The “Mac Tax” Debate

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I have been dancing around this whole Mac Tax debate all week because it isn’t like this is something we all haven’t heard before. But, as the week progressed, Mac folks fired back with the “FUD” comments and the debate kicked into overdrive. So who is right? Who is wrong? And, if you aren’t paying the “Mac tax,” why do you even care?

There's going to be an application tax, which is if you want choice around applications, or if you want the same type of application experience on your Mac versus Windows, you're going to be purchasing a lot of software. And even at that you're not going to get the same experience. You're not going to get things like Microsoft Outlook, you're not going to get the games that you're used to playing. There's a technology tax--Apple still doesn't have HDMI, doesn't have Blu-ray offerings, doesn't have e-SATA external disk drives that work at twice the speed of FireWire. And so you've got all of these things that are truly taxes.
 
hasnt this debate been around for a long while? something along the lines of two similar computers, spec-wise, always end up costing more for, what seems to be, no reason?

is it me, or does apple seem to operate more like a fashion company then a traditional computer company?
 
Lol, Microsoft is getting scared. It will be nice to see some better competition in the market.
 
A "Mac vs PC" debate is like those "Nintendo vs Sega" debates we used to have on the school bus back in '85.
 
Like Steve says, honestly who cares? People buy things they like.

*Waiting for someone to post a "clever" negative reiterated comment about Apple or Microsoft.*
 
Here's a really good comparison:
First, a Dell XPS, 13.3" laptop. Considered to be some of the nicer laptops out there and sold as the high end Dell (the studio lines are cheaper with similar specs, but no 13" screens).
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8989035&type=product&id=1218006772152
45nm Penryn, 4gb of ram, DVD/CD rewriter, 320gb HD wirelessN, bluetooth etc.

versus the new Macbook:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9107414&type=product&id=1218024598155
Similar cpu (100mhz slow, negligible, also penryn) Only 2 gb of ram, 160gb HD, wireless N and bluetooth and same sort of disc drive.

XPS: $1100, Apple: $1300
For $200 less you get a lot more computer for your money in the dell. And no glass screen.

The questions for buyers is whether or not the OS is worth the difference in hardware cost.
 
Here's a really good comparison:
First, a Dell XPS, 13.3" laptop. Considered to be some of the nicer laptops out there and sold as the high end Dell (the studio lines are cheaper with similar specs, but no 13" screens).
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8989035&type=product&id=1218006772152
45nm Penryn, 4gb of ram, DVD/CD rewriter, 320gb HD wirelessN, bluetooth etc.

versus the new Macbook:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9107414&type=product&id=1218024598155
Similar cpu (100mhz slow, negligible, also penryn) Only 2 gb of ram, 160gb HD, wireless N and bluetooth and same sort of disc drive.

XPS: $1100, Apple: $1300
For $200 less you get a lot more computer for your money in the dell. And no glass screen.

The questions for buyers is whether or not the OS is worth the difference in hardware cost.
It is not because you can osx on the dell:D
 
I think it exists. Do I particularly care? Nah. This is how I figure things:

Apple charges X for Product Y. If I desire Product Y, and if I feel X is a reasonable price to pay for Product Y, I buy Product Y. I don't spend too much time thinking about "well, does Competitor A offer a comparable product for a better price", since Competitor A rarely has products I deem comparable (mostly due to differences in product design).

Realistically, if you're going to play it purely by the numbers, nine times out of ten you're better off with the competitors' products. I just don't play things purely by the numbers when it comes to Apple vs. everyone else.
 
Here's a really good comparison:
First, a Dell XPS, 13.3" laptop. Considered to be some of the nicer laptops out there and sold as the high end Dell (the studio lines are cheaper with similar specs, but no 13" screens).
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8989035&type=product&id=1218006772152
45nm Penryn, 4gb of ram, DVD/CD rewriter, 320gb HD wirelessN, bluetooth etc.

versus the new Macbook:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9107414&type=product&id=1218024598155
Similar cpu (100mhz slow, negligible, also penryn) Only 2 gb of ram, 160gb HD, wireless N and bluetooth and same sort of disc drive.

XPS: $1100, Apple: $1300
For $200 less you get a lot more computer for your money in the dell. And no glass screen.

