The “Mac Tax” Debate

I'm being serious here. I've never used a Mac for longer than a few minutes (I didn't think it was very user friendly, but then again, I've always used DOS/Windows), so what do people mean by the OS "doesn't get in the way."

Thanks,

P.

I remember apps on OS X asking for administrative permissions only during install. Mac users like to make fun of Vista's UAC because of this. Every time I run Visual Studio 2005 (yes, with Vista patches) I always get the UAC pop-up. I'm not very fond of this and I can see how people can interpret this behavior as "Windows getting in the way".
 
Pro Tools is sort of the exception here. The Windows version is, at this time, just horrendous. The Mac OS version is practically flawless, and a real delight to work with. It's not due to the OS itself or the hardware -- not in any part -- but Digidesign just expended so little effort on the Windows version of Pro Tools, and it clearly shows.

Thusly, if you were to come up to me and ask me what kind of machine to run Pro Tools on -- PC or Mac -- I'd say (without hesitation) Mac. It's not because Macs are better necessarily, but because Pro Tools is just such a fucking disaster on Windows.

Ahh, well, I don't have a ton of experience on that. At any rate, he ended up getting a Dell XPS and running Acid on it. I think the cost of a Mac Pro was just too much for him.


KENNYB said:
I remember apps on OS X asking for administrative permissions only during install. Mac users like to make fun of Vista's UAC because of this. Every time I run Visual Studio 2005 (yes, with Vista patches) I always get the UAC pop-up. I'm not very fond of this and I can see how people can interpret this behavior as "Windows getting in the way".

Well, I use XP currently, so I've never ran into UAC. I was under the impression that a certain installation process would eliminate the need for UAC to check for permissions every time, which is a little complicated. Granted, the UAC implementation appears to be overly "needy", however I seem to recall hearing about the OS getting in the way before Vista hit the scene. I could be wrong though.

Perhaps my tune will change once I go to Vista (maybe next year) or Windows 7. I wish 7 would be out quicker... I'm thinking about getting a laptop early next year. Right now, I would never think of getting a Macbook or MBP. They are just way too expensive for what you get.

Thanks,

P.
 
The software is ~the same, it's just the OS that doesn't get in your way.
Can you explain how it does?

Anyone in real-life can't answer any of these questions. They're just brainwashed sheep, was hoping someone on an Enthusiast forum like this could answer this one for me...

I don't want to be prompted to do some mindless task that the user only wants to do 5% of the time, that's ridiculous.
Guess what? In Windows, you have OPTIONS. It's something OS X severely lacks.
You can disable the damn auto-play if you don't want to. Your configuration options in Windows are practically limitless, you aren't forced into doing just what Apple deems needs to be done.

Same goes for UAC.
The funny thing is, that Apple does this same stuff. For years the "power users" using Macs criticized Microsoft for this one. Windows finally adopts it, then gets slammed for it.
Windows even one-ups the *nix community and doesn't even force you to enter a password, just a single mouse-click.
 
The funny thing is, that Apple does this same stuff. For years the "power users" using Macs criticized Microsoft for this one. Windows finally adopts it, then gets slammed for it.
Windows even one-ups the *nix community and doesn't even force you to enter a password, just a single mouse-click.

The one thing I will probably ever agree with you on. ;) :p

Yeah, it is ridiculous how something that should have been in Windows from the start for basic security purposes gets criticized now.
 
I remember apps on OS X asking for administrative permissions only during install. Mac users like to make fun of Vista's UAC because of this. Every time I run Visual Studio 2005 (yes, with Vista patches) I always get the UAC pop-up. I'm not very fond of this and I can see how people can interpret this behavior as "Windows getting in the way".

Yeah, UAC pops up far more often then when you are asked to elevate to root or admin in Linux or OS X. That said, it is definitely a step in the right direction and I'm positive that MS will eventually get it to be where everyone else is as far as transparency and being less intrusive.
 
Can you explain how it does?

