Will Windows 7 Be The New XP?

Agreed. Win 7 x64 stays-- only reason to move is if MS forces it with a DX requirement AND the game makers use it.

If I interpret Microsofts support strategies properly, new key features should only cease to be rolled out to Windows versions after "mainstream" support ends.

For Vista, mainstream support ended in April of this year. Extended support (which includes security patches and such extends through 2017) So Vista won't see DX12.

For Win7, mainstream support ends in January 2015, and extended support ends in January 2020, so as long as DX12 is released prior to mid January 2015.

Not sure why XP didn't receive DX10 though if this is the case, as Mainstream support ended after Vista got DX10... Maybe that was because Microsoft extended XP support, and the original mainstream support end date was sooner?
 
While you may not like or need what Windows 8 offers over Windows 7 this statement just isn't correct.

It's more like for desktops and laptops Windows 8 offers very little over Windows 7.

Windows 8 has a number of tweaks to power modes,(sleep resume,etc.) improvements to boot speed, a more effective scheduler, but most of these will probably not be that significant, at least not significant enough to make people who are bothered by the user interface in Windows 8 to put up with it and upgrade.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038838599 said:
Not sure why XP didn't receive DX10 though if this is the case, as Mainstream support ended after Vista got DX10... Maybe that was because Microsoft extended XP support, and the original mainstream support end date was sooner?

Come to think of it, this makes sense. Mainstream support typically extends 5 years from launch. XP launched in October 2001, so Mainstream support originally should have ended in October of 2006...
 
This. People seem to forget how shitty XP was before service pack 1.

Maybe it just SEEMED like a stellar improvement compared to Windows ME :p

Just before the Windows XP days was back before I had discovered Linux, but I still dual booted.

Windows 2000 was my work/daily desktop OS. While I loved its stability, I found the mouse feel and rendering performance was off in games, so I maintained a separate Windows 98SE install just for games :p.

Windows XP wasn't bad. It was the best OS Microsoft had released up to that time combining some of the stability of Win2k with the mainstream and game features of Win98.

It's just hopelessly outdated today, especially when it comes to its security and stability features.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038838610 said:
It's more like for desktops and laptops Windows 8 offers very little over Windows 7.

Windows 8 has a number of tweaks to power modes,(sleep resume,etc.) improvements to boot speed, a more effective scheduler, but most of these will probably not be that significant, at least not significant enough to make people who are bothered by the user interface in Windows 8 to put up with it and upgrade.

One thing that that gets glossed over are the thousands and thousands of Metro apps that are going to run on those desktops and laptops. I know Metro opponents in particular point out they have no use or desire to run "phone" apps on their PCs but most people aren't going to see it that way. There's already a few in the Release Preview that are decent on this is just the free test stuff. Microsoft is pouring a LOT into the development of Metro apps and the sheer number what will be produced will inevitably lead to some good ones that work well with keyboards and mice.
 
Windows 7 here at work for several more years because luckily the boss and I make the IT decisions for several hundred employees. Windows 8 tested and discarded as an upgrade. MS fanbois can stomp and scream all they want but we gave Win 8 a fair assessment and its a cluster-fudge as far as business is concerned.
How can you make a fair assessment of the final product when the final product isn't yet available?
 
How can you make a fair assessment of the final product when the final product isn't yet available?

Well any real Microsoft fanboy knows that it really didn't matter what Windows 8 turned out to be, businesses were not going to deploy it in any numbers since most are doing their Windows 7 deployments trying to get off XP by 2014. Windows 8 will end up in the enterprise via bring your on device and businesses bringing in tablets that already have a lot of Microsoft platforms and tools.
 
How can you make a fair assessment of the final product when the final product isn't yet available?

Consumer previews are supposed to be a fair assesment of what they are looking to release.

Plus I doubt many businesses would install elbow stirrups on every desk so the user can use a touchscreen monitor for a few hours at a time. ;)


Anyways, Everyone seems to forget the huge outcry of when xp was released/previewed. I recall "fisher price" being loudly used in disgust of the UI because of the colour scheme of the three window control boxes in the top right corner and the "roundness" of the graphics that the windows had now taken. It had huge opposition just based on that with everyone saying they'll stay on 98. Now those very same people are thinking they are nostalgic for win xp.

