The “Mac Tax” Debate

I am a telephone PC consultant for my University. And from a strictly troubleshooting point of view, I wish every one used Mac OSx. Its about 1000x easier to troubleshoot network problems with. Windows isnt exactly hard, but talking an 75 year old professor through resetting TCP/IP gets difficult with Windows. Mac has a very easy visual interface, whereas Windows can sometimes be confusing for folks.

Another advantage that I think Apple has is that they make the hardware and the software. I know they get processors from Intel and video from everyone Intel, ATI, Nvidia. Needless to say engineering the software to get all the hardware to work would be easier and more stable if you are working with 4 vendors instead of 1,395 like im sure microsoft has to.
 
See, I wouldn't call them sheep. There's nothing wrong with Apple computers, and lets be honest, more than that they are pretty damn nice computers.
For some people, price per performance is not the be-all, end-all measure of a computer. Instead, they might put more weight on style, status and image than others. This is not unique to Apple's PCs or else companies like alienware, voodooPC and maingear (to an extent) would not exist.

The issue comes in when these folks insist that their computer is just as fast or faster than equivalently (or close enough) equipped, but cheaper, systems.

Absolutely 100% agreed... except about the sheeple part because... well... because it's funny. :)

And sheeple buy products because of marketing and not because they may or may not be better. "Best" or "Better" is relative on so many aspects it can't adequately be covered.

Are Macs the best computers on the market? Hardly, as such a thing simply doesn't exist.

Are they better? First issue would have to be answered is: better than what?

I would argue for them and say the amount of technological innovation is amazing, yes - look at the actual computer inside the MacBook Air, it's one tiny board, add a keyboard and a display and wham, you're done, so very nicely done piece of hardware. The OS itself? Nothing special, seriously. It's not. It's just an OS like any other - and I can do anything in OSX that I can do in Windows, or Linux, or whatever OS is currently available today as a distribution it seems.

In fact, I'd argue the only singular aspect of OSX that makes it "special" is that it's designed from the ground up to be installed on only "Apple-labeled hardware" and requires a rather creative hack to actually get it - meaning a pure legitimate retail OSX DVD - to boot and install the OS on (go figure) non-Apple labeled hardware. Which is precisely what I did on Friday using my OSX Leopard 10.5.4 retail DVD (not a copy, the real honest to goodness DVD) and a bootable CD containing 10MB of code that allows me to boot the retail Leopard DVD and then install it.

Am I breaking a "law" of some kind? The more important question is: do I fucking care? I paid for OSX Leopard, it's mine, I'll do what I damned well please with it. We have entirely too many stupid laws in this world, especially in the US. My Wife has to go to court tomorrow to answer for walking across the street to catch a damned bus home from the library. I mean really... what a civilized society we're in that taking a "shortcut" that's 60 feet across the street instead of walking 1200 feet as a detour to the closest stoplight and crossing zone then back another 1200 feet to the bus stop becomes illegal... I'll never figure it out.

Yes, that's an oddball analogy but, dammit, I wanted to make it because I'm pissed about it. ;)

I fully agree that Apple simply charges too much for what you actually get with their products compared to equivalent hardware from other manufacturers that can provide the same level of functionality or even more, that's it.

I guess the question is: why do they charge so much?

But then again... we've had this debate in the past and I used a Rolex vs a Timex for an analogy. They both go on my wrist, they both tell the same time, they both have the same functionality, yet one aligns itself with form (look and feel) over the other (rudimentary look and pure functionality). One person argued my Timex would lose 1 second a day and that's simply not the case, and if you were to use 1 single second a day as the basis for paying $15,000 for a Rolex over a $50 Timex, you've got other issues that I simply can't begin to fathom...

Do people - note I'm being nice to the sheeple by referring to them in this manner - pay more to get the "Mac" look and feel? Most definitely, there isn't anyone here or anywhere on the planet that can debate against that point; I don't even have to make a dare that someone try as they'd lose before they even opened their mouths.

Is there a really REALLY good reason to pay that premium? No, and that's the gist of the entire debate.

Oh, silly me, there is a REALLY good reason, at least from Apple's perspective.

It's that 40% profit margin they've been riding for over 25 years now. How could I forget that...
 
Is there a really REALLY good reason to pay that premium? No, and that's the gist of the entire debate.
Well, for some, the "look and feel" is the sole reason why some buy Macs as opposed to PCs. That's what Apple sells you on, and they do that pretty effectively, profiting more per piece of hardware sold than probably anyone else on the planet save for the super-boutique vendors.

Now, if that's someone's reason, it seems silly to assume it isn't a "good" reason from their perspective, don't you think?

Now, I'm fundamentally a PC guy, but I accessorize my PCs with Apple hardware (Cinema Displays, keyboards, iPods, etc.). Often times the construction and workmanship and quality control is better than with other hardware manufacturers, but for the most part, it's the "look and feel" for me.

Interestingly, it seems almost as if you're pissy that Apple makes more money than other vendors. That's...weird.
 
That's what Apple sells you on, and they do that pretty effectively, profiting more per piece of hardware sold than probably anyone else on the planet save for the super-boutique vendors.

Now, if that's someone's reason, it seems silly to assume it isn't a "good" reason from their perspective, don't you think?

Now, I'm fundamentally a PC guy, but I accessorize my PCs with Apple hardware (Cinema Displays, keyboards, iPods, etc.). Often times the construction and workmanship and quality control is better than with other hardware manufacturers, but for the most part, it's the "look and feel" for me.

Interestingly, it seems almost as if you're pissy that Apple makes more money than other vendors. That's...weird.

I bolded the point you made to make another one: being "sold" by Apple = marketing, as I mentioned earlier.

Am I pissed they make a great profit on their machines? No, not pissed at all. I'm pissed that they don't respond to customer requests and consider what customers want - or dare I say what customers would like to see in their products.

