AMD Responds to the Sandy Bridge Bug

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It would seem that AMD is trying to capitalize on the recent Sandy Bridge issue by launching a marketing campaign of sorts. Head on over to PC Perspective for the rundown.

The biggest potential win for AMD would have been a successful AM3+ motherboard launch, but they still were not able to move up that particular product. If AMD had been able to come out swinging with this new socket, and new motherboards designed around it, we could very well have seen a much more significant boost to AMD. While there are no Bulldozer nor Llano based chips available, AM3+ boards do support current AM3 processors. Releasing the high end 990FX and budget 970 boards, neither of which utilize the integrated graphics of Llano, and populating them with current Phenom II and Athlon II CPUs could have provided a nice impetus to AMD and given the company a marketplace more prepared for the new CPUs to arrive later this Spring.
 
They picked weird points...


1. Unlocked CPUs. All old intel chips are "unlocked" (can be overclocked) but also work at much higher tempretures... AMD isn't ecatly e overclocking haven compared to intel.

2. Superior DX11. Are they talking about GPU or CPU? I don't think any soley CPU provided graphics are stunning...Intel graphics do suck ass though.

3. Eyefinity... This isn't really related to CPUs? Why not put display port?

4. Common infastructure. Not really surprising as there isn't much difference between mid and high end. Intel does have i3 and i5s for the low end sockets, and i5s and i7s for the mid range boards.

5. 6 Cores for the price of their 4. But hyperthreading works just as well as a core, so it's pretty much 6 vs 8?

6. Socket compatibility with generations on CPUs. They probably have that one, but most the time i've upgraded motherboards for new features, like USB 3.0, PCIeX16, Lightpeak. etc.



Should have stuck with bang for buck or cheapness type points, would make more sense to a consumer.
 
I figured they [AMD] would try to take advantage of the SB debacle. People would have B&M'd if they had *not*, I am sure. We all know Intel would have done the same, had the companies been reversed.
 
Sorry AMD, I am waiting for Sandy Bridge to come out again. I would rather have a 4 core that's faster than your 6 core. Don't want to wait for Bulldozer and find out it doesn't surpass Sandy Bridge but only approaches it.
 
They picked weird points...


1. Unlocked CPUs. All old intel chips are "unlocked" (can be overclocked) but also work at much higher tempretures... AMD isn't ecatly e overclocking haven compared to intel.

They are talking about unlocked multipliers. Only Intel's super high end chips offer that. With AMD, it is only a few $ more for an unlocked vs locked chip.


5. 6 Cores for the price of their 4. But hyperthreading works just as well as a core, so it's pretty much 6 vs 8?

Hyperthreading gives you MAX 20% gain for most things that can actually use the extra threads available.. up to about 30% for things that are written specifically to keep the data being used able to fit in processor cache.
 
I guess AMD has to try any tactic they can. Hell, clock per clock, Phenom II is only as good as Core 2 architecture. Reminds me how underhanded they were with Fermi with the cop raids commercial.

If you can't compete on the strengths of your product, bash your competitor. Stay classy AMD.
 
Yea when AMD makes a processor that can compete with Intel I will be interested in reading what they have to say.

Until then I am sure the fanboys are loving it. Not sure why considering Intel could fuck up for a year and still be ahead.
 
Yea when AMD makes a processor that can compete with Intel I will be interested in reading what they have to say.

Until then I am sure the fanboys are loving it. Not sure why considering Intel could fuck up for a year and still be ahead.

Processors? Only the gullible and naive nurse that teat. CPU's... :rolleyes:

Intel lemmings...
 
They are talking about unlocked multipliers. Only Intel's super high end chips offer that. With AMD, it is only a few $ more for an unlocked vs locked chip.

Hyperthreading gives you MAX 20% gain for most things that can actually use the extra threads available.. up to about 30% for things that are written specifically to keep the data being used able to fit in processor cache.

