Bethesda: 'PC development is a headache'

Is this really any surprise? Every game they've released in the last 4 years has been horribly bug ridden, especially the two fallouts.
 
I wonder how many people 'raging' on RAGE have actually played the game?...it's seems more like a snowball rolling down a mountain effect...a few people complain about the textures and a mob mentality forms...the game had major issues at launch...but people seem to conveniently ignore the fact that most of those issues have been fixed (least for Nvidia owners) with a patch and new drivers

but it's more convenient to pile on based on misinformation rather then admit that you were wrong and the game is not as bad as what 'people' are saying
 
I would argue for the most part that their games are less complex and smaller in scope, so you won't run into as many issues.

Perhaps so, but I would also argue that they can certainly provide as much entertainment (or more) then some over hyped (and priced), buggy, eye searing peice of bloatware. Remember back in the day when you had to have a compelling storyline to make up for the crappy graphics, and even worse sound?
 
Someone call the fucking wahmbulance on these developers. Work is hard. Do it anyway. You're getting paid to do it. Yes, I complain about SELinux problems all the time because we use CentOS at work, but I make do.

Protip: There's three major graphics drivers you need to account for on the PC; Intel, AMD and nVidia. You can largely ignore Intel regarding gaming on mid-level to high-end machines, so now you have two. How many cards that will play this game do each vendor have? A couple dozen? Oh, someone stab me with the Blade of WOE! Work is hard! You sound like a bunch of women making complaints like that.
 
Face it guys, as long as piracy is a bad as it is, we're always going to be 2nd class for big titles like this. Have to put up with the console ports.

Carmack also pointed out before that there is a lot to be improved to make PC development less convoluted.
 
Perhaps so, but I would also argue that they can certainly provide as much entertainment (or more) then some over hyped (and priced), buggy, eye searing peice of bloatware. Remember back in the day when you had to have a compelling storyline to make up for the crappy graphics, and even worse sound?

Oh absolutely, don't disagree with you there. There is a secret place in my heart, locked away, that HL3 will come out with a new engine, look as good as BF3 (or better!) and have as great gameplay/story as the original. Of course the reason that it's locked away and secret is that it probably won't happen that way.... :(
 
Fuck off already with this.

Make a pc game or make a console game!

Do or do not do there is no CRY!
 
Bethesda spokesman Pete Hines has described PC development as a 'headache' thanks to the technical problems brought up by driver and hardware configurations.

'From a technical standpoint, the PC is a headache,' Hines admitted to Joystiq.

'It just is - a million different possibilities of hardware, drivers, etc...As you saw with Rage, all it takes is some bad video card drivers and years of hard work comes off as 'buggy', when in fact it's a really solid, stable game.'

http://www.bit-tech.net/news/gaming/2011/11/10/bethesda-pc-development-is-a-headache/1
Well, both AMD and Nvidia use consolidated driver distribution system, so if they want you to use a specific driver then just include it on the fucking disc. Two files would cover 99% of GPU's.
 
We whine about having to play shitty console ports, Developers whine about shitty PC development.

WHICH CAME FIRST?!
 
There aren't really a million different possibilities, more like a couple dozen variations that will cover 99% of consumer gamers out there.

How hard is it to buy a couple dozen consumer level PCs with different videocards and testing different drivers or even making sure the only two videocard manufacturers have a driver that is compatible with your game before you release it?

It's harder than making a game for the lowest common denominator (console), porting it to a pc with minimal QA, then blaming video drivers, gamers and the state of the industry for your shitty efforts.
 
It's harder than making a game for the lowest common denominator (console), porting it to a pc with minimal QA, then blaming video drivers, gamers and the state of the industry for your shitty efforts.

This...although you forgot to mention piracy :D.
 
Of course developers are going to like consoles because they are static, standardized, and come with a rather large user base which is for the most part stupid, and easily exploited.

All you have to do is look at Call of Duty as an example of that.

It's not hard to argue that consoles are easy to develop for, but then what about all those excellent PC games released in the past that were for the most part, bug and glitch free and didn't require 20 patches a month after release day?

It seems like release days are just days when the developers want to say "We're done coding this game, let's get it out the door, see what problems pop up, and then patch it as we go."

Yeah, that one is a real headache, rather than spending time, effort, and beta testers to make your product polished.

It feels like they are less and less selling games to us and more and more selling products.
 
