The “Mac Tax” Debate

That is simply not true at all and I'm so tired of hearing this. It's about as infuriating as the stereotypes that follow the auto industry.

I've seen many of these already.The Samsung's are not even in the same ballpark.

I've seen the Voodoo Envy (is that what you posted?) only in pictures, but my disdain for glossy displays is amplified when the entire laptop looks glossy. The Envy 133 is competing against the MacBook Air, not a MBP. I'd like Vodoo to make a laptop with that construction competing against the MBP.

If you're going to post pictures of a Voodoo Envy, why didn't you just post pictures of a Falcon-NW laptop? $3K+ for a laptop? No thanks.

I should also be more specific in describing which MBP I'm looking at. I'm looking at a 15.4" MBP, not the larger version. Laptops with +17inch screens are more like desktop replacements and they don't interest me.
 
INteresting ideas, but both moot points.
First, resale value is relatively meaningless, in all the years I have worked on/built/sold computers, it is VERY rare for someone to buy a new computer with the thought of selling the old one. People use their machines until they die or are out dated, or they just want a new one. They then store the old one or hand it down to a family member.

That may apply to a PC, but you forget many Mac people are fanatics. While many do keep their Mac forever, some decide to sell them to buy another Mac. Take a look at Ebay/CL and check out the prices. I always think that there is no way a person will pay that much for outdated tech, but ads just keep appearing.

Finally, and this is an important aspect of Apple computers, MOST people do not need the computing capabilities of Apple hardware. MOST people can do just fine with a TurionX2, Pentium DualCore etc as their CPU. With 3g of ram and a decent hard drive, 80% or so of consumers will never see the difference in speed. Word, excel, the internet, dvd's, music, etc do not tax even the older,, now $999, macbook. Shoot, this week (ending today) you can get a Dell inspiron laptop from BestBuy for $500, has the PDC, 3g of ram, 160gb hd, wireless internet and a CD/DVD burner.

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8989008&type=product&id=1218006772494

For mom and pop, or the budget college student, really what more do you need? Nothing basic will run any faster with more hardware. With 3gb of ram, photoediting will be comfortable. Video editing might be rough with that cpu, buthow many people do that? Not many.

Oh I agree. For the low end few people need more than Office and the ability to burn a DVD/CD. But some of us can afford to pay more for style. These attributes matter most to me with something that I will constantly have my hands on, like a laptop.
 
I have looked at the MacBook Pro on more then one occasion since they moved to Intel. They fell within my laptop budget and had most of what I was looking for with a nice feel. In the end I am always back to the Thinkpads. Primary reason has always been the lack of screen options and I find the build quality to be top notch on the Thinkpads. I did find the looks of the old MBP's attractive but the new MBP's make me sick.

On the desktop front the PowerMac has a nice case. The iMac doesn't interest me. The Mac Mini is cool and I even have one that I got when it first came out. I have it set up in my family room where it only gets used to surf the net when I have company over. I actually like the Mac for this since it keeps my friends from even thinking about downloading crap on it. All other computers in my house are home built window PC's and if I really had a compelling reason to run OSX on one of them I would long before I bought a PowerMac just to get a nice looking PC case.

Now someone made a comment in this thread about Apple being the most profitable US company per square foot or something like that. Interesting if true but really what does that have to do with the topic? Maybe I am wrong but to most the people I know Apple is just the company who makes the ipod. Sure most know Apple sells computers but don't know enough about them to know these computers don't come with windows. So even with the high cost of a Mac making them a nice chunk of profit each time they do manage to sell one I would think the company makes far more on ipods, apple care and so on.

Anyway I really see it more like membership dues in to the Mac Club rather then a tax. Said club meets anywhere on the Internet that they can find other Mac users and occasionally at Starbucks. Where they get off on chatting about the latest ways to spin the superiority of the Mac and think up new ways to bash Microsoft. Though looking at this thread some around here must not be paying the dues.

Mac for music, video, and photo editing! lol

I am rather demanding of my desktop PC but nut so much for my laptop yet apple can not meet my needs in either category even if I had an endless supply of money to throw at it.

What I said above should not be taken personally by anyone unless the shoe fits and then by all means feel free to wear it.

