'm seeking help.

Windows user makes red herring.
You think me not believing that the average person wont understand THIS
Debian/Ubuntu user (/usr/sbin/luksformat used as an example):
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ dpkg -S luksformat
cryptsetup: /usr/share/man/man8/luksformat.8.gz
cryptsetup: /usr/sbin/luksformat
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ md5sum ./luksformat
de3e7f7b71da72f7117b2ed6a274aede ./luksformat
lctsi@ubuntu:/usr/sbin$ grep luksformat /var/lib/dpkg/info/cryptsetup.md5sums
de3e7f7b71da72f7117b2ed6a274aede usr/sbin/luksformat
30ca6bea87a45a53e3f81ec4cf60c3e6 usr/share/man/man8/luksformat.8.gz
is a red herring?? like seriously?? WTF??

I guess that's why Windows has a command prompt? You realize that area effect hits Windows as well, right?
Well yeah I am aware that windows has cmd, I have been a computer user back before computers had windows, before computers has plug & play, before computers had cd-roms, back when you had to configure your computer to use EMS & XMS.

Yes I personally use cmd fairly regularly, my backups done with a batch file utilising robocopy (which I wrote) using windows scheduler to automate it. Also I use it to quickly find out network settings with ipconfig, repair windows installs using the command console and a whole bunch of little tasks which I myself as a more advanced user can find using a little faster or necessary to fix other peoples machines.

Make another straw man, pretend it's relevant. Still don't answer why Windows leaves shit lying around all over the place.
3rd party software leaves shit lying about the place, answer is simple, don't install shit you don't intend to use. I say a file is better left there unneeded than needed and not there. This is why I loved superfetch because I had loads of ram and i'd rather it utilised than have heaps of it 'free'...
 
Why are Linux enthusiasts cool for calling out Windows but Mac users are hippy elitists if they do the same? They're also Linux users, sort of. :p
 
Make another straw man, pretend it's relevant. Still don't answer why Windows leaves shit lying around all over the place.

Also, you don't think it's relevant that I question why you have a Windows VM installed on your machine. I mean you seem so worried about 50MB yet you find it necessary to INSTALL AN ENTIRE OTHER OPERATING SYSTEM ON YOUR COMPUTER?
 
I'm sorry but Windows does absolutely everything I need, I have absolutely no use for a virtual machine running another operating system.
 
Sure. Because it's an alternate to the GUI tools and has quite extensive and appropriate help built into the net.exe command itself. There are also a couple of even simpler alternatives to connecting to a share or printer.

But your question of whether a file should be somewhere is pretty generic. To see if it's an OS file and is correct, the answer was given above: sfc. Again, that command is trivial to use, even if you have no idea how to use it. Simply typing the command gives specific usage examples (the second example is the one that's appropriate to verify a single OS file):
Code:
...
e.g.

        sfc /SCANNOW
        sfc /VERIFYFILE=c:\windows\system32\kernel32.dll
        sfc /SCANFILE=d:\windows\system32\kernel32.dll /OFFBOOTDIR=d:\ /OFFWINDIR=d:\windows
        sfc /VERIFYONLY
There isn't a generic way AFAIK to check what program a random executable belongs to, if it's installed in a shared location at least. The executable metadata very often has information about the creator, file version, etc. msconfig also comes in handy if it's a service or start up item. Searching an online EXE/DLL reference could be the next steps. Most programs keep non-shared components in the application directory anyways.
 
Now if only Ubuntu 10.04 or OpenSUSE 10.3 could see the hard drive on my 890GX/SB850 motherboard, I'd finally have a new install of Linux. /shakes head

The funny thing is that phoronix "reviewed" this motherboard, but only seemed to use a Live CD to declare "we had no problems at all getting the 890GXM-G65 up and running properly." Um, not recognizing a SATA hard drive in AHCI mode is not "running properly." No, I can't dumb it down to IDE mode since I already have another OS running on it. 3 year old (Windows) OS install discs have no problems recognizing the HDD in AHCI mode. :rolleyes:
 
Truth is nobody cares about linux but linux users. Its a great server OS, but the entire desktop world revolves around windows.
 
Yes I often laugh when I'm mad. It's quite an odd trait.. but I'm seeking help.
You think me not believing that the average person wont understand THIS

is a red herring?? like seriously?? WTF??
Yes, that is a red herring. An average Linux user wouldn't understand that. An average Windows user wouldn't understand editing the registry. You introduce the red herring where you insist that an average person should understand either. Does the average Windows user understand what Geek Squad does to wipe malware from their computer? Obviously not. So it's really irrelevant and a poor red herring.

Well yeah I am aware that windows has cmd, I have been a computer user back before computers had windows, before computers has plug & play, before computers had cd-roms, back when you had to configure your computer to use EMS & XMS.

Yes I personally use cmd fairly regularly, my backups done with a batch file utilising robocopy (which I wrote) using windows scheduler to automate it. Also I use it to quickly find out network settings with ipconfig, repair windows installs using the command console and a whole bunch of little tasks which I myself as a more advanced user can find using a little faster or necessary to fix other peoples machines.
I started in DOS too, on a PS/2 Model 25.
But look at your personal utilization of cmd... do you expect the average person to understand that? No, you don't. If somebody insisted that the complicated command-line tasks you perform on Windows meant Windows wasn't going to make it into the mainstream for the layperson, wouldn't they just be talking out of their butt?

3rd party software leaves shit lying about the place, answer is simple, don't install shit you don't intend to use. I say a file is better left there unneeded than needed and not there. This is why I loved superfetch because I had loads of ram and i'd rather it utilised than have heaps of it 'free'...
I'm not talking about 3rd party software.
When you have an SSD and you're paying $3/GB for storage, it becomes more important to clean up wasted space. If I can't verify where a file came from, it's a liability.

I'm not a polemic anti-Windows person. If I could get better X integration and better verification on the OS and 3rd party programs I would probably run it full time at home. I'm looking forward to where this goes:
http://windows-get.sourceforge.net/
 
Also, you don't think it's relevant that I question why you have a Windows VM installed on your machine. I mean you seem so worried about 50MB yet you find it necessary to INSTALL AN ENTIRE OTHER OPERATING SYSTEM ON YOUR COMPUTER?

Do you run Windows 7? If so, you probably have another entire operating system on your computer.
There's a really cool concept called virtualization where you can run multiple OSes on one PC. You should check it out some time.

Sure. Because it's an alternate to the GUI tools and has quite extensive and appropriate help built into the net.exe command itself. There are also a couple of even simpler alternatives to connecting to a share or printer.

