DVD, Blu-ray Shrinking. Digital Distribution Rising

Best comment in the thread. If you read at all about the current "in the pipe" laws gaining steam. Also the Phone companies (yes they have to get the ok on new changes from our goverment) plans. Dont look for digital to take off just yet. And while Im not a big fan of conspiracy, you can bet hollywood and all those guys already LOVE what MP3's have done with music. Small Dish's for your home instead of cable. The cable companies got the US to ban the use for over 5 years (they where in most other countries) so they could "get ready" to compete. Of course all the laws, rate hicks, bandwidth regulations are just "talk" at the moment, if you really think some if not all are comming sometime and soon you are deluding yourself. Digital is the way to go, I agree, but much like cigs and booze, both harmful, we dont do away with them, why? Money. Hard cheap media (dvd's, bluerays) are cheap once the factories are in place and no matter what, there will be people who want the "real" copy. I see digital possilby being 50% in 10ish years. Blue ray should slowely (very slowely with the econemy) gain ground, but its never going to be where VHS or DVD was, tech is just to fast for any single thing to stay around that long anymore.
 
On the side note, the "best" Blu-Ray player (PS3), outsold both Wii and XBox360 in September.
That's good news. The recent increase in PS3 sales should go a long way to making it a fundamentally better gaming console than the Wii or the X360.

Hey, wait a minute...
 
"Internet usage caps will kill digital distribution."


Best comment in the thread. If you read at all about the current "in the pipe" laws gaining steam. Also the Phone companies (yes they have to get the ok on new changes from our goverment) plans. Dont look for digital to take off just yet. And while Im not a big fan of conspiracy, you can bet hollywood and all those guys already LOVE what MP3's have done with music. Small Dish's for your home instead of cable. The cable companies got the US to ban the use for over 5 years (they where in most other countries) so they could "get ready" to compete. Of course all the laws, rate hicks, bandwidth regulations are just "talk" at the moment, if you really think some if not all are comming sometime and soon you are deluding yourself. Digital is the way to go, I agree, but much like cigs and booze, both harmful, we dont do away with them, why? Money. Hard cheap media (dvd's, bluerays) are cheap once the factories are in place and no matter what, there will be people who want the "real" copy. I see digital possilby being 50% in 10ish years. Blue ray should slowely (very slowely with the econemy) gain ground, but its never going to be where VHS or DVD was, tech is just to fast for any single thing to stay around that long anymore.

dang i hate not being able to edit and missing my quote---- total new message
 
Well, essentially, HD-DVD would have been the easiest to move into due to the fact that their titles also had a side that had regular DVD on it. Making it easier to just buy the movie when it released, then upgrade down the road when players dropped in prices.

Either way, digital and rentals are moving to be the distribution methods of the future... Look at what it did to the CD market.
 
I'll have to check that out next time I go Blu-ray shopping. I don't shop at Amazon often enough to justify the cost of Prime though.

Historically I purchase Blu-ray at Fye used. They guarantee 100% condition and the clerk lets me check myself before I buy. The guys at the local Fye are pretty cool. Never ran across a faulty used Blu-ray yet.

"Normal" prices at Amazon are 35%-70% off MSRP, and that's before sales, B2G1 free, etc. Its really nice.

Used is another way to go, for sure. The coating is super durable, much tougher than DVD, which makes it very attractive used if the price is right.
 
That's good news. The recent increase in PS3 sales should go a long way to making it a fundamentally better gaming console than the Wii or the X360.

Hey, wait a minute...

Nope, that would be its awesome PSN games, games like Demon's Souls, the upcoming God Of War 3, all the cross platform stuff you can also play on the 360, and Uncharted 2, IMO the best single player action game since Half Life 2 and one of the best games this entire console generation.

Yeah, that helps. ;)
 
I've had way too many instances, even in B&M stores, where I see an old movie I simply must have on disc, and the BR and the DVD are both $15......wonder which one I'll pick up there.

