Batman: Arkham City Gets Extra Technical Tricks on PC

Fixed that for you for those who don't speak shill.

I was trying to keep it nice and clean thank you. Nvidia is also known to actually help developers implement their stuff. AMD simply doesn't do enough to compete in that respect. There are only a few cases where there has been a huge disadvantage for one side or the other usually it's not as bad. Whether they're part of Nvidia's program or not (I really don't feel like typing out that damn acronym right now) games almost always have a slant one way or the other (ignoring random driver issues on both sides obviously). As long as Nvidia and AMD aren't royally screwing consumers over (see: AA on Batman: AA) I'm in support of them working with studios to bring more games to the PC with little extras. I'd love to see AMD push their 3D and push some kind of physics. Havok is going nowhere and well PhysX is PhysX. Someone needs to push a good physics engine to actually enhance something that will actually improve gameplay instead of devs just focusing on barely noticeable graphics touches.
 
I don't see what people are blaming nVidia or AMD for in regards to the lack of AA in UE3 titles.
 
For like a week after release. And all ATI users had to do was rename the exe file to Bioshock or some other UE3 game that the CCC recognized.

And had to pay an extra performance penalty that Nvidia didn't since the initial work for AA was still done on AMD cards. The card did a chunk of the work, it just wasn't shown.

Thats something that annoys me. As a company they do seem to do the bare minimum, which is horrible for competition/new technologies.

No it isn't. AMD is a graphics company, not a physics one. What Nvidia is doing is bad for competition (artificially bundling/limiting unrelated tech), not what AMD is doing. While AMD may not be as observably active (whether or not they actually are is entirely unrelated to whether or not they put on the PR show like Nvidia does), they are *far* from hurting. The same cannot be said for Nvidia.

To be clear, I think Nvidia's work in CUDA and GPU driven physics is awesome. Right up until the point where they start doing things like preventing using an Nvidia GPU for PhysX if you use a non-Nvidia GPU for rendering (which is not for technical reasons). Or things like pushing devs to use vender ID lockouts to prevent standard code from working on other company's GPUs (the Batman AA thing). Or using CUDA to implement graphics effects that would normally be done as shaders (looking at you, Just Cause 2).

In other words, I like their technical stuff but I hate their business stuff.

It's not like they don't have their own physics technology (bullet), but they just don't seem too bothered with offering competiton

Bullet isn't AMD's. Bullet is an open source project started by some dude from Sony (he now works at AMD, but that is a pretty recent change)

as much as not using the "other team"s stuff (like when those people made physx (CUDA) work on radeons but AMD wouldn't support them, at all even though they had permission from nvidia to go ahead the project stalled).

AMD refusing to use Nvidia's API is a very, very good thing. CUDA is highly driven by Nvidia's architecture. Ignoring all the licensing and control issues (which are *huge* in their own right), AMD would be supporting an API they had no hand in shaping and is poorly suited to anything except their competitors architecture. Hardly a balanced playing field that would foster competition.

that leaves physx as the only matured tech that seems actively used/promoted.

Software PhysX is used, GPU accelerated PhysX not so much. The software side of PhysX is also pretty crappy, and does a really, really bad job at leveraging multiple threads and doesn't even use the floating point CPU stuff from 10 years ago (SSE), opting instead for the ancient x87.

Supposedly Nvidia is re-writing the software side (they inherited the current trainwreck from Ageia, after all), but who knows when/if that will come.
 
I was trying to keep it nice and clean thank you. Nvidia is also known to actually help developers implement their stuff. AMD simply doesn't do enough to compete in that respect. There are only a few cases where there has been a huge disadvantage for one side or the other usually it's not as bad. Whether they're part of Nvidia's program or not (I really don't feel like typing out that damn acronym right now) games almost always have a slant one way or the other (ignoring random driver issues on both sides obviously). As long as Nvidia and AMD aren't royally screwing consumers over (see: AA on Batman: AA) I'm in support of them working with studios to bring more games to the PC with little extras. I'd love to see AMD push their 3D and push some kind of physics. Havok is going nowhere and well PhysX is PhysX. Someone needs to push a good physics engine to actually enhance something that will actually improve gameplay instead of devs just focusing on barely noticeable graphics touches.