Anyone in real-life can't answer any of these questions. They're just brainwashed sheep, was hoping someone on an Enthusiast forum like this could answer this one for me...

Do you really want point-by-point examples of UI streamlining and OS features that speed up working with the same files between multiple programs at the same time, compared to doing the same tasks in Windows?
 
Hmmm, you own a M1330, a Dell M1330? And that it "outperforms every single Macbook Pro I've used". Wow, even the MBPs with discrete graphics? Launching the same apps side by side with both systems using Windows? Presumably, your M1330 doesn't have a faster GPU than a 8400m GS which is on the shipping version of the M1330. Why don't you try launching TF2 on both systems and report how well that goes?

Techie pulls arguments out of thin air and flips his viewpoint to fit the argument at hand, regularly. It is best that you ignore him. I mean, obviously it is the name Dell on his laptop that makes it run faster than one with faster hardware in it just because it has the name Apple on it. Its magic, doncha know?! :rolleyes:

Its like he's trying to say that an old Macbook (which is basically what his M1330 is) will run TF2 faster than a Macbook Pro. Fucking ridiculous.
 
I dabble in photography as well as having an interest in computers, and every forum I visit, I see people singing praises to Apple. They will absolutely tell you your an idiot for using a PC.
I'm a photoshop operator professionally and I can tell you that there's no reason why we should be using Macs over PCs at this point other than for compatibility reasons. Every program we use like Quark is now cross platform. It goes back to tradition I suppose, back in the day you had to Macs and people have that ingrained in their head just like they have it ingrained in their head that Domestic cars are unreliable, PC's crash, Macs are perfect, etc etc. The programs we use on a daily basis simply work better and faster on PC's and the turnaround time for workstation maintenance is infinitely faster.

I keep hearing the phrase "it just works" over and over and over... and I think to myself, I don't know of anything on a PC that doesn't "just work" unless it's something quite in depth that most people don't ever try.
I spend 8 hours a day on OSX at work and I can tell you that's a crock of shit if I've ever heard it. Our computers CONSTANTLY crash, hang, and freeze throughout the day. I don't find OSX any easier to work than Windows either.

What kills me is that Apple has most artists so brainwashed that my friends who want to do music, video, or photo editing as a serious venture now think that they have to have a Mac to do it at the professional level.
You're preaching to the choir here man. I have a friend who initially got me started building PC's years ago has been brainwashed by the Mac Cult. He says his next computer will be a mac and states that they are faster, easier to use, more reliable, and work with everything. Boy is he in for a surprise. Let them believe whatever they want, it's their loss.
 
I spend 8 hours a day on OSX at work and I can tell you that's a crock of shit if I've ever heard it. Our computers CONSTANTLY crash, hang, and freeze throughout the day. I don't find OSX any easier to work than Windows either.

You might want to get your hardware checked. I've owned Macs for only six years but the one single time I had issues like that was due to a bad stick of RAM I installed in a G4 a couple months after I bought it. I returned it to Mushkin and got a new one back, everything was cool.

Funny enough, this was in 2003, about the same time I was just going through RAM like crazy on the new PC I was building at the time. I went through three pairs before I found one that would pass Memtest and not cause constant BSODs (those were from Corsair). I don't know WTF was going on then but it was either really really bad luck or some RAM supplier was just cranking out bad batches like crazy.
 
Do you really want point-by-point examples of UI streamlining and OS features that speed up working with the same files between multiple programs at the same time, compared to doing the same tasks in Windows?

Acutally, I do. I'm honestly claiming ignorance. I keep hearing that OSX has some implementation that makes workflow so much better and faster, but I've never heard someone explain what, exactly, is so special about it. So, please, teach, cause I'm in no place to do a trial. I don't know if there's a Mac store within hours of here.

Thanks,

P.
 
Should have rolled this into a prior post, damn you lack of edit button!

I know Mac fans would argue with me on this: But Microsoft does not charge for their Service Packs.