Blu-Ray drives and support, anyone? Screw licensing, people want it, and that means people will pay for it, right? Put a Blu-Ray drive in a brand new MacBook that just hit the market and jack the price up another $500 so it's a solid $1900 or so - just like the MacBook Air almost - and guess what? People would line up in droves to get one as though it was the 3rd generation iPhone that can wash your dishes and fix dinner for you too... :p

I get the point, we all do, and this "debate" thread is getting threadbare already... bleh.
 
Now, if that's someone's reason, it seems silly to assume it isn't a "good" reason from their perspective, don't you think?
I think in term s of our argument, 'good' is used in place of logical. There is no logical reason to buy a mac over any other particular pc brand.

Preferences based on 'look' 'feel' and other subjective imeasurables don't fit in a logical decision...
 
I guess you can call this personal opinion, but folks that actually care more about how something LOOKS are generally shallow folks compared to actually being your business person that gets actual work done.

That's another complaint I've got with Apple... They're marketed, and widely used for, your "artsy" "music" "creative" types. Without your folks in the day to day business- those folks wouldn't have money coming in to start with. Windows is what business is built on, and that flows over into Macs.
 
Preferences based on 'look' 'feel' and other subjective imeasurables don't fit in a logical decision...
That's ridiculous. You're suggesting that buying any product over any other comparable product based purely on aesthetic qualities is illogical?

I don't imagine you buy clothing based on "look and feel", do you?
 
That's ridiculous. You're suggesting that buying any product over any other comparable product based purely on aesthetic qualities is illogical?

I don't imagine you buy clothing based on "look and feel", do you?

That's a trick question, right? Gotta be... ;)

Logic = Left brain activity...

Creativity = Right brain activity...

Somewhere down the line someone will find a way to make the obvious joke about "Apple owners/buyers are in their right minds... and everyone else is stupid." :D
 
PM me later in the week. I'm serious. :)

I start working tomorrow at 7am and will be swamped all the way through the weekend. I won't have time to write a detailed post during that time, but I'll be happy to go through some examples for you afterwards.

Well, no offense, but I don't really feel the need to jack with sending a PM for something that I'm just accepting as an offer you made. If you don't remember to post it here, no biggie, but I don't feel like being someone's PA.

Doesn't your Mac have some sort of daily planning prog you can set yourself a reminder in? I think MS sells Outlook for Macs. ;)

All in good fun! I'm just curious as to what makes multi-tasking so gosh darn brilliant on a Mac. Alt+Tab seems to work wonders for me.


See, I wouldn't call them sheep. There's nothing wrong with Apple computers, and lets be honest, more than that they are pretty damn nice computers.
For some people, price per performance is not the be-all, end-all measure of a computer. Instead, they might put more weight on style, status and image than others. This is not unique to Apple's PCs or else companies like alienware, voodooPC and maingear (to an extent) would not exist.

The issue comes in when these folks insist that their computer is just as fast or faster than equivalently (or close enough) equipped, but cheaper, systems.

Bingo Bango!

That's exactly how I feel. It's like build quality and all that... yeah, Macs *are* nice. Shouldn't they be? Because the build quality on other $2k computers is pretty nice too... I'd be hacked if they weren't. But it's not like they have inherent computing power unavailable to Windows. It's just a different OS. I (pending Serpico's reply) still have never found any "killer app" or function or capability that's not available cheaper in a Windows environment.

Maybe Final Cut is rock awesome, but there are several video editing solutions... pros use all of them and produce pro results. Plus, even then, it don't think they have the dominance the way Photoshop does. PS is on top because it *is* the best, bar none. There is just an endless list of crap that you can't get with Gimp or PSP. Plus, PS runs on Mac and Windows.

So, I still haven't found anything inherent to Macs that makes them better... but they are more expensive.

P.
 
Actually, FAT32 came about with Windows 95 OSR 2.0 (a service pack, go figure), sorry. And USB support? Windows 95 OSR 2.5 (another service pack, go figure)...

OK, my memory was semi off on the time line of when those were available for existing computers (win 98 vs 98 se) but quoting from MS

OSR2 was designed to be preinstalled on new computers by computer manufacturers. One of the main components, the FAT32 file system, requires that the computer's hard disk be repartitioned. For this reason, OSR2 is not distributed to resellers.

It was not available for download and I'm not sure if MS would ship it to end users or not. No matter what, for most computer users, if they wanted Fat 32, they bought 98.
 
See, I wouldn't call them sheep. There's nothing wrong with Apple computers, and lets be honest, more than that they are pretty damn nice computers.
For some people, price per performance is not the be-all, end-all measure of a computer. Instead, they might put more weight on style, status and image than others. This is not unique to Apple's PCs or else companies like alienware, voodooPC and maingear (to an extent) would not exist.

The issue comes in when these folks insist that their computer is just as fast or faster than equivalently (or close enough) equipped, but cheaper, systems.

I bolded the part that I take issue with. Most of what you say is true for the most part. Apples arent bad machines. They are just overly priced. This is because they have no direct competition using the same OS. You could say Psystar, but I really dont think they count as competition yet.

You can not lump companies like VoodooPC, Maingear or Alienware in with Apple. These are enthusiast performance PC builders. While some do buy these systems because of the name, they got their name for rock solid high end, overclocked, extreme fit and finish machines. You paid for the overclocking, for the wire management, for the cases, and for the extra work that went beyond simply slapping parts in a case. The burn in with print outs of PSI runs or benchmark programs. Can you now see how your comparing Apples with oranges?
 
Or he could perhaps re-install VS2005 after reading this post and never have those issues again. With any software.

I've tries this before installing the eVGA Precision Temp monitor. The UAC box doesn't bother me that much, but after seeing a less intrusive way of doing this I prefer the OS X approach.
 
Can you now see how your comparing Apples with oranges?