If your a Mac user and it meets your needs and is within your budget thats great and feel free to enjoy it. Unfortunately in my experience though a lot of Mac users seem to be less then satisfied. Why else would the Mac community not support pointing out the short comings of the Mac's and OSX software packages? Really seems silly not to stand together on such things. What harm would it do? Worse case nothing comes of it. Best case Apple opens it's eyes and we get Blu-ray, HDMI, e-SATA, and better screen options. Along with better software packages for your money. Again how is this bad for the Mac community?

I often wonder when Apple and some of the Mac community is going to wake up and realize PC users wouldn't give a shit if we were not really looking for a viable alternative. And no amount of Microsoft bashing or apple PR spin is going to convince us that Mac's already are. Sure I could replace the computers of most the people I know with a Mac and it would meet all needs but then so would a $500 or less windows PC. Though I guess I can't complain since all this seems to have caused an explosion in Linux development over the past few years. I have 2 of my other PC's converted to Linux for about a year now. When I get a Netbook good chance it will be running Linux. At this rate it wont be long before I just give up on Apple and Mac OSX.
 
That story would have had a little more merit with me if it wasn't done by Microsoft and the first question was about Vista.
 
Here's a really good comparison:
The questions for buyers is whether or not the OS is worth the difference in hardware cost.

It is not because you can osx on the dell:D

Only if the buyer is technically adept and there are OS X drivers for all the hardware in the Dell.

All in all, I think it comes down to the OS and what you're using your computer for. Most professional musicians seem to prefer Macs. I'm not sure if that still holds for Photographers or not, but it certainly has in the past.

For most users, the advantages of the Mac don't outweigh the cost.
 
If your a Mac user and it meets your needs and is within your budget thats great and feel free to enjoy it. Unfortunately in my experience though a lot of Mac users seem to be less then satisfied. Why else would the Mac community not support pointing out the short comings of the Mac's and OSX software packages? Really seems silly not to stand together on such things. What harm would it do? Worse case nothing comes of it. Best case Apple opens it's eyes and we get Blu-ray, HDMI, e-SATA, and better screen options. Along with better software packages for your money. Again how is this bad for the Mac community?

OS X software package shortcomings? I haven't used a Mac in months, but if IIRC Apple gives you a lot of in-box software. As for Blue-ray and HDMI, I think Apple doesn't really care about supporting that yet because they want to push HD content over iTunes. Apple will probably eventually support e-SATA, but they aren't in a rush when they have FW800.
 
And the funny thing about all of that is that, supposedly, OS X is cheaper....

NOTE: I'm using only retail versions for comparison.

OS X Leopard = $129.99
Windows Vista = $159.99 (Home Basic) - $278.99 (Business) (I would have used Ultimate, but as of this post Newegg lists a lower price for it [$267.49] than for Business. Ultimate is no longer the most expensive consumer version of Vista.)

Shouldn't the equation look something like this: Cheap OS + Cheap Components = Cheap System?

But instead it looks more like this: Cheap OS + Cheap Components = Expensive System

Your using the wrong prices.

  • Nobody buys retail copies of vista (certainly not the people who are likely to buy a Mac)
  • You're comparing an upgrade copy of OS X to full retail versions of Vista
  • Upgrade versions of Vista can be installed without having a copy of XP
  • OEMs pay roughly $50 - $60 for Home Premium

Given that, you should compare upgrade versions of vista or the price that Dell/HP pay for OEM copies.

If you compare Vista Ultimate (which the dell is unlikely to come with), then you when the debate.

If you compare it with Vista Home Premium (by far the most common version of Vista), start as low as 50-70 (according to pricegrabber search). Even if that price is $90.00, it's still less than OS X.

I'm not a mac guy. Have no desire to spend the bucks to try it, but clearly they have at least 2 things going for them
  1. Great Marketing
  2. Attractive Designs

Whether or not it's worth the extra 200 bucks, really depends on what apps you use....and perhaps on the importance of aesthetics.
 
Just food for thought for those who don't have an Apple store nearby, which after talking with Supervisors at apple care, I was told even if it went to an apple store it wouldnt have helped with the parts back order fiasco that kept happening.

A year ago, my mother said she was going to switch to a Mac. A friend who bought a mac talked her out of it. Her friend loved her mac, but she said that if she didn't have an Apple store near by where she could take classes to use it, she never would have been SOL.

As a result, she went with another PC....I built it for her (which I quickly discovered is much harder than building one for myself, especially since I live 3 hours away).
 
it is VERY rare for someone to buy a new computer with the thought of selling the old one. People use their machines until they die or are out dated, or they just want a new one. They then store the old one or hand it down to a family member.

