The “Mac Tax” Debate

They're at it again...

http://www.apple.com/getamac/ads/

"Bake Sale"

One would think that Apple has to have more in mind than just whining on about Vista, I mean really.

Honestly though its juvenile tactics, what do you do when you cant legitimately compete with something? All they can do is make up nonsense and spread the FUD around and wait for the resulting fallout to net them more sales. What do they care if they are spreading ignorance and lies? As long as its netting themmore sales Jobs could give a fuck what he has to do as long as it works.

There is a reason so many folks in the technical community wouldnt shit on a mac and why your average mac user is a thick headed dult that couldnt set the time on thier VCR with video instructions. There are always exceptions to the rule but just as an example ask the next mac user you meet what kind of memory is in his mac or any remotely techinical question about his mac and the usual response will be "special mac parts".

Its always interesting to see the responses people give when you explain to them thier mac has NO special hardware in it and the only real difference between their mac and a PC is the case and operating system.
 
Don't tell me why Vista is so bad, Apple, tell me why OSX is so good.
 
As long as its netting themmore sales Jobs could give a fuck what he has to do as long as it works.
It'll catch up to them in the long run. American consumers in the long run are still very demanding and won't take crap like that.


There are always exceptions to the rule but just as an example ask the next mac user you meet what kind of memory is in his mac or any remotely techinical question about his mac and the usual response will be "special mac parts".
QFT.
Aside from here on the forums, I've never ONCE met a Mac user that knew jack about computers. The standard answer is "It just works better". If asked for a reason, it'll usually be "It just is". This is one of the many reasons computer enthusiasts cannot stand the Mac community.

One would think that Apple has to have more in mind than just whining on about Vista, I mean really.
I believe you've said the same thing in the past, Joe, but the number one rule is you NEVER mention your competition. Period.
If you've got to mention your competition: your product just isn't that great. Apple takes direct shots at Windows.

If your product was truly the greatest thing since sliced bread, you outline the positives and leave it at that. The consumer can see for themselves.

Just for a quick example: Nintendo Wii. Their commercials show the players engaged in a fun, interactive experience with no mention of the competition. The consumers can tell themselves what makes it different.

Microsoft has done great with their ads. They have a Hodgemen character to simply reference the Apple FUD (Perfect word is actually in the ad: "Stereotype"), and that's it. They don't talk about OS X directly, but rather attacks it in a very discreet way that makes the arrogant self-indulged Mac guy look like a douche.

Apple is really playing with fire on their ads. There's a very real possibility Microsoft could just turn it upside down onto its head- and I just don't mean in marketing, but in new products.
 
Don't tell me why Vista is so bad, Apple, tell me why OSX is so good.

Yep- that's the bottom line in a nutshell.

Quite honestly I don't think they could do it, unless you think you could sway consumers with Expose`, QuickLook, and a shiny case :rolleyes:
 
Really couldn't have said it any better. Bravo!

Something that also bears mentioning is that Mac OS X provided a solid BSD foundation that is comfortable to old-school Unix guys, and second to none for multi-platform programming. Many C, C++, Python, Pearl, Ruby, and Java programmers prefer Mac OS X because they get all the flexibility and speed of Linux/BSD/Solaris systems, and the OS is a pleasure to write software in.

As a fan of *nix system, I administrate Linux systems at work, and use a Linux server at the house for it's speed, flexibility, and price, but when it comes to just day-to-day computing, Mac OS X offers me the environment I know and love, underneath an interface that doesn't get in my way (and you did a beautiful job covering). I can program in this machine, and not only is it a pleasure to work with, but what I write in it will work on my Red Hat machines and Windows machines as well. Win-win.

Thank you, very much appreciated.

I didn't go into the command-line since I wanted to focus on how the OS X GUI helps to speed along tasks, but yes, I agree with everything you've said here. If you want to dig even deeper you've got a UNIX command line. On a side note, many coders I do know use OS X as their preferred development platform these days since they can develop anything on it, whether it is natively in the OS or through VMWare if they need to do something with .NET.

Don't use OS X, but I do use Ubuntu (in virtual box) at work, and as I recall, the main thing that makes it better is that it remembers sudo authorizations. But aside from that, I'm not sure I see how it's much different....you still have a window pop up and in the case of Ubuntu type in the PW.