Har har. :D
Actually, in a way, Apples ARE enthusiast machines. They are for style and look enthusiasts as opposed to performance (not to say they are slow). And in naming those companies I was speaking mostly towards laptops, specifically systems like the Voodoo Envy.
 
Well, no offense, but I don't really feel the need to jack with sending a PM for something that I'm just accepting as an offer you made. If you don't remember to post it here, no biggie, but I don't feel like being someone's PA.

Doesn't your Mac have some sort of daily planning prog you can set yourself a reminder in? I think MS sells Outlook for Macs. ;)

All in good fun! I'm just curious as to what makes multi-tasking so gosh darn brilliant on a Mac. Alt+Tab seems to work wonders for me.

I suggested PMing you because I didn't want to bump what will be by then a very old thread back to the top, but I'm more than happy to do so anyway. I'd do it sooner but I am absolutely swamped, very rough prep day today and tomorrow I'll be on a shoot from 7am until 10pm in the desert. I hope to get this done for you by Thursday or so.

Again, the whole streamlining of things is just that, streamlining. Works for some people, others couldn't give a crap, the same people for whom the premium paid is simply not worth it. For me, it is extremely logical and fast, and I much prefer getting real work done on my OS X machine than I do on my Windows machine, but that's just me. Work processes are very fast, very functional in comparison. I'm the guy that's impatient in traffic and wants to get something done as quickly and in as few steps as possible, just FYI. :)
 
As far as performance is concerned, I wouldn't say OSX gets faster with each new release. In my own testing, performance in Geekbench and Xbench, the two most commonly used benchmarks for general system performance under OSX, has steadily declined from 10.4 through 10.5.5 which is the most current iteration. I've done benchmarks with essentially ever point release since 10.4 (all done on Intel hardware, of course, since 10.4 was the first version of OSX for the Intel architecture).

Yes, after almost a year it seems clear that 10.5 is the first version that is a little slower than 10.4 on the same hardware. I moved from 10.2 to 10.3 to 10.4 on the same G4, and there was a definite increase in performance with each upgrade. This is the first time in my time using OS X where this hasn't followed. It didn't affect me though, since I got a brand new desktop along with 10.5 so I didn't notice a thing (much like I replaced my old PC running XP with a new one running Vista at roughly the same time, haha).
 
I suggested PMing you because I didn't want to bump what will be by then a very old thread back to the top, but I'm more than happy to do so anyway. I'd do it sooner but I am absolutely swamped, very rough prep day today and tomorrow I'll be on a shoot from 7am until 10pm in the desert. I hope to get this done for you by Thursday or so.

Seriously, if this was such a major flaw in Windows, you should have been able to throw out an example in the time it took you to write that paragraph.

If you've got to prepare a damned "report" of sorts, I hardly think that's something that is getting in the way, if you've got to go to such extremes to prove it.
 
If you've got to prepare a damned "report" of sorts, I hardly think that's something that is getting in the way, if you've got to go to such extremes to prove it.

Oh, its easy enough to write, but I'm always thorough and hate backpedalling, you know this. On top of that I truly am swamped right now. When I write it I'll do it once and then go from there. Its very different from a one-off response I can just fire off.

Nice taunting though, always a pleasure talking with you in these forums.
 
Furthermore, I'm fried right now. I'll write it up when I'm ready and can actually focus outside of work.

In conclusion, STFU.
 
In conclusion, STFU.

lol :D

I want a mac: Quad core, 2 gig min, 500 gig min HDD, no integrated screen, not miniature, and priced around 600-700. A name brand board and PSU. Seriously :(

Apple... take my money!


They keep refusing. :(

Fix my problem Serp!
 
I can build that box you want for $550 out the door... $600 shipped, with 4GB actually... :p

Psystar hasn't been building 'em nearly as long as I have since I helped start the whole damned OSx86 Project in the first place. hehe
 
Har har. :D
Actually, in a way, Apples ARE enthusiast machines. They are for style and look enthusiasts as opposed to performance (not to say they are slow). And in naming those companies I was speaking mostly towards laptops, specifically systems like the Voodoo Envy.
How can you even begin to call someone who buys for style an enthusiast? Thats like calling Paris Hilton the X-Game pro of style. Christ what is this world coming to. And had you lead off with comparing "enthusiast laptops" and not just great OEM companies with Apple, this might have gone down a different road.

As for the Voodoo Envy goes, I wouldnt buy it based on the specs I have seen. I am not saying there arent other companies out there that dont do the same thing, but Voodoo, Alienware, and Maingear built their names on high end performance systems.
 
Acutally, I do. I'm honestly claiming ignorance. I keep hearing that OSX has some implementation that makes workflow so much better and faster, but I've never heard someone explain what, exactly, is so special about it. So, please, teach, cause I'm in no place to do a trial. I don't know if there's a Mac store within hours of here.

Thanks,

P.

Ok dude, here you go, old thread bumped up to the top. I'll be honest here, I'd rather have a frigging thread debating abortion than go into this considering how hostile some people here can be (I'm positive someone will say that I'm delusional because my primary OS isn't what 95% of the planet uses), but you asked and I deliver. :)

Warning, this is fucking long:

First off, I have only about six years experience using a Mac with OS X starting with 10.2. I've used Windows for much longer, starting with Win 2.0 and DOS 3.3 in my school's computer lab. At the time I got it I was primarily an XP user but I really needed a Final Cut Pro rig so I picked up a G4 tower expressly for that purpose. Later on I got a Powerbook because I liked the thin form factor better than other laptops with that amount of power, and I could obviously run Final Cut on it as well. I really started using OS X as my primary OS when 10.4 came out because to me it was a massive leap over any other commercial operating system available at the time.

I first need to make it clear that yes, you can obviously get work done on either operating system just fine. They're just tools, plain and simple. That said, OS X in my experience is less obtrusive, "gets out of the way", and generally has much more powerful and robust UI, preview, and window and workspace management features than Windows does. This is done in a variety of ways, some are subtle differences, others are major differences, but in the end they all add up to something that makes it the better choice for work and general use for me. I don't know exactly where to start so this post will be a bit scattershot, so please bear with me.