I know someone that replaces his Macbook every year and a half or so, and in each case he sell it at about 70% to 80% of its original value. I keep my machines for much much longer but I definitely get more back than I do from selling my PC stuff. The scenarios you describe are definitely true, but at the same time it isn't like Mac resale value compared to PCs is some big secret. People do it all the time.
 
I've seen many of these already.The Samsung's are not even in the same ballpark.

I've seen the Voodoo Envy (is that what you posted?) only in pictures, but my disdain for glossy displays is amplified when the entire laptop looks glossy. The Envy 133 is competing against the MacBook Air, not a MBP. I'd like Vodoo to make a laptop with that construction competing against the MBP.

If you're going to post pictures of a Voodoo Envy, why didn't you just post pictures of a Falcon-NW laptop? $3K+ for a laptop? No thanks.

I should also be more specific in describing which MBP I'm looking at. I'm looking at a 15.4" MBP, not the larger version. Laptops with +17inch screens are more like desktop replacements and they don't interest me.

You beat me to it.

Add to the fact that the Voodoo Envy with the same specs was already several hundred dollars more expensive than the Air to begin with, and now the Air has better HD specs and a halfway decent GPU. I wonder when the Envy will also bump up and how the prices will compare then.
 
I know someone that replaces his Macbook every year and a half or so, and in each case he sell it at about 70% to 80% of its original value. I keep my machines for much much longer but I definitely get more back than I do from selling my PC stuff. The scenarios you describe are definitely true, but at the same time it isn't like Mac resale value compared to PCs is some big secret. People do it all the time.

That's fine for your friend/ aquaintence, but he still represents the minority, and as I said, in my experience, that minority is so small, that the resale argument is pointless in a discussion about the s-called 'mac tax'. For those people who buy the newest and shiniest because it is, it may be a good thing to think about, but for the majority of people, especially those for whom this discussion is informative, resale value is a moot point.

Most people I sell to want the best bang/buck, and looks are secondary. Not to say it's not a consideration, but definitely secondary.
And while we are discussing looks... This HAS to be the sexiest laptop ever:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9053196&type=product&id=1218012518208
 
Well if you get the pro Macbooks the pricing gets a little bit closer. Trying to find a PC book with a 2.8GHz Core2, 4GB DDR3, 320GB 7200 HD, 1440x900 res, 802.11n, Firewire 800, 9600m GT or equivalent, DVI-D out is hard to find.

It's actually not that hard. I haven't looked at the 17" Pro, but the top of the line 15" gets a heavy beat down from this Asus.

MBP advantage:
DDR3, weight

Asus advantage:
Video card, hard drive speed/capacity, screen resolution, Bluray drive, number of ports, plus the obvious eSATA/HDMI

Not only that but the Asus comes with a 1 year Accidental warranty (on top of the 2 yr regular) and is $600 cheaper. I'm not that familiar with Asus notebooks, but I assume they're not as cheap and flimsy as Dell or HP.
 
Well it's even worse on the desktop side IMO. Even the cheapest 20" iMac starts at $1200 which is much, much more than I paid for my system including 22" LCD. Even so, it only comes with a 2.4 GHz dual-core, 1GB of RAM, 250GB harddrive, 8x DVDRW, Radeon 2400XT 128MB, 20" screen.
 
It's actually not that hard. I haven't looked at the 17" Pro, but the top of the line 15" gets a heavy beat down from this Asus.

Thanks for the look. Can you customize it to have a 2.8GHz proc? What would the price be then? The macbook Pro is 2799.00 (Damn that's steep).
Just to point out, the Mac OS X versions are complete OS's NOT upgrades. It works a bit different than Windows. The "Service packs" are the 10.x.1-10.x.2 versions. The difference between 10.0 and 10.5 are staggering and have feature differences that are more on the lines of Windows 95 - Windows 7. And whatever MS will add to that. And Apple actually takes on the core of their OS in these "Service Packs", something MS have yet to do in quite a few years. Same kernel. All improvement seem to be backed out of because they can't get it to work. Don't think I am an Apple nazi. I think MS's graphics implementations are second to none. They will always trump a Mac on gaming ground, unless you don't use boot camp drivers and pimp out Windows on your Mac. (Which you can do) All you need from Apple is the boot ROM. Free game after that.
It seems I am stuck in purgatory. Apple vs. PC thread.
 
