Google Buys Ad To Explain Offensive Image

You know, this is all funny to me. People keep talking about slaves and slavery as a reason for this and that. Can anyone on this board remember slavery? Can anyone name someone who was a slave? No? Then why does it matter now? Yes I know it is important to remember our past so we do not repeat it, but that does not mean we wallow in it and use it as an excuse.

Another little interesting point to make, where do you think the early slave traders got the slaves? Here is a hint for you, they didn't track them down in the jungles. Most slaves where sold to slavers by rival tribes or African slave traders. Another little interesting fact, did you know from the 16th to 19th centuries pirates used to sale European slaves to the Africans? Ummm I wonder what color they where? People who claim that because there ancestors where slaves entitles them to something should really look at history. Everyone can point to something in the past that happened to (insert race, nationality, sex here), unless you lived it personally, you need to suck it up and drive on.

Yes, I can actually name for you people who's family members were slaves. People who are alive today that lived through the legal segregation of the races in their lifetimes. You are forgetting that this "racism" thing was still actually legally institutionalized only 50 or 60 years ago in this country. If you think that only one or two generations is going to erradicate the effects of that, you are truly kidding yourself. If you don't understand how history shapes attitudes that are both taught and passed down through generations--or you choose, as you are now, to completely ignore it as if it doesn't exist--then you have little or no credibiltity to argue your points.

People can't continue to cite history to make their arguments and then claim or pretend that certain parts of that same history are now irrelevent. Those who do so are only doomed to perpetuate mistakes that were made, whether they know it or not. Some people like it when their heads are in the sand and when they can't see the forest for all those darned trees that are in the way...

Secondly, please do not even attempt to make the "two wrongs make a right" argument about how people became slaves in the first place. That ship does not sail in these waters. That's like saying to the cops that "somebody else made that bomb. I just baught if from them and used it to kill all those innocent people... But, you know, those other dudes did it too! Why should I feel bad?" There is also no "entitlement" being spoken of, or argued about in this discussion. This is about the well known depiction of black people as apes in order to dehumanize them. Did it ever occur to you WHY these depictions specifically as apes keep coming up again and again? You can't pretend to treat all of them as just individual incidents. You're insulting your own intelligence if you continue to do so when the evidence clearly shows otherwise. But maybe that's ok. After all, dehumanization makes it ok to do whatever you like to people--doesn't it...? "After all, their just black people... Right?"

For the person that said that the "true racists" are the ones who claim racism. You are also in denial about the facts. You really don't know what racism or even predjudice is in the first place. People don't just "claim" racism. Racism happens to and is visited upon them by others. It is not something that any sane person would choose to have experienced. If you don't understand the power dynamics of how a group of people can be oppressed by others, then you should suck it up and move on.

I can also gaurantee you that this isn't just about black people. If you think that individuals or groups of another ethnic minority would not be offended by the depiction of one of their most prominent members--someone who has been able to break a barrier that they thought may be unbreakable in their lifetimes--essentially as a gorrilla... as nothing more than an animal, think again. Seriously.
 
I just searched for "Michelle Obama" (no quotes) on images.google.com. SafeSearch is off. I don't see her alleged monkey pic. Looks like the PC Nazis removed that pic. :confused:
 
People need to get over it. It is just a picture. You don't see me whining when people photoshop pictures of white people.
 
250 years of slavery, 100 years of legalized racial discrimination, and perhaps how Native Americans were treated has something to do with it.

People forget that we really are less than 50 years out from Jim Crow laws. We have a much longer history of slavery and legalized racial discrimination than not.

Time to get over it. You were not a part of it and have the chance to make something of your life. I also hate to break it you, but in some point in history, whites were also subjegated and/or slaughtered at different times.
 
You really just don't get it do you?

Here is why there is a difference.

For more than 200 years, white people subjected blacks to slavery, ever since, they've been subjected to racially loaded attacks. In American media, apes, baboons, etc. were used for decades to depict black people as a whole. Derogatory terms like "ape", "coon", "porch monkey", etc.have been used by racists for decades towards black people.

There is no such history referring to white people in the same context. None.

You can attempt to twist out from under that all you like, but you can't erase history.

When you compare a white person to a chimp, you merely compare that individual to a chimp.

When you compare a black person to a chimp (or any other type of monkey), you carry along hundreds of years of such comparisons and their racial roots against an entire race, not a single individual.

