Microsoft to Remove Full ReFS Support from Windows 10 Pro

The response I actually want to type to this shit would get me banned.

raw.gif


Isn't this a fairly new file system created by Microsoft themselves? Seems weird they would axe it already, unless it was fairly unpopular. I've never even used it.

EDIT: Ah, never mind...noticed it was being moved to Pro for Workstations. I guess that...sort of...makes sense...?

Microsoft really never pushed it for the consumer market. They need to make Workstation SKU more attractive, so they moved it there. Which kind of makes sense. Those that would use ReFS are more likely to use the features in Workstation, anyway. Although, I'd love to see it as part of Pro, but it seems Pro is being depreciated into a more Advanced Home version, with Workstation and Enterprise taking the role of the "business" OS.

IMO, it creates confusion for the end user and business user.
 
So I wonder if they are actually going to improve ReFS or if this is just SKU change. At this point you still can't boot from a ReFS drive, so other than using it for storage spaces it has a pretty limited appeal.

I agree with others though that I don't care for the Windows 10 model of forced upgrades and forced feature removal. I do hope someone does bring some light on this because it's not good for users. I can understand that they want to pull features because it obviously costs money to keep those features around. It's probably not in anyone's interest on this board to be paying for features they are not using. But if you are forced to upgrade, then you shouldn't be forced to lose functionality as well. With 8.1 I could make the choice that I wanted to lose WMC, and it told me if I upgrade I was going to lose it. Let's see if Microsoft gives you a method to opt out of the upgrade if you don't want to lose the feature.
 
$50 on Bitlocker going from Pro next.

My take is in a couple of years, if you want to use Windows 10 for work or business you gotta have Enterprise/WS...

Pro's days are numbered.

Yeah, since Windows 10 arrived, I've started doing my work (when at home) on Linux. Windows 10 is now only used for gaming and the occasional Photoshop session.
 
Considering Windows 10's anemic uptake (+5% in the past year while Windows 7 has also gained) they may want to consider making 10 Pro and Home more attractive too.

At work, we're being forced to move to Windows 10. We're holding off until next year, though. I love Windows 10, but the forced tactics fucking suck.

Our upgrade schedule for 2017 is off. No more upgrades for laptops or desktops. Because we can't move forward. We either go Kaby Lake, which stops Windows 7 updates past a certain point which is a huge no-no in our environment, or stay behind when it comes to hardware. We just said neither. We're just pushing everything back to 2018 when we roll out Windows 10. We cannot upgrade hardware without going with Windows 10.

That uptake will start getting higher when people start upgrading to newer hardware (Kaby Lake and above) as they can't use Windows 7 securely without a third party patch (which isn't recommended in an enterprise, really). Windows 7 will start declining.
 
why remove a feature post release.

also.. why should MS be able to remove shit from your computer??


Not that I agree with it but the logical answer to your question is a simple one.

You have a license to use windows you don't actually own the software.

There for MS is free to add and remove whatever they want from their IP.
 
Has MS even bothered to fix the issues with ReFS yet?

I was thinking about using it, but then found that if the drive gets completely full, it has a good chance of just wiping all your data off the drive.

And you can't use deduplication with ReFS either, so it is pointless for a file server.

To me, ReFS is a huge joke and completely pointless unless it is fixed. As they have not even bothered to fix the major issues it still has, I doubt they ever will.
 
We're doing a major overhaul at work with internet services for patients in mind, I'm adding full Linux support as a requirement. Fuck this. I won't be taking no flak when MS pulls odd shit again.
I'm already having problems with a very expensive blood analysis machine refusing to operate properly on Win10 Pro. Explorer keeps becoming unresponsive after the machine's software been operating for a few hours.
This is a new computer, new blood analyzer from a major manufacturer, and now the supplier is in hot water because they can't get the thing to play nice on 10 Pro.
I will be yanking 10 wherever possible. I need a system I can trust and control. Yes, Linux meets most of my needs, and where it will not be able to, I'll be upgrading to 7 and placing a no-win-10 directive for the users.
 