But your question of whether a file should be somewhere is pretty generic. To see if it's an OS file and is correct, the answer was given above: sfc. Again, that command is trivial to use, even if you have no idea how to use it. Simply typing the command gives specific usage examples (the second example is the one that's appropriate to verify a single OS file):

There isn't a generic way AFAIK to check what program a random executable belongs to, if it's installed in a shared location at least. The executable metadata very often has information about the creator, file version, etc. msconfig also comes in handy if it's a service or start up item. Searching an online EXE/DLL reference could be the next steps. Most programs keep non-shared components in the application directory anyways.

net use isn't always an alternative. It is often the only way to delete fake-mapped drives so you can map them to a real drive letter.
And there are multiple GUIs for dpkg, apt-get, etc. They have extensive help sections as well.
The metadata in the EXE/DLLs can be helpful and you might eventually come up with md5sums to verify the file (if it's not signed). Obviously if you don't have either, then you head the file and find UPX strings you know you're in a world of shit.
I just wish there was a better way!
 
Do you run Windows 7? If so, you probably have another entire operating system on your computer.
There's a really cool concept called virtualization where you can run multiple OSes on one PC. You should check it out some time.

no, i'm not running any virtualization I even have it disabled in BIOS as I disable anything that I'm not utilizing. I had Windows XP Mode installed, but found no use for it and got rid of it. I've used VMWare in the past, but in the end it was only a toy and found I had no real use for a sandbox. I even had my backup server running Gentoo for about 6 months (i've used a number of Linux distros mandriva, red hat, & ubuntu) because i was interested in mdadm and also wanted to have a just-in-case i want to browse a dodgy website computer. But ran into problems like being only able to drag a limited amount of data to a linux network volume (i can't remember the limit but despite the volume having 3TB could copy+paste far far less than that, something i've had no problem with windows to windows) I did solve that by using robocopy instead. But I had to give up on it when I upgraded to Vista because rdp was no longer compatible on the Linux side, I found I was having to rdp to my Windows XP machine then rdp from that to my Gentoo box (rdp being fairly important as at the time the box was completely headless). Also was rather disappointed that the onboard driver-based software raid of my INTEL (ich9r) controller wasn't supported in linux. No matter what I did I could not get Linux to see a raid volume setup in bios, and Intel is one of the most common raid controllers out.

Yes, that is a red herring. An average Linux user wouldn't understand that. An average Windows user wouldn't understand editing the registry. You introduce the red herring where you insist that an average person should understand either. Does the average Windows user understand what Geek Squad does to wipe malware from their computer? Obviously not. So it's really irrelevant and a poor red herring.

You may have a small point, but... Windows is far easier to use for the lay person. Basically anyone can install software on windows, but it took me some fiddling and research to do the same on linux, no matter how many issues i've had with InstallShield it is still better than the process of installing software on linux.

The software available on Linux isn't up to scratch, sure you may like OOo Calc, but I sure don't it doesn't even compare with >10 year old versions of Excel. Sure you can use Wine but well if you're going to emulate Windows, you may as well run Windows. It was also rather disappointing to find that there one some of the private torrent site I'm registered with none of the Linux torrent programs were on their approved client list (you can't connect without an approved client) and had to run uTorrent through Wine, which was a real hassle to setup as compared to the few clicks in Windows. I also use the Adobe Creative Suite 5 (x64) & Office 2010 (x64), which simply do not work on Linux period. I'm sure there is a tonne of software that I use in Windows that is either a headache to install on Linux or simply doesn't work.

I started in DOS too, on a PS/2 Model 25.
But look at your personal utilization of cmd... do you expect the average person to understand that? No, you don't. If somebody insisted that the complicated command-line tasks you perform on Windows meant Windows wasn't going to make it into the mainstream for the layperson, wouldn't they just be talking out of their butt?
No I don't expect the average person to understand my utilization of cmd, but neither does Microsoft. You can use Windows from setup through every day of your life without ever having to use a command prompt, this simply isn't so with Linux.

I'm not talking about 3rd party software.
When you have an SSD and you're paying $3/GB for storage, it becomes more important to clean up wasted space. If I can't verify where a file came from, it's a liability.
You can clean Windows if it is so necessary. If you're paying such a premium for a new and very limited technology then expect to pay the price.

I'm not a polemic anti-Windows person. If I could get better X integration and better verification on the OS and 3rd party programs I would probably run it full time at home. I'm looking forward to where this goes:
http://windows-get.sourceforge.net/

I'm not totally anti-linux either, I totally see the value of it for either a Server environment and for the moment it's utilization on netbooks where the hardware limitations already exclude you from using a wide range of Windows software. If all you need to do is web browse, download a bit of music/videos, write an occasional document/email then a Linux distro like ubuntu is ideal because of it's lower consumption of resources. But if you plan on doing anything on a publication level then firstly you shouldn't be using a netbook and secondly you shouldn't be using Linux. But, as technology advances netbooks will outgrow Linux.
 
It was also rather disappointing to find that there one some of the private torrent site

should be

It was also rather disappointing to find that there were some of the private torrent site
 
You may have a small point, but... Windows is far easier to use for the lay person.
Citation needed.
Basically anyone can install software on windows, but it took me some fiddling and research to do the same on linux, no matter how many issues i've had with InstallShield it is still better than the process of installing software on linux.
Sorry, but no. This is one thing that Linux has gets very right, with centralized distribution and updates, signed packages and consistent UI. Start the package manager, search for what you're looking for and click install. If you're trying to install something weird, yeah it's not easy, but the repos contain virtually anything you will want and I'll take that tradeoff. Most weird software packages binaries these days anyway, so download the package, double click and say 'yes I want to install this package' and you're done.

While most of the article is pure horseshit, this is one place where I think Linux has an honest and real secuirty advantage in standard usage. All packages on most modern distributions are signed by the distribution, and centrally distributed. The entire system, including all installed software, is updated in the same way, at the same time, with signature verification.

It was also rather disappointing to find that there one some of the private torrent site I'm registered with none of the Linux torrent programs were on their approved client list (you can't connect without an approved client) and had to run uTorrent through Wine, which was a real hassle to setup as compared to the few clicks in Windows.
Take that up with the tracker maintainers. Linux seedboxes are popular and common, and there at least 3 very good Linux bittorrent clients. If they're banning them, they're idiots, and I don't think the torrent site you're using is very serious or successful.

You can use Windows from setup through every day of your life without ever having to use a command prompt, this simply isn't so with Linux.
I don't know why that's an advantage... working on the CLI is far more efficient for a lot of things. An average user on Linux has little use for the CLI, except possibly copy/pasting commands to do some obscure thing, which in Windows the user would have to walk through a lengthy GUI process to accomplish.

As far as overall security, I think the 3 major modern operating systems are all on the same playing field these days. You can argue small points, and I suspect that the fleet of Windows boxes running out of date, vulnerable software is proportionally much larger than the fleet of Linux boxes doing the same, but on all of them the user is the biggest liability.

But your question of whether a file should be somewhere is pretty generic. To see if it's an OS file and is correct, the answer was given above: sfc.
Yeah, if it comes from Windows, which is only a small portion of the code actually running on the average Windows box.

