Google Buys Ad To Explain Offensive Image

I judge a man by his character, how he acts is far more important than the color of his skin.

My step-father was a black man whom was a far better man than my real father, a white.

He like Bill Cosby did not care for those who played the race card or did not pull their weight.

I wonder how Bill Cosby would have reacted to someone portraying his wife as an ape. . . .
 
Yup, because to this day, people that were attacked and dominated by folks from Rome and points west of there just LOVE them . . you know, like the people in the Middle East who were massacred in huge numbers at the best of the Vatican. They just LOVE their oppressors now.

Your ignorance of history is astounding (as is your assumption that because I am able to logically evaluate the situation, I must be black) . . . little hint for you, I'm not black, not related to any black people, I just know history.
Your use of the crusades as a massacre just shows your complete ignorance of history. If not your hippocressy. Any person who can actually reason and show some real sign of intelligence will ask: What were the Muslims doing in the Holy Land on the first place when Islamism originated in Mecca and Medina? And after some research would realize that Islamism was originally propagated through genocide. Such it is that the verse of the Sword in the Qran nullifies the oldest verses of peacefulness, coexistence and tolerance which originally started Islamism when Mohamed was powerless in Mecca.
Why don't you say that to the Spanish, African,Eastern Europeans and Jews that were massacred in the name of Islam?
Why don't you mention the personal beheadings performed by Mohamed to 600-900 Jews in Medina? Oh yes, you know much history.
And you want me to maintain a reasonable discussion with you?
I think I'll just buy a parrot and have fin with it.
 

So quick, how many Jews and Muslims did the Crusaders leave alive when they captured Jerusalem following the First Crusade in 1099 (approximately)? I'll give you a hint, it wasn't very many. Now, how many Christians were left alive and allowed to leave after Jerusalem was recaptured by Salladin in 1187? I'll give you another hint, it was a hell of a lot more than were left alive in the city in 1099.

While we're at it, how many Jews, protestants and pagans did Christians torture and kill as part of the Inquisition?

Also, can you please give us in historic detail an explanation of how the Israelites came into position of Jerusalem and what happened to the previous occupants of the area now known as Israel in around 1,400 BC? How many Canaanites (and other peoples) were massacred to that a group claiming to be Gods chosen people could have that land?

If you want to discuss history, lets do it.

But first, learn how to spell hypocrisy.
 
Mmmmhmmm. . .

You continue on in your little bubble where comparing black people to apes isn't racist. I'll continue living in reality.

If someone says "Michelle Obama looks like an ape." that is not necessarily racist. If someone says "Black people look like apes." that IS necessarily racist.

Are you unable to understand the difference, or just unwilling?
 
If someone says "Michelle Obama looks like an ape." that is not necessarily racist. If someone says "Black people look like apes." that IS necessarily racist.

Are you unable to understand the difference, or just unwilling?

It doesn't quite work that way. If there were not centuries of racist bullshit portraying black people as apes and such, you might have a point, but considering that there is such a history, portraying a black person as an is racist and will continue to be interpreted as such.
 
Ekierce; Actually, it does work that way. The history you refer to is not shared by all humans globally. As well, you would further have to define exactly what pigment a person's skin would need to be in order for such a classification to be considered racist.

In reality, what matters is the intent behind the comparison. If I compare Michelle Obama to a lizard, but do it because I hate black people, it's racist even if history hasn't established it as such. How do such things become established in the first place? Unless you can place a malicious will; An intent to harm Michelle Obama on the basis of race, calling it racist is just painting it with your own feelings.
 
Ekierce; Actually, it does work that way. The history you refer to is not shared by all humans globally. As well, you would further have to define exactly what pigment a person's skin would need to be in order for such a classification to be considered racist.

In reality, what matters is the intent behind the comparison. If I compare Michelle Obama to a lizard, but do it because I hate black people, it's racist even if history hasn't established it as such. How do such things become established in the first place? Unless you can place a malicious will; An intent to harm Michelle Obama on the basis of race, calling it racist is just painting it with your own feelings.