It's not hard to argue that consoles are easy to develop for, but then what about all those excellent PC games released in the past that were for the most part, bug and glitch free and didn't require 20 patches a month after release day?

It seems like release days are just days when the developers want to say "We're done coding this game, let's get it out the door, see what problems pop up, and then patch it as we go."

Honestly, patching and glitches have always been part of PC gaming. What past history was this where there were game releases without bugs and glitches? :confused:
 
No release is completely bug free. I crashed like crazy in Fallout initially, but I don't remember much problems at all with Borderlands.

I didn't buy it right on release, but haven't had a crashing problem with Space Marine at all and haven't heard much issues for Deus Ex.

Seems pretty possible to have it stable on release.
 
I had problems just installing Fallout 3 untill I found a fix by using the University of Google to find the answer. Anybody remember that?
 
It shouldn't be difficult to program for the PC due to hardware and driver issues. That's an issue with AMD and Nvidia (and to a significantly much lesser extent, Intel, if games can run off their graphics chips) to deal with. That's why both Nvidia and AMD continuously release beta drivers, hotfixes, and driver updates each month. They're done as a hope to fix issues between the game and the video card hardware because of the driver software.

Why?

Well, as Pete Hines said it best, there are a million different possibilities and combinations of hardware and software installed in a computer. Drivers aren't perfect. They're just a software interface between the OS, applications and games, and the graphics hardware. And, those drivers are meant to do its best to work with those million different possibilities. The PC shouldn't be an excuse for being difficult to program for.

If a game is running poorly on a game, that's mostly the game developer's problems. They should only worry about being sure their game isn't buggy, has no glitches, and it runs well on the computer hardware.

That's why the game console is an attractive piece of hardware to program for. It is easy to program for, too. The game developer only has to worry about one very specific set of hardware; a very much smaller OS kernel without the bloat; a single, smaller graphics API; and have the ability to push the hardware to its limit. You can't do that on the PC because every computer is made differently.

However, as many others have said in this thread already, developing for the console is making developers lazy. They aren't trying hard enough to push the hardware to its limits, trying something new or creative. It's all about the money nowadays unfortunately.

It's cheaper to develop for the console. It's easier to develop for the console. And, if the developer wants to port it to the PC, they will only have to do minor changes to the game's underlying code. Little to no effort done to optimize it. Not much more money spent either.

There are so very few game developers trying to push the limits of PC hardware. They're pretty much not trying anymore. Simply put.

Look at GTA IV for example. When the game was released on the PC, well more like ported to PC, there were reports of poor graphics and game performance. The game was a straight port of the console version. They, Rockstar, didn't bother to optimize the game before it was released. Just changed some code and viola, port done.

But, let's face the fact: Which has the largest audience? Those with high-end PC hardware like many of those on [H] or those with consoles?

If you say consoles, then let me ask: Who will game developers develop a game for first? Console or PC?

Console. Larger market.

A console is much cheaper than a computer able to run a game at moderate to maximum settings. A $299 (or $399) 360 or PS3 is cheaper than a PC that can run BF3 at the best settings. A $299 or $399 PC will not run BF3 at the best settings (or probably not be able to run that well at all). The game will look just as good on console and that'll satisfy a lot of players on the console who aren't too serious about computer games. The console is more affordable and many consumers will buy that over a new gaming computer.

Take my four friends, for example, who wouldn't want to play BF3 with me on PC but rather on the 360. They don't want to bother spending more money to upgrade their current computers' hardware. They don't want to deal with the multitide of driver issues that may come up with running a game. Now, my four friends may not be representative of many console gamers, but I'm sure that's one example. They're also planning on getting Skyrim for the 360.

Again, it's all about money and not so much about difficulty. Difficulty is a pretty good excuse for not developing for the PC, or developing a very good game for the PC. It's also a sign of laziness and ignorance towards PC gamers for not developing a good PC game and not running it well on the PC. Sure you have to worry if the game will run on this processor and graphics card, but it isn't that much more difficult to develop for than the console. They're still using C, C++, or C#, or some variant of it like gcc.

I wonder what other excuse game developers will use now instead of using that wasted effort on making a good PC game.
 
I had problems just installing Fallout 3 untill I found a fix by using the University of Google to find the answer. Anybody remember that?