It's that simple.

Like I said, you can try to twist out from under that, but unless you can erase hundreds of years of history, you're just showing ignorance.

Seems to me you are the ignorant one since you are only choose a tiny portion of history. All humans have been hurt in one way or another in history and not only blacks. Go pick up a history book and learn something.
 
Seems to me you are the ignorant one since you are only choose a tiny portion of history. All humans have been hurt in one way or another in history and not only blacks. Go pick up a history book and learn something.

Damn no edit button. Looks like I made a grammatical error.
 
My take on this? Google is a search engine. Their job is to help others find what they're looking for. When someone types "michelle obama" into the search box, they most likely aren't looking for that picture. So props to Google for removing it and improving the user experience of their product.

Nothing wrong with a few manual exceptions to the automated search algorithm.
 
Seems to me you are the ignorant one since you are only choose a tiny portion of history. All humans have been hurt in one way or another in history and not only blacks. Go pick up a history book and learn something.

So tell me . . . when in American history were White Anglo-Saxon Protestant men enslaved, lynched, hung, segregated, treated as subhuman, legally described as less than men, and portrayed as subhuman in literature, propaganda, film and media?

Enlighten me.
 
My take on this? Google is a search engine. Their job is to help others find what they're looking for. When someone types "michelle obama" into the search box, they most likely aren't looking for that picture. So props to Google for removing it and improving the user experience of their product.

Nothing wrong with a few manual exceptions to the automated search algorithm.

Given what you just said, when people Googled "failure" a few years ago and the 1st hit was a link to the White House, would you have wanted Google to remove that link as well for that search?
 
Given what you just said, when people Googled "failure" a few years ago and the 1st hit was a link to the White House, would you have wanted Google to remove that link as well for that search?

My take on that? It was a little ridiculous, BUT, it did not reflect hundreds of years of racist history.

So, while it was ridiculous and childish for it to be Google bombed to the top of searches for "miserable failure", it was nowhere near as objectionable.

What a Google bomb that results in something like this being at the top shows is that Michelle Obama's detractors are so ignorant of the racist connotations of such a picture that they just continue anyway. Of course, that's giving them the benefit of the doubt which they most likely do not deserve, it's far more likely that they are well aware of the racist connotations and either try to justify them (as seen here), or are actually kind of proud of them (as can be seen by the signs at any teabagger rally).

Once again, it should be quite obvious . . . there aren't hundreds of years of racist history against white anglo-saxon protestants in America. . . . It could be argued that there is a long history of people referring to Bush family members as miserable failures (Presecott and his trading with the Nazis, Neil and his involvement in Savings and Loan scandals, George H. W. and his entire term, and, of course, the Bush in question).
 
So tell me . . . when in American history were White Anglo-Saxon Protestant men enslaved, lynched, hung, segregated, treated as subhuman, legally described as less than men, and portrayed as subhuman in literature, propaganda, film and media?
American history is not the only history. Practically every race of man has been enslaved by another race at one time or another.

What a Google bomb that results in something like this being at the top shows is that Michelle Obama's detractors are so ignorant of the racist connotations of such a picture that they just continue anyway.
So Google should censor their search results only when there are obvious racial connotations. Cases which are less obvious should not be censored. Is this your stance?

Once again, it should be quite obvious . . . there aren't hundreds of years of racist history against white anglo-saxon protestants in America
Once again I must remind you that America is not the only country on this planet, and most certainly not the only country with a history of adopting various forms of slavery.
 
So tell me . . . when in American history were White Anglo-Saxon Protestant men enslaved, lynched, hung, segregated, treated as subhuman, legally described as less than men, and portrayed as subhuman in literature, propaganda, film and media?

Enlighten me.

You can stop picking and choosing parts of history that only suit your agenda. Like someone else has said, American history is not the only history. It is only a tiny part of history.
 
You can stop picking and choosing parts of history that only suit your agenda. Like someone else has said, American history is not the only history. It is only a tiny part of history.

So what you're saying is that you can't point out any time in the history of this country where white anglo saxon protestants have been persecuted. Thanks.
 
American history is not the only history. Practically every race of man has been enslaved by another race at one time or another.


So Google should censor their search results only when there are obvious racial connotations. Cases which are less obvious should not be censored. Is this your stance?


