Some Initial Thoughts on AMD's HD 6800 Cards

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
PC Perspective has posted their thoughts on AMD's upcoming HD 6800 cards.

AMD appears to have changed around all the “uncore” aspects of the GPU, but have left the overall functionality of the thread processors intact. There are still 320 of these processors, but once we figure in the 4 stream units vs. the older 5 units, we see that stream count has fallen from 1600 to 1280. What makes this interesting is that the performance of the HD 6870 is very close to that of the older HD 5870 (though still slightly slower as shown in leaked benchmarks)."
 
It's not the same series cards. The 6870 and 6850 replace the 5770 and 5750 respectively. What's "weak" is the confusion instigated by AMD marketing to change the numbering scheme yet again.
 
It's not the same series cards. The 6870 and 6850 replace the 5770 and 5750 respectively. What's "weak" is the confusion instigated by AMD marketing to change the numbering scheme yet again.

Wow, talk about confusing. When I read the 6870 is slower than the 5870 I knew it didn't sound right, but didn't think this was the answer. You KNOW somebody out there will buy the 6970 expecting it to have 2 GPUs (as the X9XX normally do) only to find just one. In fact what would they even call 2 GPUs? 7XXX?
 
Wow, talk about confusing. When I read the 6870 is slower than the 5870 I knew it didn't sound right, but didn't think this was the answer. You KNOW somebody out there will buy the 6970 expecting it to have 2 GPUs (as the X9XX normally do) only to find just one. In fact what would they even call 2 GPUs? 7XXX?

if they fail to research a product they are spending $400 they deserve to get bit.
 
Wow, talk about confusing. When I read the 6870 is slower than the 5870 I knew it didn't sound right, but didn't think this was the answer. You KNOW somebody out there will buy the 6970 expecting it to have 2 GPUs (as the X9XX normally do) only to find just one. In fact what would they even call 2 GPUs? 7XXX?


it will be the 6990..

while its annoying it does actually make a little sense i mean hell out of the 5k series all we had was the 5970.. tons of unused options there.. yeah it will confuse some of the uninformed consumers.. but the majority of them were never going to buy the high end card anyways otherwise they would of looked up the information.. so in the end its their problem.. for the rest of us it really has no effect since we actually know what the hell we plan to buy before we buy it..
 
it will be the 6990..

while its annoying it does actually make a little sense i mean hell out of the 5k series all we had was the 5970.. tons of unused options there.. yeah it will confuse some of the uninformed consumers.. but the majority of them were never going to buy the high end card anyways otherwise they would of looked up the information.. so in the end its their problem.. for the rest of us it really has no effect since we actually know what the hell we plan to buy before we buy it..

It's still stupid. They really need to pick something and stick with it. The numbering should be useful for telling people what things are. Changing it up for no good reason is really silly.
 
PC Per said:
It does not look like tessellation performance has been improved on these cards as we had speculated some time ago here at PCPer.com. NVIDIA will still hold a decisive edge in that area

Anyone know what was the rumour supporting that claim?
 
Well, that's going to be a little confusing now that switched the numbering schema, but overall shouldn't be that big of a deal. I buy a card based off of the reviews and benchmarks. At least we don't have all those stupid suffixes anymore. Like SE, XT, GT, etc. That was always confusing, especially between Nvidia and ATI. Since they used the suffixes differently, and they would change them every other generation.
 
Companies always do this!!! They make everything nice and easy at first..

3870=4870/5870 You should THINK that the next in line would be the 6870.. but you're wrong. Now the 6870=the 5770. What the hell??

Example. Rocky movies.

Rocky I
Rocky II
Rocky III
Rocky IV
Rocky V

Oh you would think the next one would be Rocky VI right? Nope. Rocky Balboa. What the fuck?
 
It's still stupid. They really need to pick something and stick with it. The numbering should be useful for telling people what things are. Changing it up for no good reason is really silly.


but see thats the point.. they do tell you what they are.. the numbers are based off performance compared to the series before it.. if they used the 6770 tag and it destroyed the 5850 people would sit there and go wtf.. theres really nothing they can do to please people either way they go..
 
