Monster Cable Threatens The Wrong Guy

joker_popcorn870.gif


Those other two companies involved-- Xtreme accessories and Monster whatever-- should contact this guy. Seriously though, I can definitely see this go nowhere. A sensible response to a senseless request?
 
I've been buying A/V cables exclusively from Blue Jeans Cable for five years now ever since a thread at Audioholics got my attention. They are very nice cables for the price you pay compared to cables sold at a brick-and-mortar.

I wish Kurt all the best in getting Monster to back down. They will admit defeat, eventually.
 
Had people in the past stood up to bullies like this, our legal system today wouldn't be the lawyer's playground that it is. Medical care would be affordable. Yes, you read that correctly. The patent and copyright system wouldn't be so screwed up as it is currently if people just stood their ground (when right to do so). Car insurance would be cheap, and so on and so on.

The biggest problems in our society today can be traced to sleezebag lawyers. Companies become bullies like this knowing people cower from dealing with expensive sleazebag lawyers.

Every industry and profession has their share of honest people and sleazebags. Unfortunately, the legal profession has the highest (per capita) of sleazebags.

Why is medicine so expensive? Why everyone who gets medical care (and is a sleazebag themselves) thinks their 98 years old spunky Grandma couldn't possibly have died of natural causes when she broke her hip. It must have been the hospital's fault. Medicine pays nearly 70% of the money coming in as "payment for services" straight to their malpractice insurance. The prices have to be so high as to make what is left over a decent enough income to continue to operate.

Car insurance is so high as everyone who gets even gently touched on the road considers it winning the lottery by suing the other driver for everything they are insured for.

The phrase "I'm gonna sue!" is far too common in our society. Sleazebags are only too happy to oblige. Many of these sleazebags end up being politicians.

Want to fix this? Simple, make all complaints brought by an attorney, whether in litigation or not, have a one-sided payment requirement. Simply put, the plaintiff's attorney only gets paid if the judgment is for the plaintiff, else they get nothing AND if the plaintiff loses, he pays the defendants expenses (all of them). Eliminate the 36% fee and limit it just like other agents, to 10% or a flat rate.

Attorneys are the ONLY profession or industry in the USA that is NOT regulated. Why? We are stupid enough to elect them to office and they make the laws and they make sure those laws are so worded as to make sure you have to hire an attorney to figure them out.

You give consequences for frivolity to the legal profession and you'll see many social, business, and criminal problems solved quite on their own.
 
I've actually bought some of his cables - a 30ft run of cable to run from my home theater to a subwoofer across the room. It's a great cable, reasonably priced compared to stuff Monster peddles, and exactly what I needed. His company's web site is also great - simple and has a lot of really good and informative audio faqs. I really like the no-bullshit stance his company take to cables in general. They don't promote "esoteric" crap, just solid cables based on a straightforward approach to sound engineering using quality materials. Go have a look at his site, you'll see what I mean.

Love the letter he wrote - Monster's lawyers better send him a case of beer and an apology note... as he pretty much called them out for a gunfight and it looks like they came packing water pistols. :p
 
Settling when you know you're in the right because it's cheaper than fighting in court is bad for society.

The fact that fighting litigation costs more than a large corporation would take as a settlement is...funny?
 
i too used monoprice before, but this guy is going to get my new purchases.

BJC FTW! :)
 
I bought into the Monster Cable hype back in the day, but after 20 years, my Monster Cables that connect my stereo together still work fine.
 
Wait.......

So, not only are they totally overpriced, but they pocket additional money by not paying any federal tax.....

Glad the only "Monster" I deal with comes in a CAN. :p
 
Had people in the past stood up to bullies like this, our legal system today wouldn't be the lawyer's playground that it is. Medical care would be affordable. Yes, you read that correctly. The patent and copyright system wouldn't be so screwed up as it is currently if people just stood their ground (when right to do so). Car insurance would be cheap, and so on and so on.

The biggest problems in our society today can be traced to sleezebag lawyers. Companies become bullies like this knowing people cower from dealing with expensive sleazebag lawyers.

Every industry and profession has their share of honest people and sleazebags. Unfortunately, the legal profession has the highest (per capita) of sleazebags.