Well it's even worse on the desktop side IMO. Even the cheapest 20" iMac starts at $1200 which is much, much more than I paid for my system including 22" LCD. Even so, it only comes with a 2.4 GHz dual-core, 1GB of RAM, 250GB harddrive, 8x DVDRW, Radeon 2400XT 128MB, 20" screen.

Your system isn't an all-in-one though so it isn't quite a 1:1 comparison there. Yes, they are both desktop but the engineering requirements are different. They're closer to notebooks, and like notebooks it isn't cheap to cram a computer and monitor into one small enclosure. An XPS One is going to cost more than a regular Dell tower, for example. That said, there are some advantages to an all-in-one design. I own both, and what you gain in space savings and near silence can actually be compelling features for some people.

Price comparing an all-in-one to a normal tower makes as much sense to me as comparing a tower to a notebook. Now, if Apple sold a standalone Core 2 Duo tower with PCI-E that was significantly more expensive than your machine without offering any other additional value, that would be a different story and a valid complaint.

And bag away on the mini, worst value ever.
 
Well it's even worse on the desktop side IMO. Even the cheapest 20" iMac starts at $1200 which is much, much more than I paid for my system including 22" LCD. Even so, it only comes with a 2.4 GHz dual-core, 1GB of RAM, 250GB harddrive, 8x DVDRW, Radeon 2400XT 128MB, 20" screen.

To be fair, the larger screen Imacs (24" and up) requires you to use a H-IPS monitor for a comparable PC build, which can go from well over $600 at the very least for a 24". Using a TN or even VA panel for the comparable PC build would be cheating, and even then the comparison doesn't quite work because you have to remember that Apple is using Laptop parts for the Imacs.

Then there are the Mac Pros, where you have that back and forth between Dells and whatever.
 
Your system isn't an all-in-one though so it isn't quite a 1:1 comparison there. Yes, they are both desktop but the engineering requirements are different. They're closer to notebooks, and like notebooks it isn't cheap to cram a computer and monitor into one small enclosure. An XPS One is going to cost more than a regular Dell tower, for example. That said, there are some advantages to an all-in-one design. I own both, and what you gain in space savings and near silence can actually be compelling features for some people.

Price comparing an all-in-one to a normal tower makes as much sense to me as comparing a tower to a notebook. Now, if Apple sold a standalone Core 2 Duo tower with PCI-E that was significantly more expensive than your machine without offering any other additional value, that would be a different story and a valid complaint.

And bag away on the mini, worst value ever.

Yeah, I think I actually had that discussion with you before and lost. Dell has started to sell all-in-ones and I don't think the price is much different than an iMac.
 
Yeah, I think I actually had that discussion with you before and lost. Dell has started to sell all-in-ones and I don't think the price is much different than an iMac.

But they use desktop class cpus
 
Really? So its like comparing two companies that are 6 years away from any sort of competition?

Actually thats not that far from the truth.

for those that dont know segas first console was released in 91, in 85 sega was not in competition with nintendo. Comparing sega to nintendo in 85 is like comparing vacuums to ninjas

vacuums ftw



and I'm happy to pay the "Mac Tax" (whether i think there is one or not is a different story)
 
Ever since Apple switched from IBM CPU architecture to x86, the only difference between a PC and a Mac is what color the operating system is, the price, and the degree to which the owner of the system has their head stuck up their own ass.

That one of Apple's bigger selling points for a Mac nowadays is the ability to boot Windows is probably the most telling thing of all. What's that, our OS sucks balls and is incompatible with all of the useful and entertaining software you want to use? Don't worry, you can be a bitch and boot into Windows while still keeping that Trendy Macbook™ look! None of your friends at Starbucks will ever have to know!

But then, I'm being overly mean to Apple. Mostly because I still remember those ridiculous ads that had doped-up college students saying they liked Macs better because they were completely incompetent when it came to using their computers. With a minimum of effort and absolutely no cost other than download time you can protect your PC from the fact that Windows has the lion's share of the market and is therefore most often targeted by malware. In the end, both Macs and PCs get the same job done, and if people want to pay Steve Jobs considerably more money than they pay Bill Gates for the same product, more power to them.
 
Another anti ms troll post by bonsai? No way :p
My thoughts exactly.

is it me, or does apple seem to operate more like a fashion company then a traditional computer company?
Not just you. I've thought this same thing ever since their big revamp in what was it, 2006?