Microsoft Service Packs are mainly patch rollups for security, stability, and big fixes, with little or nothing in the way of actual features. OS X upgrades generally roll in significant new features like Spotlight, Spaces, Expose, Quick Look (which displays everything including PDFs instantly), Automator, Time Machine, Core Image and Core Animation, new filesystem options, all on top of under the hood optimizations (every upgrade from 10.2 through 10.4 resulted in faster performance on the same old hardware, even withou).

OS 10.6 is a relatively minor upgrade, focusing more on making things even faster under the hood, but even then they are rolling in OpenCL to automatically delegate normal computational functions to the GPU, automating multi-core processing for any application, and adding a ZFS filesystem option to the server. I suspect that Microsoft doing the same thing would take billions and billions of dollars and years of delays to implement.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: the move from OS 10.3 o 10.4 back in 2005 was a bigger leap in functionality and performance than the move from XP to Vista. But I must be deluded even though I've experienced both upgrades firsthand. :rolleyes:

Well, holy shit... That must mean everyone does it :rolleyes:

Nope, I generally keep my computers and parts for 2-5 years. That said, I've always gotten higher resale value out of my Macs than my PCs. Ignore the point if you want with a smartass comment but it still stands: you get much lower depreciation and much better resale value with a Mac than with a PC, period. Its not like some obscure thing, everyone knows this.
 
Acutally, I do. I'm honestly claiming ignorance. I keep hearing that OSX has some implementation that makes workflow so much better and faster, but I've never heard someone explain what, exactly, is so special about it. So, please, teach, cause I'm in no place to do a trial. I don't know if there's a Mac store within hours of here.

Thanks,

P.

PM me later in the week. I'm serious. :)

I start working tomorrow at 7am and will be swamped all the way through the weekend. I won't have time to write a detailed post during that time, but I'll be happy to go through some examples for you afterwards.
 
Do you really want point-by-point examples of UI streamlining and OS features that speed up working with the same files between multiple programs at the same time, compared to doing the same tasks in Windows?
Yes. I, and someone else here, have expressed this. Don't mess with PM- post it here.

I noticed a keyword of "multiple programs", when the discussion at hand was how running any given application, the OS gets in the way. Sorry, but once that app is running: it's running. Which is why I don't understand how the OS is interfering with that app, hence my question.

You might want to get your hardware checked.

:rolleyes:

There's several on here (namely last I remember: DeaconFrost) have bought Macs because the marketing department or whatnot requested them. They had the same issues, Apple sent their "Geniuses" out to take a look at them in the field: and found nothing wrong.

Sorry, but Macs don't "just work" like they advertise. They're just as buggy (if not more, with Vista) as Windows.

Microsoft Service Packs are mainly patch rollups for security, stability, and big fixes, with little or nothing in the way of actual features.
LMAO. APPLE DOESN'T????


OS X upgrades generally roll in significant new features like Spotlight, Spaces, Expose, Quick Look (which displays everything including PDFs instantly), Automator, Time Machine, Core Image and Core Animation, new filesystem options, all on top of under the hood optimizations (every upgrade from 10.2 through 10.4 resulted in faster performance on the same old hardware, even withou).
You mean like Security Center, Windows Firewall, .Net framework, new mobile computing features, Windows messenger, USB 2.0, WPA, Bluetooth, DEP, as well as many other features I cannot think of right off the bat.

And just as you mentioned as well: overall increases in performance.

Microsoft doesn't charge for their Service Packs, Apple does.
 
Yes. I, and someone else here, have expressed this. Don't mess with PM- post it here.

Fine, I'll copy the PM here next week, bumping up what will be a very old thread at that point to the very top of the list because that's what you want. :rolleyes:

There's several on here (namely last I remember: DeaconFrost) have bought Macs because the marketing department or whatnot requested them. They had the same issues, Apple sent their "Geniuses" out to take a look at them in the field: and found nothing wrong.

Sorry, but Macs don't "just work" like they advertise. They're just as buggy (if not more, with Vista) as Windows.