View attachment 34198



Microsoft really never pushed it for the consumer market. They need to make Workstation SKU more attractive, so they moved it there. Which kind of makes sense. Those that would use ReFS are more likely to use the features in Workstation, anyway. Although, I'd love to see it as part of Pro, but it seems Pro is being depreciated into a more Advanced Home version, with Workstation and Enterprise taking the role of the "business" OS.

IMO, it creates confusion for the end user and business user.

Except that Pro was the business and/or workstation SKU and has been for quite a while now. It doesn't make any real sense to neuter Pro to effectively turn it into Home while at the same time making a new SKU which is really just Pro but rebranded.

So I wonder if they are actually going to improve ReFS or if this is just SKU change. At this point you still can't boot from a ReFS drive, so other than using it for storage spaces it has a pretty limited appeal.

I agree with others though that I don't care for the Windows 10 model of forced upgrades and forced feature removal. I do hope someone does bring some light on this because it's not good for users. I can understand that they want to pull features because it obviously costs money to keep those features around. It's probably not in anyone's interest on this board to be paying for features they are not using. But if you are forced to upgrade, then you shouldn't be forced to lose functionality as well. With 8.1 I could make the choice that I wanted to lose WMC, and it told me if I upgrade I was going to lose it. Let's see if Microsoft gives you a method to opt out of the upgrade if you don't want to lose the feature.

Removing functionality from Pro isn't a cost cutting measure for MS. The exact same functionality exists in other versions of the OS so it is still being supported. The exact same amount of work is required by MS. This is nothing more than an attempt by MS to force certain types of users to a more expensive SKU that they did not need otherwise just like the previous removal of features from Win 10 Pro.
 
Except that Pro was the business and/or workstation SKU and has been for quite a while now. It doesn't make any real sense to neuter Pro to effectively turn it into Home while at the same time making a new SKU which is really just Pro but rebranded.

It does make a bit of sense. Look at the functionality. Home and Pro are very similar when it comes to Cortana, telemetry, etc.. Most businesses, especially those with HIPAA or PCI compliance requirements, cannot use either. It's Enterprise or Workstation now. Home and Pro are for the home and/or SOHO segment.

You want to be in control of your OS? Enterprise or Workstation. You want it to be more of a OS as a Service that Microsoft can monitor and have you with an MSOnlineServices account? Home or Pro. There's little distinction anymore. Pro isn't like it was with XP or 7. It's gone downhill to be more of a Home Plus style of OS. And not for the better. I'd rather Pro be more oriented to business instead of the home user. It's just not that way anymore. It's easier to see when you see how much control you have over the OS vs. the true business SKU's. Feature wise? Sure, it's got some business stuff.
 
This is all about advertising dollars.

MS has gotten addicted to the growth they have seen in Advertising $ since windows 10 launched. Problem is windows 10 adoption has slowed and more and more people are finding ways to disable or skip all the "features" (telemetry/Cortana/built in bing search) that have been fuelling that growth.

So the easiest way to ensure that growth stays above 5% and hopefully hits closer to to 10% for the next few quarters.... is to ensure all the Windows 10 Pro customers get back into the full telemetry fold. Easiest way to do that is create a workstation sku.... lock it to their contract customers. Then remove some of the group policy options and the like from Windows 10 Pro that allow people to avoid such things.

I think even the most hardcore MS boosters know that is the truth. There is really no other reason to add yet another copy of windows that adds nothing... but instead simply removes features from the sku it replaces. Really you can't blame MS... they have 2-3 quarters coming up of Xbox losses to hide. If they can get Ad revenue to grow 5-10% for the next couple reporting quarters they can hide a lot of losses.