Here's a really good comparison:
XPS: $1100, Apple: $1300
For $200 less you get a lot more computer for your money in the dell. And no glass screen.
That'll fall on deaf ears.
My M1330 outperforms every single Macbook Pro I've used. Even the $2500+ ones.
Side by side, launching the same apps.
Performance aside though, price is cheaper. Mac fans would come up with some way to distort those simple prices you quoted above.

I know Mac fans would argue with me on this: But Microsoft does not charge for their Service Packs.
You're paying $130 a pop for each relatively minor upgrade that Apple gives you in OS X. The latest, Leopard, is no different.

Shoot: XP: $390 in service packs.
If you want to throw 2000 in there, you'd get $520 in service packs.

Well, as an Apple stockholder, I can tell you that Steve Jobs very definitely does not have his head up his ass. He is a marketeer, not a Wikipedia article author. And he is utterly brilliant at it
Again- why Apple fans have more money than sense.
That entire company hinges on that guy's health. A freaking RUMOR will cause the stock to take a dive.
That, and it just fluctuates so much and is so volatile it's ridiculous.


I've seen the Voodoo Envy (is that what you posted?) only in pictures, but my disdain for glossy displays is amplified when the entire laptop looks glossy.
Leave it to a Mac fan to completely ignore the truths on their own side of the aisle...
In case you didn't notice: all Macbooks have glossy screens now, your argument kind of falls flat on its face.


I know someone that replaces his Macbook every year

Well, holy shit... That must mean everyone does it :rolleyes:


</endrant>
 
Leave it to a Mac fan to completely ignore the truths on their own side of the aisle...
In case you didn't notice: all Macbooks have glossy screens now, your argument kind of falls flat on its face.

You fail at reading comprehension. I said, "I've seen the Voodoo Envy (is that what you posted?) only in pictures, but my disdain for glossy displays is amplified when the entire laptop looks glossy.

Go look at pictures of the Envy and you will see the entire laptop looks glossy. Now go have a cup of STFU.
 
That'll fall on deaf ears.
My M1330 outperforms every single Macbook Pro I've used. Even the $2500+ ones.
Side by side, launching the same apps.
Performance aside though, price is cheaper. Mac fans would come up with some way to distort those simple prices you quoted above.
</endrant>

Hmmm, you own a M1330, a Dell M1330? And that it "outperforms every single Macbook Pro I've used". Wow, even the MBPs with discrete graphics? Launching the same apps side by side with both systems using Windows? Presumably, your M1330 doesn't have a faster GPU than a 8400m GS which is on the shipping version of the M1330. Why don't you try launching TF2 on both systems and report how well that goes?
 
I know someone that replaces his Macbook every year and a half or so, and in each case he sell it at about 70% to 80% of its original value. I keep my machines for much much longer but I definitely get more back than I do from selling my PC stuff. The scenarios you describe are definitely true, but at the same time it isn't like Mac resale value compared to PCs is some big secret. People do it all the time.

I gotta ask, are used mac buyer's stupid? Unless Apple is very slow at updating the CPUs, 18 months is an eternity....certainly it's worth 25% more to get a system that should be significantly faster, with a faster HD, Graphics Card and possibly a better screen.
 
Price comparing an all-in-one to a normal tower makes as much sense to me as comparing a tower to a notebook. Now, if Apple sold a standalone Core 2 Duo tower with PCI-E that was significantly more expensive than your machine without offering any other additional value, that would be a different story and a valid complaint.

And bag away on the mini, worst value ever.

This article is a bit old, but, clearly you can build an all in one for a competitive price without a lot of expensive engineering.

Of course it'd be easier to buy one built ;)
 
Macs are more expensive... it's clear. However, the last I checked, competition is good. So any anti-mac person here should at least understand that apple products will make MS products better.

Apples are essentially "PCs" now, so it's safe to assume you are paying extra for the right to run OSX. OSX86 is still infantile, but will probably gain traction.

BTW, this is my first post with my first apple product. I will always run windows, linux, and now OSX. I don't see myself spending any more money on software... as most of what I use is OSS and cross-platform.

Do what you want and don't judge others' computer buying decisions. We all have reasons for our decisions (well most of them... I hope)
 
Is it me, or does apple have a real problem with quality control. I have had 3 ipods over the years, and everyone of them ran slow and broke after six months to a year. I got feed up with it and switched to a zune, omg night and day. Back to the point. The mac community screwed it for the mac users with the smarts to use it. Last time I checked, most of them (mac community) don't even know what ram or rom stands for. And for video and audio editing, most of them use the software that comes on os. If they were really serious, they would buy a better suited program for their need (which most are ran on windows only). Some of my friends are mac users, and the reason they love there macs so much is because they were complete pc retards. They didn't know what msconfig was, nor did they know how to clean them temp files. Can a REAL mac user tell me what makes macs so much better then a pc in terms of functionality?
 