Yes, Linux will make it as the OS for the lay man (mainstream) with that sort of mumbo jumbo.
This isn't something an average Windows user is going to think about or be concerned with. It's something a computer tech or system admin is going to be interested in, and if you are tech-ing or admin-ing Linux boxes, that will make perfect sense, it's quite straightforward. The point is that it's possible, out of the box, to actually do this. It's not at all on Windows without a lot of effort.

And there's an app for that. Not installed by default in Ubuntu (I don't think, it's not in Debian), but debsums makes it a one-liner.
 
This is one thing that Linux has gets very right, with centralized distribution and updates, signed packages and consistent UI.
If I go to the store and buy a game and bring it home, installing it on Linux is a nightmare. Installing it on Windows consists of putting hte CD in the drive and clicking OK on a few autoplay prompts. Similarly, when brand new patches for my software are out, on Windows I can install them. On Ubuntu, I have to wait until they make it into the "official repositories".
 
no, i'm not running any virtualization I even have it disabled in BIOS as I disable anything that I'm not utilizing. I had Windows XP Mode installed, but found no use for it and got rid of it. I've used VMWare in the past, but in the end it was only a toy and found I had no real use for a sandbox.
In a corporate environment that "sandbox" as you put it is extremely valuable. The ability to backup, restore, and move images is the best damn thing since sliced bread. Although different strokes for different folks.
I even had my backup server running Gentoo for about 6 months (i've used a number of Linux distros mandriva, red hat, & ubuntu) because i was interested in mdadm and also wanted to have a just-in-case i want to browse a dodgy website computer. But ran into problems like being only able to drag a limited amount of data to a linux network volume (i can't remember the limit but despite the volume having 3TB could copy+paste far far less than that, something i've had no problem with windows to windows) I did solve that by using robocopy instead.
Why in the world are you using a gui if your are transferring over 3TB of data? That's a PITA to do even in Windows and definitely not recommended when dealing with such large datasets.
But I had to give up on it when I upgraded to Vista because rdp was no longer compatible on the Linux side, I found I was having to rdp to my Windows XP machine then rdp from that to my Gentoo box (rdp being fairly important as at the time the box was completely headless).
It's headless so you're using RDP?!?! WTF?!?! I'm not even going to recommend the obvious alternative here. I need an explanation for that first.
Also was rather disappointed that the onboard driver-based software raid of my INTEL (ich9r) controller wasn't supported in linux. No matter what I did I could not get Linux to see a raid volume setup in bios, and Intel is one of the most common raid controllers out.
Why not use the software raid within Linux itself and call it a day?

You may have a small point, but... Windows is far easier to use for the lay person. Basically anyone can install software on windows, but it took me some fiddling and research to do the same on linux, no matter how many issues i've had with InstallShield it is still better than the process of installing software on linux.
The package manager is pretty damn easy. It honestly can't get any easier than that.
The software available on Linux isn't up to scratch, sure you may like OOo Calc, but I sure don't it doesn't even compare with >10 year old versions of Excel.
That depends on the end user. Unless you are doing some serious calculations which outstrip the functions found in Excel OoO will do just fine for 90% of people out there.

No I don't expect the average person to understand my utilization of cmd, but neither does Microsoft. You can use Windows from setup through every day of your life without ever having to use a command prompt, this simply isn't so with Linux.

This really is an old argument that's just not true anymore. Going from nothing to creating a document in Linux happens far far far quicker than any version of Windows. Period.

But, as technology advances netbooks will outgrow Linux.
Netbooks... probably but not because of technology. Primarily because the market for it is quite small for it so the developers behind that market are limited. So you won't see the obvious nature of Linux's benefits in small form factor applications. All you have to do is look at the cellphone market to get the point. Battery life will always be preferential to performance because in reality most processors can handle the light workload that netbooks and cellphones are geared towards.
 
Similarly, when brand new patches for my software are out, on Windows I can install them. On Ubuntu, I have to wait until they make it into the "official repositories".

I think you're just really confused here. Where are you getting these Windows patches from, if not from an "official repository"?
 
Also in the context of a desktop environment, I've found Linux to be slower and less responsive. Say for a simple task like loading firefox on my Windows 7 machine is perecptionally instant, wheras when I've used linux there has been a wait time, sometimes quite a long wait time. Linux just does not seem to utilize all the resources at its disposal, Windows preloads software you use most often into ram on boot and while a Linux user will claim that having nearly 4GB of ram used before actually loading any progams is wasteful I'm very pleased with this, it means most things are instant. Its like buying a new sports car and leaving it in a garage and never driving it. I'm not worried that i'll run out of ram as Windows can dump this ram with the swiftness!

Citation needed.
Personal experience.

Sorry, but no. This is one thing that Linux has gets very right, with centralized distribution and updates, signed packages and consistent UI. Start the package manager, search for what you're looking for and click install. If you're trying to install something weird, yeah it's not easy, but the repos contain virtually anything you will want and I'll take that tradeoff. Most weird software packages binaries these days anyway, so download the package, double click and say 'yes I want to install this package' and you're done.
Yeah that's all good and well when dealing with such a limited range of software, if I went by your logic of taking what software was presented to me on Windows... I'd end up with Norton, Nero, Windows Media Player, iTunes, Ask Bar, Windows Photo Viewer and Internet Explorer running.. Seriously... NO THANKS. Just because software comes with your OS or comes preinstalled OEM that is no reason to use that software. If Linux ever became mainstream then this is what would end up happening... Proprietary software would end up infecting these package managers, pushing out decent software with big wads of cash. As one Linux distro rose to the apex, it would get corrupted and the next underdog would gradually grow support, you'd end up having to reinstall your OS fairly regularly. It may not happen, but people are inherantly greedy and I can see this happening.

While most of the article is pure horseshit, this is one place where I think Linux has an honest and real secuirty advantage in standard usage. All packages on most modern distributions are signed by the distribution, and centrally distributed. The entire system, including all installed software, is updated in the same way, at the same time, with signature verification.
Well Windows has 100x more users and 100x more software titles, so for you to have a centralised distribution system for it would be quite a task.

Take that up with the tracker maintainers. Linux seedboxes are popular and common, and there at least 3 very good Linux bittorrent clients. If they're banning them, they're idiots, and I don't think the torrent site you're using is very serious or successful.
Ok just checked and now it does allow a few linux torrent programs. Didn't solve my problems back then though.

As far as overall security, I think the 3 major modern operating systems are all on the same playing field these days. You can argue small points, and I suspect that the fleet of Windows boxes running out of date, vulnerable software is proportionally much larger than the fleet of Linux boxes doing the same, but on all of them the user is the biggest liability.
Yeah.. um Windows boxes running out of date? There's something called Windows update its automated.
 