The problem is less with UAC than the fact that certain actions (such as moving a file to/from certain directories) causes a UAC prompt, a prompt asking you if you really want to move the file and I believe a 3rd prompt related to the action. What MS needs to do is build in rules to remove the 2nd and rd prompts that aren't really UAC prompts at all.

The case with sudo is exactly the same as the case with OS X, and I agree with your solution as far as improving UAC in Windows. I am positive that the next version, whether it is in a Vista service pack or Windows 7, will be much improved upon what is currently in Vista.

Edit user you want....2 screens. I can see it as 4 or 5 steps, and I don't think that permissions are obvious in windows, but do you think the typical mac user ever touches permissions? I'm certain that the vast majority of Windows users have no desire to mess with those settings. It really seems it's a feature that mostly appeals to System Admins.

<snip>

I'm not denying that simplifying the interfaces is a good thing. A bad interface on the best tech in the world is a bad product, but I think this particular example comes across as nitpicking over an issue that virtually nobody moving to the mac will care about.

Perhaps I should have picked a different example, it was just one that popped in my head. Either way, the example is a microcosm of my general experience using both operating systems. Take that example and apply it to other functions and the resulting experience and flow (or lack thereof) will generally work out to be the same.

I'll give you points on the earch, because I didn't even know I could make a folder that had all my mpg files in it....so clearly that feature is buried more than I'd like...but then again, I tend to put all of my stuff in hierarchical folders. I like it that way.

Again, it was one example of a feature in OS X that is powerful, yet clearly exposed, easily used, and highly configurable by the user, as opposed to the same thing in Windows being more obscure, not as powerful, and not as configurable. Whether or not you actually use the feature is another issue, the point is to show the difference in design philosophies that consistently permeate through both operating systems.

Obfuscating things is not a "feature".

Like Windows doesn't? :rolleyes:

I wasn't saying Windows isn't capable of running dual 24" displays, that's absurd, I was explaining my usual workflow and setting up how OS X helps me there. You're reaching.

Expose is another thing you can use in Windows third-party that's bigger and better. You can give OS X a point for already having it included- but again this is hardly a ground breaking feature.

Really? Link please, I want to install that and the Spaces equivalent on my Windows box if it is actually better. One that doesn't suck. I expect it to be at least as powerful and easily configurable as what's on my OS X installation. I check every few months and I have yet to see anything close. Again, point me to a good one and I'll download it in a second. You'd think someone would have figured it out by now considering that the real thing has been around since 10.3.

Or is this another case where your XPS m1330 with a Merom CPU is faster than a Macbook Pro thanks to the magic Dell sticker on it, where you don't set Dell's prices, where one week you say that Apple's growth has already peaked and the next week you say that it is at least two years from peaking (you love playing the opposite game with me...), and where according to you the cost of oil is currently driven by supply and not the value of the US dollar?

I gotta step back, that's a LOT of foot in mouth you got there... ;)

After skimming through the rest of this it all looks like it's mainly what you like about OS X which I don't see much point in debating.

I'm still looking for that example of how Windows is getting in the way.

You've already stated that applications stealing focus of all things is a feature. It isn't enough for a dock icon or even a Growl notification to pop up, no the application window needs to jump in front of me and interrupt what it is I'm doing. Really? There's no rational discussing with you and I honestly don't know how to respond to that.

Well, Serpico responded to this:

"I keep hearing that OSX has some implementation that makes workflow so much better and faster, but I've never heard someone explain what, exactly, is so special about it."

I think he adequately described key OS X features that help improve end-user workflows (even omitting some, like AppleScript and Automator).

I'm as unbiased as he is, I think -- I'm a PC and Mac user -- and if I had no OS X experience, I would've been satisfied with his answer. If you aren't, well, there's really not a whole hell of lot he (or anyone else) can do.

So, like I said, the only answer you're going to like is "you're right; I'm wrong".

Thank you, and your assessment is correct. I gave a few examples as to how the OS stands out of the way, generally has a more logical and streamlined method of organizing features, changing preferences and settings, as well as having powerful, easily configurable features built into the OS that help to get things done faster. I actually skipped a lot, as you pointed out. The whole point of an operating system, aside from providing a stable and secure environment, is to get out of the way and help to use your applications quickly and effectively.