No, as a matter of fact Fallout 3 has never randomly crashed on me. Ever. I know that after about 4 hours or so of straight gaming it will be prone to crashing, so I save a lot and use different saves. The only thing that the TES and Fallout games absolutely hate is when you have 2 monitors on the first startup, it will crash every time unless you turn off monitor 2, start up and let it do the config. Restart and then monitor 2 will work fine with the game again.

And as you stated, it is pretty obvious how much easier it is to develop for consoles.
 
Absolutely. Bethesda would be nowhere without PC gamers.

Along with all the other companies out there who have placed PC gaming secondary to consoles once they saw how easily duped console gamers are compared to the fickle PC gaming market with our goddamn high standards.
 
These statements are loads of ****ing horse****, and I say that as a developer myself. Oh, and the so-called Rage "driver issues" were game problems with Rage, nothing to do with anything else.
 
These statements are loads of ****ing horse****, and I say that as a developer myself. Oh, and the so-called Rage "driver issues" were game problems with Rage, nothing to do with anything else.

So you make big games such as Oblivion/BF3 and the likes?
 
Bethesda spokesman Pete Hines has described PC development as a 'headache' thanks to the technical problems brought up by driver and hardware configurations.

'From a technical standpoint, the PC is a headache,' Hines admitted to Joystiq.

'It just is - a million different possibilities of hardware, drivers, etc...As you saw with Rage, all it takes is some bad video card drivers and years of hard work comes off as 'buggy', when in fact it's a really solid, stable game.'

http://www.bit-tech.net/news/gaming/2011/11/10/bethesda-pc-development-is-a-headache/1

This is true and if you disagree with it, you pretty much don't know what you are talking about.

The only way to develop for every system is to have test cases for everything in-engine and in-game the runs on like 100 systems with every hardware configuration \ drivers they can find with every commit (Impossible). You would also need someone playing the game on each of those systems.

But that doesn't excuse Rages poor game play.
 
These statements are loads of ****ing horse****, and I say that as a developer myself. Oh, and the so-called Rage "driver issues" were game problems with Rage, nothing to do with anything else.

Are you a game developer? If so, what games have you worked on?
 
This is true and if you disagree with it, you pretty much don't know what you are talking about.

The only way to develop for every system is to have test cases for everything in-engine and in-game the runs on like 100 systems with every hardware configuration \ drivers they can find with every commit (Impossible). You would also need someone playing the game on each of those systems.

But that doesn't excuse Rages poor game play.

I agree, Bethesda and id have never had problems with their engines. :confused:
 
Big talk from a shop who's games aren't even enjoyable until the modding community fixes them.
 
Big talk from a shop who's games aren't even enjoyable until the modding community fixes them.

That's why I'm waiting till next year to buy Skyrim.

This is the truth.

Yes and no, honestly, I agree with the sentiment to an extent, but it's an Elder Scrolls game we're talking about here, they are definitely must play experiences at some point in your gaming life.

These aren't like games from Epic, where CliffyB says dumb shit and refuses to own up when his games suck.

Or Id Software with Carmack going full retard on Rage.
 
So you make big games such as Oblivion/BF3 and the likes?

Not major titles like those, but you don't need to be a big shot to know what's what in the industry :). That's like saying to a mechanic "so you're the chief engineer on the Ferrari design team, right?" when he says "OK, this is what's wrong with your car and needs repair" :p.

Are you a game developer? If so, what games have you worked on?

Yes, and no I'm not able to disclose what for most of them on a personal forum account like this (nor do I particularly want to on the rest) :p.
 
Not major titles like those, but you don't need to be a big shot to know what's what in the industry :). That's like saying to a mechanic "so you're the chief engineer on the Ferrari design team, right?" when he says "OK, this is what's wrong with your car and needs repair" :p.



Yes, and no I'm not able to disclose what for most of them on a personal forum account like this (nor do I particularly want to on the rest) :p.

Well, without that information, then there's no reason to refer to yourself as a developer, how do we know you made fantastic games like Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines, Deus Ex: HR or shitty games like Black Ops? Maybe you make Facebook games? Flash games? Android and other mobile device games? iPad games?

Kind of ruins the point if you can't speak from the credible position as someone who actually developed a good game.
 
Well, without that information, then there's no reason to refer to yourself as a developer, how do we know you made fantastic games like Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines, Deus Ex: HR or shitty games like Black Ops?