If I go to the store and buy a game and bring it home, installing it on Linux is a nightmare. Installing it on Windows consists of putting hte CD in the drive and clicking OK on a few autoplay prompts. Similarly, when brand new patches for my software are out, on Windows I can install them. On Ubuntu, I have to wait until they make it into the "official repositories".

That's really a strawman argument. Tell me if I gave you a binary for linux how successful would you be at installing it in Windows?
 
Why in the world are you using a gui if your are transferring over 3TB of data? That's a PITA to do even in Windows and definitely not recommended when dealing with such large datasets.
Because it's easier.

It's headless so you're using RDP?!?! WTF?!?! I'm not even going to recommend the obvious alternative here. I need an explanation for that first.
Well I wanted to use it for torrents, browsing dodgy sites and generally getting a better grasp on Linux itself. So I needed a desktop connection, tried VNC but firstly I don't like it and secondly even with the help of my friend who is a Linux loyalist couldn't get it going. and bash was completely useless to me.

Why not use the software raid within Linux itself and call it a day?
Well thats what I had to do and mdadm is fine, a bit more difficult to setup/maintain than a simple raid bios but the issues were.. Firstly.. I already had the raid configuration full of data and didn't really feel like copying it all over again over which at the time was a 10/100 switch. Secondly I didn't want that data set to be totally reliant on the OS, I wanted the option to reinstall Windows at a whim if I so chose to and not have to worry about a few days without a running backup.

That depends on the end user. Unless you are doing some serious calculations which outstrip the functions found in Excel OoO will do just fine for 90% of people out there.
no, the formulas and formatting of cells etc is just terrible in calc... if you want to use it to say calculate a budget or something then fine.. but even just for personal use what I do with Excel is very hindered in Calc.


This really is an old argument that's just not true anymore. Going from nothing to creating a document in Linux happens far far far quicker than any version of Windows. Period.
You'll have to explain that one.. can you magically type faster in Linux than Windows or something? Word 2010 loads in like 2-3 seconds on my machine.

Netbooks... probably but not because of technology. Primarily because the market for it is quite small for it so the developers behind that market are limited. So you won't see the obvious nature of Linux's benefits in small form factor applications. All you have to do is look at the cellphone market to get the point. Battery life will always be preferential to performance because in reality most processors can handle the light workload that netbooks and cellphones are geared towards.
Yes Linux is good for using less resources. If that's your requirement.
 
You'll have to explain that one.. can you magically type faster in Linux than Windows or something? Word 2010 loads in like 2-3 seconds on my machine.

Also I guarantee my Photoshop is more up to date and runs much faster than yours. Please don't try to tell me that GIMP is a viable alternative and does everything you need because you obviously don't do any real graphic design work.
 
and why I don't like VNC, it's graphics aren't as smooth and most importantly I cannot go to any random computer running windows and access it remotely. You have to install VNC that is it's biggest drawback. I can access using RDP from any computer connected to the internet. Huge HUGE advantage.
 
Because it's easier.
3TB of data? Unless they are 3 files OK. But I doubt that would be a problem for Gnome or KDE. Now if you had hundreds...pfft. cp -R ./ ./ is much much easier, faster and safer as you don't have additional services causing havoc with your copy. To see what I mean... copy your C:\Windows from the GUI and see what happens.

Well I wanted to use it for torrents, browsing dodgy sites and generally getting a better grasp on Linux itself. So I needed a desktop connection, tried VNC but firstly I don't like it and secondly even with the help of my friend who is a Linux loyalist couldn't get it going. and bash was completely useless to me.
But you said it was headless....correct?

Well thats what I had to do and mdadm is fine, a bit more difficult to setup/maintain than a simple raid bios but the issues were.. Firstly.. I already had the raid configuration full of data and didn't really feel like copying it all over again over which at the time was a 10/100 switch. Secondly I didn't want that data set to be totally reliant on the OS, I wanted the option to reinstall Windows at a whim if I so chose to and not have to worry about a few days without a running backup.
My thoughts on RAID is never go cheap. EVER. The problem with onboard software raid implementations is that even for intel RAID you are not guaranteed the flexibility that can be had with hardware RAID or software raid provided by the OS. As for the ability to throw on Windows if need be from an OS provided RAID.... remember when I said that "sandbox" you spoke of earlier was useful? Since VM implementations now pass through I/O the overall performance hit, while there, is far outweighed by the ability to install whatever OS needed on a whim all without really worrying about the file system underneath..... if installed correctly. RAID ideally should be a 1 time affair. As we speak I've got two versions of Linux, Windows 7 (yes I game on a VM) , Mac OS, and Sun OS all on the same box. I can backup, remove, restore, move, and replace on a whim. Hell that RDP problem you spoke of earlier isn't even a problem and the software KVM is handled by the hypervisor.

no, the formulas and formatting of cells etc is just terrible in calc... if you want to use it to say calculate a budget or something then fine.. but even just for personal use what I do with Excel is very hindered in Calc.
Like I said 90%. Most people who use a spreadsheet at home use it for budgets. Very very rarely for much else. So basic SUM, AVG, YES/NO functions are all that's required (not like it doesn't support more than that).

You'll have to explain that one.. can you magically type faster in Linux than Windows or something? Word 2010 loads in like 2-3 seconds on my machine.

Meaning if I took two dumb users. Think grandma I'm sure I could walk both through installation of Windows and Linux. However, the hardware that linux does not support from the likes of Dell or similar is very very small (they all run Intel chipsets for the most part....very well supported). Therefore the person who is installing Linux the moment they enter the desktop (think Ubuntu) is most likely productive sooner. Basic installs of Windows don't include productivity apps, much less the applications that now come with a basic Linux install. Out the gate you've got OoO, GIMP, an AIM equivalent, etc all ready to go from 1 disc.
 
Also I guarantee my Photoshop is more up to date and runs much faster than yours. Please don't try to tell me that GIMP is a viable alternative and does everything you need because you obviously don't do any real graphic design work.

Oh my bad Photoshop gets installed automatically with Windows 7? When did that happen?
 
and why I don't like VNC, it's graphics aren't as smooth and most importantly I cannot go to any random computer running windows and access it remotely. You have to install VNC that is it's biggest drawback. I can access using RDP from any computer connected to the internet. Huge HUGE advantage.

...ahem...VM
 
3TB of data? Unless they are 3 files OK. But I doubt that would be a problem for Gnome or KDE. Now if you had hundreds...pfft. cp -R ./ ./ is much much easier, faster and safer as you don't have additional services causing havoc with your copy. To see what I mean... copy your C:\Windows from the GUI and see what happens.
What would I need to copy an actively used system directory for? I make a system image as copying it is not sufficient to restore a dead OS.

But you said it was headless....correct?
Yes, yes I did. You can browse the web through a remote desktop connection, download torrents etc etc.