The questions for buyers is whether or not the OS is worth the difference in hardware cost.

And the funny thing about all of that is that, supposedly, OS X is cheaper....

NOTE: I'm using only retail versions for comparison.

OS X Leopard = $129.99
Windows Vista = $159.99 (Home Basic) - $278.99 (Business) (I would have used Ultimate, but as of this post Newegg lists a lower price for it [$267.49] than for Business. Ultimate is no longer the most expensive consumer version of Vista.)

And wasn't the switch to Intel based systems supposed to be a "cost savings" measure?

Shouldn't the equation look something like this: Cheap OS + Cheap Components = Cheap System?

But instead it looks more like this: Cheap OS + Cheap Components = Expensive System

WTF? Really?

I guess that savings wasn't meant to be seen by anything but Steve's bank account.


And Mac owners are supposed to be "more intelligent".... Except for how they spend their money....
 
Ok. I have my desktop that I built which is a Windows-based machine. I also have my MacBook. Yes Windows excels in the gaming industry part of things, I will say that. Now on the flipside, OSX-based machines are used in tons of major entertainment industries over Windows-based machine (Music and Movies - two biggies). Oh and and by the way, they are both PC. Steve Jobs just has his head up his @$$ thinking that his baby is just o so much more than a PC (WRONG!). There is Windows-based computers, OSX-based computers, Linux-based computers, and so on and so forth, they are ALL PCs. If you want to game use Windows. If you want to create and edit any kind of audio, video, or images use Mac. These are my opinions based on using both systems. Now, fan boys, tell me I am wrong, cause I know you are aching to. But when it all comes down to it, we are arguing over OPINIONS, not FACTS which = POINTLESS!
 
Apple products are generally priced higher over a similiar spec'ed MS machine for 2 reasons:

1. Perceived Value - Many people are willing to pay for something they perceive as more reliable. Here's an analogy with cars:
Do I purchase the Toyota when they have a relatively long history of high quality and reliability, is more expensive, and does not have as much power? Or do I purchase the comparable Ford or Chevy car that has more power, cheaper, decent quality, and potentially just as reliable (although past says otherwise)? If you didn't get the analogy... Toyota is to Apple as MS is to Ford/Chevy.

2. Supply and Demand - If Apple had 50% of the desktop PC and Notebook Market, their prices would lower drastically to continue to gain marketshare. However, the overall price would again be subject to perceived value...just like the Apple Ipod.
 
If you want to compare OS costs, you can get the FULL version of ultimate by installing the UPGRADE disc, then going into windows and installing it again.

I agree that last year there was no reason to get a mac if you were a gamer, it does SEEM that today it is easier to run the "emulator" and you have a PC gaming machine.

The thing is how easy does it work and what is the performance hit, PLUS how far behind are drivers
 
A "Mac vs PC" debate is like those "Nintendo vs Sega" debates we used to have on the school bus back in '85.

Really? So its like comparing two companies that are 6 years away from any sort of competition?

Actually thats not that far from the truth.

for those that dont know segas first console was released in 91, in 85 sega was not in competition with nintendo. Comparing sega to nintendo in 85 is like comparing vacuums to ninjas
 
Coming from the TV industry where we do a lot with Graphics and Video.... The PC Equals the Mac in every way if not passes it up. Photoshop runs just as fast, Illustrator runs just as fast, Edius does a great job for video editing.

Where your not looking is warranty support. Mac is horrible! Parts are ridiculously priced and hard to come by, the service is absolutely horrible. Granted there are a lot of PC manufacturers that are not known for thier service too...

Case in point we had a Mac G5 go down completely that was still covered under Applecare. We dont have a Apple store anywhere within three hours, so a company was contracted to come out and do the repairs. Apple ordered a power supply and a power switch and said someone would be out as soon as the parts arrived the next day. Well the Tech never came out so I called apple to see what was goign on and was told one of the parts was on back order and they couldnt tell which part it was, just had a part number. Of course I said well cant you look to see what the part is off that part number. The Apple care specialist sounded baffled and said there was no possible way he could do that. So I being frustrated enough I hung up and did a google on the part number to find out the power switch was the part on backorder. So I call back and pitch a fit because they have the power supply but not the power button.... they said lets wait another day to wait for the part to come in... frustrated and pissed beyond belief I just hung up. A week later they still didnt show up so I call back and find out the button still didnt come in, so I pitch another fit and finally convince them to send the technician out. He comes out with the power supply, replaces it and the system works... great.

