Infinity Ward Founders Suing Activision

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The two Call of Duty developers that were unceremoniously fired earlier this week have filed a lawsuit against Activision over unpaid royalties. Considering how much money Modern Warfare 2 has made, you would think a settlement would require a substantial amount of money. Thanks to [H] forum member Fail for the link.

"Activision has refused to honor the terms of its agreements and is intentionally flouting the fundamental public policy of this State (California) that employers must pay their employees what they have rightfully earned," said the pair's attorney, Robert Schwartz, of law firm O'Melveny & Myers. "Instead of thanking, lauding, or just plain paying Jason and Vince for giving Activision the most successful entertainment product ever offered to the public, last month Activision hired lawyers to conduct a pretextual 'investigation' into unstated and unsubstantiated charges of 'insubordination' and 'breach of fiduciary duty,' which then became the grounds for their termination on Monday, March 1st."
 
They are also tryiing to not only sue for their royalties, but also suing to get full ownership of the CoD franchise, so that they won't have to whore it out to Treyarch, and that other new division at Activision Blizzard that was recently created to make an action/adventure spinoff of CoD

it looks like Activision wants to saturate the market with CoD titles just like they did with Guitar Hero which hasn't sold well at all since World Tour

the IW founders were also told they had to get started on MW3 and release it in 2010, which they didn't want to do, they wanted to make a completely new IP and do something other than Call of Duty and I believe that it has been reported that in their contract, that they could pursue a new IP, but Activision doesn't want them to because of Kotick's pea brain wanting to rape franchises to death instead of allowing innovation which is RISKY RISKY RISKY, in his demented mind.

Bobby Kotick is bad for the gaming industry
 
I really have bad feelings about Activision and COD franchaise under their 'vision'. I honestly can't consider COD:WAW as true to the spirit of the franchaise at all, and I believe this is what will befall all subsequent titles without Infinity Ward having free rein on the product.

Maybe this is an end to an era...
 
Sounds like Activision is taking a page from the 'Hollywood' accounting handbook.

What better way to make 110 million vs a 100 million than to bite the hand the fed you?

Maybe Activision execs will go play a real life game of pitfall in the Florida everglades.
 
Not paying their royalties...WRONG
Not allowing them to explore a new IP...WRONG

BUT..
but Activision doesn't want them to because of Kotick's pea brain wanting to rape franchises to death instead of allowing innovation which is RISKY RISKY RISKY, in his demented mind.

You can't call a CEO who's sole job is to maximize value to his shareholders demented for going with something that is a sure fire money maker and not taking risks. Especially in this economy, this is business 101 and it is amazing that so many people on here do not understand it.
 
Maybe if people would stick to voting with their wallet, we wouldn't see companies trying to milk the market dry with these rehashed games all the time. I don't know about you guys, but these days I'm more attracted to a game that brings or does something new.

I'm all for a new IP and I would love to see the cash cow which CoD has become, be ripped away from the people most likely to abuse it.
 
I've heard of publishers treating developers poorly, but this looks really bad. Truth is a three-edged sword, though. I look forward to Activision's boilerplate response (and hopefully some better evidence aired out in court. :)
 
Activision should just crash and burn. Seriously, bring out some great stuff, then flood the market with it to the point where no one cares anymore.
 
Not paying their royalties...WRONG
Not allowing them to explore a new IP...WRONG

BUT..


You can't call a CEO who's sole job is to maximize value to his shareholders demented for going with something that is a sure fire money maker and not taking risks. Especially in this economy, this is business 101 and it is amazing that so many people on here do not understand it.

Exactly my thoughts. Consumers tend to forget about the big picture that even allows them to have games to play.
 
And this is why big labels/publishing companies have a bad rep. Because they fuck with shit.

Now, to try and explain how kids grew up to be publishers... Were they the bullies on the playground, or the weaklings back to get revenge now?
 
They should start a new company so we don't have to buy from Activision anymore.
 