Like I said, this is all based on my own experience and some people like working in a different way, I get that, but like you I like to think that I provide a balanced opinion at the same time.
 
Don't tell me why Vista is so bad, Apple, tell me why OSX is so good.

Yeah, that is the bad thing about those stupid ads.

Haiku made this excellent post a few days ago on Shacknews. He does the website design and front end work for HardOCP, as well as Shacknews and a bunch of other websites. He is also a die hard Machead, much moreso than I am since that's all he uses (his Mac Pro with dual 30" ACD setup is sick).

Anyway, he summed up my thoughts very well here: http://www.shacknews.com/laryn.x?id=...nchor_18232552

TV Spots are the worst design apple does, in my opinion. As someone who buys exclusively apple, I can't stand them using Justin Long to represent me and it's terribly uncreative and sophomoric to use the boring guy in the suit analogy for PC computing.

The all white sets make the characters look like they are floating over nothing and Justin Long's posture looks uncomfortable and forced. The dialogue is forced, poorly written, and takes a back handed approach that undermines the brilliant design and passion their products embody. The agency responsible for this ad campaign has expressed the brand in a trivial and mediocre manner and it's a shame Apple still supports it.

Apple represents a revolution in design and technology. One of the only major fortune 500 companies of their pedigree (nike is up there) and they shouldn't need their competitors products to suck for theirs to be great. Their print and web campaigns and campaigns for things like ipod and iphone are all quite solid but the messaging for OSX is pathetic, and reeks of amateur ad tactics.

My thoughts down to a T. IMHO the product itself does more than enough to sell me and many other people on it (well, the ones who weren't fooled by marketing and actually saw through hands on experience how nice OS X is (the number of people I know who have gone Windows/Mac or entirely Mac in the last two years is scary). Unfortunately, in advertising and politics it is much easier to get yourself in the public consciousness by talking smack.
 
Really? Link please, I want to install that and the Spaces equivalent on my Windows box if it is actually better.


http://www.otakusoftware.com/topdesk/index.html
screen_1.jpg

screen_tileallwindows.jpg



Still wanting my point-by-point examples of how Windows is getting in my way.
 
I was wanting my "point by point" example like Serpico was going to give me, not generalizations.

His examples WERE problems with the Applications that Windows has nothing to do with.

Those alert dialogs that steal focus in windows, are microsoft API calls. If MS wrote them, such that htey were associated with a tab and such that they didn't steal focus from the application, then the apps wouldn't steal focus. I'm sorry, but you're completely wrong and either you know it and you're just being obstinate, or you don't know what you're talking about.

I own nothing from Apple, and haven't used a Mac since taking a course in college that used them in the lab (tiny gray scale screens), but his examples were pretty damn specific, and this particular example was excellent.
 
T

Again, it was one example of a feature in OS X that is powerful, yet clearly exposed, easily used, and highly configurable by the user, as opposed to the same thing in Windows being more obscure, not as powerful, and not as configurable. Whether or not you actually use the feature is another issue, the point is to show the difference in design philosophies that consistently permeate through both operating systems.

Obfuscating things is not a "feature".

Ahem. Serpico, I was agreeing with you. I have vista, and I didn't know I could do this with the search, which is why I said that I gave "you points for this one"
 
Ahem. Serpico, I was agreeing with you. I have vista, and I didn't know I could do this with the search, which is why I said that I gave "you points for this one"

Yeah, I was reenforcing your agreement, not arguing with it. Sorry if that was confusing. :)

Those alert dialogs that steal focus in windows, are microsoft API calls. If MS wrote them, such that htey were associated with a tab and such that they didn't steal focus from the application, then the apps wouldn't steal focus. I'm sorry, but you're completely wrong and either you know it and you're just being obstinate, or you don't know what you're talking about.

I own nothing from Apple, and haven't used a Mac since taking a course in college that used them in the lab (tiny gray scale screens), but his examples were pretty damn specific, and this particular example was excellent.