Frostbite? It even works on consoles :D

Of course, DICE hasn't lic it out to anyone, probably related to their normal (and traditional) reasoning of noone being smart enough to understand their engine, lol (which is why no official mod tools - which has never stopped others from developing 3rd party mod tools in lieu of them :p).

I don't see what people are blaming nVidia or AMD for in regards to the lack of AA in UE3 titles.

Were you around near the Batman AA launch? nVidia tried to prevent Rocksteady from allowing an AA function work on AMD GPU. The main cause of the flak was Microsoft developed that specific AA function as part of DirectX, not nVidia. So there was no reason for nVidia to try something as braindead as that. Instead, it gave TWIMTBP an even worse name, and moved Batman AA to the bargin bin for me (which I picked up at ~7usd :)).
 
What are you talking about? Lack of AA in DX9 titles is an Unreal Engine 3 limitation.

nVidia worked closely with Rocksteady to get in-game AA operating for their video cards. AMD could have done the same thing, nVidia isn't obligated or even reasonably expected to develop anything for other graphic card vendors. How did you manage to twist that up so backwards?
 
What are you talking about? Lack of AA in DX9 titles is an Unreal Engine 3 limitation.

nVidia worked closely with Rocksteady to get in-game AA operating for their video cards. AMD could have done the same thing, nVidia isn't obligated or even reasonably expected to develop anything for other graphic card vendors. How did you manage to twist that up so backwards?

Are they obligated? No. Is it still a dick move to put a vendor lock in a game? Very much so. They didn't have to lock it specifically to their cards to make it work, instead they wanted to be dicks about it and pull a "screw the consumer" move instead of actually I don't know doing something that would give them GOOD PR.
 
it could, and I think that's what Saist was getting at.

But rocksteady seems to be used to Physx, so they probably are going to stick with it, anyways.

Not could.

DOES

Seriously, I shouldn't have to spell this out on these forums: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&q=OpenCL+game+physics&aq=f&aqi=g-sv1&aql=&oq=

As an platform neutral acceleration API for hardware accelerated game physics the OpenCL API is already supported by both the Havok and Bullet physics engines.

Havok and Bullet can use OpenCL to leverage any processor with an OpenCL driver to provide hardware acceleration, be that a traditional CPU style processor, a traditional GPU style processor, a wide-bandwidth processor such as the Ageia PPU, or any other processor with an OpenCL driver. Support for this tech has been... get this... AROUND SINCE 2009. This is not something new. This is not something recent.

There is absolutely no reason for any game developer to still be using NovedeX/PhysX for any product. The performance over-head for using NovedeX/PhysX on non Nvidia GPU acceleration systems is atrocious, and yes, that is a reference to the deliberately detuned x87 processor de-optimizations. Again, this is the HardOCP forums. I really should not have to be given the Basic Nvidia Does Rotten Things, Get Over it, Lecture around this part of the internet.

Now, given the level of code sabotage that normally happens when Nvidia gets their paws on a game, I seriously doubt it would be possible for Rocksteady to to fix the game without having to rework the entire engine. All that PhysX moniker does is tell me this: The Game is Broke, don't buy it.
 
Not could.

DOES

Seriously, I shouldn't have to spell this out on these forums: http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&source=hp&q=OpenCL+game+physics&aq=f&aqi=g-sv1&aql=&oq=

As an platform neutral acceleration API for hardware accelerated game physics the OpenCL API is already supported by both the Havok and Bullet physics engines.

Havok and Bullet can use OpenCL to leverage any processor with an OpenCL driver to provide hardware acceleration, be that a traditional CPU style processor, a traditional GPU style processor, a wide-bandwidth processor such as the Ageia PPU, or any other processor with an OpenCL driver. Support for this tech has been... get this... AROUND SINCE 2009. This is not something new. This is not something recent.

There is absolutely no reason for any game developer to still be using NovedeX/PhysX for any product. The performance over-head for using NovedeX/PhysX on non Nvidia GPU acceleration systems is atrocious, and yes, that is a reference to the deliberately detuned x87 processor de-optimizations. Again, this is the HardOCP forums. I really should not have to be given the Basic Nvidia Does Rotten Things, Get Over it, Lecture around this part of the internet.

Now, given the level of code sabotage that normally happens when Nvidia gets their paws on a game, I seriously doubt it would be possible for Rocksteady to to fix the game without having to rework the entire engine. All that PhysX moniker does is tell me this: The Game is Broke, don't buy it.

