High End Storage Comparison

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Ryan and the crew at PC Perspective have posted a high end storage comparison today that pits a pair of SSDs against Quad Velociraptors. Who wins? Hit the link to find out!

I have to say that I was impressed with BOTH of our storage options as we tested them and it is tough to give up 1.3TB of storage in order to get slightly faster scrubbing in a specific application; and it even comes at a higher cost! But, with the ability to get a pair of 2TB hard drives at under $300 today for mass storage needs it seemed like the best fit for us. For many high end users though, the quad-Velociraptors will offer the appealing combination of speed and capacity that is impossible to resist, and we can't blame you one bit.
 
Interesting read. For now, $ for $ I’m going to have to stick with the old standard.
 
Quad Velociraptors?! Holy shit!

That outburst aside, I'm tagging this for later reading.
 
A bit of an apples to kumquats comparison here, but it wasn't meant to be a true study: Quad Velociraptors in RAID 5 vs. dual SSDs in RAID 0 (and it's unclear to me whether they all used the same RAID controller).
 
It kind of faked me out, I was expecting some sort of awesome SAN unit.

I guess consumer devices could be high end though.
 
Why would they use 2 SSDs? They could have gotten 7 80GB X25-Ms on sale for the same price, which would destroy the Raptors and has more storage then the WDs.

Hell, if they gave a damn about doing a proper comparison, they would have used 4 x 128GB WD Silicon Edge drives.
 
Given the choice, I'd still go with SSD, for their lack of any noise
 
A bit of an apples to kumquats comparison here, but it wasn't meant to be a true study: Quad Velociraptors in RAID 5 vs. dual SSDs in RAID 0 (and it's unclear to me whether they all used the same RAID controller).

They did mention they used an Areca 1230.
 
Ryan and the crew at PC Perspective have posted a high end storage comparison today that pits a pair of SSDs against Quad Velociraptors. Who wins? Hit the link to find out!

So why is this considered high end storage anyway?

I don't know...maybe I have been polluted by enterprise grade servers and SAN storage for too long now. For one: Veloceraptor drives are slow. Let them reach 15K RPM and use SAS like all the newer servers use. Oh, but now the SAS SSD's are coming into the mix.

I'd put up most run of the mill SAS raid arrays against these consumer grade devices anyday.
 
They did mention they used an Areca 1230.
They did, but it wasn't clear for me whether all 6 drives were on it. They mention the card as decreasing the price advantage of the quad-raptor and levelling the performance difference (but I see now they're thinking in terms of percentages).
 
"We have a set of four 600GB Velociraptors running in another RAID-5 array for a total storage of 1.8TB to represent our best case spindle-based solution and in front of them we have a pair of 256GB Western Digital SiliconEdge Blue SSDs in a RAID-0 array for the flash-based alternative. My goal was to see which of these two new arrays would be the best fit for our video rendering and editing configuration."

Someone want to tell me how you get a 4-drive RAID5??

Should be 4 drive RAID 1+0 vs the striped Raptors
 
You attach 4 drives to a raid controller and set it to "RAID 5" mode.
:D Nailed it!

MassiveOverkill: RAID 5 means the storage equivalent of only one drive is lost to parity, no matter what the size of the array. RAID 1+0, you would lose two, right?
 
I'll take the dual SSDs anyday. The reason is, the SSDs outperform the traditional disks in random access. Sure for sequential access, you can get a few drives and raid them for much less.... but in real world usage my SSD blows away my three drives in raid 0.
 
Haven't read the article yet, but did they touch on heat and noise at all?
 
Forget dual SSD and quad Velociraptors. I want to do this someday.
Did that guy seriously run a defrag on SSDs? Anyway, with 24 points of failure (and the cost of SSDs) I think this is a case for RAID 6.

I'll take the dual SSDs anyday. The reason is, the SSDs outperform the traditional disks in random access. Sure for sequential access, you can get a few drives and raid them for much less.... but in real world usage my SSD blows away my three drives in raid 0.
That's the option they went with. It's a video editing machine, not for high volume storage.
 
How do they consider 4 disk raid 5 a best case scenario anyway? They have no clue.
 
You're gonna run 4 drives in a stripe?

Seems like the Burlington Northern clue line doesn't stop at your station.

As mentioned before, it could have been done in RAID-10 which is MUCH faster than RAID-5, even on a dedicated controller. See the results I linked on the previous page of this thread.
 
Oh, and a correction... that RAID-10 image actually was from when I was on W7 beta, not from before on XP. So they're both W7.
 
Did that guy seriously run a defrag on SSDs? Anyway, with 24 points of failure (and the cost of SSDs) I think this is a case for RAID 6.

I ignored the defrag part. It's just the thought of doing something like this is fun.
 
Back
Top