As I said, if you honestly feel that portraying a black person as a chimp is not racist, feel free to approach random black people and ask them if you can portray them, their wife, mother or daughter as a chimp.

Let me know the results.
 
As I said, if you honestly feel that portraying a black person as a chimp is not racist, feel free to approach random black people and ask them if you can portray them, their wife, mother or daughter as a chimp.

Let me know the results.

Start calling random white people chimps and get back to me.

I have been called a cracker, I just laughed at the person doing so since it reveals far more about them than me.
 
As I said, if you honestly feel that portraying a black person as a chimp is not racist, feel free to approach random black people and ask them if you can portray them, their wife, mother or daughter as a chimp.

Let me know the results.

I would like to clarify what a given result will mean. Here are three questions:

1)If I show an image of a black man his portrait suprimposed over that of a chimp and he gets angry, what does that mean to the discussion at hand?

2)If I do the same thing as in #1 but he does not get angry, what does that mean?

3)What does it mean if I perform the experiment on a white person, using their image, and the individual in question gets angry?

Based on how you've set this up, I would assume the answer to #1 would be "That means such images are racist." The answer to #2 must be the opposite of #1 as the reaction is opposite, and the answers to #1 and #3 must be the same(except that in #3, it would be calling white people apes which would be racist).

Certainly you intended to set the experiment up to achieve only one result, and would throw out any others. Any such experiment is not only not worth being performed, but the results are not worth being examined.

All of the flaws in your argument(every one that I've noticed, anyway) stem from the fact that you are attempting to define an act as racist without knowing the motivation behind it. It seems that you have confused the terms "racist" and "offensive" as well. Defining racism from the wrong "end" brings up issues such as; just who can I, and can I not, turn into an ape? Can I do it to The Rock? Just what pigment must a persons' skin contain, and within what parameters must their facial structure fall, in order to be protected from being portrayed as an ape?

Of course, unless you turn your position around entirely I'm forced to believe all kinds of ridiculous things about your position. For example, you must believe Planet of the Apes is a racist film.
 
I love how this topic has become a conversation about racism. The decision to remove the image would have been valid even if it was comparing Adolf Hitler to a banana.
 
HOCP4ME; I won't pretend to understand how Google ranks pages, but if images unrelated to searches keep appearing at the top of results, that would indicate a problem with Google itself wouldn't it? Google's definition of relevance is one of popularity, which means that if the top image search for "Hitler" was a banana with a hitler stach commanding the third reich, it must have been a very popular HitlerBanana.
 
HOCP4ME; I won't pretend to understand how Google ranks pages, but if images unrelated to searches keep appearing at the top of results, that would indicate a problem with Google itself wouldn't it? Google's definition of relevance is one of popularity, which means that if the top image search for "Hitler" was a banana with a hitler stach commanding the third reich, it must have been a very popular HitlerBanana.

Yes, it is a problem with Google itself. And why shouldn't Google fix said problem? Ideally they would fix their algorithm so that unrelated results like this one don't appear on top, but of course even Google's best algorithm will fail every so often. Obviously they can't make a manual exception every time that happens; this one just got priority because it is offensive to some people as well as irrelevant.

I believe Yahoo, in it's early days, worked like this entirely. Human indexers surfed the web , cataloging and tagging pages as they went. Of course, this isn't practical anymore with the enormous size of the web.

I don't care how the algorithm works. The litmus test for a search algorithm is to ask the question, "is that what I was looking for?" If the answer is "no" for most people, the algorithm fails. A manual exception isn't expected, per se, but it doesn't hurt for Google to make one. As I said, this particular issue got priority because of the pic's offensive nature.
 
HOCP4ME; I understand your point and agree with it. The issue becomes; How do you test such an algorithm by such a test? Sure, you can run a single search, but I mean on a grand scale. How can you, sitting at your computer, know whether a given search I ran gave me the results I wanted unless I tell you?

What I meant was that if Google is aware of some way that their algorithm can be "gamed" to garner high-placing results, they should indeed route out the problem. If the image, on the other hand, is there due to normal behavior on the part of Google's algorithm(which works quite well the rest of the time very the very same reasons such an image may come to the top of the list in the first place), then it most certainly should not be removed and neither should concern be raised over the image's placement on Google's behalf.
 