Once again I must remind you that America is not the only country on this planet, and most certainly not the only country with a history of adopting various forms of slavery.

First, I never said they should censor anything. Please show me where I did.

Second, we are not discussing merely slavery, we are discussing the racist propaganda which was prevalent in this country comparing black people to monkeys, etc.

The lengths people will go through to justify racism is ridiculous . . .

Here's a test for you. If you think that representing black people as monkeys is fine and dandy . . . walk up to any random black person you see, ask them if it's alright if you call them a chimp. Come back and tell us the results.

Now, walk up to any white person, ask the same question. Tell us the results.
 
First, I never said they should censor anything. Please show me where I did.

Second, we are not discussing merely slavery, we are discussing the racist propaganda which was prevalent in this country comparing black people to monkeys, etc.

The lengths people will go through to justify racism is ridiculous . . .

Here's a test for you. If you think that representing black people as monkeys is fine and dandy . . . walk up to any random black person you see, ask them if it's alright if you call them a chimp. Come back and tell us the results.

Now, walk up to any white person, ask the same question. Tell us the results.

Hey kid, we're not JUSTIFYING racism. We're telling people who's so hung up on racism to shut the fuck up about racism and get over it and quit being so butthurt over it.

Don't you dare tell us we're justifying racism. Racism sucked, yes. It shouldn't have happened - the slavery, the persecution, the oppression - not only here in America, but anywhere in the world - but guess what? It did happen. We're better people than the people of the past.

We're not JUSTIFYING racism. Get over it already.
 
So what you're saying is that you can't point out any time in the history of this country where white anglo saxon protestants have been persecuted. Thanks.
We're being persecuted now, in a manner of speaking. See: affirmative action.

Of what relevance is Protestantism, anyway? This discussion has nothing to do with religious beliefs (or the lack thereof).

First, I never said they should censor anything. Please show me where I did.
I was asking if that was your stance. It's a yes/no question (which you unsurprisingly failed to answer), not an insinuation. The manner of your past posts, however, do suggest that you would favor censoring of so-called "offensive" imagery.

Second, we are not discussing merely slavery, we are discussing the racist propaganda which was prevalent in this country comparing black people to monkeys, etc.
No, you seem to be the one putting the long-past history of slavery in America (and only America) at the forefront of your "argument". No one else understands the relevance to the discussion.

Here's a test for you. If you think that representing black people as monkeys is fine and dandy . . . walk up to any random black person you see, ask them if it's alright if you call them a chimp. Come back and tell us the results. Now, walk up to any white person, ask the same question. Tell us the results.
I fail to see what bearing this could possibly have on the discussion.
 
So what you're saying is that you can't point out any time in the history of this country where white anglo saxon protestants have been persecuted. Thanks.

Again, American history is not the only history. Are you having a hard time comprehending that?
 
First, I never said they should censor anything. Please show me where I did.

Second, we are not discussing merely slavery, we are discussing the racist propaganda which was prevalent in this country comparing black people to monkeys, etc.

The lengths people will go through to justify racism is ridiculous . . .

Here's a test for you. If you think that representing black people as monkeys is fine and dandy . . . walk up to any random black person you see, ask them if it's alright if you call them a chimp. Come back and tell us the results.

Now, walk up to any white person, ask the same question. Tell us the results.

You really need to get over the past like almost EVERY other group of people of the world has.
 
Again, American history is not the only history. Are you having a hard time comprehending that?

Again, what is or is not the only history is completely irrelevant.

Anyone who is incapable of recognizing a racist stereotype or who recognizes and thinks it's unimportant is either a racist or ignorant.

I take it you're unwilling to try the experiment I presented to you.
 
I fail to see what bearing this could possibly have on the discussion.

Okay, so what you're saying is that while in the privacy of your own home and protected by your computer, you're willing to say that presenting a black person as a chimpanzee is perfectly acceptable, but you are completely unwilling to present your argument to a black person randomly selected.

Thanks.
 
Hey kid, we're not JUSTIFYING racism. We're telling people who's so hung up on racism to shut the fuck up about racism and get over it and quit being so butthurt over it.

Don't you dare tell us we're justifying racism. Racism sucked, yes. It shouldn't have happened - the slavery, the persecution, the oppression - not only here in America, but anywhere in the world - but guess what? It did happen. We're better people than the people of the past.