My thoughts on RAID is never go cheap. EVER. The problem with onboard software raid implementations is that even for intel RAID you are not guaranteed the flexibility that can be had with hardware RAID or software raid provided by the OS. As for the ability to throw on Windows if need be from an OS provided RAID.... remember when I said that "sandbox" you spoke of earlier was useful? Since VM implementations now pass through I/O the overall performance hit, while there, is far outweighed by the ability to install whatever OS needed on a whim all without really worrying about the file system underneath..... if installed correctly. RAID ideally should be a 1 time affair. As we speak I've got two versions of Linux, Windows 7 (yes I game on a VM) , Mac OS, and Sun OS all on the same box. I can backup, remove, restore, move, and replace on a whim. Hell that RDP problem you spoke of earlier isn't even a problem and the software KVM is handled by the hypervisor.
But why should I go through all these complicated processes when Windows does everything I need? I've not found anything in Linux that I've needed that Windows couldn't provide. On the subject of RAID, yes my main PC has a sweet Areca ARC-1220 running RAID-5 with 8x1TB drives which is fantastic.. but I needed a cost effective backup solution, and for all intents and purposes the intel onboard ich9r and the silicon image SiI3114 are more than sufficient for the two RAID-0 volumes I use on my backup PC. What possible reason do I have for buying an expensive controller when all I want to run is RAID-0? It has no need for redundancy as it is already a redundancy system, there are no real concerns for downtime as my main computer is the one that needs to stay online. If the volumes fail, I can replace the faulty drive/motherboard/raid card and rebuild/recopy to the array.

Like I said 90%. Most people who use a spreadsheet at home use it for budgets. Very very rarely for much else. So basic SUM, AVG, YES/NO functions are all that's required (not like it doesn't support more than that).
I can't quite remember now but I ran into some major issues, I think it had to do with sorting things by dates or something that was pretty basic and Calc just did it all wrong, i think it viewed dates as regular numbers or something.. anyways everything went pear shaped. But I can't quite remember what it was.


Meaning if I took two dumb users. Think grandma I'm sure I could walk both through installation of Windows and Linux. However, the hardware that linux does not support from the likes of Dell or similar is very very small (they all run Intel chipsets for the most part....very well supported). Therefore the person who is installing Linux the moment they enter the desktop (think Ubuntu) is most likely productive sooner. Basic installs of Windows don't include productivity apps, much less the applications that now come with a basic Linux install. Out the gate you've got OoO, GIMP, an AIM equivalent, etc all ready to go from 1 disc.
Very well supported? well unless you want to use driver-based raid. As with the software it comes with, Windows comes with media players, picture viewers blah blah blah.. But just like with the Linux software I don't like the software and am going to use something else anyways.

Oh my bad Photoshop gets installed automatically with Windows 7? When did that happen?

Why does it need to be installed automatically? At least you CAN install a 64-bit version of Photoshop on Windows. I deal with big big files and multiple files at once, 3GB of ram is no longer sufficient. Plus the advantage of 64-bit processing.
...ahem...VM

Well that kinda defeats the whole idea of having torrents, encoding, backup etc etc running on a separate machine as to lighten the load on the main computer. Since when can you run a raid array outside the computer from a VM? This is a backup computer we're talking about, with it's own tasks that either it needs to run separately from my main computer or I would prefer to delegate to it. Are you saying that I should have that computer running Linux and THEN install a VM on my main PC to browse the occasional site. Then I'm stuck with either a resource burden or a load-time burden (half the point of the task was to REDUCE resource burdens and a VM isn't like prefetched info, can't just be instantly dumped). Either I allocate my ram/hdd whatever and have that VM running 24/7 or wait a few minutes to browse a site. Why would I want to do this when I need another PC running anyways that I can RDP to in a few seconds?
 
What would I need to copy an actively used system directory for? I make a system image as copying it is not sufficient to restore a dead OS.
Exactly. No sane person would deal with datasets as large as 3TB over GUI. Windows has limitations with that as well. I just wouldn't do it and with tons of files it's quicker via command line and safer for so many reasons we'd be here all day.

Yes, yes I did. You can browse the web through a remote desktop connection, download torrents etc etc.
What visual internet browser works on a headless system (i.e Internet Explorer)? Typically headless means no gui.
But why should I go through all these complicated processes when Windows does everything I need? I've not found anything in Linux that I've needed that Windows couldn't provide.
My premise wasn't that Windows couldn't provide it. It was that a software OS implementation of RAID is far more flexible than an onboard software raid installation. Thus if an Intel software raid was problematic, since you were trying Linux anyway. The software OS Raid approach would have been just as good with additional benefits that onboard software raid implementations lack....yes even intels.

On the subject of RAID, yes my main PC has a sweet Areca ARC-1220 running RAID-5 with 8x1TB drives which is fantastic.. but I needed a cost effective backup solution, and for all intents and purposes the intel onboard ich9r and the silicon image SiI3114 are more than sufficient for the two RAID-0 volumes I use on my backup PC. What possible reason do I have for buying an expensive controller when all I want to run is RAID-0? It has no need for redundancy as it is already a redundancy system, there are no real concerns for downtime as my main computer is the one that needs to stay online. If the volumes fail, I can replace the faulty drive/motherboard/raid card and rebuild/recopy to the array.
You are not making much sense here. Typically backups are provided by a remote system. Your original concern was about trying Linux having problems, then moving to Windows... but if you were trying Linux from the jump it wouldn't have been a big deal either way. You are using RAID-0 which can be read natively. Regardless of the RAID controller... it's RAID-0 which Linux could read even if it was Windows thus making your problem with transfers over a network connection moot. If you were running something other than RAID-0 you'd have a point. However, since you were running RAID-0 ....pfft not an issue.

I can't quite remember now but I ran into some major issues, I think it had to do with sorting things by dates or something that was pretty basic and Calc just did it all wrong, i think it viewed dates as regular numbers or something.. anyways everything went pear shaped. But I can't quite remember what it was.
k... let me know what it was though... I don't believe it was sort. OoO actually does sorting better than excel in my experience.

Very well supported? well unless you want to use driver-based raid. As with the software it comes with, Windows comes with media players, picture viewers blah blah blah.. But just like with the Linux software I don't like the software and am going to use something else anyways.
What grandmother is installing a RAID collection? Whose grandmother is that?

Why does it need to be installed automatically? At least you CAN install a 64-bit version of Photoshop on Windows. I deal with big big files and multiple files at once, 3GB of ram is no longer sufficient. Plus the advantage of 64-bit processing.
Because that was my example. Like I said going from nothing to productive happens far quicker in Linux. It just does. I use both OS's so I know what the experience is like.