Thank you. I feel that I've already made several points outside of "added features" that show basic workflow and interface differences between the two operating systems that add up to a smoother workflow experience in the long run. Again, not a dealbreaker for everyone, certainly not enough to switch operating systems for everyone, but its compelling enough for me.

And to really make my point, I had Windows Explorer, Outlook, IE, Firefox, and Putty all steal focus in the last 30 minutes. Throw in the generally non-ergonomic/non-logical configuration menus and such in Windows and I think the difference is obvious, at least to anybody who has broad familiarity with both OSes.

On a side note, I do think its interesting that everyone making a case for OS X either has to make a disclaimer that "I also know Windows like the back of my hand" or "I haven't used Macs in forever", lest they be labeled crazy or brainwashed. The arrogance of the single-platform elitists here (or anywhere else for that matter) is completely fucking retarded.

Techie - I downloaded Topdesk as you linked to. It is way better than when I first used it several years ago (I just did some digging and found that they moved over from OpenGL to DirectX, which apparently made all the difference). Again, executionwise its not as smooth, it doesn't work consistently (its enough for me not to make the purchase), and configuration isn't as nice, but it ok once its all set up. Thanks for the link, and hopefully the not working consistently thing is some obscure bug in my configuration (maybe there is a key conflict, I'll check later).

As for "point by point examples of Windows getting in the way, I've already made it clear in several ways how OS X is generally more streamlined and "gets out of the way". This BTW is different from saying "you can't get work done in Windows", which might be what you think you're hearing from me. I made it very clear right from the beginning that you can get work done very well in either OS, but what I am talking about are specific ways in which OS X differs (IMO in its favor).

Do you want every single example? I gave only half a dozen individual examples that I felt represented the broader approaches of both OSes, both in terms of basic GUI paradigms and approaches, and usability features. Every other person in this thread seems to think that I made my point as well as I could, that and the post was mega-huge. I'm not gong to publish a frigging white paper just to argue with some random small-business IT guy. If your imagination can't extrapolate how those small examples reflect on the bigger picture with both operating systems then I don't know how I can help you.

(to Techie) I'm sorry, but you're completely wrong and either you know it and you're just being obstinate

I have participated in and watched threads where Techie goes around in argumentative circles for what must be the sake of argument. The thing that is most annoying is that his posts generally start well enough, normal high school english and everything, he makes a decent point, and then he veers far far off into WTF-land, at which point he spends pages and pages either reenforcing the same crazy point or spinning his own opinion around to suit what is happening in the current argument, with absolutely no receptiveness to what the other party has to say no matter how informed it may be. I know its the internet and all but its still pretty crazy.
 
I have participated in and watched threads where Techie goes around in argumentative circles for what must be the sake of argument. The thing that is most annoying is that his posts generally start well enough, normal high school english and everything, he makes a decent point, and then he veers far far off into WTF-land, at which point he spends pages and pages either reenforcing the same crazy point or spinning his own opinion around to suit what is happening in the current argument, with absolutely no receptiveness to what the other party has to say no matter how informed it may be. I know its the internet and all but its still pretty crazy.

Ironically, he exhibits all of the traits windows users typically ascribed to Apple fan boys, and i don't like it --- not one bit ;)
 
Aside from here on the forums, I've never ONCE met a Mac user that knew jack about computers. The standard answer is "It just works better". If asked for a reason, it'll usually be "It just is". This is one of the many reasons computer enthusiasts cannot stand the Mac community.

You forgot the most irritating answer/reason of all, "but it looks so pretty!".
 
There's a reason I made a face when I wrote that.

Maybe this would be clearer. :(
 
Man that alone would be enough to keep me on vista, assuming there isn't any "classic" option, which there probably will be. One of the must frustrating and nearly useless portions of MACs is the "dock" they seem to love so much. I really don't understand what they see in it, it is confusing and makes little logical sense. Is it a shortcut? Is it a quicklaunch icon? Is it a running application? Can i even tell? The taskbar i have right now is clean and makes managing running applications and starting new ones easy.
 
Man that alone would be enough to keep me on vista, assuming there isn't any "classic" option, which there probably will be. One of the must frustrating and nearly useless portions of MACs is the "dock" they seem to love so much. I really don't understand what they see in it, it is confusing and makes little logical sense. Is it a shortcut? Is it a quicklaunch icon? Is it a running application? Can i even tell? The taskbar i have right now is clean and makes managing running applications and starting new ones easy.