They are also tryiing to not only sue for their royalties, but also suing to get full ownership of the CoD franchise, so that they won't have to whore it out to Treyarch, and that other new division at Activision Blizzard that was recently created to make an action/adventure spinoff of CoD

it looks like Activision wants to saturate the market with CoD titles just like they did with Guitar Hero which hasn't sold well at all since World Tour

the IW founders were also told they had to get started on MW3 and release it in 2010, which they didn't want to do, they wanted to make a completely new IP and do something other than Call of Duty and I believe that it has been reported that in their contract, that they could pursue a new IP, but Activision doesn't want them to because of Kotick's pea brain wanting to rape franchises to death instead of allowing innovation which is RISKY RISKY RISKY, in his demented mind.

Bobby Kotick is bad for the gaming industry

That gives more credence to my theory about the lack of dedicated servers for MW2 and how they are actually blocked in the code. If activision keeps us dependent on matchmaking for online play then once they come out with MW3 they can just drop support and force you to purchase MW3 to continue playing online.
 
And this is why big labels/publishing companies have a bad rep. Because they fuck with shit.

Now, to try and explain how kids grew up to be publishers... Were they the bullies on the playground, or the weaklings back to get revenge now?

They were the rich kids who paid bullies to pick on the weak kids.
 
Not paying their royalties...WRONG
Not allowing them to explore a new IP...WRONG

BUT..


You can't call a CEO who's sole job is to maximize value to his shareholders demented for going with something that is a sure fire money maker and not taking risks. Especially in this economy, this is business 101 and it is amazing that so many people on here do not understand it.

While true that taking risks is a bad idea in this economy, so is trying to cling onto a franchise that's no longer catching the interest of your customer base (Guitar Hero).

My store still has most of the original shipment of Band Hero we got in awhile back, which was a pretty hefty order, and normally anything Guitar Hero or Rock Band related where I work used to fly off the shelf. That in itself told me that people are tired of the shit with that whole series and getup.
 
Exactly my thoughts. Consumers tend to forget about the big picture that even allows them to have games to play.

Valve doesn't have a CEO! It makes good games! They take their time to make great games, and that's what they iterate to their customers thoroughly in case they're behind schedule.

Of course they don't have a CEO that only thinks about money!

Wait a sec....
 
Valve doesn't have a CEO! It makes good games! They take their time to make great games, and that's what they iterate to their customers thoroughly in case they're behind schedule.

Of course they don't have a CEO that only thinks about money!

Wait a sec....

What drugs are you on? I never said anything about a CEO. And valve has it's own issues most of which don't apply to me. Lastly have u ever heard of Gabe Newell? He's only the CEO OF VALVE SOFTWARE. So don't mind me if I ignore you from now on.
 
While true that taking risks is a bad idea in this economy, so is trying to cling onto a franchise that's no longer catching the interest of your customer base (Guitar Hero).

My store still has most of the original shipment of Band Hero we got in awhile back, which was a pretty hefty order, and normally anything Guitar Hero or Rock Band related where I work used to fly off the shelf. That in itself told me that people are tired of the shit with that whole series and getup.

Exactly. Nobody wants to play the same game over and over and over again. Adding drums and singing to guitar hero made it different enough that people wanted the new version. when you then release 50 versions after that which are just song packs nobody is going to want to purchase all of them. Even if it is a different series, nobody wants a dozen games where you play music.

For any other game it is the same. few people are going to want to play sequals if they are exactly like the first one. They want change, they want something new mixed in with what they know.
 
For any other game it is the same. few people are going to want to play sequals if they are exactly like the first one. They want change, they want something new mixed in with what they know.

Seems to work for Halo lol.

Halo 2 is the same as Halo 3 is the same as Halo: ODST which will undoubtedly be the same as Halo: Reacharound
 
Wow, after reading the body of the complaint, it becomes extremely clear.

Activision has big plans ($$$) for the COD brand/franchise. However in order to get Infinity Ward to make MW2 they had to contractually agree to give them creative control of the franchise.

This move would cost Activision enormous amounts of potential revenue (ie. Billions!) so this process (investigation, plus firing) was started to get creative control back.

Essentially this lawsuit will be settled for large sums of money (large enough that the studio heads will simply cut their losses, and not bother with the long and painful struggle), which will still be extremely profitable from Activision's point of view. Even if each of them were paid 100million cash, if it gets them to settle and waive previous contractual agreements, it net works out for Activision.