One example of a small but significant thing done to reduce clutter and the unnecessary clicking of windows and buttons is that applications in OS X almost never steal focus from you, something that is unavoidable in Windows without a tweaking program. This is something that I wasn't even aware was a problem until after having used OS X for a couple years. It just blew right over my head until I realized why I "flowed" better on OS X. Alerts and popups didn't take me out of whatever application I was working in. This is important; I can stay in the zone doing whatever work I'm doing. Notifications are shown by the icon jumping in the dock, but that's it, nothing gets in the way and interrupts me. Furthermore, pop-up dialogue boxes (ie - yes/no/cancel or dialogue popups) do not appear as separate windows. Instead, they appear in-line in the application window that they correspond to. This even works with tabs in OS X web browsers. I can have a login box or alert appear in one tab and it will not override what I'm doing in the current tab I'm in. Again, less window clutter and it doesn't interrupt my flow, its really nice.

There are no constant notifications in the corner that such-and-such a device is plugged in or that this image or device is mounting or whatever. A mount just shows up on the OS X desktop and that's it, very simple. If I want to get in I just click it, no big deal, but the OS doesn't nag me about it. Ditto UAC (necessary btw) versus the far less intrusive admin elevation used in OS X or Ubuntu. Fortunately Microsoft knows this is an issue and I suspect it will be taken care of in SP2 or Windows 7.

Features in Windows generally have their more robust features and options hidden or obscured through multiple layers of menus and tabs, and it isn't always obvious or consistent where those settings end up being. In OS X it is usually very consistent and logical. For example, if I want to change permissions of a file in Windows it takes at least the very least five steps through menus and tabs to do so (in which case I can only see and edit what the file permissions are for SYSTEM), whereas in OS X it only takes three steps max, one of which is to enter the root password to actually make the change. Otherwise it is only two steps. Either way, it takes only one single action in OS X to see what the permissions are for every single account for a file, whereas in Vista it takes two steps just to see the SYSTEM permissions, plus an additional step to view permissions for every other account, plus another step on top of that (clicking the "edit" button) before I can change any of them. This is just one example of many of how much more streamlined and efficient the UI in OS X is. Same thing goes with changing any setting in Windows Control Panel versus doing the same in OS X System Preferences.

Another example is comparing virtual folder implementations between the two operating systems: Smart Folders in OS X versus Saved Searches in Vista. Smart Folders were introduced in OS 10.4. They are virtual folders that allow you to set parameters for their contents (ie - I can create a folder that only shows .mpeg files located in my personal user account folder larger than 15MB that are less than ten days old, or whatever). Doing it is very easy, just click the File pulldown menu in Finder, click New Smart Folder, and start assigning the rules. The resulting folder then shows up on my desktop and I can put it anywhere I like. Saved Searches is Vista's solution for virtual folders, and it isn't nearly as intuitive or powerful. First off, it is a part of Windows Search, not Explorer, so you either need to start an initial search (even a BS one) to get into the right dialogue box to set up your rules in Advanced Settings, or you hit Windows+F and pull down Advanced Settings. Then you can start setting up your rules. Unfortunately you are limited to Location, Date, Size, as well as three specific ones: Name, Tags and Authors. In comparison, there are roughly 120 Smart Folder parameters that you can set in OS X (you can specify bit rates, for example) as opposed to just the six parameters in Saved Searches. On top of that, Saved Searches can only be accessed in the "Searches" sidebar link in Windows Explorer (btw, why the hell can't you create a new Saved Search in Explorer? Makes no sense), whereas Smart Folders can be created, placed, and accessed from absolutely anywhere in the OS X filesystem. And if you prefer a shortcut in the Finder window, it can also be placed as a shortcut in the Finder sidebar under "Search For", just like in Vista (or more accurately, "just like in OS X" since virtual folders were in it two years before Vista came out).

So yeah, the Windows version is again harder to access and configure while at the same time being less powerful and functional than its OS X counterpart. That seems to be a recurring theme.

Previewing files is also miles better in OS X than it is in Vista. Quick Look is a feature that gives a full preview of a file without opening its corresponding application. Just highlight the file and press space. This works on pretty much anything: videos, pictures, Word/Excel/Powerpoint documents, PDFs, all full screen and fully scrollable. You don't even need Office installed to view the Word/Excel/Powerpoint files. You aren't compromising anything to view the files either; I have a huge 138 page PDF and a fully uncompressed 10-bit video file (812MB for 30 seconds in this case) sitting here, both opened instantly in Quick Look, both are fully scrollable/scrubbable, and optionally viewable blown up in full screen mode (just hit the maximize button on the bottom to expand it). Preview in Vista isn't as responsive, it needs to be enabled via settings, previews are restricted to the tiny little preview pane on the side of the Windows Explorer window (adding scroll bars to the Explorer window with larger files on top of it all), and most importantly it doesn't have nearly as robust file support out of the box as Quick Look does. Again, its a huge time saver compared to not having to open Office, a video player, or (UGH) a PDF viewer in Windows.

Workspace and window management is another place where OS X has big advantages. When I'm working it is generally with several applications at once across two 24" monitors. The most I'll work with is Final Cut Pro, Photoshop, DVD Studio Pro, Compressor, Sorenson Squeeze, EasyBatchPhoto, Transmit for FTP, as well as email, web browser, and IM. Photoshop alone will have multiple windows open. Even with a dual-24" desktop it is still a lot to juggle, but fortunately there are features like Expose and Spaces that make it very easy to be organized and use files across multiple applications.