The only way to prevent bombing would be to completely revise the way Google operates entirely. You're not talking about tweaking the algorithm here -- you're talking about a bottom-to-top restructuring of Google's method of determining relevance to key words.

Either you moderate search results or you completely re-architect Google. Neither is going to happen.
 
So quick, how many Jews and Muslims did the Crusaders leave alive when they captured Jerusalem following the First Crusade in 1099 (approximately)? I'll give you a hint, it wasn't very many. Now, how many Christians were left alive and allowed to leave after Jerusalem was recaptured by Salladin in 1187? I'll give you another hint, it was a hell of a lot more than were left alive in the city in 1099.

While we're at it, how many Jews, protestants and pagans did Christians torture and kill as part of the Inquisition?

Also, can you please give us in historic detail an explanation of how the Israelites came into position of Jerusalem and what happened to the previous occupants of the area now known as Israel in around 1,400 BC? How many Canaanites (and other peoples) were massacred to that a group claiming to be Gods chosen people could have that land?

If you want to discuss history, lets do it.

But first, learn how to spell hypocrisy.

Oh you mean the Christians that Salahadim didn't want to give peace to when the crusaders proposed it which was well according to the oldest verses of the Qran because also according to the newest verses of the Qran which nullify the older you also only give peace when you are less powerful? As a way to recover your strenght.
You are very selective on what you reply to, you know? You totally ignored that the Crusades besides being a quest for richness and a way for the Church to gain power was first and foremost a reaction to the "Jihad" of the Sword Islam perpetrated against Europe to propagate not their religion, but the Islam perpetrated for 400 years against Europe, while it Conquered from Serbia to North Africa to Spain. You also forgot to mention that once the Arabs were in Jerusalem they pretty much left the Jews and Christians alone(way before the Cursades), and that was until the Turkish fanatics came and slaughtered many of the non muslim people. My parrot can repeat the "history lessons" you go over and over again as they are propagated by the leftovers of the Communist academia teachings you seem so fond of. I also don't see you mentioning the massacre of Christians in Lebanon by Turkish Islamic Fundamentalists. Oh yeah, according to you the West is the bad guy and it must be destroyed. You neither question why is it that there are so many Muslims who descend from African Blacks. How curious? You selectively ignored that the Arabs started slaving Africans since the Ninth century way before Europe did and yet they exploit the flags of multiculturalism and freedom of cult while imposing themselves and conquering other countries,I wonder why? I know, you're a dogmatic oligophrenic bastard who has to live through his twisted dogma of multiculturalism even if it costs you your life and that of your own brethren. Because according to you, we: "The West" are the Bad guys.

According to you the slaughter of Jews was o.k. because their forefathers also did the same to the Canaanites a millennium and a half before. So you excuse genocide with more genocide? Because it's o.k to hate the Jewish but no the Islam. Oh really?!!!
And you complain about some idiot racist comparing the Black first lady to an Ape out of frustration because he wishes she were a slave? You know a lot more about hypocrisy than I do, that's for sure. How much does your hatred blinds you, traitor?
You made me remember a very wise quote:"Never argue with moron as he will bring you down to his level and beat you with experience". That is for you guys, don't waste your time with this irrational fanatic. As for you, feel free to request a ban of my account, I couldn't care less.

Signed, The guy who transcribed the letter from Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to the California Assembly regarding the regulation of power consumption of television sets. You can look it up in these forums as the letter goes for you too.
 
You continue on in your little bubble where comparing black people to apes isn't racist. I'll continue living in reality.

So you can reach into someones head and decide why they did something? As far as I know whoever made that image hasn't proclaimed their reasoning, maybe they had some alternative? Maybe they thought she would look good in Planet of the Apes? (Incidentally there were a lot of black people put in monkey costumes for that movie, I suppose that makes it racist).

That said, yes the image probably was made with racist intentions. Get over it and move on with your life.

ekierce, answer me this: Was the new Planet of the Apes movie racist? If not, why?
 