After that for some reason the system decided sometimes it doesnt want to power on (press the power button and the system comes on but nothing ever comes up on screen). Sometimes it boots up fine, but the fans were running loud all the time, and the system was sluggish. I call apple with what is going on and tell them what is goign on. They say ok well let us research your problem and we will call you back. The next day I still didnt get a call back so I call them to be proactive. They still dont know what to do for me and decide to escalate my case and someone will call me back shortly. Another day passes and still no call. Of course management is going nuts because the problem isnt fixed. So they decide to Send a technician out to replace the system board. A couple days later he comes out, replaces the system board and.....THE SYSTEM WILL NOT POWER ON!!!! So He decides well the system was working half way atleast before, lets put the old systemboard back in and order some more parts. Guess what.... THE SYSTEM WILL NOT POWER ON AT ALL!!! Obviously frustrated the technician and I get on the phone with apple and let them know whats going on. They decide let's order some more parts and have him come back. Well a couple days later he came out and brought a power supply since the unit would no longer turn on. That didnt fix it. So he ordered some more parts and scheduled to come out again. Well parts were put on backorder and it was a month and a half before they came back out even with us calling apple and pitching fits. So he comes back out replaces half the parts i nthe machine and still cant get the damned system to power on. so he orders some more parts which were put on backorder again...needless to say a couple weeks went by before they came back out and still the system would not come on. So I sat the tech down confrence called apple in and told them to ship every damned part in the system out and lets replace it all. It was carried out as asked, but again parts were on back order and apple didnt seem to care at all. A couple weeks later a new technician came out and brought parts in with him only to find out he was missing the processors!!!!

The system was down for more than three months which cost us lots of money and if it werent for the promises of apple to get it working we would have just bought another machine and saved the money lost due to time down.

Just food for thought for those who don't have an Apple store nearby, which after talking with Supervisors at apple care, I was told even if it went to an apple store it wouldnt have helped with the parts back order fiasco that kept happening.

In the end Apple decided to replace the machine, so we got a shiny new Intel setup... That we couldnt use because Every piece of software we had was not Universal binary so it wouldnt work (this was all bought right as the Intel Macs were hitting the scene)!!! So we would have to buy Final Cut Studio (we had 5.0 something and 5.1 was universal), Adobe Creative Suite CS3 (we had CS2), Adobe after Effects, and a new Decklink card since the new intel Mac had no PCI slots only PCI Express.... totalling over $2300 if we were able to buy upgrade versions.

So anyway... thats my rant on apple lol
 
Coming from the TV industry where we do a lot with Graphics and Video.... The PC Equals the Mac in every way if not passes it up. Photoshop runs just as fast, Illustrator runs just as fast, Edius does a great job for video editing.

Where your not looking is warranty support. Mac is horrible! Parts are ridiculously priced and hard to come by, the service is absolutely horrible. Granted there are a lot of PC manufacturers that are not known for thier service too...

Case in point we had a Mac G5 go down completely that was still covered under Applecare. We dont have a Apple store anywhere within three hours, so a company was contracted to come out and do the repairs. Apple ordered a power supply and a power switch and said someone would be out as soon as the parts arrived the next day. Well the Tech never came out so I called apple to see what was goign on and was told one of the parts was on back order and they couldnt tell which part it was, just had a part number. Of course I said well cant you look to see what the part is off that part number. The Apple care specialist sounded baffled and said there was no possible way he could do that. So I being frustrated enough I hung up and did a google on the part number to find out the power switch was the part on backorder. So I call back and pitch a fit because they have the power supply but not the power button.... they said lets wait another day to wait for the part to come in... frustrated and pissed beyond belief I just hung up. A week later they still didnt show up so I call back and find out the button still didnt come in, so I pitch another fit and finally convince them to send the technician out. He comes out with the power supply, replaces it and the system works... great.