Well that kinda defeats the whole idea of having torrents, encoding, backup etc etc running on a separate machine as to lighten the load on the main computer. Since when can you run a raid array outside the computer from a VM? This is a backup computer we're talking about, with it's own tasks that either it needs to run separately from my main computer or I would prefer to delegate to it. Are you saying that I should have that computer running Linux and THEN install a VM on my main PC to browse the occasional site. Then I'm stuck with either a resource burden or a load-time burden (half the point of the task was to REDUCE resource burdens and a VM isn't like prefetched info, can't just be instantly dumped). Either I allocate my ram/hdd whatever and have that VM running 24/7 or wait a few minutes to browse a site. Why would I want to do this when I need another PC running anyways that I can RDP to in a few seconds?
Huh? Can you rephrase this please? This doesn't make sense from a technological standpoint at all.
 
Personal experience.
Tempered by years of Windows use and a sample size of one makes that meaningless.

Just because software comes with your OS or comes preinstalled OEM that is no reason to use that software. If Linux ever became mainstream then this is what would end up happening... Proprietary software would end up infecting these package managers, pushing out decent software with big wads of cash. As one Linux distro rose to the apex, it would get corrupted and the next underdog would gradually grow support, you'd end up having to reinstall your OS fairly regularly. It may not happen, but people are inherantly greedy and I can see this happening.
How exactly is this going to happen when pretty much all the decent Desktop distributions repositories are maintained by the community? If anything like this were to happen, the community would get pissed, fork the project and the corrupted version would die off.

Not that this would ever happen. Hasn't happened on Windows, why would it happen on Linux where there generally isn't a profit motive behind distributions?

Well Windows has 100x more users and 100x more software titles, so for you to have a centralised distribution system for it would be quite a task.
It may need to be fragmented a bit more and the software rejigged a bit to scale to this size, but it's certainly possible. Maintaining the 30,000+ packages in Debian is already 'quite a task'. I don't see any reason why this style of distribution can't scale up.

Yeah.. um Windows boxes running out of date? There's something called Windows update its automated.
Since when does Windows Update actually update software the user is using? But you missed my point, which is about the boxes that are actually out there, and I think it's quite a safe bet to make that the average Linux box has much less out of date and vulnerable software than the average Windows box. The users are more likely to be somewhat knowledgeable, it's an easier process, all the software is updated at once. At least on Ubuntu, it's also much harder to ignore.

Also was rather disappointed that the onboard driver-based software raid of my INTEL (ich9r) controller wasn't supported in linux. No matter what I did I could not get Linux to see a raid volume setup in bios, and Intel is one of the most common raid controllers out.
It can be made to work. It's not difficult. But no, it's not enabled by default in most distributions. Windows sucks at softraid, Linux sucks at fakeraid. I'll take softraid any day.

and why I don't like VNC, it's graphics aren't as smooth and most importantly I cannot go to any random computer running windows and access it remotely. You have to install VNC that is it's biggest drawback. I can access using RDP from any computer connected to the internet.
Yep, if you're in a Windows environment, Windows' remote desktop client is more convenient. Go figure. Accessing RDP is a bitch from Ubuntu. And you apparently don't know that VNC generally has a Java client enabled you can use from any computer with a web browser than can run applets. Which is much closer to 'any computer' than 'any Windows computer I can run arbitrary programs on'.

Very well supported? well unless you want to use driver-based raid.
What grandma uses RAID? And if this is a fresh install, you'd just follow the instructions in the installer for setting up RAID and ignore the fakeraid entirely. Which is easier.

At least you CAN install a 64-bit version of Photoshop on Windows. I deal with big big files and multiple files at once, 3GB of ram is no longer sufficient. Plus the advantage of 64-bit processing.
Huh? Are you trying to say Linux is 32-bit? I mean I knew you were clueless, but that's just.... too much.

Not sure why I bother...
 
Since when does Windows Update actually update software the user is using? But you missed my point, which is about the boxes that are actually out there, and I think it's quite a safe bet to make that the average Linux box has much less out of date and vulnerable software than the average Windows box. The users are more likely to be somewhat knowledgeable, it's an easier process, all the software is updated at once. At least on Ubuntu, it's also much harder to ignore.
Any decent software updates itself on Windows today. Not sure of your point.

It can be made to work. It's not difficult. But no, it's not enabled by default in most distributions. Windows sucks at softraid, Linux sucks at fakeraid. I'll take softraid any day.
calling it fakeraid doesn't make it any less good. I'm more than satisfied with intel's onboard raid, even raid-5 writes very well when writeback cache is enabled. Never had an issue with it.

Yep, if you're in a Windows environment, Windows' remote desktop client is more convenient. Go figure. Accessing RDP is a bitch from Ubuntu. And you apparently don't know that VNC generally has a Java client enabled you can use from any computer with a web browser than can run applets. Which is much closer to 'any computer' than 'any Windows computer I can run arbitrary programs on'.
Well we are in a Windows world, sorry the local netcafe isn't running Linux, you average business isn't running Linux, generally family and friends aren't using Linux. So if I run Linux I'd like to make pretty damn sure I can access it remotely from a Windows machine.

Well that VNC Java app sounds pretty good (provided Java is installed and is uptodate enough for the app, I'd say there'd be more Windows computers than the number with updated Java but would be a close call), I do however doubt the performance of a Java-based desktop and am sure it would be pretty limited. Is it a fully functional desktop as if you were sitting at your computer? Is it fullscreen?

What grandma uses RAID? And if this is a fresh install, you'd just follow the instructions in the installer for setting up RAID and ignore the fakeraid entirely. Which is easier.
Intel raid is by far easier. Takes less than 2 minutes to setup a new array either in bios or through the intel matrix gui.

Huh? Are you trying to say Linux is 32-bit? I mean I knew you were clueless, but that's just.... too much.
No, I've run 64-bit Gentoo when did I claim Linux is 32-bit only? I'm saying it can't run 64-bit Office or Photoshop. Not the same thing.

Not sure why I bother...
Yeah I know, for a desktop computer Linux does seem to be more trouble than it's worth.
 
What visual internet browser works on a headless system (i.e Internet Explorer)? Typically headless means no gui.
Headless - no monitor/screen.

My premise wasn't that Windows couldn't provide it. It was that a software OS implementation of RAID is far more flexible than an onboard software raid installation. Thus if an Intel software raid was problematic, since you were trying Linux anyway. The software OS Raid approach would have been just as good with additional benefits that onboard software raid implementations lack....yes even intels.
What features do you really need besides expand or create spare?


You are not making much sense here. Typically backups are provided by a remote system. Your original concern was about trying Linux having problems, then moving to Windows... but if you were trying Linux from the jump it wouldn't have been a big deal either way. You are using RAID-0 which can be read natively. Regardless of the RAID controller... it's RAID-0 which Linux could read even if it was Windows thus making your problem with transfers over a network connection moot. If you were running something other than RAID-0 you'd have a point. However, since you were running RAID-0 ....pfft not an issue.
Well I can't afford to transfer ~7TB over the internet, internet is mighty expensive here in Australia. I'm quite satisfied having a main pc running a 8x1TB RAID5 and a secondary pc running 3x1TB RAID0 + 6x500GB RAID0 and doing nightly backups to that.