For every vocal person you find with issues, you'll have many more without that won't even bother posting about them because they don't have them. I'd be surprised if you haven't made the same argument when defending Vista in the OS forums (I sure have). You rarely hear loudly regarding Vista from people who have no problems, but one BSOD and someone will cry bloody murder on the internet about how it is the worst thing ever.

Again, my experience with OS X and Mac hardware has been extremely positive. If it wasn't I would say so.

You mean like Security Center, Windows Firewall, .Net framework, new mobile computing features, Windows messenger, USB 2.0, WPA, Bluetooth, DEP, as well as many other features I cannot think of right off the bat.

And just as you mentioned as well: overall increases in performance.

Microsoft doesn't charge for their Service Packs, Apple does.

Everything you listed there is LOL. Seriously, very funny. I didn't even bother bringing up improvements to iChat, even though it comes with screen/desktop sharing and video chat built in because I thought it was just too trivial, and you bothered to bring up Windows Messenger? Fucking LOL.

And USB 2.0, Bluetooth, WPA, those are your major new features, really? Those things you listed are in your mind, on par with systemwide indexing (a bulletpoint feature in Vista out two years after it was implemented and already improved upon in OS X), extremely robust file previewing via Quick Look, UI enhancements like Spaces and Expose (which I can't live without at this point), new filesystem support, new automation features and scripting, not to mention upcoming automated GPU and multi-core computation for all applications? Those are on par with or beyond what Microsoft has been giving us in their new operating systems, let alone their service packs (which you love comparing the new versions of OS X too).

You are fucking hilarious.
 
This article is a bit old, but, clearly you can build an all in one for a competitive price without a lot of expensive engineering.

Of course it'd be easier to buy one built ;)

Yeah, that thing looks fucking awful, no offense. ;)

If you're going to do an all-in-one then do it better than the system builders would, or don't do it at all. That guy hand built a machine that is larger, noisier, and less adjustable than any AIO I've ever seen. Its a waste of time and you're better off building a regular tower, something most people can do better and cheaper than any PC builder. Well, HP/Voodoo will build better than almost anyone out there but their Core 2 Duo systems cost almost as much as or more than a dual-quad Xeon Mac Pro; absolutely insane prices. I digress: size and design are a big factors with an all-in-one and that DIY AIO is absolutely massive compared to what others with proper engineering teams and manufacturing facilities can crank out.
 
Pro Tools is sort of the exception here. The Windows version is, at this time, just horrendous. The Mac OS version is practically flawless, and a real delight to work with. It's not due to the OS itself or the hardware -- not in any part -- but Digidesign just expended so little effort on the Windows version of Pro Tools, and it clearly shows.

Same goes for video editing software. The Final Cut Studio package is just miles beyond Adobe Premiere.

Which actually leads into this regarding used hardware:

I gotta ask, are used mac buyer's stupid? Unless Apple is very slow at updating the CPUs, 18 months is an eternity....certainly it's worth 25% more to get a system that should be significantly faster, with a faster HD, Graphics Card and possibly a better screen.

I can't speak for lower end hardware like the Macbooks, but I can for higher end stuff that you would sell to people who want to use pro software like Logic or Final Cut Studio. The hardware and OS stay viable for a pretty long time. I kept a G4 for Final Cut Pro from 2002 until the end of last year, and with no reformats/reinstalls or any real maintenance the thing ran like the day I bought it. I've seen Avids at editing bays on the Fox and Warners lots that were running on machines even older than mine! The main reason I finally upgraded at the end of last year was because I wanted faster video render times (hey, five years can only get you so much when there have been so many generational leaps in hardware, plus its fun to buy new things). Had I decided to sell it two years after I bought it, I expect that I would have gotten around 50%-70% of what I had paid for it. It basically gets someone the ability to run something like Final Cut for about $1000 less than a new machine. That's real value for someone who wants to do work but not pay the price for the latest and greatest, and it will still run great.