Havok will probably never release a GPU based API. Intel has too much interest in keeping it CPU bound. Be nice for Havok to do anything at this point though. They've pretty much been silent since they were bought.

As for "sabotage" its rarely anything beyond some performance optimizations on their hardware, something I really have nothing against (within reason, totally killing performance on the competitors cards is taking it way too far). There are of course examples where it's taken to far and that stuff needs to never happen, but Nvidia and AMD both need to push against each other and work with developers.

Anyway using PhysX for devs is probably just something to do because Nvidia says "hey we'll help you make your port/give you some money to add some stupid little PhysX effects". It neither adds nor subtracts from the experience over-all. Without PhysX the effects would probably never be there in the first place and with it they're so minimal that they don't matter and aren't worth fretting over.

PS: If PhysX turns you off completely don't buy any UE3 title. Software PhysX is part of the default engine package.
 
How hard would it be for the developer to integrate OpenCl or directcompute for physx?

Not when you get paid by Nvidia for using Nvidia only features :rolleyes: ?

Funny people blame AMD for not doing anything but then again these people don't realize that you can do things on AMD that you can't on Nvidia.

That people fall for promises on a game that has to be released and no one knows if it is even decent enough to play, is their problem.
 
Are they obligated? No. Is it still a dick move to put a vendor lock in a game? Very much so. They didn't have to lock it specifically to their cards to make it work, instead they wanted to be dicks about it and pull a "screw the consumer" move instead of actually I don't know doing something that would give them GOOD PR.
nVidia didn't put a vendor lock on anything.
 
Ok, now I'm confused.

Are you guys arguing that Batman AA would have had in-game anti-aliasing if not for nVidia injecting proprietary code into the game preventing the feature from being used?

or

Are you guys arguing that nVidia developed a method for using in-game AA on their video cards for their customers but are to blame anyway because they didn't make the feature available to AMD's customers?
 
No it isn't. AMD is a graphics company, not a physics one. What Nvidia is doing is bad for competition (artificially bundling/limiting unrelated tech), not what AMD is doing. While AMD may not be as observably active (whether or not they actually are is entirely unrelated to whether or not they put on the PR show like Nvidia does), they are *far* from hurting. The same cannot be said for Nvidia.

AMD has its special AA which is "vendor locked", but whinge and moan when the other team do similar things. It really really annoys me that they sit around doing absolutely nothing and then when anyone else (intel/nvidia) supports developers and helps them produce games/tech and makes something good happen AMD sits and waves its underdog card and cries and pisses and moans because it was too lazy to do anything.

To be clear, I think Nvidia's work in CUDA and GPU driven physics is awesome. Right up until the point where they start doing things like preventing using an Nvidia GPU for PhysX if you use a non-Nvidia GPU for rendering (which is not for technical reasons). Or things like pushing devs to use vender ID lockouts to prevent standard code from working on other company's GPUs (the Batman AA thing). Or using CUDA to implement graphics effects that would normally be done as shaders (looking at you, Just Cause 2).

It's a buisness. Not a gentlemens club. Anyway AMD was offered CUDA (and still is) but they turned it down for whatever reason. Even though things like tesselation were adopted by everyone.
In other words, I like their technical stuff but I hate their business stuff.

AMD refusing to use Nvidia's API is a very, very good thing. CUDA is highly driven by Nvidia's architecture. Ignoring all the licensing and control issues (which are *huge* in their own right), AMD would be supporting an API they had no hand in shaping and is poorly suited to anything except their competitors architecture. Hardly a balanced playing field that would foster competition.

Youd prefer openCL, which is controlled/owned by Apple inc.? Neither OpenCL (royalty free) nor Physx (royalty free) nor Havok (propriety) are open source. But all with the exception of havok are free to use.

Software PhysX is used, GPU accelerated PhysX not so much. The software side of PhysX is also pretty crappy, and does a really, really bad job at leveraging multiple threads and doesn't even use the floating point CPU stuff from 10 years ago (SSE), opting instead for the ancient x87.