After that for some reason the system decided sometimes it doesnt want to power on (press the power button and the system comes on but nothing ever comes up on screen). Sometimes it boots up fine, but the fans were running loud all the time, and the system was sluggish. I call apple with what is going on and tell them what is goign on. They say ok well let us research your problem and we will call you back. The next day I still didnt get a call back so I call them to be proactive. They still dont know what to do for me and decide to escalate my case and someone will call me back shortly. Another day passes and still no call. Of course management is going nuts because the problem isnt fixed. So they decide to Send a technician out to replace the system board. A couple days later he comes out, replaces the system board and.....THE SYSTEM WILL NOT POWER ON!!!! So He decides well the system was working half way atleast before, lets put the old systemboard back in and order some more parts. Guess what.... THE SYSTEM WILL NOT POWER ON AT ALL!!! Obviously frustrated the technician and I get on the phone with apple and let them know whats going on. They decide let's order some more parts and have him come back. Well a couple days later he came out and brought a power supply since the unit would no longer turn on. That didnt fix it. So he ordered some more parts and scheduled to come out again. Well parts were put on backorder and it was a month and a half before they came back out even with us calling apple and pitching fits. So he comes back out replaces half the parts i nthe machine and still cant get the damned system to power on. so he orders some more parts which were put on backorder again...needless to say a couple weeks went by before they came back out and still the system would not come on. So I sat the tech down confrence called apple in and told them to ship every damned part in the system out and lets replace it all. It was carried out as asked, but again parts were on back order and apple didnt seem to care at all. A couple weeks later a new technician came out and brought parts in with him only to find out he was missing the processors!!!!

The system was down for more than three months which cost us lots of money and if it werent for the promises of apple to get it working we would have just bought another machine and saved the money lost due to time down.

Just food for thought for those who don't have an Apple store nearby, which after talking with Supervisors at apple care, I was told even if it went to an apple store it wouldnt have helped with the parts back order fiasco that kept happening.

In the end Apple decided to replace the machine, so we got a shiny new Intel setup... That we couldnt use because Every piece of software we had was not Universal binary so it wouldnt work (this was all bought right as the Intel Macs were hitting the scene)!!! So we would have to buy Final Cut Studio (we had 5.0 something and 5.1 was universal), Adobe Creative Suite CS3 (we had CS2), Adobe after Effects, and a new Decklink card since the new intel Mac had no PCI slots only PCI Express.... totalling over $2300 if we were able to buy upgrade versions.

So anyway... thats my rant on apple lol

Well you know, you get what you pay for.;)

But seriously, I have had similar experiences with PC (Windows) computers but the primary difference is while Apple seems to have the exclusive parts market cornered, PCs (Windows machines) do not have the same problems.

Case In Point:

I have an HP/Compaq Presario computer (I know Compaq sucks and all that) but the problem occurred when the system would not power up due to an apparent system board failure.

Needless to say the system board was not easy to replace due to the fact that the Compaq computers are designed so that only specific types and sizes of boards fit in the cases. However, to resolve this issue, I purchased a brand new minitower case and purchased an over-the-counter ASUS motherboard and put the Compaq hard drive, CD/DVD burner, floppy, etc. into the new case. The system powered up perfectly and the only thing I then needed to do was reload Windows as the new system board was not recognized by the old Windows installation.

The "problem" was fixed to my satisfaction in less than 1 WEEK. Take that in your APPLE pipe and smoke it.

* No rant intended here just an explanation of how PCs (Windows based) are superior to comparable MAC offerings except for the EXTREME PREMIUM paid by customers for parts and service.
 
Apple isn't using SLI and the 9400 is a hybrid SLI combo of a 9100 and either a 9200 or 9300 GPU, right? Apple/Nvidia haven't stated WTF the Apple version of the 9400m is doing but it appears to just be a 9100 with DC shared system memory. Seems kinda weak.
 
valve1138 said:
A "Mac vs PC" debate is like those "Nintendo vs Sega" debates we used to have on the school bus back in '85.

