CDs Are Officially Over

My concerns are:

What is the next standard? USB ports on your car radio? Or are people just going to burn their own CDs? I just hope that whatever is settled upon is vendor neutral, and not just compatible with apple devices :rolleyes:

Also the vast majority of downloadable music is in compressed format that is actually inferior to that found on the CD. Are we simply going to lose the ability to obtain music in something other than craptacular compressed AAC, MP3, or WMA?

If anything, not being bound to a particular format should enable increased sound quality. Why can't I download music in an SACD quality format?

It is simple.
The vast majority of online music consumers have NO CLUE what quality is.
The past few year most "pop" music has been produced in the studio for online consumption. This means, all musical nuance filtered out. Recorded volume level pushed to a hair before clipping so there is NO dynamic range. You squeeze it to a 128K MP3 and this is your equivalent.
GARBAGE IN, GARBAGE OUT...........But sheeple are so brain dead now they wouldn't know the difference anyway. I DOUBT if many would notice the difference between stereo and mono now a days.
 
That's because most music today is made to be listened to on an iPod with its crappy earbuds, not a high end stero system.

Even worse, mid-quality stereo equipment has essentially disappeared from low-margin local stores.
 
CDs will be made for years to come, at least CDs of music aimed at children and older people. It's the pop music CD that's fading fastest.
 
Not to mention, if you have to pick between a 9.99 download, vs a 9.99 physical copy, I'd wager that most people are getting the CD. You can rip your disc to any format you want w/o drm, you still get the full album artwork (which sometimes is just as important as the actual music) and you can always sell/trade it later.

There's always going to be some sort of physical format for music, even if the majors drop them the independent musicians will always have CD's or Vinyl (some even cassettes) to sell when they're out and about.
 
Even worse, mid-quality stereo equipment has essentially disappeared from low-margin local stores.

Magnolia at Best Buy actually carries some solid stuff.

The low-end receivers have been getting a lot better in the last few years too. Unfortunately, they're pushing features like compressed audio "fixing" and iPod docks instead of high quality, easy-to-use streaming or even improving the quality of the power supplies on the lower end (which are reserved for the expensive models).
 
The way music is being mixed lately I'm not surprised. Try listening to some of the latest garbage on a higher end stereo system. I listened to the wife's Lady Gaga CD through my Dahlquists and it sounded like somebody poked holes in my all speakers.
If you you want to help end CD's just go spend $15 on a recent album, you'll never want to buy music again.

Way too much post processing. Gone are the days of the garage band making an album that sounds great, and you can hear every note how it was played. Every little nuance. Quiet when it's quiet, loud when it's loud, and everything in between. Now, it's major studios making it all one volume to be played loudly through any speaker, ear bud, or car stereo. It sounds like shit.

I still buy CDs, but not from any of the popular artists (unless it's an older band releasing a new album...). They all sound like shit, uncompressed or otherwise.

People wonder why I like grunge music. Yea, some of it sounds like ass, but it's all real. When grunge became popular, it was pushing out the oversampled, mainstream rock. We need another movement like that (don't care about genre, just the way it sounds) - get rid of the huge studios taking a good song and turning it into a computerized, synthesized, artificial, digital drum set pile of crap that actually sounds better at 64kb than lossless.

Even my favorite bands have gone that way. They went from playing the music to creating the music. Foo Fighters, not a huge fan of them - but their live jam session from their new album was absolutely fantastic.

Teenagers and those that grew up on the iPod haven't heard music that hasn't been compressed or processed to sound like shit.

BTW: I hope to God they don't come with a new standard that is only iPod compatible. Not everyone owns an iPod, there are tons of alternatives that are just as great. Most car stereos come with an Aux input for 3.5mm jacks and a USB that can run the iPod.
 
I've been predicting the extinction of CDs for awhile now. A huge number of cars and aftermarket stereos have USB ports now. I haven't used a CD in years.



who still buy CD's for lossless audio.

I do, because it's the only legal way I know of the get a lossless version of the album.

