No DVD Playback In Windows 8

My optical drive is disconnected... I had to plug it back in to install Mass Effect 3 Collector's Edition but after that the PATA adapter went straight back onto my backup drive.

I have an external eSATA drive, which I only connect once in a blue moon, usually to install an OS, as it is a pain to make a USB stick version of the install media.
 
This is a big problem with windows 8 so far... So much adware and junk and cut corners.

Windows 7 and before came with a media player (not including center), Windows 8 has a junky ad filled "music" metro application where you can buy music. Then a similar junky "games" section where they advertize xbox live (console) games to you... This is just another cut extra. WIll all the extra things you need to get and adware, I hope that windows 8 is free.
 
I'm more worried about Windows Media Center.

I want a damn plugin or something, even if its 3rd party to play DVD/BR in WMC.

You should pay the Home Theater PCs & Equipment forum a visit more often to stay up to date with WMC happenings. There's been plugins for WMC since Windows XP Media Center Edition.

Total Media Theater 3 and 5 have WMC playback integration. You can assign Blu-ray playback to Total Media Theater using MediaBrowser add-on for WMC.
 
Considering the reception that Windows 8 is getting, and that Valve and EA both agreed to start developing games on Ubuntu, I don't see Windows lasting much longer. Not that Microsoft won't create a Windows 8.1 version to correct all the problems, like they did with Vista and Windows 7.

Does DVD playback effect Windows 8 ability to sell? Not really, but Blu-Ray and a Media Center are going to be something people may want. Though if we start talking about VLC and XBMC, these are applications that are available on Ubuntu as well. Not to forget the holy grail MythTV, which I still love to this day.

Though I'm sure Microsoft is doing this to reduce unnecessary cost, but the price of Windows 8 won't be any different then Windows 7, Vista, or XP. A smart consumer could see this as Microsoft cheating the consumer. There are no benefits to switch over to Windows 8, and if I have to install VLC and XBMC then why the hell stick with Windows at all? Especially when EA and Valve are moving towards Ubuntu.
 
Considering the reception that Windows 8 is getting, and that Valve and EA both agreed to start developing games on Ubuntu, I don't see Windows lasting much longer. Not that Microsoft won't create a Windows 8.1 version to correct all the problems, like they did with Vista and Windows 7.

Disagree. Only a small minority of PC users actually play non-flash based games, let alone use Steam.

It's easy to forget this when you hang out on a site like HardOCP/Hardforums and are surrounded my like minded individuals, but gaming simply isn't a major factor in PC or OS sales.

Most people will whine at first when it comes out but then get used to it and continue on. Sortof like what happens every time Facebook has a layout change. I don't see Microsofts OS share suffering at all from this, in fact it may even grow due to better tablet support.

I certainly won't be upgrading to 8 right away, but it won't be long until it is bundled with all new PC's
 
Considering the reception that Windows 8 is getting, and that Valve and EA both agreed to start developing games on Ubuntu, I don't see Windows lasting much longer. Not that Microsoft won't create a Windows 8.1 version to correct all the problems, like they did with Vista and Windows 7.

Does DVD playback effect Windows 8 ability to sell? Not really, but Blu-Ray and a Media Center are going to be something people may want. Though if we start talking about VLC and XBMC, these are applications that are available on Ubuntu as well. Not to forget the holy grail MythTV, which I still love to this day.

Though I'm sure Microsoft is doing this to reduce unnecessary cost, but the price of Windows 8 won't be any different then Windows 7, Vista, or XP. A smart consumer could see this as Microsoft cheating the consumer. There are no benefits to switch over to Windows 8, and if I have to install VLC and XBMC then why the hell stick with Windows at all? Especially when EA and Valve are moving towards Ubuntu.

LOL

windows is going no where, gaming on windows is NOT what is keeping at the head of the pack
 
Cheese and Rice! Microsoft.... really.... reallly? you are really going to do this to us? Well thanks, I am now expecting a call every other week from various friends and family members now who upgrade their computers to windows 8 complaining about their DVDs not working.... It is absolutely ridiculous that this is not going to be included, windows 8 is turning into some sort of weird touch enabled downgrade from windows 7....

It is also ridiculous that even though almost every person I know has their own computer, if I tell them, just download and install a program called "VLC" they wont get it... Almost all normal computer users I know are absolutely incapable of opening and extracting a zip file with any sort of proficiency, let alone installing a single program.... I don't want to live on this planet any more.
 
Is this more about Microsoft removing the DVD decoder? Because if Windows doesn't have a decoder in it, then no player will work, unless they have paid for the license and it is incorporated into the player. Or is this not valid anymore these days?
 
Cheese and Rice! Microsoft.... really.... reallly? you are really going to do this to us? Well thanks, I am now expecting a call every other week from various friends and family members now who upgrade their computers to windows 8 complaining about their DVDs not working.... It is absolutely ridiculous that this is not going to be included, windows 8 is turning into some sort of weird touch enabled downgrade from windows 7....

