Mobius Strip Traffic Light

Because it is twisted....

I think.

(not sure why they named it that, it isn't twisted back on itself in a continuous loop or anything...)
 
Still has numbers for the traffic like the last one posted on here which means it's a bad idea. A countdown means people will try and go before the light is actually green. It happens all the time where people try and gauge when a light will turn green and start driving early. This will just make it worse.
 
People are already fucking retarded when it comes to traffic lights already, from drivers not caring what color they are to pedestrians just walking out into intersections without caring what color they are.
 
looks cool but unless that shit is going to save a city money in the long run, cities should not be tempted to spend money they probably don't have.
 
I can't imagine how expensive this would be.
 
I can't imagine how expensive this would be.

Would it be that expensive? It doesn't need the twist and all that. I like the idea of using one pole for everything. A cheap variant would be to use existing traffic lights, with the street lamp and crosswalk signals attached.

But yeah, a complete replacement would be expensive. :eek:
 
don't sweat it, your insurance will cover it if you run one over...:D

0.jpg


Still it's not any better than what we have. And the cost saving benefit doesn't make sense. Just stick a street light on our existing traffic lamps. The count down idea is stupid. Also, I was looking at the comments on that site... lol @ the guys saying it won't work for the colour blind. You can't get a drivers license in MA if you can't tell red yellow and green apart..
 
looks cool but unless that shit is going to save a city money in the long run, cities should not be tempted to spend money they probably don't have.

i assume thats the point, as the energy for LEDs instead of the presumably incandescent bulbs currently in use, times probably billions of lights across the country would be a huge energy savings.
 
These weird designs you see are not meant as actual products. They are made as projects for portfolios and assignments by design students.
 
Another note: What of color blind people?

Yeah, that was my first thought. I had a supervisor who was red/green colorblind and had to use placement to judge what color was lit. He hated traveling into the mid-west where the lights are sideways. He had to call in advance to check which side was what. They thought he was crazy but its a real potential problem.
 
yeah def not a mobius strip. If it looped back onto itself then maybe. They are better looking imo than the ones we usually see as far as the lights go.
 
Very awesome idea... too bad something that looks that fancy will never be bought with tax payer money since it will cost too much (or just be way overpriced)
 
Over here where I live, they've already started to add an additional 3 digit LED display to show the remaining seconds

So I kind of like this idea, its simple, incorporates the countdown into the color light itself. Might be cheaper than having several additional LED counters
 
1) no positional data = fail. it's not just a problem for colorblinds, it is a serious issue in certain lighting conditions for all of us.
2) countdown means taking your eyes of the road for long periods of time = fail. in normal lights you can just use peripheral vision to see any change. big countdown clock means constant changes.
3) no concession for multiple lights = fail. in normal lights it's easy to just put a few together and use lighted arrows above to indicate direction. how will it work here?
4) street light nearly flush with pedestrian light = fail. at night nobody will ever see the actual color because of glare.
5) street light has unprotected angled spill = MAJOR fail. at night the glare will absolutely demolish the ability to see anything on your front-right (or left).
6) lights usually come in pairs, one before and one in the intersection. so you need another design, higher and without the pedestrian and street light = fail.
 
I doubt this would get adopted in any meaningful way, but I know of at least a couple of downtown modernization projects locally where an original look could be used. One or two specific intersections in a high pedestrian area with slow traffic.

It is pretty cool, but what does it have to do with a Mobius Strip?
The Mobius Strip would just be the inspiration for the concept, not the actual implementation.

1) no positional data = fail. it's not just a problem for colorblinds, it is a serious issue in certain lighting conditions for all of us.
2) countdown means taking your eyes of the road for long periods of time = fail. in normal lights you can just use peripheral vision to see any change. big countdown clock means constant changes.
3) no concession for multiple lights = fail. in normal lights it's easy to just put a few together and use lighted arrows above to indicate direction. how will it work here?
4) street light nearly flush with pedestrian light = fail. at night nobody will ever see the actual color because of glare.
5) street light has unprotected angled spill = MAJOR fail. at night the glare will absolutely demolish the ability to see anything on your front-right (or left).
6) lights usually come in pairs, one before and one in the intersection. so you need another design, higher and without the pedestrian and street light = fail.
1) Note the size of the LED screen. It would be very easy to incoporate positional/size/pattern data into the display. In fact, I don't think anyone noticed that the pedestrian display is showing a different pattern for green.

2) How much time do you need to glance at a light and see how much time you have left? Countdown is pretty standard for pedestrian displays nowadays... As a driver, I find myself hunting for the pedestrian indicator as I approach an intersection. Much more dangerous.

3) Why do you need muliple lights when you have a whole display? :confused:

4) 5) I don't see the problem. The streetlight has been moved under the traffic light, so that ubiquitous nighttime glare you're concerned about wouldn't exist anymore. Think about how light reflects. At worst, the streetlight would reflect off the pedestrian light and into the ground (so walkers across the street are unaffected) and vehicle lights would reflect off the traffic indicator and into the sky.

6) You're free to photoshop another version with the streetlight and pedestrian light grayed out. This is not rocket surgery.
 