Why is medicine so expensive? Why everyone who gets medical care (and is a sleazebag themselves) thinks their 98 years old spunky Grandma couldn't possibly have died of natural causes when she broke her hip. It must have been the hospital's fault. Medicine pays nearly 70% of the money coming in as "payment for services" straight to their malpractice insurance. The prices have to be so high as to make what is left over a decent enough income to continue to operate.

Car insurance is so high as everyone who gets even gently touched on the road considers it winning the lottery by suing the other driver for everything they are insured for.

The phrase "I'm gonna sue!" is far too common in our society. Sleazebags are only too happy to oblige. Many of these sleazebags end up being politicians.

Want to fix this? Simple, make all complaints brought by an attorney, whether in litigation or not, have a one-sided payment requirement. Simply put, the plaintiff's attorney only gets paid if the judgment is for the plaintiff, else they get nothing AND if the plaintiff loses, he pays the defendants expenses (all of them). Eliminate the 36% fee and limit it just like other agents, to 10% or a flat rate.

Attorneys are the ONLY profession or industry in the USA that is NOT regulated. Why? We are stupid enough to elect them to office and they make the laws and they make sure those laws are so worded as to make sure you have to hire an attorney to figure them out.

You give consequences for frivolity to the legal profession and you'll see many social, business, and criminal problems solved quite on their own.

There are so many things wrong with this post that I could go on for days correcting some of the misconceptions. But in an effort to avoid completely derailing the thread I will only make a couple of brief points.

1. 95% of attorneys don't practice personal injury law. I am a tax attorney and have never once been inside a courtroom. I do tax planning for both individuals and businesses. The ambulance chasers are a VERY small portion of the legal community and they are generally shunned by the rest of us (at least when they aren't around ;) ).

2. Even the ambulance chasers do not sue anyone. They simply represent people who sue (or who are being sued). If people weren't so quick to try to cash in when something goes wrong, then those attorneys wouldn't being practicing personal injury. They would find a more noble field... like tax law! :D

I don't dispute that there are some really sleazy attorneys out there, but I think you would be surprised how low the percentage really is. Just because you don't see the rest of us in tv commercials doesn't mean we aren't out there.
 
yes yes yes.. Stick it to Monster... ram their bull**** right up their backsides and make them puke the paper.

This guy has my business now, flat out, even if I can get it cheaper from another vendor

i'll say this, place was getting slowed downed today.. wonder how big of a hits spike he had after that broke amd sites like [H]ard started reporting it..

[H] should give him a weeks free Ad space just for that letter alone! ;)



(yes, he really does need that site redesigned or least updated)
 
I've been buying A/V cables exclusively from Blue Jeans Cable for five years now ever since a thread at Audioholics got my attention. They are very nice cables for the price you pay compared to cables sold at a brick-and-mortar.

I wish Kurt all the best in getting Monster to back down. They will admit defeat, eventually.

That thread got me to buy his cables also. Have been shopping there since for all my cable needs. Quality stuff and good price.
 
I wish more people would fight instead of plea out or take crappy licensing deals when they get letters like this.

Frankly the whole fact that patent law has turned away from protecting a new inventor but still getting the modus operendi out to further competition and innovating to this crappy lawyering up just to make a few more dollars is a disgrace entirely. Helping you make licensing money by suing people for making stuff similar to yours but maybe better or worse is the exact opposite of the intent of patent law.
 
I bought into the Monster Cable hype back in the day, but after 20 years, my Monster Cables that connect my stereo together still work fine.

They are good cables for sure, but not worth paying that price for...other cables are just as good without Monster stamped on the side.


Wait.......

So, not only are they totally overpriced, but they pocket additional money by not paying any federal tax.....

Glad the only "Monster" I deal with comes in a CAN. :p

So basically WTF...theyre not paying federal tax and their cables still cost that much...someone is sitting in a big house somewhere drinking blue label and watching his 120" plasma tv.
 
This guy has principles, and is willing to stand up for them. Rare these days.

That was seriously one of the coolest things I have ever seen on the internet.

No doubt. I seriously detest lawyers, but this guy is the smartest/coolest one I have EVER seen. Why can't all lawyers be as thorough and have as much conviction as him?
 
Ok, That was some cool "lawyer-speak" ass chewing. I too, think I am going to send some business this guys way. His cable prices seem very reasonable. I needed and HDMI cable. Thanks [H]. :)
 
I loathe Monster and my next cable purchase will be from this man. Excellent job sir.
 
I would love to see the expression on the 1st person at Monster to read that..


and I want to see if he gets a response.
 