Expose is a feature that shrinks windows into thumbnails, which you can then browse on the desktop and click to maximize your selection to the front. You can either apply it to show all open windows, to show all windows from a single application (useful if you have a bunch of windows open in Photoshop), or to clear all the windows off of the desktop. Furthermore, you can tab while in Expose to browse through the windows of individual applications. Assigning "all window" Expose to a mouse button or hot corner is very useful. The new Mac notebooks have expose linked to a four finger trackpad gesture; four fingers forward to expose all windows, four fingers back to clear the desktop. Again, very useful when you're dealing with a bunch of windows.

The thing is that with big applications like Final Cut Pro, desktop space is still limited even with dual 24" monitors. Spaces is a feature that helps a lot there. It allows for creating multiple virtual desktops. This sort of thing isn't anything new but the implementation and integration in OS X are excellent. Here is a picture: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/bd/Spaces.png It allows you to create up to sixteen virtual desktops, you can assign applications to open in a specific one, you can move windows between different spaces when viewing them all, you can move the spaces themselves around, and finally you can use Expose functions while in Spaces.

So for example, if you want you can view all your Spaces at once, hit Expose to display all windows within Spaces, drag a specific Photoshop window over to your Final Cut Pro virtual desktop, after which you then click into your Final Cut space and drag the Photoshop image right into your video timeline. That whole process literally takes seconds, while keeping everything tidy and discreet at the same time. Spaces also recognizes multiple monitors, so with my dual monitor setup I can have up to 32 desktops to work with (I wonder what this would be like with a Mac Pro using four 30" monitors, 64 desktops?). Switching between spaces is also very easy; either use a function key or assigned mouse button to show all of the spaces, or switch directly between them without pulling the view out by pressing Control+number (1, 2, 3...) or Control+arrow (up, left, down, right) to move between them. So yeah, it is really useful for avoiding clutter with multiple applications. Generally I'll give web/email/IM its own desktop, Final Cut Pro its own, Photoshop its own, and Squeeze and Compressor its own. And of course, configuring the layout of the spaces (columns and rows) and the assigning of applications to specific ones (ie - Firefox and Mail.app open in Space 1, Final Cut Pro opens in Space 3, DVD Studio Pro opens in Space 4, etc) is really simple and takes only a few clicks.

I have these functions mapped to my five button mouse (all window Expose is middle click, Spaces is mouse button 5). Being able to zip effortlessly around my different applications makes life so much easier, I really can't work as quickly or effectively without it.

And of course, you can also command-tab (aka - alt-tab) the old fashioned way to switch between applications if you want to. :)

There are lots of other things in OS X that I really like. Integrated mounting out of the box of pretty much anything (ISOs for example) is very nice. Browsing network shares is super super easy; they all just appear in the Finder sidebar. I can see my other Windows and OS X shares straight away without opening separate network windows or initiating a workgroup browse on my own, very convenient. Integrated systemwide dictionary and spellcheck is cool. Easy screen sharing and remote desktop via iChat is really nice. Time Machine IMO blows Shadow Copy away, both in terms of user friendliness and functionally being remote instead of local. Little OS X things like arrow-up acting like "Home" and arrow-down acting like "End" in single line dialogue boxes is something I really miss when I'm using Windows, ditto hitting Enter to rename a highlighted file in OS X instead of a slow double-click or F2 in Windows. Column view in Finder is something I really like. Windows took its cue from Finder in the Vista Windows Explorer and this is one of the other things I wish they'd taken.

Then there is the long term stability issue (an issue with XP, likely not so with Vista). I kept a G4 desktop for five years and three OS versions with zero maintenance on my part and it ran like the day I bought it (probably a little faster since 10.4 was slightly faster than 10.3 which was slightly faster than 10.2). I can't say the same for XP, which despite my diligence and active maintenance (malware, defrags, registry cleaning) would still eventually start to creep after 2 years or so. All that said, I suspect that this will not be an issue with Vista as its stability and its ability to self-maintain is miles beyond XP's. I'll know for sure in another year but right now I'm guessing that I won't have to reformat/reinstall due to creeping slowdown in the same way that I did with XP. Speedwise, there is no contest. I have Vista and OS X running on the same hardware and OS X is faster.

All that said, in the end I do like Vista and believe that it is hands down the best consumer OS that Microsoft has ever made. I think it is a more than significant jump in stability and security over XP, and if you are a PC user then there is no other way to go. The thing is that despite all that, I get things done faster and more efficiently in OS X. Furthermore, some of the new features and design paradigms in Vista are the same ones I'd already had in OS 10.3 and 10.4, except Microsoft managed to make them more convoluted and not as functional in the process. As someone who uses both operating systems, this was disappointing for me.

The obvious problem on the OS X side is that outside of Blizzard, id, Epic, Activision, and EA games, gaming on OS X is very thin (translation - its missing Valve). If you are mainly a hardcore PC gamer that absolutely hates consoles and needs something other than Blizzard/id/EA games, then there is little point having an OS X desktop. Of course, in that case you really shouldn't be buying from a system builder period; you should be building it yourself. You get more for your money building compared to a Dell or HP, and premium brands like Alienware, Falcon Northwest, and Voodoo are the biggest ripoffs in the industry (they manage to make Core 2 Duo PCs that rival dual quad-core Xeon Mac Pros in price, crazy). Most Windows/OS X users I know either have a DIY Windows desktop and Mac notebook, or an OS X desktop like an iMac that they'll boot into Windows with to play games like Team Fortress 2, then go back to OS X when they're done. For me its OS X for work and everything else, and a separate Windows for games, basically making Vista a toy OS for me. I'm currently playing Far Cry 2 on my PC and Dead Space on my 360. Big ups to platform agnosticism. :)

Are either operating systems perfect? Of course not. I've only gone over what OS X does right but there are some daft decisions in there as well, like having Cover Flow as a "feature" in Finder. WTF, useless! Software aside, no Core 2 Duo Mac with PCI-E expansion is a massive hole in Apple's product line and I hate it. My perfect OS would be to basically have OS X that runs Windows (ok, VALVE :) ) games on it natively that I can also use with high end PCI-E video cards and a Core 2 Duo CPU. Running a Hackintosh with no consequences is a pretty easy thing these days, and it will be be even easier once EFI is incorporated into more high-end video cards. Valve writing native OS X games is another issue entirely. :) Then there is the fact that using OS X is simply different from using Windows, and for some people there is a period of adjustment (ie - installing programs in OS X generally doesn't use installers, you just drag the app from the mounted ZIP or DMG file over to the application folder. There is no registry, just .plist files and text entries for preferences in the System folder. OS X emphasizes using windows sized for their intended use, not having them be full-screen maximized all the time, and on and on).