We're not JUSTIFYING racism. Get over it already.

You ARE justifying it, you are justifying the continuation of it.

If you paint a swastika on a synagogue, you are presenting a racist image that is linked to history.

If you portray a black person as a chimp, you are presenting a racist image that is linked to history.

You can try to equivocated all you want. It doesn't change reality.

You know it which is exactly why you are being so defensive of racist imagery.
 
Wow you're really hung up on racism aren't you?

You don't know the first thing about me or anyone else on this forum and yet you're passing quite a lot of judgment on them. You have serious issues.
 
Okay, so what you're saying is that while in the privacy of your own home and protected by your computer, you're willing to say that presenting a black person as a chimpanzee is perfectly acceptable, but you are completely unwilling to present your argument to a black person randomly selected.
I have never suggested that portraying a black person as a chimpanzee is "perfectly acceptable", though in select scenarios it certainly could be (if the person were viewed as particularly stupid, for instance, then the comparison to a lesser primate wouldn't be specifically racist). My stance is that Google shouldn't ever filter out such imagery purely on the grounds that certain individuals find it "offensive".

You know it which is exactly why you are being so defensive of racist imagery.
We're defending Google's decision to not remove it from their search results, thereby selectively censoring offensive imagery. We are not defending, nor in any way condoning, racism, slavery, segregation or any other unequal racial constructs.
 
Again, what is or is not the only history is completely irrelevant.

Anyone who is incapable of recognizing a racist stereotype or who recognizes and thinks it's unimportant is either a racist or ignorant.

I take it you're unwilling to try the experiment I presented to you.

It's only irrelevant to you because it proves you wrong. All of history is relevant. I don't have any more sympathy for blacks than I have for the various groups of whites. They all have gone through hard times and have gotten over it. Time for you to do the same.

Anyone who keeps bringing up racism and fails to see every race has been hurt throughout history is a racist or ignorant.
 
If you portray a black person as a chimp, you are presenting a racist image that is linked to history.

Yeah.

Or.. wait, maybe they're just saying the person looks like a chimp? I've met plenty of blacks that don't look like chimps. I've met plenty of whites that don't look like chimps. On the other hand I've met plenty of both that did look like chimps. Now, I've never felt compelled to poorly pchop a chimp face onto their visage, but I can certainly sympathize with anyone that might find it funny.
 
It appears to me that not one single person who supports the use of racist imagery is willing to take up my challenge.

Interesting. Not one person is willing to walk up to a black person and call them a chimp (or even better, portray their wife or mother as a chimp).

Proves my point quite nicely.
 
Wow you're really hung up on racism aren't you?

You don't know the first thing about me or anyone else on this forum and yet you're passing quite a lot of judgment on them. You have serious issues.

I'm not passing judgment at all. I'm using the evidence at hand to present an argument which no one has been able to counter as yet.

The use of racial imagery is racist. There is no way around it. You can attempt to hurl accusations at me all you like. It doesn't change the fact that racist images are racist.
 
It appears to me that not one single person who supports the use of racist imagery is willing to take up my challenge. Proves my point quite nicely.
I wonder if you even realize how deeply you're digging your own grave in this debate. On the one hand, it's lightly amusing. On the other hand, it's infinitely depressing to think that such impassable delusions can manifest themselves within the human brain.

I think we're done here.
 
Given what you just said, when people Googled "failure" a few years ago and the 1st hit was a link to the White House, would you have wanted Google to remove that link as well for that search?

Umm...yes? Currently the #1 hit for "failure" on Google is the Wikipedia article on "failure." Are you saying that's not what it should be?

All political issues aside, when people Google "failure," they probably aren't looking for a link to the White House. If that was really the #1 hit at one point in time, then it was quite the "failure" of Google's search algorithm. I would consider it a bug, which Google should fix.
 
It appears to me that not one single person who supports the use of racist imagery is willing to take up my challenge.

That's because your "challenge" is silly as hell. I'll do that after you run down to South LA spewing Hispanic racial slurs at people. Can you kindly quote the individual here who said they personally agree with the racist imagery? I've seen some folks supporting a right to free speech; but I haven't read a single post advocating racism.

