PSA: Asus DIMM.2 M.2 risers get HOT

when SK hynix took over Intel's SSD business, and eventually Intel ditch Optane, why doesn't SK Hynix approach intel and pick up that line of business as well?

Optane was Intels brand name for 3D Point memory, developed jointly between Intel and Micron.

It's demise had nothing to do with it's capability. It was by far the fastest, lowest latency, and highest endurance no volatile memory technology ever developed, and it is even now years after being discontinued.

Intel even used it in RAM sticks for their Xeon systems for a while!

There are still applications on my server (ZFS SLOG drives) where there is no other SSD on the market that can do the same job at any price, and once the eBay supply of Optanes drives dries up, I have no idea what Is use. I'd have to go for battery backed ram drives or something.

The problem with Optane was the cost.

It cost WAY more than traditional SSD's to manufacture, and while those who needed the best were willing to pay for it, when Optane was new it was simply cost prohibitive for most, so it never took off in the volumes necessary to make it profitable.

Outside of very specific enterprise applications, there just isn't a huge market for SSD's that cost thousands of dollars in capacities that on the consumer side can be had for a hundred bucks.

Both Micron and Intel ran into these issues, and eventually discontinued their 3D XPoint lines. Micron in 2021 and then Intel in 2022. They simply could not make the money side of things work for the technology.

The irony here is that while I am saddened by Optanes demise, the only reason I can afford to run them is because the used market made them very cheap immediately after Intel discontinued them in 2022. At least until the "pro-sumer" market discovered them in masse earlier this year, and prices on eBay started climbing again.
 
Last edited:
so since this thread is on the subject of these m.2 SSD heatsink + fan, I need your input for the following:

for this m.2 heatsink+ fan,

https://www.jiushark.com/en/products/mm.2-three.html

the fan is 10 to 11 cm thick, if I were to switch to Noctua 60mm x 25mm thick fan, am I correct that I should be buying the 1st one on this link:

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005003433932889.html?spm=a2g0o.cart.0.0.741738daZHiXGT&mp=1

he has 5 options:

the 1st one is: Hook Type 9 cm

I don't know if 9 cm is long enough, but that seems to be the only choice. Does anyone has any input? say an alternative or you think I should just go for Hook Type 9 cm
 
Would need to see a picture first, but the side mounted fan, meaning one of the flat sides of the mobo so that airflow is across the surface, is likely best for case airflow. Front side to back most ideal. Use vented PCI slot covers.

My vented pci slot covers on the empty slots: This is the top of my case. The three 180mm fans are on the bottom, air intake is on the bottom. Each 180mm fan has it's own air filter, and I added a custom made magnetically attached filter. I keep the case on the desk and off of the floor.
View attachment 686150

The three empty slots have the vented slot covers. Air intake is on the opposite side, or front edge of the mobo. This results in best airlfow in most cases. SFF are a different story. So it depends on what you have. Pictures needed.

I can't visualize what you are trying to say at your first paragraph

here's my fan controller, chnl. 1 to 3 is metal tape to the 3 x m.2 SSD


View: https://i.imgur.com/z2MqJrj.jpg

and this is my case w/ 3 intake fan


View: https://i.imgur.com/PaZHTt9.jpg

the top SSD is hiding under the Coolermaster CPU blocker, the other 2 M.2 :

1 on the right side of the motherboard, the other is on that PCIe x 4 adapter, that's the 1 w/ high temperature. So w/ 2 new portable 120mm InWIn MARS fan, I should install the fan on the right side of the case, and blow the cool air towards the left, what do you think?
 
Last edited:
and this is my case w/ 3 intake fan


View: https://i.imgur.com/PaZHTt9.jpg

the top SSD is hiding under the Coolermaster CPU blocker, the other 2 M.2 :

1 on the right side of the motherboard, the other is on that PCIe x 4 adapter, that's the 1 w/ high temperature. So w/ 2 new portable 120mm InWIn MARS fan, I should install the fan on the right side of the case, and blow the cool air towards the left, what do you think?

That is quite a mess... are all three fans on the right side (front I take it) intake? Air blows in? Guessing yes. That fan on the bottom is what is disrupting the airflow. Cut power to that and give it 30 minutes and re-check temps.

You have 3 intake on the front, then 2 exhausting out of the top. the airflow gets pulled from the front to the top, it is no wonder that the lower left corner is feeling neglected and overheating. That fan on the bottom is not a good position, and further causes air to not circulate where the adapter card is. You best bet might be a slot cooler, one that sits next to the pciex4 adapter card and exhausts out the back. Or a fan on the right edge of the adapter card blowing towards the back. And you need vented pci slot covers...

