Why Linux Is More Secure Than Windows

Quite frankly, the Linux vs. Windows debate is getting quite boring and repetetive. Each have their strengths and weaknesses (which is why I dual boot both). Allow me to sum up the real advantages and disavantages of each system here in an as much as possible unbiased manner:

Windows 7 Advantages:
  • Software Compatibility: Almost every piece of software out there has a version that can run under Windows.
  • Hardware Compatibility: Functioning drivers for almost everything exist for Windows.
  • Gaming: Windows is hands down the best platform for PC gaming. There is no competiton here at all.
  • Ease of use: Windows is still slightly easier to use than Linux for most people, but this gap is shrinking QUICKLY, and in a year or so, I'm not sure we will still be saying this.

Linux Advantages:
  • Free: Free is my favorite price, especially compared to an OS that in many cases retails for above $200. I can build a complete functioning computer for that...
  • Free Software: Just like the OS, almost all the software out there for it is free too.
  • Stability: On the same boxes, Linux has longer uptimes and software crashes less often. Windows has improved a lot in this regard though.
  • Security: Linux still holds the crown here, but again, windows has improved a lot with the releases of Vista and 7.
  • Lightweight: Linux uses less RAM, storage space, and in some cases less CPU power doing the same tasks as Windows. The task scheduler and memory management also functions a lot better leading to an all around smoother and quicker functioning machine for most applications. (games being the most obvious exception)


END OF DISCUSSION!
 
Zarathustra[H];1036026836 said:
Quite frankly, the Linux vs. Windows debate is getting quite boring and repetetive. Each have their strengths and weaknesses (which is why I dual boot both). Allow me to sum up the real advantages and disavantages of each system here in an as much as possible unbiased manner:

Windows 7 Advantages:
  • Software Compatibility: Almost every piece of software out there has a version that can run under Windows.
  • Hardware Compatibility: Functioning drivers for almost everything exist for Windows.
  • Gaming: Windows is hands down the best platform for PC gaming. There is no competiton here at all.
  • Ease of use: Windows is still slightly easier to use than Linux for most people, but this gap is shrinking QUICKLY, and in a year or so, I'm not sure we will still be saying this.

Linux Advantages:
  • Free: Free is my favorite price, especially compared to an OS that in many cases retails for above $200. I can build a complete functioning computer for that...
  • Free Software: Just like the OS, almost all the software out there for it is free too.
  • Stability: On the same boxes, Linux has longer uptimes and software crashes less often. Windows has improved a lot in this regard though.
  • Security: Linux still holds the crown here, but again, windows has improved a lot with the releases of Vista and 7.
  • Lightweight: Linux uses less RAM, storage space, and in some cases less CPU power doing the same tasks as Windows. The task scheduler and memory management also functions a lot better leading to an all around smoother and quicker functioning machine for most applications. (games being the most obvious exception)


END OF DISCUSSION!

My dad can beat up your dad! :D
 
Zarathustra[H];1036026790 said:
I have found the absolute opposite to be true.

My linux install boots (from boot manager to desktop) in less than half the time of Windows 7, and once linux is booted the desktop is fully useable right away. I click on my firefox icon and firefox loads instantly. on windows 7 however, I am still waiting for the system to load. I can sit and look at the desktop, and click the firefox icon 7 times, and still not have the damned thing load or respond.

Even after windows has caught up after its problems at boot, My programs load much quicker in linux. The UI also feels lighter and more responsive, and the whole system uses MUCH less RAM. (not that this is a problem for me anymore, but I digress.)

Well just like installing the OS and software may take a little longer, booting my machines is something I'd be lucky to do once a month, I know i've gone 6 months without doing it before. But you certainly are right Windows is unresponsive during the initial loading and does take longer to boot, but to me that is a moot point. Even Windows hibernation is very quick to recover from, with no loading lag either.... With this function there is nearly no need to reboot Windows aside from installing new software/hardware. So I don't see it as a strong argument against Windows. Personally I don't believe you when you say firefox loads instantly, even if it was loading from a SSD there would still be some lag, it's simply a hardware limitation. I'm more than happy for prefetching to chew up as much ram as it likes for the performance boost it brings. When Linux finally solves this problem it'll be a much better OS.
Zarathustra[H];1036026836 said:
Linux Advantages:
  • Free Software: Just like the OS, almost all the software out there for it is free too.
There are free software alternatives for Windows too, but just like Linux's software I'd prefer not to use them. Free software at the expense of losing compatibility with GOOD software is hardly an advantage
Stability: On the same boxes, Linux has longer uptimes and software crashes less often. Windows has improved a lot in this regard though.
Since I installed Windows 7 it has never crashed, nor any software I have loaded. I have been running it for about a year. You only get crashes when you load shit software onto your OS.
Security: Linux still holds the crown here, but again, windows has improved a lot with the releases of Vista and 7.
I don't see that, for I haven't had a virus since well before Vista came along. Security is all about the user and the popularity of the OS (the drive to exploit it).
Lightweight: Linux uses less RAM, storage space, and in some cases less CPU power doing the same tasks as Windows. The task scheduler and memory management also functions a lot better leading to an all around smoother and quicker functioning machine for most applications. (games being the most obvious exception)
An advantage if you have bought underpowered hardware. For those of us with loads of ram and powerful enough cpus this 'advantage' quickly becomes a disadvantage.
 