Might have to buy some of these local, he's only ~30 minutes from me...

Says they don't have a retail shop, but could still arrange a pickup...

Now I actually need a home-theatre kinda setup... :eek:
 
I think there is an opportunity for someone here to make some money by offering Blue Jean Cables some inexpensive web design work.
 
all hdmi cables are made in china

Not "all" but "most" and those that are made in China are not made by the same factory. There's about a dozen cable factories in China making HDMI... about half of which aren't even HDMI "certified" (approved by HDMI consortium to carry logo).

So what's your point? ;)
 
This is just the funniest thing I have heard in a long time.
Blue Jeans Cables reply go on and on and on forever.
 
OMG that is awesome. His reply is a true work of art.

My favorite bit.

I assume that Monster Cable International, Ltd., in Bermuda, listed on these patents, is an IP holding company and that Monster Cable's principal US entity pays licensing fees to the Bermuda corporation in order to shift income out of the United States and thereby avoid paying United States federal income tax on those portions of its income; my request for these licensing agreements is specifically intended to include any licensing agreements, including those with closely related or sham entities, within or without the Monster Cable "family," and without regard to whether those licensing agreements are sham transactions for tax shelter purposes only or whether they are bona fide arm's-length transactions.

I am no lawyer but to me that reads, if you want to sue me based on your allegation you must then provide to me information that the IRS would just love to see. (Gotcha!!)
 
What are the odds of Monster buying out Blue Jeans Cable and appointing Kurt as their official lawyer. Hmmmmm.
 
Favorite part of his entire reply. Basically told them they were a bunch of conniving scoundrels; which they are IMO.

Further, on that point: one of the design patents you attached is closely related to a utility patent applicable to the same design, and you failed to point that fact out. I need to be able to rely upon the completeness and accuracy of the information you send to me and I find this sort of omission deeply disturbing because it is clear that the effect of this nondisclosure is to obscure the real significance of the patent features. Similarly, as I note further below, you omit reference to another patent Monster has held which appears, frankly, to be fatal to your position. If you expect to persuade me, you had better start making full, open and honest disclosures; I will find out the facts sooner or later in any event, but the impact upon your credibility will not be repaired. It looks like when you sent this letter, you were operating on the premise that I am not smart enough to see through your deceptions or sophisticated enough to intelligently evaluate your claims; shame on you. You are required, as a matter of legal ethics, to display good faith and professional candor in your dealings with adverse parties, and you have fallen miserably short of your ethical responsibilities.
 
LOL, I've been boycotting Monster cables since I first saw their prices. I think I've only bought on Monster and that was because I needed an optical cable and it was in a clearance for a buck. Other then that monoprice.com FTW!
 
There are so many things wrong with this post that I could go on for days correcting some of the misconceptions. But in an effort to avoid completely derailing the thread I will only make a couple of brief points.

1. 95% of attorneys don't practice personal injury law. I am a tax attorney and have never once been inside a courtroom. I do tax planning for both individuals and businesses. The ambulance chasers are a VERY small portion of the legal community and they are generally shunned by the rest of us (at least when they aren't around ;) ).

2. Even the ambulance chasers do not sue anyone. They simply represent people who sue (or who are being sued). If people weren't so quick to try to cash in when something goes wrong, then those attorneys wouldn't being practicing personal injury. They would find a more noble field... like tax law! :D

I don't dispute that there are some really sleazy attorneys out there, but I think you would be surprised how low the percentage really is. Just because you don't see the rest of us in tv commercials doesn't mean we aren't out there.
Hey don't forget about us securities lawyers! Funny, before working in securities, I did tax planning too, but for wealthy Fortune 500 execs.
 
Wow, I am afraid to see what this guy's customer contracts look like....

"So do I get HBO with that?"

(7 pages of response later) "Yes, but it'll cost you."

Still. I read the whole damn thing, and I gotta say... I love it. Normally legal jargon is painful to read, but this guy just does it SOOOO well. Truely a work of art. The longest "go screw yourself" I have ever read, and one of the best.

Kudos to you sir. Please, kick the crap out of Monster. I have many of their products, but from what I have come to understand, they are a bunch of douchebags.
 
Ahh. Well now that I have been to his site I see that he sells all cables exclusively. I thought this was a local cable provider company that sold cables to it's customers. Like a dinky Comcast or something.
 
Back
Top