Between that, Amazon and JR's, you can find some rather good deals on BR these days. Anyone paying $35 for a film is out of their mind, but the same could be said for 4 going to the theater these days. That's ~$40 just for the tickets, not to mention not being able to see it whenever you want, stopping the player to take a pee, rewinding scenes, not dealing with the idiotic masses, etc.

I'll still be buying hard media for a while longer. I like having that disc on my shelf whenever I need/want it. And with the plentiful sites for BR sales, I don't mind paying the same as, or a few $ more, than a regular DVD to get a new title on BR.
 
I'll still be buying hard media for a while longer. I like having that disc on my shelf whenever I need/want it. And with the plentiful sites for BR sales, I don't mind paying the same as, or a few $ more, than a regular DVD to get a new title on BR.

The only reason I buy hard copies is because there is a big difference in quality. Higher bitrate video on high capacity physical media looks better than something compressed enough to download, simple. If I could download movies that look as good as Blu Ray I would do it in a heartbeat. I love the convenience of downloading games on Steam, XBL, and PSN. You don't lose any fidelity with games by going download versus hard copy, at least not at this point with everything being 2GB-6GB. Too bad it doesn't work the same with movies, I'd love it if I could clear all those shelves. :)
 
Those studies are horribly flawed... mostly because the movie industry only released about one O.K. to good movie each week for the summer and most are holding off until Christmas for releases. Stores are hard stretched to find anything new to put out. Having DVD sales down this quarter, or really this year, is a given. Downloadable and streaming is more popular because it is cheap and gives you access to a wider veriety.
 
If true, its too bad. I don't like DVD but I'm not a huge fan of digital downloads eitherm outside of convenience.

Blu Ray however, amazing, best media for watching movies ever. I'm a home theaternut, owned a Laserdisc player and was one of the first to jump into DVD, and Blu Ray is the holy grail as far as I'm concerned.

If you like digital downloads for convenience, great, I do too, but if we're trying to compare quality then they aren't even in the same zip code. If you still insist on this then I suggest getting your eyes checked. :)

I'll assume you don't have a computer hooked up to your HT with 1080p mkv movies to compare against your bd player. But most mkv's come from bd disc, so maybe that doesn't count? None-the-less, digital is the best media format I have seen in a long time.

Monday night we replaced a htpc with the new WD Live TV - I was astounded at the quality that little machine put out. My next purchase!
 
Personally I think they just need to start making movies that don't suck.

Agreed - though being 39 years old may have something to do with my taste in movies. I watched movies from 20 or 30 years ago that I had very fond memories of and now wondered how I ever thought so highly of such crap.
 
That's good news. The recent increase in PS3 sales should go a long way to making it a fundamentally better gaming console than the Wii or the X360.

Hey, wait a minute...

lol

Wii just dropped $50 from the price tag to make sure Sony and MS don't take the top dog slot. I'm glad I got a Wii for the kids and me, I just wish the game selection didn't have so much shovelware. :(
 
I'll assume you don't have a computer hooked up to your HT with 1080p mkv movies to compare against your bd player. But most mkv's come from bd disc, so maybe that doesn't count? None-the-less, digital is the best media format I have seen in a long time.

Monday night we replaced a htpc with the new WD Live TV - I was astounded at the quality that little machine put out. My next purchase!

Warez talk? MKV 1080p downloads aren't sold by any legitimate places that I've ever heard of... so no, you can't compare that.
 
Netflix pure and simple. Why buy when a can stream or have it the next day?

Also, BR isn't the jaw dropping experience that it is hyped up to be.

Yes I can tell a difference on my 47" Full HD TV. At 15 feet away though, I'm having a hard time with the justification of the extra expence. Maybe if I was closer.... and had more time.

Erm, what BDs are you referring to? AVS's Blu tier movies?
 
Erm, what BDs are you referring to? AVS's Blu tier movies?