erm i don't think i meant hibernation.. i think thats where it dumps all the memory to the hard disk, but now it keeps power to the ram and shuts everything else down... whatever they call that..
 
There are free software alternatives for Windows too, but just like Linux's software I'd prefer not to use them. Free software at the expense of losing compatibility with GOOD software is hardly an advantage
I've found that, for the most part, the better applications for Windows are free. ImgBurn, Mp3tag, Virtual CloneDrive, foobar2000, FileZilla, Handbrake, Keepass, Abiword, Notepad2, Notepad++, SumatraPDF, CCleaner, Defraggler, uTorrent, 7-Zip, Universal Extractor, TrueCrypt, etc., etc.. The commercial counterparts to many of these programs are lackluster.

You're really making a generalized attack against free software because it suits your position, not because it makes any particular sense. Just out of curiosity, of the 17 programs I listed, how many do you have on your Windows machine currently?

Since I installed Windows 7 it has never crashed, nor any software I have loaded. I have been running it for about a year. You only get crashes when you load shit software onto your OS.
Not necessarily true. I've had Windows services (including Explorer) crash on me in my use of Windows 7, which suggests faults with OS code. No OS is 100% stable even without any third-party software.
 
Not necessarily true. I've had Windows services (including Explorer) crash on me in my use of Windows 7, which suggests faults with OS code. No OS is 100% stable even without any third-party software.
Explorer will never crash without third-party code. Are you overclocking?
 
Zarathustra[H];1036027496 said:
There is no such thing as software that will never crash. Even the best software crashes, it just does so less frequently.
That's not even close to true. It's difficult/prohibitively expensive/near-impossible to create non-trivial bug-free software, but it's reasonably simple to prevent crashes.
 
That's not even close to true. It's difficult/prohibitively expensive/near-impossible to create non-trivial bug-free software, but it's reasonably simple to prevent crashes.

Your statement is not even close to true. Programs crash all the time, for a variety of reasons. A blanket statement that a program can never crash is false from the onset.
 
I've found that, for the most part, the better applications for Windows are free. ImgBurn, Mp3tag, Virtual CloneDrive, foobar2000, FileZilla, Handbrake, Keepass, Abiword, Notepad2, Notepad++, SumatraPDF, CCleaner, Defraggler, uTorrent, 7-Zip, Universal Extractor, TrueCrypt, etc., etc.. The commercial counterparts to many of these programs are lackluster.

Oh no you're right, free software is often better than the paid versions... The free software I use that is far better than the paid versions. Well firstly I don't actually have A/V installed but I use them all the time... MalwareBytes, SAS, AVG.. then Irfanview, Chrome, Firefox (plus all browser plugin like java, flash, silverlight, air ra ra ra), Adobe Reader, uTorrent, Skype, ImgBurn, AutoGK (ok haven't used in years), MeGUI, WinAmp (suppose it comes free and I don't use the pro features), CCCP (media player classic HC), CutePDF, Core Temp, CPU-Z, Prime95, nLite, vLite, RivaTuner...

But publishing software just is unbeatable in the paid versions...
 
Not necessarily true. I've had Windows services (including Explorer) crash on me in my use of Windows 7, which suggests faults with OS code. No OS is 100% stable even without any third-party software.

I must say something else has to be going on for Explorer or services to be crashing, I've had Win7 installed since the beginning of October and on top of that I was slack and upgraded it from a >1 year old install of Vista... I have heaps of programs and games installed, updated through different versions of software etc, my registry must be getting mighty big by now. Your problems surely must be traced to some sort of malware like Nero, Roxio or iTunes...

I see computers come in that hang/crash on explorer all the time, but it's always traceable to some sort of poorly written or malicious software installed...
 
While the blanket response of "it must be malware" is typically a convenient scapegoat for issues related to Windows (which is otherwise absolutely without flaw, of course — Microsoft made it!), that simply was not the case.
 
Back
Top