Will Windows 7 Be The New XP?

To this day I still say windows 2000 was the best MS OS ever. It was lightweight and reliable. While XP and 7 are probably as reliable, they sure arn't as light weight.

I held on to win2k for a long time. I only upgraded to XP when I ran into a compatibility issue with a game, then I decided it was time to upgrade.
 
To this day I still say windows 2000 was the best MS OS ever. It was lightweight and reliable. While XP and 7 are probably as reliable, they sure arn't as light weight.

I held on to win2k for a long time. I only upgraded to XP when I ran into a compatibility issue with a game, then I decided it was time to upgrade.

What Win7 and Vista have and Win2k doesn't, which I feel is really significant, is a robust unix-like user and permissions system.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038870974 said:
What Win7 and Vista have and Win2k doesn't, which I feel is really significant, is a robust unix-like user and permissions system.

The Windows NT system has always had a robust user and permission system, with the early Windows NT operating system being designed with POSIX compliance in mind to be able to sell the operating system to meet government entities requirements. NTFS file and folder permissions have always been very robust and granular. Local computer policy through Group Policy Object Editor (and Active Directory, introduced in Windows 2000) allows fine controls over what users can do on the computer) through Computer Configuration - Windows Settings - Security Settings - Local policies).

It seemed that Microsoft always envisioned most users running as local users, not local administrators. Programmers and administrators found this scheme burdensome, and it was only with Windows Vista that Microsoft implemented User Account Controls and running most programs and processes with user permissions (unless you're THE local Administrator, domain Administrator, or turn off UAC). While many Linux distributions were already doing this before Windows and Microsoft, I felt that NTFS and user permissions were already robust and granular in Windows 2000.
 
To this day I still say windows 2000 was the best MS OS ever. It was lightweight and reliable. While XP and 7 are probably as reliable, they sure arn't as light weight.

I held on to win2k for a long time. I only upgraded to XP when I ran into a compatibility issue with a game, then I decided it was time to upgrade.

Actually, Mister Squirrel, that's a little bit nuts! Come to think of it, not really. When Windows 2000 came out, computers that were for sale at the time had enough power to run it without any trouble. When Vista came out, there wasn't enough RAM to go around until OEMs started shipping systems with 1 GB as a standard at the bottom end. I liked Windows 2000 and hung onto it for a long time too, but these days, I have turned to stuff like Puppy, DSL, and Vector Linux to run old computers because of concerns about security with 2000 and the fact that gaming isn't super important to me anymore.

Still I luffed Windows 2000! *high fives*
 
I don't mind the Metro design guidelines or philosophy. I have absolutely no problem with Microsoft's websites' Metro treatment. I don't mind the simplification and flattening of UI elements and widgets. Tiles replacing rectangular icons plus titles on the Start menu wouldn't bother me either. I'm not yet completely comfortable with the idea of live tiles' from a privacy and security perspective, but I'm sure it will prove itself out.

I do not like the full screen Start Screen and how interactions with it feel disjointed, given that I mainly work on the Desktop ("App"?). Granted, I don't know what a non-full screen start screen would look like, if it is possible. It feels like a frankenstein bolted on or crudely sewed on interface. I'm typing this from Windows 8 Release Preview on a laptop. A minor place where the Metro Start Screen is inconsistent with Microsoft Apps is how moving the mouse right (or left) scrolls the Start Screen but not the Store or XBox Live Games (hopefully to be fixed by RTM). Also, when you log in to Windows 8, escape will not take you to the desktop (Windows key + D will), but once you've been to the Desktop, you can dismiss the Start screen by using the escape key. I've already posted on my distaste for Microsoft lying about "Shut down" (Shut down is really hibernate, unless you use the shutdown.exe command).

Windows 8 seems snappier and faster in interacting with it. Unlike Windows Vista and Windows 7, I have no desire to jump into Windows 8 at launch. I may get there eventually. Knowing Microsoft though, they may tweak it, but it is very unlikely to go away. It seems silly since the consumer hasn't jumped on Windows Phone.
 
It seems silly since the consumer hasn't jumped on Windows Phone.

And this is one of most the interesting things about Windows 8. That Microsoft would take the UI of it's mobile devices that most would say have failed and put it in the most successful software franchise of all time.

As the cliché goes, it's so crazy it might just work. Being a Microsoft fan I will admit that I love seeing Microsoft take these kinds of risks, doing the thing that isn't instantly hailed or praised and even vilified. Many great things in humanity were achieved because some bucked the trend, didn't listen to the crowd and did the thing that conventional wisdom said was crazy. I don't know if Windows 8 will be successful or not but it's something that I think Microsoft had to try if for no other reason that Microsoft has been too complacent for too long.

Microsoft will now have to fight tirelessly to make Windows 8 a success. I think that's a much better situation for consumers than a Microsoft that can just stamp about another incremental upgrade and make billions of dollars.
 
Back
Top