It is also ridiculous that even though almost every person I know has their own computer, if I tell them, just download and install a program called "VLC" they wont get it... Almost all normal computer users I know are absolutely incapable of opening and extracting a zip file with any sort of proficiency, let alone installing a single program.... I don't want to live on this planet any more.

lol
 
As more is revealed about Windows 8 it just re-enforces my disinterest in it.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038687407 said:
I have an external eSATA drive, which I only connect once in a blue moon, usually to install an OS, as it is a pain to make a USB stick version of the install media.

Really? It only takes 3-5 minutes to make bootable USB install media for Windows/Linux. That is of course only if you have ISO's handy.
 
Does VLC do hardware playback yet?

Something makes me feel like this was added to VLC 2.0, but I haven't checked so don't quote me on that. I just think I remember reading about that in the release notes.
 
Who cares. I'm not "upgrading" to windows fisher price edition anyways. It's the next incarnation of "ME". They should just brand it Windows Idiot Edition. Big flashy buttons and a useless interface for fat fingered morons!
 
DVD stuff is irrelevant lots of free programs do that or better yet, rip them for Hard Disk playback.

Media Center though is a big loss for Tuner/HTPC folks like me. There isn't much out there for Free DVR recording with guide.

Though I already thought Metrosexual Windows8 was a joke, so this is just one more reason to stay with 7.
 
Windows 8 wouldnt be a bad idea for big screen TV and living room Studio PC....Taking care of everything out there. Music, TV, Internet, Gamming, Apps, Everything. There interface would make it very easy for TV use in the living room. I had a problem with the desktop out there. anyways at least you can switch back and fourth between the two. I think MS is onto something with this. If they can keep performance up, its just a matter of seeing something different for most. Ill give it a try. Driver support is critical.
 
Get the desktop out of the cave and into the living room! advanced entertainment system.
 
Am I the only one that is generally pissed about codec licensing at all?

ok I can understand odd ball ones, like real player etc

But DVD, Blu-Rays, mp3 and all generally accepted standard codecs should be available in some sort of basics player on every OS.

While there are lots of improvements from xp->win7... the most important to me were the simple things... like built in iso burner, WMP that played DVDs...

Seems like this move is going backwards in OS capability, back to the day where you had to install 20 apps before the OS was usable for just daily messing around. They are making their OS harder to us rather then easier.

I am not saying it has to be a GOOD player just a basic one.

Maybe IF MS can create a slick integration with their version of an app store, when if you click a file/ext and the computer can't play it, it will open the store with apps that can play it.

It just always bothered me that I had to pay to play DVD, even though I bought a drive and the movie itself.
 
Just when I thought Windows 8 couldn't be more pointless and ass-backwards.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038687460 said:
Disagree. Only a small minority of PC users actually play non-flash based games, let alone use Steam.

It's easy to forget this when you hang out on a site like HardOCP/Hardforums and are surrounded my like minded individuals, but gaming simply isn't a major factor in PC or OS sales.

Most people will whine at first when it comes out but then get used to it and continue on. Sortof like what happens every time Facebook has a layout change. I don't see Microsofts OS share suffering at all from this, in fact it may even grow due to better tablet support.

I certainly won't be upgrading to 8 right away, but it won't be long until it is bundled with all new PC's

QFT, what this ^ guy said.
 
Man I can't wait for linux compatible steam. I want this idiot monkey off my back. I don't disagree with Microsoft that DVD playback isn't a core functionality. They simply realized that most people used alternative software anyway. Why pay for the license? MPC-HC is ten thousand times better than WMP will ever be.
 
On the subject of DVD playback I don't really see a problem as tablets which Windows 8 appears to be exlusively written for, will not come with an optical drive of any sort.

My experience so far with Windows 8 feels like it isn't a desktop experience at all. With all I have to do now to explain things to the older generations like my dad already. I'm not going to like to explain that the start button is not visable, you just have to know it's there and how he would shut down his PC, and where to find things all over again.

I do feel Windows 8 has it's place and that would be on a device 'like' the Transformer Prime which is a tablet, with a keyboard if wanted or needed.
 
Really? It only takes 3-5 minutes to make bootable USB install media for Windows/Linux. That is of course only if you have ISO's handy.

True, but I do it so infrequently, that I have to look it up every time, and then download the tools, etc.

It takes only a few seconds to plug my optical drive in :p
 
I wonder if it'll be like some things in W7, there, but not active. Like Windows Mail, Calendar and other things. It wasn't long before people found that if you added/replaced a few files with old ones they magically worked. If so, then it won't be long before someone figures out a way to "fix" it.
 
No problem for me , I'm not going to fucking bother with Windows 8.