Stop trying to use logic and move on with your lives people.


The only way i can use 'Logic' is on OSX ;)

BTW, I'm an avid Windows user, however Logic is so hot, I'm tempted to make the switch, even if its just dual boot.
 
Is it me, or does apple have a real problem with quality control. I have had 3 ipods over the years, and everyone of them ran slow and broke after six months to a year. I got feed up with it and switched to a zune, omg night and day.

It's a shame Apple has a stranglehold on marketing for MP3 players because holy crap Zunes are amazing, especially after 3.0.
 
Is it me, or does apple have a real problem with quality control. I have had 3 ipods over the years, and everyone of them ran slow and broke after six months to a year.

Like others have stated... Its the 'perceived value' that makes macs cost an arm and a leg.

as a semi-real mac user (I use them at IADT all the time) I can say its not the functionality, its the flow and feel. (I still like my pc better for overall functionality)

Remember, not every human is a [H]ardcore computer user like most of us are. Apple knows that and HEAVILY capitalizes on it. Like some people aren't mechanics and have no idea how to swap out a thermostat in a car. (probably one of the easi

A simple dock at the bottom with 10 apps ready to use vs start menu with a hundred and one programs that come pre-installed (unless you nlite your XP disc)

In OSX, when you plug in a usb/firewire drive, it pops up on your desk top. for windows it shows in your (my)computer and you need to open that up.

Basically what I'm trying to say is most of the creative people I know aren't super tech savy and they want to get down to business. OSX lets those people have control over the creative process while OSX takes care of most of the technical stuff such as ease of saving / file structure / CD burning.

Personally, since I can't let that kind of control go, I'll always be a windows user (maybe linux SOMEDAY).
 
Is it me, or does apple have a real problem with quality control. I have had 3 ipods over the years, and everyone of them ran slow and broke after six months to a year. I got feed up with it and switched to a zune, omg night and day. Back to the point. The mac community screwed it for the mac users with the smarts to use it. Last time I checked, most of them (mac community) don't even know what ram or rom stands for. And for video and audio editing, most of them use the software that comes on os. If they were really serious, they would buy a better suited program for their need (which most are ran on windows only). Some of my friends are mac users, and the reason they love there macs so much is because they were complete pc retards. They didn't know what msconfig was, nor did they know how to clean them temp files. Can a REAL mac user tell me what makes macs so much better then a pc in terms of functionality?

Most Windows users don't know the difference between RAM and ROM.
The fact that they can use what comes with the Mac is a net positive. Buying an elements package for Photo/Video will set you back 150-200 bucks.
MSCONFIG? Really? REALLY? Do you actually think that average PC users is aware of MSCONFIG? I work in IT, and I can promise you I can find plenty of PC users that know NOTHING about windows beyond Office, Eclipse Explorer and putty.

I could argue for days about why I think the PC is a better value, but arguing that the typical PC user knows about MSCONFIG shows your ignorance about the typical Windows user easilly matches the typical PC users ignorance about Windows.

And FYI, I know developers who LOVE Macs, because they think they're the best desktop Unix box around.

It's a shame Apple has a stranglehold on marketing for MP3 players because holy crap Zunes are amazing, especially after 3.0.

From an Audio POV, the Rio Karma is still the best DAP ever made....trekstor vibez is essentially the same DAP.....but I won't buy one until they up the storage to at least 64GB.
 
Well you know, you get what you pay for.;)

But seriously, I have had similar experiences with PC (Windows) computers but the primary difference is while Apple seems to have the exclusive parts market cornered, PCs (Windows machines) do not have the same problems.

Case In Point:

I have an HP/Compaq Presario computer (I know Compaq sucks and all that) but the problem occurred when the system would not power up due to an apparent system board failure.

Needless to say the system board was not easy to replace due to the fact that the Compaq computers are designed so that only specific types and sizes of boards fit in the cases. However, to resolve this issue, I purchased a brand new minitower case and purchased an over-the-counter ASUS motherboard and put the Compaq hard drive, CD/DVD burner, floppy, etc. into the new case. The system powered up perfectly and the only thing I then needed to do was reload Windows as the new system board was not recognized by the old Windows installation.