Shrewd business indeed. Truly an epic drama.
 
even if the IW guys let Activision have the property back, that doesn't neccessarily mean that the new CoD games will sell as well without Infinity Ward behind the franchise.

Take MW2 for instance, it sold only 170K copies on the PC when it launched for the month of November 2009. Yes it sold like crazy than consoles, but they are our much inferior, lesser informed brethen who play with thumbsticks instead of mouse and keyboard, truly savages, they are!

But anyway I was being sarcastic mostly, my point being was CoD 4 sold just under 3 million copies in it's lifetime on PC, yet MW2 only sold 170k but was pirated over 4 million times according to some statistics that have been posted here on the forums.

I'm hoping the 2 IW guys either get paid an enormous sum and win the IP rights, or, refuse to settle, win money and the IP rights, or refuse to settle, but win their royalties + the IP rights.

I hope they go on to form a new studio, take what talent they can from IW and start up on that new IP they wanted to develop, I bet it would be amazing, because these guys DO know how to make good games if they are left the hell alone.
 
Not paying their royalties...WRONG
Not allowing them to explore a new IP...WRONG

BUT..


You can't call a CEO who's sole job is to maximize value to his shareholders demented for going with something that is a sure fire money maker and not taking risks. Especially in this economy, this is business 101 and it is amazing that so many people on here do not understand it.

Right, because "it's a business" justifies every choice a CEO makes even if it's morally wrong.

Besides your point is fruitless with this example. Certainly doesn't look like Activision is going to suffer now or in the near future with WoW expansion and Starcraft 2 being released this year. Your defense is hogwash within this specific example, and irks me when broadened to a wider scope because "it's a business" does not justify immoral decisions.
 
Right, because "it's a business" justifies every choice a CEO makes even if it's morally wrong.

Besides your point is fruitless with this example. Certainly doesn't look like Activision is going to suffer now or in the near future with WoW expansion and Starcraft 2 being released this year. Your defense is hogwash within this specific example, and irks me when broadened to a wider scope because "it's a business" does not justify immoral decisions.

Yea you need to learn how to research a company's actual financial's before you make wrong statements like that. I don''t think you have a single clue as to the current state of Activision, unless you decide to actually visit their investor's section after reading my response.
 
Seems to work for Halo lol.

Halo 2 is the same as Halo 3 is the same as Halo: ODST which will undoubtedly be the same as Halo: Reacharound

I'm not a fan of Halo but you cant really accuse that series of rushing out identical sequels like some others do
 
I was also wondering what this news would do to the stock price and its been pretty steady all day. Right now its at $11 even with a .27% increase.
 
And this is why big labels/publishing companies have a bad rep. Because they fuck with shit.

Now, to try and explain how kids grew up to be publishers... Were they the bullies on the playground, or the weaklings back to get revenge now?

I think I see it a little differently. The label/publishing world is taking a kick in the nuts since developers have and are figuring out that they go it alone without them. It may take a little longer, but the effects reverberate deeply.
 
I think I see it a little differently. The label/publishing world is taking a kick in the nuts since developers have and are figuring out that they go it alone without them. It may take a little longer, but the effects reverberate deeply.

Reminds me of the trend in the music industry. Artists are starting to learn how to use their money better and forming their own record labels and/or distribution channels and cutting out the big fat RIAA and other major labels, They are seeing success without needing such a huge middleman to get their IP out.
 
For any SOTS players out there - I think the best analogy is that bobby likes to over-harvest a bit too much.
 
You can't call a CEO who's sole job is to maximize value to his shareholders demented for going with something that is a sure fire money maker and not taking risks. Especially in this economy, this is business 101 and it is amazing that so many people on here do not understand it.

You are correct on most points in general but wrong in the specifics.

It is the job of the CEO to maximize profits. However, the road to maximizing profits can be very different. In this case, he is doing his damnedest to maximize profits in the very short term without looking to the future. I don't know about the specifics but if it is true that he was demanding another installment of the game a year later, it will be nothing but a rehash of the previous game. There might be some graphical improvements but it's likely anything else will really change. If anything truly new is added, it's likely to be a buggy piece of shit. With the exception of your yearly sports titles (which are nothing but rehashes of the previous game or three) you do not see all new games in a franchise every year. From my experience, it's usually about three years between most games in a franchise and there's good reason for this if they want to do a proper job with the game.