As for ReFS.... its a terrible unreliable POS FS that no one that knows better is using anyway. It shouldn't be a shock that MS is abandoning it... they don't even use it themselves. If your using ReFS right now... damn get rid of that unreliable crap while you can. ReFS is nothing but NTFS with copy on write and large file support which MS doesn't even have the know how to ensure is bootable. NTFS itself is nothing but a 25 year old fork (complete copy really) of HPFS "co-developed" with IBM for OS/2. (nothing co about it IBM developed it). MS hasn't been able to engineer a proper FS ever.... really every FS they have ever used has been "co-developed". The only MS employee that actually deserves credit for developing a FS is Marc McDonald MS first employee and that work was done in 1977.
 
I'm sorry, we're removing the seats from your car, as from now on that feature is only available in the newly introduced "sitdown" version of the car. That you have to upgrade to if you want to continue to have seats in your car. Please go to the nearest service point within 48 hours* so the "upgrade" can be performed.

*failing to comply will result in the brakes being randomly disabled during active hours.
 
The only MS employee that actually deserves credit for developing a FS is Marc McDonald MS first employee and that work was done in 1977.

Even that is debatable. I've heard that FAT actually came out of an abandoned microcomputer project at Sperry Corporation which Gates acquired and further developed with Marc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChadD
like this
Where's our favorite Windows apologist to explain how this is a good thing?
 
CUE the screams of all 5 people using ReFS on Win 10 Pro. :whistle: :p
CUE all the Microsoft haters who will call this a dick move. :whistle: :confused:
**Edit: Changed queue to cue. I was also being a bit silly, I know there are more than 5 people using it. :geek:
I didn't even know it existed till now.
 
So people purchased windows 10 pro assuming they can use the feature. they buy and and after a few updates its gone! this should be illegal!!!
For anyone that bought it, I totally agree, but if you're like most of us and you took a free upgrade from 7 or 8, I'm more ambivalent. That said, as others have said, just keep an old copy of the current build (I'd fully patch it then take an image) and you'll have a way to continue to make these partitions. I'll probably do that, even though I don't have any Refs partitions (because I never heard of it before).
 
That can't be legal. In fact, Sony was hit with a class action suit for a similar deal where they removed the "Other OS" functionality from the PS3.
Probably figure the chance of a fine/lawsuit probably costs less, which is sad.
Did they lose? AFAIK, the OTHER OS option hasn't come back on my parents PS3. What's more, I'm almost certain that it was known 2 years ago that features could be added or removed. I don't disagree with those worried about them making Pro more like Home, but so far most of the items removed are no biggie to me. I'd never heard of Refs and while many are complaining, I've only seen one or 2 people that actually use it.

If at some point down the line I want to use it, I'll just get the Workstation version instead of a license for Pro. It's not like we're going to be able to transfer these 10 licenses to new machines (unless the current workaround continue to work in perpetuity).
 
Even that is debatable. I've heard that FAT actually came out of an abandoned microcomputer project at Sperry Corporation which Gates acquired and further developed with Marc.

Very likely true. lol

The ars story author argued that during the IBM/MS OS/2 days MS did all the work on NTFS. I didn't bother arguing with them, they are pretty pro MS around those parts imo. I assume he based that on the work of Gordon Letwin who has been attributed as the main HPFS guy. (the only evidence I have ever seen of that is one line on his wiki but whatever lol) Letwin had a nice career at MS being one of the first handful of employees, he left not long after OS/2 fell apart and retired on his shares. The OS/2 project and HPFS was ran by Ed Lacobucci of IBM... the same Ed Lacobucci that founded Citrix Systems. I wasn't there of course... I'm pretty sure the bulk of the real work was performed by IBM employees and I know without a doubt the work was steered by Lacobucci. The MS management of the day was smart no doubt about that... the deals they signed with IBM where shrewd. Its hard to feel bad for IBM they had it coming at the time I guess... after years of being the company doing the exact same thing to the little guys. I may hate who MS became... but back then they where IBMs agent of karma. Of course karma has a way of circling back... and now it seems MS is unable to develop a decent FS, or get help from any company that could. NTFS is old and has been reliable enough for home PCs, (for those that don't know better) but it was never a solution for real data usage.... and more and more that is what matters.
 