So its a combination of factors. It is partly driven by the fact that Apple upgrades machines only twice a year, and partly due to the fact that OS X has excellent longterm stability and will perform very well on older hardware (this is important). OS 10.4 actually ran marginally better than 10.2 on my old G4 desktop, a very different situation from having a well maintained XP installation that will go to crap in 2-3 years, or needing to have a relatively recent machine because Vista has the hardware requirements that it does. I should also note that OS 10.5 runs better than Vista on the same hardware. I dual boot on a few machines and the difference is pretty crazy.

On a side note, there is obviously greater depreciation on the G4 and G5 machines since Apple moved from PPC to x86. I'd expect people would be giving those machines away at this point due to the complete move to x86 in 10.6, but that's life.
 
MSCONFIG? Really? REALLY? Do you actually think that average PC users is aware of MSCONFIG? I work in IT, and I can promise you I can find plenty of PC users that know NOTHING about windows beyond Office, Eclipse Explorer and putty.

I said,
They didn'tknow what msconfig was[/qoute] Please read slower.
 
Everything you listed there is LOL. Seriously, very funny. I didn't even bother bringing up improvements to iChat, even though it comes with screen/desktop sharing and video chat built in because I thought it was just too trivial, and you bothered to bring up Windows Messenger? Fucking LOL.
And I LOL at some of the shit you listed for OS X too.
Works both ways.
 
I remember apps on OS X asking for administrative permissions only during install. Mac users like to make fun of Vista's UAC because of this. Every time I run Visual Studio 2005 (yes, with Vista patches) I always get the UAC pop-up. I'm not very fond of this and I can see how people can interpret this behavior as "Windows getting in the way".

Perhaps you should read this article
 
Fine, I'll copy the PM here next week, bumping up what will be a very old thread at that point to the very top of the list because that's what you want. :rolleyes:

I would like to see the response too. I hear the OS in-the-way argument all the time and I don't get it either. And if you feel it's an old thread, leave.

Also, since you seem so very mac-defendish, maybe you can answer a question not even the Geniuses at the Bar could answer:

Why can't I get more than a dual core on a reasonably priced mac (i.e. not a MacPro)? I can get a really nice Dell, Gateway or HP desktop with a big monitor for $1000 with a quad core intel cpu. That pretty much guarantees that my AdobePremier will encode video faster than any iMac given it's multithreadedness.
 
Your system isn't an all-in-one though so it isn't quite a 1:1 comparison there. Yes, they are both desktop but the engineering requirements are different. They're closer to notebooks, and like notebooks it isn't cheap to cram a computer and monitor into one small enclosure. An XPS One is going to cost more than a regular Dell tower, for example. That said, there are some advantages to an all-in-one design. I own both, and what you gain in space savings and near silence can actually be compelling features for some people.

Price comparing an all-in-one to a normal tower makes as much sense to me as comparing a tower to a notebook. Now, if Apple sold a standalone Core 2 Duo tower with PCI-E that was significantly more expensive than your machine without offering any other additional value, that would be a different story and a valid complaint.

And bag away on the mini, worst value ever.

True, but the reason I chose to compare it to the iMac and not the Mac Pro is because the Mac Pro's are over twice as expensive as the iMac. The iMac, despite using notebook parts and being an all-in-one design, is still the cheapest "desktop" Mac, excluding the Mac mini.

The cheapest Mac Pro comes with 2GB of RAM, 320GB harddrive, Radeon 2600XT. Granted, it does come with two 2.8 GHz Intel Quadcores, but the price is $2,800 which is probably 4x as much as my system cost.

The Mac Mini at $599 or even $799 (http://store.apple.com/us_smb_78313/browse/home/shop_mac/family/mac_mini?mco=MjI4OTY2) doesn't stand a chance against my system, but I'd bet my system cost less than $799 to build (hard to say how much exactly since I've been upgrading it in increments over a long time, something you can't do with the Mini). If the Mac Mini was more like $400 I might actually consider one as a secondary computer, but paying a premium of hundreds of $ just so I can use the allmighty OSX (which would work fine on any PC if Apple didn't artificially lock it to their own machines) - just not worth it.
 