Does racism exist in the world today? Of course it does. Will it exist in 100 years? More than likely. Stating that it exists on the same level as it did 50 years ago, or even 30 years ago though, is pretty laughable. The only popular figures I see spreading racism out there today are the "anti-racism" folks, like Mr. Jackson, Mr. Sharpton. Those two are responsible for more hate mongering than whoever is currently in charge of what's left of the KKK.

Google is an non-governmental corporation, and they can filter whatever they want to as far as I'm concerned. No one has a right to tell them what content they can and cannot provide, assuming it's legal to do so. So far they appear to choose to not filter content that does not violate any laws, and I for one am very happy that they do so. They certainly shouldn't be held poorly in the court of public opinion for doing so in my opinion. I for one don't want them getting into the habit of removing content simply because they disagree with it, and if they did so, they would lose my daily visits and the revenue they derive from them.

Supporting freedom of speech is supporting someone else's right to be racist and speak their opinion if they choose to do so...it does not mean you agree with them!
 
Last edited:
To the poster above, please don't try and compare "the Irish" or "the Italians" to what is still happening today to people of color and ethnic minorities. At least not in the US. The The "Irish" were not dragged here in chains as slave labor. The Irish were not hung from trees for sport, dragged to death, or raped on a regular basis in the south as recently as the 1960's in America--with only a legal system to turn to that either enabled or turned a blind eye to such events.

Do some reading up on early American coal mining, and what was done to the poor white Appalachian populations. They were basically forced into indentured servitude, sponsored by both the coal companies and the government. They were intentionally not given the opportunity to become better educated, or even given the means to leave to find something else, as many were paid in "company dollars" instead of US currency. They were forced to work in brutal, dangerous conditions, and treated like mining equipment their entire lives. How many hillbilly jokes do you see today? As far as most of the US is concerned, not much comes out of Appalachia but morons and moonshine....and as someone who has spent a great deal of time down there, the effects of what was done to them are still very evident. Clearly blacks were the only "truly" oppressed individuals in US history. :rolleyes:

How about we stop griping about who got the worst deal, and move on with our lives.
 
That's because your "challenge" is silly as hell. I'll do that after you run down to South LA spewing Hispanic racial slurs at people. Can you kindly quote the individual here who said they personally agree with the racist imagery? I've seen some folks supporting a right to free speech; but I haven't read a single post advocating racism.

Does racism exist in the world today? Of course it does. Will it exist in 100 years? More than likely. Stating that it exists on the same level as it did 50 years ago, or even 30 years ago though, is pretty laughable. The only popular figures I see spreading racism out there today are the "anti-racism" folks, like Mr. Jackson, Mr. Sharpton. Those two are responsible for more hate mongering than whoever is currently in charge of what's left of the KKK.

Google is an non-governmental corporation, and they can filter whatever they want to as far as I'm concerned. No one has a right to tell them what content they can and cannot provide, assuming it's legal to do so. So far they appear to choose to not filter content that does not violate any laws, and I for one am very happy that they do so. They certainly shouldn't be held poorly in the court of public opinion for doing so in my opinion. I for one don't want them getting into the habit of removing content simply because they disagree with it, and if they did so, they would lose my daily visits and the revenue they derive from them.

Supporting freedom of speech is supporting someone else's right to be racist and speak their opinion if they choose to do so...it does not mean you agree with them!

Do you have reading comprehension issues?

The people I'm addressing are trying to say that portraying black people as apes is not racist. I never said they should censor it. I merely stated that the image itself is racist. Anyone who wishes to deny it is merely wrong. There are a shitload of people here trying to say that such portrayals are not racist and that they are no different than portraying a white person as an ape.

By presenting your "hispanics" contrast to my challenge, you are admitting that such images is, in fact, racist, since you refer to "racial epithets". You must be admitting that presenting a black person as an ape is, in fact, a racial epithet of sorts. Otherwise you would not have provided the "hispanic" challenge in response to my statements.
 
You're the one making this a race issue, man. I think people are just comparing this one woman, to a chimp. Not black people. You're extrapolating it and saying people are calling all blacks chimps (or apes, as the case may be).
 
Mmmmhmmm. . .

You continue on in your little bubble where comparing black people to apes isn't racist. I'll continue living in reality.

I judge a man by his character, how he acts is far more important than the color of his skin.

My step-father was a black man whom was a far better man than my real father, a white.

He like Bill Cosby did not care for those who played the race card or did not pull their weight.
 
Back
Top