In the end these things are only tools, and it is all about what your use and goals are. Vista is a really good operating system and if you're going to run Windows, IMHO its the only way to go unless you have a piece of software on XP that isn't Vista compatible. Whether the "Mac Tax" for the OS and hardware is worth it or not is ultimately up to you.

Ultimately, the premium isn't an issue for me at all and OS X for me provides a stronger, faster, more robust toolset and working environment compared to Windows, so I primarily use that instead. This didn't happen overnight for me (it took three years, actually). Again, its just me and your own milaege may vary. I hope this helps.
 
lol :D

I want a mac: Quad core, 2 gig min, 500 gig min HDD, no integrated screen, not miniature, and priced around 600-700. A name brand board and PSU. Seriously :(

Apple... take my money!


They keep refusing. :(

Fix my problem Serp!

Dude, I know... The day they come out with a normal Core 2 machine with PCI-E (ie - G4 Cube without the retarded pricing) will be a glorious one. Hackintosh for the time being and hope that more cards come with EFI out of the box, what else can I say? :)
 

Really couldn't have said it any better. Bravo!

Something that also bears mentioning is that Mac OS X provided a solid BSD foundation that is comfortable to old-school Unix guys, and second to none for multi-platform programming. Many C, C++, Python, Pearl, Ruby, and Java programmers prefer Mac OS X because they get all the flexibility and speed of Linux/BSD/Solaris systems, and the OS is a pleasure to write software in.

As a fan of *nix system, I administrate Linux systems at work, and use a Linux server at the house for it's speed, flexibility, and price, but when it comes to just day-to-day computing, Mac OS X offers me the environment I know and love, underneath an interface that doesn't get in my way (and you did a beautiful job covering). I can program in this machine, and not only is it a pleasure to work with, but what I write in it will work on my Red Hat machines and Windows machines as well. Win-win.
 
Warning, this is fucking long:
And as such I'm just skimming...
One example of a small but significant thing done to reduce clutter and the unnecessary clicking of windows and buttons is that applications in OS X almost never steal focus from you, something that is unavoidable in Windows without a tweaking program.
We're talking about WINDOWS getting in the way. Not a program.
Go complain to the program developers if you don't like their apps stealing the focus.

Granted- Windows could force all programs not to do this, but then you'd become OS X. The beauty of Windows is that it is largely open, and friendly to developers, hence it's huge software base.

What about chat software or emails, or even emergency alerts on your desktop that you WANT to steal your focus?

Again- if you don't like programs doing this- complain to the program developers, it's not a problem with Windows.

Furthermore, pop-up dialogue boxes (ie - yes/no/cancel or dialogue popups) do not appear as separate windows. Instead, they appear in-line in the application window that they correspond to.
I guess I'd need an example if you're talking about something within Windows to start with, but once again: Microsoft doesn't control what the program developers do. Complain to them if you don't like they way they run their popups.

There are no constant notifications in the corner that such-and-such a device is plugged in or that this image or device is mounting or whatever. A mount just shows up on the OS X desktop and that's it, very simple. If I want to get in I just click it, no big deal, but the OS doesn't nag me about it.
This one, I totally don't understand.
Can you elaborate?

The only thing that goes into the corner is the Safely Remove Hardware- and at that Windows isn't constantly asking you to use the damned device like you're insinuating.
You can't even open the device from there. More FUD?

If you're referencing Auto-Play: that can be shut off. That's the marvel of Windows: settings and options.

Features in Windows generally have their more robust features and options hidden or obscured through multiple layers of menus and tabs, and it isn't always obvious or consistent where those settings end up being.
I'll give you that one. However, only your power users would ever be using these options.
Vista has done a great job with this. Right-click your desktop and go to Personalize: bam, most of your user preferences right there. Control Panel has much improved categories.

For example, if I want to change permissions of a file in Windows it takes at least the very least five steps through menus and tabs to do so (in which case I can only see and edit what the file permissions are for SYSTEM), whereas in OS X it only takes three steps max, one of which is to enter the root password to actually make the change.
Context Menu- Properties- Security. 3 steps.

And I am not entirely convinced you want to debate security here. Windows is far more robust with multi-user networking and security.



much anything: videos, pictures, Word/Excel/Powerpoint documents, PDFs, all full scPreviewing files is also miles better in OS X than it is in Vista. Quick Look is a feature that gives a full preview of a file without opening its corresponding application.
What a change of gears. Going from how the OS gets in the way to general features?
You can use third-party programs to reach the same functionality (if not better) than QuickLook.
I guess you could say OS X wins that one simply by having it included already- but it's hardly anything groundbreaking.

When I'm working it is generally with several applications at once across two 24" monitors.
Like Windows doesn't? :rolleyes:

Expose is a feature that shrinks windows into thumbnails, which you can then browse on the desktop and click to maximize your selection to the front.
Again- this obviously isn't just how Windows gets in the way. At this point it's more of features, but I digress.

Expose is another thing you can use in Windows third-party that's bigger and better. You can give OS X a point for already having it included- but again this is hardly a ground breaking feature.



After skimming through the rest of this it all looks like it's mainly what you like about OS X which I don't see much point in debating.

I'm still looking for that example of how Windows is getting in the way.
 