This though, oh boy, it's a fundamental shift and much more than just colours.

Only upside I can see is that because it's made to run on the pathetic arm architecture that usually includes stuff all memory and storage space, you could pull out your pentium 2's again, load up with 64MB memory and be flying with this system. :D

I used to upgrade religiously every year, I haven't upgraded aside from one graphics card since 2009. My quad core 955BE with 8GB memory and the 5850 video card play anything I can throw at it. And the only upgrade I do want now is an ssd. So that in point, I have absolutly no desire for win8. In fact, if it would run my full steam library, office 2007 and ie9 and beyond, I'd shift to linux right now. So there we go, they have a few years of opportunity to get those working, hop to it linux distros. The only alternative I want is the os, I don't care about open office, widgee didge, oopy-loops, chezehta, lolwgols or any other stupid named alternative crap to replace those things I want running.
 
Consumer previews are supposed to be a fair assesment of what they are looking to release.
Except you know that's not the case here. Microsoft already said the desktop was getting a major revamp between "Release preview" and RTM. Who knows what else is going to change between now and the final version...

So I ask again, how can you make a fair assessment of the final product when it's not yet available?

Plus I doubt many businesses would install elbow stirrups on every desk so the user can use a touchscreen monitor for a few hours at a time. ;)
What are you talking about? Windows 8 supports mice and keyboards, just like all previous versions of Windows. There's no need to use a touchscreen at all.
 
Except you know that's not the case here. Microsoft already said the desktop was getting a major revamp between "Release preview" and RTM. Who knows what else is going to change between now and the final version...
I would not refer to the removal of reflections as a "major revamp".
 
Drat, no edit...

Consumer previews are...

Just noticed, the last version you put through its paces was the consumer preview? There were a good number of changes made to how mouse interaction works between "Consumer Preview" and "Release Preview," especially where multiple monitors are concerned.

I'd say you might want to re-evaluate when it goes final...
 
Reflections, transparency and other Aero effects.
Again, reflections? I don't see anything on my desktop reflecting anything else on Windows 7...


Uncertain weather or not that covers all upcoming changes. They've withheld information and given it up in later blog posts throughout WIn8's development.

And no, that's not the leak I was referring to. There are some leaked screenshots floating around of a post-Release preview build that has a few desktop changes already implemented.
 
I remember a lot of people were pretty upset over XP's service pack 2 breaking a bunch of programs. There were people who swore they'd never use XP because of that. I bet some of them are swearing they'll never use Windows 8 now.
 
I would not refer to the removal of reflections as a "major revamp".

Reflections, transparency and other Aero effects.


You mean this leak?

This looks like a pretty big visual change to the desktop: http://www.winsupersite.com/article/windows8/windows-8-secrets-desktop-theme-143447

And I'm pretty sure there's going to be some tweaks to Metro and app navigation, probably at least one thing that's kind of big, like the multiple monitor enhancements to Metro in the Release Preview.
 
I had an interesting experience with one of Windows 8's features in the Release Preview. I went to shut down the laptop and Windows 8 remained at the Shutting down screen. It was not frozen, the mouse moved and the animation continued, Windows 8 just wasn't shutting down.

I like my power button to shut down, not sleep, so I had my power button set to shut down. Pressing the power button did not affect the shut down screen. The old trick of pressing and holding the power button to power off worked, but when I powered the laptop back on, it was greeted with the same shutdown screen. Due to a new "feature", pressing F8 at the Windows splash screen did not bring up the Advanced Boot Options menu (http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/05/22/designing-for-pcs-that-boot-faster-than-ever-before.aspx). My laptop doesn't have a CD drive, so I had to break out my trusty Windows PE (Windows 7) USB and erase c:\hiberfil.sys /A:SHAI. You could tell a user to press F8 and boot into Safe Mode. In this situation, what would the end user do? (Error: Windows failed to resume from hibernate with error status 0xC000000F.)