Well mdadm couldn't put humpty dumpty back together again, just saw 6 separate drives and I had extensive help from someone who lives in Linux doesn't even run Windows.

Because that was my example. Like I said going from nothing to productive happens far quicker in Linux. It just does. I use both OS's so I know what the experience is like.
So how often do you have to reinstall a OS / software? I think that an hour lost installing superior productivity software on a Windows machine will save countless hours in the future as especially with 64-bit photoshop it runs much faster and production value will be much more professional too.

Huh? Can you rephrase this please? This doesn't make sense from a technological standpoint at all.

You are aware that there are TWO computers in this equation right?

Why should I allocate ram/cpu/hdd from my main pc when I have an auxillary pc with it's own ram/cpu/hdd and is sitting idle? A rdp connection firstly logs on quicker than loading a VM and chews up next to zero resources when running minimized compared to the gig of ram and say 5 gigs of hdd space the VM would consume. There would also be no point running torrents or ftp server in a VM as the point was to remove these from the main PC. Plus it is much easier to configure QoS through your router to heighten priority of an IP address rather than a particular protocol, and even when you set it up to filter a protocol it doesn't seem to work correctly, when my torrents are maxing out my broadband (remember im in australia and my broadband maxes out at about 700KB/s) I still want to be able to browse websites, getting my router to allocate higher priority to my main PC at the expense of the backup pc running torrents means I don't have to manually limit my torrents whenever I wanna browse.
 
Any decent software updates itself on Windows today.
Define 'decent'. And if you don't think having 20 different auto-updaters running in the background, with 20 different user interfaces and 20 different popup notifications for users to ignore, you're crazy. The situation is better on Linux, period. There is nothing to argue here.


calling it fakeraid doesn't make it any less good.
It's less good because it relies on a specific driver and hardware, not the operating system. If Intel changes their architecture or you decide to switch to an AMD motherboard, your data becomes unusable. And in an emergency situation you can throw the disks in any machine (hell, even via USB enclosures), boot any Linux CD and access your data with no fuss. You can mix devices on different controllers in the same RAID, and thus go beyond the limits of Intel's solution. Fakeraid has no technological advantage at all over software RAID. It is a kludge to work around Windows lacking it in the OS. Therefore software RAID is better. And regardless, your array would have been accessible just fine under Linux had you taken 5 minutes to find out how to set it up.

But your reading comprehension sucks, because I didn't say anything about how good fakeraid is. It's the generally-accepted term for this kind of RAID. Windows sucks at software RAID, and that is at least as valid a complaint that Linux doesn't support some random proprietary vendor's software RAID format (when it actually does, you just didn't bother to find out how to use it).

Well we are in a Windows world, sorry the local netcafe isn't running Linux
Many netcafes I've been to are running kiosks where you can't run anything but a browser. Your RDP is useless. Most places offering Internet access will have Java set up since it's used for lots of games and other random web apps.

I do however doubt the performance of a Java-based desktop and am sure it would be pretty limited.
Why do you think it would be any worse than a regular client? It works fine. I don't know if it's has the desktop integration you're looking for, I very, very rarely use remote desktop programs. Anything I need to do remotely I do from a terminal.

Intel raid is by far easier. Takes less than 2 minutes to setup a new array either in bios or through the intel matrix gui.
I did think this was in Ubuntu's GUI installer now, but it's still only in the curses installer. So it's still very easy, but not in the default options. Meh, okay, it's a wash as far as ease of setup. I don't think my grandma could do either of them.

No, I've run 64-bit Gentoo when did I claim Linux is 32-bit only? I'm saying it can't run 64-bit Office or Photoshop. Not the same thing.
You mentioned 32-bit vs. 64-bit and a performance advantage and > 3GB memory, and I couldn't think of any reason you would do that when you're trying to argue Linux is inferior other than if you thought Linux couldn't do that.

What features do you really need besides expand or create spare?
How about migrate from RAID1 to RAID5? Support for RAID6? Much better recovery flexibility?

Well mdadm couldn't put humpty dumpty back together again, just saw 6 separate drives and I had extensive help from someone who lives in Linux doesn't even run Windows.
Then he didn't have a fucking clue, because it's very easy, you don't use mdadm. 3rd grade Google skills should have lead you to dmraid.

Almost all of your arguments are just mind-numbingly ignorant of the actual state of Linux today. If you actually had something to say that wasn't just completely wrong or of the 'it didn't work like Windows and I did no research whatsoever to discover how to do it on a completely different system' variety I might have some respect, but this just gets tiresome around here. Every thread that mentions Linux and people like you that have never seriously used Linux and last touched it 5 years ago come out of the woodwork and treat it like its some scary thing that must be put down at every opportunity.

But wait, weren't we talking about security? Anyone want to get back to that? I'm sick of fighting FUD.
 
That's really a strawman argument. Tell me if I gave you a binary for linux how successful would you be at installing it in Windows?
I'm talking about Linux Binaries. Unreal Tournament 2004, Doom 3, Quake III, anything with a Linux version. Installing that Linux binary is a nightmare, even for someone experienced with Linux.
 
It's less good because it relies on a specific driver and hardware, not the operating system. If Intel changes their architecture or you decide to switch to an AMD motherboard, your data becomes unusable. And in an emergency situation you can throw the disks in any machine (hell, even via USB enclosures), boot any Linux CD and access your data with no fuss. You can mix devices on different controllers in the same RAID, and thus go beyond the limits of Intel's solution. Fakeraid has no technological advantage at all over software RAID. It is a kludge to work around Windows lacking it in the OS. Therefore software RAID is better. And regardless, your array would have been accessible just fine under Linux had you taken 5 minutes to find out how to set it up.
Well ICHxxR has been backwards compatible for quite some time you can rip an array from a ICH7R and plod it on a ICH10R and I believe the other way around if you're only using features from the older version, I doubt this compatibility is going anywhere soon. So in an 'emergency' and why your data wasn't backed up in the first place escapes me, i'm at no risk as I have 4 motherboards I can recover my 6-disk array on (965P-DS3P - ICH8R), (G33M-DS2R - ICH9R), (EP35-DS3R - ICH9R) & (DQ45CB - ICH10DO).. all of which have 6-ports.. So I think I'll be ok on that one.

But your reading comprehension sucks, because I didn't say anything about how good fakeraid is. It's the generally-accepted term for this kind of RAID. Windows sucks at software RAID, and that is at least as valid a complaint that Linux doesn't support some random proprietary vendor's software RAID format (when it actually does, you just didn't bother to find out how to use it).
"driver-based raid" or "driver-based software raid" is the non-linux non-derogative term for it. As for RANDOM proprietary vendor, it's fucking Intel dude. On that note I decided to look it up and fuck me dead, if you want to install Linux on an intel driver-based raid there's like 3 pages of commands to type.. what a load...