As it turns out, even consistancy with product naming is too much to ask for, not to mention driver performance... amirite???
 
Whoever comes up with the great idea to rename these really needs a forcefull boot in the swingers. Do they sit around a table for a few hours and just come up with a new naming convention to confuse people? Someone actually gets paid for this shit?
 
But he refers to them as Barts XT and Barts PRO, which according to the chart, are the 6700 series, not the 6800 series. I think the PCPer writer just mixed things up.
 
But he refers to them as Barts XT and Barts PRO, which according to the chart, are the 6700 series, not the 6800 series. I think the PCPer writer just mixed things up.


barts XT is the 6870 and barts PRO is the 6850.. or at least thats what the rumors are for now until AMD drops the NDA..

but the articles written based off speculation and rumors so really its about as useful as all the other crap floating around out there..

arg damn NDA!!!
 
Not much competition, hence the lack of horsepower UNF! in the 6G series.
 
I don't know where Josh Walrath gets his rumors, but a lot of his speculation doesn't quite fit what I've been hearing...

For example, every rumor I've heard about moving away from 4+1 VLIW-5 has been indicating dropping the T-unit and incorporating its functionality into one or two of the other SPs. Josh says it's simply dropped one of the narrow ALUs for a 3+1 arrangement which frankly doesn't make any sense to me since it's the t-unit that apparently is underutilized.
 
if they fail to research a product they are spending $400 they deserve to get bit.

Thank You. It's a name change, get over it. It's not to deceive anyone and if someone gets burned it's soley their own fault for uneducated buying.
 
So the new cards are either the same speed, useless or loads faster. This really helps to clear that up.
 
you know.. rather than argue the points, i wonder why this is front page news... I wonder if Steve is trying to tell us something. Rumors don't tend to make [H]ard front page news, do they?
 
you know.. rather than argue the points, i wonder why this is front page news... I wonder if Steve is trying to tell us something. Rumors don't tend to make [H]ard front page news, do they?

Because they be fun! I heard they coated the fans in unicorn semen to make them silent (and glittery) and it needs only half the cores because they exsist in a dimentonal flux, so 3 cores occupy the same space but weigh 0, so it has free shipping.
 
Because they be fun! I heard they coated the fans in unicorn semen to make them silent (and glittery) and it needs only half the cores because they exsist in a dimentonal flux, so 3 cores occupy the same space but weigh 0, so it has free shipping.

+1
To be fair, unicorn semen does make fans silent.
Also, to be fair AMD also dropped the ATI logo. I don't remember AMD's logo anywhere on the box of any Radeon boxes (although I haven't been in the market recently). So the new 6000 series will premiere under AMD (at least if I remember correctly).
Someone that is likely to confuse the new naming convention might as well be confused by the fact that AMD now makes the Radeon cards (at least logo wise).

It may sound a bit stupid but really, if someone is in the market for a higher end card they should know the name change by now and I am sure they will get wind of the new naming convention for cards.
 
Don't really give a crap about the name changes personally. If I'm going to be spending hundreds of dollars on a video card, I'm going to do something as stupid as not research what I'm buying (thereby making name changes 100% irrelevant).
 
Don't really give a crap about the name changes personally. If I'm going to be spending hundreds of dollars on a video card, I'm going to do something as stupid as not research what I'm buying (thereby making name changes 100% irrelevant).

Don't really give a crap about the name changes personally. If I'm going to be spending hundreds of dollars on a video card, I'm NOT going to do something as stupid as not research what I'm buying (thereby making name changes 100% irrelevant).

I AM going to typo like an idiot though. Freaking no edit...
 
New number to performance model makes sense, because it's the first set of cards that'll have AMD on them and because it's a feature refresh rather than a performance launch.