And I LOL at some of the shit you listed for OS X too.
Works both ways.

No, see, what I listed were actual bulletpoint features that any new OS would include (some of which were big advertised features in Vista). You think that moving from 32 bit to fully 64 bit is LOL? Wow.

First you say that an M1330 (the hardware equivalent of last year's Macbook) is faster than a Macbook Pro because the Dell badge on it is magic, and now you list frigging IM software to prove your point.

Congratulations.
 
Also, since you seem so very mac-defendish, maybe you can answer a question not even the Geniuses at the Bar could answer:

Why can't I get more than a dual core on a reasonably priced mac (i.e. not a MacPro)? I can get a really nice Dell, Gateway or HP desktop with a big monitor for $1000 with a quad core intel cpu. That pretty much guarantees that my AdobePremier will encode video faster than any iMac given it's multithreadedness.

I completely agree with this. My biggest complaint with Apple right now is that they don't offer a Core 2 Duo machine with PCI-E expansion. Its been my most vocal complaint for a very very long time. I don't know if this will ever happen but it would be great, something along the lines of a G4 Cube but without the completely retarded pricing.

And my condolences for being stuck with Premiere.
 
I completely agree with this. My biggest complaint with Apple right now is that they don't offer a Core 2 Duo machine with PCI-E expansion. Its been my most vocal complaint for a very very long time. I don't know if this will ever happen but it would be great, something along the lines of a G4 Cube but without the completely retarded pricing.

And my condolences for being stuck with Premiere.
Eh, I recently got Pinnacle Studio, and for what I do (family movies), both seem pretty nice. Each has nice features that the other doesn't. I think I like pinnacle more because it doesn't hold your hand as much, so you have more options to explore.

I do find it interesting, however, that Apple has turned from attacking PC's to attacking MS in its most recent commercials. I think that may be a mistake, but we'll see. When attacking PC's you are kind of poking an entire populous, but when you attack MS, it's provoking a single entity... big difference.
 
Eh, I recently got Pinnacle Studio, and for what I do (family movies), both seem pretty nice. Each has nice features that the other doesn't. I think I like pinnacle more because it doesn't hold your hand as much, so you have more options to explore.

I do find it interesting, however, that Apple has turned from attacking PC's to attacking MS in its most recent commercials. I think that may be a mistake, but we'll see. When attacking PC's you are kind of poking an entire populous, but when you attack MS, it's provoking a single entity... big difference.
Damn you no edit button...
BTW, I wouldn't call it being 'stuck' with Adobe Premier, Elements, I got it for free, so I could not complain...
 
I do find it interesting, however, that Apple has turned from attacking PC's to attacking MS in its most recent commercials. I think that may be a mistake, but we'll see. When attacking PC's you are kind of poking an entire populous, but when you attack MS, it's provoking a single entity... big difference.

It is interesting. That said, Microsoft went directly after Apple in their last campaign. Opening up with a John Hodgeman lookalike and then appropriating the "I'm a PC" line directly from the Mac ads into their own is a direct rebuttal, no matter what some people here will day.

Unfortunately the stupid ads from both sides are now aimed at... each other. Great. :( :mad:
 
Its amazing to me how the real mac fanboys regard bootcamp as some sort of extension of OSX rather than plain old dual booting. Its funny to see the way guys like that marvin word things to avoid the truth.

I get a kick out of it personally, bootcamp has the magical ability to turn a $2000 "state of the art machine" into a $500 PC just by rebooting.

What does it say to your curtomer base when the response to just about all compatability issues is "if it downt work with crossover etc. go buy windows and dual boot" Dont that just contradict their whole marketing campaign that windows = bad?

IMO every mac should come with a windows license, i imagine it would make the customers feel better and they could justify charging $600 more for it, call it the "Compatible version"
 
Serpico said:
Microsoft Service Packs are mainly patch rollups for security, stability, and big fixes, with little or nothing in the way of actual features.