Ok dude, here you go, old thread bumped up to the top. I'll be honest here, I'd rather have a frigging thread debating abortion than go into this considering how hostile some people here can be (I'm positive someone will say that I'm delusional because my primary OS isn't what 95% of the planet uses), but you asked and I deliver. :)

I appreciate you coming back to finish. You have made more backing for your position than any of the hundreds of "Artists" that I've seen spewing off on Macs in the past.

I'll start out by saying that I'm anti-Microsoft in most things, but I am even more anti-Apple, because they treat people like they are idiots (in my opinion). Also, I feel that Macs and Apple in general get away with things that MS could never do without being ridiculed into the ground, simply because they are the "little guy." I could expand on this concept, but I'm not sure that I could bring anything new into the debate.

Having said that, in your comments, I don't see so much that OSx is "getting out of the way" so much as it just has a few features you like. I don't see how Windows is in the way at all. I've simply never had an issue with the previews or searches that exist in XP. They work. I try to name my files so that I don't have to worry about previews. I should know what they are by just looking at the title.

I can't speak to Vista, I don't use it yet. I will mention however, that I've had the same install of XP since early 2003, I think. I guess I'm magic or something, because I don't have any problems with it bogging down... it's just old hardware and new programs are more demanding, so they run slower.

Overall, what I see is just that you've found a set of features you like. Much of what you pointed out doesn't mean much to me, as I wouldn't gain anything from those features. Maybe at work I would some gain, because there I'm much more likely to have multiple programs and windows going... except OSX is a really poor corporate OS. It just doesn't have the compatibility.

I think there's a lot of things that might be nice add-ons for Windows (and I figure you could probably get most of the features you listed as third party software), but I can't see any killer features there that make me think I'd save any time at all on a Mac machine. And there's the endless list of programs and things that aren't available on Macs that I couldn't have (like CS4 with 64bit support). And the fact that I have much less control over my system hardware, and thus I'd end up spending more money on a slower system.

Oh, and if you want a "fast" PDF reader, try the Foxit reader. You can open a 4.5mb 200 page PDF file in the blink of an eye, and that's on an old Althlon XP with 512mb of ram. I'm not sure why Acrobat is such a turd sometimes.

P.
 
I appreciate you coming back to finish. You have made more backing for your position than any of the hundreds of "Artists" that I've seen spewing off on Macs in the past.
Ahhh, yea... I forgot to commend him on that as well. Kudos.


II am even more anti-Apple, because they treat people like they are idiots (in my opinion).
You're not alone there. Macs are designed to be simple and easy to use for the moron, which is why the vast majority of computer enthusiasts are either using A) Windows or B) Linux, or C) Both.

Having said that, in your comments, I don't see so much that OSx is "getting out of the way" so much as it just has a few features you like. I don't see how Windows is in the way at all.
Well, I'm glad it's not just me that failed to find an example.


I'm not sure why Acrobat is such a turd sometimes.
It's like a cardial rule over at Adobe to make stuff as "big" as possible.
Granted- most of their "big" apps like Photoshop are rightly so, but Acrobat Reader? Why the heck that has to get slower with each release is beyond me.
Foxit Reader Download = <3MB
Adobe Reader Download = <34MB
WHAT THE HECK?
 
For it's own hilarity, I also have to add that not five minutes after I posted, I got BSOD. I can't remember the last time that happened. Ah well... like I said, it's old hardware. I think it's finally starting to wear out.

P.
 
I'm still looking for that example of how Windows is getting in the way.
The only answer you're going to get that'll satisfy you is obviously "you're right, I'm a total dolt". Seems a tad unfair to me, don't you think?
 
For it's own hilarity, I also have to add that not five minutes after I posted, I got BSOD. I can't remember the last time that happened. Ah well... like I said, it's old hardware. I think it's finally starting to wear out.
For me? Windows 98 SE, when in the normal operations.
Otherwise XP has all been because of something I had intentionally done (tweaking drivers or whatnot), that should be expected. Vista hasn't BSOD on me yet- and I really don't care about messing with drivers anymore ;)

The only answer you're going to get that'll satisfy you is obviously "you're right, I'm a total dolt". Seems a tad unfair to me, don't you think?
Nope. I just want it backed up, and myself (and at least I'm not alone here) have yet to see an example of Windows getting in the way.

Don't make claims if you can't back them up, especially if you AGREE to back them up.
 
Well, Serpico responded to this:
I keep hearing that OSX has some implementation that makes workflow so much better and faster, but I've never heard someone explain what, exactly, is so special about it.
I think he adequately described key OS X features that help improve end-user workflows (even omitting some, like AppleScript and Automator).

I'm as unbiased as he is, I think -- I'm a PC and Mac user -- and if I had no OS X experience, I would've been satisfied with his answer. If you aren't, well, there's really not a whole hell of lot he (or anyone else) can do.

So, like I said, the only answer you're going to like is "you're right; I'm wrong".
 
Actually, he was responding to this.

The software is ~the same, it's just the OS that doesn't get in your way.
Can you explain how it does?

Do you really want point-by-point examples of UI streamlining and OS features that speed up working with the same files between multiple programs at the same time, compared to doing the same tasks in Windows?


And yes, I still want my point-by-point examples of how Windows gets in my way.
 
One example of a small but significant thing done to reduce clutter and the unnecessary clicking of windows and buttons is that applications in OS X almost never steal focus from you, something that is unavoidable in Windows without a <snip>
Alerts and popups didn't take me out of whatever application I was working in. This is important; I can stay in the zone doing whatever work I'm doing. Notifications are shown by the icon jumping in the dock, but that's it, nothing gets in the way and interrupts me. Furthermore, pop-up dialogue boxes (ie - yes/no/cancel or dialogue popups) do not appear as separate windows. Instead, they appear in-line in the application window that they correspond to. This even works with tabs in OS X web browsers. I can have a login box or alert appear in one tab and it will not override what I'm doing in the current tab I'm in. Again, less window clutter and it doesn't interrupt my flow, its really nice.