Maybe in a different world where AMD had been treated fairly back in the Athlon days, and TSMC had not messed up royally, the 6800s had been like the 6800s of Nvidia, great asskickers.
 
so basically the question should be asked to AMD, "what would make me want to buy a new series card(if you wanna call it that) IF(and i state if) it is slower?" And the probability that the older card 5xxx series could be a bit cheaper. This is what it boils down to for me personally. I hold no favorite for branding. I go with best bang for my dollars. And this is why i look forward to [H] reviews on the matter as well as they hold this in the highest regard also.
 
It's not the same series cards. The 6870 and 6850 replace the 5770 and 5750 respectively. What's "weak" is the confusion instigated by AMD marketing to change the numbering scheme yet again.

They seem far more focused on changing their numbering schemes rather than making drivers that work.
 
Nice to see one more round of links posted by websites needing ad views lol. What's worse is the writer was not invited to AMD's press event :D
Everything he wrote is based on rumors that are weeks old and already debunked. Specially that fake chart calling Barts the HD6770
 
The leaked chart got not only the names of the chip wrong BUT some of the most important specs as well, wait and see. So the article is based on wrong info.
 
so basically the question should be asked to AMD, "what would make me want to buy a new series card(if you wanna call it that) IF(and i state if) it is slower?" And the probability that the older card 5xxx series could be a bit cheaper. This is what it boils down to for me personally. I hold no favorite for branding. I go with best bang for my dollars. And this is why i look forward to [H] reviews on the matter as well as they hold this in the highest regard also.
Yes, the only numbers that matter are price and performance. Know your budget; buy the best card in that range.
 
Just some guys 2c imo, just adding more to the rumors and mis-information floating around. Sounds a bit bitter at the begining of the article for being passed over for an invite also. I'll continue to take everything I read with the 6 series as false until it's official.
 
How is this article news/discussion worthy other than the fact that it looks like they used rumors posted in the videocard section of H as the basis for this article.

Can't decide which is more FAIL. The article or the people who bitched taking the article as fact when its a regurgitated summary of H's own 6XXX rumor thread.
 
My-troll-sense-IS-TINGLING.jpg
 
who cares about the tesselation engine, give me a game where it makes a damn then I'll care.
 
Companies always do this!!! They make everything nice and easy at first..

3870=4870/5870 You should THINK that the next in line would be the 6870.. but you're wrong. Now the 6870=the 5770. What the hell??

Example. Rocky movies.

Rocky I
Rocky II
Rocky III
Rocky IV
Rocky V

Oh you would think the next one would be Rocky VI right? Nope. Rocky Balboa. What the fuck?

Those five moves came out within 13 years of each other, if memory serves. Rocky "VI" came out EIGHTEEN years after the last Rocky, and really was independent enough to stand on its own laurels (and was a damn good film). The naming was changed because the series had become too "sequelified" and Rocky V was considered bad by many--even Stallone admitted that he let his fans down. The sixth movie was a much more fitting and honorable ending story to the hero that Balboa was (and left you wondering if he would fight even more matches at that age...)
 
The video card naming scheme is stupid and while they think its a good idea I think in the end they hurt themself the most. The vast majority of consumers could easily understand video cards if these idiots would stop shuffling names constantly. And in the end that would mean the consumer might start to purchase better video cards because they understand what they are getting and can be comfortable knowing they are making a decent purchasing decision. It is just like the Mhz wars, in the old days consumers knew just look for the fastest clocks then they were suddenly bewildered by AMDs 3200+ naming and after that it all went to hell. Consumers have no flucking clue now what the processors mean or why they are named. And most of them do not want to waste hours reading to learn it every time.

I research every decision carefully but I know that I am one in a 1000 in this world with that mentality.

Anyhow like I said in the end it hurts their own business the only companies that really make out are best buy who can peddle a garbage card off to an uninformed comsumer but nVidia isnt making much more money on that. All the profit is going strait to the retailer.
 
So what are they going to do with the next generation up the numbers again?
 
Back
Top