Last edited:
LMAO - You really know how to spin don't you. You're going to tie yoursel fin knots.

Your limited knowledge of history seems to be gleamed from quick Google searches in an attempt to prove your point.

Little hint, the reason Salladin denied the so-called "peace" that the Crusaders offered was because his people were being routinely attacked along their trade routes because the Crusaders were of the belief given to them by their Pope that "God Wills It."

If you were being honest, you'd address that issue first.

But I think honesty is a lost cause with you.


Oh you mean the Christians that Salahadim didn't want to give peace to when the crusaders proposed it which was well according to the oldest verses of the Qran because also according to the newest verses of the Qran which nullify the older you also only give peace when you are less powerful? As a way to recover your strenght.
You are very selective on what you reply to, you know? You totally ignored that the Crusades besides being a quest for richness and a way for the Church to gain power was first and foremost a reaction to the "Jihad" of the Sword Islam perpetrated against Europe to propagate not their religion, but the Islam perpetrated for 400 years against Europe, while it Conquered from Serbia to North Africa to Spain. You also forgot to mention that once the Arabs were in Jerusalem they pretty much left the Jews and Christians alone(way before the Cursades), and that was until the Turkish fanatics came and slaughtered many of the non muslim people. My parrot can repeat the "history lessons" you go over and over again as they are propagated by the leftovers of the Communist academia teachings you seem so fond of. I also don't see you mentioning the massacre of Christians in Lebanon by Turkish Islamic Fundamentalists. Oh yeah, according to you the West is the bad guy and it must be destroyed. You neither question why is it that there are so many Muslims who descend from African Blacks. How curious? You selectively ignored that the Arabs started slaving Africans since the Ninth century way before Europe did and yet they exploit the flags of multiculturalism and freedom of cult while imposing themselves and conquering other countries,I wonder why? I know, you're a dogmatic oligophrenic bastard who has to live through his twisted dogma of multiculturalism even if it costs you your life and that of your own brethren. Because according to you, we: "The West" are the Bad guys.

According to you the slaughter of Jews was o.k. because their forefathers also did the same to the Canaanites a millennium and a half before. So you excuse genocide with more genocide? Because it's o.k to hate the Jewish but no the Islam. Oh really?!!!
And you complain about some idiot racist comparing the Black first lady to an Ape out of frustration because he wishes she were a slave? You know a lot more about hypocrisy than I do, that's for sure. How much does your hatred blinds you, traitor?
You made me remember a very wise quote:"Never argue with moron as he will bring you down to his level and beat you with experience". That is for you guys, don't waste your time with this irrational fanatic. As for you, feel free to request a ban of my account, I couldn't care less.

Signed, The guy who transcribed the letter from Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to the California Assembly regarding the regulation of power consumption of television sets. You can look it up in these forums as the letter goes for you too.
 
So you can reach into someones head and decide why they did something? As far as I know whoever made that image hasn't proclaimed their reasoning, maybe they had some alternative? Maybe they thought she would look good in Planet of the Apes? (Incidentally there were a lot of black people put in monkey costumes for that movie, I suppose that makes it racist).

That said, yes the image probably was made with racist intentions. Get over it and move on with your life.

ekierce, answer me this: Was the new Planet of the Apes movie racist? If not, why?

So let's see . . . now you're equating speculative science fiction with real world. A scenario in which people voluntarily portray a role to one in which someone with an agenda attacks someone with imagery like this?

Damn, you really have to reach to try to prove your point don't you?
 
Hey Erkle-

http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/johann-hari/the-dark-side-of-dubai-1664368.html

Dubai is finally financially bankrupt – but it has been morally bankrupt all along. The idea that Dubai is an oasis of freedom on the Arabian peninsular is one of the great lies of our time. Yes, it has Starbucks and Dunkin' Donuts and the Gucci styles, but beneath these accouterments, there is a dictatorship built by slaves.

If you go there with your eyes open – as I did earlier this year – the truth is hidden in plain view. The tour books and the bragging Emiratis will tell you the city was built by Sheikh Mohammed, the country's hereditary ruler.