Also, even at Release Preview, my laptop still sad face blue screens now and again. Of the ones that produced an event in the event log and a dump file ("Crash dump initialization failed!"), here's ones I've received: IRQL_NOT_LESS_THAN_OR_EQUAL and SYSTEM_SERVICE_EXCEPTION. I had found using DP and CP that installing ThinkPad PM Device eliminated the more frequent blue screens I had received.

So yes, Windows 8 is faster and is improved, but it is not without its problems that may make me hold off a while (I did not hold off with Windows Vista or Windows 7).
 
I had an interesting experience with one of Windows 8's features in the Release Preview. I went to shut down the laptop and Windows 8 remained at the Shutting down screen. It was not frozen, the mouse moved and the animation continued, Windows 8 just wasn't shutting down.

I like my power button to shut down, not sleep, so I had my power button set to shut down. Pressing the power button did not affect the shut down screen. The old trick of pressing and holding the power button to power off worked, but when I powered the laptop back on, it was greeted with the same shutdown screen. Due to a new "feature", pressing F8 at the Windows splash screen did not bring up the Advanced Boot Options menu (http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2012/05/22/designing-for-pcs-that-boot-faster-than-ever-before.aspx). My laptop doesn't have a CD drive, so I had to break out my trusty Windows PE (Windows 7) USB and erase c:\hiberfil.sys /A:SHAI. You could tell a user to press F8 and boot into Safe Mode. In this situation, what would the end user do? (Error: Windows failed to resume from hibernate with error status 0xC000000F.)

Also, even at Release Preview, my laptop still sad face blue screens now and again. Of the ones that produced an event in the event log and a dump file ("Crash dump initialization failed!"), here's ones I've received: IRQL_NOT_LESS_THAN_OR_EQUAL and SYSTEM_SERVICE_EXCEPTION. I had found using DP and CP that installing ThinkPad PM Device eliminated the more frequent blue screens I had received.

So yes, Windows 8 is faster and is improved, but it is not without its problems that may make me hold off a while (I did not hold off with Windows Vista or Windows 7).

Bugs and oddities are to be expected in pre-release software.
 
I found out more information. When you explicitly tell Windows 8 to shut down using the interface (charms - settings - power - shut down OR ALT+F4 Shut down, it does not shut down. It hybrid sleeps / hibernates. If you really want to shut down your computer, you can use the shutdown command (like shutdown -s -t 00).

Just got another blue screen. Stop error code 0x0000007e (SYSTEM_THREAD_EXCEPTION_NOT_HANDLED).
 
I found out more information. When you explicitly tell Windows 8 to shut down using the interface (charms - settings - power - shut down OR ALT+F4 Shut down, it does not shut down. It hybrid sleeps / hibernates. If you really want to shut down your computer, you can use the shutdown command (like shutdown -s -t 00).

Just got another blue screen. Stop error code 0x0000007e (SYSTEM_THREAD_EXCEPTION_NOT_HANDLED).

That's actually documented here in the dev blog:

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/09/20/reengineering-the-windows-boot-experience.aspx

...on the 20th of September of last year. They're doing it to keep boot time down and the justification for it is also in the blog. Mind you there's some sales speak and Windows 8 love to read around, but it's all there.
 
Those blog posts are pretty wordy but they are very interesting reading. Metro opponents routinely say that Microsoft doesn't listen to its customers but they actually do. More accurately not by so much what they say but what they do, Microsoft does seem to relay very heavily on their telemetry data.
 
Yup, that's why I don't really put much stock in most of the "you're ignoring your customers" argument. Most of their blogs are pretty obviously insightful about the data they're collecting and the reasons why they make the changes they make. Well, there's that and the fact that most of the yelling is from a vocal minority.
 
