Courts: Email Privacy Protected by Fourth Amendment

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that email users have the same reasonable expectation of privacy in their stored email as they do in their postal mail and phone calls. According to the ruling, the government must have a search warrant before it can search emails stored by e-mail service providers.

Given the fundamental similarities between email and traditional forms of communication [like postal mail and telephone calls], it would defy common sense to afford emails lesser Fourth Amendment protection.... It follows that email requires strong protection under the Fourth Amendment; otherwise the Fourth Amendment would prove an ineffective guardian of private communication, an essential purpose it has long been recognized to serve.... [T]he police may not storm the post office and intercept a letter, and they are likewise forbidden from using the phone system to make a clandestine recording of a telephone call--unless they get a warrant, that is. It only stands to reason that, if government agents compel an ISP to surrender the contents of a subscriber's emails, those agents have thereby conducted a Fourth Amendment search, which necessitates compliance with the warrant requirement....
 
This won't stop anything but local police from getting access, but its nice to know this ruling is there
 
This is a good first step, but it needs to be extended to user data stored in a cloud. Real mobility requires being able to access your data from different devices, in different locations, and while in transit. That means some form of networked storage, and consumers aren't going to be able to each set up their own individually. There needs to be the same protections on your data regardless of where you store it. You should have a reasonable expectation that your private data if free from government intrusion regardless of if you store it on your computer or if you rent server space.
 
flatrock: problems will arise in the legal ramification of trying to classify data.

Data can be that of trade secrets, personal correspondence, useful information... yet legally speaking it can also be argued as a service derivative; data is an abstraction that in itself has no guarantee due to it not being a defined asset.

This is where I am concerned about cloud. Unlike our personal email, which can be deem as binding as written correspondence, any data sent back and forth cloud could be argued as derivatives to that of the services offered by the vendor, and as such would be treated on the terms of the services of the vendor.
 
I really like the courts. Its almost like checks and balances are still working. Now if the President and Legislators would stop "working together" we might actually have a government to be proud of again.
 
I bet MS and Google will get around this by saying something like hotmail and gmail isn't "technically" your email and it belongs to MS and Google, as part of the agreement you click on, I doubt this even applies.

This probably only affects ISP supplied email.
 
I bet MS and Google will get around this by saying something like hotmail and gmail isn't "technically" your email and it belongs to MS and Google, as part of the agreement you click on, I doubt this even applies.

This probably only affects ISP supplied email.

I am a bit worried about how to sort this out to be honest. This is basically the definition of data serving as derivatives and works done to provide the services. You cannot argue that the data you're handing over as trade secrets when the service providers do not utilize these data and that data by themselves aren't marketable.
 
I am a bit worried about how to sort this out to be honest. This is basically the definition of data serving as derivatives and works done to provide the services. You cannot argue that the data you're handing over as trade secrets when the service providers do not utilize these data and that data by themselves aren't marketable.

I just don't know. The whole idea of "selling" your data in exchange for online services could tank all free cloud computing if this law applied to that. Google and Facebook would be especially screwed and suddenly gmail and Facebook would have to start charging money to keep going.
 
I just don't know. The whole idea of "selling" your data in exchange for online services could tank all free cloud computing if this law applied to that. Google and Facebook would be especially screwed and suddenly gmail and Facebook would have to start charging money to keep going.

Oh noes! I'm sure the whold world would go right down the shitter without facebook. :rolleyes:
 
What is obvious is that service providers will have significant strength in stating that the data that are provided to maintain these services do not by themselves serve economic purposes for the providers. By saying that the data must be first processed (mined) into usable information and then developed into an actual tactics or practices, the providers would absolve responsibility for the potential question of breaching trade secrets.

The violation of privacy charge would perhaps be addressed by provisions within an enforceable EULA in which the utilization of stored data is at the discretion of the service provider. Rather sobering to be frank.
 
Oh noes! I'm sure the whold world would go right down the shitter without facebook. :rolleyes:

Considering facebook started as a great way to track down old friends and has degraded into millions of people making a vain attempt at drawing attention to themselves I'd say the world has already gone down the shitter :p
 
Screw all of this. I'm just going to set up my own email server here at home.
 
I am a bit worried about how to sort this out to be honest. This is basically the definition of data serving as derivatives and works done to provide the services. You cannot argue that the data you're handing over as trade secrets when the service providers do not utilize these data and that data by themselves aren't marketable.
I don't think you should be putting trade secrets on a public domain email, but that's probably just me.
 
In unrelated news, Monopoly Energy Co announced that immediately following the verdict, electricity usage for NSA headquarters dropped 90%.
 
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -BENJAMIN FRANKLIN
 
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -BENJAMIN FRANKLIN

"If the freedom of speech is taken away then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter." - George Washington
 
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." -BENJAMIN FRANKLIN

"If the freedom of speech is taken away then dumb and silent we may be led, like sheep to the slaughter." - George Washington

I like pudding.
- Me

I know, it doesn't have the same impact as Ben and George, but I like pudding, dammit!!!
 
Wait... a judge made a GOOD decision regarding electronics and privacy? Maybe that explains the brimstone-scented snowballs I've been finding of late...
 
I don't think you should be putting trade secrets on a public domain email, but that's probably just me.

Unfortunately, under cloud, even if you were to say that you are using your own domain, the servers are still those of the service provider's. That and the fact that email is now recognized to have the same kind of legal weight as letter and facsimiles would make "legally unprotected trade secrets" transmitted by email via cloud a perfect storm.
 
So (hypthetically) today, someone left their email open when they were out the room, and know christmas was coming I took a peek. There was one read email from amazon. Where does this leave me legally? I'm hoping its some blu rays.
 
What about e-mails stored on local machines (as with pop accounts?)

there would still be records of those emails likely on servers from providers, also what if the person who sent that email to you sent it via gmail or hotmail... they could then just look at that persons account to get any info they want.
 
Unfortunately, under cloud, even if you were to say that you are using your own domain, the servers are still those of the service provider's. That and the fact that email is now recognized to have the same kind of legal weight as letter and facsimiles would make "legally unprotected trade secrets" transmitted by email via cloud a perfect storm.
I don't know about you, but my work owns our own servers...
 
Back
Top