Multiple threading is down to the developer. If they have coded it in a way that it doesn't use multiple threads, it wont do so. x87 and SSE are just different ways of doing things. Physx on CPU is more than capable of pushing a multicore CPU to 100%. Just because something is compiled in SSE and not x87 does not mean it will suddenly be 300x faster and should you so wish you can compile CUDA in SSE (but this might cause calculation errors). But since SDK 3.0 it has compiled in SSE by default, and offered automatic multithreading support, removed lots of the old ageia code and was released 3 months ago. So should be ancient history by now :p
 
Waste precious GPU cycles for some more flying newspapers or waving clothing PhyX? I still want to understand why developers are using such a proprietary system when CPU's are more than capable of handling the cheesy physics effects that we mostly see in just about everything. We have processors that usually have a LOT of idle or near idle cores just asking for something to do, and yet we still go ahead wasting GPU cycles for PhyX effects that are very seldom impressive.

So long as those pricks don't try that same stunt like with the last Batman game, i'll be happy to buy this as soon as it goes on sale on Steam.

nvidia drivers allow you to choose your CPU as the primary physx processor o_O
 
I hate to say it but... I quit buying AMD GPUs because of a few things that bothered me....

Nvidia spends money to develop games, so they may get to provide code with features specific to their hardware. Their drivers are usually ready out of the box because they pay for the privilege and have access to early code. AMD refuses to do this most the time but once in awhile - like when they had the first DX11 GPU and invested in Dirt2 - so they are just hurting themselves.

I decided to stick with Nvidia because I feel they are contributing much more to PC gaming by doing this I got sick of waiting 2-3 driver releases for AMD to fix issues in new games. I want to buy a game day one and I want to enjoy it from day one. If that means I buy Nvidia from now on... then thats my choice. No one is making you guys buy AMD but realize you are sacrificing all of this when you make that decision.
 
OpenCL has nothing to do with game physics.

Thats actually quite wrong. You can do all your physics in OpenCL.
But one has to ask, if nVidia's going to do your physics for you, why would you dedicate man hours to doing physics.

Same goes for 3D. In fact I think we should be thanking nVidia, NOT Rocksteady for bringing goodies to the PC :(
 
Um, I really don't see what all the fuss is about because this new version of Batman has the exact same features as the other Batman game they did. Both 3DVision and PhysX are not new to Batman at all. I bet they are using the exact same game/graphics engine as Asylum with a few tweaks.

def. this
 
I sure hope this is decent. Not seen a decent game recently.

After the last Batman game, and seeing the 12 minute footage, should be a cracking game.

Although Playing the console version over the PC version, there wasn't that much difference, yeah there was some graphical eye candy, and the batarangs actually clattered off stuff, other than that there wasn't much difference.
 
Although Playing the console version over the PC version, there wasn't that much difference, yeah there was some graphical eye candy, and the batarangs actually clattered off stuff, other than that there wasn't much difference.

Play it in 3D Surround with PhysX, there's you're difference.
 
Is this game going to be using Windows Live like the first one? I sure hope not.
 
I haven't seen Windows Live used in any recent games lately. I sure hope Windows Live is dead.
 
Didn't they say that it was?

Just did some hunting on Google and FUCK they did. Well sort of, they released the box art with the GfWL logo on it. So they didn't even come out and say they're using it they tried to be sneaky about it.
 
Don't know what all the hate with GFWL is about, it never have me any problems in Batman AA. But isn't GFWL going away and tuning into Xbox something or another?
 
Don't know what all the hate with GFWL is about, it never have me any problems in Batman AA. But isn't GFWL going away and tuning into Xbox something or another?

My problem with GFWL specifically with Batman AA: I can't transfer my save files between installs so I have to restart the entire damn game if I don't beat it in one Windows installation and considering I like to take my time with that game and take weeks or even months beating it that hasn't happened yet.
 
Just did some hunting on Google and FUCK they did. Well sort of, they released the box art with the GfWL logo on it. So they didn't even come out and say they're using it they tried to be sneaky about it.

After working out that you just had to go get the seperate client and install it in order to get GfWL to work with steam games, it's wasn't game breaking. Then again it does add exactly nothing to the gameplay experience, and is a large pain in the ass being included ontop of another DRM service. If only they added cloud saves or something worthwhile, then I would have much less issue.

But isn't GFWL going away and tuning into Xbox something or another?