An unlocked multiplyer does help with overclocking, but unless its a sandy brige chip, doesn't change the overclockability. It is not like multiplyer changable chips are hugely ahead of 'locked" chips, or that different. I think the point they were trying to make related to SB, with it's non k versions (which are only a few dollars more anyway). Still AMD chips are not prime choices for OCing, with or without a lock.

Hyperthreading gives you another core, for a few c more in tempreture. It is a fully useable core and i've not noticed any performance difference in physical and real cores. Multithreaded applications still not being widely used is a reason why 6 cores are not really much better than 4, ignoring HT too. Hopefully with the raised core count of bulldozer, and the 2011 socket chips all supposed to be having 6 or 8 cores (+ HT) it should hopefully make programmers seek to use multiple threads to make the most of the new tech focused on it.
 
Processors? Only the gullible and naive nurse that teat. CPU's... :rolleyes:

Intel lemmings...

A Shit List, by ICOM
1) CPUs. I run my Badass™ Mk. II rig CPU-free, to unleash Maximum Badassery!
2) Operating Systems. Only Badass™ Mk. II can play porn in the BIOS!
3) nVidia. Only mortal OS lemmings need good drivers!
4) Intel. FFFFFUUUUU!!!! The lies and petty deceit put my Precious to shame! Badass™ Mk. II will triumfffffff! FFFFUUUUUUU!!!!!111
 
A Shit List, by ICOM
1) CPUs. I run my Badass™ Mk. II rig CPU-free, to unleash Maximum Badassery!
2) Operating Systems. Only Badass™ Mk. II can play porn in the BIOS!
3) nVidia. Only mortal OS lemmings need good drivers!
4) Intel. FFFFFUUUUU!!!! The lies and petty deceit put my Precious to shame! Badass™ Mk. II will triumfffffff! FFFFUUUUUUU!!!!!111

Sweat!
 
Wow, they can't even talk shit right anymore can they?

Intel has finished the new stepping and the new mobos are being made and this just NOW comes out?
 
Hyperthreading gives you another core, for a few c more in tempreture. It is a fully useable core and i've not noticed any performance difference in physical and real cores.

Seeing as you think HT gives you another core, I wouldn't expect you to notice the difference anyways :rolleyes:
 
But hyperthreading works just as well as a core, so it's pretty much 6 vs 8?

I guess AMD has to try any tactic they can. Hell, clock per clock, Phenom II is only as good as Core 2 architecture. Reminds me how underhanded they were with Fermi with the cop raids commercial.

If you can't compete on the strengths of your product, bash your competitor. Stay classy AMD.

Alotta dumb in this thread.
 
lol amd can say what they will but the benchmarks points to intel as a clear winner.
 
They are talking about unlocked multipliers. Only Intel's super high end chips offer that. With AMD, it is only a few $ more for an unlocked vs locked chip.

My unlocked Intel chip was $180. I think I paid a $20 premium to get the unlocked multiplier. Would not describe that as "super high end" at all.
 
What I think of AMD vs Intel, in terms of platforms. This is coming from personal experience.

Intel Pros:
1. Very stable.
2. Very fast CPU.
3. Things like USB, ethernet, and etc is usually very fast.
4. Easy to work with, in terms of drivers.

Intel Cons:
1. Shit for a graphics chip.
2. Extremely expensive.

AMD pros:
1. Very good graphics chips.
2. Dirt cheap.
3. Upgrading hardware is friendlier.
4. Catalyst software is very well put together.

AMD cons:
1. Slower hardware in general.
2. Behind the curve in CPU technology, like SSSE3 or SSE4.1.



In the end, I'd choose AMD, simply because they're cheaper and have better graphics. Makes for an easy and cheap HTPC. I'm more upset that people have dual core, or quad core CPUS, and hardly any application uses more then 1 core.
 
My unlocked Intel chip was $180. I think I paid a $20 premium to get the unlocked multiplier. Would not describe that as "super high end" at all.

But now that SB is out of the loop for now what does that leave?
 
