Monster Cable Threatens The Wrong Guy

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
You guys know us, we are not big fans of lawsuits (frivolous or otherwise) but this story is too good to pass up. In a nutshell, Monster Cable threatens small cable maker with a cease and desist letter. The owner of the small company happens to be a lawyer…hilarity ensues. This is easily one of the best responses to a cease and desist letter I have ever read. Here is just a small snippet of the letter:

Further, if any of these patents or trademarks has been licensed to any entity, please provide me with copies of the licensing agreements. I assume that Monster Cable International, Ltd., in Bermuda, listed on these patents, is an IP holding company and that Monster Cable's principal US entity pays licensing fees to the Bermuda corporation in order to shift income out of the United States and thereby avoid paying United States federal income tax on those portions of its income; my request for these licensing agreements is specifically intended to include any licensing agreements, including those with closely related or sham entities, within or without the Monster Cable "family," and without regard to whether those licensing agreements are sham transactions for tax shelter purposes only or whether they are bona fide arm's-length transactions.

Thanks to [H] reader Chris Flikas for the linkage on this one.
 
I found this so amusing that I intend to replace a few of my Ratshack audio cables with some Blue Jeans stuff. You just made a sale, Kurt!
 
"If you sue me, the case will go to judgment, and I will hold the court's attention upon the merits of your claims--or, to speak more precisely, the absence of merit from your claims--from start to finish. Not only am I unintimidated by litigation; I sometimes rather miss it."

LOL

Even if this guy loses (which seems pretty unlikely after reading this) he still kicks major ass.
 
fav post:)

what a sham. makes me wonder how many other companies do this... and if it would be a good investigation for other major assholes.
 
You think they would have done a simple back ground check to find out the guy they are trying to legally strong arm was a litigator for almost 20 years.
 
Lengthy, long winded lawyer bullshit.:eek:
This is why lawyers charge by the hour.
Short version: I'm not paying, and you can't make me.
 
Stick it to the man!

"I am 'uncompromising' in the most literal sense of the word. If Monster Cable proceeds with litigation against me I will pursue the same merits-driven approach; I do not compromise with bullies and I would rather spend fifty thousand dollars on defense than give you a dollar of unmerited settlement funds."
 
That was SO cool lol I loved it hehe.

"Not only am I unintimidated by litigation; I sometimes rather miss it."

OMG THAT ROCKS!!!! ROFLMAO
 
Oh wow. I hope there's a place I can follow this story from here to the end :). I hate M.C. entirely.
 
We all should buy something from Blue Jeans Cable.

Indeed, the less my customers think my products resemble Monster's, in form or in function, the better.
 
I read through the whole thing and made some cliffs for you guys:

1) He is requesting clear diagrams, pictures, or samples, that show exactly where he has infringed upon them. Ostensibly, they did not include these because they assumed the guy was a yokel who would panic and beg forgiveness.

2) He notes that certain attributes of cables are required due to the very design of the connector itself, and are thus unlikely to be considered part of a valid patent.

3) He asserts that if a court views the patents narrowly, they will find against Monster Cable, and if they view the patents broadly, that the "least dissimilar" patent is actually expired, thus this guys cables fall under the "prior art".

4) The fact that they are shady fuckers who are scheming to avoid taxes.

I am not a lawyer, but those seemed to be the important bits.
 
I just pulled the trigger. Got myself a couple short-length Canare Star Quad XLR cables for my portable recording rig. I'm just curious at this point as to whether the construction's at all better than the stuff Canare sells directly -- guess we'll see.
 
That is 7 different levels of awesome. As long as they're competitively priced, he'll get my business from now on.
 
Wow... That's great. And really the bottom line is that it's so hard for Monster to defend and design and dress copyrights that they have because they buy their product from a vendor in China who is also selling their product to other vendors and do not take "trademark" into consideration. In my opinion, if Monster REALLY DOES feel like they have a case, they need to address it with their SUPPLIER. Because it's one thing to unknowingly copy something.

If it's a legit case, leave it at a cease and desist BUT at least be able to prove your case... something Monster was obviously UNABLE to do against Blue Jean. But if they REALLY want it to STOP they need to do something about their own supplier. If they escalate the matter beyond a cease and desist, then they really are persuing a frivilous case.

For example: http://www.setexasrecord.com/news/2...ringement-cases-filed-in-u.s.-district-courts

Ultra bought these cables from the same company that makes them for Monster. The cable head had to be changed because Monster has a funky little "M" embossed in the metal shield and then a hole cut in the insulation exposing the logo. Pretty obvious trademark there, right? But when it came to packaging, there was really a "who cares" attitude about it. "Hmm.... CAD design new packaging? Mold costs for plastic shells? Screw that... Hey factory! What do you have already available? This plastic clam shell? Sounds good." Oops! That happens to be the same plastic clam shell that supplier uses to package and ship Monster's cable in. No obvious branding, but Monster CLAIMS the package holds a number of intellectual property rights and takes Ultra to court for using it.

Wait... what?

Unfortunately, I don't know if anything came out of that case as it wasn't kept in the public forum, but I hope this one does because I would LOVE to see how it turns out. :D
 
Thanks for the links Jon.

You know I disliked this company for taking advantage of the inherently subjective nature of audio and video, and pretending like their cables were better than anyone elses. But now I dislike them even more. I understand a company's sole purpose is to make money and grow, but a company that needs to resort to this kind of stuff just shouldn't be in business.
 
Ive been using Blue Jeans Cables for about 7 months now. Quality for a great price that Monster cant even compete with at their HORRENDOUSLY high price point. I can see why Monster is up in arms :)
 
Monster Cable business model is solely built on taking advantage of the ignorance of buyers. with this, I learned they are more deeper in unethical behavior so I applaud the move of the awesome lawyer ;)

 
Fantastic. I don't really have anything against Monster Cables... their stuff is overpriced, but that's not a crime in and of itself. I DO have something against companies that try to use Cease and Desist letters to scare little guys into bowing to their will.

I'm better Monster Cable just lets the matter drop. As the guy said, it's an RCA cable, for god's sake. There's just not that much design that isn't a direct result of function.
 
I just bought a couple of HDMI cables from the guy, and included the following note:

I recently heard about your laughable run-in with Monster Cable. Here's some funds for your defense. I salute you, sir. There's quite a few fellas over at [H]ardforum.com that would like to show their support as well--including myself of course. Be well.

His prices are pretty damn good, too!
 
LMAO, I actually took the time to read almost all of it. Near the end I skimmed.

I guess Monster is going to need some time to think about how to proceed with this!! :)
 
Monster's prices aren't just Monster's fault. What was that article awhile back about the markup? Something like 80%?
 
Score one for the little guy. I hope Monster Cables gets owned after this.


Oh, and I'll stick with Blue Jeans Cable if I need anything. I bookmarked their site under places to buy stuff from. :)
 
Good for Blue Jeans Cable. I'll be sure to deliberately throw them some more business.
 
They should have went for a declaratory judgment like Kyle and forced Monster's hand. That could have really screwed them for the next time they try this.
 
Now that's what you call PWN3D! :D

After looking up their site... $25 for a high quality HDMI cable AND the owner kicks ass? They'll have my business when it's time to redo the home theater for sure!

 
Ok, who brought the Popcorn. This is gonna be fun to watch :)
 
Back
Top