Last edited:
Why would Microsoft remove a feature that for all intents and purposes is vastly superior to the dated, but reliable NTFS? I still have access to it because I use Windows 10 ENT, but this sucks for other folks.
I tried ReFS and only wound up with with corrupted drives after a power issue. Recovering data from ReFS is also more difficult.
 
Not that I agree with it but the logical answer to your question is a simple one.

You have a license to use windows you don't actually own the software.

There for MS is free to add and remove whatever they want from their IP.

Sony did the same thing by removing Other OS from PS3. They got sued. They lost. It's possible that MS could be sued for "bait and switch" tactics here. Will someone sue and win? I don't know. Not for me to decide.
 
Did they lose? AFAIK, the OTHER OS option hasn't come back on my parents PS3. What's more, I'm almost certain that it was known 2 years ago that features could be added or removed. I don't disagree with those worried about them making Pro more like Home, but so far most of the items removed are no biggie to me. I'd never heard of Refs and while many are complaining, I've only seen one or 2 people that actually use it.

If at some point down the line I want to use it, I'll just get the Workstation version instead of a license for Pro. It's not like we're going to be able to transfer these 10 licenses to new machines (unless the current workaround continue to work in perpetuity).
They lost but we're not forced to re-enable it. Anyone that could show they used it "significantly" got payment. The US navy were the biggest benefitory due to the large, cheap beowarf they had.


Thing is... Filesystems are meant to be BORING because you do not want an interesting filesystem with your data because interesting usually means loss of data. This is why I am on ext4 and not on say zfs/btrfs (with all the shiny COW, Btree, deduplication, silly size...)
Filesystems are not trivial and have zero tolerance for screwups. MS probably found a major issue and it simpler to disable then come public, prob an architectural issue.
They should just contribute to ZFS

Linux has a whole host of filesystems and filesystem developers and they never remove. The F2FS Linux driver recently had 3 CVE raised against it but they just got fixed
 
Did they lose? AFAIK, the OTHER OS option hasn't come back on my parents PS3. What's more, I'm almost certain that it was known 2 years ago that features could be added or removed. I don't disagree with those worried about them making Pro more like Home, but so far most of the items removed are no biggie to me. I'd never heard of Refs and while many are complaining, I've only seen one or 2 people that actually use it.

They did lose - http://www.otherossettlement.com/

Settlement for a whole $55, as long as you have proof of purchase, which after 10+ years I unfortunately did not.
 
Thing is... Filesystems are meant to be BORING because you do not want an interesting filesystem with your data because interesting usually means loss of data. This is why I am on ext4 and not on say zfs/btrfs (with all the shiny COW, Btree, deduplication, silly size...)
Filesystems are not trivial and have zero tolerance for screwups.
You choose ext4 over ZFS?
 
Now if they
Has MS even bothered to fix the issues with ReFS yet?
I was thinking about using it, but then found that if the drive gets completely full, it has a good chance of just wiping all your data off the drive.
And you can't use deduplication with ReFS either, so it is pointless for a file server.
To me, ReFS is a huge joke and completely pointless unless it is fixed. As they have not even bothered to fix the major issues it still has, I doubt they ever will.

Only place I use ReFS on my network is on my backup servers.
We use Microsoft DPM 2016, and it uses ReFS as the data store for D2D2T backups.
Otherwise I wouldn't bother with it.
 
You choose ext4 over ZFS?
Yes but for reasons. I am not some GPL zealots... I have issues with out of kernel core drivers where core are filesystem and HDD controllers...