Its all that and its also a notification bar (the icon jumps). As I explained earlier, this is a better solution than what is currently in Windows, which is for another window or another application to steal focus from what you are currently doing. It is a major major negative to Windows right now and is one of many reasons I prefer OS X for my main work environment.

And FWIW, most old school Mac users also hate the dock. :) I'm relatively new to the OS so I'm fine with it. Its an easy way to launch apps and ones that are currently running have a glowing dot underneath them, there's nothing complicated about it at all. You don't even need to keep your applications on the dock if you don't want, you can also put shortcuts on the desktop or have a shortcut to the Applications folder either on the dock (in which case it acts like a Start Menu just for applications if you have Stacks View enabled) or on the desktop.

Also, I'm very positive about everything I'm seeing about Windows 7 so far, huge huge leap forward in ergonomics and usability. If they can make Windows stop acting like a bratty 10 year old that constantly demands my attention then I'll be super happy.
 
look each user gets what they want... nothign wrong with that..

mac users get a shiny white thing that their friends think are cool (unless they know anything about computers)

pc users get what they want, pure unadulterated hardware..

i think that's great, is there any way of giving these rich bastards better-looking even more shit computers.. im the type who likes that sort of irony..
 
Ironically, he exhibits all of the traits windows users typically ascribed to Apple fan boys, and i don't like it --- not one bit ;)

Its called blind fanatical partisanship, and it isn't fun coming from anybody. :)
 
You guys might want to take a look at what Windows 7 is bringing. MS finally copies to the Dock -_-
http://www.winsupersite.com/win7/win7_preview_02.asp

I'm not sure how to take this...

Oh man....you know you've reached the point of desperation when you start directly copying stuff from the much-hated KDE 4. They didn't even both to cover up the fact...the clock plasmoid (excuse me...."widget" :rolleyes:) even looks the same. ROFL! :D
 
Oh man....you know you've reached the point of desperation when you start directly copying stuff from the much-hated KDE 4. They didn't even both to cover up the fact...the clock plasmoid (excuse me...."widget" :rolleyes:) even looks the same. ROFL! :D

FYI the clock gadget in the picture is the exact same as the original vista clock gadget which predates KDE4 by a year or two. :rolleyes:
 
Ok, I'm a bit confused, what is a nice try? I mean, if it's the dock, then how can it be "soooo much like" and a "nice try" and concurrently be "not even remotely close?"

Maybe I just misread what you were saying...

P.
 
I just saw the new bake sale ad tonight at my parent's house I watched about an hour of TV and saw a ton of commercials and only the Apple ad was blatantly malicious. Seeing it mixed in with all of the other ads left a sour taste in my mouth over their product. A lot of people I know who aren't into computers but know I am have stated how low these new ads are and are frankly turned off by them. It makes me wonder how many people agree with them and are actually turned off by the new level they've sunk to?
 
It is almost nothing like the OS X dock, no idea where that's coming from. Everyone comparing it with KDE are much closer to the mark.

Also, I really like almost everything I'm seeing from the Windows 7 previews so far.
 
Are either operating systems perfect? Of course not. I've only gone over what OS X does right but there are some daft decisions in there as well, like having Cover Flow as a "feature" in Finder. WTF, useless! Software aside, no Core 2 Duo Mac with PCI-E expansion is a massive hole in Apple's product line and I hate it. My perfect OS would be to basically have OS X that runs Windows (ok, VALVE :) ) games on it natively that I can also use with high end PCI-E video cards and a Core 2 Duo CPU. Running a Hackintosh with no consequences is a pretty easy thing these days, and it will be be even easier once EFI is incorporated into more high-end video cards. Valve writing native OS X games is another issue entirely. :) Then there is the fact that using OS X is simply different from using Windows, and for some people there is a period of adjustment (ie - installing programs in OS X generally doesn't use installers, you just drag the app from the mounted ZIP or DMG file over to the application folder. There is no registry, just .plist files and text entries for preferences in the System folder. OS X emphasizes using windows sized for their intended use, not having them be full-screen maximized all the time, and on and on).