Kind of ruins the point if you can't speak from the credible position as someone who actually developed a good game.

I can speak just fine, thank you ;). This sort of info is not rocket science, either... it's easily ascertainable by a common overclocker if you google a little regardless :). As I said... you don't have to be a chief design engineer on a multi-billion-dollar company's titles to know how to program and develop games, nor know what is fairly low-level knowledge.

EDIT in response to your edit: I have worked on Android/iPad/iPhone titles (personally developed) as well as a few smaller desktop games as a contractor. Additionally I have experience with Unity and UDK as far as desktop work.
 
I guess life is really rough when you can't just press the MicroSoft "port to PC" button in xbox dev software tools and put the output up for sale. The real problem here is purse-string holders who insist that every game ever be multiplatform to squeeze every last penny out of every release. Devs wouldn't mind the work if they weren't pressured by idiots with business degrees.
 
I can speak just fine, thank you ;). This sort of info is not rocket science, either... it's easily ascertainable by a common overclocker if you google a little regardless :). As I said... you don't have to be a chief design engineer on a multi-billion-dollar company's titles to know how to program and develop games, nor know what is fairly low-level knowledge.

EDIT in response to your edit: I have worked on Android/iPad/iPhone titles (personally developed) as well as a few smaller desktop games as a contractor. Additionally I have experience with Unity and UDK as far as desktop work.

More code = more possibility for stuff to screw up....You can't compare Android/iOS stuff to games that have tons more code in them and that are made for systems that have many different drivers/software versions...
 
More code = more possibility for stuff to screw up....You can't compare Android/iOS stuff to games that have tons more code in them and that are made for systems that have many different drivers/software versions...

Way to ignore the part I said about desktop work :p. Unity and unreal engine 3.0.... oh and by the way android is a cluster for compatibility.....Your comparison is flawed, as well. An mmo sure I could agree, different animal, but past a certain point on desktop anx mobile it is only scale, not tech, that difers a lot.
 
Last edited:
Way to ignore the part I said about desktop work :p. Unity and unreal engine 3.0.... oh and by the way android is a cluster for compatibility.....


Ok...which engine uses more code? Unreal 3 or a newer engine as used in Skryim? I am just saying that I think you need to have experience with a bigger game/engine to understand their issues.
 
I am using a 6870, and before that a 4870 before that 8600GT and 8500GT, I had more problems drivers wise, performance, and stability with the Gefore cards, and IGP then I have ever had with my Radeons. The drivers for the 4870 were not the greatest, I can attest to that, however they have been consistently getting better, not to mention, the performance to me is well worth the price I paid for them.

A little more work could be done for better coolers, or overclocking headroom from the factory, but overall, in my mind, Nvidia vs ATI, I actually prefer the way ATI/AMD cards make the games look, they seem more "natural" as far as shdows, lighting and such, the Nvidia ones seem to make shadows/lighting etc very "unnatural" without having PhysX or fancy things like Ambient Occulsion enabled.

To each thier own, Id Tech tried something new, it did not pan out the way they wanted it to, Bethesda as well always seems to be trying something new and/or groundbreaking, of course there will be issues, but, at least they are trying :) better then spitting out the same shit over and over isnt it?

As far as the engines, well I suppose that depends, an older engine suce as Unreal need alot of legacy code, and a crud load of added code to make it the way we want it to be, whereas something like used in "creation" engine or frostbite, am sure they are complex, but they are or should also be alot leaner in comparison, kind of like a summer cleaning if you will :O
 
I'm a software developer (no game) and our product has to run on many different hardware configs and scenarios. It's not about testing on 50 vs 5000 configs, its about proper software engineering and managing issues. There is always a compromise in software development time between the amount of design, and the final performance and stability. And that is the problem - developers and publishers are after quick profits and optimize only for consoles (actually just one console) rather than take the time to architect stuff properly.

You don't need to test a million configs - if done properly, you need to test 99% of the code once, and have the other 1% be specific to a video card (like a driver), cpu family etc. This is how game engines are written for example.
 
Face it guys, as long as piracy is a bad as it is, we're always going to be 2nd class for big titles like this. Have to put up with the console ports.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

No. This has nothing to do with it.

And FYI, console games are pirated plenty. Oftentimes they are even released for download before PC versions.
 
Back
Top