Hyperthreading gives you another core, for a few c more in tempreture. It is a fully useable core and i've not noticed any performance difference in physical and real cores.

So you have noticed a 100% increase in speed in no-HT vs HT in a program that can fully load 8 threads? I'm calling shens here. You simply have no idea what you are talking about.
 
But now that SB is out of the loop for now what does that leave?

Out of the loop for now? It's having less than two months of downtime. This isn't rampant speculation like Bulldozer is. 1155 motherboards have been readily available in retail, and will be readily available in retail in a month or so.

I mean, if you're in such a rush to get a new CPU that you can't wait, there's always Nehalem, which despite lacking the unlocked multipliers can still overclock as well as the "Black Edition" AMD chips, and have a clock for clock advantage.

I'm tired of the fanboys saying that Intel is getting 'bulldozed' because of the Cougar Point silicon issue. It's not a CPU problem, it's a chipset problem. I'm somewhat doubtful that AMD has some ace microarchitecture up its sleeve that will single-handedly surpass five years of Intel progress. AMD has all the right moves with core count and efficiency, but clock-for-clock their chips are hanging right with Core 2 stuff.
 
lol amd can say what they will but the benchmarks points to intel as a clear winner.
Agreed. I like Amd, in fact the only decent system I have is AMD, but if you want the best performance, you need to go Intel.
 
Hyperthreading gives you another core, for a few c more in tempreture. It is a fully useable core and i've not noticed any performance difference in physical and real cores.

Sometimes it's better to just keep quiet let people think you are ignorant vs opening your mouth and proving it.
 
I'm more upset that people have dual core, or quad core CPUS, and hardly any application uses more then 1 core.
I'm not so worried about an application using more than 1 core as I am with the fact that I can run multiple applications at once without any problems. Hell I sat here gaming once with a virus scanner and SB-SD running and never even noticed :).
 
Oh wow so AMD have actually put together a marketing campaign and drawn up some adverts???

That's the most remarkable news this year so far.

However, we wont see them anywhere maybe other than in the corner of the AMD site itself.
 
In the end, I'd choose AMD, simply because they're cheaper and have better graphics. Makes for an easy and cheap HTPC. I'm more upset that people have dual core, or quad core CPUS, and hardly any application uses more then 1 core.

You don't need that much of a graphics chipset for a HTPC. I run a i3 530 cpu in my HTPC and use the integrated graphics. I have 0 issues with anything on that machine. I routinely will watch Bluray rips while the machine is recording 2 OTA HD channels. No problem. I don't disagree with your statement that the AMDs have better integrated graphics, however the Intel graphics are more than good enough. Given that plus the fact I live by a MicroCenter and enjoy their huge Intel CPU discounts, Intel ends up also being the cheaper choice.
 
Maybe I'd be impressed if AMD actually had a product out they could compete with.

I've been working with their new CPUs for a few months and am completely unimpressed. At this point all our new AMD-based servers have been delayed because the memory controllers on these new CPUs are so bad that we can't even get two prototype units from the same batch to behave the same (one can boot to DOS, one can't even POST). Can't comment on the performance because no one can keep their unit stable long enough to install Windows on it.
 
AMD's track record hasn't exactly been stellar either..The Phenom I and SB600 were both broken...
 
Lol. I will stick to my Intel CPUs. For graphics though, sure I have an ATI card in my system. Big woop. Does not mean I will start going to AMD for CPUs, the cards great but does not mean they make great CPUs...
 
I think this bug is being made out to be bigger then it is. Ihave a dell xps 8300 at home and ihave not run into this problem . The machine flies at everything it does. Heck when converting files I am actually having trouble keeping the processor fed and i can never get it to go at full 100 percent at most its 85 percent .

I think amd dropped the ball by not having bulldozer out to capitalize on intels perceived error.
 
Hyperthreading gives you another core, for a few c more in tempreture. It is a fully useable core and i've not noticed any performance difference in physical and real cores.