I love some of the highlights tho after doing what I've said below about setting it in bios there are a further 70 individual commands you have to follow... on top of that you have to put up with an error message everytime you bootup.. wow.. awesome...
Well, you’ve done! Remember that if you mounted a RAID0 device Linux at startup will probe your disks and he’ll wrongly detect a bad partition table: ignore error messages http://osdir.com/ml/linux.ataraid/2006-10/msg00019.html
Full instructions: http://bbossola.wordpress.com/2008/03/07/dmraid-on-ubuntu-with-sata-fakeraid/

I mean yeah that's wicked easy... instead of..
1) Enable RAID in your board's bios
2) Press CTRL+I to enter raid bios on bootup
3) Select array type
4) Choose Disks
5) Create
6) Install Windows 7 as normal

Many netcafes I've been to are running kiosks where you can't run anything but a browser. Your RDP is useless. Most places offering Internet access will have Java set up since it's used for lots of games and other random web apps.
Well not here, its a windows desktop.

Why do you think it would be any worse than a regular client? It works fine. I don't know if it's has the desktop integration you're looking for, I very, very rarely use remote desktop programs. Anything I need to do remotely I do from a terminal.
Well I to browse new torrents at work or when I'm out and if i find anything pleasing rdp home and dowload it so its ready as soon as i walk in the door no matter how poorly it's seeded.

I did think this was in Ubuntu's GUI installer now, but it's still only in the curses installer. So it's still very easy, but not in the default options. Meh, okay, it's a wash as far as ease of setup. I don't think my grandma could do either of them.
I could get a little old lady to follow those instructions I posted above over the phone.

You mentioned 32-bit vs. 64-bit and a performance advantage and > 3GB memory, and I couldn't think of any reason you would do that when you're trying to argue Linux is inferior other than if you thought Linux couldn't do that.
Whats the point in running a 64-bit operating system if you have to run emulated, outdated 32-bit applications. Sorry Photoshop & Office aren't going anywhere, there are no open-source or Linux-compatible alternatives either. Just be glad I haven't slammed Linux on gaming.

How about migrate from RAID1 to RAID5? Support for RAID6? Much better recovery flexibility?
I don't think it's really necessary, I generally have a concept of what I want a machine to be before I build it. I built my RAID-5 array years ago, and it's still a RAID-5 array despite the card supporting migration to RAID-6. RAID-5 provides more than enough protection when combined with an external backup.

Almost all of your arguments are just mind-numbingly ignorant of the actual state of Linux today. If you actually had something to say that wasn't just completely wrong or of the 'it didn't work like Windows and I did no research whatsoever to discover how to do it on a completely different system' variety I might have some respect, but this just gets tiresome around here. Every thread that mentions Linux and people like you that have never seriously used Linux and last touched it 5 years ago come out of the woodwork and treat it like its some scary thing that must be put down at every opportunity.
I always hear the same thing "blah blah blah LINUX TODAY"... It was when Vista SP1 came out when I stopped using Gentoo, are you telling me Linux is nothing like it was a bit over a year ago? But, yes i spent heaps of time researching, unfortunately for me when it came to getting help for my raid array i did include mdadm in my searches. Everything else I did like rdp I spent ages researching, updating, blah blah blah.. had to get uTorrent going and yes it was functional... but when I could no longer connect because for some stupid reason despite being able to go XP -> Vista or Vista -> XP.. all of a sudden the Linux rdp no longer worked from Vista.. also it is slow and less-responsive in comparison to Vista and 7, load times for basic tasks are annoying. Linux ridiculously under-utilizes resources which is stupid in my opinion.

But wait, weren't we talking about security? Anyone want to get back to that? I'm sick of fighting FUD.[/QUOTE]
 
So I think I'll be ok on that one.
That does not make it better.

"driver-based raid" or "driver-based software raid" is the non-linux non-derogative term for it. As for RANDOM proprietary vendor, it's fucking Intel dude. On that note I decided to look it up and fuck me dead, if you want to install Linux on an intel driver-based raid there's like 3 pages of commands to type.. what a load...
No, everyone I've ever met refers to it as fakeraid or motherboard raid. I've never heard it referred to as 'driver based software RAID'. But whatever this is not substantive or relevant. The point is why should the Linux kernel developers implement every vendor's proprietary RAID disk layout when they have their own better implementation already? Why are you not up in arms that your Intel RAID doesn't work on an AMD motherboard? But nevertheless, they made it work anyway, just so that people like you could have access to your data and people like me can easily work on random computers we come across, yet you still complain about it.

Nobody would install Linux on fakeraid because that would be retarded. Of course it's not easy, it's dumb and a completely silly thing to do. Installing on Linux's built-in software RAID is quite easy. You are completely set in your ways as a Windows user, kludges and all. Or you're being intentionally obtuse.

I don't think it's really necessary, I generally have a concept of what I want a machine to be before I build it. I built my RAID-5 array years ago, and it's still a RAID-5 array despite the card supporting migration to RAID-6. RAID-5 provides more than enough protection when combined with an external backup.
Again, 'good enough for me' doesn't mean 'better'.

It was when Vista SP1 came out when I stopped using Gentoo, are you telling me Linux is nothing like it was a bit over a year ago?
Do you really expect me to believe that when the substance of basically every complaint you've made has been 'it doesn't work like Windows and I can't be arsed to learn the Linux way'? I would think that if you had managed to bend your Windows-molded brain around getting Gentoo running on your machine that you would've been able to figure out the very trivial issues you've outlined, or opened your mind enough to try solutions that actually fit into the Linux ecosystem instead of trying to sledgehammer the Windows way into Linux. Guess not.
 
Also in the context of a desktop environment, I've found Linux to be slower and less responsive. Say for a simple task like loading firefox on my Windows 7 machine is perecptionally instant, wheras when I've used linux there has been a wait time, sometimes quite a long wait time. Linux just does not seem to utilize all the resources at its disposal, Windows preloads software you use most often into ram on boot and while a Linux user will claim that having nearly 4GB of ram used before actually loading any progams is wasteful I'm very pleased with this, it means most things are instant. Its like buying a new sports car and leaving it in a garage and never driving it. I'm not worried that i'll run out of ram as Windows can dump this ram with the swiftness!

I have found the absolute opposite to be true.

My linux install boots (from boot manager to desktop) in less than half the time of Windows 7, and once linux is booted the desktop is fully useable right away. I click on my firefox icon and firefox loads instantly. on windows 7 however, I am still waiting for the system to load. I can sit and look at the desktop, and click the firefox icon 7 times, and still not have the damned thing load or respond.

Even after windows has caught up after its problems at boot, My programs load much quicker in linux. The UI also feels lighter and more responsive, and the whole system uses MUCH less RAM. (not that this is a problem for me anymore, but I digress.)
 
Back
Top