You mean like Security Center, Windows Firewall, .Net framework, new mobile computing features, Windows messenger, USB 2.0, WPA, Bluetooth, DEP, as well as many other features I cannot think of right off the bat.


I could be wrong, but those all sound like SP2 features. In that case, you're correct, but SP2, as others have noted in the Windows 7 thread, is an exception. Interviews clearly show that SP2 was supposed to be an upgrade, not an SP. You can thank Jim Allchin for all the goodies in SP2.

I don't recall any major additions in Vista's SP1.

And just as you mentioned as well: overall increases in performance.

Unless you can show that MS SP typically include significant feature additions (skip SP2 and tell me about NT, 2000 and Vista SPs....or even XP SP1 and SP3), he wins on the point that OSX has more than a typical MS Service Pack.

Hell, let's look at Windows 98 SE. That added USB and Fat32, as well as numerous bug fixes. Was it free? No it was not.

I have no idea if OS X gets faster with each subsequent release, but clearly XP was not faster than 2000 and Vista isn't faster than XP.

Now a fair question to ask is would PC that relatively low end Mac that ran OS X .1 run faster with the latest version.

If it does, and the old mac gets all of the bells and whistles that you'd find on a modern Mac, then I'd say that's pretty damn impressive.
 
Yeah, that thing looks fucking awful, no offense. ;)

If you're going to do an all-in-one then do it better than the system builders would, or don't do it at all. That guy hand built a machine that is larger, noisier, and less adjustable than any AIO I've ever seen. Its a waste of time and you're better off building a regular tower, something most people can do better and cheaper than any PC builder. Well, HP/Voodoo will build better than almost anyone out there but their Core 2 Duo systems cost almost as much as or more than a dual-quad Xeon Mac Pro; absolutely insane prices. I digress: size and design are a big factors with an all-in-one and that DIY AIO is absolutely massive compared to what others with proper engineering teams and manufacturing facilities can crank out.

I'm not saying it's a work of art, but when viewed from the front, it looks like a monitor with a web camera on it. The ugly part is all behind the monitor. Most people have the back of the monitor facing a wall, so I don't think the looks matter, nor does the size seem like a huge issue.

Considering he built it for something like 500 bucks, I'd say it shows that you can build an all-in-one for a reasonable price. If aesthetics are important, then clearly you'd leave it to the pros.


Everything you listed there is LOL. Seriously, very funny. I didn't even bother bringing up improvements to iChat, even though it comes with screen/desktop sharing and video chat built in because I thought it was just too trivial, and you bothered to bring up Windows Messenger? Fucking LOL.

I thought WM was a strange one to bring up myself. I spent more time trying to remove WM than actually using it.

And USB 2.0, Bluetooth, WPA, those are your major new features, really? Those things you listed are in your mind, on par with systemwide indexing (a bulletpoint feature in Vista out two years after it was implemented and already improved upon in OS X), extremely robust file previewing via Quick Look, UI enhancements like Spaces and Expose (which I can't live without at this point), new filesystem support, new automation features and scripting, not to mention upcoming automated GPU and multi-core computation for all applications? Those are on par with or beyond what Microsoft has been giving us in their new operating systems, let alone their service packs (which you love comparing the new versions of OS X too).

As I recall, XP had indexing built into it (although I always turned it off). The Search engine that's in Vista is freely available for XP via windows update.....I've nver used it, and frankly can't imagine anything doing better than Copernic (which has a free version for home use).

The GPU and Multi-core is nice, but I suspect that Apple would have a much harder time implementing it if they had to support more GPUs.

Nevertheless, if MS were to release a few features each year for 100 bucks, the masses would throw a fit. People already bitch and moan about paying 100 bucks ever 2-3 years....could you imagine the outrage if they came out with a new file system and CPU/GPU update to Vista and charged for it?

Everyone would say, they should have put it in vista to begin with....that they're withholding features just to sell us the upgrade.