I like the design for the most part, it looks pretty good. The only real problems I have with it, as some others have mentioned, is no positional data. I am sure they could fix that, but the concept doesn't show it. The countdown I don't much care about as long as they only use the countdown for green and yellow and not for red. Also, I don't like the fact that they are using red and green for the pedestrian light, that makes it slightly more confusing. They use a different pattern, but why not just use a totally different color scheme or symbols instead like they currently do. A white stick figure would be better.
 
In the Mobius strip design, I noticed that in the rain, water will fall off the top of the light on the pedestrians walking below. The twist should be angled the other way to direct rain away from the pedestrians.
 
Or... we put in more roundabouts and make lights and stop signs effectively obsolete. Only places they'll be required are in high congestion areas and only during peak hours. Aside from that, let the roundabouts do their thing.
 
1) no positional data = fail. it's not just a problem for colorblinds, it is a serious issue in certain lighting conditions for all of us.
2) countdown means taking your eyes of the road for long periods of time = fail. in normal lights you can just use peripheral vision to see any change. big countdown clock means constant changes.
3) no concession for multiple lights = fail. in normal lights it's easy to just put a few together and use lighted arrows above to indicate direction. how will it work here?
4) street light nearly flush with pedestrian light = fail. at night nobody will ever see the actual color because of glare.
5) street light has unprotected angled spill = MAJOR fail. at night the glare will absolutely demolish the ability to see anything on your front-right (or left).
6) lights usually come in pairs, one before and one in the intersection. so you need another design, higher and without the pedestrian and street light = fail.

Talk about being hard to impress.:D
 
These weird designs you see are not meant as actual products. They are made as projects for portfolios and assignments by design students.

If I was digging through some kid's portfolio and came across something retarded like one of these traffic lights, I would hire someone else for the design work. I am with Impaler on this one.
 
In the Mobius strip design, I noticed that in the rain, water will fall off the top of the light on the pedestrians walking below. The twist should be angled the other way to direct rain away from the pedestrians.
This assumes pedestrians will be walking directly toward the post. For this to be useful as a traffic light, it would have to be positioned ahead of traffic (and to the left of a crosswalk). That does mean the streetlight doesn't illuminate the walk, though.
 
Also, I don't like the fact that they are using red and green for the pedestrian light, that makes it slightly more confusing. They use a different pattern, but why not just use a totally different color scheme or symbols instead like they currently do. A white stick figure would be better.
The colour shouldn't be that confusing as it would presumably be 'pointing' in the same direction as traffic. I would agree that a different symbol should be displayed for pedestrians, though. Again, LED screen--simple.
 
Would it be that expensive? It doesn't need the twist and all that. I like the idea of using one pole for everything. A cheap variant would be to use existing traffic lights, with the street lamp and crosswalk signals attached.

But yeah, a complete replacement would be expensive. :eek:
I've seen the price tags of the more standard lights that are in use. Yes, they are expensive. It depends on all the features it employs. Then the timer, sensors, and all the rest of the crap that goes with it.
This one might have the trade off of being pricier to buy, but maintenance may be cheaper in the long run. Hard to say.

Most places are more in favor of round a bouts instead of lights if they can get away with it.
 
Man these really do look cool... I wonder if you can send something like this into your county office for consideration? Anyone know?
 
The Mobius Strip would just be the inspiration for the concept, not the actual implementation.

Any folded paper could have been the inspiration. The whole point of a Mobius strip is that it folds back on itself in a constant loop. Seems more like they just wanted geek cred from the reference.
 
These do look cool but will this stuff blow the minds of old people that have a hard enough time driving now :p
 
I remember a long time ago, we wanted a traffic light put in on a corner, so we asked the town office if they could do it. They did a survey and checked it out, and said the cost of putting in a traffic light was about 1 million dollars. That's construction and the lights for all the directions, too.

That was almost 20 years ago, and this is a modern design. I'd hate to ask them the cost for this! (we still don't have a traffic light there)
 
1. Glare
2. Wont' melt snow and ice, maybe hard to see in rain
3. Colorblind drivers will have a serious problem unless it also includes a letter for each color or some such

I like everything on one pole, but there are serious logistical problems, as other have pointed out as well. Maybe someone will be inspired by this to create something more practical.
 
Still it's not any better than what we have. And the cost saving benefit doesn't make sense. Just stick a street light on our existing traffic lamps. The count down idea is stupid. Also, I was looking at the comments on that site... lol @ the guys saying it won't work for the colour blind. You can't get a drivers license in MA if you can't tell red yellow and green apart..

Lucky you, yes I can see why MA has this law, it's similar in Romania. However there are many poignant misconceptions about what colour "blind" people see. One is that they see no colour at all, when partial colour "blindness" is more common, most common is red-green. You may have heard that the red-green type is quite common but most of them do not have blindness but weakness to a colour, most common is green-weakness, known as Deutoranomaly. These people can make all the basic colour distinctions and can thus make clear distinctions between colours like red, yellow, green and blue, they thus can easily discern traffic lights and tell the green light apart from a police light.
But under the current Romania legislation, this blogger, who is green-weak was declared "unfit to drive" by their Opthamologists.
It's important to understand that green-weak people generally do well enough in tasks requiring normal colour vision that they are not aware of their anomaly until they find out in a colour vision test.
 
Back
Top