LoL at people calling CDs lossless. They are NOT. They lose less than an MP3 but any digital version is not going to have true lossless over a live performance.
All these "lossless" digital formats? They just haven't lost anything from the original digital conversion which in itself DID lose from the original music.
That's one reason vinyl is still popular among audiophiles. High quality analog vinyl recordings have less loss than CDs.
 
lies! digital albums cost much more than used CDs from go hastings! (when shipping is 99 cents each..) I bought 36 cds for $121! good fucking deal! :)
 
I wouldn't mind digital downloads so much if the industry standard were a high-fidelity recording like a CD.
I know you can get "CD-Quality" lossless downloads... but doesn't that sort of seem roundabout here?

What's a "CD-Quality" recording going to mean when there are no CD's? Are they still going to follow the red book? I don't see why they would.

On the other hand... this is a good opportunity for higher quality audio to become more mainstream... though most electronics have been on a race to the bottom recently so my hopes are not high....
 
I hope this isnt true, since some music are actually worth buying CDs

CD's do sound better than you're avg mp3... I knew on paper this was true but I was finally convinced for reals when blasting music on my friend's amazing system.. listening to my ipod tunes and his CDs back to back... the difference is a lot more noticeable when you're cranking it up in a system like that... but in my car, I can't tell the difference really.. none the less I too I will miss the option to buy stuff on CD... :(
 
Fuck now we all have to take a step backward and listen to crap sounding compressed MP3.


All those deaf bastards buying crap sounding mp3s and download music can suck it.
 
I think last years total was 150 or so for my personal listening pleasure. The CD sure is dead..

No matter if it dies off soon or not, there is a ton of great music on CDs to purchase on the second hand market. Same with Vinyl, it´s very alive for people who care about music and hence proper representation of the music they are enjoying.

FLAC and other lossless format downloads better start happening with more labels and retailers. mp3 is ridiculous.
 
Not to mention, if you have to pick between a 9.99 download, vs a 9.99 physical copy, I'd wager that most people are getting the CD. You can rip your disc to any format you want w/o drm, you still get the full album artwork (which sometimes is just as important as the actual music) and you can always sell/trade it later.

There's always going to be some sort of physical format for music, even if the majors drop them the independent musicians will always have CD's or Vinyl (some even cassettes) to sell when they're out and about.

I'd much rather have a physical copy so if something happens to my digital collection, there's back up. I personally want a physical copy of my music and games.
 
to be fair, Gaga uses auto-tone as an effect, not a crutch. She is a very skilled vocalist.

Yes, she is. But, autotune doesn't help -- it screws it up. It makes it sound a lot worse. It's an effect that is better off un-used.
 
The other big problem is mp3s are entirely faceless outside of minimal photographs on store pages. With a physical album you have an opputunity to step outside of the music and include artwork and a whole "look and feel" to go with the music, creating a kind of enviroment for it. With just mp3 download you are going to have less or no need for any kind of physical art with music, making it feel kind of one dimentional and kind of more throwaway.

If things do turn to downloads only, I hope that sites like itunes DIAF. They take huge cuts from artists for doing little to nothing (I am hosting a 5mb file! Thats 40% you owe me! :eek:)
 
Someone mentioned Radiohead and FLAC downloads. Nine Inch Nails also did a FLAC download release.

And the funny side of Radiohead? Not only FLAC and MP3 available. But also CD and VINYL :D It is all about selling what the customer wants.

was going to say mention 'NIN' as well tho i'll add 'Massive Attack' to the list also. i've found any decent artist that cares about their work & their fans will have an online presence and have a variety of formats available (flac, ogg, mp3... etc). really i don't know why we use lossy formats any more, it's not like storage is an issue these days.

regarding car head units, almost all units today offer a variety of options to play your music. my car head unit has CD (slot hidden behind the display), SD card, USB and 3.5mm stereo jack and the player is a few years old now. also has blue tooth tho i find that a bit buggy to stream audio from my phone.

regarding CD's, was nice to have the cover art work and a master to rip a lossless copy but other than that, my CD's sit in boxes collecting dust.
 
Pretty much, it's more a matter of "why not both?" They can have lossless as a premium option at double the price of the MP3's and make everyone but the really whiny types happy. I just don't see myself paying the same price as an audio CD would be for a lower quality, insubstantial product (99cents x 12 songs is about the same price as the average cd) . I just worry that's what's going to end up happening, and while that might be just peachy for some folks and the industry, it doesn't match my buying habits, so I'll be stuck browsing the used CD isle at my local flea market.