I used to run reiserfs and would patch my kernel and then wait for updated patches. There was a real issue I was facing and needed to BP but well I couldnt due to lack of external patch. That's when I converted to ext*

I would easily take btrfs over zfs but since btrfs is still lacking it's ext4.
Shame I have a 1Tb m.2 and it would love btrfs but I'll wait and rsync my drive when the time is ready
 
It's out of kernel and needs patching to keep up-to-date date
One of the zfsonlinux devs is also a Gentoo devs and the number of times he has had to post on irc or the forums that zfsonlinux is behind zfs head (by quite a few releases) or due to a major change in the kernel internal API has caused a delay.

I know it is stable, it is constantly drummed into me, but it is out of kernel and it relies on volunteers keeping it up to date while a kernel release cannot occur if it will not build

Also afaik it can only be built as a loadable module. For my home server I disable module loading and do not have any for security reasons. For my desktop I do not use an initfs and thus the filesystem and HDD controller must be built into the kernel
 
Last edited:
Pretty obvious no one here has actually used Storage Space/ReFS under Win 10 Pro. The performance is horrible compared to ZFS using same machine/hardware, even worse once you turn on sane options for the Storage pool. It truly is big data/data center service. ZFS is much more suited for a workstation class system.
 
Pretty obvious no one here has actually used Storage Space/ReFS under Win 10 Pro. The performance is horrible compared to ZFS using same machine/hardware, even worse once you turn on sane options for the Storage pool. It truly is big data/data center service. ZFS is much more suited for a workstation class system.
That's because zfs was designed to be the filesystem to end all filesystems to put to bed the "should I use X, should I use y" except for cornercases. However they went and licenced it as CDDL which went and caused no end of problems....

When it comes to filesystems I just ignore Microsoft, they are the children in this area and the larger disk pools, larger files is only going to show the weakness of NTFS & ReFS even more (ffs go look at the feature differences... ReFS is soo light. )

What's even funnier is windows does not support RAID above RAID5 So if you wanted a raid topology that will survive multiple drive failures you need an expensive raid card (and all the issues that brings) or just don't have storage above a certain value.

Windows just isn't designed for big data :) NTFS or ReFS
 
Last edited:
It's out of kernel and needs patching to keep up-to-date date
One of the zfsonlinux devs is also a Gentoo devs and the number of times he has had to post on irc or the forums that zfsonlinux is behind zfs head (by quite a few releases) or due to a major change in the kernel internal API has caused a delay.

I know it is stable, it is constantly drummed into me, but it is out of kernel and it relies on volunteers keeping it up to date while a kernel release cannot occur if it will not build

Also afaik it can only be built as a loadable module. For my home server I disable module loading and do not have any for security reasons. For my desktop I do not use an initfs and thus the filesystem and HDD controller must be built into the kernel
Ah, Linux with ZFS. Wouldn't run that, but FreeNAS or somethng BSD based is the way to go.
 
Jeez.

No ethernet link aggregation, no REFS, no this no that...

What is even the point of the Pro edition anymore? It's more and more starting to look like just a more expensive Home version.
 
Ah, Linux with ZFS. Wouldn't run that, but FreeNAS or somethng BSD based is the way to go.
That would be a no-brainer.
I hope they can relicense before the patent runs out. Zfs is the better way to go but right now btrfs is all Linux has.. rh has a bastardisation of XFS which appears to hook into systemd so if btrfs doesn't improve in 2years that might be what distro's jump on
 
Sony did the same thing by removing Other OS from PS3. They got sued. They lost. It's possible that MS could be sued for "bait and switch" tactics here. Will someone sue and win? I don't know. Not for me to decide.

Good point but my money is on MS having better lawyers than sony.
 
Jeez.

No ethernet link aggregation, no REFS, no this no that...

What is even the point of the Pro edition anymore? It's more and more starting to look like just a more expensive Home version.

RDP capability? Ability to defer updates?

It says Pro on the box? :p
 
Ah, Linux with ZFS. Wouldn't run that, but FreeNAS or somethng BSD based is the way to go.


I run ZOL on my Proxmox box (Debian based) and it has been rock solid for years now.

The release may be behind what it is on BSD and Solaris based operating systems, but it still works very well.
 
Back
Top