Except here, said debates are started by the bus driver (Steve) to stir up the pot and create banner ad hits in the forums. :p

fromeo85 said:
Steve Jobs just has his head up his @$$ thinking that his baby is just o so much more than a PC (WRONG!).
Well, as an Apple stockholder, I can tell you that Steve Jobs very definitely does not have his head up his ass. He is a marketeer, not a Wikipedia article author. And he is utterly brilliant at it (the more you hate Macs, the more you have to admit this, since people are buying Apple products more than ever). Sales puffery and image branding is an art and Jobs is a maestro (thank God for stockholders). Jobs has made Apple the most profitable retail business per square foot in America. Apple stock, even devastated by this recent market crash, is still trading at about 25 times what I paid for it. I just heard a well-respected hedge fund manager call Apple the best company in America. Dog Macs all you want, but dogging one of the most successful CEOs ever is just plain silly.

fromeo85 said:
If you want to game use Windows. If you want to create and edit any kind of audio, video, or images use Mac

Or you can get a Mac, and use Boot Camp to run both Windows and Mac OSX and do both on one machine.

For the record, since people here love to see in black and white and make ad hominem attacks, I use PC's exclusively for work compatibility (I got into Windows before Boot Camp was available). I haven't owned a Mac since the early 90's, and my total time on OSX is less than an hour.
 
One of the biggest reasons I stay away from a mac (beside gaming) is because of the lack of support for third party apps. Can you say tech nazi's. And for the video and audio debate, incase you haven't looked into it, most major studio software runs mainly on windows.
 
I think he is 100% right about Office. Office 2007 kills anything else out there, and the Mac users miss the best of it.

Thanks to the ribbon, I can do tons of functions almost instantly using keyboard shortcuts I've now memorized. It's easy to just drop in changes and such without stopping typing. Also as he mentioned, Mac users don't get Outlook. Even more important, IMO, is they don't get OneNote. I use OneNote every day when I take my tablet PC to class.... the versatility and features on OneNote are amazing. Mac users really are missing out.... especially on having extra money in their wallet, since they pay ridiculous amounts for Macs.
 
Apple products are generally priced higher over a similiar spec'ed MS machine for 2 reasons:

1. Perceived Value - Many people are willing to pay for something they perceive as more reliable. Here's an analogy with cars:
Do I purchase the Toyota when they have a relatively long history of high quality and reliability, is more expensive, and does not have as much power? Or do I purchase the comparable Ford or Chevy car that has more power, cheaper, decent quality, and potentially just as reliable (although past says otherwise)? If you didn't get the analogy... Toyota is to Apple as MS is to Ford/Chevy.

2. Supply and Demand - If Apple had 50% of the desktop PC and Notebook Market, their prices would lower drastically to continue to gain marketshare. However, the overall price would again be subject to perceived value...just like the Apple Ipod.

3. Design - Something PC makers don't seem to get.

I'd like to see a laptop with the same design characteristics (look and feel) as a MacBook Pro. I've been looking for just the right laptop for a long time and I keep looking at a Mac.

I'm tempted to buy a MacBook Pro although I know I will primarily run Linux, not OS X or Windows. For something that I will work with everyday:
1. I don't want it to feel like a sub-$1K Dell POS.
2. I don't want the extra media buttons that I will never use and that make a laptop look like a rice racer.
3. I want something that does look cool.

For all the Mac haters that disagree with #3, take a look at your current computer before commenting.

I've always believed Apple charges more just for the look and feel of a Mac. Is there a comparably priced laptop with similar construction, look and feel to a MBP for the same price?
 
I've always believed Apple charges more just for the look and feel of a Mac. Is there a comparably priced laptop with similar construction, look and feel to a MBP for the same price?


The only thing that comes close are Lenovos, and while those things are built like tanks and have excellent keyboards, they aren't what you would call sexy or beautiful. That said, I'd go with those if Mac notebooks somehow disappeared.

I agree with you though, most notebooks are designed like garbage. After I saw their gaming laptop setup at E For All a few weeks ago, it just cemented my opinion: you couldn't fucking pay me to go with a Dell. In all of its respective classes, you just can't get anything as light or slim for the power you get with a Mac, nor do you get as intelligently thought out accessories. For example, compare the airline seat power adapter on a Dell; its another huge AC brick, while on the Macs it is just a thin cord. You'd think everyone else would figure out something better than just throwing on a different plastic facade on their new notebooks and calling it a day.