The "problem" was fixed to my satisfaction in less than 1 WEEK. Take that in your APPLE pipe and smoke it.

* No rant intended here just an explanation of how PCs (Windows based) are superior to comparable MAC offerings except for the EXTREME PREMIUM paid by customers for parts and service.
This is the main reason why I dont buy prebuilt machines; why companies should have atleast a few people in the company that have some working knowledge of computers/ PCs, if not a full blown IT department or a local repair shop on speed dial; and why you should research OEM PCs before purchasing.

I have two Dells in my house that I have rebuilt with thrid party parts. Both I received from friends that couldnt get Dell to fix the issues. Most OEM PC builders today, use off the shelf parts and you can easily remove most of the hardware and replace it yourself. I know there is the issue with warranty When you have to have the system up and running today, which is cheaper, lost time or lost warranty?
 
From an Audio POV, the Rio Karma is still the best DAP ever made....trekstor vibez is essentially the same DAP.....but I won't buy one until they up the storage to at least 64GB.

This man speaketh the truth... ;) The Rio Karma still stands as the most badass DAP ever made, and I'm absolutely certain nothing will ever match it. You just had to own one to understand. As for 64GB, I can't imagine needing that much for just tunes. I've got a Dell Axim X50v with a 32GB CF card and a 16GB SD card in it for 48GB total and it's barely half full of content, and that's full blown Xvid movies at 640 pixels wide too - gotta love this VGA screen.

With respect to the Mac "tax" debate going on... well, I'm sitting here typing on a Hackintosh with 100% functionality for any and all OSX applications across the board. And yes, I own a retail copy of Leopard 10.5.4, but what I choose to do with it now that I own it isn't Apple's concern, they have my money, I have the OS, so that's that.

I do consider Macs to be niche products, believe it or not, they always have been. Their cost (the basic hardware itself) and the associated costs (tough to actually measure because I'm talking about time, effort, and patience on an individual level) do amount to a form of additional expense that could easily be compared to a "tax" of sorts. I read the article, I get the point of it and I understand what the author was trying - and succeeded - saying quite well.

Too bad too many "Cult of Mac" members simply can't read what the person wrote and get it without reading into it whatever their dogmas have entrenched in their attitudes and minds. I personally can't stand OSX, actually. Considering I'm the guy that released the world's first working generic installation DVD for OSx86 back in 2005, that's pretty damned ironic I'd say, and I'm sitting here running OSx86 on a Hackintosh I built.

Go figure that one out... ;)

It's an OS like any other, and the computers themselves aren't really any better than what's available from other manufacturers. I've always said the reason OSX is useful and stable at all is because of three other letters: BSD. Has nothing to do with Apple or their programmers, they were forced into a corner when Motorola pulled the plug - or the CPU, as the case may be - and Apple was shoehorned into choosing a new CPU (Intel had that, AMD simply wasn't a viable option) and a new architecture. Intel is the best thing that ever happened to Apple, actually - even more so than Motorola's decision to pull out of the CPU biz (and yes I know about IBM's foray into the PowerPC market but Motorola was the reason Apple existed and survived in terms of the processors).

I like the look of Macs, but unfortunately, function for me is infinitely more important than form. OSX is ok, but it's almost a dumbed down version of Windows in many respects. The Wife loves it, and she's a fairly creative person. I'll never understand it myself.

A dead Mac, while looking great (form) is useless (non-functional), sooo... ;)
 
Well, I can honestly say I don't understand the attraction to Macs for "creative" types.

I dabble in photography as well as having an interest in computers, and every forum I visit, I see people singing praises to Apple. They will absolutely tell you your an idiot for using a PC.

I keep hearing the phrase "it just works" over and over and over... and I think to myself, I don't know of anything on a PC that doesn't "just work" unless it's something quite in depth that most people don't ever try. It's like the guy that mentioned firewire/usb peripherals above. They don't "just" show up in "My Computer". On my XP box, a pop up comes up and asks me what I want to do with them. I can open them up and look at the files, I can play the video or music they contained, or whatever I want. To me, that's even more user friendly than just leaving me a link on my desktop. I go to different forums, and I see people complaining about their Macs not working... just like PCs! Except there are a lot fewer people out there that know how to fix them.