A lot of people systems i fix are XP still. XP will be around past 2013 probably around 2015-2016 it will be over. Windows 7 will be around until 2020 most likely. Microsoft needs another way to create revenue. People aren't going to upgrade like before in the 90s. Operating Systems are so robust now they can last years without a new reinstall. Its not like windows 95 or 98 where time decays the OS. XP might be around until 2020. Never know ;)
 
Microsoft has quite the dilemma with that. The better the OS gets the less likely people will move to a different one. I guess they'll just have to live in the "Longer lasting gum" altruistic company category.
 
People will upgrade their XP machines when 4gb ram doesn't cut it. Though Microsoft has had their own ways of trying to nudge people over to Vista/7 though by no longer supporting XP from the DirectX angle for example.
 
Though Microsoft has had their own ways of trying to nudge people over to Vista/7 though by no longer supporting XP from the DirectX angle for example.
The DirectX issue is more complicated than you think.

DirectX10 requires things that Windows XP's video drivers don't provide, and the Windows XP Driver Model (XPDM) doesn't support. If Microsoft wanted to port DirectX10 from Vista to XP, they would have to port WDDM and allow Windows XP to run WDDM drivers in order to support it.

WDDM can't be implemented the same way in XP as it was in vista due to how the DWM is integrated into WDDM right along side DX10. They'd basically have to replace large chunks of WIndows XP with chunks of Windows Vista.

Adding an entirely new driver model like that isn't something for a service pack...
 
The DirectX issue is more complicated than you think.

DirectX10 requires things that Windows XP's video drivers don't provide, and the Windows XP Driver Model (XPDM) doesn't support. If Microsoft wanted to port DirectX10 from Vista to XP, they would have to port WDDM and allow Windows XP to run WDDM drivers in order to support it.

WDDM can't be implemented the same way in XP as it was in vista due to how the DWM is integrated into WDDM right along side DX10. They'd basically have to replace large chunks of WIndows XP with chunks of Windows Vista.

Adding an entirely new driver model like that isn't something for a service pack...

Not too sure about this. Back when DX10 first came out, there was a hack that you could install and run DX10 on XP.

Beta versions of DX10 also ran on XP if I recall correctly.
 
That's actually documented here in the dev blog:

http://blogs.msdn.com/b/b8/archive/2011/09/20/reengineering-the-windows-boot-experience.aspx

...on the 20th of September of last year. They're doing it to keep boot time down and the justification for it is also in the blog. Mind you there's some sales speak and Windows 8 love to read around, but it's all there.

That pretty much guarantees I won't be using Windows 8, or the first thing I'll do is hack it somehow to make it properly shut down.

I am pretty obsessive about always having a clean boot. My computer boots up before I use it, and when I am done it shuts down. I never let it sleep or hibernate.

The first thing I did when I first got vista, was change the default shutdown option to actually shut down, not sleep.

Who am I kidding though. I wasn't going to embrace Win8 on the desktop anyway. If I can swing it, I may just get one of those Win8 tablets. It looks brilliant for that purpose, especially if some company makes one with enough of a GPU to play games like Civ 5.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038861648 said:
That pretty much guarantees I won't be using Windows 8, or the first thing I'll do is hack it somehow to make it properly shut down.

I am pretty obsessive about always having a clean boot. My computer boots up before I use it, and when I am done it shuts down. I never let it sleep or hibernate.

The first thing I did when I first got vista, was change the default shutdown option to actually shut down, not sleep.

Who am I kidding though. I wasn't going to embrace Win8 on the desktop anyway. If I can swing it, I may just get one of those Win8 tablets. It looks brilliant for that purpose, especially if some company makes one with enough of a GPU to play games like Civ 5.

I have to admit that I was a little put off by how Microsoft is handling shutdown, but I'm while I was reading the dev blog, I started to wonder if it was just what I was used to doing. Modern phones (I know, not so great of a comparison because of the limited functions) hardly ever actually come up clean. You have to actually pull the battery out. Personally, I'm not quite decided on whether or not I really like the idea of gaining a few extra seconds on boot in exchange for a potentially dirty system during operation. It doesn't seem like its worth the trade off, but that depends a lot on how Win8 manages memory and what applications do with the system to mess it up during operation.