Some people will hate all they want, but I just can't go back to anything else. Same reason I'll decide to spend more money on cars, food, whatever, if I feel it is worth the extra cost.
 
Really? So its like comparing two companies that are 6 years away from any sort of competition?

Actually thats not that far from the truth.

for those that dont know segas first console was released in 91, in 85 sega was not in competition with nintendo. Comparing sega to nintendo in 85 is like comparing vacuums to ninjas

Well... if your counting Sega Genesis, but i remember buying my Master System in 87, when i was 6. And i'll never forget the hours of time i wasted playing altered beast on that bad boy.

anyway, yeah i will say that macs seem to spend all the extra money in planned design.
But i'd never buy a mac.
The people i know have macs, act like they have a more refined computer experience.
That is until i let them know my Compaq that i spend 400 is 90% the same...
 
Well if you get the pro Macbooks the pricing gets a little bit closer. Trying to find a PC book with a 2.8GHz Core2, 4GB DDR3, 320GB 7200 HD, 1440x900 res, 802.11n, Firewire 800, 9600m GT or equivalent, DVI-D out is hard to find. Dell doesn't offer the X9000 for 15" notebooks. Only 17". Alienware was like $3800. And if you price stuff out you must get ultimate because Apple gives you the FULL OS with developer tools, X11 environment, all the bsd you could want. With no limits and no serial numbers. No freakin updates to verify you are "genuine". But aside from that, I love my PC for gaming. I just buy the parts and build, but the mac is still my favorite OS to do any kind of Audio and desktop work. For me it is all OS. Don't really care how the macs look, if they looked like PC's I'd still prefer the Mac OS. But they are all my babies.
 
for those that dont know segas first console was released in 91, in 85 sega was not in competition with nintendo. Comparing sega to nintendo in 85 is like comparing vacuums to ninjas
LMAO! :D
 
Nice posts about comparing a PC and a MAC, but my question is:

Why would anyone buy a MAC for?

I've never felt, "damn, I can only buy a PC again, if only I could get a MAC I could do..."

What's the big plus with MAC compared to a PC?
 
3. Design - Something PC makers don't seem to get.
That is simply not true at all and I'm so tired of hearing this. It's about as infuriating as the stereotypes that follow the auto industry.

hp-touchsmart-all-in-one-pc-100608.jpg

voodoo_envy_133_live_01.jpg

voodoo_envy_133_live_02.jpg

8285-dellstudiohybridspan.jpg

hp_voodoo_envy_133_3-100608.jpg

samsungx360-1.jpg

eeepc_540x315.jpg
 
Not only that, OSX have piss-poor driver support

X-Planes is a VERY high quality professional flight simulator that just kicks the competition sideways. It also runs on the main 3 OS's (win,lin,osx) and thus is a very good software for benchmarking

http://xplanescenery.blogspot.com/2006/10/tale-of-three-operating-systems.html
PLATFORM Mac WIN LINUX
Load/Reload 2.77/1.31 5.02/1.33 3.05/1.04
FPS Test 1 65/71/80 64/69/88 56/62/62
FPS Test 2 49/55/54 50/56/56 34/37/37
FPS Test 3 15/15/15 16/16/16 4/4/4

Analysis:

* The Mac has the fastest disk performance; both Mac and Linux are significantly faster than Windows in raw loading. For reloading a file all operating systems are about the same, but it's the load-without-cache case that counts.
* Windows has the highest frame-rates; slightly faster than Mac but quite a bit more than Linux. The lack of safe VBOs on Linux could account for this.
* In the case where the fps didn't rise when the sim was paused, the limitation is with the video card - not surprising for tests 2 and 3 where there's a lot of antialiasing, anisotropic filtering, and objects.

A refined benchmark
http://xplanescenery.blogspot.com/2008/05/tale-of-three-operating-systems-part-ii.html
Now on to the performance numbers. These numbers are the Xp900 time demo fps tests 1, 2 and 3. Each set of 3 numbers is from the three phases.