See this is the highlight of the post, as reading through the rest of the post, i kept seeing complaint after complaint of windows and each time i thought either i don't have my windows configured like that or i have no problem finding xyz etc etc... It's easy enough to disable notification balloons and uac or whatever else is annoying you... i really don't know what you mean by this internet browser stuff about different tabs affecting each other, i've never come across that..

but this emphasizes something that CAN'T be worked around and is the most solid reason to use windows. this way i can have windows running on all my machines, and not having to remember all the nuances of separate OS's just to get about my daily computing... it's simple as that, windows can do everything i want, other OS can only do .. some of what i want... and admittedly this has nothing to do with how good the OS is.. although.. i'm loving how snappy vista is.. it just responds like silk... :eek::eek:
 
See this is the highlight of the post, as reading through the rest of the post, i kept seeing complaint after complaint of windows and each time i thought either i don't have my windows configured like that or i have no problem finding xyz etc etc... It's easy enough to disable notification balloons and uac or whatever else is annoying you

Seems like much of the notification area concerns are addressed in W7. One is that things can be dragged off (see an icon - just drag to desktop - poof). Two - EVERYTHING defaults to off - which is freakin' sweet.

... i really don't know what you mean by this internet browser stuff about different tabs affecting each other, i've never come across that..

I think he's referring to websites that crash a single tab...which then crashes your ENTIRE browser window. I think FF3b1 is trying to address this, where each tab has a separate thread - so if it DOES crash, your application and other tabs a whole, aren't brought down with it.
 
I think he's referring to websites that crash a single tab...which then crashes your ENTIRE browser window. I think FF3b1 is trying to address this, where each tab has a separate thread - so if it DOES crash, your application and other tabs a whole, aren't brought down with it.

That's not really a problem with Windows though. Firefox has the same problem.
Google Chrome is the only browser I've seen really try to address this in a big way.
 
Yeah...it'd be weird if he actually blamed Windows for it. Hrmm.
 
You forgot the most irritating answer/reason of all, "but it looks so pretty!".

This on a sight where people do all kinds of cool and stylish mods that would cost you a fortune if you paid someone to do it.

Looks aren't the be all end all of computers, but the days of a fast machine in a beige box end a long time ago. Even among geeks, looks matter.
 
Man that alone would be enough to keep me on vista, assuming there isn't any "classic" option, which there probably will be. One of the must frustrating and nearly useless portions of MACs is the "dock" they seem to love so much. I really don't understand what they see in it, it is confusing and makes little logical sense. Is it a shortcut? Is it a quicklaunch icon? Is it a running application? Can i even tell? The taskbar i have right now is clean and makes managing running applications and starting new ones easy.

I'll withhold judgement till I get a copy of the beta, but the way you describe it makes it sound nice.

If you want to browse the web, you want Firefox (or one of those alternatives, like IE). Instead of looking for the location of my open Firefox (assuming one is open), I just click on the same old Firefox button and up it pops. I'm not sur ehow this will work with something like word, where you could have multiple windows open, but I can definitely see how that might be a UI improvement....but again, until I've used it, I won't know.

It's like the Vista Start Menu....I like it and I don't. I like that it's compact and the way the folders work, but I hate that MS has so much clutter under all programs. Do they really need to put all of those programs under Programs? I prefer a few programs and the rest in easy to find categories....of course even that's not completely necessary, since you can simply search for a program (which is easily one of my favorite UI additions in Vista).

We all hate change, but one thing I've learned is you gotta give things a chance before you condemn them. Most of my favorite Cd's are from artists I didn't initially like. The first time I saw Mulholland drive, I asked the friend who dragged us to it why the hell he insisted on seeing the movie (which made absolutely no sense). After discussing it, I was intrigued enough to buy the DVD and watch it many times over.

It may suck, but I have to give it a chance (weeks of use, not a few hours, much less a screen shot) before I make that decision.
 
look each user gets what they want... nothign wrong with that..

mac users get a shiny white thing that their friends think are cool (unless they know anything about computers)

pc users get what they want, pure unadulterated hardware..

i think that's great, is there any way of giving these rich bastards better-looking even more shit computers.. im the type who likes that sort of irony..