Indeed... also 47" is a bit small for a 15' viewing distance. I watch on a 720p projector setup at 84" diagonal 16:9 and Blu vs. DVD even on poorer Blu's is SHOCKINGLY different in both picture and sound with my Monitor 60's. It's not even a night-and-day comparison, it's just that different and better.
 
Bit-torrent > Blue-Ray

Actually I own about 30 BR movies, I would own more but really getting old movies on BR is pointless as they are just upscaled DVD's... so why pay 1.5x the price when I can just buy the DVD and often times get that DVD out of the 3/$10 bin at Walmart.

Because when you have a 60" TV it looks like sh*t? Or how about when you start "archiving" the movies you realize you are spending a sh*t-ton on power for HDD storage racks, much less the other hardware, and have to keep it at a reasonable quality so you won't think "my god this looks works than VHS" when you stream it back over your network.

DD will remain impotent as long as the providers of broadband also sell TV services. They can cap it, and it's perfectly ok to do so under network neutrality. They can throttle it, if neutrality is killed, and charge whatever fee they like. So they own your pipeline either way, whether it's your "cable box" or your "terminal adapter" mates. Verizon, AT&T, TWC, Charter, Comcast, yep, they all sell TV / PPV services.

Buck up for the suds.

Now I own some BD's. I am purchasing less, due more to the economy and my own saver mentality. People b*tching about BD prices wouldn't want to know what the flipper DVD of Das Boot cost on sale when it came out. Let's just say that the most expensive BD in my collection isn't 2/3 the price of the most expensive DVD I purchased. Single movie, for single movie, BD is on par with DVD same time frame. Just because some techies took it in the @$$ when they supported HD-DVD (the look and sound of perfect failure) like idiots backing any single company format vs a consortium (hello Betamax vs VHS, but Sony wasn't the idiot this time) they declare it the end of optical discs.

Yeah right, and pigs will sprout wings and fly right now.
 
Netflix pure and simple. Why buy when a can stream or have it the next day?

Also, BR isn't the jaw dropping experience that it is hyped up to be.

Yes I can tell a difference on my 47" Full HD TV. At 15 feet away though, I'm having a hard time with the justification of the extra expence. Maybe if I was closer.... and had more time.

and more money...:(
 
The absolute only reason I haven't bought more Blu-Ray movies lately is not because of Digital Distribution but because... I'm broke.
 
The only reason I buy hard copies is because there is a big difference in quality. Higher bitrate video on high capacity physical media looks better than something compressed enough to download, simple. If I could download movies that look as good as Blu Ray I would do it in a heartbeat. I love the convenience of downloading games on Steam, XBL, and PSN. You don't lose any fidelity with games by going download versus hard copy, at least not at this point with everything being 2GB-6GB. Too bad it doesn't work the same with movies, I'd love it if I could clear all those shelves. :)

You can still clear all your shelves:rolleyes: I have ~130 dvd's in my collection. They aren't on shelves, they are in a CD case taking up about .5 cubic foot of space.
 
You can still clear all your shelves:rolleyes: I have ~130 dvd's in my collection. They aren't on shelves, they are in a CD case taking up about .5 cubic foot of space.

Where are your boxes, in the closet or the trash? They have to go somewhere. :)
 
I'll assume you don't have a computer hooked up to your HT with 1080p mkv movies to compare against your bd player. But most mkv's come from bd disc, so maybe that doesn't count? None-the-less, digital is the best media format I have seen in a long time.

Monday night we replaced a htpc with the new WD Live TV - I was astounded at the quality that little machine put out. My next purchase!

That video was almost certainly compressed. It doesn't really matter if it came from Blu Ray if it was compressed to make the file size manageable, not unless you don't care about the best image quality.

Again, digital is great for convenience, but it compromises image quality too much based on how compressed it is. A 4GB-8GB HD movie won't look as good as a 25GB-35GB HD movie at a higher bitrate, simple. It won't get there until codecs get way better than where they are now.
 
Back
Top