Additionally, refusing to allow any new IP into the game is going to hurt. New IP is another franchise which could be started which can lead to further large profits down the road. Ignoring this for the quick buck right now has nothing to do with maximizing profits. It's quite the opposite since the current cash cow will decline in popularity and decrease profits. A look at history will show you this. If this wasn't true, we'd have Pitfall 257 by now. It has been shown that rehashing the same game over and over leads to diminishing returns. Reasonable time between games, generally 2-3 years, will keep the franchise fresh and allow for new ideas to be put into the games. This leads into my next point.

Now let's talk about risk. Truly maximizing profits requires a long term look into the future. Even when kept "fresh", a franchise will eventually lose appeal due to many reasons such as changing attitudes of gamers, new ideas and new games released by other companies and in some cases an inability to properly freshen up an old franchise or style of play. In order to keep profits flowing, you need new IP and this is where the risk comes into play. Without this risk, there is not going to be reward. The comment about avoiding risk due to a current recession is about as short sighted as you can get. The recession will not last forever. Also, it's best to have new ideas being created the whole time. Resting on your laurels will only insure that you will have nothing new to present to people when another company or companies will have something new. They didn't play it safe and they are the ones who will reap the benefits.

Stagnating in order to maximize short term profits will only hurt long term profits. That is business 101.

 
@SmokeRngs: Exactly!

You can't call a CEO who's sole job is to maximize value to his shareholders demented for going with something that is a sure fire money maker and not taking risks. Especially in this economy, this is business 101 and it is amazing that so many people on here do not understand it.

Well, take a look at EA, for example. They used to be a whole lot like Activision is now. They continually rehashed old material (Need for Speed, Madden... well, they still do that) and shunned creativity as it seemed too risky. Rehashing old material got them billions of dollars, but they were smart enough to know when to go out and expand. When they had the money to take risks on new IPs, they went out and did so, with mixed results. However, the consumer was the one that benefitted the most, and there continues to be a lot of goodwill towards EA. Activision has the money to take risks and expand... yet they prefer to only pick titles that they could drive into the ground over the next decade.

Gamers wouldn't have had Mirror's Edge, Dead Space, Army of Two, Crysis, Skate, Dragon Age, Saboteur, etc. etc. etc. if all EA did was endlessly released new versions of Madden (and every other sports game), the Sims, and Need For Speed year after year after year like Activision is so keen on doing.
 
The fact that they didn't want to make MW2 explains a lot about the game. Most of the single player campaign just seemed like a giant middle finger towards Activision.
 
@SmokeRngs: Exactly!



Well, take a look at EA, for example. They used to be a whole lot like Activision is now. They continually rehashed old material (Need for Speed, Madden... well, they still do that) and shunned creativity as it seemed too risky. Rehashing old material got them billions of dollars, but they were smart enough to know when to go out and expand. When they had the money to take risks on new IPs, they went out and did so, with mixed results. However, the consumer was the one that benefitted the most, and there continues to be a lot of goodwill towards EA. Activision has the money to take risks and expand... yet they prefer to only pick titles that they could drive into the ground over the next decade.

Gamers wouldn't have had Mirror's Edge, Dead Space, Army of Two, Crysis, Skate, Dragon Age, Saboteur, etc. etc. etc. if all EA did was endlessly released new versions of Madden (and every other sports game), the Sims, and Need For Speed year after year after year like Activision is so keen on doing

Mass Effect 2 and Dragon Age remain as two of my (modern) favorites of all time. And no, that was not an imitation of Kayne West. :p

Do make a good point to take a risk of producing an original/creative title.
 
Wish I could send the EU on Activision. Vivendi's still mostly French right? Hmm
 
Instead of firing them for insubordination, they should've fired them for allowing IWNet to actually be made and implemented.

What a clown decision. MW2 is a huge hit because of modern warfare 1 and it's mod community. The sales reflect the existing customer base, and the new improved gameplay the mod community brought to the game.
 
ummm IW would have not made IWnet of their own volition, they made it under pressure from Activision
 
Back
Top