It is untrue. The people who really built the city can be seen in long chain-gangs by the side of the road, or toiling all day at the top of the tallest buildings in the world, in heat that Westerners are told not to stay in for more than 10 minutes. They were conned into coming, and trapped into staying.

In their home country – Bangladesh or the Philippines or India – these workers are told they can earn a fortune in Dubai if they pay a large upfront fee. When they arrive, their passports are taken from them, and they are told their wages are a tenth of the rate they were promised.

They end up working in extremely dangerous conditions for years, just to pay back their initial debt. They are ringed-off in filthy tent-cities outside Dubai, where they sleep in weeping heat, next to open sewage. They have no way to go home. And if they try to strike for better conditions, they are beaten by the police.

I met so many men in this position I stopped counting, just as the embassies were told to stop counting how many workers die in these conditions every year after they figured it topped more than 1,000 among the Indians alone.

Human Rights Watch calls this system "slavery." Yet the Westerners who have flocked to Dubai brag that they "love" the city, because they don't have to pay any taxes, and they have domestic slaves to do all the hard work. They train themselves not to see the pain.

But Dubai's bankruptcy does not end there: it is ecologically bust. This is a city built in the burning desert, where everything shrivels up and blows away if it is not kept artificially cold all the time. That's why it has the highest per capita carbon emissions on earth – some 250 percent higher even than America's. The city has to ship in desalinated water – which is more costly than oil. When it runs out of cash, it will run out of water.

Today Dubai will be bailed out by the United Arab Emirates, the oil-rich country of which it is only one state. But the oil will not last forever. More importantly, there is no Bank of Morality that could provide a bailout for this sinister mirage in the desert.
 
How much do you know about US corporations operating in the Marianas Islands and the labor they import from Asia?

How much do you know about the fact that products you purchase labeled as "Made in the USA" are actually made in the Marianas Islands using labor acquired in exactly the manner you just outlined?

How much do you know about women forced into prostitution and having forced abortions in those same Marianas Islands facilities?

http://www.webster.edu/~woolflm/forcedlabor.html
http://www.catwinternational.org/factbook/Marianas.php
http://www.msmagazine.com/spring2006/paradise_full.asp

There are hundreds of articles out there if you look.

Don't for a second assume that US corporations don't engage in the very same practices you're denouncing.


 
Don't for a second assume that US corporations don't engage in the very same practices you're denouncing.

I was pointing out the fact that slavery is happing right now, while you are ranting about events that happend long in the past of this nation.

Did you even read any of those links you sent me or just skimmed through to find bits you agree with? Where is your outrage for events happening around the world?

You seem mighty selective.
 
I was pointing out the fact that slavery is happing right now, while you are ranting about events that happend long in the past of this nation.

Did you even read any of those links you sent me or just skimmed through to find bits you agree with? Where is your outrage for events happening around the world?

You seem mighty selective.

Ummm, this is happening NOW. Or did you miss that?
 
I was pointing out the fact that slavery is happing right now, while you are ranting about events that happend long in the past of this nation.

Did you even read any of those links you sent me or just skimmed through to find bits you agree with? Where is your outrage for events happening around the world?

You seem mighty selective.

Okay, since you obviously didn't read, I'll reply again:

The whir of hundreds of sewing machines reverberates in the thick, dusty air at the RIFU garment factory. Inside this large warehouse, behind a guarded metal fence, 300 employees—most of them Chinese women—cut, sew, iron and fold blouses with such efficiency and focus that they seem like machinery themselves. From piles of orange and pink fabric, the workers will produce over 15,000 garments today for J. Jill, Elie Tahari and Ann Taylor. These name brand companies don’t own the factory; like Liz Claiborne, The Gap, Ralph Lauren and others, they subcontract production to factories like this, scattered around the tiny Micronesian island of Saipan.

Counters above the sewing machines indicate how many pieces the women have completed. According to workers, if they can’t finish a set quota of garments in a day, they may have to stay later and work for free, or they won’t be eligible for future overtime opportunities—which they desperately need.