Yes, something like that. Instead of GFWL the site has become part of xbox.com where you can find the games in a sub section... Really microsoft pushing PC gaming to the fore...:D (but before mobile)
 
Thats something that annoys me. As a company they do seem to do the bare minimum, which is horrible for competition/new technologies. It's not like they don't have their own physics technology (bullet), but they just don't seem too bothered with offering competiton, as much as not using the "other team"s stuff (like when those people made physx (CUDA) work on radeons but AMD wouldn't support them, at all even though they had permission from nvidia to go ahead the project stalled). I'm hoping physx/GPGPU gets integrated into DX12. Physics in the majority of games is still horribly primitive, and it's not going anywhere without some kind of competition or joint work between the major players. Havok is very repetitive and "smoke and mirrors"ish. Bullet isn't used by anything, nor is openCL (nor do I trust the trademark holders with their corrupt buisness practices) so that leaves physx as the only matured tech that seems actively used/promoted.

No one made physx run on Radeon. That was a prank that a lot of people fell for because they didn't do even the most basic amount of research.
 
I think the best chance for vendor neutral GPU accelerated physics on the PC would be if Microsoft pushed DirectCompute, or a similar derivative, in the next Xbox. This would mean that all titles choosing to use GPU accelerated physics must use a physics engine that supports DirectCompute. Since the game will need to be on the PC as well, making sure that same engine is also compatible with DirectCompute would the logical step.

Also creating a stronger brand link with DirectCompute and DirectX would also encourage more physics engines to support it due to marketing reasons.

True but then that means they can't do any physics on PS3, Android, or iOS. Those last two are growth markets. If I were a Dev I'd be writing my physics code to be as crossplatform as possible.
 
My problem with GFWL specifically with Batman AA: I can't transfer my save files between installs so I have to restart the entire damn game if I don't beat it in one Windows installation and considering I like to take my time with that game and take weeks or even months beating it that hasn't happened yet.

Yeah, I was happy with GFWL up until that point.
 
My problem with GFWL specifically with Batman AA: I can't transfer my save files between installs so I have to restart the entire damn game if I don't beat it in one Windows installation and considering I like to take my time with that game and take weeks or even months beating it that hasn't happened yet.
Um, yes, you can. I have reinstalled Batman AA on Steam and loaded my old saves and it worked.

The trick?

You see, in the My Documents or My Games folder or wherever the files are put, it makes a directory named with seemingly random characters. You may have seen this. All you do is let the game create the new directory (it will not be named the same as your previous saves) and you copy your save files INTO the directory that the game creates.

Voila. It worked for me.
 
Fixed that for you for those who don't speak shill.

Nice troll attempt, but there's a huge difference between "sabotaging" (actively making it worse) on competitors products and improving the experience (BEYOND WHAT IT WOULDVE BEEN IF THEY NEVER GOT INVOLVED) for their own users.

It sounds like you're jealous and would rather see a console port for everyone than a PC differentiated game for some people (I.e. the people who busted their asses and invested to make it happen).
 
GFWL should have a way to easily import save games. And they need to remove the 15 time installation limit. I bought the game, if I want to reinstall Windows 22 times this year and reinstall Batman AA 22 times... I should be free to.
 
Um, yes, you can. I have reinstalled Batman AA on Steam and loaded my old saves and it worked.

The trick?

You see, in the My Documents or My Games folder or wherever the files are put, it makes a directory named with seemingly random characters. You may have seen this. All you do is let the game create the new directory (it will not be named the same as your previous saves) and you copy your save files INTO the directory that the game creates.

Voila. It worked for me.

Some games require u to backup the save game AND also the live files for it. Otherwise it tells you the save is corrupt even if you did what you did. This happened to me with Red Faction Guerilla and Batman AA.
 
Some games require u to backup the save game AND also the live files for it. Otherwise it tells you the save is corrupt even if you did what you did. This happened to me with Red Faction Guerilla and Batman AA.
I only copied over what was under the SaveData director; I did not backup any of the Live files.

/shrug
 
Are they obligated? No. Is it still a dick move to put a vendor lock in a game? Very much so. They didn't have to lock it specifically to their cards to make it work, instead they wanted to be dicks about it and pull a "screw the consumer" move instead of actually I don't know doing something that would give them GOOD PR.

God so much misinformation. AMD drivers didn't support AA on surfaces using the particular format the development used for motion blur effects. The necessary driver support came months later after the game shipped. If they didn't lock it out, THEIR ADDITION would've caused corruption and increased user support issues for their partner, the developer, and obviously that's not good. The motivations were not terrible as you say. That said, it would be fair to argue that they should've left it in and let users hound AMD into fixing it.
 
Back
Top