For now, apple gets away with a lot of things that MS cannot. If their marketshare continues to increase, I think that things will change.
 
I have had both. I enjoyed using OSX and some of the features of the apple notebooks were useful during college. Through my time in college (6 years) I went through nearly 30 different laptops. I worked part time at a Compusa and got big discounts. So I was able to generally use a laptop for several months then turn around and sell it for what I paid. However, my use was limited to notebooks, which were being used to primarily school, music, videos etc. I had a desktop windows pc for gaming. I doubt I would ever spend the money on an apple desktop (I have always built my own desktops) but I do think that is apple geared a product toward the gamers it could do well. All they really need to do is write the drivers for the enthusiast video cards, and push for more games to support either OSX, or windows via bootcamp.
 
It is interesting. That said, Microsoft went directly after Apple in their last campaign. Opening up with a John Hodgeman lookalike and then appropriating the "I'm a PC" line directly from the Mac ads into their own is a direct rebuttal, no matter what some people here will day.

Unfortunately the stupid ads from both sides are now aimed at... each other. Great. :( :mad:

Eh....apples ad's have always been directly aimed at MS. PC=Windows. There was never any doubt what they were talking about.

All MS is saying in their ads is that we're not just the stodgy accountant.

Haven't seen the mac ad, so I have no idea what Apple is saying now.
 
You think that moving from 32 bit to fully 64 bit is LOL? Wow.
Considering you never listed that in your list, I LOL still.


I could be wrong, but those all sound like SP2 features.
Many were SP1 as well.

I don't recall any major additions in Vista's SP1.
Nope, other than performance.


he wins on the point that OSX has more than a typical MS Service Pack.
While that may be, to an extent, a Mac "SP/Upgrade" still has not near the amount of new features a new Windows version does.

You combine both versioning and SPs, Microsoft has Apple beat hands down, for much cheaper.



Of course right now at end of this post I realize this is more of differences in opinion.
 
Hell, let's look at Windows 98 SE. That added USB and Fat32, as well as numerous bug fixes. Was it free? No it was not.
.

Actually, FAT32 came about with Windows 95 OSR 2.0 (a service pack, go figure), sorry. And USB support? Windows 95 OSR 2.5 (another service pack, go figure)...

As far as performance is concerned, I wouldn't say OSX gets faster with each new release. In my own testing, performance in Geekbench and Xbench, the two most commonly used benchmarks for general system performance under OSX, has steadily declined from 10.4 through 10.5.5 which is the most current iteration. I've done benchmarks with essentially ever point release since 10.4 (all done on Intel hardware, of course, since 10.4 was the first version of OSX for the Intel architecture).

That's quite a thing to have benchmark data on considering the original benchmarks I ran on 10.4 even on Intel hardware was running under Rosetta - the translation layer for PowerPC code - because the benchmarks hadn't been updated to Universal Binary format when I ran them.

Now, per my previous post, if Apple can actually make the performance improvements with Snow Leopard - HEY PEOPLE, GET READY TO PAY ANOTHER $129 JUST SO YOU GET THE PERFORMANCE WE'VE BEEN CLAIMING SINCE THE OLD PowerPC COMPARISONS WITH PENTIUMS BUT NEVER DELIVERED TILL RIGHT NOW, MAYBE - then good for them.

I just can't see why people think it's such a great thing considering how long it's taken them to get this far. Apple is most famous for one thing above and beyond all other things with the Apple logo on them:

Marketing.

"Build it and the sheeple will buy it..."
 
See, I wouldn't call them sheep. There's nothing wrong with Apple computers, and lets be honest, more than that they are pretty damn nice computers.
For some people, price per performance is not the be-all, end-all measure of a computer. Instead, they might put more weight on style, status and image than others. This is not unique to Apple's PCs or else companies like alienware, voodooPC and maingear (to an extent) would not exist.

The issue comes in when these folks insist that their computer is just as fast or faster than equivalently (or close enough) equipped, but cheaper, systems.
 
Back
Top