1 2 3
MAC 49/ 60/ 62 38/ 43/ 44 21/ 20/ 21
WIN 121/128/133 114/115/119 77/ 75/ 82
LIN 143/144/157 130/123/132 92/104/113

That's not a typo. Linux is beating out Vista, but both are absolutely killing OS X. What's going on here? I don't know. But there appears to be something that isn't well optimized in the GeForce 8 drivers on OS X.

now before any of you MS-shills step out to then shout down linux, I aint posting this to show performance if linux (its just a by-product and as you can see win<->lin it can be quite close)

WHAT I am posting this for is OSX performance which is SHOCKING
 
Ok. I have my desktop that I built which is a Windows-based machine. I also have my MacBook. Yes Windows excels in the gaming industry part of things, I will say that. Now on the flipside, OSX-based machines are used in tons of major entertainment industries over Windows-based machine (Music and Movies - two biggies). Oh and and by the way, they are both PC. Steve Jobs just has his head up his @$$ thinking that his baby is just o so much more than a PC (WRONG!). There is Windows-based computers, OSX-based computers, Linux-based computers, and so on and so forth, they are ALL PCs. If you want to game use Windows. If you want to create and edit any kind of audio, video, or images use Mac. These are my opinions based on using both systems. Now, fan boys, tell me I am wrong, cause I know you are aching to. But when it all comes down to it, we are arguing over OPINIONS, not FACTS which = POINTLESS!

you are wrong, i worked in media firms and they used pc exclusively. Premiere works just as well as final cut. All adobe products are on either so we both get photoshop. And most music software i've had to use both professionally and as a hobby are on both (i'm thinking primarily pro-tools). Most of the reasoning i got from the people who aren't just fanboys is cost. A quadcore windows pc running raid is cheaper than a mac and more powerful.

I have only worked at a one place that used macs, and even that setup had both macs and pc.

the fact is that the whole "macs for multimedia" is outdated. Are they good at it? sure. Are they still the big thing? no. Macs are now a stylized computer product. They sell on aesthetics and image because that is what some people want. if any of you ever watch or read neurotically yours...its like the rant on starbucks over the same coffee around the corner for a 3rd of the price.
 
Here's a really good comparison:
First, a Dell XPS, 13.3" laptop. Considered to be some of the nicer laptops out there and sold as the high end Dell (the studio lines are cheaper with similar specs, but no 13" screens).
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8989035&type=product&id=1218006772152
45nm Penryn, 4gb of ram, DVD/CD rewriter, 320gb HD wirelessN, bluetooth etc.

versus the new Macbook:
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=9107414&type=product&id=1218024598155
Similar cpu (100mhz slow, negligible, also penryn) Only 2 gb of ram, 160gb HD, wireless N and bluetooth and same sort of disc drive.

XPS: $1100, Apple: $1300
For $200 less you get a lot more computer for your money in the dell. And no glass screen.

The questions for buyers is whether or not the OS is worth the difference in hardware cost.

People always mention the immediate price when comparing. Here is what no one ever mentions:

  • Resale value - Macs hardly lose value. Powerbooks and original Macbooks are still going for well over $700 on eBay. The initial money you spend is gotten back when you sell.
  • Product life - Mac hardware lasts YEARS longer than a comparable PC does. The Dell you listed will struggle with Windows 7 next year, and probably won't even meet the minimum system requirements for Windows 8 come 2011. We'll be generous and say that's 4 years of life from your $1000 laptop, after which you will spend another $1000 for 4 more years of computing. Compare that to my friend's Powerbook G4: it's coming up on 8 years old, and runs the current Mac OS X as fast as the day he bought it. What are you spending for 8 years of computer? $2000. What did he spend for 8 years? $1200. ;)
 
the fact is that the whole "macs for multimedia" is outdated. Are they good at it? sure. Are they still the big thing? no.

The main reason for going with a mac in a typical "design" environment seems to closer related to being part of the established "group" than it being a technological advantage... (my Lenovo Tablet PC sometimes gets stared at like an alien lifeform, but maybe that's only cause the apple tablet PC is overdue a few years ..)

Also depends on the kind of media you're working with, for 3D animation/effects and industrial design your software choices on a mac would be rather limited, The Wintel PC (and linux farm) kinda dominated the 3D environment since the fall of SGI.

Yes Windows excels in the gaming industry part of things, I will say that. Now on the flipside, OSX-based machines are used in tons of major entertainment industries over Windows-based machine (Music and Movies - two biggies).