Is Civ5 playable on a HD4000? If not, maybe AMD's eventual tablet solutions or a next generation Intel processor will offer the necessary graphics power. Give the aim of a tablet's small size and long battery life, faster GPUs might not find a home in tablets for a while. By the time integrated solutions catch up, we'll probably want to play other games with higher system requirements. The cycle of system requirements versus hardware is annoying sometimes.
 
Is Civ5 playable on a HD4000? If not, maybe AMD's eventual tablet solutions or a next generation Intel processor will offer the necessary graphics power. Give the aim of a tablet's small size and long battery life, faster GPUs might not find a home in tablets for a while. By the time integrated solutions catch up, we'll probably want to play other games with higher system requirements. The cycle of system requirements versus hardware is annoying sometimes.

Depends on what you consider playable.

When you first fire up the game it will run decently, but CIV's scenes get more complex late game with more units, cities, improvements and more explored land. Towards the end of the game the HD4000 is ony good for ~10-12fps.

That's not as bad as it sounds, as this IS a turn based strategy game. it's possible to play it, but its very annoying when scrolls are that slow.

I was thinking that a AMD Trinity APU might do the trick.

According to my calculations 17W TDP models most are using in tablets won't be much better than HD4000 though. If a tablet maker can come up to the 25W TDP range they could use the A10-4655M which should be good for ~22fps late game in Civ 5, if my calculations are accurate. While not perfect, this should definitely be playable.

Ideally the top end mobile A10-4600M would be used, as it is capable of 30fps late game, but the 35W TDP numbers probably prohibit it from being used in tablets, or at least any tablet thin enough that you'd want it.

A low power 17W Ivy bridge with a companion mobile GPU from AMD or Nvidia might get the job done as well.
 
It doesn't sound like there are any really compelling options. 10-15 FPS is doable, I guess, but pretty far from ideal and I didn't realize that the TDP was so high on the A10 APU. :(

Perhaps larger screen tablets (13-15 inch) will find their way to the market and the increased size will allow for enough thermal headroom to include some sort of slightly more reasonable discrete graphics card. There may eventually be gaming tablets, but I can't see vendors getting into that kind of thing until they get a feel for how Win8 tablets with less risky, mainstream hardware sell.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038861648 said:
That pretty much guarantees I won't be using Windows 8, or the first thing I'll do is hack it somehow to make it properly shut down.

There's no hack required. The shutdown behavior can easily be changed in the Power Options -> System Settings Control Panel applet. Really it makes a lot of sense, how often does one need to a complete restart? Other than driver changes it simply shouldn't be necessary. And for all of the hate of Windows 8 it's proving to be even more stable to me than Windows 7 on the same hardware.
 
There's no hack required. The shutdown behavior can easily be changed in the Power Options -> System Settings Control Panel applet. Really it makes a lot of sense, how often does one need to a complete restart? Other than driver changes it simply shouldn't be necessary. And for all of the hate of Windows 8 it's proving to be even more stable to me than Windows 7 on the same hardware.

Bear with me a moment. I'm not interested in beating up Microsoft over shutdown. They know their OS better than some uninformed outsider, but they do seem to be pushing the hibernate versus shutdown. I found that annoying when I encountered it in Vista for the first time and I'm still annoyed by it now. The metrics in their blog demonstrate that most people do indeed let their systems hibernate, but I think that the justification for pushing the feature forward seems based on the faulty assumption that most people want to hibernate their computers. Its possible that hibernation is so heavily used because lots of people simply have no idea how to change shutdown behaviour in the power options. As far as I'm concerned, startup time, while somewhat important, isn't a big enough deal to warrant hibernating versus cold booting.
 
Its possible that hibernation is so heavily used because lots of people simply have no idea how to change shutdown behaviour in the power options. As far as I'm concerned, startup time, while somewhat important, isn't a big enough deal to warrant hibernating versus cold booting.

I guess I don't why anyone would need to cold boot versus hibernate 99% of the time. The only reason would be for stability purposes and Windows 8 is so stable that it's just not necessary to restart.
 
Back
Top