Windows 7 works fantastic , thanks Microsoft but you can go suck a bag of dicks.
 
Sorry but i am a big Windows Media Center user... removing DVD playback is a joke.. if anything i was expecting them to add bluray playback support in natively by Windows 8..
 
This is going to cause a huge headache. While all of us here will be fine, a ton of people who buy new laptops will be wondering why they cant play a dvd. With Win 8 launching around back to school I can see this being a huge issue.
 
Heh - all this bitching on the [H]ard forums about M$ stripping a little used feature out when there are better free options out there. What's next, everyone going to get upset about not having good onboard video? Other than the legit complaints from those who do sales or tech support for a living, having to deal with sheeple who aren't smart enough to download WMP classic, etc, etc, the rest of you are getting oft!
 
Zarathustra[H];1038687460 said:
Disagree. Only a small minority of PC users actually play non-flash based games, let alone use Steam.

It's easy to forget this when you hang out on a site like HardOCP/Hardforums and are surrounded my like minded individuals, but gaming simply isn't a major factor in PC or OS sales.

Most people will whine at first when it comes out but then get used to it and continue on. Sortof like what happens every time Facebook has a layout change. I don't see Microsofts OS share suffering at all from this, in fact it may even grow due to better tablet support.

I certainly won't be upgrading to 8 right away, but it won't be long until it is bundled with all new PC's

EA and Steam are just recent examples. The reason developers are looking to Ubuntu is because they wanna avoid losing 30% of their profits. Sell an app on Microsoft's Windows 8 app store and you lose 30% of the sale to Microsoft. This is bad for consumers as this will likely either drive up the price of software, or developers will just have to eat the 30% loss.

Lets not forget that majority of flash based games are free and are not OS dependent. The point is developers aren't happy with the direction that Windows 8 is going and a exodus maybe underway.

People will inevitably get Windows 8 one way or another, but I think you're going to see a lot of people asking for new Laptops and PCs with Windows 7. This sorta think occurred with XP --> Vista. Tablets are going to be a strong market for Windows 8, but as you can see anything that isn't an iPad doesn't sell well. Android is barely making a dent in the market. Windows 8 will likely do better with X86 compatibility, but I really don't it'll take off. If we learned anything about non iPad tablets is that they have to be cheap. Such as the Kindle Fire. I really doubt Windows 8 tablets will be in that price range.
 
EA and Steam are just recent examples. The reason developers are looking to Ubuntu is because they wanna avoid losing 30% of their profits. Sell an app on Microsoft's Windows 8 app store and you lose 30% of the sale to Microsoft. This is bad for consumers as this will likely either drive up the price of software, or developers will just have to eat the 30% loss.

Lets not forget that majority of flash based games are free and are not OS dependent. The point is developers aren't happy with the direction that Windows 8 is going and a exodus maybe underway.

People will inevitably get Windows 8 one way or another, but I think you're going to see a lot of people asking for new Laptops and PCs with Windows 7. This sorta think occurred with XP --> Vista. Tablets are going to be a strong market for Windows 8, but as you can see anything that isn't an iPad doesn't sell well. Android is barely making a dent in the market. Windows 8 will likely do better with X86 compatibility, but I really don't it'll take off. If we learned anything about non iPad tablets is that they have to be cheap. Such as the Kindle Fire. I really doubt Windows 8 tablets will be in that price range.

Steam and EA doesn't have to go through Microsoft's App store. Just go to steampowered.com and get the Steam UI and be done with it, the same way as it's been the past 10 years. I think you're running around shouting that the sky is falling. It's just an acorn.
 
This is going to cause a huge headache. While all of us here will be fine, a ton of people who buy new laptops will be wondering why they cant play a dvd. With Win 8 launching around back to school I can see this being a huge issue.

People are making way more of this than is really going to be the case. XP didn't have built-in DVD support but it was included with with machines that came with DVDs. It just doesn't make business sense for Microsoft to include these features in every copy of Windows as fewer and fewer people use them while paying the royalties on every copy of Windows. Sure I'd like to have all of this stuff included, I use all kinds of media on my PCs, DVDs, BDs, TV but I really can't expect Microsoft to support technologies on the decline that have cost to them for nothing. It's not like every free option out there won't work and people can get a simple to install probably low cost pack that adds the features back in if they need them.

Again, I don't know how Microsoft could justify keeping these things bundle from a business perspective as much as I don't like the idea.
 
For a split second I was all...:mad:

But then, I thought about the last time I played an actual dvd on my pc and used windows media player to view it. Doesn't this also save Microsoft some sort of license fee's from the dvd codec?

Im pretty sure MS came out a while ago and said they were going to stop support for DVD playback. Don't feel like looking it up now though, they were trying to save on liscensing fee's so this would make sense.

Not like it matters, any player you download will consume less resources and offer a pretty good interface with the ability to use any codec you have installed.
 
Back
Top