For movies, In the mid range, yes a lot of people like Final cut. But the more high end you go with audio and video the more diverse the choices, with soft and hardware being available for both platforms.
Video composting is often restricted to one platform +linux, Apple made a great tactical decision with buying shake and killing it's Windows version also giving it one exclusive.
 
God this argument is old.

Computers:
Dell is to Apple like...

Purses:
Target is to Dooney and Burke

Similar size and function. How does a woman justify buying the more expensive purse? She wants it. It makes her feel good. Its the perceived value and how her snooty friends will perceive its value.

Stop trying to use logic and move on with your lives people.
 
God this argument is old...

Computers:
PC is to Apple like...

Purses:
Target is to Dooney and Burke ( sp? )

Similar size and function, but women will pay ridiculous amounts for a brand name purse. Does it make any sense? Only in that it's something they want.

Move on with your lives people. It's not gonna change.
 
the fact is that the whole "macs for multimedia" is outdated. Are they good at it? sure. Are they still the big thing? no. Macs are now a stylized computer product. They sell on aesthetics and image because that is what some people want. if any of you ever watch or read neurotically yours...its like the rant on starbucks over the same coffee around the corner for a 3rd of the price.

Are they good at it, sure, and since the typical new PC is using more advanced hardware, then they typical PC is "better" , assuming the software runs on a PC.

Oh wait, The ALTIVEC runs CIRCLES AROUND PC's becuase it was built from Alien technology! Oh wait, they run the same CPU now , gee I forgot :)
 
People always mention the immediate price when comparing. Here is what no one ever mentions:

  • Resale value - Macs hardly lose value. Powerbooks and original Macbooks are still going for well over $700 on eBay. The initial money you spend is gotten back when you sell.
  • Product life - Mac hardware lasts YEARS longer than a comparable PC does. The Dell you listed will struggle with Windows 7 next year, and probably won't even meet the minimum system requirements for Windows 8 come 2011. We'll be generous and say that's 4 years of life from your $1000 laptop, after which you will spend another $1000 for 4 more years of computing. Compare that to my friend's Powerbook G4: it's coming up on 8 years old, and runs the current Mac OS X as fast as the day he bought it. What are you spending for 8 years of computer? $2000. What did he spend for 8 years? $1200. ;)
INteresting ideas, but both moot points.
First, resale value is relatively meaningless, in all the years I have worked on/built/sold computers, it is VERY rare for someone to buy a new computer with the thought of selling the old one. People use their machines until they die or are out dated, or they just want a new one. They then store the old one or hand it down to a family member.

Second, the reliability argument is BS. Read up on it. When consumer reports did their study on reliability, the return for repair rate on all the major PC brands were within 7%, and Apple was second from top. These companies have been making computers long enough that, with the exception of periodic recalls (like the nVidia one affecting windows and OSX machines), it's really the luck of the draw when it comes to failures.

In terms of upgradability to a new OS. You are wrong with Win7, MS has already stated that the minimum requirements are the same as Vista. Even better (which I didn't mention in my original statement) you don't have to pay $130 for your service packs on Windows machines. They are free!

Again, though, windows users, and even most mac users, rarely upgrade OS's. For many reasons, cost and time being first and foremost between the two (cost on OSX, Time on Win). Most people don't want to upgrade because what they have works fine, and most people are not tech savy enough, or THINK they are not savy enough to do it anyway.

Finally, and this is an important aspect of Apple computers, MOST people do not need the computing capabilities of Apple hardware. MOST people can do just fine with a TurionX2, Pentium DualCore etc as their CPU. With 3g of ram and a decent hard drive, 80% or so of consumers will never see the difference in speed. Word, excel, the internet, dvd's, music, etc do not tax even the older,, now $999, macbook. Shoot, this week (ending today) you can get a Dell inspiron laptop from BestBuy for $500, has the PDC, 3g of ram, 160gb hd, wireless internet and a CD/DVD burner.

http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?skuId=8989008&type=product&id=1218006772494

For mom and pop, or the budget college student, really what more do you need? Nothing basic will run any faster with more hardware. With 3gb of ram, photoediting will be comfortable. Video editing might be rough with that cpu, buthow many people do that? Not many.
 
Back
Top