This, mounted under the pcie adapter. The fan intakes on the side facing the adapter card, and will blow air out of the back of the case.
1729440579879.png

https://www.amazon.com/CCBBAA-Computer-Chassis-Exhaust-Cooling/dp/B09BM2MSDF/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2UUJS0CBTEBUU&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.mZpnwmCxqlsXOoXZEWfvenp2PxIjJowtlAg1ABEaxpW_6Zcz4KSxCtliA2Ncw0bjqju8FFWUoX0przHg-BEY3-u9eXf9u_n51f8-4Lwv1e_OmFiV5sr-oE1MHV2OYJzyAcEwCAmt5f80HKGV4diPvgnlsKJG-jV5wO_GbNpd1bdr1vCDyvAPcgVWwdJofxjYChUq4e4LqpKRRsYmc-CN3t3orKZ5qNF1hz6D8HaNl_Q.eAE8cBpF_FfbNNMS_lWnAfNAeg2R3ok4ZZqA5F964IE&dib_tag=se&keywords=pci+slot+fan&qid=1729440184&sprefix=pci+slot+fan,aps,135&sr=8-4


You might consider a different case. That one looks... not very good. But this fan is cheap and would likely solve the overheating nvme. Worth trying at least. If it doesn't help, get a new case.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
All 3 on the right, 1 x 140mm, 2 x 120 mm are all intake cool air fan, yes.

the design of having that bottom fan (intake) is a clone idea that I got from the NZXT Phantom 920 that Kyle Bennett reviewed back in 2014. That bottom fan should bring it fresh cool air.

I shouldn't need the above, as the InWin Mars is coming. As to the case, it's a $600 case. It's the In Win S-Frame hybrid. The In Win S-Frame is a single sheet of Al bend to a certain angle, Jonsbo does the same. The bottom supposedly support 3 x 120mm fan or radiator

https://www.jonsbo.com/en/products/mod1blackred.html

you can see from the above link, that they also suggest 3 x 120mm fan bottom.
 
Last edited:
You still need to check temps with that bottom fan off. That fan is not helping the airflow. MAAAYYBE if you reverse the direction so that it blows out, down. But that still isn't going to help the temps of that adapter card. That case isn't good for internal airflow. Doesn't matter what it cost.
 
Lol small form factor guys do it to themselves :D

Out of all of those little lunchboxes that they make, grab the one with the most holes :)
 
Gen4 drives were introduced 5 years ago now.

I wonder how many of the Gen3 drives out there are old stock they are still trying to sell off. At best, I'd imagine any Gen3 drives still being made are just taking advantage of old manufacturing lines until they shut them down and repurpose them for something newer.

Samsung still lists one Gen3 drive on their site, the regular non-pro 980.

View attachment 685684

(I'm a little confused by this 980 Gen 3 drive, as I thought all Samsung srives were either Pro or Evo, but this one is neither)



WD seems to have rebranded their entire line. The excellent SN850x is gone, and the rest seem to have a new 4-digit naming scheme. Sadly they don't put PCIe Gen directly in the title, but I have taken the liberty of labeling them.

View attachment 685686

The only Gen3 drive left is one they are marketing for the "industrial" market.


Crucial markets a lot of drives: (but that might just be because they list each size independently)


View attachment 685687
(no idea why that P310 image doesn't load)

Gen 5 and Gen 4 are represented, but none of them are Gen3.


I'm not going to bother digging through the product pages of shitty me too Chinese reference design Phison rebrands, but the above indicates that Gen3 is at the very least on its way out, with only very few still hanging on, and a good chunk for specialty "industrial" purposes, where the latest Gen doesn't matter much anymore.
The SN850X is still listed. I don't know why you're filtering by form factor instead of just brand, but that filter isn't working for some reason. The SN850P is the successor to the SN850X, but it performs worse.

https://shop.sandisk.com/product-portfolio/ssd?filterByBrandName=WD_BLACK&filterByConnector_List=M.2
1729519807908.png


You can still buy the SN850X directly from them.

https://shop.sandisk.com/products/ssd/internal-ssd/wd-black-sn850x-nvme-ssd?sku=WDS100T2X0E-00BCA0
1729519884451.png
 
World: Oooh... ultra mega lighting super speed!!

That one knowledgeable person: There's a price to pay, and it's not just money.

World: But look at my Crystal DiskMark..... who can beat it?

That one knowledgeable person: Sustained though, it has to degrade to what NAND can provide.
 
The SN850X is still listed. I don't know why you're filtering by form factor instead of just brand, but that filter isn't working for some reason. The SN850P is the successor to the SN850X, but it performs worse.

https://shop.sandisk.com/product-portfolio/ssd?filterByBrandName=WD_BLACK&filterByConnector_List=M.2
View attachment 686478

You can still buy the SN850X directly from them.

https://shop.sandisk.com/products/ssd/internal-ssd/wd-black-sn850x-nvme-ssd?sku=WDS100T2X0E-00BCA0
View attachment 686479
Interesting.