Coming from rural villages and the big city slums of poor Asian countries, these garment workers began their sojourn in the Marianas with a huge financial deficit, having paid recruiters as much as $7,000 to obtain a one-year contract job (renewable at the employer’s discretion). Many of them borrow the money—a small fortune in China, where most are recruited—from lenders who charge as much as 20 percent interest.

In a situation akin to indentured servitude, workers cannot earn back their recruitment fee and pay annual company supplied housing and food expenses of about $2,100 without working tremendous hours of overtime. Before being able to save her first dollar, a worker who owes, say, $5,000 to her recruiter has to work nearly 2,500 hours at Saipan’s current minimum wage—which equals six more 40-hour workweeks than exist in a year.

And that’s assuming she gets paid. Increasingly, workers are filing formal complaints that they have not received their wages, with some women going without paychecks for over five months. Still, workers at RIFU and other Saipan garment factories labor six days a week, sometimes up to 20 hours a day.

Now, knowing that these products are manufactured for US corporations and labeled "made in the USA", why are YOU being selective and not addressing issues created by US corporations and instead focusing on Dubai?
 
Now, knowing that these products are manufactured for US corporations and labeled "made in the USA", why are YOU being selective and not addressing issues created by US corporations and instead focusing on Dubai?

"The CNMI has become a center of international human trafficking operations, with connections to the People's Republic of China, Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Pakistan, the Philippines, Russia, Sri Lanka and Thailand. "

"The Northern Mariana Islands are the only US territory that has local control over both immigration & naturalization and minimum wage. The government there has repeatedly reneged on its promises to US federal authorities to equalize its minimum wage with the federal minimum wage and to reduce the number of nonresident guest workers."

This is from a report over a decade old AND no where does it state "US Corporations are involved" it states because items are being made on a US territory it can carry the "made in USA" stamp.
 
"The CNMI has become a center of international human trafficking operations, with connections to the People's Republic of China, Bangladesh, India, Nepal, Pakistan, the Philippines, Russia, Sri Lanka and Thailand. "

"The Northern Mariana Islands are the only US territory that has local control over both immigration & naturalization and minimum wage. The government there has repeatedly reneged on its promises to US federal authorities to equalize its minimum wage with the federal minimum wage and to reduce the number of nonresident guest workers."

This is from a report over a decade old AND no where does it state "US Corporations are involved" it states because items are being made on a US territory it can carry the "made in USA" stamp.

You might want to check into Jack Abramoff's connections to Saipan. You might also want to review the list of corporations in question who STILL use the conditions discussed.

You might also be interested in what Tom DeLay told the government of Saipan "“You are a shining light for what is happening in the Republican Party, and you represent everything that is good about what we’re trying to do in America, in leading the world in the free-market system.”

It seems rather obvious that you're trying to be selective and ignore what's going on in your own backyard in favor of criticizing others.

People like Abramoff and Delay have continually fought to insure that laws do not pass Congress that would change the conditions in the Marianas Islands. Of course, you didn't bother to read that far did you?
 
Again, I find your outrage rather selctive and tells people far more about YOU.

So let me get this straight . . . you chose to ignore activity carried out by US companies, but instead chose to focus on countries in the Middle East, showing that you don't want to acknowledge or are completely ignorant of the fact that the same behavior you bring up takes place with the blessings of US lawmakers, and you call me selective?

Tell the truth now . . . you were blissfully unaware of the situation in the Marianas Islands until I mentioned it weren't you?
 
You might want to check into Jack Abramoff's connections to Saipan.

Dude, Abramoff is in jail.

You might also want to review the list of corporations in question who STILL use the conditions discussed.

You have yet to have named any, this island where this is happening is clearly NOT under US control if they are failing to abide to the federal government requests.
 
How in the hell did we go from Michelle Obama's "offensive" pictures to slavery in Dubai and the Marianas? Take that crap to PM's, PLEASE. Nobody wants to come to these threads expecting to read about what's actually in the title, and then see an argument between you guys about something entirely different and unrelated.
 
Back
Top