I think you meant to say virtual cores and physical cores or virtual cores and real cores. All hyperthreading does is inform your operating system that you have '8 cores' and on the cpu, it shoves instructions for 'virtual cores' 1 and 2 into actual core '1' and 'virtual cores' 3 and 4 into actual core '2'. You don't gain any cores, you just basically setup a queue system for threads where each core has two queues.

The goal being that if somehow the OS side/games/what not are not fully taking advantage of your processors cores or that your processor could more efficently handle threading/queuing workloads for your core than your OS, you'd benefit in speed. To an extent, it makes sense from an abstraction point of view since hardware layers are in general faster than software layers by nature.

Turning HT on versus off doesn't make a physical or real core suddenly appear in your processor. It makes a virtual core appear to your OS and it viewable in task manager's performance tab etc. In reality, having your processor handle threading/queuing makes your programs perform anywhere from 5 to 20% faster, if that. HT is really just more marketing with little real-world performance advantages except in highly specialized/theoretical scenarios. 4 cores /w HT is closer to 4.5 cores than it is to 6 or 8.
 
I can only conclude one thing from the article:
AMD has a really poor marketing team that also lacks a lot in creativity, they just come out as bitter.
 
What I think of AMD vs Intel, in terms of platforms. This is coming from personal experience.

Intel Pros:
1. Very stable.
2. Very fast CPU.
3. Things like USB, ethernet, and etc is usually very fast.
4. Easy to work with, in terms of drivers.

Intel Cons:
1. Shit for a graphics chip.
2. Extremely expensive.

AMD pros:
1. Very good graphics chips.
2. Dirt cheap.
3. Upgrading hardware is friendlier.
4. Catalyst software is very well put together.

AMD cons:
1. Slower hardware in general.
2. Behind the curve in CPU technology, like SSSE3 or SSE4.1.



In the end, I'd choose AMD, simply because they're cheaper and have better graphics. Makes for an easy and cheap HTPC. I'm more upset that people have dual core, or quad core CPUS, and hardly any application uses more then 1 core.

Strange, whenever I have put a comparable spec system together, both the intel and AMD system, work to pretty much the same price.

I can't complain about AMD as they have served me well in the past, but their current lag behind intel concerns me.
 
AMD resorting to trash talk? Its trashtalk masked in moderation.
If there is trash talk benchmark they would smoke intel.
 
Hey guys, remember the marketing campaign Intel released during the AMD tlb errata? /sarcasm.

Sorry AMD, you're not getting my processor dollars any time soon. Lol. Your CPU products are terrible.
 
Sorry AMD, but this just reeks of desperation. You've no response to Sandy Bridge and that's a damn shame. It is an amazing chip. AMD caught a minor reprieve with the bug, but only by like a month and that doesn't seem to help since Bulldozer is still at least a quarter or two away.

I particularly find the "Our 6 or their 4?" marketing funny. Well, given that their 4 is FASTER than your 6, I'll take their 4 please and thanks. Needing more cores to try and keep up is not a selling point given that many apps aren't all that multi-threaded. Most games can use 2 cores well. Some games can use 2 cores well and 2 more a little. A few can use 4 cores well, but rather few. Almost none use more than that. Means that 6 cores really doesn't get you much

I wish AMD had a good response to SB, I really do since competition is nothing but good for us consumers but they are fooling no one with the marketing BS. Their chips don't compare will to the old Core i series, never mind the Sandy Bridge. They can talk all they like about Bulldozer, but until we actually see the thing it is just that: talk. We've been hearing about it for years and it was supposed to launch in 2009. That is not promising.

At least they keep making good graphics cards.
 
AMD Doesn't make shit. Sorry, but IMO 90% of the direction AMD's graphics devision has taken recently is due to ATI's expertise.

I'm aware of that. Doesn't matter. AMD owns them, they are AMD now, the money goes to the company that is AMD. It's a good thing for them, since the CPU division isn't doing so hot, and I question their ability to start to do so. Bulldozer has been heavy on talk, light on facts.
 
Back
Top