I agree with your previous posts wholeheartedly, but that cost estimate is a bit off and it's one I've seen several times in the thread. When you buy a full album digitally you usually get a discount so that you're paying less than the total cost if every song in it added up, at least that's the impression I've gotten whenever I shop at Amazon.

I pretty much never buy a full album digitally tho, if I like a band/artist enough that I want the whole thing I generally get the CD so I can rip it to FLAC, etc.; even if it's $6-10 vs $12+. I know I'm in the minority there tho. These days I buy a lot of music online I otherwise would've never purchased, and less full albums overall, but I still buy CDs and my tastes are probably more diverse.
 
The other big problem is mp3s are entirely faceless outside of minimal photographs on store pages. With a physical album you have an opputunity to step outside of the music and include artwork and a whole "look and feel" to go with the music, creating a kind of enviroment for it. With just mp3 download you are going to have less or no need for any kind of physical art with music, making it feel kind of one dimentional and kind of more throwaway.

If things do turn to downloads only, I hope that sites like itunes DIAF. They take huge cuts from artists for doing little to nothing (I am hosting a 5mb file! Thats 40% you owe me! :eek:)

Amazon and iTunes both sell a digital booklet with albums if you buy the whole thing... I know right now it's not the same thing, but it has potential...

Also, record companies have been experimenting with DRM on CDs for a while. Frankly none of those two arguments (physical product with extras & DRM) really have any relevance in this discussion imo. I buy CDs because I like having a ripped FLAC "master" I can re-encode or edit (ringtones etc.), a better alternative will probably replace this eventually (FLACs for a premium or whatever)...

The biggest issues facing music have nothing to do with the distribution medium and everything to do with the labels and mixing process.
 
CD's will be around a lot longer then that, i want more depth to my music, not some 8bit crap
 
From my little corner seat here... this article is good only for chuckling at. Yes I have an MP3 player. I don't honestly think I know more than one or two people without one. I also have music on vinyl, audio cassette, and CD. I've listened to all three. Honestly... mostly CD and computer music.

My record player is a Yamaha that sits atop our Sony 3-part stereo (top to bottom: tuner, dual tape deck, and 5-CD changer). I can't say that I don't like the sound... but it's rather a bit staticky. (Probably if I wanted to I could spend half a grand on some fancypants turntable that could play everything short of a Domino's pizza... not gonna happen folks.)

Cassettes are great as long as you like every single song on the entire cassette -- unlike CDs, there's no "skip track" -- fast forward and rewind are it, and you make an educated *guess* as to when to go back to the Play button! (Also, the little "play" arrow is backwards for a reason -- that's the direction the tape goes!) BTW, there's a reason for this. Look up "sequential data access" and you'll figure it out eventually, lol.

As for CDs and MP3s... by far the biggest difference is made (in MY experience at least) by what is actually doing the sound reproduction. AC'97 vs Intel HDA... yeah, I can hear the difference, but it's not exactly a tearjerker to go one way or the other. Every CD player I've ever owned sounds basically the same. It's the speakers or headphones you're using that make the difference -- by a landslide.

By and large, this is true of pretty much every medium. How you get the song is a matter of price and convenience to the people involved (you as well as the various corporate entities that record and distribute it). Personally, I can't speak to earbuds, because I can't stand having them in my ears. But I can say a few words about speakers and headphones.

For a long time, Sony's MDR-V150 set has been my favorite... between $10 and $20, and the sound is AMAZING compared to the cheap crap ones I've always used before. Of course, the Philips ones that I picked up at Wal*Mart for $10 are about the same (don't know the model, but they come in pink, blue, and grey, thin wire for the headband... yeah, those) sound wise. A kind fella here on [H] recently traded me his USB headphones (model UDJ-1 is all you need to know) and they blow every other set of headphones in the house completely out of the water.