There are no constant notifications in the corner that such-and-such a device is plugged in or that this image or device is mounting or whatever. A mount just shows

If the notifications aren't important, then I think Macs way sounds like a decent way to do it. Yes/No dialogs associated with the tab sounds pretty good too.

The 3rd example strikes me as irrelevant. First of all, I'm pretty sure you can have it default to whatever you want (such as don't do anything when said media is inserted.
I also don't get tons of notifications about devices being installed, unless I'm installing and uninstalling lots of USB devices, in which case I'd think that would take me out of whatever zone I'm in far more than any notification.

up on the OS X desktop and that's it, very simple. If I want to get in I just click it, no big deal, but the OS doesn't nag me about it. Ditto UAC (necessary btw) versus the far less intrusive admin elevation used in OS X or Ubuntu. Fortunately Microsoft knows this is an issue and I suspect it will be taken care of in SP2 or Windows 7.

Don't use OS X, but I do use Ubuntu (in virtual box) at work, and as I recall, the main thing that makes it better is that it remembers sudo authorizations. But aside from that, I'm not sure I see how it's much different....you still have a window pop up and in the case of Ubuntu type in the PW.

The problem is less with UAC than the fact that certain actions (such as moving a file to/from certain directories) causes a UAC prompt, a prompt asking you if you really want to move the file and I believe a 3rd prompt related to the action. What MS needs to do is build in rules to remove the 2nd and rd prompts that aren't really UAC prompts at all.

Features in Windows generally have their more robust features and options hidden or obscured through multiple layers of menus and tabs, and it isn't always obvious or consistent where those settings end up being. In OS X it is usually very consistent and logical. For example, if I want to change permissions of a file in Windows it takes at least the very least five steps through menus and tabs to do so (in which case I can
only see and edit what the file permissions are for SYSTEM), whereas in OS X it only takes three steps max, one of which is to enter the root password to actually make the change.

1. Right Click on File/Click properties (in my book, that's one step).
2. click on security tab
3. click on edit button

Edit user you want....2 screens. I can see it as 4 or 5 steps, and I don't think that permissions are obvious in windows, but do you think the typical mac user ever touches permissions? I'm certain that the vast majority of Windows users have no desire to mess with those settings. It really seems it's a feature that mostly appeals to System Admins.

As for the individual users, I believe that type of granularity is desirable for most people that care about this type of feature. If you wanted to make it apply to to all users, you could create a user group, put everyone in that group and assign permissions that way.

I'm not denying that simplifying the interfaces is a good thing. A bad interface on the best tech in the world is a bad product, but I think this particular example comes across as nitpicking over an issue that virtually nobody moving to the mac will care about.


I'll give you points on the earch, because I didn't even know I could make a folder that had all my mpg files in it....so clearly that feature is buried more than I'd like...but then again, I tend to put all of my stuff in hierarchical folders. I like it that way.

I'm not sure how installs on the mac are, but I do know that I find windows installs much easier than Linux.....now if you use Ubuntu's search/install tool, it's not bad, but if the install fails (see Jedit) or you're doing a manual install, it's not always as easy. However, I do like that you can just move a directory from one install to another and it works. Dos was like that, and I miss that.
 
And as such I'm just skimming...

We're talking about WINDOWS getting in the way. Not a program.
Go complain to the program developers if you don't like their apps stealing the focus.

Granted- Windows could force all programs not to do this, but then you'd become OS X. The beauty of Windows is that it is largely open, and friendly to developers, hence it's huge software base.

What about chat software or emails, or even emergency alerts on your desktop that you WANT to steal your focus?

Again- if you don't like programs doing this- complain to the program developers, it's not a problem with Windows.

Do you write software? I ask, because even though I don't write windows software, even I know that most of those dialogs that Serpico feels get in the way are simply windows API calls with a message of some sort. Without a doubt, a change like this IS within MS's control. I'm not going to debate the desirability of such a change, but it's absolutely something that MS would have to do.

I'm still looking for that example of how Windows is getting in the way.

He gave you several examples, you've just chosen to ignore them or dismiss them as problems with the applications.
 
Do you write software? I ask, because even though I don't write windows software, even I know that most of those dialogs that Serpico feels get in the way are simply windows API calls with a message of some sort.
I was wanting my "point by point" example like Serpico was going to give me, not generalizations.


He gave you several examples, you've just chosen to ignore them or dismiss them as problems with the applications.

His examples WERE problems with the Applications that Windows has nothing to do with.
 
Often the very first "maintenance" tip I've seen from Mac users is to "repair permissions". All that talk about not requiring maintenance is bit generous. Likewise, corrupted plists are a nagging problem. Neither of these have a Windows equivalent. I've seen Finder crashes take down an entire system, or even lead to kernel panics. I'm talking hard crashes, in this day and age.

Definitely agree on the application focus issue. I can't help but think that part of this is inherent in how the Menu bar is dynamic in OSX vs. a static task bar (with individual File/Edit/View per app). It'd be nice for MS to create a central setting for this, e.g. "Focus Settings" in Control Panel, but it's WAY too late to see this in Windows 7. I'm afraid this is just something that the avg Windows user doesn't mind it enough that MS would make the concerted effort to change ASAP.
 
I'll give you points on the earch, because I didn't even know I could make a folder that had all my mpg files in it....so clearly that feature is buried more than I'd like...but then again, I tend to put all of my stuff in hierarchical folders. I like it that way.
It's pretty handy, I've found. I use Smart Folders to do quick sorts, like Pro Tools session files less than one month old, WAV/AIFF files that match a certain file name criteria, and so forth. If you're comparing XP and OS X, which you might be inclined to do if you hadn't made the transition to Vista in the studio environment, you'd be looking at Smart Folders vs. nothing.
 
Back
Top