I think you have to change that to PC Enthusiasts. PC Users don't give a rats ass about the hardware. They want a tool that serves the purpose they're using it for at a reasonable price.

The Mac's price keeps them out of many homes, and the software (or lack thereof) may keep them out of those who are less price sensitive, but very few buyers are looking at the CPU or GPU. They should, but the truth is they don't know much about it.

It's the same with cars. Most people don't look at the parts in the car. They look at the bells and whistles, the way it looks and maybe they look at Consumer Reports' reliability ratings....I guess these days they're looking at MPG ratings as well.
 
It's easy enough to disable notification balloons and uac or whatever else is annoying you... i really don't know what you mean by this internet browser stuff about different tabs affecting each other, i've never come across that..

Don't recall him saying anything about balloon notifications, which generally don't get focus.

However, disabling UAC, is not an option if you're concerned about security. It'd be like running *nix system and removing the requirement to log in as admin (via Sudo or a UAC like GUI prompt) when you install software. You might was sell just say security is for wusses. Real pc users don't need no security.

UAC isn't perfect. It's not as bad as those who incessantly bitch about it ruining their day (unless there day is spent installing software or moving things around protected directories), but it needs some improvement, and they're getting there.

I hate that MS get's it wrong so often. I love that MS continuously improves things and after a few iterations, they get it right. And while they almost always have issues at launch (it's tough when you've got 90-95% of the market and the H/W is anything but homogeneous). It's even harder when H/W vendors don't get beta drivers out during beta.

I still remember people defending the lack of a working driver from Creative when RC1/2 came out. Creative had no excuse, but MS got the blame. There's only so much you can do..especially when the architecture that MS made....necessary, but painful for some.
 
That's not really a problem with Windows though. Firefox has the same problem.
Google Chrome is the only browser I've seen really try to address this in a big way.

In this case you're technically correct. However, since IE, which is basically a part of windows, has the same issue, I have to give the point to Serpico. You and I may use FF or Chrome, but the vast majority of windows users just use IE.

Maybe it'll be in IE8 (though I don't believe it's in Beta 1 (never got around to installing beta 2....actually i did and windows wouldn't boot, so I did a system restore).
 
In this case you're technically correct. However, since IE, which is basically a part of windows, has the same issue, I have to give the point to Serpico. You and I may use FF or Chrome, but the vast majority of windows users just use IE.

But faulting it as a problem with Windows is wrong.

Unlike some smaller software companies that might cross job responsibilities a bit, Microsoft is huge. The IE team is separate from the WMP team is separate from the Windows team. I guess IE is crossing a bit into Windows territory now that we've got Protected Mode, but it still remains.
WMP, IE, Movie Maker, whatever you want: Those are just programs that are INCLUDED in Windows to just make it more attractive for Average Joe.

This is an enthusiast board. Blaming an IE issue and saying it's a problem with Windows is asinine.
 
But faulting it as a problem with Windows is wrong.

Unlike some smaller software companies that might cross job responsibilities a bit, Microsoft is huge. The IE team is separate from the WMP team is separate from the Windows team. I guess IE is crossing a bit into Windows territory now that we've got Protected Mode, but it still remains.
WMP, IE, Movie Maker, whatever you want: Those are just programs that are INCLUDED in Windows to just make it more attractive for Average Joe.

This is an enthusiast board. Blaming an IE issue and saying it's a problem with Windows is asinine.


Almost everything you use, in windows is a application. We're not discussing memory management, thread management or virtually anything else that's traditionally associated with an OS. Hell, Taskmanager is an App. The clock is an app.

Explorer isn't part of the OS. A GUI isn't part of an OS. It doesn't matter. If the UI sucked, you could have the underlying OS designed and written by Jesus Christ and nobody would want it, because it'd be unusable, even though it was technically perfect. There's a reason why non-tech users don't use *nix (OS X not withstanding).

So yes, it's an App, but it's something that every computer buyer expects the OS to come with. And when the app is written by the OS publisher and the only place that App runs is on the Desktop OS's that they make (or previously made), it's a part of the OS.

It's not like we're having a discussion about Kernels (which the vast majority of posters are not qualified discuss and most never will be).
 
Back
Top