I have TBH only two real speaker sets (the ones that came with my mother's eMachines in '06 don't count!). Both are 2channel, beige, no subwoofer. I don't care, I'm no audiophile. One pair is labeled as Keysonic KS-70... the Internet seems to have forgotten about them so I can't give tech specs or even age. Found 'em in a closet is all I know. The others were given to me by a friend, they are Harman Kardon HK-195 and I'm too busy enjoying their sound to look up ANYTHING. They're at least on par with my USB headphones. That said... as my netbook is currently without an operational audio jack (courtesy of the cat) I am using a Plantronics USB audio dongle to connect the HK speakers, so that may skew the results somewhat.
 
If things do turn to downloads only, I hope that sites like itunes DIAF. They take huge cuts from artists for doing little to nothing (I am hosting a 5mb file! Thats 40% you owe me! :eek:)

iTunes is only taking a 30% cut. It's the music labels that ripoff the artists.
 
It's kind of weird with all the "HD" tv's people are so into below SD audio. It's not even a question of storage anymore with 16gb memory cards being so cheap.

While a lot of people have "HD" TVs most of the content people watch isn't real HD. The "HD" from most cable providers is highly compressed 720p, and Netflix is also highly compressed. I think a lot of the "mainstream" appeal of HDTVs is their size, rather than the resolution. Also, anything looks good compared to an old tube TV (which often can't even produce DVD quality).


Yes this is something that pisses me off. Me and lots of other people I know mix/compose/master albums in 24bit 96khz audio (pretty much industry standard, though many people use 16/44.1 CD quality) making it sound as good quality as possible. Then shitty stores turn it into crappy low fidelity mp3s and sell it to people who haven't got a chance to tell the difference. THen people listen to it on crappy little white headbuds that sound absolutely shitty. It's not being audiophiley bullshit, it's just how things really are, and it's kind of sad...

I think the earbuds/speakers are the bigger issue generally. A 320kbps mp3 on studio monitors sounds 10x better than a CD played on ipod earbuds. Once you have decent speakers/headphones then you may start to notice the deficiencies of compressed formats, but most people are using $10 earbuds.
 
It's the music labels that ripoff the artists

From recording artist Janis Ian..

They told me downloads were "destroying sales", "ruining the music industry", and "costing you money". Costing me money? I don't pretend to be an expert on intellectual property law, but I do know one thing. If a music industry executive claims I should agree with their agenda because it will make me more money, I put my hand on my wallet...and check it after they leave, just to make sure nothing's missing.. Who gets hurt by free downloads? Save a handful of super-successes like Celine Dion, none of us. We only get helped.. I have no objection to Greene et al trying to protect the record labels, who are the ones fomenting this hysteria. RIAA is funded by the labels. NARAS is supported by them. It stands to reason. However, I object violently to the pretense that they are in any way doing this for our benefit

Music industry chooses to bite hand that feeds it[
..musicians such as Roger McGuinn of the Byrds have testified in Congress that they've never been paid a penny in royalties, even though the Byrds sold millions of albums on Columbia Records. How has the industry been able to get away with this immoral behavior for so long? The industry controls the recording, manufacturing, marketing and distribution of virtually every album, and can add up the costs any way it pleases, knowing that most artists can't afford to sue or audit them.

The Rolling Stone who's stony broke
..what about his royalties from the Stones? ‘In 1982 they stopped paying me. They’d signed to a different record company and had new contracts and were advised they didn’t need to pay me any more,’ explained Taylor with a shrug. ‘Until then, I’d had a contract with Rolling Stones Records which was licensed to Atlantic Records – the same contract as the rest of the band.' The deal gave him an equal share of performing royalties, though Jagger and Richards shared the writers’ royalties. But when the Atlantic contract expired, the band’s management used a loophole in Taylor’s contract to stop all payments.

http://www.pophistorydig.com/?tag=rolling-stones-history

During the mid-1960s, when the Stones first broke out, they had sold some ten million singles, including their monster 1965-66 hit “Satisfaction.” They also sold some five million albums in the early years. Still, they were not making money.“When we first started out, there wasn’t really any money in rock ‘n roll. There wasn’t a touring industry; it didn’t even exist….” – Mick Jagger “When we first started out, there wasn’t really any money in rock ‘n roll,” Jagger explained to Fortune magazine in 2002. “There wasn’t a touring industry; it didn’t even exist. Obviously there was somebody maybe who made money, but it certainly wasn’t the act. …[E]ven if you were very successful, you got paid nothing.” The Stones also suffered from lack of negotiating experience. “I’ll never forget the deals I did in the ’60s, which were just terrible,” Jagger would later say. In 1965, Allen Klein, a New York manager, helped the Stone’s negotiate a new contract with Decca records and also helped the group win their first million-dollar payday. But Allen Klein also helped himself. His company, ABKCO, still retains the rights to the Stones’ early songs from the 1960s through 1971
 
So what is going to be the next removable medium of choice?