I guess their website filters are broken.

Thank you for pointing that out.
 

Zarathustra[H]​


1) how did you get that CrystallDisk Mark test result on Crucial T705? do you own a T705? and where's your 905p test result?

I grabbed it from a review. I think this one came from Servethehome. Their reviews are usually pretty reliable, especially when it comes to storage.

see I don't play any PC games. The boot time is important to me, it's currently at around 5 sec. or so. As program load time, I only use WordPerfect, Chrome, Firefox and Excel, Fox PDF, all these s/w loads up under 1 sec. But I do backup on 100GB blu-ray, and I edit 4GB home made video MP4 files. And most of all, my unrar of a 10 to 18GB MKV files takes too long. It takes forever on these PCIe 3 m.2 drives. So I need a T705 drive to unrar them on my RAM drive, and I need to buy 3 of them

RND4K is not useful to me, my data file is just text file or XLS file, they are only 20K bytes.

If you are copying these large files to and from RAM, then I think that places you in my "corner case" or "outlier" I mentioned above. That is one of the rare use cases where a drive like this actually might live up to its sequential benchmarks.

To be fair, as far as boot times and program load times go, you might be insulated from low queue depth 4k random speeds a little bit if you use large amounts of RAM, and don't do clean reboots often. Microsofts default setting is to use "fast startup", which essentially just hibernates to disk on shutdown and resumes again once you power it on, this will result in a mostly sequential load. And with a large amount of RAM Windows is pretty good at caching lots of the things that benefit from high low queue depth RND4K speeds. The first load following a fresh reboot (not shutdown, startup) will still benefit, but after that you are likely RAM caching lots of it.

Games are one of the big exceptions to this, as they usually load lots of data in random fashion, and caching it all is usually not feasible, but since you don't run games, I guess that doesn't apply to you.

One place where you will definitely run into the benefits of low queue depth RND4k performance is Windows Updates. It makes a pretty huge impact there, and can - depending on the update - improve the install time and subsequent boot by a factor of 3x-4x, which is nothing to scoff at.

As to your friend Intel's Optane, there is no more "buzz". Noone talks about it anymore. If it were as good as you said on RND4K, shouldn't the industry get something new and out equivalent to it, or shouldn't other manufacturer such as your friend Samsung clone the Optane idea and make an professional line drive out of it?

I guess that depends on where you go. In the homelab/storage server/enterprise type forums (Serve The Home Forums, Level1techs Forum, etc.) they still have legendary status. These forums are chock full of people who originally bought an Optane for their server, and it opened their eyes, and now they use them for everything they can.

In more mainstream enthusiast and gaming circles, not quite as much. They tend to be more focused on consumer hardware, as they haven't been exposed to enterprise stuff as much.
 
I grabbed it from a review. I think this one came from Servethehome. Their reviews are usually pretty reliable, especially when it comes to storage.



If you are copying these large files to and from RAM, then I think that places you in my "corner case" or "outlier" I mentioned above. That is one of the rare use cases where a drive like this actually might live up to its sequential benchmarks.

To be fair, as far as boot times and program load times go, you might be insulated from low queue depth 4k random speeds a little bit if you use large amounts of RAM, and don't do clean reboots often. Microsofts default setting is to use "fast startup", which essentially just hibernates to disk on shutdown and resumes again once you power it on, this will result in a mostly sequential load. And with a large amount of RAM Windows is pretty good at caching lots of the things that benefit from high low queue depth RND4K speeds. The first load following a fresh reboot (not shutdown, startup) will still benefit, but after that you are likely RAM caching lots of it.

Games are one of the big exceptions to this, as they usually load lots of data in random fashion, and caching it all is usually not feasible, but since you don't run games, I guess that doesn't apply to you.

One place where you will definitely run into the benefits of low queue depth RND4k performance is Windows Updates. It makes a pretty huge impact there, and can - depending on the update - improve the install time and subsequent boot by a factor of 3x-4x, which is nothing to scoff at.



I guess that depends on where you go. In the homelab/storage server/enterprise type forums (Serve The Home Forums, Level1techs Forum, etc.) they still have legendary status. These forums are chock full of people who originally bought an Optane for their server, and it opened their eyes, and now they use them for everything they can.

In more mainstream enthusiast and gaming circles, not quite as much. They tend to be more focused on consumer hardware, as they haven't been exposed to enterprise stuff as much.
no, I turn off the PC at the end of the day. My RAM disk does not retain image
 
Back
Top