CDs Are Officially Over

I rip to FLAC not because of audio quality, but so I can archive my music in an unaltered format and not have to worry about the where the hell the CD went. It also gives me the flexibility of re-encoding my music if some new lossy format comes around that's better than MP3 or AAC.

So unless I can directly download FLAC or some other lossless encoded files, I'm going to keep getting CDs wherever I can.
 
I got rid of mine about 8 months ago. I think it was just over 200 CDs and had to let them go for next to nothing. Nobody wanted them. Even used CD stores were turning me away. lol
 
I got rid of mine about 8 months ago. I think it was just over 200 CDs and had to let them go for next to nothing. Nobody wanted them. Even used CD stores were turning me away. lol

Not sure what this says about your taste in music...:D
Then again theyd probably not like my kind of stuff either. :(
 
Not sure what this says about your taste in music...:D
Then again theyd probably not like my kind of stuff either. :(
I had the same problem with DVDs. It's not my taste in music in movies, but the lack of demand. They might buy 1 out of every 20 DVDs I brought in because it wasn't something that sold very well or they had too many copies of it. The main store I used to sell to shut down about a year ago.
 
MP3 @ 320 isn't good enough. I don't want to have to put up with that bullshit.

Bullshit. It's all histrionics, and I'm saying that as an audiophile and someone who's been a musician for 23 years and produced albums of others, so stop with this shit.

The human ear cannot tell the difference between 320 @ 44 @ CBR and "loss-less" wav etc. Only if it's encoded in VBR would you ever possibly be able to tell the difference, because there will be drops in the bitrate downward of 160, which can be detected.

320 @ 44 @ CBR is CD quality and the best headphones or speakers in the world will not show a difference. Anything above 320 is actually not any better. If you don't know what I'm talking about, it's because you've never actually gotten into the guts of recording and producing.

I've an ear that picks up on things that others do not hear, I'm known for it, and I truly cant tell the difference between full 320 @ 44 @ CBR from uncompressed files. Maybe on the slightest occasion, in very, very, very minute ways that are imperceptible for more than a second somewhere.

Otherwise, it's in people's heads.

Going digital at a full 320 @ 44 @ CBR, if that's what was offered, is perfectly sufficient, as it's CD quality. Only 160 and/or VBR is considered "near-CD quality".

Fuck CDs. It's nothing but pointless overhead these days. Artwork can still be done and made available, so artists don't get put out of business. It's just on people's computers to be looked at... but who the fuck stares at CD covers anyway. Sometimes I look at my favorite covers... for fifteen seconds... but I don't look for a CD to stare at the art. It's the music that matters.

Get the fuck over it. Digital is the way to go and allows many musicians to get their shit out there who otherwise might not be able to, due to costs and bullshit labels who wont sign them. I would know, I've been signed to large independent labels and have run my own, and been involved in the industry from both sides for 21 years.
 
I wish my car stereo (2002) could play MP3s. :( So I'll have to continue burning MP3s onto a CD-R to listen to my tunes in my car.
 
People still buy CDs? lol.


LOL, yeah people that give a crap about sound quality and hate listening to ass MP3's that are very fatiguing still buy them , lol, lol.

Misguided notions of CD's being antiquated and inferior aside. Ive had Cassettes and CDs of the same album and and generally the cassette ended up sounding better. CD's have a dry harshness that vinyl and cassette do not have. From my understanding and listening 320kb is the absolute lowest digital music should be (CD's are 1441). But then again i don't listen to music through apple earbuds or my uber sweet logitech PC speakers. lol
 
Music from iTunes follows the same licensing bullshit that games are now subjected to, if I recall correctly. You buy a limited ability to listen to music until Apple or other vendor decides to revoke it.

I'll stick to CDs, thanks.
 
Music from iTunes follows the same licensing bullshit that games are now subjected to, if I recall correctly. You buy a limited ability to listen to music until Apple or other vendor decides to revoke it.

I'll stick to CDs, thanks.

No, you're ill informed... It's been years since iTunes sold music with DRM. Amazon, iTuned, etc are all DRM free now; you buy the tracks and the files are yours, forever, no matter what, to do with them as you please. You can make backups, email it to a friend, cut it into a runtime, whatever. This is one of the few cases in history where the consumer actually came out on top.

Furthermore, iTunes, Amazon, and even Google Music have recently introduced services where the music you buy from them is forever backed up in the cloud under your account, which means you can re-download it multiple times (or if you happen to lose your local copy) and even stream it to any PC/phone at any time.

Honestly, digital distribution has so many many benefits that'd you have to be very obtuse not to see it. The only drawbacks to digital distribution are relatively minor and artificially created by the currently established methods, but if there's a demand for lossless files instead of lossy (or as a complement) then the market will react to it and someone will fill the void.

Frankly it'd be nice to have the option for lossless downloads, more for archival purposes than anything else... From a sound quality standpoint you're not really gonna gain anything unless you're actually editing and re-transcoding MP3s. Bad sounding mixes sound bad because they're poorly engineered, not because of the medium. There's plenty of poorly mixed CDs out there too.
 
What about us stereophiles, who still buy CD's for lossless audio. Other than Radiohead, I have not seen another band or record company offer lossless audio in digital download format. There is more to music then just listening to it on an iPod.

CD is lossy. Your music was mastered at 24-bit 96KHz and the CD 16-bit 44.1KHz.
 
CD is lossy. Your music was mastered at 24-bit 96KHz and the CD 16-bit 44.1KHz.

Not always. Have seen plenty of studios with the HDD recorders set to 16bit 44.1khz for a variety of reasons (to save space on HDDs or because some other audio unit/program only uses that so would be pointless). Know of plenty of people who do mastering at "CD quality". Plus historically, 24/96 recording/digital capture/capable soundcards haven't really been commonplace for that long, and CDs have been around for much much longer.
 
Yes this is something that pisses me off. Me and lots of other people I know mix/compose/master albums in 24bit 96khz audio (pretty much industry standard, though many people use 16/44.1 CD quality) making it sound as good quality as possible. Then shitty stores turn it into crappy low fidelity mp3s and sell it to people who haven't got a chance to tell the difference. THen people listen to it on crappy little white headbuds that sound absolutely shitty. It's not being audiophiley bullshit, it's just how things really are, and it's kind of sad...

It's kind of weird with all the "HD" tv's people are so into below SD audio. It's not even a question of storage anymore with 16gb memory cards being so cheap.

That is exactly why people do not care because most people do not have speakers capable of giving them even the quality their mp3s can produce. I am sure some sort of source will pop up for better quality music. It may take a while though. Kinda like TVs and monitors we had to go through the crappy flat screen phase before we started to focus on improving quality.
 
It will also be fun to see what some stores do with the huge space they have for CDs. I noticed over the years the local best buy had racks spread out more and more in the center where that stuff is. The center of the store is like a dead zone to me now I don't even venture into it. It is all the stuff that is dieing like point and shoot cameras, movies and music.
 
Too bad iTunes uses a proprietary format instead of MP3. :( Amazon > iTunes because of that. Not to mention that in general, Amazon has cheaper prices for a given song than Apple.
 
AFAIK AAC isn't propietary, you can even encode your own stuff... It's probably as ubiquitous as MP3 by now, tho some older players can't play it (including a Creative Muvo thumbdrive/player I use when I go running).
 
Back
Top