WAV's off CD's will be as close as we can get to the Source without raiding the studios.
FLAC is the next best thing to the Original WAV that resides on the consumer CD.
MP3's can come close to FLAC but most MP3's in the wild are a mere shadow of a reflection.

The idea that CD's will die is exactly what the RIAA should want.
The consumer demands an inferior product!
Lets give it to them! YES!
Then we re-market the same old shit in the future as a superior product!

I love my iPod as much as anyone else but my FLAC and MP3's come from my CD's.
Now if they sold WAV's as downloadable products I might be happier about this.

You ID10TS who prefer the inferior product that is the MP3 get what you deserve.
Crap Sound at Fantastic Prices.
Enjoy!
 
I'm sure there are many people out there who still plays music on a good audio system at home. You can't exactly expect people to be playing compressed mp3 on them.

Unless the have other plans to release music in a high quality format, killing of CD would be a retarded move.
 
The audio CD was ALWAYS a terrible format. It is not audiophile quality in the least. We can also blame this terrible format for the complete junk that music has turned into.

In the early days of the format every prominent audio engineer around complained that it was not a good format. Yes it allows for lots of digital information.... it still isn't enough room to capture music. The dynamic range on modern CD recordings is terrible. Even worse modern music producers have more and more pushed recordings into a narrow band of freq.

Honesty its about time we say no thank you to the CD.... let the market dictate a lossless audio format that will hopefully have enough freq and res to be a true digital representation, 24/96 min.

Also support the superior format Vinyl... in particular 180 and 200 gram audiophile releases. Let the music business know how much real music resolution means too us.
 
The audio CD was ALWAYS a terrible format. It is not audiophile quality in the least. We can also blame this terrible format for the complete junk that music has turned into.

In the early days of the format every prominent audio engineer around complained that it was not a good format. Yes it allows for lots of digital information.... it still isn't enough room to capture music. The dynamic range on modern CD recordings is terrible. Even worse modern music producers have more and more pushed recordings into a narrow band of freq.

Honesty its about time we say no thank you to the CD.... let the market dictate a lossless audio format that will hopefully have enough freq and res to be a true digital representation, 24/96 min.

Also support the superior format Vinyl... in particular 180 and 200 gram audiophile releases. Let the music business know how much real music resolution means too us.

the problem is the supposed reason for dumping cds has nothing to do with sound quality...

"we" havent even let the music industry know that we want properly recorded, mixed, and mastered audio...let alone a format for the masses.
 
I don't know. I can't tell the difference. I like CD's because I can rip them and store them in multiple locations, IE the mp3 player, the laptop, different computers around the house, etc. I always rip my CD's at 320, I am just not sure I want to go through the hassle of re-ripping them all to FLAC. Plus you can't get much simpler than Audiograbber along with the LAME mp3 pluggin. Actually that brings up an interesting question, what does everyone use to rip to FLAC? I want something simple and free. Thanks.
 
I don't know. I can't tell the difference. I like CD's because I can rip them and store them in multiple locations, IE the mp3 player, the laptop, different computers around the house, etc. I always rip my CD's at 320, I am just not sure I want to go through the hassle of re-ripping them all to FLAC. Plus you can't get much simpler than Audiograbber along with the LAME mp3 pluggin. Actually that brings up an interesting question, what does everyone use to rip to FLAC? I want something simple and free. Thanks.

ill tell you one thing. unless you have a very nice setup lame mp3 vs CDs is hard to distinguish. but even the 256kbps "high quality" digital download is garbage.

i dont know if its prior compression from how its stored or the fact that they never get good sources to begin with and the conversions take its toll but i havent heard a single legal download that sounded even OK in my book. if these downloads are the best we are going to get, its a sad day for music....
 
Back
Top