What kills me is that Apple has most artists so brainwashed that my friends who want to do music, video, or photo editing as a serious venture now think that they have to have a Mac to do it at the professional level. Why? Because every time they visit a forum, all the Mactards there tell them that Mac is just totally superior. They don't know any better. They aren't computer experts, so they believe what these people tell them, because Lord knows that if a pro uses something, it must be the best! Somehow they ignore any pros that use Windows.

I do my best to talk them out of these decisions, but it's no use. Now my friend that does photography is about to buy a Mac. I don't think she's ever used one before, but that's what all these other people she sees are using, so she thinks she has to have one.

I don't get it. Is Photoshop different on a Mac? Lightroom? Yes, actually, it is. Best I recall, the new 64bit versions of Adobe software won't work on Macs, only Windows.

Is Pro-Tools different? Premiere? Will Illustrator not work on a PC? Bibble?

Best I recall, it's Macs that lack the broad base of software compatibility. But for anyone so inclined, you can do any type of creative work on BOTH platforms equally well... except it'll probably be cheaper on a Windows box.

What's stupid is I believe that they think that a Mac will be faster. And they may very well be for equal speed hardware, but for the premium, you can build something better. If I remember correctly, the Mac Pro isn't a bad deal for the *exact* hardware you get, but you can get pretty close to that level for a lot less money.

I think a lot of people have had bad experiences with computers, and they think that switching platforms will magically keep them from having those same experiences in the future. What happens is that you're paying Apple a lot of money for quality equipment. I won't knock their quality; they are well made computers. But people attribute their awesomeness a lot of time to the OS, when they never stop to think that all the problems they had were on Dells or HPs that cost $600. Basically, they always buy something cheap, because they just read specs on stickers at Best Buy or Wal Mart, and they get cheap-o hardware that breaks down quickly. So they go drop $1200-$1500 on a Mac, it works better with fewer problems, and they think Apples are the best thing ever! Well duh, if you spend $1500 on a well built PC, maybe you wouldn't have had all the problems the first time around.

P.
 
The Mac tax is paid to use the computer and not be used by the computer (Windows).
The software is ~the same, it's just the OS that doesn't get in your way.
Your give an excellent example in the "pop-up on insertion of a storage peripheral". The difference between us is that I loathed it from the moment I first installed Windows XP (or was it introduced in w2k? don't remember). I don't want to be prompted to do some mindless task that the user only wants to do 5% of the time, that's ridiculous. Same goes for UAC.
Yes, I've had a Mac for a few years now, and I'm loving it.
 
The Mac tax is paid to use the computer and not be used by the computer (Windows).
The software is ~the same, it's just the OS that doesn't get in your way.
Your give an excellent example in the "pop-up on insertion of a storage peripheral". The difference between us is that I loathed it from the moment I first installed Windows XP (or was it introduced in w2k? don't remember). I don't want to be prompted to do some mindless task that the user only wants to do 5% of the time, that's ridiculous. Same goes for UAC.
Yes, I've had a Mac for a few years now, and I'm loving it.


Umm... then you realize that you can go into the properties on that periph., and turn the autoplay function off, or pick what action you want it to automatically take, or what program you want it to open with, right? Then it won't do the pop-up ever again if you don't want it to, it'll just do what you tell it to. I mean, should it have just known you didn't want to be asked what you wanted the computer to do with the device? Giving you the choice is bad?

I mean, that's the OS getting in the way? I've never had XP interfere with Photoshop at all. I don't understand what people mean when they say "Windows gets in my way."

I'm being serious here. I've never used a Mac for longer than a few minutes (I didn't think it was very user friendly, but then again, I've always used DOS/Windows), so what do people mean by the OS "doesn't get in the way."

Thanks,

P.
 
Is Pro-Tools different?
Pro Tools is sort of the exception here. The Windows version is, at this time, just horrendous. The Mac OS version is practically flawless, and a real delight to work with. It's not due to the OS itself or the hardware -- not in any part -- but Digidesign just expended so little effort on the Windows version of Pro Tools, and it clearly shows.

Thusly, if you were to come up to me and ask me what kind of machine to run Pro Tools on -- PC or Mac -- I'd say (without hesitation) Mac. It's not because Macs are better necessarily, but because Pro Tools is just such a fucking disaster on Windows.

But for anyone so inclined, you can do any type of creative work on BOTH platforms equally well... except it'll probably be cheaper on a Windows box.
I'm not sure if that's necessarily true. It's possibly true in many circumstances, but not in all circumstances.
 
Back
Top